“ARE YOU FREAKING KIDDING ME RIGHT NOW GUYS!? AGAIN!?”

“F-fluttershy!?” Mr. Shy stood up in shock, tears streaming down his face.

Fluttershy was caught halfway between absolute rage and a sudden shock and concern for her distraught father.

“Wh-what’s…” Fluttershy began to ask, before being interrupted by another groan as Anon shot another weak rope of cum that splattered across her mother’s back. She could see how her beloved and mild mother had a gaping and leaking ponut and marehood, as she shivered in a pool of her own arousal.

“Flutter-sh-shy… S-something’s wr-wrong with y-your…” Mr. Shy choked, putting his hoof on his daughter’s shoulder, trying to direct her out of the room.

“Hngh! Fuck Mrs. Shy!” Anon moaned. He’d collapsed onto his ass on the mattress, and the deliriously aroused pegasus had turned around and crawled through her arousal to nuzzle and suckle at Anon’s deflating cock.

“M-mom?” Fluttershy squeaked, resisting her father’s attempts to get her out of the room. “Wh-what’s happened to your cutie mark!?” The mark in question, once a trio of flowers colored the shades of her family, one of the three had shifted to become a single green-colored flower with a black question mark in the center.

“Mmmghh…” Mrs. Shy ignored the question and continued nuzzling and lapping at Anon’s testicles. It wasn’t until Anon started to snap his fingers in front of her face and push her off of his flaccid penis that she started to finally rouse from her delirium. As she looked up with pupils of different dilations, somewhat dizzily, she spotted her concerned looking daughter staring right at her.

“Oh… oh honey?” She shakily started to get to her legs. “Do you know Anon?” She motioned at the human sitting in a pile of sweat and exhaustion.

“Mom? Yes I know him... “ Fluttershy steadied her mother, not caring that she was painted with ropes of Anon’s cum and drenched with her own sweat and fluid. “Mom, what’s the matter? What’s happened?” Fluttershy directed her father to go get a glass of water immediately, and she began to nurse her beloved mom carefully, bringing her out of her orgasmic stupor.

As more and more of Mrs. Shy’s consciousness came back to her she became more and more coherent. But it was still a few minutes before Fluttershy let her sit up and speak.

“Oh… oh my goodness. I really… I really lost it there, didn’t I?” She chuckled, pulling off her glasses and wiping them clean of the thick cum stain using her wing. “I… I can’t describe to you what that was like.”

Mr. Shy sighed in relief. Reaching out to touch his wife’s hoof. “Thank goodness you’re alright Honeybun.”

Mrs. Shy looked at her husband’s hoof touching hers. Observing it coldly, empirically, before softly lifting it from hers and putting it back on the ground. “Mr. Shy.” She began, calmly,”I am alright. But… something… something has changed.”

Fluttershy leaned felt tears starting to form in her eyes. “Wh-what do you mean mom?”

“Honey, oh please don’t cry! This isn’t anything to do with you.” She stroked her daughter’s hoof. “I love you very much… but I just… I don’t love your father anymore… there’s a hole in my heart where he used to be.”

Mr. Shy turned away, sobbing. His worst fears were being realised. The foolish fantasies that they had both played out, he thought that their love was stronger than this, stronger than simple physical pleasure.

“Mom! What are you saying!?” Fluttershy sobbed, “How can you say that!? What about Dad?”

“Oh Honey,” Mrs. Shy cooed, stroking Fluttershy’s hair. “We had a good run, but what I just had… it changes a mare.” She got up, trotting over to where Anon sat, now clothed and bewildered on the edge of the bed. “My Nonny here has filled that hole in my heart…” Mrs. Shy nuzzled into Anon’s leg and looked up into his eyes with her big heart shaped pupils. “He’s filled it with his, big, fat, cock!”

“MOM!” Fluttershy screamed.

Mrs. Shy was barely paying attention, as she nuzzled the bewildered Anon’s leg. “Sorry, Fluttershy, but this…. man has stained me… he’s claimed me. Forever. What he did to me… I’ll be a slave to him and his wonderful cock for the rest of my life.” She sighed happily as she nuzzled herself into Anon’s hand.

Fluttershy looked in horror at Anon, as her father tore from the room in anguish.

Anon continued petting the cute MILF-mare’s head, before looking over at Fluttershy.

“So… are you gonna pay me those bits or…”

Author's Note

WHAT IS WRONG WITH YOU HOW COULD YOU CHOOSE THIS ENDING YOU MONSTER.

Just playing of course.

LIKE AND FOLLOW IF YOU ENJOYED!

Woo!

So I just got this idea when I woke up this morning and HAD to get it out of my head and onto paper. This is totally outside my usual schedule, which has 4 fics being written right now with about 1000-1500 words per day (writing is very much a side gig, sorry fans and followers!)

The original idea that stayed with me after my dream state was super simple, just: what if a human dropped his trousers, and a pony was so stunned by what she saw that she just went: "Nuh huh, fuck that!" For some dumb reason I was so tickled with that, that I decided it had to be done.

So I took it to the Space Ponyos discord to ask which pony should be the target of my erotic assault... next thing I knew, I was thinking MILFs, just because. I almost went with stellar flare...

Then for some reason the idea of the sweet and innocent Mrs. Shy, and her super mild husband being ultra-kink swingers hit me.

It was magic.

A quick writing session after work and here we are. I hope you enjoyed, even if it is a bit of a different fetish than I'll usually write!

Sorry if the editing is fairly light, like I said, this is one of those fics I really just wanted to get out quick!