Shycakes and Pinkiemuffins

Chapter 3 - A Stroke of Jealousy

“Fluttershy, are you ready to get bakin’?” Pinkie said excitedly as she got up, breaking the silence that resulted from five minutes of unadulterated cuddling.

“You mean with my milk?”

“Yep!”

“Are you sure, Pinkie Pie? Don’t you think ponies will be too embarrassed to buy it?”

“Nope! As long as I whisper what they are made of, I bet almost everypony would want to try one.”

“If you say so, Pinkie...” Fluttershy was skeptical, bending her limbs to lift herself up after such an exhausting yet wonderful experience.

Noticing Fluttershy’s unkempt mane, frazzled fur, and sweaty forehead, Pinkie didn’t want to leave her friend dishevelled. Trotting back to her, the bubbly party pony gently patted down the tufts of fur that stuck out of her body.

“Thanks, Pinkie,” Fluttershy said, feeling the warmth of a friend that cared about her.

“Yep, I wouldn’t want my naughty little friend looking a little too naughty.”

“Pinkie...”

“What? We still have some naughty stuff to do.”

“Y-yeah... my milk....”

“Not that, silly!”

“You mean, naughtier than using my milk in things ponies will be eating?”

“Yep! We’re gonna make cupcakes with your milk. But, what else do you think cupcakes need?”

“I don’t know...”

“What goes on top and is always the best part of the cake?”

“Frosting?”

“Yep! And guess what flavor we’re gonna make?”

“Vanilla?”

“Nope!”

“Chocolate?”

“Nope!”

“Lemon?”

“Close! We’re going to use your pee!”

“N-no, no, no, Pinkie. We can’t do that!” Fluttershy protested.

“Why not? We’re already using your milk!”

“But milk is just milk, it’s not going to make everypony feel...”

“Horny?”

“Y-yeah...”

“Oh come on, Fluttershy, your milk already makes me horny! Add some pee and everypony will have orgasms from just the taste of our cupcakes and muffins! Don’t you remember what happened when I told you I peed in the muffins?”

“Yes, Pinkie... but I didn’t want it to happen that way.”

“And it’s not gonna happen that way ever again, this time ponies will get even hornier when they know what they are going to eat!”

“I...”

“Please? Do it for me, Fluttershy?”

“Okay, Pinkie... but no tricking anypony about what’s in them.”

“Alright, do you want ponies to know you peed in them?”

“No, of course not, Pinkie! That would ruin me forever!”

“No, not forever, maybe just this afternoon. It’s not like anypony is going to hold it against you if you do some dirty things in your life.”

“I’m just not comfortable with it being with anypony besides you, Pinkie. You understand that I’m shy, and it’s really only you who is making me do this stuff.”

“Omigosh, I’m sorry, Fluttershy! Do you really think I’m making you do this? I didn’t want to put any pressure on you, I just thought it was fine because of how happy you were and you were just being your usual nice self.”

“I-I don’t mean it that way, Pinkie. I think it’s fun to be a little naughty, I just don’t want to be naughty in front of anypony I’m not close with.”

“I understand. So will you bake with me?”

“I... I guess.”

“Okiedokie!” Pinkie Pie cleaned up the wet tablecloth on the floor and then happily grabbed a large plastic measuring cup that was capable of holding up to three cups. “You just gotta pee in here, and we’ll be all set.”

“D-do you want to watch me?” Fluttershy’s heat came back to her face.

Pinkie Pie giggled, “I’d love to! Omigosh, I’m super-duper excited just thinking about it!”

“Don’t get too excited, I don’t think I’ll be able to bake if you do... that again.”

“Okiedokie, we can do that again later!” Pinkie suggested, picking up the measuring cup and moving it closer to Fluttershy.

Fluttershy blushed, turning around, and moving her tail, exposing her privates just above the container that Pinkie Pie was holding in her teeth. “Y-you’re going to hold it up?”

“Yes! We wouldn’t want any of your delicious juice to get on the floor now, would we?”

“O-okay, Pinkie.” Fluttershy felt the hard plastic lip pushing against her backside. She couldn’t help but freeze, shaking under the pressure of what Pinkie was asking her to do. It was easy enough when a pony got used to another pony and they had sex as friends, but peeing in front of somepony was different.

The problem was that it was too much for Fluttershy’s body to handle. Her urethra clenched and her body quaked, scared of peeing in front of Pinkie Pie. “I-I can’t do it... I’m too nervous.”

“Don’t worry, Fluttershy, relax yourself. You’re just doing it with me.”

“I don’t know, Pinkie. I’ve never done this before.”

“Just think about how it will make me feel! You can pay me back for doing that to you this morning.”

“Umm, okay, Pinkie. I’ll try.” Fluttershy concentrated and lost the tension in her backside. She adjusted herself, spreading her back legs as best she could. She thought about the passion in the air, the giddy feeling of just losing her virginity. She was a dirty mare, but she didn’t mind it. With the thoughts of Pinkie Pie getting aroused by her, she started to feel the tension in her bladder release as the floodgates opened.

The golden juice soared through the air, bounced off the lip of the container, and half splashed onto Pinkie’s nose while the other half settled into the floor. The urine being emitted shot out at a moderate speed and made a loud tapping sound similar to what Pinkie heard during rainstorms. The sweet aroma of Fluttershy’s natural perfume was being complemented by the scent of fresh urine. Pinkie’s privates started to lubricate once more as she tilted her head a bit and felt the steam of the hot liquid forming droplets on her face.

The first experience of letting go in front of another pony was daunting for Fluttershy. Her entire body was shaking from the struggle to keep her composure. She felt herself twitch as the excess liquid ran between her folds, knowing that Pinkie was no doubt looking at her mare-bits.

As the stream died, Pinkie’s excitement had brewed enough for a large strand of her lubrication to leak to the floor. She watched as the excess urine flowed off of Fluttershy’s labia, loosening her grip on the measuring bowl so Fluttershy could shake to get the extra drips out. “Omigosh Fluttershy, my heart is racing! I’ve never been so close to a pony peeing before!”

“Mine is too!” Fluttershy said excitedly as she realised the rush of excitement had caused her to pumped full of adrenaline.

“Okay, I’m gonna dry you off now.”

“Thanks, Pink-.” Fluttershy’s eyes popped open as she felt the familiar wet entity touch her genitals, opening her sensitive lips.

Pinkie moaned under the first taste of Fluttershy’s pee. She had tasted her own urine before, but it was nothing like the flavor of her shy friend’s. It had the same essence of saltiness and sweetness found in her own, but Fluttershy’s radiated a flowery scent that created a more pleasant flavor when combined with the sensation on her tastebuds.

The party pony’s boundless energy seemed to calm as she gently swept the drips of urine off of Fluttershy’s folds, and savored every last drop. Both ponies couldn’t help but give off soft moans from the experience, Pinkie melting under the flavor, and Fluttershy melting under the gentle touch. Pinkie’s mouth did a final pass as she heard a door creak and a voice saying, “Hey guys!”

Fluttershy jumped at the voice, quickly hiding herself behind a counter.

“Oh hey, Rainbow Dash,” Pinkie Pie said, placing the large measuring cup, three-quarters full with Fluttershy’s pee on the ground. She then nonchalantly licked her lips, and enjoyed the last bits of flavor in the urine.

“What the hay are you two doing?” Rainbow Dash said, looking over to the clear container full of amber-yellow liquid. “Is that pee?”

“Yep, me and Fluttershy are baking!” Pinkie said.

A muffled squeak was heard from behind the counter.

“There’s a recipe that requires pee?”

“My special Pinkie Pie recipe requires it.”

“Woah, Pinkie. That’s pretty hot,” Rainbow Dash said as her interest suddenly piqued. “And you actually made Fluttershy piss in there?”

“Yeah, we’ve been doing naughty things together.”

The newly informed pegasus’ wings popped up as chills ran down her body at the thought of Pinkie Pie and Fluttershy tasting each other. “Woah, I never knew Fluttershy was into that kind of stuff.”

“She’s really shy, but she can be naughty if you make her comfortable.”

“Aren’t we making her uncomfortable now, seeing as she isn’t talking to us?”

“Oh yeah,” Pinkie realised, “Come back out, Fluttershy. It’s just Dashie.”

Fluttershy wanted to die. Her veil of privacy had been shattered and now one of her friends knew about the dirty deeds she had done. She couldn’t make up her mind, she had her hooves over her eyes and didn’t know if she could stand living anymore with somepony knowing her secrets. She had to stand up for herself, it was only Rainbow Dash. It wasn’t anypony like Applejack, Rarity, or Twilight who all held her up to high standards. It was the pony who would be a loyal friend no matter what dirty things she had done.

“H-h-hi Rainbow Dash,” Fluttershy said, fully embarrassed as she revealed herself from behind the counter.

“Let me just clear up a few things, Fluttershy. I don’t care what you’re into, your secret is safe with me. I won’t tell anypony.”

“T-thanks.” Fluttershy couldn’t get over her nervous stutter.

Rainbow Dash couldn’t get the idea out of her head. Just the thought of ‘Fluttershy’ and ‘pee’ in the same sentence made her giddy. She was a mare that liked to corrupt the innocent and loved to see them quiver under her experience. There wasn’t a romantic feeling of attachment between her and her friends, but just thinking about them doing steamy stuff made her excited.

The aroma of Fluttershy’s urine only a few hoofsteps in front of her was driving Rainbow Dash crazy. It reminded her of a dream she had the other day. The horny pegasus stood with wings erect as the dream came back to her.

~~~ *** ~~~

Dash imagined herself in a secluded spot with Fluttershy in cloudsdale. The fluffy, cotton-like clouds under her hoof reminded of her of her bed. She couldn’t help but think of being in a giant bed with Fluttershy, doing the dirty with her.

“Hey Fluttershy, you wanna do it?” Rainbow Dash suddenly called out.

“You want to... d-do me?”

“Yep, right here.”

“Dashie?” Fluttershy blushed.

“Yes, Fluttershy?”

“C-could you, umm do something for me?” Fluttershy’s voice projected perfectly in Dash’s mind.

“Anything, Fluttershy”

“I-I... have this thing...”

“What thing?”

“I-I really want somepony to pee on me.”

“What!?”

“I... I know it’s gross.”

“It’s not gross, Fluttershy. I think it’s hot.”

“Y-you do?”

“Yeah! And I’ll totally do it for you. But you gotta promise to pee on me too!”

“O-okay.”

Rainbow Dash smiled, playfully saying, “Go hide inside that cloud. I’ll give you a surprise!”

“You mean...”

“Go!”

“Okay!” Fluttershy buried herself inside of a cloud.

Promptly seeing Fluttershy disappear into the center of the fluffy cloud, Rainbow Dash spread her body on top of it.

“What are you going to-” Fluttershy stopped talking immediately.

Rainbow Dash released herself and let her urine squirt liberally into the cloud. She felt a deep sense of arousal as she peed all over the shy mare. The sizzling sound of the urine making contact with and loud moans of joy forced Rainbow Dash to thrust, feeling the softness of the cloud rubbing against her clit as she peed.

“Ohhhh Rainbow Dash!” Fluttershy moaned. “It’s hitting my-”

Rainbow Dash smirked as she heard a large moan from inside the cloud, knowing her forceful stream was pounding against’s Fluttershy’s pleasure dot. The cute mare orgasmed under the pressure of the stream.

“Oh Rainbow Dash! I’ve never came so hard in my life!” Fluttershy bragged.

“Well when you play with the *Rainbow Dash, you know you’re going to cum in no time at all!”*

“Yes, Rainbow Dash. You’re amazing! I love you!”

“And I’d love to taste your pee...” Dash said with a naughty smile.

“You would? That would be so wonderful!”

Laying down on the soft cloud, Rainbow Dash motioned for Fluttershy to come over. As soon as Fluttershy got her pert little behind over Dash’s face, Fluttershy dug into Rainbow Dash’s pussy with her hot tongue.

“Woah!” Rainbow Dash let out a moan as she realized she had broken Fluttershy’s shyness. Moving her lips over to Fluttershy’s arousal-drenched marehood, she opened her mouth and a little stream of urine started shooting down her throat. The warm, salty liquids quickly warmed her insides.

Fluttershy lapped at Rainbow Dash’s marehood, making the rainbow-maned pegasus go over the edge.

Rainbow Dash spasmed and squirted her own orgasmic fluids into Fluttershy’s mouth as she felt pleasure ripple through her body. Urine drenched her mane and rolled down her cheeks as Fluttershy continued to relieve herself on Rainbow Dash’s face.

Rainbow Dash dared to penetrate Fluttershy’s marehood as the stream lessened, only to be interpreted by Pinkie Pie appearing right next to her wanting to join in on the fun.

~~~ *** ~~~

“Dashie?” Pinkie Pie said noticing that Rainbow Dash was in a daze. “Rainbow Dash!”

“Huh-huh, what?” Rainbow Dash said as her pleasant daydream came to an end, feeling a definite wetness on her crotch.

“You’re dripping all over the kitchen!”

“Oh, oh, right. Sorry.” A large drip fell from Rainbow’s backside, and made a splash on the floor.

"So, do you have any of these baked goods already done?"

"Yep, I made some muffins with my pee earlier!”

"Awesome, think I could try one? Though I really need to get going, AJ wants me over at her place to show me some of her new puppies or something."

"Yeah, they're right over here.” Pinkie said, taking three muffins from the stock she had left.

“Did you make any rainbow-sprinkled cupcakes today?”

“Yeah! But I’m gonna  make some more, this time with Fluttershy’s milk!”

“Her milk?”

“Yeah, it’s a long story.”

“We’re gonna make some cupcakes using her pee and milk!”

“You better save me some!”

“Of course we will!”

Fluttershy stood silently, feeling awkward as her friends talked about her bodily fluids.

“You want some glaze for the muffins, Dashie?” Pinkie said as she brought the three muffins to Rainbow Dash in a small basket.

“You know it!”

Pinkie stood up on her hind legs and thrusted her pelvis outward. The silky solution coating her vulva was on full display.

Rainbow Dash got the message. Creeping up close to the back bubbly earth pony, she also stood on her two back legs and began to grind  and picked up one of the muffins with her hoof and started to tenderly rub it up between Pinkie's legs as she stood. Fluttershy stood silent, unsure of what to say or do.