Author's Note

NOTE: Screwball is 18

SPECIES COLOR KEY:
Anthro | Human | Equestria Girls | Pony

TO HELP YOU REMEMBER:
Pink FetishVerse Logo | Human Skin Color | Equestria Girls Logo Color | Rainbow Dash Coat Color

The Arrivals

Twilight stomped down the hall towards her bedroom, huffing and puffing as her body was heating up. She needed some action and she needed it now. Arriving at her room, she opened the door and entered, slamming it shut. About to head to the bathroom to masturbate, she stopped when she saw three identical mirrors set up against the wall beside the bathroom door. They each had a crystal frame and clean, shiny glass.

"What the..." the alicorn started, walking towards them with a confused look on her face. "Where'd these come from?"

Standing in front of the middle one, she slowly reached a hand out to feel the glass when she heard a giggle from behind her.

"I wouldn't touch that unless you know what'll happen..." the female voice cooed.

Spinning around with a gasp, Twilight saw a young-looking purple mare sitting on her bed. She had curly purple and white hair and was wearing a hat with a propeller. Her pupils were swirls and she was wearing just a white dress that went down passed her crotch. She also seemed to be floating above the bad rather than sitting on it. Letting out a sigh, Twilight knew exactly who this was.

"Screwball... Of course. Was this you?" She asked, pointing over her shoulder at the mirrors.

"You bet," the young mare sang with a wide smile. "To help you with your fetish problem."

A huge blush appeared on Twilight's face as her wings fluttered a bit. "U-Uh, what?"

Letting out a giggle, Screwball covered her mouth. "Oh, Twilight... You don't have to keep it a secret from me... I've been watching you girls. Looks like fun, and I wouldn't do anything to ruin that kind of fun..."

Hesitating as she stared at the mare, Twilight thought about the current situation. She then slowly began walking towards the mare. "You won't tell anyone about what we do?"

Shaking her head, Screwball smirked. "Nope... Although, I... wouldn't mind joining you girls some time..."

Standing in front of her, Twilight blushed some more. "I see... And, what do the mirrors do, exactly?"

"Exactly?" the swirly-eyed mare asked, leaning back over the bed and interlocking her fingers behind her head. At this angle, Twilight could see part of her marehood. "Through each mirror is a different world. The one on the left has human versions of us. They pretty much look like us but don't have rainbow colors for their skin..." As the crazy mare explained, Twilight's eyes kept looking up her dress. Screwball had nothing on under the dress. "The one on the right leads to a world like ours but our versions there don't have wings, tails, or horns, and her technologically more advanced than us..." the mare continued explaining. "And, the one smack dab in the middle leads to pony versions of us..."

After the explanation, Twilight pulled her eyes from Screwball's puss and looked over her shoulder at the mirrors. "Three different worlds, huh?"

"Yep," Screwball confirmed. "And, I may have let a certain couple friends of yours know about the portals and that they should head through them..."

Going wide-eyed, Twilight turned around to face her again. "What? Who?" She asked, sweating nervously.

The purple swirly-eyed mare smirked. "You'll see... And, when the fun begins... I wanna watch..." She then trailed her fingers over her still-developing chest and sleek body.

Watching her teasing movements, Twilight bit her lip before letting out a sigh. "Alright..." she said, moving to sit down on the bed, facing the mirrors as she waited. "Any idea how long before they arrive?"

Shaking her head, Screwball floated up behind the alicorn and placed her hands on her shoulders. "Nope... We'll just have to wait and see..."

When Twilight felt her hands on her, she looked over her shoulder at her. As she did, the chaotic mare floated up beside her with a smile. "You really want to join in?"

Nodding, Screwball licked her lips. "You betcha... I wanna feel your thick mare cock penetrate my tight pussy..." she cooed, running her hand up her own leg towards her crotch.

Watching her hand, the princess was already starting to sweat. She then quickly turned and grabbed Screwball's shoulders, laying atop her and forcing her on her back. "You are such a tease..."

Grinning, the mare held her hands above her head, not attempting to slip away. "I was wondering how long it'd take you to lose it... I thought longer..."

"It's been a long day..." Twilight argued. "Now, I can finally do something about it..."

"That, you can..." Screwballs said with a giggle. "What are you going to do to little old me?"

"Nothing you can't handle, psycho..." Twi said with a playful smirk, placing her left hand on Screwball's right leg.

Chuckling this time, the purple chaos mare licked her lips. "Mmm... True... I can handle a lot... Even Fluttershy's huge... throbbing... meaty... penis..."

Letting out a shuddered chuckle, Twilight slid her hand up higher on the mare' leg. "You stretchy?"

Stretchy enough..." Screwball cooed, squirming with delight as the alicorn's fingers almost reached the tight pussy.

Suddenly, there was a knock on the bedroom door. Freezing up, Twilight stared Screwball in the eyes as the purple mare grinned deviously.

"You've gotta be kidding me..." Twilight groaned, sitting up and getting off the bed.

"I'll be waiting..." Screwball sang as she slid up against the pillows, legs spread casually and not caring if her puss puss was on display.

Getting to the door, Twilight opened it to see Sunset Shimmer. "Oh... Sunset..." Twilight said with a blush, not expecting an uninitiated friend to show up. "Uh... H-Hi..."

Looking confused, the yellow mare crossed her arms. "Something wrong?" She asked. "I got a letter saying you wanted to meet me here?"

"Did you?" Asked the alicorn, before turning to look at Screwball.

Sunset looked over at the mare on the bed, too, who just smiled and waved at them.

"Oh..." Sunset said as she entered, closing the door behind her. "What's up this time?"

"Something... different..." Twilight said nervously as she headed for the bed. "Something I've been into lately..."

"Such as?" Asked the unicorn, eyeing Screwball.

"Well..." Twi started, a blush on her face as she felt her heart rate increase. Her other friends took it well so maybe Sunset would, too. "Our friends and I have been helping satisfy each other's fetish fantasies..." she explained, making her present friend blush. "We're sort of... friends with benefits now..."

"Ah..." Sunset muttered, rubbing the back of her head. "I see..."

After hesitating for a moment, Twilight took a step towards her. "Would you... like to join us?"

Blushing even more, Sunset was about to speak when the mirror on the left lit up. All three mares looked over at it as a figure suddenly stepped through it. She resembled Sunset but had tan skin and was wearing a white shirt, leather jacket, shorts, and boots.

"Ah, you must be a... human Sunset..." Twilight said with wide eyes. "Uh..."

The human Sunset looked over at them and went wide-eyed, too. "What is this?" She asked, seeing the anthro pony version of herself. "What are you?!" She said, sounding frightened as she took a step back towards the mirror.

"Wait..." Twilight said, holding out both hands to calm the human down. "I think I know what's going on here... And, no this isn't a dream or a nightmare... And, no we're not going to hurt you..."

The human Sunset eyed her before looking at the anthro version. "This is real and... safe?" She asked, seemingly calm as she slowly approached her doppelganger.

The current world's Sunset hesitated before stepping up to the human. Both then reached out a hand and touched palms.

"This is freaky, but... cool..." the human said with a smile.

The anthro smiled back. "I was thinking the same thing..."

Watching them get used to each other, Twilight smiled and walked up to them. "So... are you friends with a Twilight Sparkle in your world?"

The human looked at her before lowering her hand. "Twilight?" She asked, before stepping up to the alicorn princess. "You're Twilight Sparkle?"

"Yeah..." the purple mare said with a confused chuckle. "Harder to believe than another version of yourself?"

"No, about the same..." human Sunset said, before smiling. "The Twilight I know doesn't have wings, a horn, or a tail..." she explained, before starting to circle the princess. "You do look pretty cool, though..."

"Uh, thanks?" Twilight said questioningly.

"So, why was I asked to walk through a mirror?" The human asked, wanting to know what was going on.

"Well..." Twilight began, before anthro Sunset took over.

"She's in a friends with benefits relationship with her friends and has asked me to join. And, knowing something about the one who actually asked you to come here... I'm betting she wants to spread the love into the other worlds..."

"Oh, you're clever," Screwball cooed as she sat up. "And, hot, too..."

The human listened to the conversation, looking only very slightly shocked. "Huh... Friends with benefits, huh? I mean, I... don't see the down side..."

"There isn't one," the chaotic mare said in a sing-song voice. "You get to live out your fantasies with those you trust whenever you want... I'm bringing all you here so you can try it out first before going back to your own worlds... Plus, I want a good show. You can start now, if you want..."

Letting out a sigh of annoyance, Twilight walked over to the bed again, climbing up beside Screwball. "That's it. Time to put the tease in her place."

Looking up at her, Screwball put on a fake scared expression. "Oh, no, your highness... Please, don't punish me..."

Human Sunset watched as Twilight put a hand on the chaotic mare's right leg, thinking about this. "I suppose there's no harm in... doing yourself..." she said, looking over at the other version of herself. "I wouldn't ruin my own reputation... or a friend's..."

Anthro Sunset looked over at her, too. "And, it does sound like a fun idea... Being able to satisfy your desires whenever you want..."

"So, we okay with this?" The human asked, receiving a nod from her other.

Just then, there was flash of light as the mirror on the right lit up. Human Sunset walked over to the Anthro and put an arm around her before the two of them watched the mirror. Twilight was so close to rubbing Screwball's pussy again before she noticed the mirror. Letting out a groan, she turned and laid down on the bed beside Screwball, watching the mirror.

Suddenly, a figure emerged from it, standing on two feet like Human and Anthro Sunset. She had a normal body like the human version but had the skin color of the anthro. She also looked a ad younger and wore a white shirt with shorts.

"Um..." the young Sunset said, spotting the two Sunsets first. "What?"

"Yeah, we thought it was weird, too," the human said, removing her arm from the Anthro and walking over to the newcomer. "So, you're he Sunset from your world..."

"Yes?" The new Sunset muttered, before seeing Twilight. "Twilight?" She asked.

"Hello," the princess waved. "Welcome to our world, other Sunset. Long story short, we're becoming friends with benefits to help each other with certain needs. Right now, my friends are probably having sex with each other..."

The High School Sunset stared at her, mouth slightly agape. "Oh... I see..."

The human stepped up to her and put a hand on her shoulder. "We both think it's a great idea and worth trying out. I'm sure you'll eventually come to that conclusion, too..."

Eyeing her and the Anthro one, the new Sunset gave a light nod. "I suppose that makes sense... Seeing as how we're pretty much the same person..."

"That's the spirit," Human Sunset said with a smile, holding out her hand. "Come join our group."

Young Sunset nodded with a smile and took her hand, following her over to the first Sunset. As they got to know each other, Twilight put her right arm around Screwball and rubbed her clothed belly. To her surprise, the crazy mare nuzzled up to her. Eyeing her, she didn't have much time to react as the middle mirror lit up.

Everyone in the room looked over at it to welcome a new Sunset Shimmer. This one was a pony, however. Same mane style as the anthro and same coat color, only she walked on all fours and resembled and actual pony.

"Well, this is new," the human Sunset pointed out, noting that every other copy walked on two legs where this was a pony who walked on four.

"Uh..." the pony said, stopping in place as she looked at the three other Sunsets. "Wh--"

"Friend with benefits," Twilight said, interrupting. "We're getting closer to our friends. But, you'll be having fun with yourself to see if that's something you'd be into before seducing your friends in your own worlds..."

"Oh..." the pony replied with a blush.

"We all think it's a great idea," the Anthro Sunset cooed with a smile.

Looking over at her, pony Sunset smiled lightly. "Well, if you're me... then I'm guessing I'd eventually come to that conclusion myself..."

Rolling her eyes, Twilight was getting sick of all the repeated dialogue. Though, that was to be expected when there were four different versions of the same person in the same room meeting each other for the first time. "Why don't you four get to know each other first before I join. I have something else to take care of first..."

All four Sunsets looked over at her and smiled.

"Sounds like a plan," Anthro Sunset replied.