Author's Note

SECTION CONTAINS: F/F, Anthro/Feral, Anthro/Human, Feral/Human, Anal Fingering, Clones, Crotch Boobs, Cum Play, Fisting, Interspecies, Multiple Orgasms, Orgy, Realistic Pony Orgasm, Xenophelia

SPECIES COLOR KEY:
Anthro | Human | Equestria Girls | Pony

TO HELP YOU REMEMBER:
Pink FetishVerse Logo | Human Skin Color | Equestria Girls Logo Color | Rainbow Dash Coat Color

Sunset Orgy

Rolling her eyes, Twilight was getting sick of all the repeated dialogue. Though, that was to be expected when there were four different versions of the same person in the same room meeting each other for the first time. "Why don't you four get to know each other first before I join. I have something else to take care of first..."

All four Sunsets looked over at her and smiled.

"Sounds like a plan," Anthro Sunset replied.

Human Sunset knelt down in front of the pony, reaching out and gently stroking her back. "So a pony me, huh?"

The anthro version knelt next to the human and looked her over. "So, you're a human?" She asked, reaching out and touching her arm. "You feel stronger... Like you have more muscle..."

Smiling, the human eyed her. "I do work out a lot..." she said, before looking at the pony again. "Now, if we're going to do this, let's do this. I've never done it with an animal before..."

High school Sunset knelt beside the pony and looked her over. "Neither have I..."

Pony Sunset eyed them all and smiled. "Why am I getting all the attention?"

"You're the odd one out," Anthro Sunset cooed. "We all look relatively the same... Then, there's you..."

Pony Sunset blushed before she felt the younger Sunset run her hand over her side towards her backside. Looking over her shoulder, she saw the other Sunset knelt behind her butt. After hesitating for a couple seconds, the pony moved her tail aside so young Sunset could see her horse pussy.

"Do we need identifiers?" The human Sunset asked suddenly, getting the other Sunsets' attention. "Like, a way to differentiate?"

"How so?" The pony asked.

"Well, there's me who's human... one that's an anthropomorphic pony... one that's an actual pony... and then one that's something else," she said, looking at the high school Sunset. "She's sort of human, but not... so we can't call her Human Sunset. So, I was thinking nicknames."

"Nicknames?" asked the other Human Sunset. "Like a Sunset, a Shimmer, a Sunny, and a Shimmy?"

The others all eyed each other, not sure who should get what.

"Maybe pony us gets Sunny because it's adorable," the human said with a smile. "Then the human pony can be Shimmy..." she said, motioning to the anthro. "I can be Sunset. And that leaves Shimmer."

The pony, anthro, and other human all nodded in agreement.

"Now, that that's settled..." Shimmer said as she leaned in close to the puffy pony pussy. "Can we start? The smell is really getting to me..."

Sunny looked back at her with another blush before she felt hands on her face. The human made her look forward again as she leaned in and kissed her on the lips. The anthro Sunset watched them with a smile.

"Can't really do anything with these clothes on..." Shimmy said as she began to disrobe.

As she did, the other three watched as she removed her shirt and pants, throwing her clothes aside as she sat fully nude. Breaking the kiss with the pony, Sunset crawled over to Shimmy and nuzzled her left breast.

"You have a nice pair..." she cooed, before sitting up. "Let me show you mine..." The human disrobed as well, tossing her clothes aside and stretched her arms above her head. "What do you think?"

Shimmy leaned in and felt over the human's breasts, squeezing and rubbing them. The two then pressed their chests together with a light giggle before kissing, their tongues meeting as they let out moans. The anthro's tongue was a bit wider than the human's and had a different flavor.

The anthro pushed the human over and climbed atop her, cupping her tits and sucking on the right nipple. As she did, the human moaned out and licked her lips, her hands resting on the floor above her head as Shimmy licked over her breast.

Shimmer gave the pony pussy another sniff before she began to remove her clothes. Throwing them aside, she grabbed Sunny's butt again. Smiling, she scooted closer and pressed her breasts to the pony's butt, sliding her hands up to the pony's body. Sunny could feel Shimmer's nipples harden against her butt before the orange human moved back and leaned in to sniff her pussy again. Sticking her tongue out Shimmer gave the meaty pony puss a long lick.

"Mmm..." Shimmer cooed, licking her lips. "I actually like that..."

She then went back and buried her mouth in the pony's wet lips, slipping her tongue deep inside and licking around, moaning at the taste of the pony puss, making Sunny moan out.

"Oh, wow..." the pony moaned, panting heavily with a blush. It was odd for her to hear her own voice saying how much she enjoyed the taste of her pussy. If her other liked it, would she? "This feels amazing..."

Shimmer smiled and slurped up some juices before pulling away. "I wonder..." she cooed, looking at her hand.

Curling her fingers into a fist, she pressed it to the pony pussy. Sunny looked over at her and was about to say something, getting cut off as she let out a gasp when she felt the fist enter her. Shimmer smiled as her hand was engulfed in the warm pussy of her animal self. She then slid her fist deeper and deeper, making the pony moan out louder and louder.

Soon, the orange human was elbow-deep in the puss. She could feel the inner muscles of the pony pussy squeezing her arm as she felt the insides become more and more wet. Letting her arm rest in there for a couple seconds, she began to pull her hand out. Sunny panted heavily and moaned out, drool dripping from her mouth as she felt the fist moving in her pussy. When she felt the fist about exit her, it was pushed back inside, making her moan out again.

As the orange human fisted the pony, the human and the anthro looked over at them.

"That looks like fun..." Sunset cooed, before looking up at Shimmy. "Maybe we should start doing something like that..."

Shimmy smiled down at her and nodded. She then turned around so they were face-to-pussy before she lowered herself. "Here. Let's taste each other..." she cooed, before leaning in and licking the human pussy.

Sunset moaned out before gripping the anthro's ass and pulling her pussy into her face, burying her mouth in the wet lips. Both began to eat each other out and let out muffled moans. As Sunset licked the insides of the pussy, she moved her right hand closer to the anthro Sunset's crack and pressed her thumb to her hole. After rubbing it a little, she gently pushed it in and drew out a deep moan from the anthro.

Meanwhile, Shimmer sped up her fisting as sloppy wet noises could be heard as an orgasm was building up in the pony's pussy. Suddenly, the pony let out a loud moan as her legs twitched. Shimmer felt a milky liquid rushing towards her elbow before a flood of mare cum poured from her pussy, coating Shimmer's arm. Not stopping her fisting as she watched in awe, Shimmer both felt and saw more and more milky cum pour from the pony puss.

"Oh, wow..." Shimmer said with a smile, slowly pulling her arm out of the pony.

Looking over at them, Sunset and Shimmy smiled and looked at each other. Both getting the same idea, they began to crawl over towards them. Seeing the other two approaching her, Shimmer gave them a smile. Crawling close to the orange human, the human and anthro leaned in and began to lick Shimmer's arm. As they licked up the pony cum from the arm, the pony collapsed, panting as she rolled onto her back.

"That felt great..." Sunny moaned, drool staining her lips.

Looking down, Shimmer saw the puddle of pony cum she was kneeling in. "That's a lot of cum... Never tasted pony cum before," she said, looking at the two licking her arm. "How is it?"

"Pretty good, actually," the human replied.

The three of them then looked at Sunny's soaked crotch and smiled. Taking turns, Shimmer leaned in first and began to lick up the pony juices that stained Sunny's crotch. Moaning at the taste, she licked a couple times before sitting back up. Next, was Shimmy's turn as she leaned in to taste the mare cum from the source, licking all over the meaty pony pussy lips. Letting out a happy moan, she sat up as Sunset leaned in. She wrapped her lips around the pussy and sucked, making wet, lewd, slurping noises as she sucked up the juices that leaked out. As they did this, Sunny moaned and panted, her hind left leg twitching.

When they were done, Sunset placed her hands on Sunny's hind legs and spread them apart to expose her crotch teats. They were about the size of tennis balls. "Those look pretty delicious, too..." Sunset cooed as she leaned in, cupping the sides of the teats as she licked at the right teat. Flicking her tongue over the nipple, she then sucked on it with a moan. Rubbing the other nipple with her thumb, she drew some more cute moans from the pony.

While Sunset enjoyed the pony teats, Shimmer turned to Shimmy and pulled her into a kiss. Not resisting at all, the anthro returned the kiss as both let their hands explore the other's body. As Shimmy's hands ran over the slightly smaller tits, Sunset's hands explored the larger ones.

Looking over the pony's pussy, Sunset smiled and rubbed it with her hand. "I wanna feel..." she said, before slipping her hand inside. Sunny's eyes went wide as her hind legs twitched. Her tongue rolling out of her mouth, she felt the human's hand slide deep inside her.

Getting in to her elbow, Sunset smiled and rubbed the inner walls with her palm. "It's nice and warm in here..." she cooed, before beginning to move her arm back and forth. "It's also very wet..."

Sunny bit her lip as her pussy winked in arousal. As pants escaped from her mouth, she could feel another orgasm coming.

Breaking the kiss, Shimmy and Shimmer looked over at them as Shimmy scooted closer. Running her hand over the pony's right hind leg, the anthro leaned in and kissed the pony's hoof. Smiling, she watched the human's arm slid in and out of the pony's pussy.

"I want a turn to feel around inside there..." she cooed, making Sunset look at her.

"You can have your turn when I make her cum that sweat cream again..." the human said with a smirk, pumping faster.

Sunny was in so much bliss that she couldn't form any words or make any noises. Her mouth just hung open as her second orgasm neared. Her whole body twitched as she breathed heavily. Soon, her thick mare cum began pouring out of her pussy, coating the human's arm.

Wet sloshing noises could be heard as Sunset kept pumping her fist inside Sunny's flooding pussy. "It feels weird, but... hot..." she said with a chuckle before pulling her hand out. When she did, a larger rush of creamy cum poured out, making quite the puddle beneath the pony.

Shimmy smiled and rubbed Sunny's belly. "I'll let her rest a bit before I fist her. I want her to have some cum built up..."

Sunny eyed her with her mouth open and drool staining her chin. The anthro looked at her and smiled, leaning in and kissing the pony on the lips, her tongue entering Sunny's mouth and licking at the thick pony tongue.

Sunset watched them as she licked her arm. Looking at the cum on her hand, the human placed her hand on her chest and smear the pony cum on her breasts. Shimmer crawled over to her and nuzzled her left tit, before giving it a lick. Smirking, Sunset turned to face her as Shimmer continued to lick at her breasts.

Breaking the kiss with the pony, Shimmy smiled at her and rubbed her belly. "Think you'll be able to cum again?"

"I-I don't know..." the pony moaned out softly. "We ponies can have many orgasms a day, but... so soon after already cumming twice?"

"Theeeeeen..." Shimmy began, leaning in and kissing the pony's neck. "Can I just keep my hand in there until you're ready?"

A huge blush appeared on Sunny's cheeks before she gave a light nod. "O-Okay..."

Smiling, the anthro rubbed the pony puss before slipping her hand inside. After feeling inside a little bit, she began to move deeper and deeper. Staying knelt next to Sunny, she pushed her arm all the way in up to her elbow. She then leaned in and kissed the pony's belly.

Sunny closed her eyes and tucked her forelegs close to her belly and moaned, feeling he anthro's arm inside her. The feeling of a thick appendage deep inside her would never get boring as it felt way too good. She could then feel fingers rubbing her inner walls which made her pussy wink again.

"Why am I so horny?" The pony asked with a moan. "How can.. I be cumming so... so much?"

Shimmy smiled and began to move her arm. "Maybe you have the ability to have multiple orgasms... You're a unicorn, right? That mean you can use magic?"

Sunny gave her a light nod. "Uh-huh... Y-Yeah..."

Shimmy moved in between the pony's legs to get a better view of her pussy. "Ever experiment on yourself?"

Shaking her head, the hoofed Sunset twitched a little. "N-No... Never done that..."

"Well, let's not look a... gift horse... in the mouth..." Shimmy said with a wink, getting a smirk from the pony. "Now, relax while I make you cum for the third time..."

Moaning loudly, Sunny tilted her head back, her stomach moving up and down as she breathed heavily. Watching the pony's belly, Shimmy noticed her breathing increase as her pussy winked more frequently. Smiling and licking her lips, the anthro sped up her fist-fucking before she heard Sunny moan out loudly.

As she arched her back, the pony moaned again as a flood of her mare cum poured from her pussy, covering Shimmy's arm. When her pussy was done, she lay limp, breathing heavily. Like before, she could feel some of her cum trapped inside by Shimmy's hand. When the anthro Sunset pulled her arm out, the cum was released and poured out.

"Mmm..." Shimmy moaned. "Pony cum looks so hot..." she said, looking over her hand before licking it.

Sunny just lay there, panting heavily and staring up at the ceiling. Shimmer and Sunset looked over at them and chuckled.

"I think we're just about ready to invite Twilight over, right?" Sunset asked, looking over at the bed as she saw Twilight throat-fucking Screwball.

Shimmy and Shimmer looked over at Twilight before looking at Sunset.

"I'm pretty sure I'm ready for the finale..." Shimmer cooed as she put an arm around the human.

Shimmy patted the pony's belly before nodding. "I'm ready... And, Sunny should be ready soon..."

"It's settled, then..." Sunset cooed. "Let's invite her over."