Sugar Coated Lust

by Old Goat Abadeer

Rating: mature
Tags: Equestria Girls, Sex, Sour Sweet, Shadowbolts (EqG), Sunny Flare, Other, Romance, Drama, Porn, Profanity, Non-consensual, Sugarcoat
Length: 4519

Afew months after Sour Sweet's "Reformation" Sugar Coat is getting a little too attached to her new pet, but surely breaking her deal with Sunny Flare won't cause too much of a fuss, will it!?

(One-Shot) (Sequel) Afew Months have passed since Sour Sweet's "Reformation" into Sweet. During this time Sugar Coat and Sunny Flare have done a decent job of sharing their beloved leader. But when Sugar Coat schemes to keep Sweet all to herself she'll learn first hand their leader wasn't the only one with A Sour Side!

Story Contains: Bondage/BDSM, Pet-Play, Hypnosis and maybe a few other surprises.

Published 2018-08-16 04:30:01 UTC
Last updated 2018-08-16 04:30:01 UTC

Control VS Compromise VS Submission

It was a sunny Friday afternoon at Crystal Preparatory Academy and most students and clubs had left for the weekend, one however seemed to have a few lingering members not quite done with their argument, er meeting.

"It's my turn with Sweet!" Sunny Flare huffed. "You can't just hijack her!" The petite purple haired girl fumed,

"I'm not hijacking, i'm just deciding to redistribute our allotted time" Sugar Coat bluntly stated in her usual blunt and recently increasingly crass and defensive voice. "We agreed to be co-owners of our little pet so I don't see the problem" Sugar Coat added.

"The problem is that you will have gotten her two weekends in a row!" Sunny Flare scowled.

"True" Sugar Coat admitted. "Though that would mean you would get her the next two weekends after" Sugar told her in an effort to persuade.

"So you say, but how do I know you won't just try to change things up again!" Sunny huffed.

"Are you calling me a liar!?" Sugar growled. She was many things but she was not a liar, well not most of the time anyway.

"If the Glasses fit!" Sunny angrily teased. Smiling wickedly at Sugar Coat.

"Why You!" Sugar Coat Growled as the two girls stared at each other in a deadlock.

Meanwhile outside of the room and down the hall SourSweet or just Sweet as she went by now just set on a nearby bench and hummed a melancholic tune.

"Oh, Ms. Sweet, you're still here? A familiar voice asked in surprise. Sweet looked up and saw Dern er Principle Cadence standing not too far away.

"Oh, um Principle Cadence, I ah..." Sweet blushed as she looked down and fidjited her finger. "Um, yes i'm waiting for Sunny and Sugar, they're still in the club room....arguing."

Cadence just smiled and let out her usual soft chuckle. "Well first off Ms. Sweet you don't need to avoid eye contact with me. Your friends already explained your, hyperactive...shall we call it outburst a couple months back was from your new medication, it's all water under the bridge, just don't go around kissing any more faculty members out of the blue, OK." Cadence awkwardly chuckled.

"O-OK" Sweet awkwardly chuckled back.

"Well, anyway I do believe you said your friends were arguing, would you by chance no what it's about?" Cadence asked with concern.

"I-I think it's about me" Sweet admitted.

"Oh? Is that so?" Cadence asked, her voice a bit more sly this time, that old high school part of herself potentially eager for some juicy gossip. Not that she would ever share her students private lives with anyone else, she was a professional after all, but there was part of her that still liked to hear about relationship woes, after all in her days as a student she was a bit of a matchmaker.

"Yes, yes it is" Sweet sighed. "They both want to spend time with me this weekend and they're both in there arguing over who gets to..."Sweet paused remembering her mistresses had told her it would be bad if she told people what they really did on their weekends. "Who gets to spend time with me." She finished.

Cadence just looked down at SourSweet and sighed. "Well, I think I understand it. But it still seems like a bit of a silly argument, why don't you just spend time with both of them." Cadence chuckled.

"Huh?" Sweet asked somewhat confused.

"Find something all three of you like doing together, maybe go to the park, walk your dogs, or go see a movie." Cadence suggested.

"A-A Movie, that's it!" Sweet cheered with a smile "Everyone love's movies!" she chuckled. "Oh Thank you Dean, er Principle Cadence i'll go tell them right away!!" Sour continued to cheer as she ran back towards the room.

"Those girls" Cadence chuckled. "They may be the academic and athletic elite of this school, but I think sometimes their stubbornness gets in the way of common sense" The principle joked to herself. "Oh well, I just hope whichever one of those girls does end up being the right one for her that they make her happy." Cadence sighed with a smile as she began to walk back towards the Principles office to get her things and double check to make sure everything was locked down for the weekend.

"I've got the answer!" Sweet cheered as she burst into the Shadowbolt's meeting room. The other two girls just looked at her somewhat dumbfounded not expecting their argument to be interrupted so well, loudly.

"Who said you could come in here?" Suger Coat Growled.

"W-well no one but..." Sweet began with a gulp.

"Just a minute now Sugar Coat, we're still at school and Sour Sweet is still the captain so she out ranks you for now" Sunny Flare reminded the angry nerd giving her a sly smile.

"er...fine" Sugar Coat scowled. "What's your dumb idea!?" She bluntly and rudely asked.

"W-well" Sour Sweet stuttered before closing her eyes and took a deep breath in and out. "A-As your captain I demand you stop arguing and both agree to go with the movie to me tonight, that way all three of us will be together and you can settle what else to do after that!" Sour Sweet commanded.

Sunny Flare chuckled and gave off a sly smile. "Sounds perfectly good to me." She chuckled.

"Fine...whatever" Sugar Coat reluctantly agreed.

"YAY!" Sweet happily cheered, glad she would be spending time with both of her ~~mistresses~~ friends for a bit longer.

Later that evening the three girls made their way to the movie theater, or a movie theater anyway. "This isn't the way to the mall" Sugar Coat bluntly stated.

"Well, we aren't going to the mall" Sweet smiled.

"What?" Sugar coat huffed.

"I thought we could go to the Crystal Palace Theatre and see their special showing of The Countess of Mareneigh Crista!" Sweet happily exclaimed.

"Oh Darling, that sound's lovely, it's a classic!" Sunny Flare cooed.

"And one of our childhood favorites!" Sweet smiled looking at sunny with a bit of a blush.

"Ugg, this is ridiculous!" Sugar Coat thought to herself "I thought reprogramming this bipolar bitch to be nicer and more eager to please would make her less annoying, not more!" Sugar internally whined. "I guess some extra lessons are in order this weekend, i'm still the main mistress and she should be thinking about what pleases me, not that hoity toity fashionista!" Sugar Coat internally grumbled.

"Sugar? are you OK dear you seem to be growling." Sunny Flare pointed out.

"I'm fine, I just....I just don't care much for old black and white films is all" Sugar Coat stated.

"Hmm, odd...and here I thought you nerdy types loved the classics. How disappointing" Sunny chuckled. Sweet also giving a bit and more sincere pouty face.

"That's a stereotype" Sugar bluntly replied. "I am a modern nerd thank you very much and I would much rather see a modern movie!"

"Oh...OK" Sweet sighed her happy step stopping to a crawl as they approached the theater.

"Fine, if it means that much to you i'll see your silly movie" Sugar Coat huffed. Sweet getting a big grin across her face and rushing to hug Sour Sweet "Oh Thank you, Thank you Mistress!" She cheered as she squeezed and the two girls chests came close together causing Sugar to blush.

"Now, now" Sunny tisked "none of that Mistress stuff in public, remember!" Sunny scolded.

"Oh right Sorry Mis..er Sunny" Sweet chuckled as she let go of Sugar Coat and began to skip towards the old theater once again. The other two girls just looking at her and rolling their eyes.

After a couple hours the sun had set and the street lamps began to glow brightly as the peatrons left the theatre.

"Oh man, that was great!" Sweet happily chuckled. "Action, Drama, Suspense, Romance, Heartbreak!" She screamed as she swung from a light pole.

"And best of all Justice!" Sunny Flare Sang as the two girls crossed arms and began to spin around together.

"You two are being ridiculous" Sugar Coat stated as she shoved up her glasses once more.

"Oh come now darling you can't say you didn't enjoy the film as well" Sunny teased.

"I can and I will" Sugar Coat huffed.

"aww...b-but why!?" Sweet asked with a pout.

"Well the main character was a complete idiot!" Sugar Coat began. "Ella Dantes was dumb enough to get herself framed she had no one to blame but herself." Sugar stated. "And on top of that you know that Ferena Mondego chick seemed pretty smart, she more then earned the right to call Mercedes her own!" Sugar huffed.

"Sorry darling but i'm afraid that's a horrible opinion" Sunny Flare rebutted "Ella and Mercedes were in love, there's no way she would ever abandon her, she had to escape from prison and rescue her love and their adopted son!" Sunny confidently stated.

"Or she could have just accepted Ferena was the better woman and sailed off somewhere else to start a new life" Sugar Coat Scowled.

"Well maybe love means more then brains!" Sunny Flare er flarred.

"Ha, yea right, love is just a chemical reaction in the brain, just an excuse to give into lustful urges, might as well have a partner worth having, one with both brains and beauty!" Sugar Coat growled.

"And who's to say Ella didn't have both!" Sunny growled back, the two girls once again giving each other death stares.

"Somehow I don't think this conversation is about the movie anymore" Sweet awkwardly chuckled. "H-hey girls why don't we go back to my place and chill down I can make us some strawberry lemonade and...." But before Sweet could finish Sugar Coat grabbed her by the arm and began to run off.

"Wh-what are you doing you cad!!" Sunny Flare screamed.

"Taking her home with me remember, you can have her the next two weeks after or whatever!" Sugar Coat waved as she ran off Sweet trailing behind still confused by the whole situation.

"Don't worry my dear Mercedes! I shall save you from that scoundrel!" Sunny Flare stated trying to do her best impression of a professional 1940's actress. "No one shall stop our love dear Sweet!!" She finished as she gave a determined look and began to run after the two girls, unintentionally tripping as she did so. "Oh right, I wore heels today, this...this might take awhile" Sunny Flare nervously chuckled.

Back at Sugar Coat's house the angry silver haired pig-tailed girl quickly threw Sweet onto her bed. Both girls already panting as they had run the entire way home.

"M-mistress" Sweet panted.

"Shut-up, no one said you could talk!" Sugar Coat wheezed. "Now lay there and be quite, i'll get us a bottle of water, we'll cool down a bit before we start" Sugar Coat commanded. Sweet just said nothing and nervously nodded in submission. Sugar Coat let out a half smirk and left the room. After about 15 minutes she returned, sucking on a giant water bottle, the thing almost empty, throwing Sweet a much smaller one as she did. "Drink it" She commanded as she gulped the last of her's down.

"O-OK" Sweet complied, drinking the smaller water bottle to re-hydrate herself.

"Good" Sugar Coat smiled. as she took off her cloths and fell down face first onto her bed "Now massage my back!" The girl commanded as she took off her glasses and did her best to try to relax.

"A-as you command mistress" Sweet nervously stuttered as she began to rub the voluptuous brainy girl's backside.

"Oh yes, that's nice." Sugar Coat moaned as Sweet slowly rubbed and massaged the girl's backside. "Isn't this much nicer then spending time with that boring ol Sunny Flare?" Sugar Coat asked with a chuckle. There was a slight pause before Sweet finally answered "Y-yes mistress" She said in a rather downtrodden tone.

"That didn't sound very sincere" Sugar Coat growled as she set back-up and stared daggers at her sub.

"I-i'm sorry mistress..I..I" Sweet stuttered.

"C'mere!" Sugar coat growled as she pulled Sour Sweet close to her chest puffing her large breasts as the girl's face was planted firmly in the middle. "My breasts are much bigger then that prissy petite so n so's!" Sugar Coat boasted. "There even a bit bigger then your's yea know" She teased as she gently punched one of Sweet's breasts. "So tell me how is it you still prefer her's to mine!?" Sugar Coat growled pushing the girl back down on the bed and slowly began to undress her.

"I-I don't" Sweet gulped as she began to shake, looking at her mistress stare at her with hungry and angry eyes full of lust and rage dancing around as she undressed her.

"LIAR!" Sugar Coat growled. "You like her more then me, even though we're both supposed to be your doms, you like her better, even though i'm smarter and i'm better, tell me why!!" Sugar Coat Hissed.

"BECAUSE I LOVE HER!!" Sweet cried as she continued to shake, now frightened of her mistress.

"You love her eh" Sugar Coat chuckled as she got off the bed and to the corner of the room where she kept her chest of toys, getting out a whip, a riding crop, some rope and the book on BDSM that had started the whole thing, the hypnotic pendant inside it like the book mark. "Well then I suppose i'll just have to teach you to love me instead, won't I dear Sour Sweet" Sugar Coat chuckled looking back at the poor girl with a straight evil glare, her desire for control and power over her once stubborn leader's mind and body fully corrupting her. Sweet just shook and began to sob.

"Don't you worry my love, i'll save you!" Sunny Flare dramatically stated for the dozenth or so time since she had started running towards Sugar Coat's house after finally giving in and taking off her heels, not that running in her bare feet was much better. Stopping to catch her breath for a moment Sunny Flare breathed heavily as she composed herself and stood up facing the manor. "Don't worry babe, i'm coming!" She exclaimed as she pulled the emergency key from under the rug and unlocked the front door. "Never make an enemy of someone who knows where you keep your keys darling!" Sunny Flare chuckled to herself as she quickly opened the door and began to run up the stairs.

Meanwhile in Sugar Coat's bedroom the girl had poor Sour Sweet hanging from a sex swing while bound in ropes, a ball gag in her mouth and a black sleep-mask over her face, head phones playing sounds of the girls past excursions that Sugar Coat had secretly recorded and to top it off vibrators in both her snatch and butt hole. "maybe with enough conditioning you'll finally understand why i'm the better mistress" Sugar Coat chuckled watching her pet squirm in her swing.

"Let her go you vile fiend!" An overly dramatic voice exclaimed from behind. Sugar Coat looked back to see a rather worse for wear Sunny Flare holding a pair of broken heels and fritzy hair just standing there in a brave stance looking like she was ready to fight.

"You look ridiculous" Sour Sweet bluntly stated. Sunny Flare replying by throwing one of her high-heeled shoes right at the girl's face.

"What the hell was that for!?" Sugar Coat shrieked.

"You know exactly what it was for!" Sunny growled.

"Ugg, why can't you just get over this! Why can't you just let me have my fun!?" Sugar Coat angrily whined.

"Because this isn't fun, this is abuse!" Sunny flare stated pointing to Sour Sweet. "I bet you don't even have a safe word!" Sunny huffed.

"Why would I need one? I can do whatever I want with my toy." Sugar Coat deviously chuckled.

"She's not your toy, she's our friend, and our sub. There's rules to these kinds of relationships Sugar. You can't just treat her like she's some high tech sex doll!" Sunny scolded.

"Oh, and why not?" Sugar cooed. "She was going to do the same to us not to long ago, before we stopped her and turned the tables" Sugar Coat reminded her friend "And you seemed to be OK with it that time" Sugar Coat smirked.

"Yes, but--but that was different" Sunny Flare stuttered. "We didn't have a choice then, not any good ones anyway" She stated. "But now we do, and whatever you're planning to do here it's wrong!" Sunny stated as she began to move forward and untie Sweet from her sex-swing bondage.

"Don't you dare touch her!" Sugar Coat hissed as Sunny ignored her and continued to take the girl down. Sunny inspected Sweet and noticed she had some fresh whip marks on her back, obviously Sugar Coat had managed to have a bit of fun already before she got here. Sunny took off the blindfold and took out the gag and looked at Sour Sweet who was crying and shaking.

"I-i'm sorry" Sweet sobbed as she hugged Sunny Flare "I-i'll be a good girl, i'll love both my mistresses equally I promise!" Sweet sobbed. Hearing those words both made Sunny Flare's day and broke her heart as she stood-up and faced Sugar Coat.

"So that's what this was about?" Sunny glared "You and your jealousy"

"What i'm not jealous!" Sugar Coat tried to lie, but her nervous voice gave her away.

"Yes you are, you always have been, jealous of Sour Sweet for being the leader, Jealous of me having a closer bond with her then you, jealous we might actually have a real relationship someday!" Sunny Flare stated.

"SHUT UP!!" Sugar Coat growled as she whipped the girl.

"H-hit a nerve did I!?" Sunny Flare chuckled as she winced.

"M-Mistresses please stop!" Sweet begged, hating to see her two handlers fight with one another.

"C'mon Sweetie, we're leaving." Sunny Flare smiled as she helped Sweet up and began to escort her out the door.

"NO YOU DON'T!!" Sugar Coat huffed in rage as she lashed out and whipped Sweet on the back. The girl letting out a sharp scream as she fell back down to the floor.

"YOU MONSTER!!" Sunny Flare screamed as she turned around preparing to attack Sugar Coat, only to see the girl too, like the one she had just stricken was crying. "It's not fair" Sugar Coat sobbed "All the night's I spent helping her with her homework, all the test's I helped her cheat on, that weekend we spent at her beach house together celebrating how we were the only two in the school that hadn't caught the horse-fever during spring-break." I-I thought maybe I meant something to her, I-I could be more to her then just a pawn, just a stupid member of some stupid club. I became the Shadowbolt's Treasurer to get closer to the only person who even bothered to talk to me other then the teachers on the first day of school" Sugar laughed through the tears as she couldn't believe she admitted some stupid sob story.
"But I guess in the end I didn't have a chance, you two have known each other since preschool, you've grown-up together and i...i'm just a third wheel" Sugar Coat reluctantly admitted as she wiped the tears from her eyes.

Sunny Flare moved back, not sure how to react to this spontaneous and unexpected confession. "W-wait you...you really love Sour Sweet too?" Sunny asked still somewhat stunned.

"Well duh!" Sugar Coat scowled! "Why would I put up with brats like Indigo & Lemon if I didn't!" Sugar coat stated.

"Hmmm" Sunny Flare contemplated taking in this new information. "OK then, she can stay" Sunny Flare smiled.

"What!? Really??" Sugar Coat asked in disbelief.

"Yes, unlike your greedy ass I am actually quite generous" Sunny Flare chuckled. "Of course their will be some conditions" Sunny Flare deviously smiled.

"Conditions like what" Sugar Coat scowled.

"Well you may use our dear Sweet here as some shameless sex toy, but I've been teaching her proper techniques for a proper lady and I think you should let her show you, while I watch of course." Sunny Flare mischeviously grinned.

"Fine, whatever, not like we haven't fucked in front of each other before." Sugar Coat huffed. "Let's just get this over with before I completly lose my buzz.

"Tut tut, A proper lady takes her time dear Sugar Coat" Sunny scolded. "Isn't that right sweetie?" She teased winking at Sour Sweet. Sweet just winking back in reply.

"OK, Let's begin!"

Sugar Coat set on her bed as Sour Sweet approached. "How may I serve you tonight mistress?" The sweet girl asked as she climbed on the bed and bowed her head in submission.

"I dunno, just do whatever sunny taught you or whatever." Sugar Coat blushed.

"As you wish mistress" Sweet compiled as she took Sugar Coat's hand and kissed her palm. "You look lovely this evening mistress." Sweet whispered in a sultry tone.

"Y-yea whatever, just get on with it!" Sugar Coat nervously comanded.

"As you wish mistress" Sweet compiled as she positioned herself behind Sugar Coat and began to massage her back. "First let me help you relax, and then I shall begin the real fun" Sweet happily chuckled, Sugar Coat just rolling her eyes. Sweet going along her merry way none the less, messaging Sugar Coat's shoulders and then moving to her back, eventually pressing down on two pressure points causing the girl to moan.

"Ooohhh" Sugar Coat moaned.

"Did you enjoy that mistress?" Sweet asked.

"Ohhh" Sugar Coat moaned as Sweet continued the massage.

"I believe that's a yes darling." Sunny chuckled as she watched the two, lustfully licking her lips.

"Very well, I shall continue then" Sweet smiled in response as she began to kiss Sugar Coat's neck and started to knead and squeeze her large breasts. Sugar Coat's body beginning to warm up. "Ohhh...yess" she happily moaned as her face began to get red. Sweet taking this as confirmation to continue, turning her kisses into love nibbles then love bites as her hands alternated between softly rubbing Sugar Coat's body and playing with her breasts, even being so bold as to nibble on Sugar Coat's left ear causing the girl to moan out in pleasure as juices began to drip from her lower lips.

"Oh my, I do believe she's ready for your best trick now Sweetie" Sunny Flare cooed. "You know my dear Sweet's fingers can make you cum in 10 seconds flat shall we try it out" Sunny Flare sang in a sultry tone looking at Sweet and nodding. Sour Sweet taking two of her fingers and placing then in Sugar Coat's snatch.

"OK, let's begin" Sunny sang as Sweet began to finger fuck her friend.

10
"Ohh" Sugar moaned
9
"Yes" Sugar wheezed
8
"Soo good" Sugar relaxed
7
"Oh, more, faster no slower, no..ahh." Sugar exclaimed
6
"Tingling, getting there"
5
"Oh Godess Yess!!" She sultrly moaned
4
"So..so close"
3
"Any second now" Sugar blushed
2
"Ahhh"
1
"Ahh.ah...ohg... I'm
0
"Cumming!!" Sugar Coat screamed as her love juices began to pour out.

"Good Girl" Sunny Flare smiled. "Now Fall"

"Whaa" Sugar Began as she heard Sunny snap her fingers and saw the girl had been holding the hypnotic pendant. Sugar just smiling goofily as she feel into a trance like state.

"Hehehe" she chuckled as drool began to roll down from one side and her lower lips still steadily streamed a bit of fluids.

"Such a naughty girl" Sunny Teased. "So obsessed with getting pleasure from your pet you didn't notice I was working to hypnotize you the whole time" Sunny chuckled. "Now tell me Sugar...do you like how you feel now?" Sunny Flare asked with a devious smile.

Sugar Coat just nodded yes.

"Good Girl" Sunny Cooed. "Tell you what Sugar, as I said earlier I'm a generous girl so I'll let you keep feeling good with Sour Sweet and me, but you have to be a good girl, ok" She teased. "No more helping people cheat on tests, no more trying to be so controlling, that makes you just as bad as Sour used to be for Pete's sake." Sunny scolded. "Got it!" Sugar Coat just nodded in compliance.

"Good" Sunny smiled. "Now I'm the one in charge, the head dom, got it. From now on you too shall be a pet, only to teach you some proper manners of course" Sunny Flare cooed. "In fact that sounds quite fun, you as a pet, next time I snap my fingers you will believe yourself to be a dog. A horny female dog in heat who will eat out or or suck off the closest person next to her and let them fuck her to their hearts content if need be. Of course the next time I snap after that you can go back to normal, or...normalish" Sunny chuckled snapping her fingers causing Sugar to get down on all fours.

"Woof, woof, woof!!" Suger Coat barked as she hopped of the bed and crawled towards Sunny placing her muzzle under the girl's dress and began to lick her panties and whine.

"Oh my, aren't we eager" Sunny Flare cooed as she began to slowly remove her panties, Sugar Coat diving in and eating her out like a hungry puppy causing Sunny to release her pleasure sooner then she expected. Sunny just panting exclaiming "oh my!" Before pushing her back causing Sugar Coat to whine as she licked Sunny's juices off her face. Thankfully Sweet was nearby and had her legs spread open and wanting causing Sugar Coat to dive right in and eat the eager yellow girl as well."

"Oohhh" Sweet moaned as she released her love all on Sugsrcoat's face.

"So my sweet, how do you like your new doggie?" Sunny chuckled as she hopped up on Sugar Coat's bed.

"I love her" Sweet cooed in delight.

"Good, now get up here you two" Sunny chuckled as she patted the bed and the two complied, Sweet laying her head on Sunny Flare's lap and Sugar Coat panting and wagging her ass excitedly.

"Cute, but why don't you take a nap too doggie." Sunny chuckled as she snapped her fingers once more and Sugar Coat returned to normal, er normal
-ish and began to fall into Sunny's lap her eyes heavy for some reason, quickly giving into slumber.

"Yes" Sunny Flare chuckled. "I believe this will do nicely" She smiled as she laid back on the bed and also began to fall asleep, her girls at her side.

Author's Note

Moral: Don't try to cheat your friends or something something can't force love.

Anywho second Shadow Bondage one-shot down, kind of vanilla I know but we'll have more next time. And as always will try to fix mistakes as I see them. Thanks for reading! Hope you enjoyed!!