To Conquer a Nightmare

by 10champ10

Rating: mature
Tags: Slice of Life, Alternate Universe, Nightmare Moon, Original Character, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Romance, Porn, Sex
Length: 2288

Nightmare Moon needs a stallion, luckily for her, there is one close by.

Nightmare Moon is a powerful and somewhat feared ruler. Ruling her own kingdom is hard. But just like every mare, there comes a time of the year for her. She can't hide from this forever, so she gives in to find a possible suitor. Those in her kingdom either respect her too much or fear her too much to be a viable option. But her guards did capture this foreigner other day, crossing into the kingdom illegally. Happens to be a stallion. The odds seem to be in her favor.

Was bored the other night, skimming around some of the groups one of my stories was plopped into and saw some Nightmare fan art in there. Then this idea came to me. So running with it. It is going to be a longer comic, but probably not as long as my other two projects. The later part of this is going to be more emotional, while all the fun happens up front.

Published 2018-09-10 05:10:01 UTC
Last updated 2018-09-10 05:10:01 UTC

The Propositiion

Nightmare Moon was nearing her estrus cycle. That dreaded time of the year for her. Having to lock herself away to her own prison and leave the ruling her to her advisors. Though this time was going to be different. She had no offspring, she had no lover, she had nothing. Luna had her sister and vice versa. As well as Twilight. Nightmare was a lone ruler. She couldn't stay that way forever. She needed to find herself a stallion.

At first she thought of finding the best stud and letting him be the father. But she didn't want to be a single mother and ruler of her own kingdom. No, she wanted to a suitor that could fit the bill and she could keep long term. Something in her just wanted it to go that way. Besides, she did like the term, queen. Finding her king was going to be hard. No stallion in her domain was going to treat her the way she would want to be treated long term. Unfortunately, they either respected her authority too much or feared disappointing her to the point of fearing her. Then she remembered, her guards had arrested an Equestrian stallion not that long ago. She never bothered dealing with him personally. That was left to other positions. But Equestria was being really slow in responding to their inquiries about him. He had no I.D. Refused to talk, but didn't fight the guards at all. She found it strange. He willingly surrendered, but just refused to answer questions. But maybe she personally could get something out of him. Maybe even offer him something he may not be able to refuse.

She trotted to her castle prison. Only three prisoners, and this mystery stallion was kept closest to the entrance and exit. He was peaceful after all, followed the prison rules, did any commands the guards asked of him. He just stayed silent. The other prisoners were further down. Both assaulted other ponies in the kingdom and were awaiting their trial. Again, something Nightmare didn't participate in. She would give the guilty verdict too much. But sure enough there was this stallion, exercising. He was well built, good tone. Even before he was in prison. Why did he just surrender? Just as simple as being spotted by the guards he gave up any fight. They didn't bother putting him in chains he was so cooperative.

"So, you are the prisoner that my guards keep talking about. The one that surrendered and is so well behaved, yet could probably have easily won a fight against the rookies that found you. Why?" Nightmare asked him.

"I did something illegal, got caught, doing the time for it. Though in my defense, there wasn't much of a fence there to begin with." The stallion replied, finishing his exercise before wiping away the sweat with a towel. He gave her his full attention, though to her partial enjoyment, was treating her like a ruler, rather, almost like she was one of the guards. Time to see what he thought about getting out of prison.

"You do know who I am right?" First things first, make sure this stallion knows who she is and the power she holds.

"Nightmare Moon, current ruler of this kingdom. I also know, that you did not come down here just to have a casual conversation with me. You hold an offer for me, yes? One of either governmental power, or for your personal gain? Did a guard cough on your shoes?" He was being witty with her. He also was testing her, just like she was testing him.

Nightmare couldn't believe the way this stallion spoke, it was almost insulting. She growled a little, before realizing that this was something she was somewhat looking for. One that was not afraid of her, nor over respected her position. This was when she also realized he was testing her. If she really had something to offer of importance, she would only go so far with him, as he was useless with any injuries. This stallion was quite smart, she liked that. After a quick breath, "It's of personal matters that I came here for. Equestria has not responded to our inquiries about you, nor has made any attempt to try to get you back. So I have a chance for you to earn your freedom and earn citizenship."

"I am listening." The stallion replied. Her offer was looking good, give her something and he was free. He wasn't really sure what he had to offer though, but hey, no complaints yet.

"I am in search for a suitor for myself. A mate." She was a bit hesitant to say she wanted a mate, but it was the truth. His next few responses would determine whether his personality would match up to she was looking for in a stallion.

"There aren't stallions roaming the streets right now that would be capable? I am flattered that you would offer this to me. But you could do better than some prisoner, right?" He was surprised that she wanted him to be, quite blunt, a sperm donor. But why of all stallions did she go to him first?

"You are the only one that doesn't either respect my position too much or fear that I would angry if you didn't live up to expectations. You show the right amount of respect, and quite humble." He was living up to every one of her requirements right now and then some. "Though, before we go any further, what is your name?"

"Name is Ghost, ma'am. If you find me to be worthy of what you desire, I shall accept your offer." He bowed gently to her, just for bonus respect to her. He never thought he would land himself in such a position. A ruler was offering him a chance to be her personal stud. From her wording, she was looking long term, so sperm donor was not the end game. She wanted one stallion, one she could love. She wanted to give him the chance at it.

Nightmare was pleased with this stallion. He physically was a stud, giving good chance for favorable offspring that could be capable of ruling after her passing. He also had the right mindset, making him favorable as a long term partner. She had the cell opened and Ghost walked out. Now that he was in full light, she could see him better. Fur blacker than her nights, blue eyes that could see through souls. His whole body was toned with muscle. He naturally was just built that way and he just sharpened it. No cutie mark though. Odd. "Why don't you have a mark?"

"Guess it was just meant to be. No mark, forever a mystery. That's how I earned my name. Others thought I was a ghost in physical form." He shrugged. At this point in his life, he didn't care if he did or did not have a mark. Not having one, though, was more fun. Could be anything, could be nothing. Made it all the more mysterious.

Nightmare, connecting all the dots, accepted his simple explanation. It made perfect sense. Just never meant to have one. But enough of that. Time to take him back to her personal quarters and learn more about him. She did have approximately two days before her body would be completely screaming for a stallion to claim her. She wanted to learn as much about this stallion as she could before she let him relieve her needs.

She was blushing once they were alone. It was one thing to think it, but now she is doing it. Courting a possible stallion that could be the father of her offspring. All he had to do was still be the same stallion she questioned and he was guaranteed to have her body and her heart. "So, tell me about you." She asked softly as they sat on the sofa.

"I grew up, lonely. My parents weren't around much and never bothered to hire any babysitters or the like. So I was just left to my own devices. I was a troublesome foal growing up. Getting into fights in and out of school. But after a year or two of that in high school I got my act together. Channeling myself better, getting my focuses where they needed to be. I then served in the Equestrian Royal Guard for six years right out of school. After that, decided to travel."

Very interesting. He turned out pretty decent despite not having much supervision growing up. That alone may be enough for Nightmare to say he was going to be her stallion, now and forever. But she wanted to know he was loyal. "Any friends during those times?"

"Yeah. I have a few friends from school I used to keep in touch with. Hard to do that when in a prison cell. But, yes I do have some childhood friends." He smiled a bit. Though now that he probably was allowed too, she started to pay more attention to Nightmare's body. Despite the tales of old, she wasn't overly evil. Just enjoyed the night sky. Her kingdom was doing okay to say the least. Her fur was just as black as his, it was curvy, very attractive. Though had the poise of power. It asked for simple respect. Muscular chest, shoulders and wings. Hips were properly plump. She was strong, had to be to stay a leader and earn respect among other nations.

Nightmare noticed his eyes trace her body. She felt so exposed, despite wearing her crown, collar and shoes. Though, those did not cover her body, just complimented it. Did he like her? She was caught up in making sure he was fit for her, she hasn't given him a chance to make sure she was fit for him. Her face turned red though, blushing as he looked at her body. He didn't look disappointed, which made her feel a bit better and blush a bit more. Was she attractive to him? "D..Do you like me?" She asked softly.

"Yes." He replied, closing the gap between her and him. Only make her face turn almost red instead of black. "I wouldn't change a thing about you. Beautiful, and based on the fact you asked that question shows you care about me. Give us some time, we would be a good couple."

Nightmare was so relieved. This was the stallion she wanted. Her heart was racing as new emotions grew inside her. She decided to let him see the real her. She took off all the royal garments. "Ho...how beautiful am I?"

"As I said, I wouldn't change anything about you." He gently took her hoof and held it. She was so nervous that she wasn't going to be good enough for him. After trying to make sure he was good enough for her. Though he took another look at her, now completely nude form. She was quite naturally beautiful and her form was more enticing to him like this than with her royal attire. "Though if I had to make a choice, between with and without you wearing the attire, you look more beautiful to me, without it on."

She felt really exposed when she saw his eyes once again look at her body. Now with nothing on. Though she felt so happy that he approved of her natural beauty and her personality. The way he held her hoof, so gentle, passionate, so loving. She couldn't hold herself back. She leaned into Ghost's side, taking him in for herself. He felt warm, soft and strong. The last two were really driving points for her. Protective and comforting at the same time. Though she really blushed when Ghost pulled her against him and held her. She didn't feel like a leader anymore, she felt like a helpless mare being protected by her love. His touch was so gentle to her, she felt malleable. It was glorious. For once, she didn't think about the kingdom's troubles. She didn't need to be special or have a mask on. She could be herself. Right now, though, she wanted nothing more than just be loved by Ghost. She wrapped her hooves around his neck and rested her head against him as she let him do what he pleased.

Which right now was soft and passionate rubs along her mid back and sides. It felt so good coming from him. Just something about being him doing it that pleased her body. Her strong wings started to extend as a result of his rubbing. She didn't care at all. She let them unfold to their full span. They were huge. Much larger than most pegasi would have. Stronger too. Though Ghost took slight advantage and rubbed where they usually rested. A spot not usually touched and it sent a new wave of pleasure into Nightmare. She moaned into his neck as she felt herself relax against his hooves.

Nightmare felt nothing like this before. Her body felt so soft and pleasured. She felt like she actually belonged to Ghost. She wanted to belong to him. No one else, just him. Feeling the mood, she started to kiss his neck, which made him gasp and groan in pleasure, also telling her that she was allowed to continue doing this. So she did. Slowly, passionately kissing up and down his neck. Doing her best to please him the way she felt pleased.

Author's Note

Yup, just a fun little story I'll be working on whenever I feel like working on it, or need a break from the other two stories.