Do You Trust Me?

by Real_Harmony Sparkle

Rating: mature
Tags: Fetish, Rarity, Pinkie Pie, Sex, Random, Slice of Life, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Romance
Length: 3775

Rarity decides to test how much her partner trusts her in a night of fun.

Pinkie Pie has always been super careful with everything. Sounds completely opposite to her right? Well, that's because she hides it behind her mask of the carefree party animal most of Ponyville knew her to be. Rarity, however, soon saw past that mask once the two became a couple.

As time went on, Rarity learned many things about her marefriend; such as the fact she was actually quite timid in situations she didn't fully understand, she was very protective of her body, she was secretly shy around ponies she didn't know well, and she was also a virgin.

Warning! Contains: Dom/Sub (Rarity is dominant), medium bondage, slight humiliation, and a bit of discipline.

Published 2018-10-21 04:30:01 UTC
Last updated 2018-10-21 04:30:01 UTC

Trust

It was a bright, sunny day in Ponyville. The wind was blowing softly, the birds were chirping as they flew through town, and the streets were crowded, but not too crowded with ponies, as usual. Pinkie bounced around Sugarcube Corner, a smile on her face as she continued to take orders, bake treats, and conversate with the ponies around the bakery. As far as Ponyville knew, Pinkie was Pinkie. However, in the back of her mind, the party pony was nervous and slightly scared. That evening, she had a date with her marefriend, Rarity, who claimed she had a special surprise planned for the earth pony. The "surprise" part is was scared her, and she was sure that Rarity knew that. Of course, she knew that Rarity, nor any of her friends, would ever hurt her, she still was a little squeamish that she wasn't aware exactly what she would be doing in the upcoming evening. All of these thoughts distracted her a bit as she worked on a batch of cupcakes somepony had ordered, "Pinkie Pie, dear!" Mrs. Cake called as she entered the kitchen, causing the latter to look back at her employer.

"Yes, Mrs. Cake?" Pinkie asked with a smile.

"Rarity's here," Mrs. Cake replied with a smug smile, but her words caused Pinkie's eyes to go wide as she looked at the clock.

"Is it six o'clock already?" She gasped, before taking a deep breath and standing, "Are you sure you don't need me to do anything else while I'm here?" Pinkie asked as she approached her friend, who was standing in the doorway of the kitchen.

"Nope! I think Mr. Cake and I can handle everything from here. I assume you won't be home until tomorrow?" Pinkie wasn't sure how to answer this question, as it took her completely by surprise.

"I...I'm not sure. Just assume I won't be I guess."

"Alright then, go have fun," Mrs. Cake giggled as she continued into the kitchen to watch the cupcakes Pinkie had been making, while the party pony put on her smile, trying to hide her nervousness as she entered the front part of the bakery with her bouncy walk as she found her marefriend near the counter, a smile on her face, "Hiya, Rarity!" She giggled as she bounced up to her and pulled the unicorn into a hug, which the latter returned with a smile.

"Hello, darling. Are you ready?" Those words shot a bullet of fear and nervousness into the earth mare.

"I...guess I...well what are we going to be doing exactly? You never told me..." Pinkie said softly, backing away from Rarity a little, who giggled.

"Don't worry, I think you'll have fun. I was thinking we start with dinner and a movie?" This made Pinkie smile and nod.

After a dinner at Pinkie's favorite diner, and watching a movie at the theater, Rarity brought her marefriend back to Carousel Boutique, "That was a lot of fun!" Pinkie giggled as she bounced into the boutique, most of her fear having disappeared for the moment.

"Glad you think so!" Rarity smiled as she sat down on the couch, and patted the spot next to her. Taking the hint and invitation, Pinkie jumped over and sat next to her marefriend, and snuggled against her, laying her head on Rarity's shoulder. This was a simple task for her, as she was almost two inches shorter than the unicorn. Smiling, Rarity wrapped an arm around her and caressed her mane with the other hoof. Pinkie blushed but kept her smile as she curled up against the unicorn and closed her eyes. Rarity let the peaceful silence between the couple stand for a few minutes, letting Pinkie be comfortable before raising the subject that had been on her mind for nearly three weeks now, "Pinkie Pie?" She asked after a while, though she continued to stroke the earth mare's mane.

"Mhm...?" Pinkie asked, keeping her eyes closed.

"Do you trust me?" This question caught Pinkie off-guard as she opened her eyes and stared up at the unicorn, who returned a look of seriousness.

"I...of...of course I do! Why wouldn't I?" Pinkie planted a smile on her face and a kiss on Rarity's cheek. Rarity smiled slightly.

"Do you trust me with...say...your body?" Pinkie's eyes widened at this, and she pulled away from Rarity and looked at her in shock. The party pony wasn't a genius, and she didn't understand a lot, but even Pinkie knew what Rarity was implying she wanted.

"Rarity...you...you know I'm a..."

"A virgin I know, and we've been dating a while and...I can't imagine us ever separating...I..want...if you trust me enough yet and want to...I want to be the one who holds your virginity." Pinkie hesitated before she replied, sweat formed on her face, and fear filled her eyes.

"And I...I want to give it to you but...I...I'm scared..." Pinkie's ears fell flat against her head, her breathing staggering. Rarity only smiled as she placed a hoof on Pinkie's cheek.

"Don't be...if you agree...I promise to be gentle, and if you want to stop, all you have to do is say the word." After a moment, Pinkie smiled.

"Okay...Let's do it then," Rarity smiled too and she stood up and gave Pinkie a quick kiss.

"In that case...follow me please," Rarity said in a whispered, gentle but slightly commanding tone, which sent chills down Pinkie's spine, but nonetheless, she obliged and followed her marefriend upstairs to the bedroom. Pinkie stiffened when they entered, but smiled when Rarity looked at her, "Come on over, sweetie it's okay I promise," The unicorn promised as she shut the door behind Pinkie with her magic. Pinkie nodded slowly and approached the bed and laid down, Rarity laid beside her and wrapped a hoof around her marefriend, "You know I love you?"

"Y-yes, I love you too," Pinkie replied and snuggled closer to Rarity, feeling safer when her body was present against her own.

"You know I would never hurt you right?"

"Yes..." Rarity smiled as she ran a hoof down Pinkie's back to her flank, causing Pinkie to stiffen a little.

"If you want me to stop something just tell me...for now though, you do trust me to be in charge of this little play right?" Pinkie hesitated but nodded after a moment.

"Yes...just...just, please tell me before you do something new," Rarity smiled and nodded, before squeezing slightly on Pinkie's flank, making the earth pony bite her lip and whimper, but she didn't say anything, so Rarity continued as she pressed her lips to Pinkie's, the latter returning the embrace as she wrapped her forehooves around the unicorn's neck. Rarity smiled and pushed her tongue slightly against Pinkie's lips, silently asking permission to enter her partner's mouth. With only a second's hesitation, the party pony gave silent permission as she opened her mouth slightly, letting Rarity push her way in, letting her tongue get familiar with the new territory before pulling away for breath, a string of saliva keeping the two mares connected for a few seconds.

"Do you trust me to take total control and please myself and you?" Rarity asked in all seriousness, and Pinkie bit her lip.

"I...I know you love me, and you would never hurt me so...so yes, yes I do. I trust you. Do what you wish," Pinkie said bravely, giving Rarity a soft but weak smile. Her statement made the unicorn smile as she stood from the bed.

"In that case, stay right here, I need to grab a few...things," Pinkie gulped at this as she watched Rarity cross the room and open a chest. A part of the party mare wanted to change her mind, and tell Rarity she was sorry, but could they hold off on this kind of thing until later, but another part wanted to prove she could trust Rarity, and not just to her marefriend, but to herself as well. So she remained silent and told herself that no matter what the unicorn brought back to the bed, she would let her do it, just to see how things turned out, and if she didn't like it, then she would say so and she wouldn't have to do it again. Relationships were about risks right? She had taken a huge risk when she asked Rarity out, so why not take a risk with sex? There was a first time for everything, and she knew she would probably enjoy some if not all of what they were about to do. These thoughts brought a genuine smile to her face, just as Rarity approached the bed. Pinkie swore her heart stopped for a moment when she saw what Rarity had brought over, however. In her magic was at least five feet of rope, four leather cuffs, a vibrator, a crop, a ball gag, and a long, thick white cloth that would probably be used for a blindfold. Seeing Pinkie's panicked look, Rarity smiled, "We don't have to use all of this, but these are my personal favorite items. However, if you aren't against it, I would like to assert my dominance with..." she put down everything but the ropes and cuffs. Pinkie only nodded, telling herself just to let Rarity do what she wanted so that she could see what she liked herself. The unicorn smiled, "Excellent! Then lay on your back please."

Doing as told, Pinkie laid down on her back and got comfortable, "Okay...I'm ready," Pinkie said gently, looking at Rarity with a small smile. Almost instantly, Pinkie felt the leather straps be fastened around all four hooves, "Though I'm curious, why not just use the ropes?"

"I don't want to hurt you, and using the straps will keep you more comfortable," Rarity said, and Pinkie smiled, even though she was taking complete control over her, she was touched at the consideration Rarity had for her. After making sure all the straps were in place, Rarity picked up her ropes and tied each of them to the loops on the straps before tying them tightly to each of the bedposts, "Now, try escape," The unicorn said, and Pinkie nodded and tested the strength of the ropes, pulling on them to try and get free, part of her wanted to panic when she couldn't move very far, while the other part of her wanted to see where this went, "Now...unless you ask me to stop, from here on out I will be your Mistress, and you'll do what I say, unless you want me to whip you with my crop," Rarity explained, levitating the metal crop and running it across Pinkie's flank, causing the bound mare to shudder, but nod. Rarity smiled as she climbed onto the bed and ran a hoof down Pinkie's side, causing the latter to giggle a little and pull on her restraints. Rarity smiled before pushing her body against Pinkie's and kiss her again, this time forcing her tongue into the earth pony's mouth, taking Pinkie by surprise, though she returned the embrace. Rarity wrapped a hoof around her marefriend's neck and pulled her closer while running her other hood down Pinkie's body to her marehood. Pinkie gasped when she felt Rarity's hoof begin to slowly rub circles in her marehood. She whimpered slightly, but allowed her to continue, as she kind of liked it. At least, she assumed she did, as she seemed to involuntarily began to push her lower body against Rarity's hoof, a low moan escaping her body. Rarity smiled at this and pulled away from the kiss, "I think somepony is enjoying herself?"

"Y...Yeah..." Pinkie smiled, then frowned when Rarity pulled her hoof away, which was slightly wet with Pinkie's sweet fluids. The party pony blushed when she saw Rarity's hoof.

"Somepony is wet already too! Are you that easy to please, Pinkie Pie? I know this is your first time but that's almost a little embarrassing!" Rarity exclaimed a smirk on her face. Pinkie knew Rarity was trying a bit of humiliation on her, and it was working! She blushed as she looked away. Her ears perked up when she saw Rarity was licking her hoof, "Though I will admit, you really are sweet inside and out," Rarity giggled.

Once her hoof was clean, she decided to try something new. She lifted up the blindfold and the gag, "Both of these will be used," Rarity said, "But for now, I'll let you choose which one you want first."

Pinkie bit her lip at this. If Rarity did something she didn't like if she chose the gag, she wouldn't be able to say to stop, but with the blindfold, she wouldn't know what was going on. After weighing her options, she realized the blindfold would be her best option, "The...the blindfold please..." She said meekly, and Rarity nodded and put the gag down, and wrapped the cloth around her marefriend's eyes, knotting it into a double knot. Pinkie bit her lip as her sight was stripped from her.

"How about we play a little game," Rarity suggested as she sat on the bed next to Pinkie, the latter smiling a little.

"I like games..."

"Okay then, I'm going to ask you some questions about our relationship, if you get them right, I'll massage your marehood. If you get it wrong, I spank you with the crop. Understand?" Pinkie only nodded, "I'll start off easy, what day did we get together?" Pinkie smiled, that really was easy.

"May 29th, 2017. A year, five months, nine days, three hours and twelve minutes ago. It was a sunny day with not a cloud in the sky. We were at the park on the bench by the fountain where you confessed your love to me."

Rarity smiled, Pinkie truly did have a vivid memory. As promised, she brought her hoof to Pinkie's pussy, massaging it gently, earning a moan from the bound pony as she rocked her hips against her partner's hoof. After a moment, Rarity pulled her hoof away, causing Pinkie to whimper in disappointment, "More...please...!" She begged, much to Rarity's pleasure.

"Get this next question right and I will." Pinkie whimpered again. Being blindfolded, she grew nervous when Rarity's hooves weren't on her. She didn't think she could handle being alone, the thought made her shiver slightly, "Alright, what did we do on our first date?" Pinkie was actually glad to be blindfolded now, as her eyes dilated with fear. They had gone on so many dates, and they were all very similar with only minor differences, not that she didn't enjoy every one of them, but it didn't help her situation now.

"I...we...we had a picnic in the park for lunch...watched a movie...then...ate a small dinner and spent the night together..." Pinkie bit her lip, hoping she was right.

"Whose house did we stay at?"

"Yours...?" She replied with a hint of a question in her voice. She gasped when she felt the cold metal of Rarity's crop run up her side.

"I want you to answer with confidence or I'm counting it wrong!" Rarity said with a bit of command in her voice, it both turning Pinkie on and frightening her a little.

"We were at your house!" Pinkie said confidently and quickly.

"Good girl," Rarity complimented as she returned her hoof to Pinkie's marehood, pushing her hoof gently against her body, Pinkie smiled and relaxed, of all the things Rarity had done so far, this was probably her favorite. Once again, she found herself whining a little when Rarity pulled her hoof away after a few minutes, "Now, who was the first pony we told about us?"

"Twilight."

"You're good at this Pinkie!" Rarity said with a smile as she massaged Pinkie's pussy once again, Pinkie turned on by the touch. She smiled as she tried to move her body closer against Rarity's touch, but failed to find enough leeway in her restraints. This time, Rarity continued to rub her hoof on Pinkie's marehood as she asked her question, "I only told you this once, but what is my biggest weakness?" Pinkie bit her lip, she had no idea. What was it? She thought for several minutes, Rarity had pulled her hoof away at some point, though Pinkie was more focused on trying to get the question right than what Rarity was doing.

"Uhm...you're biggest weakness is...is...I don't know!" Pinkie cried, then squealed when the sharp, stinging sensation of the crop smacked against her left flank. Her body began shaking a little bit.

"Guess your winning streak is over," Rarity said as she put the crop down and picked up the gag, "How about we try this. Open your mouth, Pinkie," Rarity commanded, and Pinkie obeyed, knowing already what was coming. She flinched when the ball gag was placed in her mouth and latched around her head, "Now say stop so I know what to listen for."

"Stmp," Pinkie stated and Rarity nodded, even though Pinkie couldn't see it.

"Okay, now..." Rarity smiled as she lifted the vibrator from the table and teased Pinkie's marehood with it by circling her parts gently, "Let's see how you like this, and no cumming until I say," Rarity said and Pinkie nodded as the unicorn pushed the vibrator into Pinkie's parts until only the handle was visible. Pinkie moaned in pleasure. Rarity flipped on the toy to a lower setting, and Pinkie gasped in surprise, but soon sunk into the pleasure this new object was giving her. She felt herself growing wetter the longer the object stayed there, then she remembered that she wasn't supposed to come and began to grow worried.

When Rarity saw Pinkie had come she shook her head, "I thought I said no cumming Missy?"

"Mm... srry..." Pinkie said then gasped when the toy was briskly pulled from her and shut off.

"I know, but I'll have to punish you for that," Rarity said as she picked up the crop and brought it down with some force on Pinkie's left flank, the one she hadn't hit earlier. Pinkie yelped in surprise, though she couldn't say she wasn't enjoying it. The pain felt good, so long as Rarity didn't hit her too hard. The unicorn then brought down the crop on her other flank again, much harder than the last strike, Pinkie started to cry, tears leaking from under her blindfold. Rarity smacked her again, hard enough for Pinkie to start struggling and try to pull away, she finally emitted what she assumed would be their safeword.

"STMP! Plsme!" Pinkie cried starting to thrash against her bindings. Rarity instantly put the crop down and used her magic to unhook the gag from Pinkie's head and pull it out of her mouth, she set both objects on the bedside table.

"I'm sorry, darling! I didn't mean to hurt you that bad! Are you okay?" Rarity asked as she also untied the blindfold from around Pinkie's head and tossed it to the side. It took a few blinks before Pinkie's vision returned properly. She was glad it was already dark in the room, or the lights would have blinded her.

"Y-Yes...I'm not ready to call it a night yet but...for the rest of the time...could you untie me?"

"Of course, dear," Rarity said as she effortlessly undid Pinkie's bindings with her magic, and tossed the ropes and straps to the floor for now. Once free, Pinkie snuggled into Rarity's arms for the moment, letting silence overtake them for a few minutes as she contemplated everything that had happened in the past hour. Rarity had worked so hard to please her, and for her first time, other than the excessive spanking, Pinkie would say her marefriend had accomplished just that, now she wanted to return the favor.

"R...Rarity...could I...maybe take over for a little...? I want to...return the favor and...and please you..." Pinkie said meekly, her voice a near whisper. Rarity smiled.

"If that's what you want to do, sweetie, then yes," Rarity replied with a gentle smile as she laid down on her back. Pinkie smiled and laid practically on top of Rarity as she pulled her into a kiss, and slowly reached her hoof to Rarity's marehood, and began to massage it gently, while still kissing her. Rarity smiled into the kiss, a light moan escaping her lips. True she was enjoying it, though she also found it adorable how Pinkie was mimicking what she had done at the beginning of their night of "fun". She didn't say anything though, as it was Pinkie's first time, and dominance wasn't something she was familiar with. Pinkie pulled away from the kiss and focused her attention on what her hoof was doing, she dug her hoof a bit harder against Rarity's pussy, still trying to be gentle. Rarity bit her lip, holding back her moan. Her breaths were deep and sharp as she did so.

After a bit, Pinkie pulled her hoof away and decided to experiment. She pulled herself completely on top of Rarity and positioned herself to where her marehood was touching Rarity's and she began to slowly rub them together by moving her body. She continued, slowly picking up speed, but still staying at a slow speed the whole time, still feeling a little shy. It didn't take long before Rarity was pushed over the edge and a louder moan escaped her mouth. Pinkie smiled, she took that as a sign she was doing something right. Soon, the too climaxed together, their fluids making one large puddle on the bedsheets. Exhausted, Pinkie collapsed next to her lover, Rarity wrapping her hooves around her partner, "Are you sure...you haven't done this before? You really know how to please a mare..." Rarity said with a smile as she planted a kiss on Pinkie's forehead, the earth pony blushing at the compliment.

The two laid in silence for a while, just enjoying each other's company, not to mention they were both tired and starting to feel an adrenaline crash. Just before they fell asleep, however, Rarity managed to say one more thing, "You remember when I asked you what my biggest weakness was...and you said you didn't know...?"

"Mhm...What was it?" Pinkie asked.

"You, Pinkie Pie. You are my weakness."

Author's Note

This took a few hours of straight writing...omg! Luckily, my girlfriend, Silent Sparkle, and my good friend, Lunar Eclipse, was able to help me write this and give me ideas! So thanks to you too! I hope you enjoyed another little clopfic from me!

Yeah, this is not my OTP, but I do ship these two.