Stars Only Come Out At Night

by PRlNCESS CADENCE

Rating: mature
Tags: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Porn, Coloratura, Sex, Diamond Tiara
Length: 5599

It's Nightmare Night, which means that everyone in town is trying to get as much candy as they can. For one filly, though, she's going to get a little bit more than candy.

Nightmare Night is the best holiday of the year, a day filled with thrills, chills and stomachs getting filled. Which houses give the best candy, though, isn't entirely known, and one filly is about to find out which house gives her a better treat than she could ask for.

Published 2018-10-31 20:00:01 UTC
Last updated 2018-10-31 20:00:01 UTC

Nightmare Night

“I think we should go this way!”

“Well, I think we should go this way!”

Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon bashed their foreheads together and growled at each other, neither one willing to give an inch of their burning pride. Behind them stood three concerned fillies, Applebloom, Scootaloo and Sweetie Belle, who much preferred just picking a direction and getting it over with, but none of them wanted to get involved in the heated fight between the two temperamental foals.

“I have an idea!” Sweetie Belle shouted, raising her hoof. “What if we went one way, make a quick loop, and then go back and do the other way?”

“Are you kidding?!” Diamond Tiara snapped. “This is our last Nightmare Night, and I don't want to ruin it by taking the road down Old Man River's street.”

“At least we know what's down there!” Silver Spoon rebutted, smacking her forehead back onto Diamond Tiara's. “You have no idea what you're even going to find going that way!”

“You know what I won't find?” Diamond Tiara lifted her head higher than Silver Spoon's, walking forward with dominance and forcing the gray-maned filly to gradually step backwards. “Candy corn! Black licorice! Jelly beans! All of which you can find if you want to waste your time begging for candy from Twist's mom and dad!”

This year, the pressure was at an all-time high. Once foals reached a certain age, usually not long after earning their cutie marks, it would be looked down on for them to go knocking on houses, asking for candy, and this was the year that these five fillies were about to graduate. If they didn't get the best haul ever this year, it meant that they would never get the chance to fix their mistake. Thus, the quality versus quantity debate sprung up, leading to a heated argument between the two most spoiled foals in Ponyville.

“This way has WAY more houses!” Silver Spoon shouted. “Who in their right mind would go somewhere expecting to not get as much candy?”

“What good is having all that candy if none of it is worth eating?” Diamond retorted, causing the three girls behind her to grumble in frustration.

“If y'all can't make up yer mind, we ain't gon’ get any candy this year!” Applebloom complained.

“Or ever!” Scootaloo chimed in, adding her own dissatisfied tone. “Can't we just go down the safe road and get the same candy as every year?”

Diamond Tiara broke her view from Silver Spoon's, shooting a fiery glare at the other fillies and making them flinch in fear. “Fine!” Diamond Tiara exclaimed. “You all want to get tootsie rolls again, be my guest! I'll go by myself and get all the candy I want!”

“Wait! You don't have to go alone!” Sweetie Belle said in an attempt to stop the pink foal, but her patience had already been brought to its limit, leaving the other ponies to take the safe road without her. She would show them. She would come back with the best treats in the entire history of Nightmare Night!

Her plan was simple: go up the Hollyhoof Hills, knock on every door whether their porchlight was on or not, and get out of there the second their hoof let go of their candy bar. The fact of the matter was, Silver Spoon was right. This way had far fewer houses than the road they normally took, but Diamond Tiara had noticed that the kids who went this way had much more confidence than the kids going the safe route. They knew something she didn't, and she was going to find out what that was.

When she knocked on the first door, she was greeted by an older stallion whom she didn't recognize. ‘This is good!’ she thought to herself. ‘If he doesn't know who I am, it'll mean less chitchat! I'll be able to hit twice as many houses as those loser ponies!’ Then, just as she expected, two hay bars fell into her bag, the most coveted candy of Nightmare Night!

“Yes!” Diamond Tiara exclaimed before realizing how impolite she was being. “Oh, I mean, thank you, sir! Happy Nightmare Night!”

The pink foal smiled and waved happily as she began walking away, but as soon as his door was closed, she sprinted to the next doorstep, ready for another haul of rare candies. Now, without four other ponies slowing her down, she could move at triple her normal pace, which only became faster when kids at the next house over did the courtesy of knocking for her, giving her time to catch up while cutting the time it took for ponies to answer their doors. Plus, she was getting way better treats than she ever had in the past! This was becoming the best Nightmare Night ever!

As she made her way through the neighborhood, though, more and more houses were beginning to turn out their lights, and kids were beginning to disappear one after the other. Even though Diamond Tiara's excitement was at an all-time high, even though she was in the zone like some kind of sugar-addicted panhandler, the night was coming to an end. As she looked up and down the street and saw that there were no foals left, she realized that her final Nightmare Night was over.

“No…” she said through gritted teeth as she knocked on her fourth straight door with no answer. Even after looking at her bag and seeing more candy than ever before, she wasn't ready to pull the curtain on this holiday forever. “I'm not finished yet! Hey! Answer the door, will you?!”

Diamond Tiara then began yelling, pounding on the door in front of her with all her might. She wasn't about to leave this pony's doorstep until somepony answered her, and luckily for her, it wasn't long until the door creaked open, revealing a young mare with a concerned look that actually made the pink foal feel embarrassed.

“Yes?” the mare asked hesitantly.

“Nightmare Night! What a fright! Give me something sweet to bite!”

Unsurprisingly, the mare frowned with a sigh. “I'm sorry, child,” she said with genuine sadness. “I've already given out all the candy I had.”

“Are you kidding me?! How much candy did you even have?!”

Despite the reaction she was expecting, the mare did not get angry or try justifying herself any further. Instead, she opened her door up further and said, “If you want, you can come inside and I'll see if I have anything else.”

Diamond Tiara stepped back with an eyebrow raised. “Wait, you'd seriously let me have food from out of your kitchen?”

“Well, I doubt you'd want any apples, but I can at least check to see if I have any fudge bars. It'd probably be best if I didn't have those nearby anyway. Come on in! I'm sure I can find something worth taking home.”

Again, Diamond Tiara was left feeling ashamed and embarrassed at the surprising generosity from the mare, especially when she had acted so entitled and rude just moments before. Still, though, without looking for a reason to reject her kindness any further, she entered into her house and closed the door behind her, gawking in awe at the beautiful home she lived in.

“You live here?!”

“Well, it's one of my homes,” the mare said as she walked towards her kitchen. “Why don't you have a seat on the couch? I'll be right back after I find something.”

“You know what? I don't really need anything! I'm sorry about the way I acted.”

The mare looked back and giggled. “Well, you're more than welcome to take off if you want, but you'd be the first filly I've ever met to turn down free candy.”

“Do you give out free candy to a lot of fillies?” the foal asked, taking a seat on the mare's expensive leather couch. The grown pony, however, froze in her tracks, trying to smile awkwardly through her obvious discomfort.

“Heh heh. Yeah, something like that. *Ahem!* Which do you prefer? Something with hay or something with chocolate?”

“Uh… Either one works for me. Thanks.”

The mare smiled and disappeared into her kitchen for a few moments, but after the sound of a cabinet closing, she walked back into the living room with a pack of small custards in her mouth. “I really should get rid of these things,” she said after plopping them onto the coffee table in front of them. “It may not be candy, but it should definitely satisfy that sweet tooth of yours.”

“And you're just OK with me taking these?”

“Well, if you feel that guilty about it, we can eat them together. Does that work for you?”

“Sure,” Diamond Tiara said, awkwardly opening the bag and taking a bite out of one of the custards. The taste was exquisite, and she could tell that these weren't just regular treats you could get at the local market. Something this rich in taste had to be imported, which begged the question again just how much money this pony made. “You said… this was one of your houses?”

“Yeah,” the mare replied, taking a bite out of her own treat and moaning with pleasure. “I'm originally from Manehattan, but I have houses there, here, one in Canterlot and a beach house in Las Pegasus. I travel a lot, so it's nice to have somewhere to settle down when I'm not too busy.”

The more the mare spoke, however, the more the filly began to notice something familiar about her. “Have we… met somewhere before?”

“Maybe. I meet all kinds of ponies, especially school ponies. By the way, aren't you gonna tell me what you're supposed to be dressed up as?”

Looking down, Diamond Tiara noticed that she was still wearing her Nightmare Night costume, complete with a short skirt, a colorful top and her mane done up into pigtails. “Yeah. I'm supposed to be a cheerleader. I thought it would look cute, but I look kinda dumb. Good thing this is my last Nightmare Night.”

The mare beside her giggled, reaching down again for another custard. “I think you look great, but I guess this explains why you're so adamant about getting as much candy as you can.”

“Yeah… Again, I'm really sorry about that, miss!”

“Please! Miss is my mother's name. Call me Rara.”

Suddenly, all the pieces were beginning to come together: the expensive home, the imported custards, all the traveling she did. “Wait a second! Are you…”

“Maybe,” the mare replied with a seductive grin. “Am I?”

“You're Countess Coloratura!! Oh, my Celestia! I can't believe it! I'm in your house, and I'm eating your food, and you're right here next to me, and--”

“Hold your dragons, there!” Coloratura said with a giggle, silencing the filly's mouth with her hoof. “I'm just a regular pony just like you are. Like I said, just Rara works fine.”

“You are not just a regular pony!”

“You're right.” With another grin, Rara slouched back into her seat, laying her head back onto the armrest while dropping another custard into her mouth. “I'm a pony with an amazing taste for junk food. That's pretty special, right?”

Despite her celebrity status, this mare was acting completely different than Diamond Tiara had expected. In fact, it was Diamond Tiara who was acting like the world revolved around her desires, but in reality, she was really a nopony who had been invited into the home of a somepony! Not just any somepony, either! Countess Coloratura was the biggest pop star in all of Equestria, yet she acted the same as Applebloom's sister.

“So!” Rara said, sitting back up in her seat. “Are you going to tell me your name?”

“Me? Oh! Right! I'm uh… M-my name is Diamond Tiara.”

“That's a cute name! Would it be alright if I called you ‘DT’?”

Diamond Tiara's cheeks blushed. “Y-yeah! That would be fine!”

Even though Coloratura was trying to act like a normal pony, though, she couldn't help but notice how weird the filly was acting towards her, making her feel like she was doing something weird or inappropriate. “Listen,” Rara said. “You don't have to stay here if you don't want. You're totally free to take the rest of these and go back to knocking on doors. I promise I won't be offended.”

“What?! I don't want to go! You're not kicking me out, are you?”

“Hmm… How about this? I'll let you stay, but you have to promise not to treat me any different than anypony else you normally hang out with. Deal?”

Suddenly, all the butterflies in Diamond Tiara's stomach flew away, leaving just the two of them to be themselves. Just two regular ponies. “Deal!” the filly replied, shaking hooves with her new friend.

“So do you normally do Nightmare Night by yourself?”

“Oh… uh… No, this is my first time doing it alone.” The pink foal had completely forgotten her friends whom she had left behind, and upon remembering, she finally realized how immature she had acted towards them. Suddenly, though, she noticed that she was acting weird again and quickly changed her demeanor before she was kicked out of the house. “I got into a fight with a couple of my friends. They wanted to get candy where they always go, but since this is my last Nightmare Night, I just wanted…”

“An adventure?”

“Yes! Finally somepony who isn't boring! I mean, it's not like they'll ever get this chance again!”

“You know what? I don't think you made the wrong decision, and no, it's not just because you got to meet me. This may be the last time you get to go house to house and get lots of free candy, but this isn't your last Nightmare Night.”

Diamond Tiara raised an eyebrow. “Uhhh, what's the point of Nightmare Night without candy?”

Rara giggled again, giving her another one of her smirks. “Being with your friends.”

“Oh…” Diamond Tiara's ears fell, realizing again that she was doing the exact opposite. “So then why aren't you with friends right now?”

“Probably because it's 11 o'clock at night.”

“Oh, right. I forgot.”

“But also because sometimes not having any friends around is the best excuse to make new friends.” As Diamond Tiara looked up at Rara, she couldn't help but smile at her new friend. “I am a little worried, though, DT. Aren't your parents worried sick right now?”

“No,” Diamond Tiara scoffed. “They're off at Pinkie Pie's first annual Up-All-Nightmare-Night Party in Canterlot. They think I'm with my friends right now. Oh, not that you're not my friend! They just think--”

“I get it,” Coloratura said, smiling again, only this time a little less genuinely. “They think you're with friends your own age. You know, sometimes I wish I could give up everything to go back in time and be a filly again.”

The pink filly couldn't help but furrow her eyebrows. “Are you KIDDING me?! You're rich and successful and beautiful!”

“But at what cost?!” Even though Rara was raising her voice, she couldn't help but blush at that last part from Diamond Tiara. “The best part of my job is getting to spend time with school children, but it also is the hardest part. If I lose a fan, I can always make another one. If one of my songs flops, I can always make one better, but youth is something that I can never get back, no matter how hard I work.”

“What's so great about being young anyway?”

Rara shot her a smarmy smile. “I would get free candy on Nightmare Night, for one. Plus… I guess life is just easier when you're a filly.”

“Easy?” Diamond Tiara scoffed. “You think being the daughter of two successful business ponies is easy? Do you not think I deal with any pressure, just because I'm not some important pop star? I always have to be the one on top all the time, and sometimes…” Diamond Tiara began to trail off, fighting back tears as they threatened to pour out of her eyes. “Sometimes I wish I could just hurry up and be an adult. Maybe then I wouldn't have to worry so much on Nightmare Night.”

Without having any real ideas on what to say, Coloratura grabbed the filly by the waist and brought her into a warm hug, patting her on the back the way that her mother never would, and at that moment, Diamond Tiara began to cry. “I'm sorry, DT. I didn't mean to make you feel bad.”

“No, you're fine,” Diamond Tiara said, wiping away her tears. “I'm sorry for that.”

With the conversation derailed and leaving an awkward aura in the room, Coloratura looked down at the bag of custards and smiled. “Just one more left! Wanna share it?”

“Sure,” the filly replied, expecting her to tear the pastry in half. As she pulled the custard out of the bag, though, Rara bit down on one end of the pastry, closed her eyes and leaned forward for Diamond Tiara to bite down on the other half… which she didn't do. “Uhh… What are you doing?”

Coloratura's eyes went wide, biting off her half of the custard and pulling the rest away with her hoof. “Nothing!” she said as her whole face turned red. “Sorry! I guess I didn't bite hard enough. H-here! You can have the rest if you wan--”

“Oh, my Celestia! Were you trying to kiss me?”

“No! I swear, I--”

Even though she was expecting the filly to be offended, angry or even frightened, once she finally grew enough courage to look Diamond Tiara in the eyes, she saw that the filly was laughing, holding onto her gut. “That has got to be the lamest excuse to kiss someone I've ever seen!”

“Yeah! Heh heh.” Coloratura rubbed the back of her neck while her face grew even redder. Hopefully she could play this off like it was all just one big misunderstanding.

“I mean, I guess if you're into fillies, that is probably the easiest way to do it.”

“Huh?! I never s-said I was into fillies!”

“Oh, come on,” Diamond Tiara said, resting her cheek against her hoof while she smiled coyly. “It's been written all over your face ever since you invited me in. I mean, getting me into your house just to give me free snacks? Having me sit on your couch while we talk? The best part of your job is being near school ponies? Come on. You're not fooling anypony.”

Again, Coloratura's face turned red, making her look away from the filly's smug grin. “You won't tell anypony, will you?”

“You admitted it! Ha! I literally can't believe it!”

“OK! I get it!” By this point, the mare was basically trying to duck beneath her shoulders and melt onto the floor in embarrassment. “Maybe you should go.”

“Are you crazy? I'm having way too much fun right now! Besides, what are you gonna do once I leave? Are you still going to think about me? Are you going to picture me between your legs with my face in your crotch?”

Coloratura was now covering her face with her hooves. “Why are you doing this to me?”

“That really turns you on, doesn't it? You know, you sound like you want me to stop talking, but I bet deep inside, you want me to keep going. You probably got turned on just from hearing a little girl say ‘deep inside you.’ I bet anything I say at this point is just going to get you even more--mmff!”

Before either of them knew what was going on, the two of them were suddenly kissing. On one side, Coloratura's eyes were squeezed as tight as she could press them, while on the other side, Diamond Tiara's eyes were wide in her state of total shock. Several moments passed by before either of them moved a muscle, but once Coloratura opened her eyes enough to see Diamond Tiara's reaction, she quickly pulled away, clearing her voice awkwardly while the filly remained frozen.

“Sorry about that,” Rara said, pulling her mane behind her ear. “I got a little carried away there.”

“That was my first kiss…” Diamond Tiara said without emotion.

“Oh, no! I'm sorry! Ugh! I can be such an idiot sometimes! Listen, I--”

“No, YOU listen!” Diamond Tiara shouted, making Rara recoil in fear. “I wanted my first kiss to be with somepony special, NOT with somepony who's going to ask me to leave right after doing it! So…” The pink filly trailed off, her eyes dancing around the room as she awkwardly looked for the right words to say what she wanted. “So are we going to do it again, or are you just going to make me leave?”

“Actually, I don't think I should. You're just a filly, after all. You don't know what you're--”

Diamond Tiara growled, causing Coloratura to abruptly end what she was saying. “You think that just because I'm a filly, I don't know what I'm doing? Well, I'm obviously not going to learn by not doing anything, so kiss me!”

“But…”

“Ugh!”

Before Rara had any time to react, Diamond Tiara brought her hoof around her head and pulled the two of them in to kiss again. This time, both of them closed their eyes while Coloratura’s lips lightly danced against Diamond Tiara's, who awkwardly mimicked as best she could. The feeling of lips much smaller than Rara's pressed to her own was making her head spin, while the foal across from her was trying to not act too timid about her first kiss being with Equestria's top idol.

Suddenly, Diamond Tiara felt something pierce between her lips. Opening her eyes in shock, she noticed that Coloratura was probably just acting off of impulse at this point, and not wanting to make things awkward, the filly joined in, dancing her tongue across the mare's. Coloratura squeezed Diamond Tiara harder, pulling her in closer while the younger pony tried her best just to keep her tongue from being dominated in her own mouth. Out of nowhere, however, the foal began to feel a hoof run down her back, freeing her from the costume she was wearing.

“Hold on!” Diamond Tiara exclaimed, making Coloratura snap her hoof back to own body. “How far are we going to go tonight?”

“Actually, I think that's far enough. Thank you for uh… that… Maybe you should--”

“I swear, if you're going to tell me to go home, I will tell everypony about what we did tonight.”

Coloratura was hoping that she was bluffing, but it seemed like no matter what she did, she was going to risk getting into trouble. “Diamond Tiara, listen. I can't have sex with you.”

“Well, duh! We're both girls! How would we have sex?”

Despite what she just said, Rara squeezed her legs together at the thought of demonstrating to a filly what it was like to become a mare. “Do… Do you want me to show you?”

“Wait. Can two girls have sex?”

“Mhmm,” Coloratura said happily before pressing her lips back to Diamond Tiara's, bringing her tongue back into her mouth violently as her hoof completely unzipped the filly's costume. Then, as Diamond Tiara shook the fabric off of her legs, Rara ran her hoof through the foal's mane, releasing the ribbons supporting her pigtails and letting her mane fall down onto her shoulders. “Alright, DT. Last chance to change your mind.”

“No. I want to do this.”

“If you say so.” Without giving her any further instruction, Coloratura guided her partner's body around, moving her to where the filly's front hooves were on the couch's armrest while her hind hooves were spread slightly. Upon moving her tail out of the way to reveal Diamond's privates, Diamond Tiara reflexively whipped her hoof back to cover herself back up. Just as soon as she realized what she did, though, she blushed, hesitantly moving her hoof away from her private area again.

“Sorry, Rara. It's just a habit.”

“Don't worry, DT,” the mare said, rubbing her hoof around the foal's rump. “In just a minute, you're going to want me to see you there more than anything.”

Closing her eyes and opening her mouth, Coloratura began to run her tongue between Diamond Tiara's legs, making her jump at first, but gradually calm down at the unrecognizable sensation she was probably feeling. With her tongue acting like an extra hoof, Rara danced around the filly's lower lips, spreading them wide to get between all the folds underneath. Every once in a while, when Rara would hit a sensitive spot, Diamond Tiara would let out a cute, high-pitched “Eep!” which drove the countess into a frenzy to explore her until she heard her make the sound again.

Leaving the filly's vulva, the mare brought her tongue up about an inch higher, using her hoof to rub in replacement of her tongue, which was now preoccupied with Diamond's backdoor. Diamond Tiara quickly looked back to make sure that the countess knew what she was doing, which she answered by running her tongue in circles around her tight, little butthole, sending shivers up the filly's spine. With one hoof rubbing circles around Diamond's clitoris, making her breathe heavily, her other hoof pulled back on Diamond's buttcheek, opening her anus just slightly enough for Rara to explore the skin around her.

“Mmmm! Hey, Rara?”

“Yes?” Coloratura said, lifting her face enough to see her partner's, but still licking and rubbing with her full attention.

“Does… Does it taste good down there?”

Rara giggled. “It takes some getting used to, but after a while, it becomes the best taste in the world.”

“Do you think…” Diamond Tiara's voice trailed off as she looked for the right thing to say. “Do you think that maybe I could try?”

Coloratura tried to hide her smile, but she couldn't hide how much her cheeks burned. “Yeah! Come try it out on me!” Without hesitation, Coloratura laid back on her sofa, spreading her legs and allowing her folds to display proudly in front of Diamond Tiara, whose face was also burning red now. Then, after a big gulp, the filly lowered her face and gently ran her small tongue between the mare's labia, making her involuntarily moan already.

“Hey!” Diamond Tiara snapped. “If I'm going to do this, no weird noises!”

“I'm sorry, DT. I guess you're just too good at this.”

“Whatever.” The filly then went back to licking between the mare's legs, causing Colorature to drip like a faucet with her wildest fantasies coming to life beneath her. Once Diamond Tiara got a tongue-full of her natural lube, though, she quickly spat to the floor, taken off guard by the pungent flavor. “Yuck! Ptoo!”

“Like I said, it definitely takes some getting used to.”

Diamond Tiara wiped her saliva from her mouth. “I don't think I can ever get used to that.”

“Then why don't we try something else?” Before Diamond Tiara could even speak, though, the mare had already pulled herself off of the couch and begun trotting away. “I'll be back in just a second!”

While Rara was away, the pink foal quickly ran to the closest mirror she could find, fixing her mane as much as she was able to be presentable for when she showed back up. Suddenly, though, she heard hoofsteps and quickly made her way back to the couch, pretending like she had been sitting there the whole time. “What took you so long?” Diamond Tiara asked.

“I was just getting something maybe we could both enjoy.” The mare was carrying a wooden box on her back, which she then placed onto the coffee table and opened up, revealing a dark purple toy inside.

“And what is this supposed to be, exactly?”

“It's a toy for grownups!” Rara replied with a smile, making Diamond Tiara crack up laughing.

“Grownups still play with toys?! Do they play pretend while having sex too?”

“Sometimes.” Again, Diamond Tiara went into a hysteria of laughter, holding onto her sides as she fell backwards. “Hey, you'll never know unless you try it!”

“Alright, alright,” Diamond responded, wiping away a tear. “I guess if you're into fillies, it shouldn't surprise me that you play with toys too. What do you do with it? Dress it up?”

Rara rolled her eyes. “Here. Spread your legs a little bit and I'll show you.” With a smile still on her face, Diamond Tiara complied, spreading herself wide enough to just barely be able to see into the filly's orifice. Then, taking one end of the toy and putting it into her own vagina, she gently pulled apart Diamond's filly lips and eased the other end inside her. The initial shock made her eyes go wide, but after the surprise had sunk in, she could fully enjoy the feeling of the dildo sinking inside her. “It doesn't hurt at all, does it?”

“A little, but I don't want you to stop. This feels really good.”

“OK. I'm gonna go a little bit harder, so just tell me if it starts to hurt too much.”

The filly nodded, giving full control to the mare as she began rocking her hips back and forth, sinking the toy deeper into both of their holes. Diamond Tiara's chest visibly rose and fell at this newfound sensation of her innocence being taken away from her. Coloratura, on the other hand, was trying to be as gentle as she could while simultaneously trying to push harder until their lower lips kissed.

“Is this how all mares feel when they have sex?” Diamond Tiara asked in a little more than a moan.

“Mhmm. Now you see why we like it so much.”

“Like it? Why would you ever stop? Mmmmm.”

“Hey, no weird noises, remember?”

“Oh, shut up and go deeper in my pussy.”

With her smile growing wider on her face, Coloratura pushed the toy in deeper, filling up her own insides in the process. Holding onto the filly's hips, she started moving her hips more violently, causing them both to moan in fervor as the toy robbed them from any logical thought. For minutes, the only sounds in the room were the two ponies’ moans and the splashing sound of their vaginas, which began to drip down onto the couch underneath them. As they continued to grind their hips together, they gradually moved themselves into a position where their hind legs had intertwined, lifting their butts off the sofa and slamming together as hard as they could, ignoring any pain they would probably feel afterwards.

“Mmm, Diamond Tiara. Can I make weird noises now?”

“Whatever. Just keep going.”

Without further permission, Coloratura began screaming her lungs out, making Diamond Tiara's hooves nearly give out at the arousing new stimulus. The filly then bit onto her hoof to keep her from screaming herself, but whenever Rara hit her in just the right spots, she couldn't stop her high-pitched breaths from escaping.

“I wanna cum so bad right now,” Coloratura moaned.

“Come where? What are you talking about?”

Hearing the filly's innocence just added to her arousal, giving her everything she needed to send herself over the edge. “It's happening! I'm cumming!”

Quickly pulling out the toy and aiming her vagina away from her partner, Rara lifted her legs into the air and began squirting onto the coffee table, involuntarily shaking as multiple streaks cascaded from her insides. Despite not understanding what was happening, though, Diamond Tiara felt even hornier, taking the other end of the toy and running it inside her as she waited for Coloratura to recover from her orgasm. Finally, once the sensation had subsided, Coloratura looked down at the foal with a smile, pulled the toy out of her fillyhood and licked up and down her thighs, catching as much of Diamond Tiara's deflowered nectar as she could.

“Now you see why I like fillies so much,” said the countess with a wink. Diamond Tiara, on the other hand, looked down at her crotch with disgust.

“Gross! Now I’m all sticky! And why did you pee everywhere?”

“I was cumming. Do you know what that is?”

“No. Don't tell me. It's gross. I don't wanna know.”

“You didn't seem to think it was gross when I was doing it.”

With her cheeks blushing red one final time, Diamond Tiara got off the couch and quietly put her Nightmare Night outfit back on. “I'm gonna go for real now,” she said, struggling to get her ribbons back on the way they were. “I need to show my loser friends how much more candy I got than they did.”

“Yeah, they’re probably worried sick about you right now,” Rara replied, smelling the arousing scent on her hoof.

“But…” Again, the pink filly looked for the right thing to say, but couldn't think of anything other than blurting out what she was really thinking. “I can come back some time, right?”

“Just as long as you promise not to tell anypony what you're coming back for.”

Diamond Tiara promised herself she wouldn't blush anymore that night, and so with her bag full of candy in her mouth, she turned towards the door and began walking herself out. With the door slamming behind her, the filly walked outside, back into the dark streets of Ponyville on the final minutes of her final Nightmare Night.