Lost in Bliss (Complete Story)
Bon Bon neatly placed two plates on the table, next to them were two empty wine glasses. Two large unlit taper candles sat in silver holders in the center of the table. Tonight was her and Lyra's second anniversary, and that wasn't the only thing that made it special. Earlier in the day Bon Bon had received a letter from her beloved Lyra stating that she planned on moving from Canterlot to Ponyville to live with her within the next week. This is the news Bon Bon had been waiting two long years to hear, and she couldn't be happier.
The oven beeped, she quickly pulled the large glass dish out and replaced it with another. Bon Bon had been hard at work since the afternoon preparing this meal, she wanted everything to be perfect. Everything...
She went into her room after ensuring everything was cooking at the proper temperatures. She opened a small drawer on her nightstand. Inside was a small bottle of pills, Inst-arouse. Bon Bon took a deep breath, then swallowed two of the tiny pills. She tucked them back into her drawer, ensuring they were well hidden beneath a small pile of receipts and papers. She hated to admit it, but lately her sex drive left something to be desired on both ends of the relationship. But with the help of these pills, nothing will get in the way of her perfect night.
She looked up at the clock, the food would be done soon. Approximately the same time Lyra was meant to arrive. Bon Bon pulled an upclass bottle of champagne from her fridge, setting it on the table next to the finely organized dishes. She then carried a match into the dining room with her mouth, striking it along the bottom of the table. She held it out and lit each candle, then shook it out.
She let out a deep sigh, "Perfect."
The dim flickering light reflected in Bon Bon's beautiful eyes, the dancing flame mimicked the excitement in her heart. She looked back at the clock, it was time. With another beep she went to the oven. Everything was cooked to perfection. She looked back at the door, still no sign of Lyra, but there was no need to worry. Bon Bon knew Lyra wouldn't miss this for the world.
"Hmm, should I serve the food now, or wait." She decided to wait. She went back into her room and grabbed a jewelry box. Inside was a custom piece of jewelry she had Rarity make for the occasion. It was a brilliant gold pendant with a beautifully cut emerald in the center. Bon Bon snapped the case shut with a wide grin on her face. She knew Lyra would love it.
About ten more minutes went by, Bon Bon ventured outside. It was a bit late and there were no ponies in sight. With a pang of disappointment Bon Bon went back inside. She trotted in circles around the table nervously.
"No need to worry, she'll be here in a few minutes, probably just a flight delay or something at the carriageport."
Bon Bon brushed the hair out of her face and sat down. She looked at the bottle of champagne, then back at the clock. It was already half past eight. She hesitantly poured herself a glass, if anything just to pass the time. One glass turned into three, then five. She looked back up at the clock. It was a quarter to ten. She walked into the kitchen, feeling a slight dizziness resting on her shoulders. Just then a bright flash appeared in front of her, and a letter dropped to the kitchen counter. It was from Lyra. She quickly grabbed it and began to read.
Bon Bon, I'm sorry I couldn't make it today, my concert however went much better than expected and I got invited to a party with some pretty important ponies. I feel like I might encounter some amazing career opportunities here and this is simply something I can't pass up. I know you'll understand, I love you. xoxo Lyra.
A deep pain filled Bon Bon's chest, and she gently let the letter fall to the floor. The food was cold and Bon Bon's heart was broken. She walked back to the table and grabbed the bottle between her hooves, slugging the small amount that remained. She sloppily wiped her mouth with a hoof and quickly snatched the jewelry box off the table. She headed straight for Rarity's house to return the gift, she didn't expect a refund considering it was a custom. She merely wanted to return it on principal. She stomped through the quiet roads, kicking dust into the air behind her. As Rarity's home came into view Bon Bon saw a few ponies leaving Rarity's home, they happily giggled as they cheerily trotted off in different directions, still shouting their goodbyes into the quiet night.
"Well at least I know she's not sleeping."
Bon Bon gave her door a few quick knocks. Rarity was quick to answer.
"Oh hello there dear, what brings you here so late in the evening. Not that you're unwelcome at this hour, please come in." Bon Bon followed and sat her saddle bag down on a table.
"I'm sorry to come so late, I didn't really think about it. Anyway the reason I'm here is to return this, I'm not asking for a refund or anything, I just don't need it anymore and figured you could sell it to some other pony or something..." Bon Bon looked away, trying to hold back her tears. But Rarity unsympathetically pushed for information, being the juicy gossiper she is.
"Oh my, did something go wrong? Do you want to talk about it? I'll gladly be a shoulder to cry on if you need it."
"No it's just, I was really looking forward to tonight and Lyra blew me off for some stupid party. It's our anniversary today..."
"I'm so sorry to hear that Bon Bon my dear, come here." Rarity offered her comfort.
Bon Bon walked over to her and was met with a warm hug along with a few pats on the back. "Some ponies just don't understand the importance of romantic occasions. I for one understand exactly what you must be going through. And I'm here for you."
"Thanks Rarity, should I um, set this somewhere?" She pulled the jewelry box out of her bag and hoofed it to Rarity.
Rarity opened it up and looked at her fine piece of work. She unclasped it and put in around Bon Bon's neck.
"Why don't you keep it for yourself, it looks beautiful on you."
Bon Bon blushed a little and giggled, the dizziness in her head was making her feel bubbly. Rarity found amusement in Bon Bon's state of mind, feeling glad that she seems to have had her spirits lifted with her kind words.
"Thanks Rarity, but I don't know if I want to keep it, just because it was meant for Lyra, and I'd feel awkward with it around." She felt an uncertain smile make its way to her face. "I suppose I should keep it, I mean its not like I'm not going to forgive her anyway. Also it is custom made to fit her perfectly, its a bit loose on me."
"So keep it then, and come sit down, I'm feeling a bit wobbly at the moment. Lets just say I've had my fair share of wine tonight."
The two mares made their way to Rarity's overly plush couch, plopping down next to one another. Rarity let out a long yawn and stretched all four of her hooves out, her arm brushing against Bon Bon's cheek.
"I'm sorry, I should be going now, I'd hate to keep you awake." Bon Bon stood up, then immediately lost her balance, collapsing on top or Rarity.
"Oh my, I'm so sorry!" She tried to stand up again, this time stumbling into the side of a table.
Rarity laughed at the clumsy pony. "My Bon Bon, have you had your share of wine today as well?" Rarity mocked her slightly inebriated friend.
"Heh, I guess you could say that." It seems the pills were amplifying the effect of the champagne. She hadn't recalled reading the warnings on the back.
"Come sit with me Bon, I don't see you making the trip home in your current condition, and we can use this opportunity to catch up on a few things. We haven't sat and talked together for quite some time."
"That sounds nice, I really don't feel like being alone anyway." Bon Bon giggled as she stumbled back onto the couch.
"Well, no need to be alone when you've got me around." Rarity brushed her hoof through Bon Bon's soft mane, stretching it out and watching it bounce back into place.
"I love your mane Bon Bon, its just so, refreshing."
"Thanks Rarity, yours is nice too." She reached up and poked at Rarity's glamorous curls.
"Listen Bon Bon, I really want to tell you that I am truly sorry about tonight, I know it's not my place, but I feel angry for you."
Bon Bon's expression became more serious. "It's alright Rarity, I understand why she couldn't make it, she has a lot of important connections to make in Canterlot if she wants her career to be successful."
"Well to me, that's no reason to miss out on such an occasion. Connections will always be there waiting. You will only ever have one second anniversary."
Bon Bon finally let her emotions out, her tears ran down her cheeks, and she grabbed onto Rarity for another comforting hug.
"Oh hey now, please don't cry Bon, I'm sorry if I crossed the line, I know it's really not my place to say these things, I just really feel genuinely bad for you. I know what you must be feeling inside and it makes me angry knowing that someone who loves you so much would put themselves ahead of you like that."
Bon Bon's tears continued to pour onto Rarity's shoulder. "It's alright Rarity, I know where you're coming from. I just don't want to think about it, or her, right now."
"I know sweetheart, just remember that I'll always be here if you need me for anything, I'll drop anything I'm doing to spend time with you no matter what it is. Now let me wipe those tears away, and lets talk about something else then. Sound good?" Rarity wiped her sobbing friend's tears away and let her lay back down on the couch.
Bon Bon sat up a bit and leaned her face towards Rarity's chest, rubbing her cheek against her warm white coat. She felt Rarity's hoof rest gently on her head, and she closed her eyes as she took in the beautiful mare's sweet scent. Her chest began to ache with a familiar feeling, bliss filled her heart, and desire filled her mind. Rarity leaned back onto the arm of her couch, letting Bon Bon's cheek rest on her stomach.
"So... What did you want to talk about?" Bon Bon broke the sweet silence. Rarity swallowed a painful thought. She wanted Bon Bon, but knew that her heart belonged to Lyra. An act of such selfishness was greatly below her, but the urge was still there, looming above her mind.
"Well, I... How are you feeling?" Rarity stumbled around her own words, trying not to speak her mind for a change.
Bon Bon giggled. "I'm feeling just fine, thanks for asking."
She looked up at Rarity, resting her chin on her stomach. Rarity met her gaze with a shudder when she realized she had a married mare laying in between her legs. Not only was that fact on her mind, but also the fact that she was very attracted to her at the moment. Rarity didn't know why, maybe it was because of the wine, or because of some deeper hidden feelings she had for this cute stumbling little mare. No matter what the case, this was happening, and Rarity found the urge to stop it was dwindling into nothing more than a distant thought in the back of her mind.
She forced herself to slide down further on the couch, causing Bon Bon's body to grind up against hers. Rarity continued to wiggle herself down the couch, until her face was level with her blushing friend's.
"Well hello there." Bon Bon chuckled. Rarity smiled, and took a deep breath. She gulped, feeling more nervous than she had ever remembered, then she gave Bon Bon a quick kiss. Rarity blushed immediately after, not knowing what to expect, but fearing the worst.
Bon Bon blushed as well, but felt a sickly sweet pain fill her stomach. She wasn't sure why, and despite her best judgement, she wanted Rarity to kiss her again. She leaned down, her eyes partially closed, she touched her nose to Rarity's, which caused the unicorn to close her eyes and shiver as she felt her heart blissfully explode. Rarity's breaths became short and fast as she wrapped her arm around Bon Bon's head, pulling her into a deep and passionate kiss.
Bon Bon was exhilarated, she ran her hooves down Rarity's sides, sending chills up her spine. Bon Bon moved down and began kissing and biting her neck, while Rarity ran her hooves aggressively down her back. Bon Bon's tail flipped back and forth in the air as she made her way down to Rarity's chest, kissing her the whole way. Rarity bit her lip as she watched the blue and pink mane sliding down to her stomach, making her tingle with every kiss. Rarity pressed her hooves up against her eyes, she knew this wasn't right, but that fact seemed to make it that much more exciting. She tightly closed her eyes and let a slight moan escape when her cream colored friend began kissing and nipping at her thighs. Rarity's heart was racing, half of her was begging Bon Bon to stop before she did something she'd regret for the rest of her life, the other half never wanted anything this badly before and begged her to continue.
With a warm wet sensation, all her doubts disappeared, she was lost in pure ecstasy. She bit the tip of her hoof and rocked her hips back and forth in a rhythmic motion that matched Bon Bon's tongue. Rarity's breathing became quite heavy, and her voice filled the quiet house with each exhale. She lifted her back hooves up, resting them on Bon Bon's creamy white shoulders, feeling her soft warm tongue grazing the center of her lips. After a few moments, Rarity arched her back and began gasping for breath, her face was flushed, and her hooves were all shaking. She reached into Bon Bon's blue hair and sat her up, then she leaned forward and once again locked lips in a passionate display of affection. Rarity pushed her friend over onto her back, being careful not to break their intense kiss. She felt her friend's excited tongue erotically dancing with her own. After what felt like an hour they broke their kiss.
"You are simply amazing Bon Bon. I can see why..." Rarity was interrupted by another kiss. Bon Bon didn't want to spoil the mood by allowing her outspoken friend to complete that sentence.
"You're not so bad yourself." Bon Bon winked at the swooning mare.
Rarity smiled and looked at her blushing friend with devious intentions. She intended to prove just how not bad she really was. She pinned Bon Bon's hooves down with her own, licking her from her chest up to her cheek with one swift motion. She bit onto her ear, lightly licking the inside. Bon Bon closed her eyes and lost herself in the chilling pleasure. The bittersweet pains of infatuation pulsed through her body with every heartbeat, and with each passing minute she sank deeper into the heat of the moment. Rarity moved down to Bon Bon's chest and neck, vigorously kissing every inch of the mare's sensitive body. Bon Bon looked down, and flicked the tip of Rarity's horn with her tongue. She felt a light tingling sensation as her tongue brushed across the magically charged horn. Rarity giggled, "Hey you, that tickles."
"Really now? I never would have guessed." Bon Bon playfully teased the over excited mare. Then she grabbed her mane, pulling her horn closer to her face.
Bon Bon let out a deep breath, then licked her friends horn from the base to the tip. The magical horn sent tingling sparks across her tongue as she slowly let it slide to the tip a second time. This was normally a chore for Bon Bon when Lyra asked her to do this, but this time she actually felt herself enjoying the sparks on her tongue. Something about the thought of the intense pleasure Rarity must be feeling resonated in her own mind. Rarity rest her cheek on Bon Bon's chest, her initial intentions were gone, she was now simply waiting for her dear friend to continue playing with her surprisingly sensitive horn.
Rarity had never had her horn licked or treated this way before and wasn't expecting the intense pulses of pleasure that followed each stroke.
"Does it still tickle?" Bon Bon snickered at her own slightly mocking gesture.
Rarity just laid on her friend's chest with a wide spread smile on her face. She let a small giggle escape as her only reply. Then she lost all control, she tightly wrapped her hooves around Bon Bon, pulling her body tightly up against her own. Rarity let a small whine out and pressed her face forcefully into Bon Bon's chest, her mouth was open and her deep hot breaths warmed her friend. Bon Bon had placed her horn inside her mouth, rubbing her tongue all around it as she slowly let it slip out, making sure she paid close attention to the tip. She then put it all the way back in, wrapping her lips around the base and repeating to motion until Rarity couldn't handle the intense waves of pleasure filling her trembling body. She began to moan loudly in a high pitched voice and blushed due to her own inability to control herself. Rarity pulled away from Bon Bon, her horn released a large discharge of disorientated magic into the air. It filled the room with its pale blue aura and fell across Bon Bon's body, causing her to feel a small fraction of the pleasure Rarity had recently felt. Rarity fell over on her back once again, she was completely overwhelmed by the sensation and laid with her eyes mostly closed, desperately trying to catch her breath.
"Sweet Celestia, that was simply amazing Bon Bon." Rarity's horn was still glowing softly, a feint blue aura lingered.
"I'm glad you liked it, now I do believe it's my turn right?" Bon Bon turned around on the couch resting her elbows on the plush arm. She lightly flipped her tail back and forth, slowly swaying her flank from side to side. Rarity knew what to do, she turned around, still laying on her back, and slid herself beneath Bon Bon. She gently lowered her plot down to meet Rarity, supporting all of her weight on her back hooves. The unicorn wasted no time in aggressively licking the already dripping wet earth pony. Bon Bon smiled and pressed her face into the cushy arm of the couch, attempting to muffle the moans of pleasure she couldn't resist creating. Rarity continued to satisfy the mare, she lightly bit down on her lips, gently letting them slide through her teeth. She reached up and bit down again, a bit harder this time, and with her teeth resting gently on Bon Bon's most sensitive area, she shoved her tongue deep inside. With that she felt her lower herself further, prompting Rarity to force her tongue even deeper. Bon Bon bit down on the arm of the sofa, closing her eyes tightly as she rocked her hips back and forth over Rarity's face. The unicorn wiggled her tongue back and forth inside, bringing Bon Bon to a highly desired orgasm. Bon Bon pushed herself down harder, caught between laughing and moaning, loving the feel of Rarity's teeth grinding across her lips. She then threw herself backwards, letting herself land just above Rarity's head on her back.
Rarity turned around and rested her head on her shivering friend's thigh, facing the ceiling. Bon Bon reached down and pressed on Rarity's horn, leading it between her legs. Rarity smiled even though she wasn't a hundred percent sure how this would work. Horn play was something very new to her. She placed the horn gently in between Bon Bon's soaking wet lips, sending a small spark of pleasure pulsing through the eager mare. Rarity closed her eyes and gasped when she felt Bon Bon push her hips down, forcing her horn deep inside the trembling earth pony. Bon Bon lifted her legs up and placed her hooves gently on Rarity's chest, keeping her legs spread wide apart. As she continued to gyrate her hips, Rarity felt her horn emitting it's sparks of magic, sending pulsing tingling waves of pleasure through each one of them. Rarity couldn't help but push her hoof in between her legs as she tightly hugged onto Bon Bon's thigh. As Bon Bon's movement became more forceful, she felt Rarity's cool soft mane rubbing up against her thighs. The warm deep squeezing on her horn was too much for Rarity to handle, she tightly squeezed her legs around her hoof and bit down on her other one. Her breathing was erratic and her screams of ecstasy brought herself to an explosive orgasm, the blue magic once again erupted from Rarity's horn, this time filling Bon Bon with all the pleasure Rarity felt on top of her own. The intense sensation was even too much for the more experienced Bon Bon to handle. She pulled away from her blissfully panting friend, and rolled over on her side, biting down on her hoof and trying to regain control of her own movements. She was shaking and breathing spastically. Once again finding it difficult to control her own laughter.
Rarity crawled up onto Bon Bon, meeting her gaze with tired eyes halfway closed. She kissed her again, this time with no tongue, just a few moments of bliss with their lips pressed tightly together. Bon Bon wrapped her hooves around Rarity, and she did the same. They laid there side by side on the soft sofa, and drifted into sleep in each other's warm embrace.
The morning soon came, and Rarity woke. A sleeping creamy white earth pony was still holding her tightly in her arms. She was softly breathing into Rarity's chest with a slight smile on her face. Rarity smiled and closed her eyes as she felt Bon Bon's chest pressing against her's. She could feel her light breathing, and every single heartbeat. She wished this moment would last forever, and that Bon Bon would never wake up. Rarity pressed her face into her sleeping friend's soft mane, its gentle sweet scent filled Rarity's lungs. She felt a tear drip down her cheek, a deep pain began to overtake her bliss. She knew when Bon Bon woke up, these feelings would end, and she'd walk out of her life forever. Rarity tried to push these thoughts out of her mind, and simply wanted to enjoy this moment while it lasted.
The sunlight was beginning to shine through the window, lighting the room. Bon Bon stirred in her sleep a bit. Rarity attempted to quietly use her magic to shut the blinds and keep her friend asleep for as long as possible. It didn't work, Bon Bon woke up and looked at Rarity with wide eyes.
"Oh um, excuse me." She stood up and brushed herself off. She was no longer under the influence of any pills or alcohol.
Bon Bon rubbed her head with her hoof, trying to suppress the rising headache. "I, I should probably be going now. I think it's best if we don't talk about last night... Ever..."
"Well... You're more than welcome to stay for breakfast if you'd like, you don't have to leave so quickly, and I promise we don't have to talk about last night. I'd just really like if you stayed... just for a while." Rarity tried to swallow the painful lump in her throat.
"I'm sorry for what happened last night Rarity, I wasn't myself. I really should be going now." With that said, Bon Bon walked out the front door.
Rarity stamped her hooves on the floor, desperately searching for the words to make Bon Bon come back. Her tears began to pour down her cheeks. She knew Bon Bon didn't share any of her emotions, and she knew that it would never work, Bon Bon was meant to be with Lyra, they were perfect together, even if they did have their off moments. She went back to the couch and sobbed, angry for allowing herself to fall for a taken mare.
"Of all the stupid things you've done Rarity. This is just..." She broke herself off with uncontrolled crying.
A sudden knock on the door snapped her out of it and she wiped her tears. The door opened, it was Bon Bon.
"You, you came back?" Rarity's voice reflected her glee as she wiped the rest of the tears from her eyes.
"Well, I left my saddle bag here, so I'll just be grabbing that and be going now." She picked up her bag and looked at the jewelry box. "I won't be needing this after all, it would be kind of awkward to give this to her now ya know?" She then walked back out the door, leaving Rarity's small glimmer of hope crushed.
She laid down on the couch feeling her heart ache with every beat. It pained her knowing she'd never get to be with this wonderful mare, but at least she'd always have the memory of an amazing night with an amazing friend.
Bon Bon stumbled through her door with a searing headache. She readily dropped her saddle bag on the table, creating a loud clang as it hit the edge of a couple empty plates. Bon Bon put her hooves on her head and went into her cupboard to find some aspirin. To her surprise she heard a feint yawn come from her living room. Lyra was waking up from her slumber on the couch.
"Happy late anniversary Bonsie, I missed you last night." Lyra sat up resting her chin on her hoof.
"Oh, hey, when did you get in?" Bon Bon felt her heart sinking into her stomach.
"Around eleven, I left the party early and wanted to surprise you, but you weren't here when I showed up." Lyra lifted her other hoof to her chin. "So where were you all night?"
"... I was feeling lonely so... I went to Rarity's place and lost track of time, before I knew it I was asleep on her couch." Bon Bon was satisfied with that, it wasn't entirely a lie, but the guilt was still eating her up.
"Oh I see, well aren't you going to come give me a kiss? I've missed you this past week." Lyra rolled over on her back and opened her arms, prompting her lover to join her in an affectionate embrace.
"Of course I am, just one moment. I'm sweaty from the walk home, I should shower first." Bon Bon knew Lyra would immediately detect the scent of another pony on her, not only that, but the traces of magic left behind staining her coat.
"Hurry back sweetie, I'll be here, snoozing."
Bon Bon turned the water on as hot as she could stand it. She then began desperately scrubbing every inch of herself with a soapy sponge in her mouth. It wasn't working, the scent was gone, but she could still feel Rarity there, clinging to her. She threw the sponge down and stomped on it. This reminded her of the first time she had ever done anything with Lyra, how it felt like her magic had become permanently infused with soul. But she wrote that off as a side effect of being in love, every bit of her being told her that she shouldn't feel anything at all for Rarity, it was a simple mistake, nothing more. But the thought of her scent, her warm coat, her light breaths, even her sparking horn filled Bon Bon's heart with joy.
Bon Bon walked back into the living room, her normally poofy bouncy mane was wet and hanging in her face.
"Hey there my sexy little filly, come here and say hello." Lyra once again spread her arms out in a welcoming invitation.
Bon Bon made her way over to her unusually affectionate partner. She climbed onto the couch and rested herself on Lyra, softly kissing her cheeks. Lyra brushed the blue hair to the side and locked lips with her partner, closing her eyes to take in the full effect of the first kiss they've shared in nearly a week. Lyra lost herself in the pure bliss that followed, she felt her cheeks get hot and parted her lips a bit more, pulling the mare into a deeper more passionate kiss.
Bon Bon felt Lyra's horn brush against her head, sending a familiar tingling spark through her body, and with her eyes closed, her mind became filled with images of Rarity. She closed her eyes more tightly and cringed, trying to force the beautiful white unicorn out of her mind. She couldn't and soon stopped trying, she felt herself begin to kiss Lyra more passionately and deeper, but she was looking into Rarity's deep blue eyes while she did it. She knew it was wrong, but it felt right, and she didn't want to stop, until she reminded herself that this wasn't Rarity, this was Lyra.
"Is everything okay hun? Something on your mind?" Lyra detected the distraction in her kiss.
"Oh no, it's nothing. I'm a bit tired is all." Bon Bon felt her heart split down the center as she looked into Lyra's trusting eyes. Tears began to well up and she grabbed her, pulling her into a tight hug.
"I love you so much Lyra, I just want you to know that." Bon Bon tightly closed her eyes again, shunning all images of Rarity out of her mind.
"I love you too babe, what's got you so worked up?" Lyra sat up and held Bon Bon's face up with her hoof, forcing her to make eye contact. "Oh, before I forget, I got you something. It's an anniversary gift." Lyra levitated a small bag off the table into Bon Bon's lap.
"Go ahead and open it!" Lyra didn't attempt to hide her enthusiasm.
She opened the lightly tied bag and pulled out a long beige cashmere scarf. It was plush and had elegantly embroidered black vines and flowers on each end.
"It's beautiful, thank you..." Bon Bon spoke softly, trying her best to make eye contact. She swallowed gulp after gulp of emotional pain rising up in her chest, finding a deep sense of shame knowing where Lyra's gift was, and why she couldn't give it to her.
"So where's my gift hmm?" Lyra sat on the couch facing the troubled mare.
Bon Bon leaned into Lyra, giving her one more kiss before she told her everything. One last kiss turned into two, then she found herself desperately holding onto Lyra in a never ending chain of kisses, she knew that each one could possibly be the last they shared, accepting that was too much. She lost control of her emotions and pulled Lyra's head tightly against her chest while she cried.
"Baby, you need to tell me what's going on." Lyra caught her breath and let her concern take control of her.
"I'm so sorry, I have to tell you. You deserve to know. Last night at Rarity's house, I... cheated on you." Bon Bon swallowed her urge to run away and waited for Lyra to react.
Her cheerful yellow eyes turned to watery reflections of a broken heart. "You cheated? Meaning what exactly, you... Kissed her?" Lyra spoke slowly and softly, delicately wording her sentences, desperately avoiding a truth she knew she wasn't ready to hear.
Bon Bon nodded, her lip began to quiver, and the tears began to pour. "She kissed me, but I didn't stop her. I liked it. Then I... Well, we did everything." Bon Bon spoke with a hoof covering her mouth, her sobbing was amplified by Lyra's tears.
Bon Bon looked around, she felt like the room was collapsing around her. Lyra was her life, her whole world, and now her world had every right to leave her behind. Lyra held her hoof out to Bon Bon. "We can get through this, it'll be hard, but I love you Bonsie. As long as you love me too, I won't let something like this push us apart." Lyra offered a halfhearted smile and cupped Bon Bon's hoof between her own.
Bon Bon pulled away, making eye contact again. "I think we should spend some time apart, we... I, need to get my feelings in order. The truth is Lyra, I think I have feelings for Rarity, I think I always have. I keep thinking about her, I can't get her out of my mind, even when I'm kissing you. It's not right. I thought the feelings from last night would disappear when I saw you again but they didn't. I need to... I just have to know."
Lyra felt like she had just been stabbed in the chest. She stood up and grabbed her things. It seemed like she attempted to speak, but nothing came out. She closed her eyes and headed toward the door, her balance was off and she wasn't sure where she planned on going, but she knew she couldn't stay there. Before she left she looked back at the sulking pony. "I'm sorry Bon Bon, I know this is partially my fault, I should have been here on time... I don't want it to end like this, I don't want her to take you away from me, but I guess that's your choice." She then stumbled out the door, lightly shutting it behind herself.
Bon Bon sunk deep into the couch. She stared at the wall with a blank expression. She felt hollow, and full of regret. All that lingered was a pit of pain in her chest and an image of Rarity smiling in the back of her mind. She decided to get ready and clean herself up, then head over to Rarity's, they had some talking to do.
She made herself as presentable as possible in her state of emotional distress, then headed out, hoping not to run into Lyra. There was no sign of her as she made her way back to Rarity. She hesitated at the door, lifting her hoof up to knock and just holding it there. With a few deep breaths she worked up the courage and gave the door three swift knocks. As she waited she began to question herself, suddenly this didn't seem like such a great idea.
Should I have just stayed with Lyra and forced her out of my head? Maybe I should just leave now, and go find her. I can't imagine living without her, I should beg her to take me back, I'm sure she'd forgive...
"Oh... I didn't expect to see you back here, at least not today. Please come in." Rarity stood back allowing her to walk in.
She's beautiful. Bon Bon couldn't help but notice as she met her beautiful blue eyes, Rarity's mane was mostly pulled back, a small lock dangled in her face, she was wearing her red glasses, and had some fabric draped around her neck.
"I'm sorry I ran out on you this morning, but I really want to talk to you." Bon Bon stumbled around her words.
"That's quite alright dear, I understand. Now come in and have a seat, we'll talk." Bon Bon followed her into the dining room and sat her bag down on the table.
"If this is about last night, don't worry, I won't tell a soul. I promise you that." Rarity was straight to the point, being forward felt like the polite thing to do, rather than wait for the obviously troubled mare to work up the courage to say it.
"That's not it Rarity, well actually that's exactly it. I didn't think last night meant anything to me, I thought it was just a mistake. But I can't stop thinking about you. I saw Lyra today, and when I closed my eyes and kissed her, I saw your face, and I liked it. I think I love you." Bon Bon was blushing and looked at the floor as she spoke. There was no point in holding anything back due to her shyness, she owed at least that much to herself after pushing Lyra away.
Rarity stood there with a worried expression on her face. She was torn between hearing exactly what she had hoped for, and being the cause of the perfect couple splitting up. Her legs began to grow weak and her mind was racing. She rubbed her forehead with a hoof, searching for the right words to say. Oh dear Celestia what should I do, it would be selfish of me to pull those two mares apart, I should tell her to go back to Lyra. But... I think I'm in love with her, I think I always have been. How can I send love trotting out of my life?... If I don't take a chance, I'll never know.
"Rarity, I'm sorry, should I go?"
"No, no I'm sorry, I was just taken by surprise. I didn't think you'd want to see me again after you left this morning, but here you are, telling me you love me."
Rarity couldn't help but smile, she was torn inside but still found a reason to be happy. She was with a gorgeous mare that was confessing her feelings for her, it's hard not to smile. Rarity's smile made Bon Bon relax a bit, then she led her back to the couch where they had made love only hours ago. Rarity took her hoof and held it tightly between her own as she leaned into the sulking mare.
"I'd be lying if I didn't say the feeling is mutual. Last night only made me realize that I've had feelings for you for a long time now, and this morning while you slept in my arms, I wanted time to stop, I couldn't bear the thought of watching you go." Rarity reached around and hugged onto Bon Bon.
"I'm sorry I left so quickly and on a sour note, I was just confused and needed to sort my head out. I didn't want to drag you into my problems." Bon Bon pressed closer to her loving friend, finding comfort in her warmth.
"So you think you love me, after just one night?" Rarity smiled as she spoke, making sure to keep her sensitive friend confident.
"It's been a while now, that I've had feelings for you that is. I just always ignored them and wrote them off as me being silly since we've only every really known each other as casual acquaintances. It was a couple weeks ago when I realized those feelings were deeper, I heard you sing, and I thought your voice was the most beautiful thing in the world. I felt my heart racing for you that night, and even though I was there with Lyra, I wanted to be with you. It all made sense to me then, I feel like I settled for Lyra because I didn't think I'd ever meet another mare who'd want to be with me. Don't get me wrong, I really do love Lyra, but she's more like my best friend." Bon Bon poured her heart out, letting Rarity know everything there was to know, she had nothing to hide anymore, as far as Rarity should be concerned, she was an open book.
"I know what you mean, I've always been able to spot you in a crowd. You stand out to me as someone beautiful, and I didn't know you liked my singing." Rarity couldn't stop her self from blushing although she tried.
"I do, your voice is, beautiful. Your eyes are amazing, your mane is so soft and elegant, everything about you is just... perfect. There just aren't enough words to describe you or the way I feel about you right now."
Rarity pushed up on Bon Bon's chin, meeting her lips half way. She gave her a light kiss, trying not to move too fast, even though she wanted to lose herself in the heat of the moment once again. Bon Bon shuddered and closed her eyes half way, the kiss felt so perfect and made her heart explode. She moved closer, kissing her a bit harder and wrapping her arms around her more tightly. Bon Bon closed her eyes, but she still saw Rarity in her mind, this time she didn't dare suppress the image, those glowing blue eyes were making her heart tremble.
Rarity stopped her for a moment. "Wait, follow me." Rarity kept her sentence brief, she was a bit out of breath and wanted to hurry. She led her affectionate friend into her bedroom and closed the door.
Bon Bon jumped onto the large soft bed, landing on her back. She laughed and rolled herself up in the luxurious soft blankets.
"This bed is amazing Rarity, I could lay here all day." Bon Bon seemed to have forgotten all about her rough morning, and turned this day into something special. Lyra was still in the back of her mind, but this bliss was overwhelming.
"All day? That'll due nicely. Oh wait, I... I want to do something. I've never had a chance to try these on before, but I think now is the perfect opportunity." Rarity winked and opened her large wardrobe, she found a small drawer within and opened it. Inside were four neatly folded socks, still in their packaging. She grabbed them with a magical aura and held them in front of Bon Bon, who giggled at them with a hint of blush.
"Kinky Rarity."
Rarity raised her eyebrows gave a wide crooked smile. "Put them on."
"Me?! You put them on, they're your socks!" Bon Bon retreated deep into the pile of blankets wrapped around her.
"Fine, how about we each wear two?" It's only fair that we each get to equally enjoy the other wearing them.
"I guess I can do that. But why do you have socks anyway, I mean, I never saw you as the type of pony to have something like that?"
"Well it's a long story." Rarity sheepishly smiled and put her hoof on the back of her head.
"I'm not going anywhere... so please tell me, pretty please." Bon Bon fluttered her eyelashes and put on a small pout.
"Well okay, but it's not like it's an interesting story. I got them as a gift from Twilight Sparkle."
"Wait, what?! Ha, no no no no, don't tell me, that dork has a thing for you too?" Bon Bon rolled over on her back laughing.
"Please, don't insult the poor thing, she tries her best to be a great friend, and she is. But no, she doesn't have a thing for me, they were a birthday gift I got last year because I asked her not to get me another book I'd never read. She asked what I'd like instead and I told her to surprise me with something fashionable." Rarity looked at the socks for a moment, then repeated her last words "Something fashionable...."
The two mares broke out into a hysterical laugh. Rarity plopped down on the bed next to Bon Bon and tried to calm herself down.
"Oh sweet Celestia, that poor confused little filly. I can't even begin to imagine where she found these. I mean, even for socks, these are... particularly sexy."
Rarity unfolded a pair of the socks, they were long and black with a white and icy blue argyle pattern. There were wide cut-outs on the knees, and they were made of a glossy velvety material. She stood up off the bed and began to put them on. Rarity noticed that Bon Bon was watching her closely, and chose not to use magic to do it. She sat down and gripped the top of a sock with her teeth then gently slid her back hoof inside. She stretched her leg out and pulled the sock up as high as it would go with her teeth, then used her front hooves to pull it the rest of the way up. Bon Bon felt her heart rate increase as she watched the sexiest mare she knew get even sexier. Rarity stood up with both socks on and stretched her legs out one by one. She wiggled her flank and flicked her tail into the air, having found a new higher sense of confidence she had no problem showing off her perfect body with a few sensual gestures.
Bon Bon dangled the other two socks in front of Rarity in her mouth, she made wide puppy dog eyes, implying she wanted Rarity to wear all four. Rarity rolled her eyes and smiled, with a boosted ego she had no problem dressing up for her company.
With a blue aura surrounding them, she swiftly slid each one onto her front legs. "So how do they look, and be honest."
Bon Bon looked over the edge of the bed so that Rarity was in full view. She stood there wearing the lingerie proudly and confidently. Her chest was a bit puffed out and her small red glasses were low down on her nose. Her mane was coming loose from the ponytail it was in, and more of it hung in her face. She was looking deep into Bon Bon's eyes, lightly blinking every few seconds, her lip was slightly pouted. Then she bit down on her lip and narrowed her eyes, she didn't need Bon Bon to answer, she could see it clearly in her facial expression, she knew Bon Bon was resisting the urge to jump on her and take her on the floor.
"Rarity, I can't even begin to describe how you look. Just get over here." Bon Bon quickly uncovered and sprawled herself out across the large bed. She gently rubbed her hoof down the sheet right next to where she was laying, urging Rarity to join her.
Rarity sat her glasses down on the night stand next to her bed and used her magic to undo the ribbon holding her mane back. Her long wavy hair fell down across her shoulder, curling at the ends, just when Bon Bon didn't think it was possible to be more attracted to her.
She climbed into bed from the bottom, intentionally grinding every inch of her body against the quivering mare as she made her way up. When Rarity reached her neck she stopped, her chest pressed tightly up against Bon Bon's. She closed her eyes and took in the sweet scent lofting off her creamy white coat before gently biting onto her warm tender neck. Bon Bon closed her eyes and let out a deep long breath, the wondrous sensation quite literally took her breath away. She arched her back and felt her spine tingling as Rarity continued to stimulate every muscle in her body with a barrage of nips and kisses. The sensation grew to become too much, causing Bon Bon to begin giggling and push Rarity away.
"Stop you, you're tickling me." Bon Bon looked down into Rarity's eyes. Every ounce of sadness that lingered in her thoughts was carried away, she had never been happier.
Rarity blushed a bit and smiled, then scooted all the way up til they were nose to nose. Their smiles both disappeared as they met one another's gaze. Each was attempting to read the other's eyes, trying to learn something about the other, or simply lost in a beautiful blue sea of emotions. Before they knew it, they were touching lips, and at some point had closed their eyes. Time seemed to be standing still, the only thing that existed was that moment and each moment that followed. A loving lock of lips turned into a deep and emotionally charged kiss. Rarity inhaled deeply through her nose as she wrapped her arms around her new-found love's head, pulling her tightly against her lips. Bon Bon did the same and opened her mouth, allowing Rarity to explore every inch of their passionate kiss with her curious tongue. Bon Bon ran her hooves down Rarity's back, causing her to let out a high pitched moan mid kiss. She then rested her front arm along Rarity's, enjoying the soothing warmth that the sock had absorbed. She rolled Rarity over onto her back and climbed on top, licking her own lips and looking down at her glowing snow white chest and cute stomach.
"Rarity, If only you knew how many times I've imagined this moment. This truly is a dream come true."
Meanwhile, Lyra had made her way to the Ponyville Pub. She sat on a bar stool and looked around the room at her company with a searing expression of disdain. They all sagged their heads across the tables, most of them sleeping in their own filth. She was thankful to be the only pony at the bar counter.
"Somethin' bothering ya, what's on your mind?" A large bartender stallion caught her attention while he dried a few freshly washed mugs with a small towel.
"None of your business barcolt!" Lyra snapped at the well intended stallion.
"Sorry bout that, didn't mean to pry miss." The bartender gave her a slight bow and walked away, he shortly returned with another tray of mugs to dry.
"So what can I get to drink in this place?" Lyra looked around for some kind of menu to no avail.
"Just whiskey and beer, and we only have one kind. The only question is do you want it from the tap or in a bottle." The stallion then noticed a small smudge on the inside of the mug. He spat on the towel and scrubbed it off, then sat it back down on the tray.
Lyra cringed, "Bottle will be fine."
"Here ya go, this ones on the house miss, my apologies."
"Oh you're too kind..." Lyra spoke with blatant sarcasm.
"I try." The bartender lowered his head and went back to work.
"Look, I'm sorry for yelling at you, I've had a rough day and I don't mean to take it out on you." Lyra looked down and ground her teeth, apologizing didn't come easy for her, especially to the lower class. But if being with Bon Bon has taught her anything, where you're from doesn't determine who you are.
"That's alright miss, I can tell you've had it rough and to top it off you're not from around here. Havin a bad day away from home only makes it that much worse."
"My flight doesn't leave for a few more hours, I'm just killing time til then and I don't want to think while I'm doing it." Lyra popped the top off her bottle of cheap beer and levitated it to her mouth. It was cold, not refreshing, and the taste...
Lyra painfully swallowed the wretched liquid and put on a face of horror. "What the hay is this?! You call this beer? Only because the bottle says beer on the plain white label in generic black font. Come on, how cheap can you get!"
The bartender found amusement in the young unicorn's discontent, laughing under his breath. "Hold on kiddo, try this." He poured a small amount of whiskey into a small square glass. "Once again, it's on the house."
He slid it over to her with a hoof. Lyra looked up at him with a raised eyebrow. She bit the side of the cup and quickly slugged it. She learned the hard way not to take a shot using magic. She felt the hot liquid running down her throat and into her stomach surprisingly smoothly.
"That's better, gimme another."
After an hour or so, Lyra was itching to pour her heart out to some pony. The bartender was sitting at a stool across from her. Lyra was looking down at the hardwood counter, staring at nothing. Her eyebrows lowered and the ability to suppress her sorrow was fading along with her sobriety. She looked back up at the bartender with tears in her yellow eyes. "I'm lonely..."
"Wanna talk about it?"
Lyra slowly nodded. "I... I kind of got dumped."
"Is that all? There are worse things ya know. Just give it time, you'll meet someone new."
"That's just it, I don't think I want to meet someone new. Yesterday was our second wedding anniversary although it's not technically legal and we've been together for over seven years. I don't even remember what my life was like without her. I know I'm not ready to start over." Lyra looked back down, her plans for the future were thrown out the window and she needed something to look forward to.
"Well that's different, I can't imagine what that must be like. But I have to ask, why are you here and not fighting for this mare to take you back?"
"... Well, she wasn't happy with me, her heart belongs to someone else now. I don't want to make this any harder on her than it already is."
"If you ask me, it sounds like you really care about her a whole lot. I can tell for sure you really love this mare, but I think we both know you're not in love with her."
Lyra looked up in confusion, a hint of anger shone in her eyes. "What do you mean I'm not in love with her, of course I am!"
The bartender let out a deep sigh. "Trust me kid, I've heard it all and I've been around the block a few times myself. Let me guess, she's the first pony you've been with, at least the first mare. You two were probably already close friends and this shared interest in mares only allowed you two to connect on a deeper level. Your friendship grew into a relationship, mostly experimental while you two discovered everything about the other. The more time you spent together the closer you got, and the stronger your love for one another grew. But even though your love was strong, you were never in love with each other. You were simply friends on the highest scale possible, that's why even now, at the peak of your love for her, all you care about is seeing her happy even if it's not with you. Let me tell ya, true love can be a selfish thing at times and you ma'am, are not being selfish in the least. Just take a minute to think about what I told you, then you can go tell your friend how happy you are for her, and I truly hope you find your true love someday as well. But what do I know, I'm just a simple barcolt right?" He smiled and gave Lyra a quick wink, knowing his deduction was completely accurate.
Lyra's tears dotted the counter, the more she tried to argue in her mind, the more she felt he was right. She gave a trembling sigh and stood up, slightly off balance. "I hate to admit it but I think you're right. I need to go talk to Bon Bon before I leave Ponyville."
He gave her a slight nod in agreement. "No problem kid, good luck."
Lyra dropped a generous amount of bits on the counter and trotted out the door. It was a long road to Rarity's home, but she still had a couple hours to kill. The cool afternoon breeze would help settle her mind as she trotted through the quaint streets of Ponyville, hay, maybe she'd see a few familiar faces to catch up with on the way. Anything as long as she got her mind off her broken heart.
Rarity looked back up at Bon Bon, "You've imagined pinning me down in my own bed while I wore kinky socks?"
"The socks are a surprise." Bon Bon leaned down and kissed Rarity with an aggressive force, taking her by surprise, much to her delight.
Bon Bon took great pleasure in the feel and taste of Rarity's tongue gently stroking her own. Their front hooves connected and interlocked at the ankles, Rarity used her grip to roll Bon Bon back over on her side. She then began stroking her smooth cream coat with her soft socked hoof. She rolled over on her other side as she made her way down to Bon Bon's stomach, her back hooves now resting on the pillows. Rarity kissed and licked her stomach, slowly moving lower. She lifted her leg with one hoof, and wrapped the other around her waist, pulling her in closer. She took a short moment to enjoy the fragrant aroma within the heat radiating between her creamy thighs, then bit down gently on her sweet spot. Bon Bon bent her knee and lifted her leg higher, she reached out hugged tightly onto Rarity's thigh, her intentions and focus clouded by the intense bursts of pleasure pulsing through her body. Rarity pushed Bon Bon onto her back again and simultaneously climbed on top of her, her face buried between her wide-spread thighs. Her long purple tail flipped back and forth in the air, inviting Bon Bon to join in. She reached up and pulled down on Rarity's flank, hardly aware of what she was doing under the blanket of overwhelming sexual enjoyment shrouding her mind. Her eyes were nearly closed and a hint of blush sat on her nose. Rarity didn't mind that her distracted friend didn't get the hint, she was more focused on her own endeavors. She pulled her close and gave her a long lick from her lower stomach to the base of her tail, then shoved her tongue deep inside. With moans growing louder, her back fully arched, and her hips thrusting tightly against her mouth, Rarity knew now was the time. She bit down on her, sucking tightly on her lips and clit as Bon Bon lost control of her body and came to a nearly heart stopping orgasm.
Gasping for breath, trying to compose herself she spoke, "Rarity, you are simply amazing."
"I know I am." Rarity smiled and turned around, crawling back up to Bon Bon's face to share another kiss.
After a minute or two of sharing tongues, Rarity decided to crawl further up. Bon Bon slapped her flank as Rarity's knees made their way to her ears. She reached up and tightly squeezed Rarity up against her face as she began to take care of her. Rarity rested her front hooves on her bed's headboard as she sat up and enjoyed the repetitive lapping of Bon Bon's warm tongue. She thought it might be fun to take one of her socks off and wrap it around Bon Bon's neck, using it to pull her up against herself. She began to bend further back and brushed the hair out of her face with a hoof, pulling tightly on the loosely wrapped sock with her teeth. She started rocking her hips back and forth as Bon Bon penetrated her with her tongue, with each passing second Rarity pushed deeper and moaned out in sheer excitement combined with the sensation of an approaching orgasm. When it hit it was highly anticipated, Rarity reached down and pulled roughly on Bon Bon's mane, as she released her pent up pleasure into her lover's mouth. Bon Bon's eyes widened as she didn't expect this to happen, but enjoyed every drop to its fullest.
"Rarity I had no idea..." She was interrupted by the unicorn's magic falling across both of their exhausted bodies, filling them with an echo of her recent experience. Bon Bon's eyes rolled back as she trembled once again under the weight of an overwhelming explosion of bliss.
The two mares laid quietly in one another's embrace. The only movement was their quick yet slowing breathing. The two stayed calm and quiet in an almost euphoric state as they drifted off into a sexually induced sleep.
Knock Knock!
Bon Bon quickly sat up after hearing there was someone at the door.
"Psst, Rarity, get up." She nudged the sleeping pony with no luck.
"Bon... zebras aren't that bad... once you get to know them... zzzz..." Rarity was fast asleep.
Bon Bon decided to go answer the door, simply not to be rude. To her surprise, Lyra stood there.
"Lyra! What are you doing here?!" Bon Bon yelled and whispered at the same time, trying not to wake her snoozing lover.
"Well, it looks like you've been having fun." Lyra noted the mare's messy mane and random sock tied around her neck.
"Oh this? Um, nothing, what are you doing here?" She quickly grabbed the sock with her mouth and threw it out of view, it landed directly on a sleeping Opalescence causing her to shriek in terror and run off.
"I'm just here to tell you that you're right in doing this. And I hope that you're happy with Rarity, she's a really nice pony and I'm happy for you both. I really want you to know that you're my best friend and I'll always love you, even if not in the way I thought I did. You've shown me that having an amazing friend by your side can get you through pretty much anything, and I still want you to be that amazing friend. I refuse to lose you because of this." Lyra stared at her friend's hooves, forcing the rising tears back down.
"Lyra... I'm so happy to hear you say that."
A groggy Rarity walked up behind Bon Bon, still wearing three socks but not realizing it. As soon as she realized who was at the door she snapped awake and gulped, fearing an imminent attack. Lyra spotted her wide eyes and smiled to calm her down.
"Don't worry Rarity, I come in peace." She held up her hoof and smiled wider, actually feeling legitimately happy for the new couple. "Nice socks by the way." Lyra giggled at the awkwardly standing unicorn.
"Oh these?! I, um, they were a gift!" Rarity ran back into her room to fix her messy mane and change into something more presentable, probably nothing.
"Does she have a fuzzy saddle back there too?" Lyra mocked playfully.
"Oh dear Celestia I hope so." Bon Bon chuckled at the thought.
A sickly sweet sensation washed over Lyra, she kissed Bon Bon on the cheek for the last time. "I really am happy for you two. I want you to know that. I'm going to head back to Canterlot now, my carriage will be leaving soon. I'll invite you two to my next show if you'd like, we can all get together and catch up. Maybe I'll have met someone new by then." Lyra winked and trotted off.
"Lyra, thanks, you're really the best friend a pony could ask for. I'll always remember the time we had together, they were the best years of my life." Bon Bon wiped a couple tears.
Lyra stopped and turned around. "Me too Bonsie, I don't regret a minute of it. Also she's not allowed to call you Bonsie, that's my thing. Have fun you two, I seriously have to go now."
Rarity was standing just inside the doorway, she smiled softly and felt humbled by the kindness Lyra had shown. She put a hoof on Bon Bon's shoulder and led her to the couch.
"You're lucky to have had such an amazing friend, I personally can relate to a pony showing a similar sense of understanding even when I was sure she never would. The magic of friendship will always amaze me, even when I thought I've seen the limits of it's power, it continues to surprise and inspire feelings of humility within me."
Bon Bon rested her head on Rarity's chest and listened to her heart beating. "Thanks Rarity, I'm glad too. Even more so I'm glad I finally opened myself up to you."
"I am too, I've never felt so content before, this is a feeling I can't begin to describe. Unless I simply describe it as, being in love."
"I love you Rarity."
"... I love you too."
