Me, in Equestria?

By the time Trixie eventually showed back up, I'd had Twilight move on from sucking me off to... well, I told you my fantasy with her in the last part of this story. She was engaging in it willingly too, that trick with the mirror still in full effect. She had to listen to what I said, and so as grossed out as she'd looked when I made the request, there was nothing she could do but slowly lower her muzzle while I rolled my hips back, keeping my legs up in the air. With some hesitation, her tongue extended, flicking up along my asscrack. Then she did it again, the lick better focused on my hole this time, a wave of a new kind of pleasure shooting through me.

The pony rimjob I'd always dreamed of felt even better than I'd imagined it would. Maybe a lot of you I'm telling this to think it's weird, or submissive, letting a pretty pony tongue your back door. Well, a lot of you are fucking wrong, then. You try it, see how damn humiliated your favourite pony looks as you help push her head on in there, and then tell me it's submissive. The sensation is great too, a nice teasing tingle that in this case, really helped fill in the time while I waited until I could get properly hard again.

And the best part? With the addiction to me that Trixie had given her, Twilight soon seemed pretty into it. Her disgusted whimpers at having to worship hairy, sweaty brony ass were soon muffled moans of pleasure, and the longer it went on (I was in no hurry to stop!) the more I was convinced I had her totally in my power. So I took a little bit of a risk... you'll see.

Trixie trotted up the stairs not too much later, carrying some food with her magic, though it all dropped to the floor in an instant when she saw what was happening.

"You are the dirtiest little whorse in Ponyville!"

Trixie told Twilight with a surprised glee in her voice. Twilight just gave a kind of muffled groan in response - even if she was bound by the mirror to obey me and to get horny from my smell, that hardly meant she had to enjoy Trixie's rubbing it in. Either way, her muzzle didn't budge from where it was currently pressed into my hairy asscrack.

"I can't believe it... Trixie wouldn't even do that with the most handsome of stallions!"

She left the food where it had fallen, bounding on over to us to get a proper look at her rival's latest humiliation. I played it up for her, too.

"You were right, Trixie. I think this pony really is just a little slut for smelly human, deep down. You can see her face better, she look as into it as her tongue is making me think?"
"Oh yes, hoo-man! Her face is telling me what I already told her. She's going to be your bucktoy forever and ever!"

That did sound good. Right now, though, I was just trying to get Trixie to let down her guard a little.

"Mm, what dirty thing will you make her do next?"
"Her? Nothing. Twilight, now!"

The pretty purple pony withdrew her muzzle from my asscheeks, glaring over at Trixie with horn aglow. The silver-haired pony was quickly engulfed in magenta light.

"What?! What are you doing? Trixie commanded you not to-"

Trixie had made a mistake granting me the same power over Twilight that she had. Giving Twilight the use of her magic back had been a tough call, but seeing how damn into me the mirror had her, I'd taken the chance. Now it was paying off. Trixie was completely paralysed, her body stuck there motionless on the upper floor of Twilight's treehouse, her face locked into an expression of abject surprise. You see, I hadn't spent the whole time Trixie was away just lying back in Twilight's bed, smelling her pillow and stroking her mane while she tongued my ass. I'd also told her body that it tingled with excitement at the thought of revenge on Trixie (something I might not have needed the mirror's magic for, heh), and also that she could use her magic, but only on Trixie. I'd had no idea if my command would be able to override Trixie's like that, but my plan had clearly gone off without a hitch.

The supposedly great and powerful Trixie was now completely at my mercy, and after all those comments about how I looked and smelled, not to mention the shit she'd pulled on that early episode of the show that had led to this, I was thinking it was time that she got the comeuppance she'd wanted to give Twilight.

"Human. Can we... make her do what... you made me do just before?"
"Mm. Good idea. She said she wouldn't even do it with the most handsome of stallions. Didn't you, Trixie?"

I got up off the bed, walked over to her, my greasy fingers stroking over her frozen face. Getting a real kick out of her helplessness, knowing that she was only paralysed, that inside she was still experiencing every touch from the man she'd called so gross and fat.

"But how do we do it, if she's paralysed?"
"Just turn around."

Twi was compelled to obey me, and to desire revenge on Trixie on some level. Still, she surprised me a little when I noticed the dark smile that had started to creep onto her cute face. Certainly not behaviour becoming of a princess of friendship, but then again this was still Season One, and she also had to compete with all the intrusive instincts Trixie and I had given her poor body. I doubt the poor thing could think straight with a sweaty me still smelling up the room. That's what gave me the confidence she wasn't going to try to pull something.

She didn't. Didn't even move. Instead as I turned around, leaving my fat, bare ass facing Trixie, the blue unicorn took a step forwards and gave me a nice long, slow lick up one of its cheeks.

"Are you doing that?"
"Mhm."

Twilight hopped off the bed too, trotting around to the front of me, her horn still aglow.

"I'm going to do this, too."

Twilight wrapped her mouth around my cock, which immediately twitched and advanced one more stage towards a proper erection. It jumped another stage when Trixie, telekinetically controlled by Twilight, lifted a leg and pressed one hoof to one of my asscheeks, helping push it out of the way some so her tongue could start worshipping my asshole. I know I said rimjob plus magicjob was always my fantasy, but was is the operative word there. Since this time I'm telling you about now, I've had plenty experiences of both, and I can tell you without a doubt that double-ended oral with two cute mares is superior. Especially when they're both actually actively doing it, instead of the weird body puppeting situation I was in then!

Even still, it felt incredible. For a good long while I just stood there, letting Twilight go at me from both ends, and playing with this new power I had over her.

"Tell me if you've sucked dick before."
"Never... but I've read a lot of books about it."

Of course she had.

"Tell me you love my cock."
"I love your cock, Human."

She was taking my manhood out of her mouth to answer me, but never failed to go right back to sucking after each thing I had her say. I didn't even have to command her, the geeky mare doing it all on her own, the strange mirror convincing her she loved this, loved human dick, just because I said so. And even better, because Trixie had made her moan every time I touched her, she couldn't go down on me without compulsively giving out a muffled sound of pleasure. It was incredibly hot, my cock rapidly swelling back up toward erection already.

"Ngh... yes you do. Your mouth waters at the thought of it. Your tongue longs for the taste of my cum."
"Mmmph..."

I figured if I kept the commands to her body's reactions to me, they were more likely to stick. Those certainly did, anyway, a fact I realised when the circling of Trixie's soft, warm tongue around my butthole suddenly got a whole lot more... distracted. Twilight was getting too horny to control her properly! A perfect signal to move on to giving it to Trixie proper, as far as I was concerned. I had no idea if I could get it up a third time, nor any idea how long Twilight's magic could hold her, and there was no way I was gonna miss out!

Reaching down, I pushed Twilight off of my dick, and she shot me a look like a puppy pleading for a second serving of dinner. She actually whimpered when I told her I was going to fuck Trixie then.

"No please! Can't I suck it?"

With the look she was shooting me, and her saying that, I damn near just shoved it right back in. I managed to resist, though, and she soon switched from staring pleadingly up at me to staring lustfully at my crotch. Kept Trixie rimming me the whole time, too, the stage magician now being forced to tongue my ass deeper now that Twilight could concentrate a little better. Or maybe because she thought it'd convince me to let her get back to going down on me.

"Twilight. You think you could hold just her hooves, and her mouth, and keep her magic under control?"
"I think so."
"Try."

I stepped away from the two ponies, to the side, so Twilight could concentrate. She came through for me, as you might expect of one of the greatest magic-users in Equestria. Her success was obvious, Trixie's attractive pony body suddenly starting to squirm in place, her upper body desperately shifting left and right, forwards and back, but her hooves staying fixed to the ground. She was basically just shaking her rump at me, tempting me further to go get it.

"Mmmm!"

She couldn't part her teeth or lips, was never going to make a noise loud enough to alert anyone outside, but now we got to hear just how she felt about her little predicament. Not. Happy. Served her right. Twilight didn't deserve what was happening to her. Even if I was gladly taking full advantage, and would do it all again in a heartbeat, I could still admit it wasn't fair for her. Trixie, though? Fuck Trixie. Which was exactly what I was about to do.

"What did you say, Trixie? You'd never take a human as a lover?"
"Mmm mnph! Mmph hmmph nnnh!"
"Oh, well I'm glad you changed your mind."
"MMMMMPH! HMM MMM MNNNPH!!"

Twilight let out a soft giggle, tinged with bitterness. Well I had commanded her to desire revenge, after all. I smirked, walking around behind Trixie and kneeling down to admire her back end properly. Before I could do much of that though, *WHAP!* Her tail suddenly slapped against my stomach, surprising force behind the hit. Nothing like the kick from Dash, of course, but it actually did hurt! I quickly grabbed the tail in one hand, held it up in the air out of the way while my other hand tried to steady her writhing body.

Now I keep pointing this out while I tell this, because it really is important. Equestrian ponies are small compared to humans. I mean, look at me. The only weights I've lifted in my life are 24- and 30-packs of Pepsi Max cans. Yet even I was able to hold her firm, feel her trembling and struggling beneath my touch, her tail easily held out of the way while I sat down on my legs to put my head at a better level to admire the view.

Trixie's pussy, much like all pony pussy, looked inviting as hell. Unlike with Twilight, though, I could see the ends of her pink inner lips peeking out of the gap between her plump, lightly-furred folds. It made it seem more mature, and probably experienced. If I'm honest, I like the neat little ones better, you know... ones that look like a filly's, heh. I can tell you though that these days, after all the pony pussy of all ages I've got to enjoy, some visible pussy lips mean crap all about age or experience, or how tight it's gonna be. Back then, though? My eyes were sliding upwards, away from Trixie's stallion-pleaser and instead onto the tiny, dark entrance that seemed almost like it was trying to hide from me under her tail.

All the pieces suddenly fell into place. I had never tried anal sex before, Trixie needed a good hard punishment for what she'd done to Twilight, and her vagina was probably as dry as her asshole anyway.

"Ever had it up the butt, little miss Great and Powerful?"
"Mmmggghhh!!"
"I figure, you did such a good job making my ass feel good... time I repaid the favour."
"You're going to put it in her tailhole?"

I nodded over to Twilight, and that was when she quickly trotted over to watch from close up. I couldn't read her face, couldn't figure out what balance of lust, vengeance and scientific curiousity was motivating her to come over. Either way, having the cute little nerd nearby was only making this hotter for me. My dick was throbbing so hard I swear I could feel my heartbeat in it, yelling at me to put it in the blue pony in front of me already.

Well, by this point in the story I'm sure you know me well enough ー I tend to do what my dick tells me. So I lined up the head of it with that little furrow under her tail, barely even an opening, and started trying to use the saliva Twilight had generously covered my dick with to grant me access into the tiny hole.
"Gghh! Mmmgh!!"
Trixie's thrashing grew more desperate, but I gripped her firm, the movements she did manage to make only serving to rub the soft fur of her rump up against my sensitive member and get me all the more excited. Every time she displaced my cock, it quickly found its way back to that little groove without me even trying, as if the sexy pony magician's body had been designed to take human cocks up the butt.

I mean, probably not though, with how much Trixie was carrying on. Which was still nothing compared to what happened when, with enough pushing to have a fresh sweat breaking out on my body, I finally felt myself start to sink into the unicorn's unlubed asshole.
"Eeeeeeeeeeeegggggghhh!!"
It was so incredibly tight, tighter than either Rainbow Dash or Twilight's pussies, and I'm sure you remember how much I raved about them. This was a bit of a different sensation, too. The inner walls of an anus felt firmer, offered more resistance to stretching. I could only imagine how much it was probably hurting the mare as I used insistent rocks of my hips and a firm grip on her to gradually sink inch after inch of my dick in her. She certainly continued carrying on as much as she did when I first got it in, but hell like I was stopping. She'd known what happened to Rainbow Dash. She ought to have known what happens to stuck-up ponies who call me fat and smelly! Hehe. Even if I am.

Pretty soon I was in just about the same position I'd been in with Twilight, my gut resting on the mare's back, my big fat body looming over hers from behind while I savoured the sensation of the Tight and Wonderful Trixie's ass squeezing around my whole length. Couldn't see my dick sinking into her, unfortunately, but the feeling of fucking her more than made up for it. I probably should've taken it easy, really paced myself with such a tight hole, but I was so worked up after getting tongued front and back by the two pretty mares that I couldn't help myself.
"This is... ngh... what you get, Trixie. You think you're better than Twilight? You think you're clever? Nnngh... now look at you. Bucked by the smelly hoo-man!"
"Eeeeggh! Mmmmgh!"
I was getting off on her suffering almost as much as her tight little pooper, the squeezes of protest it gave as it tried to push me out giving the sadistic bones in my body as pleasant of a tingle as they were giving my cock. Twilight watched with intense interest and close proximity, just about trying to poke her muzzle between my and Trixie's body. Mumbling to herself, probably something lewd, and yet nothing as brazen as Trixie had been doing when their positions were reversed. She had that same glassy look in her eyes as before, well under the spell of the mirror, and my musk, but she wasn't even touching herself. The only words I managed to actually pick up from her mouth were an "Oh, gosh."

Just knowing she was watching, and wanted Trixie to suffer the same revenge I was giving her, was enough though. I certainly wasn't going to have any trouble cumming, especially as I started really working my hips back and forth, satisfied now that her ass had been broken in and freely enjoying the hole for what it was made for. Teasing myself with those addictive moments of ecstasy when I moved and her insides tugged along my foreskin that much more frequently, forcing upon the two of us more and more of that rough, raw friction. Trixie went from trying to tough it all out with grunts of pain to outright shrieking, although Twilight's magic keeping her jaw clenched muffled each sound, actually making them sexier in a way, as well as preventing any other ponies outside from hearing the cries for help. All they achieved was getting me to give her tail a good hard couple of tugs, just for the hell of it.

I'm not gonna pretend I'm some mega-stud, and especially back then when I was still getting used to pony pleasures. I came in her ass and I came hard, right about then. Still eagerly fucking her even as I felt myself starting to explode, working her snug insides with deep thrusts even as I doused 'em with so much thick, globby human cum. A bit exhausted, even from such a quick fuck, I switched from kneeling to just sitting there on the floor of Twilight's treehouse, the paralyzed pony right in front of me. Just about immediatley, showing no hesitation about where my cock had just been, Twilight trotted up between my spread legs and started sucking me clean. I pushed her lower, keeping her head out of the way so I could watch to see if my cum'd drip out of Trixie's asshole. I just sat there a while, still coming down from the highs of what I'd just done and struggling to believe that I had the Twilight Sparkle moaning as she eagerly sucked up what cum was left stuck to my cock.

I'd tell you it was heaven, but it's hard to give you a good perspective on that at this point.

Now, this next part serves me right, really. I wasn't being careful... and really can you blame me so much, considering how lucky everything was working out for me? I was busy coming down from ponyfuck! Not planning out the optimal way to keep both Twilight and Trixie under control, via indirect application of a magical artifact I didn't even fully understand. Maybe I should have at least tried harder, though, because I blew it. Twilight lost control over Trixie's body, probably so caught up in swallowing what cum she could get (cum that, I admit, I had made her especially crazy for), and all of a sudden Trixie just bolted.

"Forget you, Twilight Sparkle! Hoo-man! You. Will. Pay for this!"

The mare called out to us as she galloped to the stairs, down them, and out the door. Twilight was so into my cock she didn't even acknowledge it, instead busy now holding it in place with the chill touch of her magic while she ran slow, firm licks of affection up the whole length of my gradually softening shaft. Well, at least if I was fucked, I'd be going out on a high note.

I couldn't hear Trixie screaming for help outside, which was a plus. Maybe I had time to escape, and I sat there a moment wondering if I couldn't get away with also bringing the cute mare currently nuzzling my crotch along with me.
"Twilight."
"Mmyes, Mr. Human?"
Her voice sounded like she'd just woken up, her eyes slightly unfocused. I was just then realising how much of a number Trixie and I had done on the poor mare.
"Twilight, snap out of it! We have to get out of here."
"Out? But, your cock..."
I groaned, worried I'd have to leave her here after all. Then suddenly, something appeared out of nowhere in the edge of my vision. Something that promptly flew, alight with the glow of magic, right into Twilight's cheek. By the time I realised what it was, Twilight was already looking at it. The pocket mirror, showing her reflection.

Shit.