Spike's Slice Of Lime Pie

by Claws And Hooves

Rating: mature
Tags: Anthro, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Alternate Universe, My Little Pony Comic, Porn, Sex, Fetish, Spike, Limestone Pie, Profanity, Pinkie Pie
Length: 4302

Limestone finds out that she is the only pie sister who is still a virgin, and Pinkie has a idea to change that.

Limestone comes to Ponyville to visit her sisters and while there she learns that Pinkie is pregnant with Spike's foal. This causes her to get upset as not only does it mean she , the oldest, is the only pie sister not in a serous relationship but she also the only one who is still a virgin. Pinkie Pie has an idea on how to help with that last problem, after all sharing is caring.

Edited by ShadowSpider

Published 2019-01-23 14:30:01 UTC
Last updated 2019-01-30 14:02:15 UTC

The Pie

Limestone drank her milkshake as she watched her younger sister with eyes full of envy. She and Marble had decided to visit Ponyville, both so they could see their sisters and so Marble could see her long distance coltfriend, Big Mac. However when they got there they found out that Maud was out of town thanks to her coltfriend taking her to some kind of rock con as a romantic getaway; and when they decided to stop by Sugarcube Corner they found Pinkie she was up to her mane in customers. It was then that Big Mac and the other mares he had been dating walked in looking for Marble.

Apparently in order to show they were taking their relationship seriously they were all learning sign language for Marble, who was mute except for some mmm sounds she could make. Marble was currently busy talking to them and helping them with their sign language. Which left Limestone alone with nothing better to do but watch them and try to remember what Marble said their names were. She knew that the pink unicorn was Sugar Belle and the dark pink earth pony was Cheerilee. As for the two green ones she thought the unicorn one was Sweetcream something and the earth one was, Tealove, she wanted to say.

"I guess I better work on remembering their names sense it looks we will be family soon enough by the looks of it." Limsetone mumbled under her breath more than a little upset.

"Aren't they just so cute together."

Limestone turned around in her chair to see that Pinkie was now standing behind her.

"Yeah I guess that’s one way to look at it." Limestone mumbled.

"How about you come help me with something while we let these love birds have some time alone?" Pinkie asked.

Limestone shrugged. "Sure, anything is better then just sitting here watching this," she said as she stood up and followed Pinkie into the kitchen. Upon entering she was surprised by the large number of boxes in it.

"Hey Pinkie, why are there moving boxes everywhere?" Limestone asked

"Because I'm moving out silly." Pinkie said with a smile

"You're moving out? What brought this on?" Limestone asked her smiling sister.

"Oh it’s because of reasons that involve me throwing a party to tell mom and dad about. Or maybe I should throw two parties sense that there are two big announcements? Hmm, one big party for both or two smaller parties, which would be better? What do you think Limestone?" Pinkie asked.

"Well giving that I no idea what in Tartarus you're talking about I can't really say." Limestone responded in her normal grouchy tone.

Suddenly a timer when off which caused Pinkie’s eyes to widen as she jumped an inch. "Oh. There’s the oven. Limy could you get that for me?" Pinkie asked.

"Ya ya, but don't call me Limy." Limestone said as she grabbed an oven mitt and walk over to the oven.

Limestone opened the oven and pulled out the bake good that was cooking in it, with a confused look on her face.

" A bun? Pinkie why were you cooking just one bu-BY CELESTIA'S EVER BURNING CUNT YOU'RE PREGNANT?!?!" Limestone screamed in shock and surprise.

"SURPRISE! I have a pie in the oven! Maybe more, Cadence did say that the spell would increase the odds of having more then one and Twilight explained that twins have a higher chance of having twins. Maybe I should ask mom or Mrs. Cake what it like having two little party guests growing in your fun house." Pinkie said with a smile that never left her face

"You got knocked up by that barely legal dragon colt you like didn’t you?!" Limestone screamed still making sense of the news.

Pinkie nodded with a huge smile. "Yelp, and that brings me to my second announcement. I'M GETTING MARRIED!"

"MARRIED?! Oh that’s great, THAT’S JUST GREAT!!" Limestone screamed with anger.

"Are you okay Limestone?" Pinkie asked, clearly worried about her older sister

"Of course I’m fine! why wouldn't I be!? Just because all of my younger sisters are in serious relationships and I’m not. Tartarus, you're pregnant and getting married while I the oldest have never even been with a stallion!”

Limestone fire dissipated as she stared sullen at the floor. “And who can blame them, who would want plain old Limestone.

Pinkie frowned as her eyes watered. She knew that Limestone had always had some self esteem issues. While Limestone wasn't bad looking she was for the most part average. Average height, average bust, average ass. She was a little more muscular than normal but her lack luster coloring made it not stand out much. To make matters worth she was a member of a family of not so average mare’s. Though Maud always wore long plain looking dresses and had the similar coloring to Limestone she was very tall and muscular for a mare, and a pair of well shaped double dds.

Marble was a little shorter than normal and also had similar colors to her older sisters but unlike them had a soft earthly like look to her. That and her shy personality was enough to melt stallons heart. Then there was Pinkie. While not the brightest colors Pinkie’s bright and flashy colors were still enough to get anypony’s attention, and she was also what all would call a bottom heavy short stack. With her plump dd breasts, thicc thighs, wide hips that made it clear she was going to have little trouble birthing her foals, and and a large jelly bubble ass, and combine with her chubby build it was no wonder why stallions smiled at the sight of her.

Pinkie not wanting to see anypony sad, much less on of her sisters. So she begin to think of a way to cheer her up. ‘Hmm, she said she’s sad because she doesn't feel like a stallion could see her as beautiful and that she is still a virgin. What she needs is stallion, one that can not only rut her but make her feel truly beautiful. Or maybe what she needs isn't a stallion at all.’ Pinkie thought.

"You know Limestone I think I know just the thing you need, or should I say the two things you need." Pinkie said with a smile.

Time To Eat

"Pinkie, I'm back!" Spike said as he entered the now closed Sugarcube Corner.

"Spike!" Pinkie shouted as she bounce over to her new husband and gave him a deep kiss.

Spike enjoyed the sugary kiss of his hyperactive Pink wife. "How have you been Pinkie?” He then leaned down to speak to Pinkie’s slightly chubby belly. “And how about you? Have you been good for mommy?"

Pinkie giggled. "Spike it’s has only been five days since we found out, I don't think our little pie can hear you yet."

Spike shrugged. "Hey those books Twilight gave me all say it’s never too soon to get ready. Also sorry I'm late but after my and Twilight’s little get together with our parents Celestia and Luna had me breed about a dozen of their maids, after them that is."

"Oh don't worry about it. I have had plenty to keep me busy." Pinkie said pointing to boxes. "By the way how did they take the news."

"Apparently Celestia told them what I was and what she planned for me not long after Twilight became an alicorn. So they kind of figure that something like was going to happen sooner or later. Which now that I think about it does explain a few things about my childhood. Oh and by the way Trixie is insisting on this special all grass diet while she’s pregnant. I guess it’s something her mother always told her was necessary while pregnant so she’s trying to get everypony on board for it."

Pinkie recoiled at the idea of an all grass diet. She knew she had to get along with Trixie now that they were part of the same heard but there was no way she was giving up her sweets. "Blugh. I'll talk to her later about it,” said Pinkie then moved next to Spike In the meantime the cakes are away and I have special surprise for my big strong drake," she said while giving a light purring noise.

Spike’s eyes lit up like a kid in a candy store. "Oh I like surprises. As long as they don't involve my ass. I had more than enough of that from the sisters today, I swear I could taste Luna’s nail polish." Spike got a bit of chill as he recalled how the large alicorns spent their time trying to prove who was the best at anal.

"Wwweeellllll, I don't think it will involve anything going up your scaly booty but I can't promise anything." Pinkie said

"....You know what that is good enough. So where do I go to get my little surprise?" Spike said with a small growl.

"My bedroom of course silly." Pinkie give Spike bedroom eyes as she moved behind him and covered his eyes before leading him to her bedroom.

"Now get ready for you surprise," said Pinkie as she opened her old bedroom door.

Pinkie lead Spike inside where she removed her hoof’s and allowed Spike to open his eyes. Spike’s expression quickly went from excited to confused as what was revealed to him was a naked grey mare that he had never seen before lying on Pinkie’s bed.

"What the tartarus?! Pinkie who is this?" Spike said in shock as his face turned red seeing the strange mare.

Pinkie smiled and hopped into the middle of the room between the two. "Why don't you two make a game of it? Can you guess who this big strong drake is?"

Limestone rolled her eyes. "Oh this is so hard. I mean there are just so many dragons around that speak in a thick Canterlot accent."

"Give it a few years and there will be." Spike mumbled.

"What?" Limestone asked.

"Nothing,” said Spike waving his hands then began taking stalk of the mare in front of him. “Now lets see. Grey with a little bit of muscle and a lot of attitude, you must be Limestone Pie. Not that I don't enjoy the sight but this isn't how I thought we would meet for the first time. Pinkie what’s going on here?"

"Well it started with my sisters Marble and Limy coming over to pay me and Maud a little visit." Pinkie said

Spike raised an eyebrow. "Marble’s here too? I guess that explain why when I ran into Big Mac he asked me how safe words work in sign language."

"That’s something I didn't need to hear." Limestone said

"Anyway,” interrupted Pinkie. “As you know Maud’s not here right now and when they came over here I was to busy to talk that’s when Big Mac and his herd showed up and starting hanging with Marble so I took Limy to the back and told her about our little pie and then when she told to me that she is still a virgin and wasn't happy about it I thought my big strong stud could make her feel like a real mare, after all sharing is caring." Pinkie said in a single breath.

"Don't call me Limy." Limestone mumbled

Spike blinked as he tried to catch up with Pinkie’s rapid speech. "So you want me to rut your sister?” Spike asked and then turned to Limestone. "And you’re okay with that?"

Limestone grunted and folded her arms. "I'm find with it, now just stick it in already and lets do it."

"Just stick it in?" Spike said a little confused by Limestone’s remark.

Pinkie snuggled up to Spike as she whispered into his ear in her best secy voice. "Like I said poor little Limestone needs a big caring drake to show her what love making is really like."

"No kidding.” Spike walked over to Limestone and sat down next to the mare as he put a claw on her shoulder. Limestone there is a right way and a wrong way to lose your maiden hood and if you really want to do this with me then that means I'm going to make damn sure we do this the right way. And that means starting it off the right way with a kiss, now do you really want to do this?" Spike said as he got up to the bed and held out his claw to help Limestone up.

Limestone took a moment to think about Spike’s words. She really did want to lose her virginity but she was nervous. She had heard the typical talk of how guys only cared about themselves when it came to sex and fully expected her first time to be unpleasant. And while she may have just met this drake in person for the first time Pinkie had been telling her about him for years in her letters as well as whenever she visited. She had always been skeptical of strangers but this drake did seem to be as caring as Pinkie made him out to be and he did really seem like he had nothing but her best interests in mind.

"Alright, you clearly have done this more than me and I do want to go ahead and loss my v-card already so lets do it your way." Limestone said as she give Spike her hand, allowing him to help her up.

And soon as she was lifted up Spike pulled her close to him and gave her a deep and passionate kiss. Limestone may have been a virgin but that didn't mean she hadn't dated before. She had dated quite a few stallions before, and even one blue unicorn mare that worked on the farm for a while. So even though this wasn't her first kiss it was a kiss unlike any she had ever had before.

Spike held her close to him with his powerful and scaly, and surprisingly warm, arms as his long strong tongue utterly dominated her own and tasted every inch of her mouth. As she was lost in his embrace she failed to notice as he slipped his tail between her legs. She squeezed when she felt his rounded soft yet firm ridges tease both maiden hood and her back door and a shiver ran up her spine.

Spike slowly ended the kiss and cupped the blushing Limestone’s chin in his claw as he spoke to her. "Now let's get you loosened up. Lay on your front and our give you a quick massage."

Limestone could only nod as she laid down on the bed wondering what was next to come.

She was a bit confused when Spike crawled onto the bed behind her and forced her into a sitting position. Her curiosity quickly evaporated as Spike’s claws touched her shoulders. Am mmm sound that could be mistaken for Marble escaped her lips as Spike began working the knots in her body. As she enjoyed the bliss of her first massage in, possibly ever, Spike took the spade of his tail to her lower lips. Slowly, and teasingly rubbing them while also dragging across her skin to her anus where it ever so carefully danced on the outer edges before returning to her flower in the same way it left.

"Oh fatherutter that feels good." Limestone moaned. The feel of her back muscles being massaged mixed with the feel of her lower lips being teased made for a strange but amazing feeling she had no idea how to cope with.

As Spike’s claws slowly went down to the center of her back he lowered his head so he could whisper into her ear. "So many knots and so much tension. You really need to take better care of your lovey, sexy body." and then let his tongue dance on the outer edges of her ear.

Limestone didn't know what to think about this, she never thought of herself as sexy before. She couldn’t be, no stallion had ever desired her before and even now the first male she was with was doing it on behalf of his future wife. Not because he had wanted to. Still, the way he said it his voice spoke only honesty and made her confused on if she should believe him or not. She tried to think of something to say, but found that impossible once Spike ever so gently bite her ear.

His fingers worked their way across her back and his spade played with her lower area. The mix of relaxing and exciting stimulation soon became too much for Limestone. She wanted, no, need cum right then and there. But Spike seemed to be intentionally keeping her right on edge.

"Uh uh uh,” tisked Spike. “We can't have you going off just yet. After all we aren't nearly done just yet." Spike said as he moved his claws lower still, first to take care of lower back, then lower still where he not only playfully teased and messaged her cheeks but even took car of her dock.

But he didn't stop there, he then started working on her legs. From her thighs to her hooves he didn't leave a single inch uncare for. All the while never letting up or changing the way his spade teased her mercilessly.

"I think we are finished with the first part. Now why don't switch sides so we can continue." Spike said as he removed his spade from between her legs

Limestone frowned as she felt the appendence leave and began to feel herself coming down. "Just hurry. I never needed to get off so rutting bad in my life!" she said as she flipped herself over.

"Patience my dear. All good things 'cum' in time." Spike said with a sly smile.

He then started to message and play with her breasts while his spade returned to her lower lips. This time letting the tip enter to play before going to her backdoor to do the same.

Spike lowered his head and kissed each of her nipples before he took his long fork tongue and licked each of them. He then used the tip of his tongue to pinch one nipple and used his claw to pinch the other. All Limestone could do was grip the bed as hard she could while pushing her hips back. Trying to get just a another inch of Spike’s spade inside her and push herself over the edge.

Spike was clever though, each time she rutted back he pulled his tailback the same amount. Keeping her from pushing it any deeper then it already was. "Don't worry, we are almost done with the foreplay." Spike said with a sly smile.

He kneeled down between her legs where he took one of her hooves in his claw then kissed it and started to make his way up her inner leg as he slowly kissed, licked, and even playfully nibbled his way to her flower. Only to stop inch’s away from her flow and and do the same to to her other leg. Leaving her fur moist with both his saliva and her own love juices that wouldn't stop flowing.

Finally after doing both her legs Spike placed his lips on her back door where he give her a deep Prench kiss, filling her with tongue and causing her to go cross eyed. He made sure not to go to deep so as to not tip her over that final edge. He then rose his head higher for a reprise of the kiss to her flower, while being so skillful and careful as to not allow her release. Limestone arched her back as she tried shoving Spike’s snout in deeper and force her to cum but the drake was stronger than her and the awkward angle.. All she could so was pant and squirm as she grasped the bed sheets and prayed that he would show mercy and finish off!

Finally Spike decided to see just how much like her sister she was and took his tongue and wiggled one tip into her urethra while the other worked her clitoris.

Limestone’s eyes went wide in shock and pleasure as she arched her back and lifted herself up screaming at top of her lungs. "RRRRRUUUUTTTT!!!!"She sprayed out her juices uncontrollably in the most powerful orgasm she has ever had before going limp and falling back onto the bed.

"So screaming runs in the family then." Spike laughed

"Pant Fatherrutter rut! Pant see why Pinkie is marrying you! Pant Rut!" Limestone grasped out.

"Well now that we are done with the foreplay just let me know when you are ready for the main event." Spike said as he undid his pants, showing off his large pointy and spiny glistening phalluses.

"Pant Holy rut, what are you, Celestia’s gift to mare kind?" Limestone said. Her eyes unable to remove themselves from the twin drakehoods in front of her.

"Well technically in a way yes, but never mind that now, just rest up for the event." Spike said

"Hey pant what’s that smell?" Limestone asked

"Smell? What smell?" Spike asked.

Limestone sniffed the air as an unknown but strong scent caught her nose. "That paint strong rich musky smell, it smells a little spicy too." Limestone said

"Oh that’s just Spike musk, it comes from his cocks whenever he takes them out." Pinkie answered from her chair. Her right hoof moving frantically inside her pants.

"I have a musk? Why hasn't anypony told me about this before?" Spike asked.

"I dunno, we don't really mind it and I guess we figured you already knew." Pinkie answered.

Limestone sniffed again. "Well it does pant smell nice..Okay, I think pant, I think I'm as ready as I'll ever be. Just go slowly alright." Limestone said.

"But of course my lady." Spike said as he got into position. Lining up both shafts he ever slowly started to enter the grey mare. All the while staring right into her eyes.

As she watched Limestone couldn't believe her eyes. The size, how it seem to go in so easily, the feeling of firm yet soft spines pressing against her inner walls. She let out a moan as she flung her head back felt her eyes trying to roll into the back of her head. It was then that Spike finally hilt himself within her, and Limestone took notice that his spines were wiggling inside her.

"You ready?" Spike asked while looking her right in the eye.

"Y-yes." She said

Spike’s piston ability started up and his dicks began slowly moving as if they would exist her only to go back it without ever fully leaving. With one always retracting while the other moved back in. Each time going a little bit faster them before.

Spike placed one claw behind Limestone’s back and the other on her shoulder as he lifted her up into his arms and started to add thrusts to his own natural positioning.

Limestone’s body had never felt like this before. Having two large rod alternatively pushing deep inside her as the rods themselves were pushed and pulled even more from the base. She knew she couldn’t last to much longer under this kind of treatment, not after her last powerful orgasm, but she tried to hold out as long as she could. Her willpower finally gave out when Spike brought her in for another kiss like the one that begin their time together. A powerful orgasm rocked her body as her eyes rolled into the back of her head and she tried to scream into Spike mouth. Her whole body shook and quivered before ultimately going limp in the hold of Spike powerful arms as his strong seed shot deep within her.

Once both he and her were finished Spike gently laid her back down on the bed , never letting go of her as he removed himself from within her. Leaving the now small belly bulge as proof of his work.

'So how was your first time?" Spike asked; only to find that Limestone was now asleep within his arms.

"Careful Spike, I think you may have ruined Limy for any other stallion." Pinkie said with a giggle.

Spike turned to his bride to be and saw that the now nude Pinkie seemed to have enjoyed the show if the large wet spot on her chair and her moist hand was any proof.

"Normally, I would be happy to do the same to you but I think Limestone needs a little cuddle time after this." Spike said with a smile.

"You're probably right but I think my big strong dragon deserves a little reward for helping my big sister. So why don't we clean you up." Pinkie said as she walked over to her drake and placed one of his members into her mouth.

One Week later

It was a slow day at Sugarcube Corner when Limestone walked in carrying a box.

"Limy, what brings you here?" Pinkie said with a smile as she walked over to greet her sister.

"Don't call me Limy. Anyway is Spike here?" Limestone said as rubbed the back of her head.

Pinkie shook her head. "No. He, Twilight, Fluttershy, and Applejack had to go to Kirin Grove for something called the festival of new life. Why are looking for him?"

"Well I kinda of need to tell him and you something, something about well here just open this box." Limestone said as shoved the box into Pinkie’s hooves.

Pinkie open the box and remove the one item that was inside of it,.....A single bun.