The Proposition

by Sherlocked-Dawn

Rating: mature
Tags: Spike, Sex, Human, Sunset Shimmer, Main 6, Applejack, Slice of Life, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Romance, Porn
Length: 2566

"So, a virgin, huh? Would you like to change that?" Sunset offers to relieve Applejack of her virginity, no strings attached. But how will it go?

After Applejack let slip one night that she was still a virgin, Sunset made her a proposal. Lose her virginity, no strings attached. Will Applejack take her up on it, and if so, how does it go? Will Sunset's offer result in more than just a one night stand when unwanted feelings get thrown in the mix?

Published 2019-01-11 04:30:02 UTC
Last updated 2019-04-23 01:39:57 UTC

The Question

Author's Note

Hey y'all, just thought I'd throw together a Sunset/Applejack fic together! I've been wanting to for some time! It'll be 2 chapters, so I'm hoping to have the next one out soon! I hope y'all enjoy this, and lemme know what you think!

-Dawn

The Question

“So, a virgin, huh?”

Applejack rolled her eyes and looked over to Sunset Shimmer who was draped over the garden fence, watching her plant this season’s crops.

“Remind me t’never drink ‘round y’all again. I can’t let one secret slip or everyone starts pokin’ fun at me.”

“No, no, I wasn’t making fun of you, it’s cute really,” the blonde groaned at that, “I’m just surprised. You’re twenty five, hot as hell, with guys and girls fawning over you, but you still have your v-card. How is that?”

“Did you actually want somethin’, or…”

“Yeah, I have a party invitation from Twilight,” she held up the envelope between her fingers as proof, “and I need some good baking apples, but I thought I’d be nice and let you finish your work. So c’mon, spill.”

Applejack carefully covered a few holes with dirt before replying.

“I don’t have a good answer. It just don’t feel right laying with strangers and the few times I was in a relationship, it never got that far. I’ve got enough toys and magazines t’keep me satisfied, so I just don’t look for anyone. Ain’t like I don’t wanna, it’s just not a top priority right now.”

“I get it. It’s commendable, really. I wish I would’ve waited longer, but I didn’t care back then. I would do anything it took to get my way. I’m glad I grew up, that was a dark spot in my life.”

Applejack smiled. “All that matters is that you realized what you were turning into and you changed for the better.”

“True, and that allowed me to meet you and the girls, so it was worth it. Wait, we got off track, we were talking about your lack of sex life, not my reformation.”

The farmer moved to the last row, poking shallow holes in the soft ground.

“Do we have to? What else is there t’know? It ain’t like I’ve got juicy gossip or somethin’ about my last roll in the hay.”

“Oh, there’s plenty to talk about. Even though you haven’t done the deed yet, I bet you have all kinds of fantasies when you’re alone. Maybe a romp in the barn or getting pinned up against one of your apple trees?” Sunset teased, her eyes slowly moving over the blonde who was squatted down, working diligently.

“Good gravy girl, I know I’m a rancher, but I do have interests outside of Sweet Apple Acres, y’know. Besides, the barn? Really? You got any idea how gross that is?”

The redhead shrugged. “I thought you country types weren’t afraid to get down and dirty.”

“Dirty? No. Covered in horse manure and scratchy hay? Yes. Believe it or not, even us country types have limits and standards.”

“Then tell me, what do you think about at night when you’re by yourself?”

Applejack huffed. “You’re nosy, I’ll tell you that. And if you gotta know, I get off on the harder stuff. Bondage, spankin’, hair pullin’, bitin’, maybe the odd slap or two... Don’t seem like much fun if you’re just layin’ there like a limp noodle.”

“Wow, AJ., that’s actually pretty hardcore. I didn’t expect that. I dated a girl once that was really into BDSM. It was hot while it lasted.”

Finishing the last row she had to do, Applejack stood up and stretched before taking her work gloves off and sticking them in the back pocket of her jeans.

Walking over to Sunset, the blonde responded, “the only other person I’ve told that to is Twilight, and she thought I was crazy. Speakin’ of Twilight, what’s in the envelope?”

Sunset handed the card to Applejack as she passed through the gate out of the garden.

“Spike’s eighteenth birthday party this weekend.”

Looking over the brightly colored card, Applejack asked, “how’s living four houses away from Twilight goin‘? Obviously not well seein’ as she’s got you doin’ the mailman’s job.”

Sunset chuckled and stuck her hands in her leather jacket pockets, “I was over at her place while she was making them, so I offered to bring yours. Had to come over here anyways.”

They started making their way back to the farmhouse.

“So what’cha plan on makin’? I know you ain’t much of a cook.”

“Just a basic pie. I’m trying to learn some easier recipes. Now that I live on my own, I realized I can’t eat take-out every night because I don’t have anyone to help me pay the bills anymore. I’ve made a few meals and they actually came out okay, so I’m hoping I’ll get better as time goes on.”

“Well, if you ever need some tips or anythin’, let me know. I’m not Granny Smith, but I do know my way around a kitchen.”

They stopped in front of Applejack’s house. “Lemme get’cha some apples real quick. Is a paper bag full enough?”

“Oh yeah, that’ll be plenty. I’ve got be able to fit it in my backpack since I’m on my bike.”

Applejack disappeared through the front door for a minute before coming back with a full bag of fruit.

“Here you go, a bag full of jonagolds. They’re some of the best for bakin’.”

Sunset took the paper sack from her as they walked to the driveway where her motorcycle was parked.

“How much do I owe you?”

Applejack held up a hand. “No charge. A few missin’ apples ain’t a big deal. I hope your pie turns out good.”

“Really? Thanks! I appreciate it!”

“It’s thanks for bringin’ the invitation by, and for the uh, lovely conversation,” the farmer laughed as the redhead adjusted the now-heavier bag on her back.

“Yeah, no problem! See you Saturday for the party?” Sunset asked as she straddled her bike.

“Yepp, I’ll shoot Twi a text and let her know I’ll be there. See y’then, Sunset.”

“Bye, AJ!”

The farmer waved and turned her back to start up the stone pathway to her house but was stopped a few steps in.

“Hey, Applejack, wait!” Sunset called after her.

“Huh?” the blonde turned to look at her friend.

“This might be awkward, but, uh, if you ever want to have some fun, if you know what I mean, call me. No strings attached. Maybe I could show you a thing or two.”

Applejack’s face flushed red as she heard the proposition laid in front of her. “O-oh, yeah, alright. Thanks for the offer. I‘ll think about it.”

“No problem, see you later Applejack.”

“Yeah, bye Sunset.”

The biker smiled and started up her motorcycle, leaving her best friend behind.

The Answer

Author's Note

I lied. Again. Not only did I not get this chapter out 'soon', there's also gonna be three chapters, not two. Oops. Anyways, here's the next chapter finally, so enjoy!

The Answer

“Blow out the candles, Spike! And don’t forget to make a wish!”

Smiling, Spike leaned over his cake and put out the glowing candles with his breath.

Cheers and applause rang through the room as Twilight moved to turn the dining room light back on.

“So, what did you wish for, huh?” Pinkie Pie asked, pulling the used candles out of the cake so that she could cut it.

He looked around the room at his friends until his gaze settled on Rarity for a moment, a dopey grin on his face.

“I can’t say or it won’t come true, not that it will anyway…”

“I bet I can tell you what he wished for,” Rainbow smirked, leaning against the wall.

Applejack snickered and elbowed her lightly in the ribs before taking the piece of cake she was handed.

Everyone chatted as they ate, Spike and his high school friends talking about the new video game he was given.

After they had their fill, the birthday boy and his friends went into the living room to test out the new game Spike had received for his birthday.

Twilight and the girls cleaned up the mess and migrated to the kitchen to chat.

“So Spike seems like he’s had a good birthday,” Sunset said at the sink as she handed Fluttershy a clean plate to dry off.

“Yeah, it really seems like he has. I’m glad you all were able to come, I know it made him happy to see each of you.”

“Don’t seem like much of a birthday for an eighteen year old guy though, does it? Don’t they usually wanna go out and do somethin’?” Applejack asked.

“Uh, what kind of boy doesn’t want to be surrounded by six hotties on his special day?” Rainbow chimed in, “that’s gotta be every dude’s wet dream.”

Twilight rolled her eyes. “That’s my brother and that’s disgusting, Rainbow.”

The athlete shrugged.

“Besides, I got passes for Spike and his friends to go paintballing tomorrow. His friends will spend the night tonight and head over there tomorrow. I thought just having a party was a bit bland as well. This is what he wanted though.”

“Ohh, that sounds like so much fun!” Pinkie squealed.

“That sounds scary,” Fluttershy said, putting up the last of the now-clean dishes.

“I do hope they are careful, I’ve heard it can be dangerous!” Rarity added, placing a delicate hand over her heart. “I wouldn’t want anything to happen to him!”

Rainbow rolled her eyes.

“He’ll be fine,” Twilight told them, “you have to wear a helmet, facemask and pads, so he will be well protected. He‘ll have a fun time.”

“Oh! I nearly forgot! Twilight dear, while I’m here, did you still want me to look at your wardrobe and help you pick an appropriate outfit for your dinner with your brother and his new girlfriend next week? They chose a very upscale restaurant and you simply must look your best!”

“Yes, I’d appreciate the help! I want to make a good first impression, he really likes her.”

“Then let us go, there isn’t a moment to waste! Fluttershy? Would you be a dear and come along? You have a good eye for accessories and would be of great help.”

“O-oh, yes, of course!”

“We’ll be back,” Twilight said as the three friends walked out of the kitchen.

“Lame. Hey Pinks, wanna see if we can prank the guys while they‘re distracted?” Rainbow asked, hopping off the counter she was sitting on.

“Ab-sol-utely! And I’ve got the most perfect prank ever! Come on!”

Pinkie and Rainbow left, leaving Sunset and Applejack to their own devices.

Sunset grabbed a glass and poured herself a drink.

“Guess we ain’t cool enough to be included,” Applejack joked, sticking her thumbs through her belt loops.

“I don’t know about you, but I don’t find either of those things interesting. I’d rather just watch Spike play video games,” the redhead shrugged, taking a sip of coke.

“Nah, video games ain’t my thing. I’d rather read or somethin’.”

There was a pause.

“Hey Sunset? ” Applejack got her friends attention, “This might be a weird time to bring it up, but I wanna take you up on your offer, if it still stands…”

“My offer? Wha- oh! Wow, of course it still stands, I just didn’t actually think that you’d accept.”

The farmer shrugged. “I wasn’t gonna, but I really started thinkin’ ‘bout it. You’re one of my best friends and I trust you with damn near everythin’. You’re a bombshell, feistier than hell, and you’ve got a head full of red hair I wouldn’t mind tuggin’ on all night.”

Sunset raised her eyebrows.

“Plus, I know you wouldn’t make it awkward or make fun of me for not knowin’ how to please a person. You’ll be understandin’ and show me how to do it. If I have to lose my virginity to someone, you’re a solid choice.”

Sunset smiled. “I’m flattered that you feel like you can trust me. I’d love to show you the ropes. Both figuratively and literally, since you said you were into that.”

Applejack blushed as Sunset’s voice changed into a deeper, more seductive tone.

Stepping closer, the ginger said, “This party’s almost over, did you have anything else planned for the evening? Maybe we could go to my place and I could give you a few private lessons.”

Sunset ran a finger up Applejack’s arm.

“N-nope, free as a bird all night.”

“Good.”

Looking towards the kitchen entryway, Sunset made sure the coast was clear before reaching up and wrapping her arms around Applejack’s neck, pulling her in for a kiss.

The blonde froze as their lips met, her mind going into overdrive at the warm body pressed against hers.

Sunset immediately felt her tension and moved back. “Was that too much?”

“N-no,” Applejack stuttered, “it was great, I just need a minute to get used to it. And it don’t help much that I’m worried someone’s gonna pop in here while we’re doin’, y’know… that.”

“You’re right, we need some privacy. Let’s go tell Twilight that we’re leaving. Spike’s party is all but over and everyone is just hanging out now. She won’t mind.”

Giving Applejack a wink, Sunset grabbed her hand, and pulled her until the blonde got the hint to follow.

Walking up the staircase they found Twilight’s room and a very distressed trio of girls.

“No, no! This won’t do!” Rarity looked over Twilight who was wearing a pastel pink dress that seemed more suited for a young girls Easter outfit. “Take it off. Fluttershy, hand me the next dress please?”

Clearing her throat, Sunset announced their presence before their purple haired friend could start stripping off her clothes.

“Oh hey, Sunset, Applejack, what’s going on? Come to help? I could probably use all the help I can get, this isn‘t going well.” Twilight said, moving her hair so that Rarity could unzip her.

“Actually, we came to say goodbye. AJ and I are going to go back to my place. She said she’d give me some cooking advice and show me some simple techniques. She’s gotta get home in a little bit so I wanted to wrack her brain while she was in the area.”

Twilight smiled and looked at Applejack. “Oh, that’s so thoughtful, AJ! I know Sunset’s been trying to improve her cooking, so it’s nice of you to offer to help her out!”

Applejack gave what she thought was a simple grin as she lied through her teeth. “Uh, eyupp, that’s exactly what we’ll be doin’… Cookin’ and such, mhmm!”

Sunset briefly glared at her taller friend. “Anyways, we better get going Twilight. Thanks for having us over, it was a lot of fun!”

“Of course! Thank you for coming! I know Spike appreciated you both being here!”

“No problem, we enjoyed it! Good luck with the dress hunt you guys. I’m sure Rarity will find you the perfect outfit.”

“You know I will, darling,” the fashionista replied, “ta-ta you two!”

“Bye guys,” Sunset and Applejack waved to their friends before they shut the door behind them.

Turning to Applejack, Sunset gave her a sexy smirk and hard slap on her bottom that made the farmer yelp. “Ready to cook, cowgirl?”