Love and Conquerors

“Tea, ladies?” offered Twilight, sipping from her cup and nodding in the direction of the teapot on the kitchen counter. She was doing her best to stay casual, despite the life-changing three-way that had just taken place.

“Yes, please,” said Celestia, and Luna simply nodded. The royal sisters were back to their normal selves - shorter, not as muscular, regal but far less imposing. They'd reverted shortly after the two of them had finished making love to Twilight Sparkle, and the three of them had gone to separate bathrooms to take showers and magically summon clothes for themselves.

Now they were converging on the kitchen - a more intimate, less formal venue for three princesses to share tea. Twilight poured a cup for each of them, and the sisters pulled stools up to the long kitchen counter.

“Soooo…” said Twilight, and the three princesses shared a laugh.

“We've made things terribly awkward, haven't we, Twilight?” said Luna.

“I can't defend all the things I did and said as Daybreaker,” said Celestia, “but as our alter egos explained, the desires that brought them out are very real. Now that our feelings are out in the open, though, we won't be seeing those two again.”

Twilight smirked. “Oh no? What if I want to see them again? They were awfully buff, and tall, and so passionate…”

“Well, if you insist, I'm sure Nightmare Moon would come out to play,” said Luna.

“Well, yes,” chuckled Celestia, “unleashing Daybreaker was rather freeing, and I wouldn't mind letting her out from time to time. But now that we're back to our usual selves, Twilight, we won't be putting quite so much pressure on you. If you need some time to process what just happened before you arrive at an answer, then that's more than all right.”

“Yes, I think we've both made very strong cases for ourselves,” said Luna. “We shan't press you for a decision… we trust that you won't keep us in suspense longer than necessary.”

Twilight smiled, her posture relaxing as she sipped the soothing tea in her cup. “Thank you,” she said. “Today has been… a lot… although I think I started to find my stride at the end there. I certainly do have a lot to think about, but one thing I know for certain is that I care deeply for both of you… and I think we've established that there is, er, sexual compatibility as well.

“But relationships are made of more than that, aren't they?” said Twilight. “Now that the fiercely passionate sides of you girls have had their say, maybe it's better if I just… dated the two of you for a time. And once I've explored my feelings a little better, I can confidently say whether I'm ready to be with one of you, or… maybe both?”

Celestia met Twilight Sparkle’s eyes and laughed gently. “I was thinking you might say that,” she said. “I saw how you enjoyed being the object of two princesses’ desires, and I suspected it might occur to you that you needn't give that up. Well, Daybreaker wanted you for herself, but at the end of the day, I am Princess Celestia - and Princess Celestia understands the value of compromise.”

“Princess Luna would still very much like you for herself,” huffed Luna, “but as the two of us are generally awake at different times, I suppose we would not be competing too much for your attentions. Very well - we shall have our dates, Twilight Sparkle. The stars will shine only for you, and we two will dance in and out of dreams.”

“There is another matter to discuss,” said Celestia, patting her stomach. “Your talk of making us broodmares was very stimulating at the time, but…”

“Ah, yes,” muttered Luna. “In a more sober frame of mind, one must consider the more practical implications of, er…”

“Becoming massively pregnant with a litter of my royal foals?” said Twilight matter-of-factly. She watched the awkward expressions on the royal sisters’ faces, then broke into a naughty chuckle. “Oh, girls, I'm sorry if I had you worried! The balls I created for myself didn't produce actual, viable sperm! Otherwise, my cum was pretty similar to the real thing, but making something that can actually make a mare pregnant… that's some pretty complex magic! All that broodmare stuff was just dirty talk. A little flight of fancy.”

Twilight observed the princesses’ reactions. There was relief on their faces, but it almost seemed performative. She thought she detected a trace of disappointment, actually.

“Of course, I do have a knack for complex magic,” said Twilight, a naughty smirk returning to her face. “I have a few ideas for experiments that would give me viable sperm, suitable for knocking up a couple mares with a belly full of Princess Twilight Sparkle’s beautiful foals…”

Twilight was watching Celestia and Luna’s reactions closely, so she noticed the flash that went across each Princess’ eyes. Luna’s eyes grew darker for a fraction of a second - and Celestia’s eyes glowed a flaming red.

“Experiments, you say?” asked Luna. “I am intrigued. Let us discuss the matter further sometime.”

“Yes, I am eager to hear more,” said Celestia.

Twilight licked her lips, already imagining the royal sisters burdened with pregnancies. This was going to be fun.