Evil Returns

by APStories

Rating: teen
Tags: Tragedy, Horror, Five Nights at Freddy's, Cozy Glow, Profanity, Violence, Crossover, Death, Alternate Universe, Human, Gore, Original Character, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Rainbow Dash, Fluttershy, Mystery
Length: 2902

While celebrating Verdana's fifth birthday at Freddy Fazbear's Pizzeria, the animatronics plot their revenge!

Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash celebrate their daughter's fifth birthday at Freddy Fazbear's Pizzeria. However, the animatronics (Freddy, Bonnie, Chica, and Foxy) plan to get their revenge on a mysterious killer. They're fully convinced that Fluttershy, Rainbow Dash, and Verdana can provide them with information on the killer's whereabouts. These good-natured animatronics must team up with the FlutterDash family if they ever hope to save the pony race from annihilation!

"Five Nights At Freddy's" belongs to Scott Cawthon.

Published 2019-02-02 19:30:01 UTC
Last updated 2019-02-02 19:30:01 UTC

Evil Returns

"I'm sorry if you think we're evil, Dash. We're not what people say we are", Freddy said.

"Don't sweat it, Freddy. William Afton has been a pain in the ass for my family for five years. Ever since Verdana's birth. We've been doing everything we can, but I don't think it's enough", Rainbow Dash said.

"She is adorable, I'm not gonna lie. Congratulations, by the way", Freddy said.

"Heh, thanks. Once the party is over, we'll help you guys out", Rainbow Dash said.

"Excellent", Freddy said.

After the party...

"Yar, guys! I found a dead pony", the raspy-voiced animatronic said.

"Ah, that's creepy! Thanks, Foxy. I'm gonna have a hard time sleeping tonight", Rainbow Dash said.

"Hmmm, these gashes look familiar. It's not a coincidence", Fluttershy said.

"What does it mean?", Chica asked.

"It means that the pony race is also in danger. Verdana, you said there were ten dead ponies in Equestria, correct?", Bonnie asked.

"Yeah, at least that's what my mothers told me. Moms, what are we gonna do?", asked Verdana.

"We keep- holy shit!", Rainbow Dash said. "There's a pair of lungs right here!"

Everyone else in the room screamed. Chica fainted. "Ugh. Chica, we've seen worse. I mean, a dead body-", Freddy said, but was eventually cut off by Bonnie.

"Hey, watch it! There's a kid in the room!", Bonnie said.

"Heh, it's okay, Bonnie. She's listened to songs with swear words, like Five More Nights, Another Five Nights, and We Don't Bite", Rainbow Dash said. "What were you saying, Freddy?"

"A dead body's been completely ripped up. Looked like something that came out of a horror movie", Freddy said. "Anyways, Springtrap's been dead for a year, and the killings just started last year. So, Springtrap is innocent. Heck, he was probably the first one to get killed."

"Yar, hang on a minute, bucko. I recall seeing a pink Pegasus with blue curly hair near Springtrap's dead body.", Foxy said.

"Wait, a pink Pegasus? There's only one pink Pegasus we know", Verdana said.

"Cozy Glow!", Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash said in unison.

"You know her?", Chica asked.

"She's bad news. She must have escaped Tartarus!", Rainbow Dash explained.

"And she's psychopathic! She tried to take over Equestria! We have to stop her... again!", Fluttershy said.

"While we appreciate your enthusiasm, we don't even know where she is. Unless...", Bonnie said.

"There's a pattern. There's gotta be a pattern", Freddy said.

"What do you mean, pattern?", Fluttershy asked. "The killings were all around Equestria."

"Wait, no two killings were in the same place", Rainbow Dash said. "The killings were in Vanhoover, Manehatten, Baltimare, Fillydelphia, Canterlot, Manechester, Appleloosa, Las Pegasus, Ponyville, and Yakyakistan. That's ten."

"And now, there's a dead pony here. That's eleven", Fluttershy said.

"Cozy Glow is probably still here. This place is a maze", Chica said.

Just then, the lights went dark. Fazbear Family by Stupendium played.

Open up the doors and let them in
Gotta mop the floors and clear the bins!
Better check the stores and order in!
Don't you just adore this sort of thing?
Welcome to Fazbear Training and your new career!
Please just ignore the staining, the last guy disappeared.
Management may be frustrating, it's gonna be weird.
To hold team meetings as the only employee here!
It's guaranteed that you'll probably succeed
Cutting corners is just how you achieve
Remember that return customers are key
So try to let at least a few of them leave
Lally's Lollies! You'll have a lolly good time!
Welcome to the Fazbear Family!
Clean family fun! (With some tragedy)
You've sunk your savings, they'll sink their teeth
Into a juicy slice! (Or a lobotomy)
Who's scared of a little liability?
Health and Safety? More of a Luxury.
You've got a lot to learn, so if it's unclear
Just know the crusts aren't all that's getting stuffed here
Hear the creaking of gears creep in your ears
Deep secrets we have been keeping for years
Can you keep from their teeth and your sheets from arrears?
No funeral cover, so sort your affairs
Who would think this could be such a lethal career?
That cuddly creatures could leave you in tears?
No culinary teachers could leave you prepared
For guarding the kitchen while screaming in fear
You gotta be kidding me, Kiddies come here?
For tyrannical mechanical murderous bears?
I was planning for a life as a restaurateur
So, robotics was probably an awful idea!
Now I'm the boss of a cursed pizzeria
I'm no villain, just an innocent entrepreneur
I want to fill children with fun and with cheer!
Not kill them and fill them with pistons and gears!
Marty's Plungers! Nothin' goes down that can't come up!
Welcome to the Fazbear Family!
Clean family fun! (With some tragedy)
You've sunk your savings, they'll sink their teeth
Into a juicy slice! (Or a lobotomy)
Who's scared of a little liability?
Health and Safety? More of a Luxury.
You've got a lot to learn, so if it's unclear
Just know the crusts aren't all that's getting stuffed here
So, play the music, light the lights
You're gonna get a private show tonight
Discount items might be nice
But save too much, you'll pay the price!
There's a world of cheap attractions to buy!
Or save the cash and find them outside
That pestilent elephant is a hell of a find
But a malevolent element could develop inside
We're gonna get you to the end of the week
Now you can run a restaurant effortlessly
‘Cus you can clean the toilets at the press of a key!
Just check the ball pit for any fleshy debris
Flo's Glossy Floss! The first step to true romance!
Welcome to the Fazbear Family!
Clean family fun! (With some tragedy)
You've sunk your savings, they'll sink their teeth
Into a juicy slice! (Or a lobotomy)
Who's scared of a little liability?
Health and Safety? More of a Luxury.
You've got a lot to learn, so if it's unclear
Just know the crusts aren't all that's getting stuffed here
Hey, BonBon! It's the birthday boy!
Well hello again! Here we go again! Start the show again!
I think we all know the direction this is going in!
You sit by the vents and prevent us getting in
Then get a big hug from a friendly exoskeleton!
No use in fleeing, you're feeding a sequence, keeps repeating
No time for grieving, the scene is teeming with demon playthings
Reeking and leaking, unspeakable freaks who need spring cleaning
Just keep the springs dry! Or you'll end up screaming!
It's safe to say you aren't what we all expected
But you're a gift and it'd be rude to just reject it
We were built to dance and sing but we're infected
So make us whole, feed us the souls that you've collected
I'm not a monster, I just want to be liked
Am I what you designed, daddy? Do you feel pride?
I want to talk about these feelings deep inside
But every time I open up some children tend to die!
Congratulations, your probation was a triumph!
But we're afraid that you're now surplus to requirement
Unfortunately, we will need to keep you silent
You'll find our severance package gets a little violent!
Welcome to the Fazbear Family!
Clean family fun! (With some tragedy)
You've sunk your savings, they'll sink their teeth
Into a juicy slice! (Or a lobotomy)
Who's scared of a little liability?
Health and Safety? More of a Luxury.
You've got a lot to learn, so if it's unclear
Just know the crusts aren't all that's getting stuffed here!

"What the hell?", Foxy said.

The song was six minutes long. "I'm still here", a voice said.

"Show yourself!", Rainbow Dash said.

"Follow my voice", the voice said. The creature sang Welcome To Freddy's by Madame Macabre.

I can see you there, warmth and life why don't you share?
It's been many years stuck here living with our fears
Please do pardon me, I can't help it, can't you see?
In this misery, you can join our family
Why'd you lock the door? Don't you like us anymore?
This game's lots of fun, you look funny when you run
Eyes up on the wall, well that's just no fun at all
Watching us in there, using cameras hardly seems fair
Stalking hallways, getting closer
Got you now, it's nearly over
Found your blind spot, lurking within
Sooner or later we'll get in
Careful not to waste your power
You've still got to last an hour
I can hear your heart pound heavy
Here we come I hope you're ready
Shouldn't have come here to this house of fear
Pray that those doors hold steady
As the clock ticks on you pray to reach dawn
Can you last five nights at Freddy's?
They don't let us out, all the people scream and shout
After they go home, that is when they let us roam
Once we got a taste, but they shut us down in haste
Called us things of hell, blamed it on the rotting smell
Who's that on the phone? You're supposed to be alone
You're not playing fair, we'll just have to break in there
You can join the crew, we have got a suit for you
With you I'll confide, it's no use to run and hide
Stalking hallways, getting closer
Got you now, it's nearly over
Found your blind spot, lurking within
Sooner or later we'll get in
Careful not to waste your power
You've still got to last an hour
I can hear your heart pound heavy
Here we come I hope you're ready
Why'd you come back here? You should have fled, dear
Pray that those doors hold steady
You've made it quite far it's rather bizarre
Can you last five nights at Freddy's?
I just want to go home
Don't want to be alone
Please don't cry or scream out
You won't ever get out
Shouldn't have come here to this house of fear
Pray that those doors hold steady
As the clock ticks on you pray to reach dawn
Can you last five nights at Freddy's?
Why'd you come back here? You should have fled, dear
Pray that those doors hold steady
You've made it quite far it's rather bizarre
Can you last five nights at Freddy's?

It didn't take long for the seven heroes to track the imposter down. She was in the office. "Cozy Glow!", Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash said in unison.

"Ah, we meet again, Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash. Oh, and I see you brought some friends. How fun. Too bad they won't live much longer. You see, I was able to escape Tartarus after ten years of careful planning. I've grown older and stronger. If you would've allowed me to take over Equestria, none of this would've happened! This is my world, and I deserve to be an empress! You might've thought I was gone, but I'm still here, and ready for REVENGE! HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!", Cozy Glow said.

"Yar, you forgot one thing", Foxy said.

"What?", Cozy Glow asked.

"Your power's running low. You're in our house now. Our rules", Freddy said. "We're homicidal! We're puppets taken by a jester in disguise!"

"It's a fact without the ties!", Chica shouted.

"Link us together! We're a family forever!", Bonnie shouted.

"Ready to show you our SURPRISE!", the four animatronics shouted in unison.

"Copyright infringement!", Cozy Glow said. "That's Unfixable by DAGames!"

"Damn it", Freddy said.

"I'm fully aware of the power in this place. Once the power runs out, I can escape!", Cozy Glow said.

"Shit. Bonnie, Foxy, block the exits. Chica, Fluttershy, bring Verdana to safety. Rainbow Dash, help me break this door down!", Freddy commanded.

"Right!", Rainbow Dash said. Freddy and Rainbow Dash pushed on the door with all their might, but it wouldn't budge. "It's too heavy! Stand back, Freddy!" Rainbow Dash flew to the end of the hallway, and, using her supersonic speed, blasted the door open!

"Whoa, that was awesome!", Freddy said.

"Ah, crap!", Cozy Glow said. "Well, I'm not leaving empty-handed!" She grabbed a sharp piece of glass from the shattered window, and stabbed Rainbow Dash in the heart!

"NO!", Freddy shouted. He talked into a microphone. "Fluttershy, get over here, NOW!"

"On my way!", Fluttershy responded. She flew to the office.

"F-Fluttershy?", Rainbow Dash asked.

"Oh, no! Dashie!", Fluttershy said. She ran over to her wife's side, picked her up, and cradled her. "Don't leave me, please!"

"It's okay. I'll be okay. Just promise me one thing. Keep Verdana safe", Rainbow Dash said. She gave her wife a final kiss on the lips and went limp.

"No!", Fluttershy said. "You... you... you MONSTER! YOU TOOK AWAY MY CHILDHOOD FRIEND-TURNED-WIFE! NOW, YOU'LL PAY!", she yelled. She grabbed a sharper piece of glass, and stabbed Cozy Glow in the heart and through the body. She ripped out the villain's heart, and smashed it. Blood sprayed everywhere. Freddy backed away fearfully as Fluttershy continued her bloody revenge on Cozy Glow. Soon, all that was left of Cozy Glow was a pair of wings.

"Okay, then. I'll go get the others. Fluttershy, clean this up, please", Freddy said.

"Yeah, sure", Fluttershy responded.

It didn't take long for Fluttershy to clean up the bloody mess. Rainbow Dash's body was lying in the corner, her vacant eyes staring off into oblivion.

"I'm sorry, Fluttershy. We couldn't save her", Bonnie said.

"Well, at least I avenged her. Cozy Glow is dead for good", Fluttershy responded.

Verdana flew over to her mother. "Mom, what are we gonna do?", Verdana said.

Suddenly, Rainbow Dash came back to life! "Whoa, that was trippy. I met my maker", Rainbow Dash said.

"Dashie!", Fluttershy said. The two Pegasi embraced tightly and kissed passionately.

"Mom!", Verdana said. She hugged both her moms.

The animatronics stared at the happy family. "Thank you, Puppet", Freddy said quietly.

In another location, a puppet-like animatronic smiled and sunk back into her box.

A final song played.

Five Nights At Freddy's: Sister Location Song Left Behind by DAGames

Everyone, please stay on your seats
The show will begin momentarily
Behold the horrors
They lurk beneath the shadows of remorse
You wouldn't know of course
But i forced a new judgment day
On this day you will repay
Your respects to all that may
Lurk in between your mind and man kind
So have a seat and be afraid
Fears about to commence the final ritual
One body is all we need for this to be complete
And when the day begins to take form, you wont be leaving those doors
You'll only live with us inside the darkness as we tear you up inside
I WAS LEFT BEHIND
All this torture will unwind
I was never all that kind
If you were to rewind
Then you would find
I was left behind
Take your turn to run and hide
I will catch you all the time
This might no longer shines
Your tears divine
You'll now be mine!
Behold the terrors
You wont believe
What i have done to you
I've made it look brand new
Oh how cute
But dont digress
Im the ring master you see
In this horror game you flee
I take up every shadow
Believe me
Now have a seat
And grab your light
Tears begin to run
You dry
But darkened thoughts are the command grounds I give myself to be complete
Be as it may
Our courtesy remains
So we offer you
Our darkest passion
Take off that blind fold that heals
And reveal your soul that dies
I WAS LEFT BEHIND
All this torture will unwind
I was never all that kind
If you were to rewind
Then you would find
I was left behind
Take your turn to run and hide
I will catch you all the time
This might no longer shines
Your tears divine
You'll now be mine!
You dare bring your filth into my lair?
WELL THEN
LET US DECEND
Re-born again
Our suits are now refined
Breathing new life
Inside our tombs tonight
You have no idea what we've been through
Time and time again
Dont hold it on our deadliest demise
We can't keep you alive!
All this torture will unwind
Take it from our broken crimes
We have no place to go
But you would know
Take your turn to run and flee
But deaths your destiny
Stop holding back from me
They burned it all down!
They burned us alive
They made us look like clowns
Our souls arise
But like the jester said to the king
There is bad news i bring
Now let the night begin!
I WAS LEFT BEHIND
All this torture will unwind
I was never all that kind
If you were to rewind
Then you would find
I was left behind
Take your turn to run and hide
I will catch you all the time
This might no longer shines
Your tears divine
You'll now be mine!
We hope you enjoyed the show
With in your grave down below

Author's Note

The songs in this chapter belong to DAGames, Stupendium, Madame Macabre, and JT Music.
"Five Nights At Freddy's" belongs to Scott Cawthon.

Cozy Glow was an adult in this.

Unfortunately, I'm gonna have to kill Rainbow Dash off in the next chapter to keep things going.