Not Her Choice

by Sonic_Applejack2005

Rating: mature
Tags: Applejack, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark, Drama, Apple Bloom, Suicide / Self Harm, Tragedy, Profanity, Non-consensual, Big Macintosh, Sex
Length: 1309

When Apple Bloom falls victim to a horrible crime committed by her own brother, she makes up her mind on how to get her life back together. However, things don't go quite how she wanted.

Big Mac was somepony that anypony could learn a thing or two from. At least, that's what Apple Bloom thought until Big Mac showed her his dark side, leaving her with a permanent reminder of his sin. He is locked up, but his legacy is forced onto Apple Bloom. Will she be able to set herself free and get her life back together, or will Big Mac's crime ruin her life forever?

Published 2019-05-10 19:00:01 UTC
Last updated 2019-05-10 19:00:01 UTC

A Backward State

"Uh, Big Mac? What're ya' doin'?" Apple Bloom asked as her big brother towered over her, grabbing at her with a strange look in his eyes. She stepped back as he came closer, but her heart sank as she felt her back hit the wall, trapping her between it and Big Mac.

"Ah ain't gonna do nothin' bad," Big Mac reassured her as he reached out and lifted the filly, putting her on her back with her stomach facing up. Apple Bloom squealed as Big Mac put both hooves around her legs and pried them apart, revealing the cute little horse pussy between them. "Ah think you're gonna like this real good," said Big Mac.

Apple Bloom's eyes widened in horror as Big Mac unzipped his pants, revealing his throbbing erection. It was almost as long as her entire body, and maybe as thick as a red delicious apple. "H-He--" Apple Bloom tried to cry out for somepony, but she felt her throat closing up as Big Mac descended upon her. She didn't want to believe her big brother was about to rape her, but she knew what it was just as she feared. Again, she tried to close her legs, but Big Mac was far too powerful, forcing himself between her legs. "APPLEJACK! GRANNY SMITH! HELP!" Apple Bloom managed to scream finally, but nopony came. It was just her and Big Mac.

The big red pony wasted no time, jamming his fat tip against Apple Bloom's completely dry cunt. "big Mac, please don't do this!" Apple Bloom cried desperately, covering her eyes with her hooves. But Big Mac didn't relent.

"I'm gonna take ya' to heaven, Apple Bloom," Big Mac slurred as he pressed himself into Apple Bloom's slit, moaning as he entered her tight, dry entrance.

"AHHHHHHH!" There was a horrific burning pain in her nether region, and it was at that moment that Apple Bloom knew that Big Mac had taken her virginity. Blood dripped from her torn vagina, coating Big Mac's cock in the process.

"Oh yeah, ah like that," Big Mac moaned, beginning to pump in and out of Apple Bloom. Apple Bloom felt a strange tearing sensation followed by a blinding pain that left her gasping for breath. In that moment, she wanted nothing more than to die. A few moments later, she passed out from the pain, Big Mac still steadily thrusting his cock in and out of Apple Bloom's broken pussy.

Some months later...

Apple Bloom shot up in her bed, shaking. Months had passed since she had fallen victim to him, but she was still haunted by nightmares of him, the very moment when he forced himself on top of her, thrusting inside... She shivered at the thought, eyes darting back and forth across the room as though Big Mac might pop out at any moment.

"You okay, Sugarcube?"

Apple Bloom jumped as a voice sounded from somewhere close by. "Who's there!?" she shouted, holding her front hooves up defensively.

"It's all right, Apple Bloom. It's me, Applejack." Apple Bloom put a hoof in front of her eyes, shielding them from the bright, white light as she peeked out from behind it. Indeed, it was the sister she loved so much, even more so after her incident. The day Applejack had heard the news, she'd dropped everything she was doing and headed straight to the Ponyville Hospital. In the following days, she spent day and night at her sister's side, cursing out Big Mac both in her mind and aloud for his sin.

Apple Bloom pulled her sister into a hug, unable to stop the tears from flowing as memories of that day flooded back to her. If not for Applejack, she wasn't sure if she would be alive right now. In fact, it was Applejack who had discovered Big Mac's treachery in the barn house. The stallion had fallen asleep after ejaculating inside his sister at least five times, according to the doctors who had inspected her. He had been laying in a pool of his own semen on top of Apple Bloom when Applejack had found them. The older sister had went for a kick to the dick, essentially neutering the big earth pony with her powerful legs. When the police arrived, Big Mac had been sentenced to eternity in Tartarus, and that was the last anypony had heard of him.

Applejack stroked her sister's mane comfortingly. "Ah know this is hard for ya', Apple Bloom. Um listen, ah got some news for ya," she said but immediately regretted her decision. Her sister looked up at her for a moment before responding.

"W-What is it?" asked Apple Bloom. She didn't know if it was good or bad, or whether she wanted to find out at all.

"Well, ah, maybe ah I can tell you some other time," Applejack said suddenly. "You know, it's a lot to deal with an' all right now."

"Please tell me, Applejack," whispered Apple Bloom. There was a moment of silence as she waited. Eventually, Apple Bloom heard a sigh, and she knew her sister had given in.

"Listen Sugarcube, ah don't know how to tell ya this, but... you're pregnant."

"WHAT THE FUCK?" screamed Apple Bloom. "With his foal?" She slammed her hooves on the table beside her. "T-That's a good one, Applejack!" Apple Bloom giggled hysterically. "But ah'm not in the mood for jokes right now!"

"Apple Bloom..." Applejack trailed off. She knew there was nothing she could say to make her sister feel better, nor could she change the reality of the situation.

"Ah... sorry Applejack, ah kinda lost my mind there for a second," Apple Bloom said with a sad laugh. "But ah, ah can't go through with that." Apple Bloom shook her head. "Ah need to get an abortion."

This was the moment Applejack had been dreading. In the months that Apple Bloom had spent inside the hospital, Celestia had made a few drastic changes to Ponyville, one of them including... "Sugarcube, abortions ain't allowed in Ponyville anymore." Applejack forced the words out. "Celestia made an amendment a little while ago, and while the majority of us in Ponyville were against it, the top heads in her counsel voted to outlaw abortions."

Apple Bloom shrieked. It was a piercing cry that made Applejack cover her ears, but luckily the room was soundproof. "T-That's fine," she said, her voice rising as she slumped back into her bed. "Ah, ah'll just have to go to Canterlot for it!"

"Apple Bloom, they made it illegal to leave Ponyville to go get an abortion too."

"SO WHAT? AM I JUST STUCK WITH BIG MAC'S FOAL?" screamed Apple Bloom.

Applejack scratched her head. "Ah, ah guess so."

"WHY DOES CELESTIA AND HER GROUP OF GUARDS GET TO DECIDE WHAT I DO WITH MY BODY? GET THE FUCK OUT OF HERE, APPLEJACK! I WANT TO BE ALONE!"

Applejack debated staying, but she knew from past experience that there was no changing Apple Bloom's mind when she had it set. "All right, Sugarcube. But don't go doin' anythin' dangerous. Can ya promise me that?"

"I SAID GET THE FUCK OUT!" Apple Bloom's voice cracked, followed by heart breaking sobs that Applejack couldn't bear to listen to anymore. She got up slowly and opened the door, hearing it click shut behind her.

The next day, Apple Bloom was found dead in her hospital bed with a coat hanger up her vagina. The doctors determined she had died from toxic shock due to an attempted abortion.

Author's Note

hiiii everypony! :coolphoto: how u all doing on this fine day :pinkiehappy: im doing very good :pinkiesad2: um i have to go rely soon1!! :pinkiesad2: but um i wrote this suuuuper quick for u all!!! :pinkiehappy: enjoy everypony :pinkiesad2:

also um :fluttercry: