Luna turns into a Filly

by isabella7890

Rating: teen
Tags: Main 6, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Alternate Universe, Sad, Princess Luna, Comedy, Suicide / Self Harm, Random, Princess Celestia
Length: 2211

An alternate ending to Luna eclipsed, where Twilight fails to help Luna. She stumbles into the forest and finds a weird object.

An alternate universe, where Twilight never figures out how to help Luna. Luna bans Nightmare Night forever and goes back to Canterlot, feeling dejected. She decides to go to the Everfree Forest where she finds a weird object, and the next time Celestia sees her, she's not a mare anymore.

Published 2019-09-16 10:40:02 UTC
Last updated 2019-10-30 19:46:34 UTC

Chapter 1

It was a gloomy night. The stars and moon were dim and hidden behind clouds. The ponies of Ponyville were still recovering from what a disaster of a Nightmare Night it was.

Twilight was mainly upset. A bit mad at herself for letting Luna run away before she could help her and mad at her friends, mainly Pinkie Pie for not giving Luna a chance when they were the people who reformed her in the first place. She threw away her Starswirl costume, as she wouldn't need it if there was no Nightmare Night anymore. She sighed and continued removing all the Nightmare Night decorations

While this was going on, the two sisters were having dinner in their castle. Luna was moodily playing with her food, replaying the events of what happened in her mind and what she could've done to not make this night such a disaster.

She decided to break the silence and said "Hey Tia, do you think they'll ever love me?". Celestia was caught off guard. She didn't want to lie to her sister, but she didn't want to make her disheartened either.

"Of course they will Luna, they just have to get used to change. It's been a thousand years since anypony saw you" Celestia replied.

"They made me into a story to scare foals, Celestia. They made a whole festival about how scary I am."

"Was. Scary I was. You're not scary anymore and I'm pretty sure they'll grow to love you, Luna. They'll see how you've changed for the better." Celestia assured her with a soft smile. Luna gave her a half-smile back.

Maybe if I ever want to change I should go to the first place I ruined. She thought. Luna got up from her seat and started walking towards the door. "Where are you going?"

"To the Everfree Forest to get some fresh air," Luna said. To this Celestia raised an eyebrow.

"You could just go to the gardens instead of the Everfree Forest. The garden is much safer than the forest."

"I wanna relive the past tonight," Luna replied with a bitter chuckle. "Maybe visit the place I swore to protect, destroyed by myself."

"You didn't destroy it, Luna. I did. I ignored your wishes to be noticed and I-" Celestia began but was cut off by Luna.

"We both know exactly who was responsible for it Celestia." Luna's horn started glowing. "I'll be back in a few hours." And just like that, she teleported. Celestia sighed and continued eating. Celestia knew it was her fault, it didn't take a brilliant pony to figure that out. I messed up so much that day...

Thousand years ago...
Celestia's pov

Luna, we can talk about this." Celestia, the goddess of the day, trying to comfort my younger, weaker sister. The mare was crying in her chamber after she got shunned away by the ponies on her birthday. The first birthday I remembered. I usually was to busy to care, but then I would look like a terrible pony, so here I was, in the young mare's chamber.

"You didn't want to talk about it before! Face it, Celestia, you only care about yourself and NOPONY ELSE!" My bratty sister shouted pointing at me while using her other hoof to wipe her tears away.

"Luna, I have been caring for you since our parents' death." Yet Luna still didn't care. Didn't she see how much work I did every day? And today I even abandoned I work to comfort my sister. Of course, I cared!

"Ignoring me every day and yelling at me the one day I spoke up about this, yeah sure, that's caring." I had more useful things to do than cater to my irrelevant sister all day. But I didn't say that. Instead, I said-

Luna, the ponies need sleep, and your night provides it." That was true.

Well, that's only because you and your sun take up 14 hours while my night only takes 10!" Because the ponies need the Sun more!

"The ponies need sunlight more than night! And if you want we could take a week, a celebration when your night shines for 12 hours, and so does my Sun, is that settled?" She groaned inside. She was being so generous today

Why just one week? Why not every day, it seems much more balanced then what you are doing now." Hah, balanced?

"More balanced? It will break the balance we've been trying to keep for so long. The Sun gives light to ponies, helps plants to grow and everypony would die without it. Now, what does the moon or night do? Nothing, but helping ponies sleep and looking pretty. That's why the Sun gets more time to shine." I could be the element of honesty at this point. I hoped Luna would understand, but as always she didn't. That naive foal shouted-

WHAT BALANCE!? Everypony adores you. They worship the very ground you step on. When it's your birthday, it's a whole celebration! And when it's mine, nobody even remembers. Not even you." Tears start pouring out her eyes. "What's wrong with me that they just can't love? Am I not good enough? And is the night I work on for so long, making sure every star is perfectly aligned in a constellation, disappointing compared to your day?" Night and Day are both equal, I was just saying the day is a bit more important. But I can't just say that it'll make her madder.

"Of course not, my little sister. Everypony adores you and they will continue to." She spread her wings and went closer to her sister to hug her. but the whiny foal pushes her out the door using her magic.

"Nopony does Celestia! You don't even mean it!" The mare was crying again and now she was getting on my nerves.

"Well, maybe if you stopped being so whiny and greedy THE PONIES WILL LOVE YOU!" She was shocked for a minute. Then she opened her mouth to say something but I interrupted her. "You are always complaining about this! Why not just go out and try to make some friends instead?!

"I can't! You know I tried once, but they only befriended me to talk to YOU!" Luna shouted back. I can't blame the ponies. I am more interesting than Luna, but still.

"That's because you've not done anything to be congratulating or admiring yet and once-"

"NOT ADMIRING? I single-handedly defeated Sombra when you fainted after he attacked you! And you know what thanks I got? NOTHING! Because anything I do right is automatically handed to you because 'I can't do anything right', and any mistake YOU make, I AM BLAMED FOR because only the naive stupid one could do something like that, not the older more AMAZING ruler everyone LOVES!" Luna cried out. I tried to say something but she continued, "I feel like I am invisible to the world, neglected by all the ponies I oh so terribly desire to be loved by. All because you become the wall in front of me that prevents ponies to see me, just so you can get all the attention FOR YOURSELF!"

I was shocked. I felt awful, guilt washing over me. Did that happen? Looking at her now, I didn't see the young foal I always saw. Instead, a mature, diligent mare, who was never given her dues. God, I am such a monster to be one of the largest barriers keeping her from reaching her full potential. I have to apologize at least, to be a good sister for once.

"Luna I.. didn't know. I was so busy and this evening was no different. I didn't notice-" I was interrupted by Luna's bitter laugh.

"Oh, god I am sorry your highness. I hope I didn't ruin your evening with my presence." She said with a sarcastic smile on her face.

"Luna please I-" I tried to reason with her but to no avail. She looked at me with hatred.

"I HATE YOU" Was the last thing I heard before she shut the doors on my face. I sighed and walked away. Till I heard a shout from her bedroom. I wanted to go check on her, maybe even try to apologize again but I think she had had enough of me so I decided to let her be. Big mistake.

Author's Note

I think it came out better than last time. I paced it a bit slowly this time because the first fic was so fast-paced, you didn't even know what was happening most of the time. Also, I think Celestia wasn't always so nice,calm and collected. My headcanon is that Celestia used to only act nice in front of other ponies and that she thought that she did so much work while Luna was just sitting around doing nothing and still whining for no reason. She got some sense knocked into her by the elements and her guilt piling on her during Luna's banishment.

Anyway, criticism is welcome as I know I'm still not the best writer. :twilightsheepish:

Chapter 2

Luna felt the cool night wind on her cheek as she teleported into The Everfree Forest. She walked through the Everfree Forest. It had been a thousand years since she walked here. The forest had changed for the worse since she left. Nopony had taken care of the forest since her banishment. As a result, it was chaotic and in a state of disarray. It was dense and had an enchanting and bewitching atmosphere. There were unkept bushes that were outgrown and many vines were hanging from the huge trees, covered with moss and didn't allow the Sun's ray from reaching the forest ground. In the bushes, she could see some animal's glowing eyes and eagles sitting on trees watching her with intrigued and fiery eyes. Luna sighed and sat down under a big tree.

She was annoyed. Why wouldn't she be? The ponies made her into a monster. A monster who ate children, a monster who was just a story to scare children just like the "Mare With No Head" story. But it was reasonable. She was technically a monster who wanted to kill her sister. She didn't even know what to do AFTER killing Celestia. Even if she found a way to make life function without the sun, that wouldn't make the ponies love her. They would notice her sure, but they would hate her. Hate her for killing their beloved and kind ruler. Heck, even canceling Nightmare Night was stupid.

"Wow Luna, your SUCH a genius. Canceling one of the ponies' favorite festival was going to make them love you. But even if I didn't, it wouldn't make a difference. They would still hate me. Be scared of me. Because I'm just a monster. A fiend. A freak. I was the villain of the story, I could never win. She always won. She was the golden child, the perfect ruler a heroic angel from heaven. Who would love me over her? Who would stay up to stare at my night, when you had her morning to look forward to? Celestia, my dear sister, why did you ever forgive me when I deserved a fate crueler than death?" She began sobbing. Why did she feel so horrible? Hot tears kept pouring out her eyes. She curled up on herself and let out a wail.

The animals noticed her sobbing. One rabbit cautiously made its way towards her. It slowly sniffed her and then nuzzled her. Luna noticed the rabbit. She looked down on it as it was trying to pry her hooves open to sit on her lap. She sighed and hugged it. It made her feel a bit better. Other animals eventually started piling up around her, all motivated to make her feel better and it did. She pushed away all her dark thoughts and horrible feelings and just closed her eyes. She enjoyed the warmth and made her feel wanted. When she opened her eyes she noticed something green glowing deeper into the forest. Her curiosity caused her to break away from the hug and gallop towards the object.

It was a green and glowing crystal. She used her magic to pick it when suddenly her blue magic turned green. The crystal floated up into the air and shot a green beam at her. She was suddenly surrounded by green magic that didn't let her move
and before she could even think of anything her mind went blank and her eyes rolled back into her head.

The animals ran in the same direction towards Fluttershy's house.

Author's Note

This is kind of a vent chapter so sorry if the paragraphs were too long of something. I just had a lot to say.:twilightsheepish:

I really hope that this fic will be better and make more sense than its predecessor. I will be cutting the chase to find Luna because it seemed pointless. Twilight won't just be reading the book of exposition this time so she won't know what the frak happened to Luna when she disappears.

This chapter was small but the next one would be bigger