Shining Armor expected to find a crystal mare – or more than one – waiting for him in his bedroom when he got out of the shower. He was partially right.

There were three crystal mares on his bed: one pink, one green, and one blue. But they certainly weren't waiting for him. All three of them were as tangled as his bedsheets, kissing and stroking each other. Two of them rubbed their pussies together while making out with each other, while the third plunged her tongue in between the two and rubbed herself against whatever limb happened to find its way between her legs.

For a long moment, he just stood in the doorway and stared, his mouth hanging open and his cock springing back up to full readiness after wilting in the heat of the shower. The three of them were so into each other, they didn't notice him at all.

But they were putting on quite the show nonetheless. As he watched, the pink mare held the pale blue one tightly against herself, crying out and quivering. Her pussy winked and squirted against the blue mare's pussy and the green mare's tongue, soaking them both. She shuddered, her whole body convulsing, until she flopped limply backward, flat down against the big bed.

The way she fell left her belly-up, her face pointed right at the door.

Their eyes met. Neither of them moved. He just stared down into her blue crystal eyes, and she just panted for breath, her body heaving and her legs twitching. The two of them stayed locked right where they were, neither able to make the first move. To Shining Armor, it suddenly felt as if he was intruding, as if he shouldn't have been there after all, even though it was his own bed they were in. He could only wonder what she was thinking. Maybe her mind was just too blown from the recent orgasm to think anything at all.

He wasn't sure how much time passed that way. It seemed like only a few seconds, though he knew it must have been longer than that.

Finally, though, one of the others – the green mare – took a moment away from sucking on the blue one's teats, just to take a breath, by the looks of it. But she glanced down at the pink mare for a moment, held a moment longer, then looked up to see what the pink mare was staring at.

She gasped. “He's here!”

The blue mare snapped her head around to look at him as well. It was even more unnerving with all three of them staring at him. He felt more than ever that he was intruding on them and should leave. He even took a step backward.

But then the blue mare smiled and waved him over. “Well come on, don't just stand there!”

Shining Armor tentatively smiled back and slowly approached them. As he did, the three of them disentangled themselves and sat in a row on the edge of the bed. He could only imagine the interesting stains they'd be leaving on the sheets.

He stopped a couple paces away from the three of them, and he ventured a faint smile in return. They were really cute, and younger than he'd thought at first. Barely more than teenagers.

And yet ... they didn't say anything. Were they waiting for him to make the first move, even though they'd been making plenty of moves with each other before he'd arrived?

“Hi,” he began lamely. “Um... I don't really think I've seen you girls around the palace before. Are you new to the staff?”

“Oh, we're not in the palace staff,” the pink one said.

“We petitioned the Princess of Love a few weeks ago,” the green one added.

He glanced back and forth between the three of them. “And ... what did you petition her for?”

“You,” the blue one said, getting up from the bed and sauntering over to him. “The three of us are very happy in our triad relationship with each other, but we've decided that it's time. We need something that none of us have.”

The pieces were beginning to come together, and he already had a good idea of what the three of them were missing ... but if they were so happy with just the three of them, why did they want it so much? “And that would be...?”

“A cock,” the green one said, coming up to him as well.

The pink one got up and joined the other two. “More specifically, your cum.”

The blue one grinned. “This is Beryl Roll.” She kissed the pink one on the cheek. “And this is Jade Dreams.” She kissed the green one. “And I'm Celestine.” She darted in and kissed him on the nose, pulling back before he could reciprocate. “All three of us have decided that we're ready for a baby, and we want you to put one inside each one of us.”

He choked a bit when he heard that. “You want... All three? Like, really pregnant?”

“Pretty eloquent, isn't he?” the Jade observed.

Beryl licked her pink lips. “I hope he's better with his cock than his words.”

“I'm... I'm flattered, ladies.” Really, he was sweating a little, and a bit intimidated by the idea that he might impregnate three mares tonight. The more mares, in addition to the possibility that he'd already knocked up Amber. His cock wasn't intimidated, though. It raged harder than ever. And yet, he somehow felt the need to stall. “But, um... You can't possibly be sure that all three of you will get pregnant on the first try ... or even that any of you will get pregnant on the first try. Right?”

Celestine grinned at him. Her smile was soothing, but also had undertones of predatory intent. “Oh, we can be sure. The other part of our request to the Princess was that she cast a fertility spell on all three of us – it should be at its peak effectiveness tonight.” She took a small step toward him. “It's”— another step —“a”— another step —“sure”— she was right up against him —“thing.”

He felt the heat of her, the softness of her crystal fur against his chest. Celestine glanced at her two lovers, giving each of them a small nod.

The other two mares turned around, presenting him with their cute little rumps, upturned tails, and madly winking pussies. Celestine kissed him, full on the lips this time. When she separated from him, she looked him right in the eyes. “Which one of my marefriends are you going to pump a foal into first?”

His brain was going off alike all the slot machines in Las Pegasus jackpotting at once. The two pretty rumps to either side of Celestine – one pink and one green – filled his whole vision. His eyes must have been pointing in opposite directions like the messenger pegasus he'd met in the audience chamber, because he could barely see anything but those lovely round ass cheeks, and Celestine didn't seem to register in his vision at all. There was no way he could make a choice. He wanted both of them first, both of them now ... and yet, he only had one cock.

In the end, it was probably their color that decided him. He couldn't have articulated why he was choosing which in the moment, but Beryl's pink coat was only a little lighter than Cadance's. Whether it was simply the allure of familiarity after so many unfamiliar mares or whether it was out of some sentimental longing for his wife, he lunged to the left and heaved his chest up onto Beryl's rump.

It was a good thing they'd already gotten each other so worked up and ready, because he couldn’t have held himself back if he tried. Beryl let out a little squeak as his thick tip pressed its way between her dripping-wet pussy lips. That squeak gave way to a gasp as the rest of his shaft followed it in a single massive thrust that suddenly filled her to the brim.

“Oh wow,” Celestine murmured. “I can see it inside her. Look, Jade, he's already flaring!”

Both of the other mares came in close, staring at their lover's body, at his cock inside her. Shining Armor, for his part, barely noticed. All that mattered was the hot and sweet insides of a willing mare gripping him, her pussy winking around his base and her inner walls stretched tight around his girth. He gave her strained little thrusts, barely moving an inch as he struggled to go in, in, in ... never out. Ever since that little accident with Amber, all he'd been able to think about was...

With a groan through his clenched teeth, Shining Armor came inside Beryl. His flared tip sealed against her womb, and he clenched her tight between his forehooves as streams of cum surged into her.

“Look! Look!” Jade said, her hooves tight around Celestine. “It's happening! I can see his cum making her pregnant!” Celestine just stared and smiled warmly.

Pulse after pulse came, filling Beryl up one splash at a time until she could hold no more. The wave of white surged back up along Shining Armor's cock and began leaking out around his base. Beryl's pussy winked open through the sticky mess, causing thick drops to fall to the floor.

Only then was he finally done. Breathing heavily, he let himself slide back away from Beryl's rump. His softening cock flopped out of her pussy, trailing a wide strand of white for a moment as his excess spilled out of her. He fell unceremoniously to the floor, panting.

“I can feel it,” Beryl said, looking over her own shoulder at the white mass slowly crystallizing inside of her. “It's so warm, and... and... splooshy inside.”

Celestine still stared at the white filling in her marefriend's womb, but Jade looked over at Shining Armor. “The way other mares go on about it, I thought stallions were supposed to last longer than that, though...”

That finally turned Celestine's attention away from Beryl's newly impregnated body. She chuckled softly. “They usually do. But what he lacks in staying power, he makes up with in volume. He's the perfect stallion for us. That is, of course, if he has the kind of stamina the Princess promised he would.” She looked down at his now-soft cock with a critical eye.

“Just need a little breather,” Shining Armor panted. “And I was a bit worked up. The next time I'll last longer.”

Celestine glanced over at her two lovers. Beryl was lying on the floor and rubbing her belly lovingly; she'd be of no help at the moment. But Jade returned her glance. Celestine grinned widely. “What do you say we speed things along a little bit?”

Jade looked back down at him. “How?”

“Oh you two...” Celestine shook her head. “How can you be so good with mares and still know nothing about stallions? Just follow my lead.”

Without pausing to ask for Shining Armor's permission, Celestine pounced on him. She intercepted his cock along its retreat into his sheath, slathering it with her tongue and licking up the mixture of Beryl's juices and cum all along his shaft. Jade joined her a moment later, more slowly and tentatively, starting with hesitant little licks even as Celestine slurped the sloppy head of his cock into her mouth.

He shuddered as he felt – and saw – Celestine forcibly swallowing his cock down her throat. Even though it was reversing course and growing again, it wasn't stiff enough yet to push into her on its own. Instead, she gulped it down, pulling more of his length back out of his sheath as she worked it down her throat. Soon, Celestine had taken every available inch of his shaft and was busily drawing the rest out of his sheath. But Jade wasn't left with nothing – Celestine pushed her down to Shining Armor's balls, where she took the hint easily enough. Jade kissed and nuzzled his balls affectionately, as if thanking them for filling her marefriend.

The heavenly feeling of a two-mare blowjob was already having its effect on him. His cock rapidly came back to hardness ... but what really made it snap to attention was the way Beryl looked over her withers at him. That warm glow in her eyes, that darker-pink blush on her cheeks. Now that was the face of a mare who'd just had a new life planted inside her, and knew it.

His restored cock was finally too much for Celestine to handle. She pulled herself off of him, coughing and gasping, a thick trail of spit hanging down and dripping onto Jade's face. “You take him next,” Celestine croaked. “I need a minute.”

Jade had her mouth most of the way around one of Shining Armor's balls; she looked at him with undisguised glee.

The two of them couldn't get in position fast enough to suit each other. Jade spun around, spreading her hind legs apart a little and crouching her font legs until her face almost touched the ground. Her tail flipped up and her pussy winked out proudly and desperately. Shining Armor stumbled up and onto her back without pausing even for a moment.

This time, though, he wasn't in quite such a hurry. He still planted his cock against this mare's pussy as eagerly as ever, but instead of ramming it quickly inside, he slid it slow and easy. Jade's pussy lips parted effortlessly, and her inner walls rippled over his shaft as it glided smoothly into her. Jade let out slight, shuddering breaths as his cock filled her just as it had her marefriend ... except that at this slower pace, both of them could feel every detail. She gave a tiny gasp when his medial ring entered her; he moaned slightly when his crotch pressed up against her upturned tail, his entire length smothered in her love-slick warmth.

Once he started moving again, though, he didn't go quite so slowly, but he did give her much longer, fuller thrusts than what he'd done with Beryl. The entire length of his cock slid across the entire depth of her pussy, from her winking lips to the entrance of her fertile and waiting womb.

Celestine, now recovered, came up in front of Jade. The two of them looked at each other a moment, both still except for the little back-and-forth jerks Jade went through every time Shining Armor's cock hilted inside her. Celestine grinned at her marefriend. Jade gave a strained, yet still lustful, smile back.

When the two mares kissed, Shining Armor could instantly feel it in the way Jade's pussy tightened around him. Through the back of Jade's head, he could see the way the two mares' tongues writhed against one another, dancing out Jade's pleasure and Celestine's anticipation.

Then Beryl came back into the fray as well. She simply pulled herself across the floor, not bothering to stand up as she made her way underneath Jade's body. If Shining Armor looked down, he could see Beryl straining her neck up and beginning to suckle at Jade's teats – first one, then the other.

That was all Jade could take. With a squeaky little cry, she came. Her pussy clenched down hard around Shining Armor's shaft, all but locking him in place as her body shook and her juices poured down her inner thighs and dribbled over Beryl's face.

That was as much as Shining Armor could take as well. Almost taking him by surprise with how quickly it happened, his tip flared and erupted with a fountain of white inside her. Every throb of his cock triggered another squeeze and another tiny, helpless “Mmn!” from Jade. His cum poured into her ready womb, easily filling her to the brim. Even though there wasn't enough to overflow and leak out this time, it would be more than enough – far more than enough – to ensure that she got pregnant.

He was left panting once more, this time still on the mare's back, until Jade came back to herself enough to step out from under him. He slid his chest down over her rump as she stepped away ... and his cock slipped out of her pussy just in time to dump a sticky white shower on Beryl's face still below.

Shining Armor backed away hastily, ready to apologize profusely ... but the words died on his lips when he saw Beryl licking hers. She smiled up at him, a huge streak of white splattered from her forelock to her muzzle, then immediately went to Jade.

Celestine did as well, and as the two mares fussed over their newly impregnated marefriend, Shining Armor stumbled over to the edge of the bed and sat down. This should have been at the beginning of these three days ... maybe then he'd have the stamina to take all three without a struggle. But after all he'd already been through in the last few days, he honestly wasn’t sure if he'd be able to manage it.

Before he'd even really caught his breath, the three mares turned their attention back to him.

They came to him side by side, Celestine in the middle, Beryl on his left, and Jade on his right. The latter two had very satisfied-looking grins, but Celestine didn't smile up at him. Her eyes were entirely focused on his cock – now limply lying against his right thigh – and her lips were set in a thin, determined line.

He could already tell that not performing wasn't an option. Celestine was going to get what she'd come for, one way or another.

None of them needed instructions about what to do this time. All three of them went straight for his cock. Well, actually, Jade took the tip of his cock into her mouth, since she was the closest to that side. Celestine wrapped her lips almost all the way around his shaft and started sliding her mouth up and down his length. And Beryl – her face still messy – was left with just his balls, but she went at them even more eagerly than the other two took his cock. It was as if she couldn't get enough of their smooth, heavy roudnesses rolling over her face. The leftover cum on her muzzle smeared over each of them.

Jade wasn’t as skilled as Celestine when it came to sucking his length into her mouth. Every time she tried to swallow it deeper, it slipped back out again. Not that Shining Armor was going to complain about that, though. The constant sliding in and out felt wonderful, and Celestine was more than making up for any part of his length Jade couldn't get to. The two of them worked beautifully in synchrony with each other, so much so that if he'd closed his eyes, he could have imagined it was just one fantastically skilled mare on his cock.

Not that he would close his eyes, though. More than a little bit of the pleasure came from seeing the three mares like this. Two mouthing his cock, and the third lovingly nuzzling his balls. All three tails held high above their wiggling rumps, swishing back and forth as they spread mare-in-heat scent throughout the whole room. And Celestine's deep green eyes stared up at him from between his legs and glimmered with what her mouth was too full to say: 'When is it going to be my turn?'

That would come sooner than he would have thought possible. His cock was surprising even him with how quickly it was recovering. Not up to full hardness yet, of course, but enough that Jade had to squirm her way higher between his leg and Celestine's body, and she was able to force more of him into her mouth.

Celestine herself didn't seem to notice the change ... until her lips touched Jade's. That was when she let the side of his shaft slip wetly out of her mouth and looked up at him. “Girls,” she said, “I think he's ready.” Without waiting for a response, she climbed up his legs and body, squeezing her way between and over the other two mares.

Jade obligingly pulled herself off of his cock, the tip popping free with a little spatter that she took no mind of. Instead, she held his shaft with her hooves, helping him get lined up as Celestine straddled him and lowered her pussy into position.

Celestine gasped slightly when she felt it against her pussy. She winked, smearing her juices onto his broad tip. Then she leaned down and whispered into his ear, “I hope you saved plenty for me. I can't wait to see a little crystal foal swelling my belly. Are you ready to put one inside me?”

He nodded dumbly.

With a grin, Celestine lowered herself... But his cock didn't penetrate – it bent to the side, flopping sideways a little.

“Hey,” Jade said, looking down at Beryl. “Can you help me out with this?”

With four crystal hooves holding his cock up now, the next attempt fared far better. Jade and Beryl helped each other stuff Shining Armor's cock into their marefriend's pussy, and once his tip slipped into her, it was much easier going. They only guided his length along as it slid inside Celestine's crystal body.

Shining Armor watched it the whole way. Now that it wasn't at full hardness, he could see the way the contours of this mare's body nudged and squeezed his cock along the way – the little tightness around her entrance, the slight ripples deeper in, and the soft warmth of her roomier inner depths, right up against her womb.

The other two mares let go of him as the entirety of his length found its way into Celestine's pussy, but Celestine wasn't done with them yet. She looked over her shoulder at the two of them. “I want to make sure he gives me just as much as he gave Beryl – take care of his balls, would you?”

She didn't have to ask twice. A moment later, Shining Armor felt two mouths, one on each of his balls. The tingling touch of their lips and the smooth caresses of their tongues sent shivers up his spine and made his cock pulse harder inside Celestine. If he looked through Celestine's body, past his own cock inside her, he could dimly see the two of them down there. Both of them looked up through their marefriend at him, their eyes full of anticipation.

All Shining Armor could do was to hold his hooves around Celestine's shapely waist and enjoy the seemingly impossible softness of her transparent body. She rocked her hips back and forth in a way that kept his cock moving inside her but didn't let it out of her pussy for even a moment ... nor did it jar him up and down in a way that would disturb the other two mares.

Celestine moaned softly and smiled down at him as his cock once again returned to full hardness. She could no doubt feel it swelling inside her and feel its occasional twitches as he responded to the teasing pleasure of her marefriends' mouths on his balls.

“That's right,” Celestine said. At first he thought she was talking to him, until she added, “Keep licking him, girls. Tease me out the biggest orgasm you've ever seen.”

Shining Armor shuddered as all three mares continued on, as Celestine's rocking grew more and more insistent, yet never so vigorous as to disturb the two mares below her.

His grip grew more insistent as well, holding the pale blue mare tighter and tighter, pressing her down against his cock as she kept rolling her hips back and forth on him. It was perfect. Every inch, from his tip to his balls, was swimming in the wet, eager warmth of mares. Even after blowing two loads already, he knew he wasn't going to last much longer than this.

Celestine must have felt his tip flaring inside her, because she leaned down to his ear again. It wasn't a whisper this time, though, more of a breathlessly moaned command: “Do it! Give me every drop you've got! Enough for a hundred foals!”

Shining Armor tilted his head back, his eyes closed and his body trembling. He was so close! If only ... if only...

“Do it for Princess Cadance,” Celestine whispered.

He let out a huge, wordless moan, pressing Celestine's body so tightly against his lap that he risked leaving bruises. But Celestine didn't mind; she moaned right along with him, right next to his ear.

And then it came. An enormous burst of cum streamed up out of his cock, filling Celestine to the brim in just the first pulse. He stared down at her body, and he wouldn’t have believed it if he didn't see it happening inside her. Even the first long stream of it was so huge that the trailing end of it left cum dripping from where Celestine's pussy lips wrapped so tightly around his base.

White droplets spattered both of the other mares as more and more pulses of cum came, spewing out around the base of his cock since there was no room left inside Celestine to fill. On and on it went, and no matter how messy their faces became, the other two mares never stopped teasing his balls. Their tongues licked his own warm cum off of them even as they coaxed out more.

Celestine was just as frozen in place as Shining Armor. All four legs trembling, she held herself solidly in place as she was filled, overfilled, and absolutely, undeniably impregnated.

Even the last few spurts – the smallest – would have been enough for a stallion to be proud of under normal circumstances. They joined the rest and swirled inside Celestine's womb, then on their way to join the rest as it squeezed out of her pussy and sprayed onto the other two mares.

When Celestine finally lifted herself off of Shining Armor's rapidly wilting cock, though, the sloshing pool of white inside her was quite obvious. No matter how much had leaked from her after she'd been unable to contain it, she'd still gotten plenty of it inside her, enough for all the foals she could ask for. Even though Shining Armor knew it was entirely up to the mare's body how many foals she'd get from this, he couldn't help but think that he must have just given her twins or more.

She gracelessly fumbled her way back to stand on the floor, and her two marefriends followed her. “Thank you,” Celestine said, rubbing her belly where the load of cum was slowly turning as transparent as the rest of her body. She turned to leave, as did the others.

All Shining Armor could do was stare at the three mares. Two of them had their faces plastered white with his cum, and all three were dripping white from under their tails ... and all they had to say was 'Thank you'?

He sighed.

Not that he had any reason to complain. How many stallions out there would kill for a chance like this? Still, he couldn't help feeling a slight longing on the inside. Some part of him wanted more than just physical lust with these three mares who would soon be the mothers of his children. He wondered if he'd ever see them again at all. They would at least tell him if the fertility spell had really worked ... wouldn’t they?

He cast himself down on the bed, scooting over to what was usually Cadance's side in order to avoid the wet messes left behind from him and the three mares. The bed was cold and lonely, and more than ever, he missed having Cadance there with him. Cadance wouldn't have walked out of the room right after letting him impregnate her.

Just as he sighed again and closed his eyes, there was a knock at the door.

Author's Note

This story is brought to you thanks in part to my Patreon supporters! They're invaluable for keeping me focused and motivated to write with the power of the deadline.

If you'd like to help keep me writing, and even decide which stories I write next, please check out my Patreon page.