Stuck in a Love Pentagon

by AlicornSpirit21

Part 1/5: Starlight's Secret

Load Full StoryNext Chapter

Spike is currently sleeping in Twilight's bed in her house. Being an adult for a week now and growing mentally and physically, Twilight gave him a deal to let him use her bed until she gets back and orders a new one. She also let him have the whole week off since he was and adult now. She didn’t want to treat him like a kid anymore, mostly now that he was taller than her. It was already 10am, and Spike decided it was time to start his day. He sits up in bed, stretching and yawning while trying fully awaken himself. Opening his eyes, he looks around, then freezes when seeing Twilight wrapped in a towel and water dripping off of her as she searches for clothes in her closet. The towel drops, revealing her plump hind quarters and the sides of her DD size breasts. Spike tongue slips from him mouth while staring a Twilight.

“Damn.” He whispers to himself. Twilight grinned and peeked back at him while placing on her bra.

“Like what you see?” Hearing her, he looks away as his cheeks flush pink. After placing on her panties, she turns back. “You can’t hide it Spike. Besides, you’re an adult. There isn’t a problem with staring at attractive mares.” She looks down at the blankets covering his lower body, seeing a bulge. “Especially if it excites you that much-”

“Stop it Twilight!” Spike turned his face away and trying covering his erection by turning the lower half of his body. Twilight started chuckling while placing in the rest of her clothing. “It’s not funny. You know that was on purpose to tease me like that. Doesn’t privacy mean anything to you?”

“If I’m not mistaken, your tongue was hanging from your mouth and you whispered damn. Plus you’re the one with the boner. Also you’re sleeping in my room, so I can come in whenever I want.” Twilight finished placing on her jeans and T-Shirt, walking over to Spike and hugging him. “But that doesn’t mean I’m gonna treat you like a kid anymore. I’m sorry for teasing you. I just wanted to see how my number 1 assistant is enjoying being an adult with a little wake up call.” Spike smiles, feeling her twitch from his claws gripping her flank. “Excited I see?”

“Very.” He whispers in her ear as his tongue slides across her neck, making her shiver in pleasure. She lets out a slight moan, then removes her arms from him, gathering her purse, sunglasses, and a book. “Going somewhere so soon?”

“As much as I like to have fun with you Spike, The princesses and I are heading away for a week to Nippone to help with education, supplies and magic. I’d rather not look like a complete mess before I leave. Besides you used your freebee 2 days ago. We're only dating until you find someone remember?”

“Oh, yeah, part time.” Spike frowned at the statement. It’s been months of trying to find someone, but with no success. Dates were possible, but long term relationships weren’t apart of the question. He’s tried going out with countless ponies he labeled as attractive. Carrot Top, Colgate, Rose Blossom, even Derpy Hooves. He’s even tried ponies he thought his friends were close to. Moondancer, Spitfire, out of all ponies Trixie, even Gilda. Some older mares he gave as an option as well. Ms. Harshwhinny, Mayor Mare, Miss Cheerilee…he stopped with older mares after that when Big Mac came to visit while Spike was on a personally helping Miss Cheerilee. She asked him earlier that day to help relieve some stress and Mac was going on a trip to Appleloosa. Unfortunately, that time was cut short when Mac came by because he forgot his jacket which had his train bits inside. To briefly explain the incident in one sentence, Spike hid with Zecora for 3 weeks straight and personally dug himself a grave until Mac came to his senses and calmed down enough that he, Mac and Cheerilee were able to talk and sort it out. Spike even tried dating Queen Chrysalis. She accepted, but he realized he wasn’t going to last long since her Changelings feed off of love, and since he would be the only one to provide it for the multiple Changelings she had, he knew he’d be non-responsive after the first week if he was lucky enough to survive that long. Twilight broke his train of thought by giving him a quick kiss.

“Don’t be too rough on yourself about it. You’ll find someone. Who knows? I could come back and some lucky mare could be pregnant with your child.” Spike chuckled shaking his head. “Hey, it could happen. Last thing. The library is going to be open while I’m gone and I know you don’t want to be bothered by ponies around here. You can stay in the castle till I get back. I’ll call to check in on you and make sure you’re alright.”

“Alright.” Twilight walks out of the room closing the door. Spike decides to lay back down, closing his eyes to get some more relaxation now that he’s alone, but that’s quickly interrupted by hearing the front door open and twilight calling back to him.

“Get dressed Spike! You have work to do!” He opens his eyes in irritation when hearing the door close.

“(Fine mom).” He slowly got up, still trying to fully be awake and prepared before he goes to the castle for 2 weeks. After taking a shower and getting dressed, he packed a small duffle bag of clothes and multiple items he wanted to take with him, including Magazines, Comic Books, and a Ponestation 3 given to him of his 16th birthday with a 3 games. Afterwards, he headed downstairs with the bag over his shoulder to find a note on a basket covered in cloth written by Twilight.

“Spike, this is just something the princesses and I put together to help you relax and keep you occupied. Call if there’s an emergency, be good while I’m gone. Twilight.” He smiles, lifting the cloth from the basket and reveling a small bag of 50 bits, a dragon spell book, a Bluetooth speaker, a gaming headset, and a new video game “Call of Ponies: Changeling Warfare.” His eyes immediately lit up when he saw that, knowing that this particular game wasn’t supposed to be out for another 3 weeks. A small note was on it written by Princess Luna, easily able to realize the Crescent Moon Cutie Mark at the top of the note.

“Just for you Spike, I pulled a few strings to get you this early. Don’t tell anypony else about this. Enjoy being an adult. And for Celestia’s sake get a marefriend and have a child already. Auntie Luna can’t wait forever.” A small blush appeared on his cheeks, placing the game back in the basket, taking it and heading out the door, he instantly felt how hot the weather was and was relieved that it wouldn’t be a long trip to get to the castle. Making it in under 5 minutes due to flying, he was already slightly sweaty from the increasing heat. Never the less that still didn’t stop him from seeing multiple friends along the way, waving as he passed. A particular mare by the name of Tree Hugger held up a picture of a poster she drew of Spike guarding a castle with her inside.

Flying by and seeing that, he put thought into a relationship with her, but realizing what she does on her time off which is smoking and how much she does it, he thought still being friends with her would be the best option. Walking inside the castle and heading to Twilight’s room, he stops in the kitchen to grab a bowl of gems, 2 large bags of chips and a 6 canned soda 6 pack.

Closing the door behind him to Twilight's room, he instantly sets up his game system, placing in a double featured game named titled Equestrian Brawlers. The 2 games to select from was “Fighting is Magic” and “Them’s Fightin’ Herds.” While waiting for the game to load, he surrounds himself with the bags of chips and the 6 pack of soda on the floor, not wanting to mess up Twilight's bed while she was gone. In front of him he left the bowl of gems waiting while the games turned on. Looking at both games percentages he was at from completing them, “Them’s Fightin’ Herds” was the highest at 78%. Only 43% of “Fighting is Magic,” he chose that to get farther and to unlock a character Luna didn’t yet. When the game loaded, he pulled out Bluetooth headphones from his bag he packed and tuned out the rest of the world around him.

For 8 hours he stayed to himself playing the game. To be specific, 7 hours of gaming and 1 hour of sleeping. He ended up passing out after a fight that unlocked a new character and rewards to upgrade and buy new characters. The time was now 7pm and he was still continuing to sleep with empty potato chip bags and empty cans of soda surrounding him. His shirt was also taken off due to the heat of the room and being alone. As he stayed asleep, the door opened and in came Starlight Glimmer. Surprised to see Spike by himself with empty bags around him, she looked towards the television and saw in bold letters, “New Character Unlocked,” and was even more surprised to see herself. Looking back at Spike, she saw he was sleeping but had a bulge in his pants during that time. He cheeks flushed pink when seeing it, but she grew a slight grin on her face. With nobody else around, she closed the door and walked over towards him. Originally, she came to talk to Twilight about certain problems and conflicts that have been happening with Trixie and she needed some place to sleep for about a week until it got resolved. But with Spike here all alone and nobody else to bother her, that plan switched. She heard that Spike was looking for a marefriend, and thinking back to when these 2 had their adventures together, they never really had a conflict. Besides that fact when Starlight used her magic and took out Discord for the school incident, he thought that might be a slight problem for guys night out and role playing, but she brought him back later on. Quite frankly, she couldn’t remember that last time or even one incident she was ever upset at him. As she walked over staring at bulge trapped in his pants, she glanced over at his bag and saw a picture slightly pointing out of it. Curious, she used her magic to pull it out, stopping next to Spike, and her expression was instantly filled with love and joy when seeing the hand drawn picture of Starlight in a sparkling blue dress with violet lipstick and her hair let down longer than usual. Also, she was wearing a golden crown and had wings. He drew her as an Alicorn Princess. A tear formed in her eye, realizing that he had feelings for her and she didn’t even know it. Setting the picture down, she went down next his bulge, using her magic to remove his pants. She flinched when she saw it standing, frozen in shock.

“(Oh my stars. He’s a lot bigger than I thought. But what if Twilight…)” She paused though her thinking, then smiled. “(We’ll, I’m sure she won’t be back for a while. But Spike could wake up and tell her, but he has feeling for me. What if that picture isn’t for me, but for Sunburst and he was saving it)?” Multiple questions rushed through her mind of all the possible outcomes of this, but she stopped as a seductive smile grew on her face. Using her magic, she placed in spell that seemed to go inside spikes head. “Perfect, a sleeping spell.” She said with confidence as she used her magic to lift his naked body onto the bed behind him. Getting on the bed and standing over top of him, she looked down at his dick, and with a lusty smile, she positioned herself over him, not hesitating to sit down and let herself be taken by the dragon of her desires. Sure she liked Sunburst, but she didn’t think he liked her in a romantic way anyway ever since the weekend she was supposed to spend time with him and he ended up doing so with Twilight, Trixie and Maud Pie. While thinking about that incident, she slid half of Spike dick out of her and was already sliding back in. Her thoughts were interrupted when hearing a slight grunt from Spike. Frozen in place, she though the spell didn’t work and she woke him up. Gladly she was wrong as Spike lightly snored away. She had a quick thought to herself about their past adventures which gave her an idea. “(I know a lot of times were rough, and Spike liked challenges. Maybe he’ll like this).” Without hesitation, she stated slamming he hips against him with her pace moving faster, hearing more grunts and moans from Spike as she continued her efforts while louder moans and grunts came from her. From how loud it was, she could guarantee if anyone was in the castle downstairs, they would hear thumping from above them, but that didn’t matter much to her even if anyone was downstairs. The more she continued, the more she desired him. Already sweaty from her efforts for 5 minutes straight, she started slowly down, but felt the need to continue with this pace. She wanted Spike to take control, but didn’t want him to wake up. An idea instantly popped in her head. “(I think we could continue the show with a puppeteer).” With her magic, she wrapped and wrist and ankles, leading him behind her. A light giggle came from her as she still saw Spike sleeping away. She bent over in front of him with her flank in the air and spread her legs, reveling her wet dripping folds. Using 2 fingers, she reached under herself ad spread her folds apart. “(Take me you fire breathing beast. I want you to fuck my brains out.” Laying her head down, she blushed from embarrassment from the comment she made earlier, thinking it sounded a little too cheesy. She waited for Spike to enter, then remembered she was in control as the puppet master. With her in control, she could make him do anything. Making him lift his wrist, a loud smack came down on her flank. “Oh Spike!” She yelled. “Hit me harder! Punish this mare! I’ve been very bad!” To this point, she didn’t care who else came in the castle. Even if Twilight walked in, Starlight was willing to risk this. Multiple more loud smacks came across her flanks from one side to the other, leaving red marks of his claws. “Yes Spike! Take me! Own me!” With one last loud smack, she covered mouth from screaming. She felt the throbbing pain of him spanking her, but loved it the more he continued. She positioned himself behind her, purposely having his dick miss her folds and instead rub against them. She starts panting as she uses Spike to tease her, not wanting to wait any longer for him. “Oh Spike! Don’t tease your Alicorn Princess! Just stick it in already!” She exclaimed as she lost control of her magic and released him. Thinking he would drop on the bed being held up due to her magic, he didn’t. In fact, she heard a whisper in her ear from behind.

“As you wish, Princess Starlight.” She froze, opening her mouth to say something, but let out of loud lusty sigh of relief instead as Spike thrusted his dragon hood inside of her farther than she had him before. He started at a quick pace, hearing echoes of loud slaps around the room and the bed shaking. Through heavy breaths, panting and moaning, Starlight managed to barely get a sentence to Spike.

“How-ah! Did you-uh! Wake up from my-ah! Sleeping spellaaaaaahhhhhhh!” With a heavy thrust from Spike, Starlight screamed out, throwing her head up and feeling her head jerked by Spike grabbing and pulling her mane as he continued to thrust harder and harder. “Oh never mind! Just fuck me till I pass out!” As they continued for another 5 minutes, Starlight screamed out to him. “Spike, I’m close!”

“So am I Starlight! Where do you want it?!” Without hesitation, Starlight answered that made Spikes ear twitch.

“Do it inside! Fill me up!” He let her mane go, letting her head drop on the bed.

“But Starlight-” She snapped her head back to look at him in anger.

“Spike, I want this! I don’t care if I get pregnant! Finish inside and don’t you dare pull out or I’ll end you the way I did Discord! Your Princess demands you to CUM INSIDE!” With a quick look of shock remembering what happened to Discord at the school, Spike bit down on the side of her neck and thrusted one last time with a loud grunt. “YEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!” Starlight screamed and her head jerked up as she felt her stomach starting to warm and stretch feeling Spike cum enter inside and continue to fill her. She let herself drop down with Spike still holding her flank up. Releasing his teeth from her neck, he realizes the bulge in her stomach that expanded to far for his comfort and her safety and pulled out, letting the rest of her body drop on the bed as he dropped down next to her. They both continued panting for another minute, before silence fell over the room.

Starlight opened her eyes, looking around to realize it was dark around her with the light shine of the moon. “What time is it?” She asked, slightly lifting her head. When she moved, she realized 2 pairs of arms and claws were holding her around her waist and her back was against something that seemed solid and felt like scales.

“It’s 1:30am.” Starlight craned her neck to see Spike holding her. She opened her mouth to say something, but felt something wet on the sheets and on her legs. Since it was too dark to see, she reached down and swiped with a finger, bringing it up to her nostrils and smelling it. He eyes shot open realizing what it was ad remembering what happened to cause this. Feeling a small in her stomach, she placed her hand on it, realizing the small bulge. Spike released her and sat up, realizing the look of concern on her face. “Sorry Starlight. You didn’t want me to pull out and I was scared of hurting you, but you-” he sentence was stopped by her hand over his mouth. She smiled, removing her hand and turning over to face him.

“I remember Spike.” She said before she pulled him in for a quick but passionate kiss. “And I’m not hurt. I’m grateful. I’ve always wanted a foal, but no pony could satisfy me the way you did.” Spike took the tie to take in what she said as they laid back down together. “And I mean no pony.”

“How do you know if you’re pregnant?”

“Well, with what you loaded inside of me, it would’ve had to do something.” A quick 3 second silence fell between them until Starlight asked a question she didn’t finish from earlier. “Spike, I’m a little confused on something though. The sleeping spell I put on you earlier. Did it not have any effect on you?” Spike chuckled, making Starlight even more confused. “What?”

“I guess you haven’t been studying as much as you tell Twilight. Through Dragon aging, Dragons scales become harder and we become immune to our surroundings. Lava is a big one. Certain metals such as Swords and Axes, no problem. Growing up in the dragon lands is different for immunity, but I grew up around ponies, so certain magic has no effect. That conclusion came the day after I was training with Shining Armor. Being Twilight's assistant, she wanted my help for what she implied as impact for future attacks, but it was really to test the strength of my scales. Multiple attacks with her magic and I didn’t get a scratch. There was a night I had with Princess Luna and after the 4th round I was done, but she wasn’t. I fell asleep. So she didn’t hurt me, she used a sleeping spell to continue her fun. It only lasted about 5 minutes before I took control again. That grunt from earlier should’ve been a good enough signal.” Starlight’s eyes widened in shock and her face flushed red. “Yeah, I heard everything you were saying. Hit me harder. Punish this mare. I’ve been very bad. You’re moaning is adorable by the way.” Starlight smiled, feeling Spike wrap his arms around her and hold her close, snuggling against her. “Did I satisfy my princess?” He said as his dragon hood slipped between her flanks, brushing against her folds. She cooed back at him, rubbing her plot against him and snuggling her back against his scaly chest.

“Very.” A brief 5 second silence fell over them until Starlight craned her neck to ask Spike a question. “Spike, I remember you said dragons live for close to 1000 years and through dragon aging, dragon’s scales become harder and you become immune to certain things of your surroundings. How old are you in dragon years?” Spike stayed silent about the question. “Spike?”

“You’ll laugh.”

“What? Why would I laugh?”

“Because 95% of the mares I’ve dated laughed when they found out my true age as a dragon. They stopped laughing after sex came into play. Nevertheless, it’s embarrassing and I don’t want to say.” Starlight turned over to face him.

“Alright, how about this? If you tell me and I laugh, snicker or even chuckle, you can do what you want with me until the sun rises, and I can’t complain for how rough you are. As long as you don’t hurt our child.” Spike raises an eyebrow, as they both sit up. “As your Alicorn Princess, I promise you. If that’s not enough, I Pinkie promise you. You already know what happens if I break a Pinkie promise right?”

“Let’s not be reminded of past scarring events.” Thinking over it for about 2 seconds, he slowly inhaled and exhaled. “Fine. In pony years, I’m 18. In Dragon years, I’m…” He looked away from Starlight closing his eyes. “I’m 10.” Slightly turning his head back and peeking one eye open, he expected to see her biting her lip to contain her outburst. Instead, she stared at him with a calm and slightly confused expression.

“Okay. And?”

“I thought you would find it weird, funny, or perverted.”

“Spike, the only time I felt those feeling at the same time was when I found out Trixie was a lesbian and has feeling for Prince Blueblood.”

“Ew! Blueblood of all ponies?!”

“I know. That’s weird. Spike as long as you’re an illegal age in Ponyville, I don’t care about your age as a dragon. You should feel comfortable with that. Even if they call you a kid, you have a hell of a way with showing you’re not.” Starlight lay her back on the bed, spreading her legs, and placing the tip on her finger inside her folds. Pulling out with a long and slim string of cum, she placed her finger in her mouth, swirling it around for 3 seconds, then pulling it out with her saliva surrounding it. “But it seems like my little 10-year-old made a mess down there. A responsible thing to do would be to clean it up.” Spikes dick twitched as he licked his lips, crawling over to her. When his face is inches away from her mare hood, he takes a large whiff of it, taking in the smell of her arousal.

“As you wish, my princess.” His snake tongue slithered out of his mouth prepared to enter her, but was stopped by Starlight.

“Spike, can you keep this relationship between us? I really want to do this with you. I just don’t want anypony to find out yet. Especially my father, or Sunburst for the matter cause I know he’ll get jealous."

“Sunburst wouldn’t get jealous. I mean, you guys had sex before, but he’s been actually dating Moondancer secretively.” A mixed emotion of anger and shock came to Starlight when she heard that. “I know this breaks a certain line in the bro code, but he actually used you to get closer to her.” Starlight’s horn lit up a dark red as her anger was building. “Uh, Starlight?” Spike tried to back away, slightly startled of seeing her like this. Feeling something against his back, Starlight used her magic to push Spike forward to face her folds again, but locked her legs around his head so he couldn’t move.

“Pleasure, now, or I go to prison for murder.” Spike instantly went to work from her request, not wanting to make her more upset than she already was.

The castle seemed quiet, only able to hear moans and thumping from upstairs. At least that’s what Ember ignored while eating parts of the walls of the castle. Originally, she was looking for Twilight to find Cadence. Unintentionally, Garble got hit with a spell earlier in the day that came out of the blue. It seemed to be a love spell since Garble has been following Ember all day and using cheesy pick-up lines to get her in bed with him. Lines such as “If I said you had a beautiful body, would you hold it against me?” Ember rolled her eyes trying to forget the constant memories of Garble harassing her. Lucky his friend Fizzle was able to help, but held Garble back as Ember tried to get help. Being early in the morning, she only came in her bra and panties not bothering to get dressed for anypony out this late to see her. Before coming over, she saw a note in the library saying she was gone and if it was an emergency, see Spike at the castle.

“(The little guy doesn’t even know magic. He won’t be any help. Well, I can’t say little since he’s an adult and has matured a lot. And I couldn’t make it to his birthday due to the chaos I had to fix in the dragon lands. He hasn’t talked to me ever since. I wanna make it up to him, but how)?” She thought over multiple possibilities, but nothing seemed to come to mind that would help. She even thought of birthday sex, but erased the idea since she didn’t he found her attractive. An idea popped in her head, thinking about how she treated Spike growing up and how demanding she was. A smile grew across her face as she took flight through the castle. “(Now, I just gotta find where Twilight placed that maid outfit).”

To be continued in Part 2/5: Embracing Ember


Author's Note

For the age in dragon years, I looked up "aging humans to dragons" just to make this seem a little more accurate. Seriously, when did this with horses, Spike was 3

Next Chapter