Professor Haysworth, Ponyville's local robotics expert, built a 'Personal Duplicate' of Liam the Human's wife, Fluttershy, giving her her old life back. She was granted a second chance at life, given the original mare's memories and personality, and, after three days of returning, Fluttershy is having trouble adjusting where she left off.

She has been experiencing flashes of her old life, seeing old memories that took place between being in labour and her own death. Due to this, she has this gut feeling that draws her towards someplace haunting that leaves her questioning her existence. She asks herself, ''What am I?'', and she does this by going to where she was buried.