Button grinned down at his eager girlfriend, then reached up and yanked off Sweetie’s t-shirt, revealing her beautiful white orbs to the world. They were actually dribbling milk a little, probably a side effect of the potions or some unlock he didn’t know about. Or maybe some bonus thing she hadn’t mentioned. Whatever it was, it was fucking hot. He leaned forward to her tits and tasted her milk. It tasted like peppermint.

“Naughty… now I’m topless for the rest of the night…” she rubbed his tits with her hands and he let out a moan. Then, using her magic, she yanked off his boxers, leaving him totally naked.

“Hey! Not… oh…”

She had leaned down to nuzzle his cock, then she licked it from base to head before climbing up to straddle him.

“Remember, this might be your last fuck as a guy… make it good.”

Button rolled his eyes. Like that was—

Sweetie plunged herself down on him. Button groaned, but his hands instantly went to her hips as she started bouncing and he started to thrust.

“Yes!” Sweetie screamed, going wild atop him. “Come on, Button! Ram it deep!”

Button didn’t respond with words, but instead shoved himself upward as he yanked her hips down. She squealed in delight, fondling her tits, dressed only in her tiny microskirt. Button slammed her again and she cried out his name, begging for more. A third time, as her pussy clenched on his cock as an orgasm ran through her body.

“More…” Sweetie mumbled as she started slamming her hips up and down on his cock. “More!”

Button knew that sometimes they danced the line between game streamers and… well, amateur porn, but it almost felt like Sweetie was trying out for the real thing tonight. And she wanted it bad.

She suddenly dropped to squeeze her milky tits against Button’s. “Celestia, I love how much of a big-titted slut you are…” she growled, still bouncing on his thick member.

Button reached up and kissed her hard. Her hands wrapped around his head, fingers tightening in his hair. Then she began to pull. But it didn’t hurt. Instead… she stretched his hair. Or maybe his hair was just growing. It didn’t really matter.

Their bodies moved against one another, sweat-soaked coat against sweat-soaked coat as Sweetie impaled herself again and again. Suddenly, Button felt a wave of magic wash over his face. He let out an involuntary gasp as his muzzle shifted, his eyes changed, then his entire facial structure altered in a strange sensation of weird distortion, like his face was only a mask and somepony had just tweaked it a little, making it softer and better suited for what happened next. And he knew without a doubt that Sweetie was now making out with a pony wearing the face of Joystick, his female self.

Sweetie pulled back and grinned. “Celestia, I forgot how hot and cute you are as a mare.”

Button only groaned, his hips beginning to buck harder and harder.

“You’re close?” Sweetie asked, her eyes hungry with the need to know.

Button gritted his teeth and nodded. Even that felt weird right now…

“Then fill me up!” Sweetie cried as she began to do… things with her pussy. Things that no normal pony could do. But Button had stopped underestimating just how talented Sweetie got when it came to this sort of thing. “Come on, baby! All of it! I want all of it!”

That was the breaking point. Button gave a loud grunt and his cock began to spasm, shooting his seed deep inside of his girlfriend. Sweetie came with him, squealing like a mare in heat. Despite his previous loads, this one was even bigger, lasting a full minute and a half. All the while, all he could do was hold on as pleasure slammed his crotch with such intensity that he could barely breathe. It was like his entire essence as being poured out of him…

Time slipped away, then after what felt like a lifetime, the deluge began to slacken. He gasped as he slumped back on the bed, only to have Sweetie practically leap off of him.

Moments later, Sweetie yanked his legs apart for the camera as he felt the magic swell within his crotch.

“Here we go!” Sweetie cooed as her hands danced along his thighs, hips and front.

The first to go where his two heavy balls. They slowly shrank, smaller and smaller, until they slipped inside of him, leaving only his hardened cock. But as soon as the balls were gone, his cock began to shrink. A few seconds later, the slit started to form. He moaned, his voice far higher than it had been a minute ago. He tried to rub at his vanishing cock, but Sweetie hit him with a light bondage spell, pinning his arms and legs to the bed. He panted and moaned… but she had him completely helpless, unable to do anything but whimper and watch as his masculinity slipped away in the most pleasurable and intense way possible.

He could feel parts rearrange themselves deep within him as his new slit became fully formed, complete with the cute little clitty that Sweetie loved to suck. But still, it took another minute before he felt it.

At the end, the potions always did something inside his body and mind. Something intensely personal and completely irresistible.

That something clicked inside him. A gasp escaped. Eyes widened. Then came the soft, delicate sigh.

“Welcome back, baby,” Sweetie cooed.

And just like that, she couldn’t think of herself as anypony else but Joystick. She knew her given name had been Button Mash. She knew that she’d been male only a few minutes ago. She knew she normally had a cock she loved pounding her girlfriend with. But she also knew that wasn’t who she was right now.

Her name was Joystick, a hot—and somewhat slutty—gamer girl who loved to play with her girlfriend on streams for silly levels of bits. Nothing about this was different from the person she’d been a short time ago. No new memories or crazy things like that. Just a deep-seated knowledge that she was a girl and she liked it.

Actually, Joystick loved it. It was the reason Button had been becoming her at least twice a week for months now. That and Sweetie found it unbearably sexy.

Sweetie undid the bondage spell and flung herself into her girlfriend’s waiting arms. They tumbled and made out as if they were long-parted lovers, ending up with Joystick on top and Sweetie on the bottom.

“I’m glad you back, hun,” Sweetie whispered as she stroked Joystick’s cheek. “Missed you.”

Joystick kissed her on the nose. “I missed you, too… even if I’m still the same person.”

“Nah, you’re way cuter,” Sweetie grinned. “Now, should we go back to our game? There’s still plenty more challenges.”

“You brought back my dildo challenge, didn’t you?”

“Of course not!”

Joystick raised a playful eyebrow.

Sweetie, still only clad in her skirt, slid off the bed. “It’s not yours. It’s for all of us!”

“Anyone ever tell you you’re a bit of a perv?” Joystick giggled. She remained stark naked as she climbed down.

Sweetie beamed at her. “You’re saying that like you don’t want to get fucked by a dildo while saving a town.”

“Nope. Totally want to. You’re still a perv though.”

“I don’t see a problem with that!”

Sweetie bounced over to her seat and slid back into the game.

“Neither do I,” Joystick giggled, then hopped her cute naked ass over to her gaming chair, though she took the time to make sure she had a towel down first. She suspected she would need it.

Then she glanced at Sweetie, already moaning to something in the game.

Yup, she was sure she was going to need it.

Author's Note

Joystick is such a hottie~! Her and Sweetie are great, because Sweetie was totes more tender with her than Button. And they're cutttteeeeeee~!

I like cute. :3

See a mistake? Lemme know by PM, cuties~! <3