That's not how you pay the rent, now more fabulous

by riicky83

Rating: mature
Tags: Porn, Rarity, Fluttershy, Sex, Applejack, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Alternate Universe, Human, Anthro, Original Character
Length: 2116

I have two tenants living in my house, why not make it three?

So it turns out that my Tenants friend has a plan, a plan to bring them back to their world and to stop Discord.
Problem is, she's isn't revealing all of it yet as she is still trying to work out a few potential problems.

We find this out when another of Fluttershy's friends joins us in my world.
Once again I'm gonna let her stay here rent free.

Fluttershy and Applejack will obviously change that no doubt.

Also I happened to come across something that might help my friends.

Published 2019-08-01 01:10:01 UTC
Last updated 2019-08-01 01:10:01 UTC

My little tenant, Diamond edition

I feel better now going to work knowing that Fluttershy has company, even better knowing it's an old friend of hers. Still I can't shake the feeling that I'm being a bad person by keeping them cooped up in the house. I keep telling myself, if word got out that there are walking, talking bipedal ponies then they might be in danger. The locals and the press are the least of their problems. It's the higher powers that worries me. Thinking about them being strapped down to a table whilst they prod them with various instruments or running various tests on them.

The worst is think that the people will simply rape them, the part that makes that thought worse is the fact that I've started to care for the two. It's not due to all the sex we have, it's just something I feel deep down in my heart. It's the reason why I can't wait to get home from work once my shift is over. I just like being with them, hearing stories about their friends as well as their homes. They make me feel comfortable and welcomed. They don't even mind me asking questions about them and their friends or their homeworld.

Applejack was one example. I once asked her about her figure, ranging from her well toned body to her strong thighs that leads to her glorious bottom. She didn't even mind me asking that as I groped her flank to highlight what I meant about.

"I do a fair bit of working out on the farm" she'd say, "ploughing the fields and sowing the seeds keeps you fit. The best bit is how I get my shape, bucking trees", she slapped her thighs as she gotten to the details. "I use my butt to hit the trees to make the apples fall off".

"Really?" I'd ask.

Applejack laughs, "no silly that'd be impossible to do. Not to mention I'd injure myself. No what I do is step back and give it a good hard kick. All that work and exercise is what made my legs so strong as well as giving these babies their glorious shape", to emphasise what she meant, she turned around and used her hands to jiggle her butt. "I'll be honest though" she said shaking her rump, "the best exercise for getting a flank this good. A good hard rutting, doggy style, heck even a good fashion cowgirl or reverse cowgirl works wonders to help work out these cheeks. A good hard spanking also helps too". She'd then tell me about the times when her parents spanked her when she was naughty and when they left it was up to her Granny Smith to deal the whooping's and man can she tan a hide. "Another way to tone the ole glutes" she'd continue after her spanking stories, "is getting down and dirty with some deep anal action". Applejack had no problems telling me about her sexual escapades, but she'd always say the same "they were good for the pleasure but they'd never make me feel special or loved. Just a moment of need and they wanted my body to get rid of the burn in their loins. You though, you make me feel like a well-loved mare. You make sure I feel just as good as you're feeling and you're quite nice to snuggle up with, compared to those stallions that either fall asleep or are off as soon as their done. Plus", she'd say rubbing my crotch, "I do like how you feel inside of me. Different but in a good way".

***

It has been two weeks since Applejack started living here. I was on my way home when I came across a box half-ruined in a small tip. Normally I'd leave it alone but something caught my eye, a glint of something shiny. As the saying goes "one mans garbage is another man's treasure". I went over and had a quick look inside the box. A smile crept across my face as I looked at the contents before I felt a bit woozy. Taking the box I headed home to show the girls.

Naturally I was welcomed home with open arms and breasts to my face. They questioned about the box I was carrying. I opened the box as their eyes opened wide.

"You found them" Fluttershy squeaked, "you found the Elements of Harmony".

They started checking the box to make sure they were all there, as they did my head felt woozy again. "Sorry girls I'm gonna lie down for a bit, kinda feeling tired". The two gave me a quick kiss before I headed up to my room, as soon as I laid down my eyes closed as sleep took over quickly.

I hardly remember what I was dreaming about, all I remember was being woken up by a weight falling onto my body. Soft and plump flesh filled my hands as they bounced off the bed and onto the flesh, a tender pair of lips accidently locking with my own. I opened my eyes just as my door opened to reveal Fluttershy and Applejack in the doorway.

A beautiful pair of blue eyes met my own as the newcomer pulled her head away slowly, light blue eyeshadow highlighted her eyes. Marshmallow white skin and a purple curled hair and tail, three blue diamonds on her thighs. My hands released her generously sized chest pillows, as they fell my eyes followed them on their downward trip. A small trimmed patch of purple pubes rested above her pussy which was resting on top of my now raging hard-on.

"Rarity!" the two girls chimed together as they surrounded us, they embraced the new mare in a hug. As they hugged they moved around in a way that Rarity's pussy was rubbing against my crotch.

Fluttershy noticed that Rarity was holding something in her hands, "what have you got there?" she asked.

Rarity held out a book, "something Twilight came up with" she said.

The girls helped Rarity off my lap, no-one noticed a small trail of fluids that leaked from Rarity as the strand that connected our crotches broke.

I let the girls carry on for a bit as the new girl explained the detail. Apparently the book shares a link to another book that Twilight enchanted, if one was to write in one book then the other book would also receive the same writing. Kinda like a non-electronic version of sending a text message.

Once explained the girls introduced Rarity to me and I introduced myself to her.

"Charmed dear" she said as I took her hand and kissed it. She batted her eyelashes at me "do you happen to have a shower I can use?, being teleported by Discord made feel all nasty and I'd like to freshen up".

Applejack helped out by showing her where the shower was.

When they left I noticed Fluttershy crawling over the bed to get to me.

"Oh you poor thing" she said rubbing the slightly damp patch on my crotch, Rarity got you all worked out. Here" she said undoing my pants, "allow me to relieve you". She wasted no time in pulling my pants and boxers down my thighs as she eyed up her prize. "You know?" she said as she slowly jerked my meat, "I bet Rarity would love to join your little herd". Fluttershy kissed the head of my dick, "I saw the way she looked at you as she asked where the shower was". She then took my cock into her mouth. She bobbed her head for a bit before pulling my meat out of her mouth with an audible pop. "In fact" she began, "why not join her?. Give her a good length of your man meat, I bet she'll love it". She sat up on the bed and began to pull my shirt off.

I stepped out of my bottoms as she led me into the shower.

As we entered the room we saw both Rarity and Applejack in the shower, damn they look sexy with the water running off their bodies and their hair and tails soaked as it clings to their bodies. I was thankful that my shower was massive as Fluttershy took my dick in her hand as she led me over to the girls. As we approached, Applejack and Rarity hugged each other. Applejack was facing us and she held open Rarity shapely flank as Rarity looked back at me with a "come hither" look on her face. Fluttershy slipped me inside of Rarity as I took hold of her hips.

"Oo!" Rarity exclaimed as she felt my meat slipping inside her hot and tight love hole, "How gentlemanly," she said as she reached back to place a hand on my face. She pulled me in for a kiss, "sorry about the first kiss, that wasn't quite a proper kiss, I hope this makes up for it".

It felt nice fucking Rarity, she had a certain feel to her that was almost more velvety, somewhat silky. Like an expensive glove wrapped around my shaft, one that was expertly crafted and tailored to not only meet its standards, but to exceed them.

However, after a while, it was hard to fuck Rarity as both Applejack and Fluttershy dropped to their knees. Applejack started sucking away on Rarity's clit whilst Fluttershy started eating out my ass, this made it hard to move our hips. I settled for moving my hands up and gently playing with Rarity's breasts.

The two girls finally allowed us to resume after they've brought us a bit more closer to our orgasms. I made sure not to make Rarity feel left out as I slipped my right hand down between her legs so I can rub her clit. This caused her to bend over as she placed her hands on Applejack's shoulders, the angle allowed me to penetrate her deeper.

Applejack looked up as she grabbed Rarity's face, the two started kissing as Rarity began to cum.

Feeling her tunnels tighten, I too was at my limit as I tried to hold on a bit longer. Rarity must've sensed this as she broke the kiss for a second, "please darling, inside. Don't hold back and fill me with everything you have". Didn't need telling twice as I felt my first shot firing from my cock, I kept myself buried to the hilt as wave after wave of cum filled Rarity's pussy.

***

A few hours later.

We were all laying on my bed. Well when I say laying what I meant was I was laying. Rarity was between my legs gently sucking me off. Applejack was lying next to me on her belly as I gave her ass the occasional slap. Fluttershy was also laying on her stomach but she was writing in the book, updating Twilight and the others on her status.

"You really know how to treat a mare and make her feel special" Rarity said as she nuzzled my dick. "Make her feel wanted, loved and feel good. Plus like Applejack said, your unique shape feels even better than a stallions. Granted I've only have one stallion but he wasn't even worth it".

Applejack looked over to Rarity. "You mean Prince Blue Blood?, didn't you mention how he wanted you to do all the work and how he couldn't even stay hard for long enough to get any pleasure?".

Rarity spotted my reaction as she deepthroated me to get my next orgasms worth of cum. She drank it all like a glass of expensive wine. "Well" she said, "the less said about him the better".

Fluttershy closed the book. "So what do you say?" she asked me, "would you like Rarity to join your herd?. She can even pay the rent the same way we do".

Rarity looked at Fluttershy, "Applejack mentioned about that before you joined us". She then looked back at my cock, "can't say it's a bad deal". She gave my dick a kiss before looking at me, "so what do you say?. I join your herd and you get the most fabulous and most classiest cocksleeve this side of Equestria".

I didn't get a chance to answer as Fluttershy mounted my head as I got a mouthful of pussy. My cock however, twitched with glee.

Rarity sat on my lap, her pussy hovering over my meat. "Deal" she said impaling herself on my shaft, don't stop until you've painted my inside white. That way we can sign our contract darling".

I wasn't gonna argue as she started moving her hips.