It was Rarity's birthday

It was Rarity’s Birthday

Chapter 2 heartbreak

Fluttershy had been sitting at the table in the very chair where Dash had sat an hour ago before she killed her, the table was covered in blood and Fluttershy was using her hoof to draw smiley faces in the relatively fresh red liquid that covered the surface of the table… She had turned off all the lights, if Dash was here, that could only mean one thing, the other ponies from… that night were probably going to be coming along very soon…

She didn’t even try to clean herself up yet, the blood from her last victim was drying on her coat, when she realized her neck was itchy, she reached up to scratch but stopped as she realized the reason why, maneuvering her hooves behind her head, she untied the necklace…

She thought she had lost it, but now here it was. Angel Bunny made it for her on that day… They had been working on Rarity’s present, and after so much work, they finished the locket…

“It looks so pretty on you…” She whispered, as she laid it on the table…

Fluttershy had no idea what happened to Angel’s body… And it reminded her about how angry she was… It reminded her just how badly she had been hurt…

-//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////-

Fluttershy was standing at the door… “I… Should I go home?” She mumbled looking down, her dress was pretty, but she was wondering how it would compare to the other ponies’ she took a deep breath, and then sighed… turning around ready to make for home- she nearly crashed right into Rainbow Dash.

“Hey the party’s this way!”

“Um… I know, but you know, I think I’m going to go home if it’s all the same to you.”

Dash could tell Fluttershy was worried; parties usually presented this problem, but when Fluttershy did muster up the bravery to go to a party, she had a great time. Last time she danced with a few nice stallions, began singing in the band and left the party totally pumped and happy to have gone.

Dash knew her friend, and immediately looked Fluttershy over searching for something to ease her discomfort and give her a boost of confidence, that was all she needed and she would join the party and have the time of her life.

Dash caught notice of Fluttershy’s necklace, it looked beautiful and intricate…“That’s a pretty awesome looking locket Fluttershy!”

The locket Angel Bunny had made looked amazing, being a talented little bunny it had been hollowed out, and carved to look like trees, and the trees twisted and weaved around each other, there was nothing in the locket; they had not gotten that far as to decide what would to put inside of it.

“Thanks, Angel Bunny made it for me”

Dash was genuinely interested “Wow! I know that little ball of fur is talented but this is crazy.” The dark brown intricate little heart-shaped pendant almost seemed to possess a light of its own.

“That’s really cool!”

Fluttershy smiled, she was beginning to feel so much better about her appearance, “Thanks I was going to give it Rarity but Angel insisted that I keep it.”

“It looks so pretty on you.” Dash said as she walked up next to Fluttershy standing ready to knock on the door, “I can’t see why it was you were going to go home, that necklace is so amazing and it suits you so perfectly, this is the perfect place to have something like that.” Fluttershy felt such confidence; she was ready to go to the party now and nothing was gonna stop her. She smiled her best and knocked on the door.

What happened next was unusual; they had expected Rarity or Spike the security dragon to answer the door… Instead the door opened to reveal a bad-breathed and rather depraved looking Pinkie-Pie shaking her head like a mad-pony.

+//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////+

Fluttershy jolted her head, shocked, she had drifted away into thoughts and memories, the front door was opening and she could hear a familiar voice, the door creaked open and in strode Pinkie “Dash, I know you’re probably really tired, but you gotta keep the lights on we wanna let Fluttershy know we-”

She stopped, the silence filled the room and the tension rose to an almost suffocating level. Pinkie Pie could see Fluttershy sitting at the table, a candle illuminated her bloody face and hooves. Pinkie stood in the doorway too scared to speak too frightened to run and absolutely at a loss for words…

“Fluttershy… Where is R-rainbow Dash…?”

Fluttershy turned her dead eyes towards Pinkie… “Now Pinkie… Wasn’t it you who once told me to not ask questions I don’t want to know the answer to?” Pinkie shuddered at Fluttershy’s raspy voice, it sounded like Fluttershy needed to clear her throat, in fact hearing the grittiness of her friend’s voice made Pinkie clear her own throat before speaking.

Pinkie began to slowly advance. “Fluttershy, you gotta understand, it was my fault, if I hadn’t listened to Mary Wanna and Moonshine then none of this would’ve happened… We’re all really, really sorry.” Fluttershy stared at Pinkie, her pink coat made her stick out in the darkness like a sore thumb… the door slowly closing behind the pink party pony.

“We all came over and cleaned up your house, we were all so worried about you, you know, anything you need, you just say it! Ok? Anything you just name it and we’ll all pitch in, whenever you need it-”

“Pinkie…” She froze, gulped and trembling with fear, hoarsely choked out “Y-yeah…?”

“I want you to suffer for me…” Fluttershy said with a menacing smile the words filled Pinkie with such fear that it felt as if it were a physical stabbing in her heart “Can you do that?”

Pinkie screamed and started for the door she tried pushing, but it was no good, “Oh, no! NO! PLEASE FLUTTERSHY I’M SORRY I DID IT PLEASE DON’T KILL ME PLEASE DON’T I’M SORRY I’M SO SORRY!!!” Pinkie’s heart stopped when she heard a familiar sound.

The low rapid buzzing of the clippers she had used on Fluttershy. She began pushing harder on the door, frantically trying to escape the inevitable “NO FLUTTERSHY I’M SORRY! I’M SORRY!!!” Fluttershy bit down on pinkies curly hair and pulled her head back, clippers in hoof; she shoved the haircutting tool into Pinkies eye then swiftly pulled it out, splashing blood on the doorway and all over the floor.

Fluttershy released Pinkie, who fell to the ground screaming, covering her eye with her hooves, Fluttershy wasted no time, she jumped onto Pinkie and used the blunt end of the clippers to beat Pinkie, in a blind fury of inertia and rage.

Pinkie rolled around, trying to ward off the blows by moving her hooves in the way and by kicking and screaming. But it was useless; Fluttershy would force Pinkie’s flailing limbs out of the way and bash her head even more and even harder.

Pinkie’s nose shattered, her wounded eye was hit once and it exploded like a blister. Fluttershy was relentlessly beating Pinkie into submission.

Pinkie’s vision in her good eye was fading and blurring. Her face was bruised up and bleeding just over and under her eyes, by her ears and in the back of her head. Pinkie was slipping away now; she laid on the ground, subdued by the pain, a puddle of blood forming under her head and her ruined eye leaking a disgusting fluid onto the ground…

Pinkie pie was trembling, barely awake and filled with terror, “Fluttershy… No…” Fluttershy popped her own neck and grabbed Pinkie’s long curly mane. The clippers began to buzz again, they sounded like a swarm of angry wasps and Pinkie Pie, weakened as she was from the ruthless assault, just cried… Tears were falling from her eye, as the buzzing sound became louder and closer.

Pain burned through her skull, and her eyes widened in horror, “NOOOO!!!”

Blood sprayed from the afflicted area on her forehead, and she felt the sharp blades of the clippers ripping and tearing through her skin, ravaging the surface of her skull and the ensuing emptiness of not having a scalp.

Pinkie Pie fainted when it was all over; Fluttershy held Pinkie’s head firmly and jammed the clippers into the soft flesh in the spot where her neck connected with her head. Pinkie Pie fell to the ground in a literal tidal wave of blood…

Fluttershy began to stomp on Pinkie’s removed scalp; the force was squeezing out the blood and soft flesh that clung to the remnants with a squishing sound…

She pressed harder on the scalp, moving her hoof to squeeze out even more blood and flesh, the sound was disgusting and sloshy, and occasionally a long spritz of dark blood would fly out… Fluttershy had stomped the scalp clean of most of the spongy flesh in the primary layers, and all that was left, was Pinkie herself…

Holding the clippers in her hoof, Fluttershy turned them off then ran her tongue along the rigid teeth of the diabolical tool, her tongue bled a bit but she didn’t care; now she had work to do!

Fluttershy dragged Pinkie into her dining room and tied her to the chair with barbed wire. After that she moved Pinkie’s fore-hooves to the surface of the table, leaving the unconscious, scalped and brutally bludgeoned Pinkie she walked outside… She needed some more supplies…

As she walked into the shed she cautiously stepped over Dash’s mutilated remains, looking into Dash’s skull, she could see the brain pulsating a little bit, her new ‘friend’ was really settling in nicely. Flies were already gathering, and they crawled about freely through anyplace Dash had been injured. There were so many in Dash’s torn open back that it looked as if it was alive.

Fluttershy looked over many a possession in her shed, there were shears, a croquet kit, an old hammer, some chisels, and for a moment, Fluttershy figured that each of those items would suffice for Pinkie… but she remembered something… “I’ve killed Dash, Pinkie is here now… that means the only ones that are left are big Macintosh, Applejack, Twilight, and Spike and…” Fluttershy paused, and with a reaffirming sigh whispered out the last name on her list “Rarity…”

Fluttershy looked over each of her tools, and then looked again to her wall of implements on the wall of her shed…

One minute later, she was carrying a heavy bag on her back, filled to the brim with everything she needed for the others.
Walking into the kitchen, she was shocked to see Twilight and Spike, trying to revive Pinkie Pie and untie her from her chair…

“Spike, quickly, you gotta send something to the others, they have got to know what’s happening-“The loud thud of Fluttershy’s bag hitting the floor stopped Twilight’s sentence in its tracks. They turned, frozen in fear at Fluttershy, covered in dry blood, shaven and the way she had seemingly appeared out of nowhere. It only took a terrified heartbeat for them to realize this was all Fluttershy’s doing.

“Fluttershy… Why, why would you do this to Pinkie?”

Fluttershy had kept the flathead shovel in the kitchen for just such an occasion; she picked it up, and began to walk forward…

“Spike! RUN!!!”

Twilight and Spike made for the door and began pounding on it, trying to escape, no use; no matter how hard it was rammed it wasn’t budging. Fluttershy Grabbed Twilight by the tail and dragged her back “Ever heard of pulling?” Twilight knew now, she wasn’t going to escape, and it was made worse by the underlying realization that it was her own fault. She began to cry, just before she felt the shovel’s corner crack her in the side of the face, it tore open her cheek and the second blow destroyed her ear.

Fluttershy was about to bring the shovel down again, but Spike lunged forward and tried to claw at Fluttershy, he was on top of her, his little claws going as fast as they could, but Fluttershy had him at bay with the shovel, keeping him away from her face. “Run Twilight! Save yourself!”

Twilight was not responsive though, she was now racked with guilt and pain… She looked at Spike fighting furiously against her now deranged friend who was trying to kill her and Pinkie Pie on the table… She couldn’t even move.

Fluttershy had enough of this miserable little creature’s prolonged existence using her free hoof she put it over Spike’s throat, and forced him to the ground. Releasing the shovel she was on top of spike, choking him.

Spike was so scared now, Fluttershy was smiling as she choked him; she was smiling, and enjoying his death. Fluttershy spoke, in a calm voice that began to spiral into an all-out shrieking rant. “Now it’s my turn to hurt you! It was all just a game right? A PARTY GAME YOU SAID!!! IT WAS A BUCKING PARTY GAME YOU SICK LITTLE CREEP!!!”

Fluttershy withdrew from Spike; she could see Twilight trying to crawl away. Fluttershy picked up the shovel and stomped on Twilight’s tail to halt her retreat. Twilight couldn’t scream she was too afraid she couldn’t even concentrate for a spell. Fluttershy jumped onto Twilight and began to furiously beat her head, Twilight was fading fast, she felt weak and was wobbly, blood began to coat the floor and she could feel it running down her face…

Tiny patches and chunks of skin were hanging from her face here and there, but Fluttershy eventually let go and Twilight’s barely coherent head was slammed to the ground, again and again.

Fluttershy grabbed Twilight by the horn and pulled her head back. Twilight trembled, “W-what are you gonna do…?”

Fluttershy reared back with the shovel, holding Twilight’s horn as tight as possible, when she could suddenly smell smoke.
She turned around just in time and blocked Spike’s flames with her shovel. Fluttershy growled and quickly advanced making sure to keep the shovel’s blade between her and Spike’s flames. Spike was doing his best, his throat felt terrible and he knew he was probably going to die, but it was well worth it…

He stopped breathing flames, panting and tired, he looked up, the shovel blade was glowing red and Fluttershy raised it above her head with a shriek. Just a moment before Fluttershy brought the shovel blade down into his guts, Spike puffed out a green flame. Fluttershy sunk the shovel into Spike’s stomach as he howled with pain underlying his screams was the merciless hiss of the shovel burning his flesh. Fluttershy began twisting it around, then swift pulls from side to side like a giant lever, causing Spike’s intestines to seep out more.

Fluttershy swiftly yanked the red hot shovel from Spike, the smell of fire, and burning flesh filled the air. Spike lay on the ground, his exposed insides going up and down at a rapid pace… He began coughing as he felt himself fading away, “Oh, please no, not like this…” he whispered before blackness consumed him.

Fluttershy walked up to Twilight and stomping on Twilights back, she grabbed her horn and pulled her head back again, Twilight screamed at the sudden overwhelming amount of pain, and then with tear-filled bambi eyes looked up at the heartless Fluttershy…

Pinkie Pie was just coming to and she noticed first off, it was dark then the pain in her skull reminded her how she had gotten tied up and as she looked towards the door, she remembered who did it.

“I-I’m so sorry… Please forgive me…”Twilight whispered through her sobbing as she looked up at Fluttershy, who did nothing but twist Twilight’s horn causing her to scream in pain, then Fluttershy, using the red hot shovel removed Twilight’s horn with a bloody dry snap. Fluttershy looked at the horn in her hand and then again at Twilight…

Pinkie Pie screamed and began shaking furiously in her chair, bringing Fluttershy back to the situation at hand; she turned around and began to approach Pinkie Pie… “Are you feeling ok Pinkie Pie?” Fluttershy whispered as she walked towards her next victim.

-//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////-

Dash and Fluttershy looked at each other skeptically, something seemed wrong with Pinkie Pie at this point in time, sure, to the untrained eye; this would’ve been regular Pinkie Pie behavior, but something about that bad breath…

“Are you feeling ok Pinkie Pie?” Fluttershy mumbled out, almost afraid to hear the answer to her own question.

Pinkie Pie’s eyes filled with serious and she leaned forward, barely able to keep her balance and with a loud burp, replied, “How about you?” Fluttershy smiled and said “I’m doing ok, I guess, so can we come in?” Just before pinkie could respond, dash burst into the door, nearly flooring Pinkie in the process, “Hay yeah we can go in!”

Dash made her way into the crowd and began to do her thing. Fluttershy walked inside too, not sure if Pinkie was ok, she was acting very strangely even for Pinkie, and then Fluttershy realized something seemed to be going on with all the other ponies too! Dresses and any form of pony clothing lay abandoned and trampled all over the floor. Fluttershy wearing her dress made her stick out in the crowd like a sore hoof.

“I suppose I should go do something” she muttered and made her way into the dance area… Meanwhile, the inevitable was underway, Dash had found the snack table and grabbed a cupcake, and managed to snatch a keg of party fuel from behind the hammered Big Macintosh.

It didn’t take more than a couple sips before Dash began to feel the effects, she shook her head and the whole world was a blur… “What is this stuff?” she mumbled out, but just then, Twilight came out of nowhere.

“Dash, thank Celestia you’re here!” I can’t find Spike anywhere and I do believe that Pinkie has come under demonic possession! Dash looked over; she was under the influence but still had one hoof in reality. “What…? I know Pinkie is crazy but, she’s probably not possessed or anything…” Twilight was in a panic, she could see Pinkie across the room loading up a squirt gun with the party fuel.

“Look, I need you to distract her! If I can find Spike, then I can leave.” Dash was slipping away and she looked at the cupcake, “Ok, Twi, I’ll distract her, here eat this Pinkie always says that cupcakes help calm the nerves…”

Twilight looked at the cupcake, “Wait, we are talking about the same Pinkie Pie, right?” Dash nodded, and handed the cupcake to Twilight, then sauntered off to distract Pinkie. Twilight looked at the cupcake, “For being possessed or whatever; Pinkie pie could still make a pretty good-looking cupcake.” Twilight resumed her hunt for Spike with cupcake in hoof as she realized that another two ponies were examining her flanks and drooling.

Fluttershy was feeling more and more worried… Each of the ponies were doing some nasty stuff, she couldn’t turn her head an inch without seeing some kind of group orgy. And most of the time there weren’t stallions involved… Fluttershy’s new concern was getting home. Just drop off the present at the gift table and leave… But the gift table was nowhere to be found.

Twilight was looking around, there was no sign of Spike, and her journey had taken her to the stairs… the sounds of the party were fading and she became aware of a sound, Rarity! Maybe she could help find Spike, and maybe her presence would even calm the guests.

Rarity’s door was open and Twilight walked in- to a horrific sight…

Frosting, everywhere, chunks of cake all around, the room looked like a junk food tornado had touched down, and at the center of it all, she had walked in at the climax. Spike sprayed rarity’s body with cum, she was lathering it over her body and after releasing his load, Twilight watched Rarity spray all over Spike’s body. She turned away and leaned against the wall…

She didn’t know what to think… “Is the world going crazy or am I going crazy?” she sighed shaking her head, and remembered the cupcake, she looked at it and tilted her head, “Well, Pinkie may now be certifiably insane, but maniac makes a pretty strong cupcake… “Twilight took a bite, it was really good, looking at the area, and she noticed green speckles in the cupcake…

“So, you like the cupcake don’t ya?” Pinkie’s voice startled Twilight, and she looked up to see Pinkie, but, she wasn’t afraid anymore. “Pinkie, it’s a really good cupcake and I… Has your hair always looked so, cute?” Twilight asked leaning forward towards Pinkie’s face. Pinkie moved closer, but Twilight jolted herself back to reality. “What am I doing? What’s going on and, what’s that smell?!” Twilight gasped and looked down, she was soaked.

“What’s happening-” she got her answer quickly when she felt Pinkie softly rubbing her legs… Twilight couldn’t handle it, and she ejaculated from Pinkie’s soft touch. Pinkie giggled “I see you’re, Cumming, around…?” Twilight stopped resisting and gave in; Pinkie spread Twilight’s legs open and kissed her.

Their tongues twisted around each other and they furiously began pushing their mouths together, their heads separated, a long strand of saliva hung between both of their mouths Twilight smiled, this feeling was new and exciting, she simply forgave Spike. He was just doing what came naturally when one’s in love, right?

Twilight put her hoof on Pinkie’s curly hair and pushed her head down to her own soaking wet pussy. The feeling of Pinkie’s tongue running up and down the lips of her vagina and the sudden, extremely kinky feeling tug on her clitoris was magnificent. She laid herself out on the ground letting Pinkie Pie pleasure her with her mouth…

…While Fluttershy stared on in terror. She had seen Twilight go upstairs and tried to follow her to see if she knew where the present table was, but by the time she had made it through the crowd; she had come around the corner just tin time to see Twilight’s vaginal spray. Fluttershy ran away from the putrid display, whatever was going on was wrong! “I have to find Dash; we need to get out of here!” Fluttershy was racing through the crowd, looking around, nothing but ponies licking one another’s vaginas and stallions sucking cock. She was so scared, and things were about to get worse because she crashed square into Big Macintosh.

“I’m sorry,” she worriedly said before she continued on her run, big Macintosh said nothing but looked up and saw Fluttershy’s rump, and he grew more excited.

“Eeyup!” he said with a chuckle. Rising to his feet, Big Macintosh had seen all kinds of hot and heavy stuff that evening, but it just didn’t appeal to him… Fluttershy on the other hand, for the first time that whole evening, he felt aroused it grew as stiff and hard as a steel pole, and he began to follow slowly.

Fluttershy was seeing too much, she hadn’t had anypony come onto her or try to get her to willingly join into their fray, but what she was seeing was violation enough. Applejack was being done in the front and back by two stallions, Pinkie and Twilight was in their own little world, Fluttershy needed to find Dash and get out of there!

She raced through the crowd, and was slowly pursued by Big Macintosh the entire time, there was no sign of Dash… at least for a while… She stood panting in the center of the dance floor, “Dash, Dash?! Where are you!?” Just then she felt a hoof on her dress, “Oh, no…” she thought, “Please not me…”

A familiar voice dissuaded her doubts.

“Fluttershy?” She turned around, happy to have found dash, or vice versa, either way, she could leave now.
But just as quickly as the fear left her system it returned ten-fold Dash was totally drunk, and she quickly ripped Fluttershy’s dress, “Dash STOP IT!!!” Fluttershy looked at her friend “What’s happening?” She whimpered out tears were welling up. “Come on Fluttershy why don’t you take it off, I think you’ll be more comfortable!?”

Fluttershy tilted her head, “Comfortable?! This is sick and wrong! We can’t do things like this, and I… I’m not going to stay anymore!” She was backing away from dash, Dash only looked on with a smile, “I don’t think so… You haven’t had any fun yet… Right?” Just then Fluttershy realized the music had stopped, she looked around, and it was just as she had feared. Everypony was looking at her, disapproving of her actions no doubt.

“I think you just need to relax Fluttershy…” Dash said happily Fluttershy began to cry, tears were rolling down her face and she was cowering, “We’ll take care of this for you.” Just then Fluttershy felt hooves on her rump; she turned and filled with fear as she saw Big Macintosh, who quietly replied “Eeyup!”

The feeling came intense and hard as the crowd cheered and laughed. Big Macintosh slid his huge dick into Fluttershy’s tight virgin pussy, the feeling took her breath away, he was sticking it in as deep as possible, and it seemed to be getting thicker the deeper it went.

She screamed and all ponies rushed in to help the process. Dash ripped Fluttershy’s dress off, while applejack and some other stallions held her limbs. Fluttershy flapped furiously, trying to escape but it was no good. She was effectively held down and the pain was getting so intense.

She kept screaming, just yelling “NO!!!” as loud as she could, but her protests were falling on naught but deaf ears. She had no idea why her friends had so suddenly and swiftly changed, but she had no time to think or ponder about it. Big Macintosh was on the offense.

“Ooh she’s nice and tight” he commented, sliding it in more. Fluttershy felt his huge tip hit the deepest wall of her vagina and she screamed while trying to get away “ITS IN ITS IN LET ME GO!!!” Rainbow Dash came in right in front of Fluttershy’s face. Dash rubbed Fluttershy’s soft mane and whispered with tender mockery “Now why would we do that…?” then Dash pulled Fluttershy’s face upwards and nodded to Big Mac, who began to force his way in.

“NO THERE’S NOT ENOUGH ROOM!!! THERE’S NOT ENOUGH” Fluttershy felt intense sharp stinging pain around the already stretched to capacity opening and the warm stream of blood. She screamed in pain as more tears ran from her eyes, her cries were cut short when she felt Dash’s hooves against her face, clenching her cheeks so her jaw would stay open.

She looked up through blurred tear-filled vision to see a long trail of drool stream from Dash’s mouth and slowly get closer to her own held open mouth. She tried to pull her head away but Dash had a good hold. She just closed her eyes and decided to let Dash do what she was going to do, Big Macintosh’s torture was far worse… Blood was dripping out and forming a puddle on the floor as Fluttershy was being entered.

Just then Fluttershy’s eyes widened, her feeling of being penetrated intensified and came with much more speed and force. Then it came again and again and she screamed he was furiously pounding her tight bleeding hole. She looked up to see Rainbow Dash and Applejack laughing at her. Her privates filled with blood and her eyes filled with tears…

+//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////+

Fluttershy looked at Spike as his bloody mess of a gut moved up and down with each slow breath, and she pulled out a hammer and several nails. Twilight watched, bound and gagged she stared on in horror. “Where did you send that message!?” Spike shook his head and coughed up some more blood “You’ll have to kill me first!”

Fluttershy rushed forward to Spike, and angrily hissed out “Who said I was going to just ‘kill’ you?” She dropped the hammer and using her bare hoof, slammed a nail in the soft flesh of Spike’s inner thigh, it went straight through and he screamed looking down at the nail sticking out and he twitched at the immense pain.

Fluttershy quickly grabbed his arm and slammed a nail through his hand pinning that one down too, his screams were high pitched and Twilight was crying, doing her best to look away. Fluttershy grabbed Spike’s last arm and rather than jam the nail into it, she grabbed the hammer, raised it over her head and turned it so she would be hitting him with the claw of the hammer.

She beat his fingers first, and he screamed shaking his head back and forth. “I’LL NEVER EVER TELL YOU!!!” Fluttershy held his arm down and with the hammer this time, began to pound his arm, the loud snapping of his bones the blood splattering as his screams turned from high pitched shrieks into that of a dying cat.

Fluttershy took a step back, Spike’s arm had been obliterated, it was no longer attached and blood poured from it. His arm looked more like an earthworm smeared on the ground rather than something that was once attached to any living thing, the only distinguishable sign it was an arm once were the of shards of bone.

Fluttershy walked around Spike, “It’s ok, already know who you sent it to… And believe me, I will get her too! Because finally! After all you have done to me; I get to do things to you! And in the next three minutes… You’re gonna wish you were dead!”