Amagami FiM

by TheAnimerican

Rating: everyone
Tags: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Human, Main 6, Romance, Original Character, Crossover
Length: 6616

Some romance for a group of girls from Equestria High!

The main protagonist, Story Rich, became heartbroken last year on Hearth's Warming Day as a girl he liked stood him up. Despite trying to move on, the memories of that moment always found their way back. Now he starts a new semester at Equestria High and hopes that things will get better. Perhaps this semester there will be a girl to help pick up the pieces.

***

Credit for cover art goes to Erim-Kawamori.

This story was inspired by one of my favorite romance anime, Amagami SS.
For this story, I am going to try and follow what the anime did and keep each story arc within 4 chapters.
Please keep in mind that this is not EQUESTRIA GIRLS related.

Thank you and I hope you enjoy!

Published 2019-09-20 10:10:01 UTC
Last updated 2019-11-10 17:39:31 UTC

Start New

Story Rich, like most of the students, sat there pretending to pay attention to the teacher. Time was always slow as he and his fellow students waited for the bell to ring for lunch. Thankfully, he was one of the lucky students to have his desk next to the window. The view from there was nice since his class was on the top floor and overlooked the courtyard. Although the courtyard wasn't too special it was best known for the large cherry blossom tree in the center.

Sadly, the tree did not have any cherry blossoms as it was wintertime. Just looking at the tree reminded Story Rich of that night...

*** 2 Years Ago, Middle School ***

Behind the gym, there was Story Rich and a fellow student. The fellow student being a girl he has had a crush on since the start of Freshman year. Despite the day being cloudy and cold, the moment between them was enough to provide him warmth. He was hoping that she felt the same way.

"Uh... Hi... Thanks for meeting me here. So umm, I was hoping that maybe... We can spend some time together on the night of Hearth's Warming Eve?" Story nervously asked.

She tilted her head and gave a light smile. "Are you asking me out on a date?" she asked, but it was obvious she was teasing him.

The question made him blush even harder than before. "Umm... Yeah. I suppose I am," he replied with regret. "'You suppose you do?' Ugh, you are such an idiot. What kind of answer was that?" he thought to himself. "I mean yes," he corrected himself, "Yes. It is a date."

She giggled, "How bold and romantic of you. Hmm..." As she thought to herself, Story couldn't help but think of the things he liked about her. She had a playful personality and was not afraid to take on life. He also found her short red hair and brown eyes to be very attractive. Story hoped that she would say "yes." If she rejected him, he hoped he could take it.

"Sure." Her voice broke the silence. At least, that was what he thought had happened. He questioned himself if he heard her right.

"Yeah?" he had to ask.

"S-U-R-E. Sure," she spelled with a smile.

All the weight he was carrying was suddenly lifted off of him. He felt light on his feet and couldn't break the smile from his face. "That's great!" he cheered, "When can we hang out?"

"Well, I would like to spend a little time with my family first. So it would have to be later at night. What do you have planned for our date?" she asked.

A date. He was so happy to hear that and confident in that being what it was. It was a date with his crush! "Sure of course. Umm... Oh! You know that park, up the hill, that overlooks the town? You want to meet there at 7?"

"Hmm..." She thought to herself, "That should be just fine." She gave a thumbs up for approval. She then ran around him toward the front gate. She turned around and waved, "Have a nice winter break! See you Hearth's Warming Eve!"

Story returned the wave, but she turned away before she could see him. It didn't matter to him though since the date was a few days away. He believed that that night was going to be the most memorable night of his life. Unfortunately for him, it was.

For on that night, he waited at the park just as planned. It was nearly 7:00 p.m., the snow was falling lightly, and he held his present for her as he waited on a park bench. He held the present tight, eagerly waiting for her to arrive. It didn't take long for the clock to strike 7... then 7:15... then 7:30... 8:03... "She will be here soon. She will..." he tried to tell himself. He tried to convince himself that she had a hard time leaving the house or that perhaps she was in trouble. He wanted to contact her, but he forgot to get her number before she ran. So he waited.

Finally, it was close to 8:30 p.m. His clothes were wet, he was freezing, and still hasn't shown up. It was then he stood up, dropped the present, and said, "She isn't coming..." Feeling weak and heavy, he began his long trip back home.

*** Present Day ***

After the break, it was found out that she transferred schools. However, at that point, he didn't care about that. It was because of that night, he had to spend the rest of his winter break with a fever and a broken heart. Since then, he hasn't had feelings for another girl and Hearth's Warming was no longer a reminder of happy occasions.

"Story hey!" a voice interrupted his daydreaming. He then felt an arm wrap around his neck. "What's up? It's lunch and you are not eating?" Story was so lost in thought, he completely missed the bell for lunchtime.

"Oh. Hey Backbone. Sorry, I was lost in thought," said Story.

"Lost in thought? Story, it isn't about HER again, is it? It has been two years bud. You have to move on and let it go," Backbone said with sympathy.

"That is easy for you to say. I doubt a girl you liked stood you up like that. You, on the other hand, get most of the girls anyway. Being a valuable player on the football team is a big plus. Seriously though, I actually thought I had a chance with not just any girl, but my crush. With the one question always on my mind. 'Why?'" And again, slowly the pain started to pour back into him. Before he said something he would regret, he began to search for his lunchbox. Once retrieved, he stuffed his mouth with an apple as an extra precaution.

Feeling guilty, Backbone backed off a little. He then repositioned himself in front of Story by taking the empty desk. "You're right man. I'm sorry. I didn't mean to upset you like that, but you see what I mean? I worry about you every year because of that and it isn't healthy. I think of you as my brother now and I want to help."

Story slowly chewed his food as he stared at his lunch box. He then looked at his friend and gave a smirk. "I'm sorry too Backbone. It's just a pretty touchy subject. You're right. I do need to get over it, but I am not sure how to go on about it."

"Well I never said it would be easy," said Backbone. "We have to take baby steps."

Story nodded in agreement, "Okay. What's the first step?"

"That's just it. Some people start on the left foot and some start on the right. In other words, there is no correct first step. It is based on the individual on where you go and how you get there," stated Backbone.

"... Okay, where the heck did you get that? From some book?" questioned Story.

"Hehe. Okay, you got me. You are close. I was reading a SPORTS magazine and there was a small article on 'Road to Recovery.' I forgot who by. So anyway, the point is, we need to find out what your first step should be."

Story shrugged his shoulders, "If you say so. It would have to be under 20 min. though since that's when lunch is over."

"Right right. By the way, are you going to eat that?" Backbone then grabbed half of Story's tuna sandwich and took a bite.

"Not anymore," he replied and playfully smacked Backbone on the head. As the two sat together, Story continued to enjoy his apple. While Backbone enjoyed his friend's sandwich, he stared out the window and observed the courtyard. On one side, he saw a couple laughing in the window of another school building. Near the tree, he spotted another couple holding hands as they walked together. He thought to himself that it was nice to have that special someone. "If only Story hadn't got hurt that night, he might just be as happy as they are... That's it!"

"Ah!" Backbone cried in pain from biting his tongue.

Startled, Story dropped his apple, "Backbone? You okay?"

"Better than okay, I know what should be your first step to recovery."

Story raised an eyebrow at this, "Oh, have you? Then please, don't keep me in suspense any longer. What is the first step?" he asked sarcastically.

"First of all, cut the sarcasm. Second of all, we need to get you a girl!" Backbone suggested.

There was nothing but silence between the two. Story stared at his supposed friend with his jaw dropped. With the fact, he announced that to the students present in the room and to suggest to get something that caused the pain in the first place.

"I am going to pretend you didn't just say that. With that, please go back to your original room while I finish my lunch," he asked politely while controlling his inner rage.

"Wait wait wait. Just hear me out on this. Look, this whole thing started because the girl you liked stood you up, right?"

"Keep it up Backbone. You are getting warmer, but the grave you are digging is getting deeper and colder," Story said with some malice.

"No, I am serious. You just wanted that one shot right? With a girl of your dreams. Well, now I say the time is right to find a new girl. There are plenty of girls here in this school for you. What do you say?"

Suddenly, any evil thoughts toward Backbone left Story's mind. He thought to himself, "Try again? Another girl? Can I really...?" Story looked down to his food and said one word, "No."

"What?" Backbone asked.

"No," Story repeated. He shook his head and made eye contact with his friend again, "I can't go through that again. Besides, what girl would like me? I haven't really talked to any girl for a while now. The only time I ever did was when it was school-related or necessary."

"Oh come on. There must be someone out there. Well, what about her? I see you two talking all the time," Backbone pointed behind Story.

Story turned around and spotted a tall blond girl, slightly tanned, wearing a brown sweater, and a skirt with apple accessories. He turned back to his friend, "Applejack? We have been friends since middle school yeah, but she isn't interested in me."

"How do you know that? Maybe it's time to take that friendship to the next level," Backbone suggested.

"I don't know. I never really thought of her like that."

"Well, that's fine I guess. But you should at least think about it. Oh, what about those two with her?" Again, Backbone pointed behind Story and again he was forced to turn around. He then saw Applejack with two other girls by the door. One was very beautiful with curly purple hair, with a gem-shaped hair clip, and bright blue eyes to match them. The other girl wasn't as well-groomed. She had her shirt untucked, wore a loose tie, and her hair was a rainbow mess. However, he had to admit, the rainbow girl had a nice body and she was not hard on the eyes either.

He turned back to Backbone, "I don't recognize them. I don't know about that rainbow girl, but that purple-haired one is beautiful. She seems to care about her image."

"Oh, I can fill you in on the two easily. The stylish one's name is Rarity. If it wasn't obvious, she is a bit of a fashionista and designs clothes as a hobby. I heard she works on actual projects for clients, but that's hush-hush. As for the rainbow one, that is actually her name, Rainbow Dash. She is the most athletic person I have ever seen. She is captain on the girl's baseball and track team. She tried to do more, but the school didn't allow it due to her grades. Actually, I heard if she doesn't pick them up, then she would be forced to drop one of the teams."

"Backbone, how do you know all this?" Story asked.

"When you are part of the football team, you get around."

"Okay football star. Any other potential 'targets' you have in mind?"

"Oh come on. Don't think of these girls are targets. Simply as potential love interests. And as a matter-of-fact, I do have a few more girls in mind for you."

"Oh really? I am curious to hear. Who else?" Story leaned in to listen.

"Actually, you and I both know her very well. Why don't you try and ask out Pinkie Pie?"

Story was taken aback by the suggestion. "Pinkie Pie? She knows just about every student on campus and you mean to tell me she is still single?"

Backbone looked at his friend unamused. "Story, you and I both know that she is still single. You two have been friends since elementary. She is probably your best chance at romance. Just think, childhood friends, now all grown up, suddenly realizing their feelings for one another, and live happy lives together." Backbone said with confidence.

"Either that or perhaps you have read way too many romantic comic books," said Story.

Again, Backbone looks at him with that unamused expression, "Story, you know very well those aren't comic books. They are called manga and they are works of art."

Story pondered at the idea. He was right. Both he and Pinkie Pie have been friends since they were kids. However, she made just about everyone she met her friend and did her best to make them happy all the time. It was because of this he never really looked at her in a romantic sort of way. She just didn't seem like the type to him. Also, her personality can be overwhelming to some people. But that was her charm and he would actually hate to see her lose that. "I don't know. She might be a little too hyper for me right now."

"Hmm... fair enough I guess," his friend seemed to agree. "That's okay though. I still have a couple more in mind," he said proudly.

"Please don't," Story begged, closing his eyes and rubbing his temples.

"Oh come on. Just one more. I swear you will like this one. She is a real cutie."

"Even if I said 'no' you were going to tell me anyway."

"And you are right my friend. Have you heard of a girl named Fluttershy?"

Story thought about all the girls he knew, but that name was unfamiliar to him. He shook his head, "Can't say that I have."

"Well, that isn't a surprise," said Backbone. "She is truly a natural beauty. She has long pink hair and green eyes. You know how rare that is?"

Story shrugged his shoulders in response.

"Rare. She is probably the nicest person you would ever meet and does a lot of volunteer work at the animal shelter."

"You seem really excited about this girl. I don't see why you don't just date her yourself."

"Ha! Oh, believe me, I have thought about it. Although, she does have this one drawback."

Now that caught Story's attention. A girl his friend took an interest in, with natural beauty, and who is very kind has a drawback? "What drawback?" he asked.

"Well... she is too quiet. You try to talk to her, she speaks almost in whispers and sometimes stutters. Also, she easily gets scared and worries too much. I'm sorry, but I couldn't handle that. You on the other hand just might be able to get her out of her shell," Backbone gave a wink.

"I doubt that. You can't even get me out of mine," Story said jokingly.

They both shared a laugh before a voice interrupted the two. "Umm... Excuse me you two." Both Backbone and Story Rich turned to the source. It was a female student with long purple hair, a short blue skirt, with star accessories. "Hello, Story Rich. I'm sorry to bother the two of you, but the class will be starting in a few minutes. I suggest your friend heads back to class before the bell."

"Oh. Time sure does fly with friends around. I didn't even get to finish my lunch. Thanks, Twilight," said Story. Twilight Sparkle was the class-representative. The two didn't talk much, but he knew her to be very reliable and popular with most of the students. It also helped that she had the best grades amongst the students. Some are jealous of her, while others admire her and hope to do just as well.

"Sorry, but I just want to have a couple more minutes with my buddy here," said Backbone.

"Of course," Twilight smiled, "I just thought I should give you two a heads up." With that, she returned to her own desk before class started.

"You know, she might be worth a shot too," Backbone whispered.

The suggestion nearly made Story jump out of his seat, "Are you crazy? There is no way I have a chance with her. You are comparing two different worlds. Sure she is the smartest girl in school, has the admiration of most of the students, and-."

"She is pretty cute?" Backbone interrupted.

"Yes she pretty cu-," Story once again smacked his friend upside the head. Backbone laughed.

"Don't sell yourself short buddy. You might be surprised by the guys I hang out with. Let me tell you, I was even more surprised to see how lucky they were to even have a girl. Look, it doesn't even have to be THESE girls per se. They are merely suggestions and pretty damn good ones if I do say so myself."

"Whatever you say Backbone, but you are going to regret those words," Story said with a grin.

"I will. Why?" he asked confused, but understood what his friend meant after hearing the bell ring.

"Those final words cost you the time to get back to class," Story chuckled.

"Ah crap! Just think about it," Backbone said as he bolted from the chair while trying not to knock over any students on the way out.

Story laughed at this and hoped his friend would make it back to class before his teacher did. While waiting for his own teacher to return, he was once again looking out the window to the tree. "Hmm... Try again huh? But can I really...?"

Author's Note

Hello everyone!

I hope this chapter was a good start.
It has been a while since I wrote anything so I am afraid I am rusty. (Not that I was ever that good before. :derpytongue2:)
So I already have an idea on which order I will go.
However, I am curious to know.
Which girl do you hope he talks to first?
Please let me know what you think and I hope you enjoy future chapters.

Thank you!

Rarity Arc: Chapter 1

The bell rang and students were exiting the classroom with excitement. Story Rich, however, preferred to wait until the traffic of students died down. While waiting he would collect his notes, textbooks, and other school essentials. After about 10 minutes of waiting he was sure that most of the students cleared the halls.

As he put on his jacket and scarf, he noticed that Twilight remained at her desk. He could see her working with a stack of papers to the side of her. He never knew exactly what the responsibilities of a class rep were, but he admired her for her hard work regardless. "I will see you tomorrow Twilight," said Story. However, Twilight did not respond. He knew she wasn't trying to be rude and took no offense. With all that work, he felt that one must be fully concentrated. He decided to just leave her be and left the classroom as quietly as possible.

As expected, the halls were nearly empty as the last of the students headed downstairs. Story preferred this as he didn't like the students shoving one another as they tried to leave school grounds.

On the way down, he would spot some stragglers here and there. He would also hear groups of students still in the classrooms. Usually, they were clubs for afterschool activities. This was something that he was used to seeing as this happened almost every day he left for home.

Once he made it to the first floor, he heard something new to his daily routine. "Is someone... Humming?" Normally, he would ignore it and continue on his way out, but he noticed that the humming got a little louder as he made his way to the exit. To satisfy his curiosity, he would peek through the open doors of each class he passed by.

As he made his way down the hall, getting closer to the exit, he thought he might have missed the source of the humming. Or maybe it was even behind one of the closed doors? "Oh well," he thought to himself, "It was probably someone practicing in the Choir Club or something anyway." However, as he was about to give up, he instinctively peeked inside another class. This time, something caught his eye and stopped him in his tracks.

Inside the classroom, there was a female student, with a drawing pad, sitting on a stool, positioned in front of a mannequin. She didn't seem to notice Story as her back was turned to him.

Story could not help but notice that the mannequin was wearing a plain red dress. It was one of those mannequins with no head, no arms, and no legs. All it had to stand on was a slime metal pole. If she was wearing it, he guessed that the dress would end just below the knees. "Hmm... What is she doing?" Story asked himself. Then he realized, the humming was much louder than before. "Wait, was she the one?"

The student then stood up and set down her pencil and pad on a nearby desk. She then moved closer to the mannequin and observed it rather closely. Standing in front of it, she tilted to the right, then to the left, peeked over the chest, then under the arms. Finally, she proceeded to move behind the mannequin.

It was then, Story had a much clearer view of the female student. To his surprise, it was one of the girls that Backbone pointed out from before. "Wait... Isn't that-?" Story didn't have time to finish his thought as a sudden gasp interrupted his thinking. Awake, he saw the curly purple-haired student startled. "Oh. Sorry! I didn't mean to scare you," Story apologized.

The female student breathed a sigh of relief and regained her composure. "Well, you certainly gave me quite the start. Did you need something?" She asked with a raised eyebrow.

"Oh no. I just heard some humming and I was curious about it," replied Story.

The student's face changed from startled to questionable as she crossed her arm, "So, do you investigate every humming you hear?"

Now that Story thought about it, there was nothing special about someone humming. Why did he feel the need to find the source? He realized that it was silly and maybe creepy. "Umm... No, you're right. I'm sorry. I will leave you alone," Story apologized again and began to leave.

"Wait," the student called, "I apologize for my rudeness. Was I disturbing you? I didn't even realize I was humming so loudly."

Story shook his head, "Oh no. Not at all. If anything, you hum a very nice tune. I normally go home around this time and that was my first time hearing it. So on the way out, I saw you in here doing... Whatever it was that you're doing."

"I see," she said, "Well if you must know, I was brainstorming for a new design I am working on. Normally I would continue my work at home, but I do have a deadline to meet. I thought there would be less distraction here."

Story noticed her emphasis on the word "distraction." He nervously chuckled and scratched the back of his head. "Yeah. Sorry about that. Wait, you design?" asked Story.

She nodded, "Would you like to see? Actually, if you have a moment, I would be very grateful if I can get your opinion on my work."

Although Story was willing to help when he can, he felt that he was one of the last people to ask for help on art and designs. "Umm... You sure you should be asking me? I mean, I don't exactly have an eye for art."

"Oh nonsense," she replied, "I am sure your take on this will help me greatly. Besides, think of this as a way of apologizing for spying on me. Besides, one's view can represent thousands."

Story took a slight offense at the accusation, "Huh? I wasn't spying."

Again, she crossed her arms and raised an eyebrow. "Weren't you?" she questioned him as if he caught him in a lie.

Technically, he was watching her without permission. Feeling defeated, he re-entered the classroom and walked toward the desk with the drawing pad. The two students met and sat across one another.

Once Story took the pad, he was slightly confused at what he was staring at. He kept looking between drawing and the dress-wearing mannequin. In the drawing, there was a woman wearing a dress with far more detail than even he can describe. Also, the dress seemed to have a mesh overlay with the design of vines wrapping around the woman. Plus, the vines were decorated with what appeared to be small crystals. The best he could tell when there was no color.

"So?" she asked, "What do you think?"

"Uhh..." Story started, "Is there another drawing? The two dresses are completely different."

This caused Rarity to chuckle, "Oh no no no darling. They are the same dress, but the drawing is what I picture the dress to look like. I use that mannequin to pose and I added more to it with the drawing."

Again, Story looked back and forth between the two but wasn't quite sure how to answer her. "Well, I like the one in the drawing more."

She rolled her eyes at the obvious answer, "Yes yes, but what do you think of it? Too much? Too little? What does it need?"

Story was stumped and unsure of what to say. "Umm... Well... I'm sorry, but I really don't know."

The student gave a sigh and took back the drawing pad, "No it's alright. Can't say you didn't try. I suppose it is okay, but I still feel that it is missing something."

"This might be dumb to ask, but what is it exactly you are trying to do? Who is this dress for?" asked Story.

"This dress was a request from a friend of mine. She asked that this dress would make her event memorable and romantic."

"Romantic?"

"Yes. I can't give all the details, but this is for a VERY special event. There will be someone there and she wants to capture his heart. I couldn't possibly say 'no' to such a request. but that is why I have to get this one just right," she said as she rubbed her temples. "I chose the dress to be red since the color represents love and passion, but all I have been seeing is stress."

The two sat there in silence and Story didn't want to be the first to make a sound. He just waited patiently as he watched her rub her temples. It was almost as if she forgot he was still in the room with her.

He caught himself looking out the classroom window and completely lost track of time. He looked back at the clock and saw that it was 3:23 p.m. "Damn. I'm going to miss the bus. I will have to catch the next one," Story thought to himself.

However, the female student noticed this and slightly gasped, "Oh dear. I'm so sorry. Did you need to be somewhere?"

"Huh? Oh no, it's nothing. I can catch the next bus," Story said with a smile.

"Oh, you missed your bus. I really wished you had said something. Do you live far?" she asked.

"No, I actually live about 15 min. away from here," Story pointed in one direction.

"Well allow me to give you a lift back home," she offered. "After all it was my fault that you missed your bus."

"No, it's fine. The whole point of me being here was a way of apologizing. And like I said I can catch the next one."

"But the next bus may not arrive on time due to it being traffic time. You might be waiting for an hour and it is cold out. Although you did make up for spying on me, I don't like the idea of you probably getting sick on my account. So please, I insist that I take you home," she offered again.

Story didn't want her to go through the trouble, but she did make some valid points. At that time of year, it wasn't clear when the next bus would arrive. Although it wasn't freezing cold outside and no snow, it may still be an uncomfortable experience for him. "Well," started Story, "If you don't mind then I would like to take you up on your offer."

She smiled, "Of course I don't mind. Just let me pack my things." At a quick pace, she got out of her seat, gathered her supplies, and even carefully removed the dress off of the mannequin. She placed everything in her rolling cart, put on her jacket, and even put on one of those faux fur hats. "Shall we go... Uh... You know what? I never got your name did I?" she asked.

"Oh right. I'm Story Rich," he offered his hand for a shake.

The student returned his shake and her eyes widened, "Ah! You're Story Rich? Oh, darling, I wish you had told me sooner. Applejack talks about you from time to time."

"She does? Good things?"

"Well, for the most part," she giggled. "I am Rarity. Although she and I are from two different worlds, we have been friends for quite a while. She never mentioned me?"

"Well, we do talk, but not like we used to back middle school. Did you need help with your cart?" he asked.

"Such a gentleman," she complimented, "But I can manage thank you. Now then, we should get going." With that said, she walked ahead of Story, leading them out of the school building.

***

The two exited the building and was hit with a light gust of wind. Luckily, with his warm scarf and windbreaker jacket, Story was able to tolerate the cold. Rarity, on the other hand, slightly squealed at the cold breeze. "Oh my, it is much colder than I thought it would be."

"Are you okay?" Story asked.

"Oh yes, I'm fine. No worries. Come on, my car is just over there," she said as they walked toward the school parking lot.

As Story followed Rarity, he noticed she was trying to cover her neck with her jacket. She tried not to make it obvious, but that coat wasn't providing much warmth. She probably wore the coat more for the style. "It isn't that cold, is it?" he thought to himself. "Rarity wait a second," he said.

"Huh? Is s-something wrong?" Rarity asked, trying not to click her teeth.

Without saying a word, he unwrapped his scarf and stepped toward Rarity.

"What are you-?" Rarity didn't finish her question as he wrapped his scarf around her neck.

"Sorry, but it looked like you needed it more than I did," said Story.

Rarity was surprised and thought it was very forward of him. However, she couldn't help but embrace the warmth of the previous wearer. "Oh my. This white and blue scarf does go nicely with the jacket. But won't you be cold?" asked a concerned Rarity.

"Nah I will be fine. I actually like the cold weather. Besides, we aren't that much further from the car are we?"

"Not at all. It's just over there," Rarity pointed. From Story's point-of-view, he was shocked with wide-open eyes. He was looking at a white luxury SUV with not a single scratch on it. Although he was not into cars like most guys in his school, he was pretty sure that the car was a newer model by the manufacturer.

"Rarity, you drive that!?" asked an astonished Story.

Rarity raised an eyebrow and looked back in the direction. She then hid behind her hand as if she was embarrassed, "Are you looking at the white one?"

"Huh? Uh yeah?" Story replied.

"That's not mine. I was pointing at the one to the right of it..." she corrected.

Story looked at the vehicle she was referring to and was shocked again. The said vehicle was an older brown sedan model and was in need of new paint. This surprised Story in many ways, but he didn't judge Rarity for it. "Oh, well, it's still a nice car," he lied.

Rarity came out of hiding and gave him her signature "Seriously?" face. "Let's go Story."

"Yes ma'am," Story obeyed.

***

Despite how the vehicle looked on the outside, the inside wasn't bad at all. It was clean and he was unable to see any damages. Despite the mileage almost hitting the six-figure mark, the car seemed to be running fine. "Rarity, if I may ask-"

"I know I know," Rarity cut him off, "But first, where do you live again?"

"Oh right. Just drive straight until you hit Ruby St. When you do you will make a left." directed Story.

"Mhm," Rarity nodded, "You see, I might look the part, but the sad truth is is that I can't afford cars like that. At least not yet anyway. So for now, I concentrate my finances on my materials. I only like to work with high-quality fabrics. I just know that one day all my hard work will finally pay off."

"Wow," said Story.

"Hmm?"

"Oh, nothing. I was just thinking about how incredible you are."

Rarity slightly blushed at the comment, "What? Oh thank you, but it is nothing that special."

"Nothing special? Rarity, not a lot of students do what you do. You work hard and maintain good grades. I am pretty sure that your hard work will pay off," said Story.

"Aww. That's very sweet of you to say. You sound just like Spike," said Rarity.

"Spike? Is he your boyfriend?"

Rarity laughed at the question, "Oh no no no, but it is funny that you asked that. You see, Spike is a child that attends Canterlot Elementary and is friends with my sister. He has been by our house many times and is a great helper. At some point, I realized that the little darling has a crush on me. He is rather adorable."

"Has he confessed to you?" he asked curiously.

"He has actually. A couple of times already. I tried telling him we can't, in many ways, but he is very persistent. I blame myself for not giving a more straight forward answer, but I don't want to hurt his feelings. I was hoping his sister could help me explain, but she wasn't much help either as she is always busy. I feel like I am in a little delicate position," Rarity said with some worry.

"Oh. I sort of know what he is going through," said Story.

"Really? Do you have any suggestions?" asked Rarity.

Story didn't hear the question as he reminisced his rejection. "I hope that he doesn't feel hurt like I did," he thought to himself.

"Story?" Rarity called out.

"Huh? Sorry did you say something?"

"I was asking for advice on how to approach Spike, but I think we are close to your house," said Rarity.

Story looked back on the road and recognized his surroundings. Rarity made the left turn as directed and waited for further instructions as she has slowly driven down the residential area.

"This house right here," Story pointed at a small cape cod style house.

"This is your home? It is quite lovely," Rarity complimented. She parked the car in front of the house as she waited for Story to exit.

Story grabbed his backpack and got out of the car. Before shutting the door, he looked inside at Rarity, "Thanks for dropping me off. Sorry for the trouble."

"Oh, no trouble at all. I will see you at school," she waved.

"Thanks again," he said before shutting the door.

Story walked around the car and headed for the entrance. When he got to the door, he turned around and waved goodbye to Rarity. She smiled and waved in return before driving off.

Once inside, Story thought to himself, "Wow. She was actually pretty nice. Wait, why do I feel like I am forgetting something?"

***

As Rarity entered her home, she felt the warm air escaping as she rushed herself to get inside. "Sweetie Belle!" she called out, "Are you home?"

"I'm coming!" a voice shouted back. After listening to the pitter-patter of her sister's feet, a girl with curly light and dark purple hair appeared. "Hey Rarity," she said, "How was school today?"

"Oh the usual really," Rarity replied as she removed her shoes.

"I like the new scarf you got," said Sweetie.

"New scarf?" Rarity suddenly realized that she was still wearing the scarf that Story had lent her. "Oh no. I forgot to give it back."

"What back? The scarf?" asked Sweetie.

"Yes. This boy I met was nice enough to loan it to me and I forgot to give it back."

Sweetie gasped, "Rarity, did you get a boyfriend?"

"No no. Nothing like that. He was just being a gentleman that's all. Can you be a dear and take this cart to my room?"

With a slight pout, Sweetie Belle took the bag as requested and rolled off.

Rarity's attention went back to the scarf. "That was nice of him. It is soft and warm," she thought to herself. She then took off her jacket and the scarf to hang on the nearest hooks. "I have to be sure to return that to him. I should probably wash it too." She then walked to her room, only to find Sweetie Belle on the floor picking up a pile of papers. "Sweetie Belle! What happened?"

"I'm sorry Rarity. One of the wheels broke off your cart and everything fell out," said Sweetie with her puppy green eyes.

Rarity sighed, "No it's okay Sweetie. I suppose it was time to replace it anyway." Rarity kneeled down to help her sister clean up. While cleaning, she picked up her drawing pad. She then flipped the pages to her latest design. "Ugh, I still don't know what I'm going to do about y-," she cut herself off. Something clicked inside like a light bulb turned on. Everything in her mind seemed clear and bright as a new idea came in mind. "That's it!"

Author's Note

Hello readers!

I'm sorry this took a while, but work schedule and writer's block suck.

I finally got back to it and I hope you all enjoy it!