Return of the Melody

by Thunder Star

Rating: everyone
Tags: Princess Celestia, Twilight Sparkle, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Rainbow Dash, Original Character, Mystery, Noteworthy, Adventure
Length: 6977

He is known as Noteworthy. His real name? Patch Melody. When framed by an old enemy, Patch must hide in Ponyville as a simple pony. Meanwhile, a dark force threatens all that is musical in Equestria.

He is known as Noteworthy. However, there is much more to this 'earth pony' than meets the eye. His real name is Patch Melody. Once a prince from another land, he was the consul of music in Equestria. When he is framed by an old enemy, Patch must flee the castle and his old life. Hiding as Noteworthy, a simple pony in the background of Ponyville, he soon realizes that keeping his secret will be much more difficult than he thought. Meanwhile, a dark force grows, threatening all that is musical in the world. It is up to Noteworthy and his 'new' friends to save Equestria from a silent future. Along the way, they all realize that in friendship, there are two sides to every story.

This takes place right after Season 1 Episode 10 in the Main Universe
(The story is written to fit within the timeline of the show, inspired by all the appearances of Noteworthy in the background. Ever wondered why he was sometimes a cyclops or a pegasus?)
This story is the start of something much bigger. Stay tuned for more!

Published 2022-12-27 00:20:01 UTC
Last updated 2022-12-28 23:36:37 UTC

Two Sides to Every Story

The moon shone above the town of Ponyville and its sleeping residents. The distant sound of a hooting owl crossed the cool night air. A layer of late autumn snow covered the ground and the straw roofs of the houses. The snow, which was earlier than usual for the season, reflected the moon’s light across the buildings.

Near the edge of town was a particular run-down house with only half of the second story and many of the window openings covered in fabric. A faint light spilled out of an uncovered, first-floor window. One earth pony sat on the floor by a small, lit fireplace. His coat was a light cobalt blue, and his spiky mane was a darker shade. The cutie mark on his flank was two pairs of reverse eighth notes. The most peculiar aspect of this stallion was the pastel green pendant around his neck, with a glow of the same color surrounding it. A similar glow was holding a quill aloft as it scribbled across the pages of a large journal.

“…welcome to Ponyville,” the earth pony said with a nod of his head. He sighed in satisfaction, and the quill gently lowered down to the dusty wooden floor. The glow from the quill faded and then moved to one of a few pieces of wood in the corner. This was added to the fireplace.

Well there’s the end of this afternoon’s section, he thought to himself. Not my favorite day to write about, but hopefully tomorrow will be better. Definitely better than yesterday. Still gotta finish writing about what happened then. The stallion turned his journal back to the first page of yesterday’s entry. He concentrated his gaze on the page. Hmm, where should I begin? Perhaps some context on my current situation. The quill lifted back up, and the earth pony started by writing: “How did I become the earth pony known as Noteworthy, all the way here in Ponyville? That’s an interesting question I didn’t think I’d ever have to answer. This all came about because of who I am, or rather who I was in this case, and what happened to me as a result. I was not always known by this name, in fact, it’s rather new. My actual name is Pitch Melody, but Patch is definitely preferred. And the circumstances behind my current condition? Well, it all started…”

*** Yesterday Morning ***

The gleaming walls of the royal castle radiated in the late fall sun over Canterlot. A slight breeze chilled the already frigid air. Residents of Equestria’s capitol hustled about in the streets, rushing from one errand to the next. One particular cloaked pony scurried through the crowd, keeping his head down. He soon reached his destination, a small music shop with a sign that read Grandioso’s, and ducked inside. The ring of the bell on the door alerted the shopkeeper as the pony stepped through. He lowered his hood and lifted the cloak onto a hook with a glow of magic from his horn.

The sunlight through the window reflected off of the pony’s bright pastel green coat. His darker green mane was frazzled, and his tail swished around his cutie mark: a double pair of eighth notes. He wore a light cobalt pendant around his neck and saddlebags on his back. This unicorn also sported a pair of wings, the left one with a brass brace attached along the front edge.

“Greetings, Prince Melody,” the shopkeeper said with a slight bow of the head. “To what do I owe the pleasure?” The pony he greeted nodded in return with an awkward half-smile.

“Please, Mr. Grandioso, you know you can just call me Patch,” the alicorn said. “And stop with the bowing! I’m not really a prince here.”

The rust-colored unicorn let out a deep laugh. “But where’s the fun in that, your highness.”

Patch rolled his eyes.

“Besides,” Mr. Grandioso continued, “if Princess Celestia refers to you as the Prince of Music, that’s what you are to me.”

“Eh, that’s just a ceremonial title, no more special than the ‘Prince of Janitorial Duties.’ I’m more of a ‘consul’ of music. But I do appreciate your kindness.” Patch slid his saddlebags to the floor. “I have something for you,” he said, lifting a folder to the unicorn.

He removed the contents of the folder and looked through each page. Lines of musical notes were filled in underneath the printed measures, with chords and tones added throughout. “Oh wow,” Mr. Grandioso said. “Wait… isn’t this my music that I showed you a few weeks back?”

“Yeah, it is,” Patch replied with a smile. “It’s really well written. You told me that you’d love to have it be a full song. I created a harmony line to the melody, filling out the chords. I hope you don’t mind.”

Mr. Grandioso shook his head. “No, no, this is fantastic.” He flipped through the score and looked up, surprised. “How in Equestria did you find time to do all this?”

Patch replied, “you’d be surprised how much spare time I have after completing my duties every day. Just me and my job.”

“Don’t you spend time with friends? Surely they’d find it odd you’re helping some old music pony in this tiny shop.”

Patch sighed and his gaze wandered. “Nah,” he said with a dismissing shake of his head, “they’ve got lives of their own. A lot more exciting than mine. I haven’t known them for long, but I’d be lost without them. But hey, I still love doing this! Much better than acting fancy for nobles who don’t even like me. Which is also ok, I don’t like the royal treatment anyways.”

Mr. Grandioso gave Patch a reassuring look. “Hey, you’re young. You…you are young right? I can’t tell with royal ponies sometimes.”

Patch chuckled and said, “yes, I am as young as I look. No surprises here.”

“Good, good. Anyways, you’re young. Spend some time with those friends. Add a bit of fun or relaxation into your life. And don’t concern yourself with those nobles. It seems that not even Celestia can get their approval.” They both chuckled at this.

A bell chimed from the clock on the wall twice. Patch’s eyes widened in realization. “Oh no! Is that clock correct?”

“Perfect to the second ever since the day I bought it,” Mr. Grandioso said. “Why?”

“I’m late for my meeting with the princess!” Patch rushed to the door and swung his cloak and hood back on. “Sorry, Mr. Grandioso, I’ve gotta go! I’ll be back tomorrow. We can work on the score then.”

“Thanks, Patch!” the shopkeeper called after him in a now empty store, dust settling in the silence. He smiled. “Always on the run, that one.”

Patch ran through the crowd towards the castle. He bounded between vendor carts and ponies in coats along main street, the cold air stinging his face. All of a sudden, a gust of wind caught his hood and blew it back from his head. Patch barely noticed until the crowd recognized him.

“It’s Prince Melody!” somepony called out.

The crowd called after him, trying to catch a glimpse of anything royal. Patch hated when ponies did that. I don’t deserve this treatment, he thought. Leave me alone! His horn lit up, and he teleported around the corner. The group rushed past before Patch scurried away. The twisted alleyways were known to him well, as these escapes were all too common.

He eventually made it back to the main street. Patch reached a hoof up to his pendant. It would be so much easier to use a disguise, but he wanted to save those for true emergencies. Deciding to throw the hood back on his head, he continued his quick return to the castle.

He arrived at the front gates a few minutes later, and he removed his cloak for the guards to let him in. The castle’s front hallway was much warmer than the outside thanks to the roaring fireplace in the middle of the left wall. Patch sighed at the feeling of warmth before approaching the receptionist. He walked up to the older mare at the desk. “Hi, I’m here for…”

“You’re late,” the receptionist replied abruptly. “Pardon me. You’re late, your Highness.”

Patch cringed even more at the formal tag. “I’m deeply sorry for that, Solar Stamp. And please, just Patch is fine.”

The mare got up and Patch trotted next to her towards the throne room door. “As per the rule 10.18-a, any pony will address the crown and its relations in the correct title or…”

Patch gave a quiet sigh of defeat as they walked through the hallway. His gaze wandered over to the portraits of Celestia and Luna. These paintings showcased the majestic actions of Equestria’s rulers, something he could not compete with. Not that he wanted that kind of recognition.

The tall doors to the throne room stood before them. Solar Stamp tapped her hoof three times quickly, and then three times again on the door. When it creaked open, Patch walked in alone. The throne room was empty, save for the guards next to the door. One raised a hoof in salute and then stepped towards him.

“Good afternoon, your Highness,” the guard said. “I regret to inform you that Princess Celestia is away in Ponyville at the moment. There was an emergency, and she will be a bit delayed for this appointment.” He saluted again and returned to the door.

Lucky break, Patch thought. He could almost see Solar Stamp’s smug look at her silence on this. He decided to not say anything about the guard’s formality, since none of that had worked with anyone else so far. He gave a responding nod. “Thank you very much, sir. I will wait here for her return.”

He moved to the edge in the center of the room, hoofsteps echoing against the tall ceiling. Patch sat down on a cushion in a sunbeam from the stained glass window. Specks of dust floated in the quiet expanse of the sunlit room. The empty space reminded him a bit of home, but the memories here were much brighter. It did not take long for the warm sun to make Patch drowsy. He slid his hooves forward on the cushion and put his head down between them, letting sleep take him.

The loud clack of the door’s latch stirred Patch from his afternoon slumber. Based on the same guards at the post, he deduced that it had only been about an hour since he arrived. Celestia stepped into the room and smiled as she walked over to him. Her waving mane glowed in the sunlight, and Patch bowed as she approached.

“Rise, Patch,” she said to him. “I apologize for being so late. There was an incident involving parasprites and a little bit of misplaced kindness. Although Solar Stamp said my tardiness would not be an issue.” There was a gleam in her eye with that last statement.

“Well,” Patch said with a small smile, “I did kind of get sidetracked with something, and I lost track of time.”

“That’s quite alright,” she responded. “Helping citizens is always an acceptable excuse.”

“You knew?” he asked with a raised eyebrow.

“Well I usually find music lying around where you work. You spend quite a bit of time on that, after all.” She smiled, saying “That’s fine though, as long as it doesn’t interfere with your royal duties as a prince.”

Patch frowned slightly. “I’ve been meaning to talk to you about that. Is it really okay that I be called a prince? I mean, I appreciate the title, but this whole Equestrian royal treatment thing doesn’t really make sense for me.”

“Nonsense, Patch,” she replied. “It’s all part of our agreement. Besides, you are an alicorn. It would be against the status quo for you not to be considered royal.”

“Yeah, but I can’t even fly,” he responded, extending the brace on his left wing using his magic. “Just a glider, not a flier.”

“You’ve gotten used to that mindset,” she said with the same warm smile, “but the ponies here haven’t gotten that memo yet. As long as you keep putting effort into your duties, you’ll keep the honor you’ve earned.”

“Hmm,” Patch said with a slight smirk, “so if I don’t do those royal duties…”

“You get to go back home,” Celestia said.

Patch could tell she was probably joking, but he didn’t want to chance it. “Alright, I’ll keep at it. I do enjoy the work, after all.”

“Good,” Celestia said. “Now let’s get on with our meeting, shall we? You mentioned something in your report about musical magic?”

“Oh, right,” Patch said, “that magic. Well, I found something while reading Magical Wonders of Equestria in the archives. It’s similar to some other spells I’ve dabbled with, but I suspect there’s something more to them. The text hints at the potential to pull actual music from certain objects, kind of like a variation on that aurora spell I was practicing. In fact, I would suspect the structure of that spell might be similar to a music spell.”

Celestia listened with interest. “That does sound like a fascinating possibility. Is there any way to test these out.”

“Well…” he said, hesitating. “I couldn’t find that in Magical Wonders. However, I do remember seeing a book listed in the restricted catalog called Melody of the World, which seems like too nice of a title to be restricted.”

At the mention of this book, Celestia tensed up. “How did you get to see that catalog?” she said as her tone became more severe. “Those titles should be locked up!”

Patch flinched at this sudden change. “Hey now, wait a minute. The restricted records are right next to the main ones. It’s the books that are locked up.”

Celestia relaxed a bit, realizing her mistake. “Yes, you’re quite right. Sorry.” She took a deep breath. “I can assume that you want access to this book, am I right?”

“If it’s not too much trouble,” Patch replied hesitantly. “It might point me in the right direction.”

Celestia pondered his request for a moment. “Fine,” she said curtly. “But only for your research. I don’t want any incidents. These books are over a thousand years old. They contain knowledge that’s sacred to this land and others.”

“Well yes, of course. I’ll take extra care when handling them,” Patch said. He still wondered why her tone shifted that quickly, but he was glad nonetheless to get access.

“You’ll have to wait until tonight,” Celestia said. “The local school is here right now for Royal Story Time. Luna got up bright and early this afternoon to cover for me.”

Patch bowed to her. “Thank you very much, Princess. I will attempt to make the most of this research.”

Celestia exited the throne room without another word, leaving Patch to question why their discussion soured so quickly. I’m sure it’s been a long day, he thought. Perhaps a bad memory of some kind, or maybe she just didn’t trust me enough yet to think I could make such a request. Both are reasonable. With that, Patch left the room and trotted down the corridors until he reached his quarters. He threw his journal, some paper, several quills, and a scarf into his saddle bags. The massive archives tended to be drafty without a fireplace on every wall. Patch lay down on his bed and glanced around. He always felt cozy in the small, silent space. He then closed his eyes, contently waiting.

Once nightfall came, Patch walked down the hallways, hoofsteps echoing on the walls. He reached a tall set of double doors, with a sign above reading Canterlot Royal Archives. Inside, magic lanterns provided light to the expansive room. Patch walked over to the Restricted Access door and used the key that Princess Celestia gave him. The lock clicked open and the key disintegrated. Better make this count, he thought.

The corner was surprisingly warm, and he sat his bags on the table. He then unlatched and opened the balcony door, letting the moonlight spill in. The archives’ magical defenses provided a convenient barrier between the doorway and the cold air outside. He looked through the ancient texts on the shelves until reaching Melody of the World. He grabbed the book and set down at one of the tables, taking out some sheets of paper and a quill.

Patch turned the old pages carefully with his own hoof, since magic was forbidden in this section of the archives. He searched through the sections, hoping to find anything related to magic. Songs of old, conquering through words, exploiting minds through song…hmm, I can see why this might be restricted, he thought to himself.For the next hour, Patch kept skimming through the book. Eventually, he came across a section labeled Secret Spells and Songs. “Heh,” he said aloud, “something promising. I’m actually surprised.” He began to look through the chapter, until something fascinating came up on the page. “Aha!” he exclaimed. In an excited hurry, Patch grabbed the quill with the hoof-holder and started to jot down some notes. Writing was always peaceful to him, and this new information was the perfect cherry on top.

His peace was abruptly shattered by the sound of breaking glass. In the blink of an eye, a fire sprung up from the carpet in front of the balcony door and spread across the floor along the wall. The flames surrounded the outer edge of the room, and magic alarms started blaring, triggered by the fire. “No!” Patch cried, trying to summon a spell to quench the blaze. This only caused the flames to increase. “What’s happening?!” he exclaimed.

“Hahahaha!” The laugh came from outside the balcony door. Patch leapt over the flames and towards the doorway. Outside, a deep sapphire unicorn floated above him. She had a black, frazzled mane with gray stripes and a matching tail.

Patch was shocked by this unicorn’s sudden appearance, but he definitely recognized her. All too well. “Dissonance!” he yelled. “What have you done?”

“Oh, you really are a fool, aren’t you,” she called down to him. “Your magic will only increase the flames, thanks to the Equestrian origin of that fire jar. Watch as your precious texts burn, ‘Music-Mane’.”

“How dare you come here!” Patch yelled back. “This is senseless destruction!”

She put a hoof to one ear. “I’m sorry, Pitch, what was that? I couldn’t hear you. Oh wait, I just chose not to. Ha! So annoying, just like your music.” Dissonance cackled at this.

Patch’s sneer was intense as he quickly surveyed his surroundings. The fire licked the edges of the doorway, barely keeping to the carpet. What do I do?! he thought. He spun around to face Dissonance. “Why did you do this? What’s the point?!”

“Like I’d tell you,” Dissonance snarled. “Hmm, Celestia should arrive any minute now, just behind her guards. Who of course will see you standing in the midst of her sacred books surrounded by fire. Good luck explaining this to her.”

“I won’t need luck, Dissonance. I’ll tell her exactly what happened!”

“Oh yeah? Who is she going to believe? Her loyal guards who’ve stood by her side for years? Or you, a worthless pony from Iremane who felt lost and confused, needing confidence and friendship.” She spat these last words with indignation.

“With those, I will accomplish more than you ever will!” Patch yelled.

“HA! And that’s exactly what tonight has proven, right?” she asked. Then they heard the front door blow open and the fire brigade stream in. “Well,” Dissonance said, “it looks like that’s my cue to leave.” And with that, she vanished.

“Come back here!” Patch cried after her, but she was already gone.

“Patch?” he heard from behind him. He turned around, and found himself facing Princess Celestia.

“What have you done?” she asked in shock.

“I...it wasn’t...she attack-” he tried to say.

“Enough! Don’t try to lie with me,” she interrupted.

“But-”

“SILENCE!” she yelled in her Canterlot voice.

Patch shrank back against the wall, finding himself unable to speak. The flames still roared around them.

“I trusted you Patch,” she said. "How could you do this to me, after all I’ve done for you? It seems I was right all along about you, and I had so hoped to be wrong.”

Patch’s eyes widened in surprise. My earlier suspicions were correct, he thought. It was still hard to blame her, considering the scene she walked into.

“Guards! Get him!” she called out, breaking his train of thought. The guards started to corner him.

Patch stood there motionless, stunned by the sudden turn of events. He thought frantically for a solution, but he could only come up with one: he ran. He grabbed his bag and papers with his magic. For a split second, he wondered where the book went. However, escape was more important than anything else. He jumped over the first guard and bolted towards the door.

“Stop him!” Celestia shouted. “Don’t let him get away!”

Patch teleported to the hallway, and booked it through the corridor and straight out the open window at the end.

*** The Next Night (Present Time) ***

Patch stopped writing and set the quill down. He closed his eyes and took a deep breath. That moment in the archives; it had all happened so fast. There was no time for reasoning or questions. Why couldn't Celestia just give me a chance to explain my side of the story? Also, why would Dissonance come here, and why now? Patch thought to himself. Whatever it is, trouble is brewing. Perhaps it has something to do with my friends. Patch stopped for a second, and thought of his first adventure with a particular group of six mares and one dragon. He thought about writing a note on it in his journal, but that had already been covered. “A long story for another day” is all Patch decided to put under the recap writings he just finished.

What would Twilight have done here? he asked himself, before his heart sank to his stomach. Patch had just realized that he wouldn’t even be able to talk to them after this. I honestly can’t even call them friends,he thought dejectedly. We barely knew each other before I came here to Equestria, outside of those first few interactions.

Patch stared crestfallen at his book. Tears began to form in his eyes, and one fell onto the page. I’m alone again. Before he completely broke down, Patch decided to distract himself. I’ve gotta finish this journal entry. Just a bit more from that night. Then I’ll get down to business and find some answers. The quill lifted back up, and Patch started to write again. The only sounds heard in the room were the crackle of the fireplace and the scratching of the feather on the page.

Welcome to Ponyville

*** Yesterday Evening ***

Patch found himself falling through the cold night air. The archives were on the fourth floor, but the castle’s sheer height placed that window almost seven stories high. His horn lit up, and a light blue glow stretched the brace on his left wing straight out. Using his right wing for steering, Patch glided out of his fall and away from the castle. Unfortunately, he was not able to pull himself completely out of his spiraling descent. He landed in the courtyard in front of the castle doors, which burst open with a stream of guards running through them. Patch wasted no time in putting his wings away and bolting for the streets.

In a desperate attempt to lose his pursuers, he took a few turns down the alleyways. Luckily, the castle guards at this hour were less experienced and had yet to complete any training within the city. Patch realized that the best course of action would be to leave the city. Within minutes, he was sure that every guard would be aware of the situation and be looking for him. Stopping to catch his breath, he listened for the guards. Quick hoofsteps halted right outside of the alleyway hidden in the darkness.

“Look this way,” one said.

“He couldn’t have gotten far,” said another.

After the voices had moved on, Patch breathed a sigh of relief. He decided that heading to the front gate would be the best place to get out of Canterlot and go anywhere else. Luckily, getting out of the city unseen will be easier than getting in, he thought.

Patch moved southeast until he came to the front gate. As he expected, four guards stood watch. Living in the castle did come with its perks, as he remembered seeing a map of the outer wall in one of the rooms. He walked along the wall just away from the gate, remaining out of sight of the guards stationed there. If my memory serves me correctly… He pushed against the wall below the third lantern from the gate. Miraculously, a section of bricks opened up like a door. Yes! he thought in triumph.

Wasting no time to celebrate, Patch rushed through the secret door. The bricks slid back into place behind him, sealing from the outside. Only for exits, I suppose. Not that I can go back in. Realization just hit him of what that really meant. Oh my, he thought. What am I going to do now? I…I… Patch took a few steps towards the trees just outside the city. He stumbled forward, completely unsure of what to do. Where can I even go?

There was a sound at the front gate, and Patch saw a group of guards pass by it and inform the front sentries of the situation. Time to keep moving. The orchard just outside the city extended towards the cliffs, beginning just past the train station down the path from the main gate. The train was not running at this time of night, so that currently wasn’t an option. He couldn’t risk waiting in the station either; the guards were sure to check there sooner or later.

There appeared to be a commotion at the front gate, so Patch decided to run further into the forest. While the moon sat lower in the sky, it still provided enough light to see between the trees. He shivered in the freezing night air. Dawn was only a few hours away, but the winter air still chilled him by the minute. None of his shield spells would work against the Equestrian cold, so it was useless to try. Patch set his bags down and pulled out his scarf. Or he would have, if it were in his bag. Oh you’ve gotta be kidding me. I left it on the table. He took a deep breath and thought of the warm train station. There’s just no way, he thought. It’s too risky.

He reached back into his bag to check again when he felt another object against his hoof. He then pulled out his necklace, with the light cobalt crystal attached. Patch’s mind recalled the words somepony had once spoken to him: “When the time comes, you’ll find a use for this. Make it count!” As he held the crystal up, the moonlight shone through, covering his face in a light cobalt shade. “That’s it! This is the solution,” Patch said aloud. “I have no choice. To get the answers I need, I must change.”

He put the necklace over his head and took a deep breath. “Here goes.” His horn lit up with a glow, and his hoof tapped the necklace four times in two seconds. A tingle ran down his horn and down his back. He closed his eyes and felt small vibrations across his entire coat of fur. Then, the glow from his horn transferred to his necklace as his horn and wings began to shrink. The brass brace fell off his left wing. After a few seconds, the tingling vibrations stopped.

Patch opened his eyes. He was still able to feel the strength of his arms and legs. He held up a hoof, and stared at his fur. The bright pastel shade was now covered in a light cobalt color. He reached up his hoof and felt nothing on his head. Patch then turned his head and saw that his cutie mark was reversed and his wings were gone. It worked! he thought in quiet wonder. I look just like an earth pony! From green alicorn to blue earth pony, this just might do the trick. He took the pendant off his neck. It now shone a bright green like his original fur color. He put it and the wing brace into his saddlebags.

The air felt a bit colder than before, probably because of his now missing wings and horn. However, an encouraging thought now crossed his mind. Patch began walking towards the train station, the desire for warmth taking command. In the morning, I’ll get away from here. I must find Dissonance, or else my old life is as good as gone.

*** The Next Night (Present Time) ***

“…and that’s how I became an earth pony.” Patch set the quill down after writing about the rest of last night. The fireplace crackled as he considered his next move. He turned his journal to the section he had finished earlier that evening. Alright, he thought, I just finished writing about yesterday, and I already wrote about today on this page.

Patch thought back to the book he had been reading. He was sure that it was gone just before he ran from the room. The fire wasn’t too bad, and the guards couldn’t have reached it that quick. At least he had the notes from that section. Not that they were of any use to him now. With my current predicament, there won’t be any chances to practice my magic. The sad feeling returned to him, once again as a deep pit in his stomach. Adjusting to this was going to be more difficult than he thought. How could he keep an entire life a secret? I’ve got to find out what’s going on, he thought. The sooner I figure this out, the better.

It occurred to Patch that he had much fewer resources than before. Everything had happened so fast, and he didn’t even have time to process what he learned from the book. One aspect that crossed his mind again was the coincidence of the timing of all this. Could Dissonance be after the same information? Patch thought. How would she have known about my research? He looked down at his journal. Perhaps I should reread what happened today. I might find a hint on where to begin.

*** Earlier This Morning ***

WHOOEE-UUEET! Wheels chugged down the track as the train whistle blew. The late morning sun brought warmth to the chilly autumn day, reflecting off the trees that were starting to turn colors. The wind whipped through Patch’s mane as he peered out the window of the train. He was speeding along through the countryside, thankfully having enough bits in his bag to purchase the ticket in Canterlot. I’ll have to worry about money later; that’s the least of my concerns right now, Patch thought.

He sat back in the seat and closed the window. He had always felt at peace in nature, but today the green pastures whizzing by did little to calm his mind. What am I going to do now? Since he had managed to hide himself, figuring out what came next was a bigger problem.The pit in his stomach had remained as a dull ache. Patch sighed and rested his head on his hooves. One step at a time, he thought to himself. Being up all night had left him exhausted, and a solution would have to wait. He almost immediately began to fall asleep. One step at a time…

***

“NOW ARRIVING IN PONYVILLE!” The loud, magic speaker startled Patch awake. He groggily raised his head up to the window. Green pastures had been replaced by old houses with straw roofs, and the sun was past its zenith. Ponies were going about their daily business, a few stopping to chat with each other. A flash of light yellow caused Patch to duck below the window, before he remembered his disguise. Oh fanglesticks, how could I forget. All her friends live here, too. Perhaps I should go somewhere else. But then again, they might be in danger. Maybe I—

“Sir? Are you alright?” The attendant was looking down at him with a confused gaze. “I believe this is your stop.”

“O-oh, yes,” he stammered. “Thank you.” Patch swung his saddlebag over his shoulder and stepped out onto the platform.

“ALL ABOARD!” the conductor shouted as the train whistle blew.

Too late to turn back now, Patch thought as the train huffed away. He shivered as the wind blew through the station. “Of course I don’t have my scarf,” he said to himself. A bit of nostalgia tugged at his mind, as he was reminded of everything he had to leave behind.

“Better not stay outside for too long.” Patch started walking out into the plaza, taking in all the sights. The quiet atmosphere was much nicer than the noisy streets of Canterlot. Ponies here didn’t seem to care about trivial matters like princess sightings or what the latest “in” trend was. Most of whom he passed gave him nods of greeting or asked how he was doing. This feeling helped warm him up just a little bit. For the first time in a long time, Patch felt relaxed. However, that feeling only lasted another few seconds. As he was glancing at the row of market tents at the plaza’s edge, he did not notice another pony who was also distracted until they both walked right into each other.

“Oof!” he exclaimed, as the speed of the other pony caused him to fall on his rear.

“Oh my gosh! I’m so sorry!” the other pony said, with a familiar voice. He looked up and his stomach dropped. Twilight Sparkle stood in front of him, with her hoof outstretched to help him up. Patch looked away, fearing she would recognize him. Luckily, his disguised form seemed to do the trick.

He grabbed her hoof, and she pulled him up off the ground. “No, no. It’s my fault,” he said. “I should have been paying attention.”

“Well, it’s ok,” Twilight said, “Spike says I’m always in too much of a hurry. The one thing about dragon assistants is that they are always honest.”

Patch chuckled at this. He knew how much sass that little dragon was capable of.

“I haven’t seen you around here before,” she said. “Are you visiting friends?”

Patch could feel his heartbeat speed up, and he was unsure of what to say next. He couldn’t let her know who he was, surely Celestia would have already gotten word out about the incident. He decided to go with a half truth, only increasing his guilt. “No, just looking for a place to stay,” he said, looking away. “I’ve heard a little bit about this place. Plus, I’m sure my friends would want nothing to do with me anymore.” That last thing he felt was entirely true.

“Oh, nonsense!” Twilight exclaimed. “True friends understand when you make mistakes. I’m sure they will come around.”

Patch looked at her. “You really think so?” He slightly pondered on if he should tell her everything, but his mind kept the words from coming out. No, I can’t. I just can’t, he thought.

“I know so. I myself am still learning so much about friendship, but that much is certain.” She gave him a reassuring smile, until she glanced at his cutie mark. “That mark looks familiar. Are you sure we haven’t met?”

Patch’s heart was pounding so hard, he was sure she would almost hear it. His new mark was reversed, but of course Twilight would be able to observe the similarities. “Eh heh, I don’t think so,” he said with a hoof behind his head. “First time in Ponyville.”

“Well then,” she said, “My friend Pinkie Pie would be upset if I didn’t give you the official Ponyville welcome tour. She’s taking care of an issue in Fillydelphia right now. One we just had ourselves here a few days ago.”

Patch had heard about the parasprite incident when Celestia came back from Ponyville. That was the afternoon before the trouble in the archives. “The official Ponyville welcome tour?” he asked her, extremely relieved that she didn’t recognize his cutie mark.

“Oh yes,” she said. “I promised Pinkie I would cover for her until she got back. By that, I mean to show you what we offer here, especially to those who need a home.” Twilight smiled and the two of them began to walk through the town. Patch felt a bit more at ease with this familiar activity. They made their way into town, and Twilight started to sing (to the tune of “Shining Time” by Maren Ord):

“When you find again, you have lost your way
You will discover then, there’s a place to stay
Flowers are growing, the magic is flowing too
Here we will always say…”

“Welcome to Ponyville
Let’s watch the sun rise, over the hill
Soft rays are lightly, shining down brightly
Warming up Ponyville”

The sun was shining through the trees as the pair stopped by the park. Fillies and colts from school were outside having recess. Twilight and Patch walked along, and she kept singing.

“Feel the cooling breeze, from the pegasi
Friendly unicorns, with a gleaming eye
Playing earth ponies are making new memories
Spirits are flying high”

“Welcome to Ponyville
See all the stars through, your window sill
Welcoming places and friendly faces
Greet you in Ponyville”

The two hopped in an air balloon to view the town from above.

“Come along, begin your magic journey
Faithful friends awaiting down below
Harmony is everywhere
You’ll see that when we land
Home is found right here”

“Welcome to Ponyville
Rest here in places, and get your fill
We’re all here with you, and you will enjoy too
Your time in Ponyville”

She stopped singing and looked back over to Patch. “You see? There’s plenty of ways you can enjoy yourself in this town. While you’re here, don’t ever feel like no one wants to be your friend. Besides, you at least have one: me!” Her eyes widened. “Wait a minute! I didn’t even ask what your name was. Oh my, that’s embarrassing.”

The breath caught in Patch’s throat, and he almost facehooved when he realized: uh oh, I hadn’t even thought of a name. Gotta think of something simple and not very noteworthy. “Oh, that’s okay. I’m, uhhh,” he said panicking, “Note…worthy.” He forced a cheesy smile, holding in a sigh of relief. That was close!
“Well then, Noteworthy,” Twilight said with a bright smile, “welcome to Ponyville!”

*** Later That Night (Present Time) ***

Patch set the quill down and got up off the floor. He lifted the book back onto the shelf. Writing in his journal relieved his mind after a tough stretch. It allowed him to revisit the best, and worst, parts of the day. He would often read back on the first adventure he shared with his new friends before he was framed. However, all that was different now. “I am no longer Patch;” he said out loud, “I am Noteworthy, earth pony of Ponyville.” The only response was the sound of wind blowing the snow in the moonlight. Easier said than done, I suppose, he thought.

Running into Twilight earlier that afternoon was almost too much for him to handle. The weight of having to hide his problems from one of the few friends he had, perhaps the one he was closest to, only added to the issues already on his shoulders. Despite being so close to them all in this town, Noteworthy never felt more disconnected from his friends than he had since meeting them back home.

He stepped over to the open windowsill, peering between the makeshift curtains he put up to keep out the cold. The night sky shimmered above his head, thousands of lights surrounding the moon in intricate patterns. Luna’s work was still one of the best sights he had witnessed in Equestria. Much like the green pastures from the train ride however, the peaceful feeling of a starry night evaded him.

Noteworthy’s exhaustion was catching up with him as he let out a large yawn. He almost didn’t hear the wheels of the apple cart moving down the road. Two sisters rounded the corner with that day’s unsold product. He moved to the side of the window before they could see him. Noteworthy tapped his pendant, and a green glow lifted the blanket in front of the fireplace. He may have a disguise, but this house was still supposed to be abandoned. Noteworthy didn’t like the idea of lying to the element of honesty, so it would be best to not have to say anything. The thought of this caused tears to well up again in his eyes. He blinked them back and reassured himself that Dissonance had a plan for all this. When he found out, his old life would be waiting for him. I’ll be ready for you, he thought, just you wait.

The solid layer of coals was keeping the room’s corner warm. Noteworthy set the blanket and himself down on the ground, folding the other half over his cobalt, earth pony form. Just you wait…