According to plan side story: We owe you one

by Mpony1

Rating: teen
Tags: Sex, Bon-Bon, Lyra, Drama, Original Character, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Comedy, Romance
Length: 4989

Lyra and Bon bon wants todo something for S after helping them save Octavia from her arrange marriage.

Just a little side story base off The Buck It Bros, According to plan story chp.10 come and get your love. (Spoilers ahead go check out there story if you want to understand things properly).

https://www.fimfiction.net/story/416116/according-to-plan

At the end of According to plan chp.10 come and get your love. We learned that both lyra and Bon bon had a roll in the hay, with a yellow pegasus mare named Sunflower Shine A.K.A. S. After everything S put the mares through especially to Lyra, how did they go from wanting to kill her to sleeping with her???? Well this is my idea on what happened.

Published 2019-11-09 10:40:02 UTC
Last updated 2019-11-09 10:40:02 UTC

Giving her what she always wanted

Author's Note

This is my first ever fanfiction and my first tme writing a story in years, I do hope you give this story a chance and plz leave any feedback u can about the writing, so I can improve it in future stories. Thank you and enjoy 🙂

Giving her what she always wanted

[Hidden Gem Hotel Lyra and Bon bon Room 2 hours after the wedding crash]

“I’m just glad you two didn't get arrested.....anyway stay safe and we'll meet you and Vinyl at the train station tomorrow.....Goodbye Octavia.”

Bon bon hangs up the phone and turn to leave the bedroom walking into living room where S and Lyra were sitting on the couch chatting and laughing about todays earlier event. It turns out their mission was an absolute success, Octavia was saved from marrying that expressionless colt size stallion minitone, as the girls like call him. Her mother fully accepts her daughter for who she is and the two reconciled, and it seems Vinyl and Octavia talk things over and made up, everything was going great.

Bon bon walk towards the couch climb up and sat down next to yellow pegasus who just finish laughing after talking with lyra about minitone drunken rage.

“HAHAHA OH sweet celestia that funniest thing I ever seen.” says S. “I mean the way minitone acted after getting drunk was soooo priceless.”

Lyra chuckled some while wiping the tears from her eyes. “Yeah and who knows mayby this will be a good experience for him to learn to some emotion from time to time,” says Lyra. She noticed Bon bon sitting next to S. “Oh hey Bons, so what the news on Vinyl and Octavia are they ok?” Lyra asked, both her and S looking at Bon bon expecting good news.

“Their fine, right now there laying low at lara trofth house after all the destruction vinyls rocket powered bass cause, fortunately no pony was hurt just a multitude of food stands were destroyed, and there sure lucky Princess Celestia have a high since of humor, the royal gaurd was about to arrest them until she came and stop her gaurds , and let Octavia and Vinyl go free.” Explained Bon bon. Lyra and S both let out a relaxing sigh glad to hear that their friends are ok, before Bon bon continued speaking. So now that the mission is a success and their nothing else for us todo for Octavia, we can meet up with them at the train station tomorrow when Lyra and I along with Vinyl and Octi will leave for ponyville. Bon bon finished.

“Tomorrow!” S says with a little sadness. “your leaving tomorrow...that suck's and I was having so much fun to, wish didn't have to end.” Says S looking sad.

Bon bon reach out hugging her pegasus friend trying to cheer her up. “Hey now don't be sad, yeah it sucks that the mission over and it was working together again like the good old days but all good things must come to an end.” Bon bon breaks the hug and look into S eyes and smiled. “Also Vinyl and Octavia says Thank you for all your help, I want thank you to, you really made a difference by joining us and supplying all those gadgets and despite all the hiccups, I really appreciated that you stuck by us to the end.” said Bon bon.

Lyra with a hoof to her mouth cough into it to get S and Bon bon attention, once they turn to look at her, lyra put her hoof down turn to look at S with a gentle smile on her face. “S, I’m still a bit peeved after all your crazy antics but I can still see that you pull your weight and did your part, you help us in saving our friend and for that I wanna say Thank you.” Lyra gave S a hug which S accepted it and hug her back, soon Bon bon join the hug to. After a couple moments the three mares broke the hug and S look back at lyra and smiled.

“Your welcome Lyra.” S turns to face Bon bon. “and your welcome to Bonnie I’m always happy to help out a friend.“ S slowly turns back to Lyra with a apologetic look on her face. ”And lyra I want to say I’m sorry for all the trouble I cause you, with the whole constantly flirting with Bon bon, even though she's married to you, and tricking you out of the Skytanic mission.” S takes a deep breath. “I would never try and steal Bon bon away from you nor would I constantly flirt with her like that if I knew she really wasn't ok with it...though I admit spanking her on the flank...twice, was pushing it to far. You see I still have feelings for Bon bon but I learned to move on and accept that I am not her special somepony, but she still wants to remain best friends.“ S with a gentle smile on her face turn to look at Bon bon then then back Lyra and said. “Im glad she did found her special somepony and its somepony I know will make her happy.”

Lyra and Bon bon couldn't help but shed tears at Sunflower heatfelt words. After wiping their tears away, Lyra with a warm smile look at S. “Wow, Sunflower...Thanks and apology accepted.” says Lyra giving S another hug.

Bon bon joins in to hug her friend again, “Yeah thank you S, you really are a true friend.” says Bon bon.

After The three mares broke the hug S, got off the couch, she took a few steps forward before turning back around to face the married mares.“Once again no prob girls, but now I think I should go and head on home, I’ll meet two at at train station tomorrow to see you off so until then ciao.” says S using one of her wings as send off salute gesture before turning around and walking towards the front door.

Lyra and Bon bon look on as S got closer to the door, then to each other, they didn't want S to leave, not yet! they still have something they want to tell her but both were to nervous speak up. Lyra gesturing eyes and tilting head at towards S, silencely communicating with her wife to say something to stop her before she leaves. ”Go on say something, this was your idea.” Lyra Thought.

Bon bon had nervous embarrass look to her face, she can tell Lyra wanted her speak up since this was her idea. She turn to see S about grab the door handle and just when S touch it Bon bon called out to her. “S WAIT!” Bon bon got off the couch and ran to S stopping a few feet from her. S turn around looking at the Bon bon who have a silly looking smile on her face.

“What's up, Is something wrong?” S Question S.

“No nothing wrong it just I...I mean we want to ask you something.” says Bon bon. She turn to Lyra who is still sitting on couch also looking nervous. “Come on its best we sit down for this.” says Bon bon looking back to S and gesturing her to follow. The two ex spies went back to living room to the couch, returning back to the spots they sat in earlier. Once both mares were comfortable, S decided to speak up first.

“So what is it you two want to ask me?” asked S looking at the two mares she sat between.

Lyra turn her head looking away from S to try and hide the growing blush on her face. Bon bon, though feeling both nervous and embarrass keeps her cool by taking few deep breaths, once she felt relax enough she turn to look at her pegasus friend and began to speak. “Ok Sunflower here's the thing, remember earlier back at the castle after Vinyl and Octavia made their daring escape, the three us went to use the restroom, but since you finished first you left togo wait at the castle entrance for us.” Sunflower nodded. “Well you see me and Lyra had a little.....discussion about you, that we want tell you adout.” said Bon bon scratching the back of her head a bit before putting her hoof back down. Lyra laid her head on the back of the couch both forelegs covering her face. Both Lyra and Bon bon embarrass reactions did not go unotice to S, as it only made her more curious.

“What is it you two talk about after I left?” asked S. Lyra sat back up, hooves off her face, and sat properly she turn and lean forward a bit to look at Bon bon, with smile Lyra nodded to her wife, giving her the ok to continue. Bon bon nodded back to Lyra, took another deep breath and Began to answer S question.

[2 HOURS AGO CANTERLOT CASTLE, MARES PUBLIC RESTROOM]

“I'll wait for you girls at main entrance ok.” says S after drying off her forehooves and throwing her paper towel in he trash.

"OK!” says Bon bon from inside one of the stalls. S then walks out of restroom and heads towards the castle entrance. Lyra and Bon bon are now the only two mares in restroom now both in their own separate stalls doing their business. Bon bon had finish her business 2 minutes ago, she just been taking the time to think. “Ok by the look of things I say our mission was a success, we saved Octavia from her arrange marriage and just before we all leave to head back to ponyville tomorrow.” thought Bon bon, she heard Lyra flush the toilet in the stall next to her and walk out towards the sinks to wash her hooves. Bon bon did the same, she hop off the toilet flush it and walk out of the stall to the sink next to lyra and wash her hooves as well, all while still deep in thought. ”And then their S, she been a really big help it would be wrong to just leave without showing her some appreciation some way to thank her for all she's done, It need be something big something she'll love, but what.”Lyra and Bon bon finished washing their hooves, there are two separate paper towel dispenser face to face with one another on opposite walls, both mares chose one, grab a few paper towels and started drying off their hooves. Bon bon continued her thought process. ”What could we do for her at the last minute, DANG IT I was so focus on the mission I didn't think todo anything for S until now....Come on Sweetie Drops think there must be something you could give S, Something....you....could............”Bon bon froze after an idea pop in her head, her cheeks started to turn red as she finish drying her hooves and tossing the used paper towels in the trash can. The idea she just had was crazy, hell just suggesting it was bat shit insane, but it was the only thing she could think of that would definitely make S very happy. It was their last day in Canterlot their last chance to make sure S gets something in return for all she done for them. Bon bon knew exactly what S wanted she just hope her wife will be open minded to the idea. Bon bon turned to see Lyra long done drying her hooves and was about to start heading for the exit.

“Hey Bons if your done lets go.” said Lyra she then started walking towards the exit.

“Lyra hold on a second! there something I need to discuss with you.” says Bon bon. Lyra stop and turn back towards her wife and walk up towards her gettingin perfect speaking distance.

“What is it Bons?” asked Lyra standing there waiting for her wife response.

Bon bon had already formulated her whole plan in her head, now all she have todo is tell Lyra, who might not like the idea and probably get mad at her for even suggesting it, but Bon bon was confident she could convince Lyra into accepting her plan but she’ll cross that bridge when she gets to it. First thing first.

Bon bon took a deep breath and exhaled before speaking. “I just been thinking.....about S.”

“What about her?” asked Lyra.

Bon bon takes another deep breath. “Now Lyra I know this gonna sound really really weird and please for the love of Celestia don't take this wrong way just hear me out ok,” another deep breath “seeing how we succeeded in our mission to help Octavia, and tomorrow we will be leaving to head back to ponyville, I was thinking we should do something really nice for S to thank her for all her help. Now I know you still harbor some anger towards her after all she put you through, but you can't deny that she's been a big help to us, and I don't wanna leave without showing her how much I appreciate all she did to help save Octavia.” Lyra thought about her wife words. Its true, she's still a bit mad at S for flirting with Bon bon and is still angry about being used as bait during the Skytanic mission, slowly but surely she got over it. Bon bon was right S did help them out alot, and Lyra also believed they should do something nice for her.

Lyra look at her wife and smiled. “Your absolutely right Bons we should do something for S, though I don’t see how you wanting todo something for a friend weird?” Said Lyra.

Bon bon winced. ”That because I haven't told what it is that want to give her yet”. Thought Bon bon. Bon bon open her mouth to speak but was quickly interupted by Lyra rambling.

Lyra begins pacing back and forth thinking really hard on what to give S. “Oooookkkkk lets think, what could we do for her, hmm, the day is still young, so we have plenty of time to come up with something.”

”Its ok Lyra I know what she wa-”

”OOOhhh we can take her to her favorite Restaurant.”

”Lyra I already have an-”

”or to a theater.”

“Lyra!”

”or buy her a gift.”

“Lyra!”

Lyra stops pacing ”I GOT It We’ll just do all three.”

“LLLYYYYYRRRRRAAAAAAAA!!!!!!”

Lyra jump at her name being yelled out like that, instinctly pinning her ears down to try and block out the loud scream. Lyra turns raising her ears as she face Bon bon who have stern look on her face.

“Yes Bon bon.” said Lyra with a sheepish smile.

Bon bon takes a breath to calm her self down “ Now as I was trying to say, I already know exactly what to give S, but I want your help in giving it to her.” Said Bon bon.

Lyra smiled. “Sure Bons whatever you say, I'll be more than happy to help, and I promise I will do everything in my power to make sure your surprise for S is an arousing success, says Lyra full of confidence.” Bon bon wince real hard when Lyra said “arousing” Lyra doesn't yet know about Bon bon plan, but hearing that one word doesn't make her feel any less awkward.

“So Special Agent Sweetie Drops whats our plan of attack?” asked Lyra.

This is it the moment of truth, will Lyra get mad at Bon bon for this, will she take it the wrong way arguing her disagreements, barely giving Bon bon a chance to properly explain, or would Lyra ask for a divorce right then and there. Bon bon threw the negative thoughts to the back of her mind, Lyra wouldn't do those things without first hearing her out, though Bon bon do believe Lyra will no doubt argue against the idea and chances are she might say no, but Bon bon believe she could convince her wife in going through with it, but enough on what ifs, Bon bon will cross that bridge when she get to it. Its time to focus on the here and now, and maybe a little leading Lyra on wouldn't hurt, it would help ease some of the tension Bon bon been building.

Bon bon clears her throat “Ok Lyra you got to know S alot this past week, I told you even more tales about her back in our hotel room” a moment of silent. ”Soooo after everything you SEEN! her do and everything you LEARNED! about her what do you think is the one thing she wants more than anything in all of Equestria?” asked Bon bon. Lyra sat down on her haunches, tapping a hoof to her chin as she began to think long and hard about Bon bon question. Bon bon sat down to, staring dumbfounded at the unicorn in front of her. How could she not see the obvious, Lyra should of blurt out the answer right then and there, for Luna sake a brain dead parasprite could figure it out.

“Oh I know you want to help her start up a new spy organization right.” said Lyra.

Bon bon faced hoof. Though its true S did mention starting a new spy organization to protect Equestria to Bon bon a couple yeasr ago, Sunflower also drop the idea now that elements of harmony been doing a great job at it, they even recaptured the Bug Bear that escaped tartarus. But Bon bon told Lyra all that, So why would she think S want that.

“Oh Lyra, I love you but you can be really bucking dense sometimes.......Screw it.” Tought Bon bon, as she removed her hoof from her face placing it back down on the floor. Bon bon took one more deep breath put on a serious face and look Lyra straight in the eyes. Its time.

“I want to invite S to our bed when we get back to the hotel for a roll in the hay, finally giiving her what she always wanted from me, BUT on the grounds that you are 100% apart of it. Its just for today, a one night stand, and to make sure she has the best time of life, lets make it last as long as possible going as many rounds as it takes, we'll even take request from her as well. This is her gift, her night and we’ll make sure by the end of it she is 120% Satisfied and with our combined efforts I know we’ll succeed.....So I ask you Lyra will you join me in bucking Sunflower?” Bon bon face was as red as Big Mac coat by the time she was done talking. She sat there silent waiting to hear her wife answer, waiting for the storm she knew would come but Bon bon remain strong and patient despite her the embarrassed stern look on her face.

Lyra eyes grew wide her mouth agape, she paid close attention to Bon bon plea, heard every word but still couldn't believe her ears. Lyra shook her head to get rid of her shock face expression, she look down at floor, eyes closed and took a second to think about her answer. It didn't take long she open eyes look back up to her wife, with serious look on her face which frighten Bon bon, after what what felt like an eternity, and in a serious tone, Lyra gave her answer.

”Ok!”

Now its Bon bon turn to look shock, did she hear Lyra right. “What did you just say?” asked Bon bon.

Lyra instantly drops her serious expression for a simple non caring one and shrugged her shoulders. “I said Ok.” Lyra says in a tone that makes the situation their in not seem to be all that big of a deal.

Bon bon right eye lids twitch a few times before stopping. ”Ok......I just asked you to join in threesome with your arch nemesis and all you have to say is OK!” asked Bon bon.

“Yeah, I mean sure I was shocked when you suggest it, but that doesn't mean I don't know why. Like you mentioned earlier you told me everything about the two of you when you were spies, you were even honest with me about how you once thought about giving in to her advances but held back because you didn't have romantic feelings for S and wanted your first time to be with somemare you did love. And despite everything she put me through I could still see that Sunflower is a good pony.“ Bon bon was stun, she was not expecting Lyra to be so open minded about this, all of the earth pony previous worries vanish without a trace. Bon bon smiled. “And can I be honest with you to?” ask Lyra. Bon bon nodded. “Well you see......I do find S to be pretty hot and despite all the times she made me angry when she flirted with you, I admit I really liked it when she does it, especially when she.Spank.you...cough...So to properly answer your question, YES Bon bon I would love to join you in having sex with S.” Lyra face was just as red as Bon bon after telling her honest feelings.

Bon bon lean forward and gave Lyra a hug, “Thank you Lyra for being so understanding” Bon bon breaks the hug and gives lyar quick kiss on the lips”

“Anytime Sweetie says Lyra“ giving Bon bon one quick kiss.

“Now that's all settled we should go, S probably worried about us.” said Bon bon standing up.

Lyra stands up “Yeah lets head- grumble.....Hehehe think we could still fit in my restaurant idea?” Said Lyra.

Bon bon chuckle Yes Lyra, “come on lets go find S and see what her favorite restaurant is and after we’re done eating will invite her to our hotel room where will tell her about our surprise.” said Bon bon. Lyra nodded in agreement. The married couple left the restroom and trotted down the hall to the castle main entrance, where they spotted S sitting there humming a tune to her self. She was interrupted when Lyra and Bon bon step up next to her.

“What took you two so long did you had the runs or something?” asked S.

“Sorry about that we were just talking about a few things and lost track of time.” answered Bon bon.

“About what?” asked S.

lyra and Bon bon look to one another, faces starting to turn red before quickly looking back at S. “We.Were.Trying to figure out your favorite restaurant, so we could go there and get something to eat...our treat.” answered Lyra with a nervous grin.

S raise an eyebrow. “Really....you two spent like 20 minutes in the bathroom after I left trying figure my favorite restaurant, when you just could of came to me and asked.” says S being skeptical.

Lyra and Bon bon gave each other side glances as beeds of sweat started to form on their heads. eyes return to look at S. “We can get really carried away at guessing games.....Sooo what is your favorite restaurant me and Lyra are kinda hungry and want to treat you to lunch.” said Bon bon.

S calmed her self before answering and with a bright smile. “The Tasty Treat, its not far and the food is sooooo delicious, I always wanted to go back there again.” S bounce joyfully 3 times. “Wait are you asking me out on a date Bonnie?” said S with a sly grin.

“Bon bon frown a little. ”No S, we just want to get something eat, and treating you is just our way way to say thank you for all your help this past week.” said Bon bon.

“Yeah so lets go already i’m starving.” whined Lyra. The 3 mares trotted out of the castle and off castle grounds, heading towards The Tasty Treat. S led the way while Lyra and Bon bon follow close behind, as they walk both Lyra and Bon bon couldn't help but think about what they just agreed to, as what they're going todo later dawn on them hard. They both caught each other stealing glances at the pegasus mare flanks, both blushing real hard, as they followed S Lyra and Bon bon tought the exact same things in their heads ”SWEET CELESTIA WHAT DID WE JUST AGREE TO.”

[THE HIDDEN GEM HOTEL LYRA AND BON BON ROOM, PRESENT TIME]

“And thats what we discuss!” said Bon bon. Face still red from telling the story.

S, sat there between the two mares, watching them both try to hide their faces. After hearing the truth about their plans to pay her back, Sunflower couldn't help but give deviant smirk. Bon bon, willing to sleep with her and Lyra admitting not only how see really felt about her but was just as willing. S chuckle a little then turn to face Lyra.

“So Lyra.” S use her right wing to slide Bon bon closer to her, Bon bon did not resist. “You love it when I flirt with Bonnie hmmm.” S started to nuzzle Bon bon cheek then slowly plant several kisses on her neck. Lyra watch as her wife gasp and moan at the yellow pegasus affections, not taking her eyes off the two mares for a second. Lyra felt no anger towards S only pure excitement. S stop her kissing and turn to look at Lyra as she smirk at her, happy to see that lyra didn't turn away.

“Y-yeah I do, I really do!” Lyra admit. S smirk grew to a deviant smile. “So I guess this means you accept our offer? asked Lyra.”

S held out her left wing gesturing the unicorn to come closer. Lyra scooted her self closer to S, once she was, S wrap her wing around her, pulling Lyra even closer. “Yes?...I accept.” S gives Lyra few kisses on her neck, making her moan and shutter in pleasure. “And thank you both of you, you don't know how much this means to me, you two won't regret this.” says S she then proceeded to give both mares a single loving kiss on the cheek.

Lyra and Bon bon couldn't help but feel some regret with this plan but not to much to make them uncomfortable, S soothing words drove them to carry on and just enjoy themselves. Bon bon gently freed her self from S wing and hop off the couch “Bon bon turns to look at S with a serious expression”

“Just promise us S, that you won’t tell anypony about this!” Said Bon bon.

“I promise, I WILL NOT tell a soul, what happened at The Hidden Gem stays at The Hidden Gem.” Said S.

Bon bon nodded and gesture to S to follow her into the Bedroom, S gets off the couch and follows Bon bon. “Oh and Lyra, can go put up the do not disturb sign on the front door?” asked Bon bon walking with S to the bedroom.

Lyra nodded. “Sure thing Bons.” Lyra watch the two mares quickly enter the bedroom before getting off the couch and heading to the front door. The sign lyra was looking for was hanging on the door handle of the front door. Lyra picks it up with her magic open the door and hang it on the door handle outside before closing the door. Lyra then turn and trotted to the bedroom. When she enterd she stood there at the door as she sees Bon bon and S sitting in the middle of the bed, making out passionately. Their toungs fighting for dominance, both mare have their forehooves wrap around the other. S use one hoof to slowly carress Bon bon marked flank before giving it a slap, Bon bon broke the kiss as she moan from the strike as it filled her with pure ectasy. S noticed Lyra standing at the door, and with a wing silently gesture her to join.

Lyra did not need to be told twice, she rush up to the bed and hop on. Once she was face to face with S, the unicorn and pegasus started to make out, holding each other in a loving embrace. Bon bon watch them for a minute before joining in. Lyra and S happily accept. What started as a three way kiss between the mares, turn to both S and Lyra kissing Bon bon together, with Bon bon sitting in between them, Lyra and S plant kisses on her cheeks and neck this went on for a few minutes till S stop her kissing.

“Pant..Pant. Ok enough child play, its time take this to the next level, so prepare yourself girls, especially you Sweetie! S slowly licks her lips. I got alot of fantasies im just dying to make real.” S says in a lustful voice.

Bon bon gulp. “Ok, S Iets do this.” Bon bon crack her neck to prepare herself. “Lyra close the door and place a silence spell on the room, things are gonna get loud.” Bon bon and S stared each other down like their in a old western show down waiting for the sound of the bedroom door to be fully closed.

Lyra lit up her horn and began to cast the silent barrier spell, as she did this she turn to look at the clock. 4:36 pm, she crawled over to it and set the alarm for 6:30am, so to not miss the train which leave for ponyville at 8:30am. Once she was done setting the alarm and casting the spell, using her magic again she slowly close the bedroom door, the second it click, the long night of fun began.