(Takes place between LEGO Equestria Girls 7 and LEGO Equestria Girls 8.)

The Equestria Girls of Canterlot City's LEGO Team have defeated a number of villains over the years, many of whom later regretted their poor choices. Convinced that these former villains deserve a second chance, Celestia Playwell has decided to create a new team within the LEGO Team that would consist of these former adversaries, and assigns the seven Equestria Girls to go out and invite them to join this new team. Some candidates are easily reasonable, others are rather questionable, and a certain few are so controversial that only two of the Equestria Girls are even told about them.