Last Hearth's Warming Eve

Just an hour away from Hearth’s Warming Day, and the four girls had just finished forming their plan. They were set on getting the truth out of the three and knew they couldn’t just straight up ask them. Oh no, they had to be far more subtle about it. And they found the perfect opportunity. Breakfast, they knew that Night was always the one to set up the meal. But this year will be different, this year would be especially special. The four of them quickly flying into action as they set about their plan. Pewter and Steel handled setting up the batter for waffles, while Shadow and Black searched for the best possible wine. Drinking wasn’t a major part of the household, not for any moral reasons, but rather because they knew Night, Silver, and Dark couldn’t hold their liquor.

“How about this?” Shadow asked, holding a rather expensive looking bottle of wine. “It’s a decade old vintage.”

“No, no, that won’t do.” Black giggled, thinking about how much fun this would be. She wasn’t the biggest drinker, but she can be very playful when drunk. “Oh? What’s this?” Reaching far into the back of the liquor cabinet, the mare pulled out a strange looking bottle.The bottle was quite large, and the label looked worn away. Only a vague image of what could be Princess Luna's silhouette. Or possibly the Mare in the Moon, was still visible. While the liquid inside was a deep red, the bottle itself was a dark blue, giving the liquid a near purple hue. “I think it says ‘Boisson de la Lune’.”

“Boisson de la Lune?!” Steel gasped, her eyes lighting up in excitement. “That’s a super rare and expensive vintage.” Grabbing the bottle, she marveled at it. “There’s a vineyard in Trotsylvania that sells these Prench bottles. It means Drink of the Moon. It was supposed to be something to celebrate Princess Luna when she was still banished in the moon. Even the youngest bottle is nearly a century old, and this looks even older.”

“But will it get them good and drunk?” Shadow asked, not too knowledgeable on alcohol. “We need something that will act fast after all.”

“If I remember correctly.” Pewter exclaimed, vaguely remembering a little about wine. “I believe the wine does get stronger, but I’m not sure.”

“Oh yeah.” Steel coughed after uncorking the bottle, only sniffing at it. Her face already looking a little flushed. “This will do it.”

“Perfect, let’s get to work!” Black cheered, quickly joining in the preparation of the meal. It didn’t take them too long in order to set up the meal. With the four of them, it all worked out almost too well. “Yes, yes, this is going to be great.” But as she was bouncing around in joy, the sounds of three ponies coming down the stair was making her super giddy with excitement. “Oh! So exciting!”

“Good morning girls.” Night greeted the four girls, but his eyes were more amazed by the food spread out for them. “Looks like you did more than wake up ahead of us.”

“We wanted to make this year especially special!” Black smiled, spreading her arms to show off the meal. “So please, please, let’s enjoy breakfast!”

No sooner had Night, Silver, and Dark sat down, Pewter, Steel, and Shadow joined them, but Black brought out the wine, pouring a glass for everyone. But unbeknownst to the adults, their three glasses had a special thing placed out of sight at the bottom. Pills, nothing too strong or even traceable. Just something that would act only as a heat inducer. Not a full aphrodisiac, but something that can help put the pony more in the mood for sex. A perfectly legal, easy to obtain, and easy to overlook things. Once the three had full glasses, Black poured four more glasses, but took her time to let the medicine take effect.

Lifting the glasses, the mare could only smile as she saw that there was no sign of the medicine. Toasting for the Hearth’s Warming Day meal, the whole family drank their wine. Almost immediately, Night, Silver, and Dark seemed a little tipsy from the drink, but were unable to stop themselves from taking another sip. After a few more moments of enjoying the wine, the three were more than buzzed, they were borderline drunk. And they were not staying quiet about their thoughts. The three were laughing to themselves as they looked at the other four.

“You know, I was right.” Silver hummed, giggling between her words. “Remember what I said last time?” She gestured her hands across to her daughters and nieces. “They grew up to be so sexy.” After downing another gulp of the wine, she nearly breaks the glass as she slams it down. “We could have a family orgy. Wouldn’t that be so hot?”

The four mares were in total shock over what Silver just said; though they were also intrigued. The mare wasn’t the most soft spoken when it came to sex or sexuality. But she was a little reserved when it came to anything too person. Mostly because whenever she would get too into her own sex life, Dark or Night would stop her. But now the mare was set loose to talk, and neither her sister or father could stop her. While Pewter was speechless, and Shadow blushing a little, Steel and Black were listening closely.

“Just think about it.” Silver remarked, looking at her two daughters. “My girls are so damn sexy now. Pewter is so cute I just want to hug her between my boobs, and Steel is getting so hot I want to go down and taste how good she is.”

“Now now Silver, you’re getting too drunk.” Dark protested, though her tone only betrayed how intoxicated she was. “My daughters are hotter. Shadow works out so much, she’s got a toned ass you could make out with all day and never quit. And Black’s my bubbly good girl that any man would want to shove their dick in her, but not before I try her out.”

“Girls, girls.” Night said, his voice showing he was just as drunk as the others, but seemed to have some degree of control. “I don’t want any competition, all my daughters are beautiful.”

‘All my daughters?’ Black thought to herself, curious why he phrased it like that. “You know, maybe we should have that orgy.” She looked to the other three to gauge their reactions. They were blushing bright red and were almost trembling at the thought. “That would be so hot.”

“Then it’s decided!” Silver cheered, finishing the last of her drink before she stood up. In one swift, and fluid, motion, the mare lifted her shirt. The entire families' eyes opened wide in shock and awe as the mare’s tits bounced free, showing she was braless and her nipples were already hard and leaking milk. Groping at her chest, the mare leaned in a little to lick her own milk. “So, who wants to go first?”

But no sooner had she finished her statement, the mare’s eyes rolled back as she fell backwards. Night and Dark both tried to get up to help the fallen mare, but they too fell prey to the drink, collapsing in their chairs. For a couple seconds, the four mares looked at the three, mostly worried if they got hurt from the fall, but after hearing Silver’s small snoring, they all let out a sigh of relief. But now they had to get to the next phase of their plan, moving the three into the right positions. Though as they stood up, a sudden feeling of heat rolled through them. Possibly a mix of the wine they drank, even undrugged was still a strong drink; as well as what was just discussed had gotten them pretty hot and bothered.

“This couldn’t have gone any better.” Black giggled to the others, but before reached to pick up Silver, she turned to the others. “Alright, now we have to decide who gets who.” She then held out a turned fist. “Rock, Paper, Scissors.”

Some amount of time had passed, possibly an hour or two, before Night felt his eyes slowly opening and his senses returning to him. He could feel he was on his bed, it was a large cushion that he had ordered back when he and his two daughters would fuck throughout their pregnancies; it was certainly more than big enough for the three. The last thing he remembered was the wine, how it tasted better but stronger than last time. His thoughts immediately went sideways as his vision cleared up and the first thing he saw definitely got him both aroused and confused. Black was sitting besides him, her naked body already sending him a number of signals, but a tingling by his crotch caused his gaze to turn down. There he saw Steel, the busty mare had his erect cock sliding between her chest as she was kissing and licking at his cum dripping cockhead.

“Well good morning...daddy!” Black said, her tone showing a mix of playfulness and seduction. His eyes went even wider as he heard what she called him. But before he could say anything, she smacked her lips against his, shoving her tongue to rub against his as she moaned passionately in his mouth. He tried to lift an arm to get her to stop, but she was too quick, grabbing it and forcing him to grope at her own sizable chest. After a few seconds of this deep making out, the mare finally released him, keeping her tongue out in a playful tease. “Oh don’t be too shocked daddy, us four already found out.” She then gestured over to something happen at each of his side. “And as you can see, we’re having our own fun to make up for lost time with you three.”

Turning his head from side to side, Night saw that Silver and Dark were both having their pussies erotically eaten out by the others’ daughter. Pewter was buried in Dark’s pussy, while Shadow was flicking Silver’s clit with her tongue as she was rapidly fingering her gushing hole. Both mares were also awake, but were not stopping their nieces from their oral play. Rather the opposite. One was holding Pewter’s head in place as she slid her mouth from side to side, while the other was gripping at the bed sheets as she was moaning from Shadow’s amazing fingering. Night couldn’t believe how those two were so quick to go along with this, though he could also believe it as well; knowing how easily they could get turned on after having foals, and with how they’ve been teasing him all night.

This situation was happening so fast and so sudden, he wasn’t sure how to handle this. Black just admitted she knew the truth. But how did she find out? There was no way anypony would’ve told her, or any of the four mares. It was the wine, it had it be. It was the same drink that caused the threesome that brought about the four being born. But strangely, Night wasn’t as worried as he thought he would be. It was over twenty years ago, and in that time, cultural aspects have changed. Many families were being more and more open about their incestuous relations. Though not as many have admitted it has caused foal birth, it was assumed or expected after so long.

“So what do you think?” Black asked, leaning in to kiss at Night’s cheek as she started to whisper in his ear. “You knocked up your first two daughters, now you can do that to all six.” The thought did spark in his mind before, and hearing it from one of them seemed to get him more and more aroused.

“Whatever you just said Black, keep saying it.” Steel cooed, giving Night’s dick a few more kisses as she spoke, looking at her father with an alluring gaze. “His beautiful cock is leaking so much delicious precum. I can’t stop tasting it. You should try it.”

“Oh I plan to.” Black replied with a giggle, turning back to whisper in Night’s ear again. “How about it daddy? Want to fuck some more foal in your daughters?”

While he didn’t give a response with words or sound, his cock started to swell as it was nearing a quick orgasm. Steel could feel as her father’s dick was getting hotter and was letting out more and more precum. She only smiled as she kept her titfuck going, being more forceful in her oral, suckling along the cockhead and not lowering herself too much. Black saw this and was more than eager to join in. The mare was quick to lay across Night’s chest, letting her wet pussy press against his mouth as she started to lick along his cock between Steel’s tits.

“Since you already fucked Silver and Dark, well obviously, since that’s why we’re here.” Black explained, her words being somewhat scattered and muffled as she licked and kissed along the exposed parts of his shaft. “I think it should be fine if you fuck us too. Well, it’s pretty obvious you want to. Your hot dick is getting ready to cum all over Steel’s huge rack.” Reaching a little, she pinched at the mare’s nipples, making her squeal out a muffled moan. “See? She loves it, coat your daughter’s tits with your hot cum daddy!”

Night wasn’t sure if it was Black’s words, the situation he was in, Steel’s titfuck, or a mix of all of them, but that was the breaking point for the stallion. His cock stood rigid as his balls tightened against him. His cum bubbled up and coursed through the shaft, releasing itself into the mare’s mouth. But the volume being fired off at once was too much for her and she ended up pulling her lips off the cockhead. This happened just in time for not only her chest to be covered in hot cum, but Black’s face was also splattered with spunk as it fell on her. Though she did get a decent amount in her mouth as she extended her tongue.

“I think that’s a good sign that you’re into the idea.” Black smiled, giggling a little as she looked over to the others. “I think we can really get this party started!”

With that being what seemed to be some signal, the other three got more in depth with their actions. Pewter and Shadow pulled away from their aunts for a moment, only to somewhat quickly flip around and place themselves on top of the older mares. Before Silver or Dark could do or say anything, the mares were back to eating out their older sisters. Unable to hold back the pleasure it was giving, both started to eat out their nieces’ too, letting their more skilled tongues slide and fuck in and out of their tasty pussies. Pewter and Shadow let out low moans, both only letting it escape their throats in a muffled sound as they did not want their tongues leaving their mares’ sweet, wet holes.

Steel and Black picked up with own paces, the former now bobbing her head up and down her father’s cock at a faster and more maintained pace, while the latter turned around again to face him. He wasn’t even able to open his mouth long enough to let out a sound before his daughter started making out with him again. This time, she had her soft chest rubbing against his own body, and her hands were feeling their way from his shoulder to his sides. Wanting to do more for these two, Night knew he couldn’t reach Steel, but he was able to get to Black. Not only grab at, he reached his hands up to smack and grope her soft and jiggly ass.

“Oh daddy!” Black moaned, letting go of Night’s mouth as she shivered in the pleasure his assertiveness brought. “Are you finally getting into it?”

“He must be.” Steel confirmed, pulling herself off Night’s dick, showing it was a bit different than the last time. “Daddy’s gotten even bigger, and his cum has such a strong flavor. I could lick it all day and night!”

“Oh? Then show me what you got daddy!” Black said, almost demanding it from Night as she wiggled her flank at his touch. “I want to see what you go-ahh?!”

The mare’s words were suddenly interrupted by the feeling of Night’s strong and flexible fingers being quickly shoved into her pussy. WIthin the first push, he managed to squeeze in nearly three fingers with how wet she was already. Black seemed to only continue her wiggling, nearly starting to bounce herself on her father’s fingers with her movements. As well as this, she was beginning to pant, as if she was getting closer and closer to her own climax. This came as no surprise, she had been building herself up all this time, and Night was just that talented at making a mare cum; especially one of his daughters.

“Oh fuck, oh fuck, oh fuck!” Black moaned, gritting her teeth as she felt her eyes rolling back as she was reaching the point of no return. “Fucking make me cum! I wanna cum dadd-eeeee!”

Black’s mouth stopped any legible words, replacing any sound for the next several seconds with a near high pitched eeping noise. She shivered as the orgasm was coursing through her body. The mare wasn’t sure what to make of it. This wasn’t the first time she ever came, she’s had numerous experiences with a number of toys at home. But Night was able to beat anything she could ever buy in a store, with just his fingers. Her inner wall squeezed down on the digits, nearly preventing them from being pulled out. Her pussy was trying to claim her father’s hand for herself and keep as a toy. But Night was just a little strong, though the force of yanking himself free only caused Black to let out another high pitched moaning sound.

“Oh fuck daddy...that felt so good.” Black cooed, almost losing all her strength from the climax. “I need you inside me daddy. Right...fucking...now!”

Black didn’t even bother to check if Steel was still suckling on their father before she nearly plopped herself over his cockhead. Thankfully her cousin was out of the way, but it was by a close margin. Though the mare did give her an annoyed glare for having her delectable cock taken from her, the bubbly mare didn’t care. Even in her haste, and her sensitive, soaked pussy, Night’s dick was still too thick to take all in one go. She was only able to take in about half of his length in the first drop of her ass.

“F-F-Fuck Daddy!” Black moaned, leaning her head back as her tongue was hanging from the side of her mouth. “Fill me up! I want all my daddy’s fat cock in my tiny pussy!”

“Well, if you’re going to be such a cock stealer, I’ll just have to have my own fun with daddy.” Steel cooed, slowly crawling around her cousin to approach her father. Her eyes seemed to only make him more and more aroused. Once she reached him, she lifted herself over, making sure her chest was pressing against his face. “You can have a taste too daddy.”

Night knew what this meant, opening his mouth and using his tongue to guide one of Steel’s breasts closer. Within a blur of seconds, he was suckling on one of her nipples, making her tremble with delight. Reaching around with one hand, Steel pulled Night’s head closer to her, letting him do to her what her own future foal would do. The only thing she wanted to make this even more perfect, was to be able to nurse him with her breast milk. But she was getting ahead of herself. She knew she wasn’t going to walk away from this without being impregnated. So she would be patient. Though it didn’t help that Black was being very vocal about everything.

“Oh fuck me daddy! Fuck your slutty daughter’s pussy full with that fat dick!” Black moaned, feeling as Night’s cock was causing a belly bulge to form as it was sliding in and out of her body. Her wet hole was gushing out her sweet nectar, making her motions more and more slick, allowing her to bounce harder and deeper over the stallion’s cock. “Oh fuck me pregnant daddy! Give me your foals!”

Black’s words were becoming more and more erotic with each bouncing of her flank, which only made Night’s cock get harder, and that only made the mare want to bounce on it faster. It was a perpertual motion of father daughter fucking. The stallion’s dick was getting closer and closer to his next climax, swelling in size and his balls tightening against him. Black’s pussy seemed to have noticed as her inner walls were coiling around tightly, letting her warm and slick silky feeling hug at her father’s shaft as she was grinding faster and faster.

“Fuck, keep going daddy!” Black moaned, leaning forward, placing her hands on Night’s midsection to keep herself balanced as she was getting closer and closer to orgasm. “Are you gonna cum? Inside, all of it, give me all your cum. Fuck my cum full of your foals daddy!”

Whether it was Steel’s soft chest against his lips, Black’s tight pussy sliding over his cock, or even her sultry moaning and pleading, Night’s body was seconds away from another orgasm. Loads of more thick cum were churning in his tight balls, bubbling up as it was reaching its boiling point. Lifting herself up for one more time, Black dropped herself over her father’s dick, bottoming out deep inside her. The warm embrace of her pussy pushed him over the edge, his cock releasing its next heavy and thick load directly into her womb.

“Oh daddy!” Black cooed, leaning forward a little more, rubbing at her belly bump with one hand. “I can feel your cum looking for my eggs. I’m cumming from you knocking me up.”

“Well, it you’re done then.” Shadow said, lifting her head up from Silver’s pussy to look at the mare. “We all want a chance for him too.”

“Oh no you don’t.” Steel protested, hugging Night’s head against her breasts. “I’ve been waiting long enough. I’ll be having daddy’s cum in my pussy next!”

What happened for the rest of the day was a series of one position after another. Time blurred as it passed by. But Night knew he had to keep going for all his daughters. Especially since he knew if the four were anything like their mothers, they would be insatiable. For untold hours, he fucked each daughter, switching between them after filling them each with load after load of his impregnating cum. But while he was fucking each daughter full, the mares wanted to show off their own talents to him in an attempt to get him to pay more attention to them. It was a harmless competition, but it was exhausting Night; who more than once had to drink an energy potion he bought from a traveling zebra apothecary.

Silver was one of the most tame of the six mares, but she made up for it with her willingness to bring out as much pleasure as possible. She preferred to take Night’s dick from behind, bouncing herself against his size over and over as her face was pressed against the bed. Her moans were mostly muffled but they were no less arousing. Dark was more driven to make Night groan, having him fuck her as she rode his dick, leaning over him to hug him as she made her ass grind up and down his full length. This angle allowed him to rub his dick against the most sensitive spots along her vaginal wall, making her tremble in orgasm several times.

Pewter and Steel worked together when having Night fuck them. Both mares making out over his body, then switching to eating each other out, while their father shoved his dick in and out of their pussies. Even as he released his loads into them, the two continued to lick and taste not only their nectar, but the mix of their father’s masculine cum. It was a beautiful and arousing display, but it was the least active, with more mares seemingly being more into making out with each others’ pussies.

But this didn’t fully last as both wanted to have more personal time with Night. But Silver couldn’t help but have fun with her daughters. Steel laid on her back as her father pounded himself in and out, causing her large breasts to bounce with each thrust. But her mother was unable to hold back as she started to make out with the mare as Night continued to fuck in and out of her pussy. This kept up for several long minutes before he was able to release a heavy load directly into her womb with a hard thrust against her cervix.

Pewter was more into taking it from behind as well, enjoying the idea of being a bad girl as Night grabbed at her mane, tugging it back to make her feel the slight twinges of pain that were immediately drowned out by the immense pleasure. But like her other daughter, Silver couldn’t resist herself. Laying on her back, the older mare slid under Pewter as she was being fucked, reaching up around her back and pulling her closer so that she could suckle at the mare’s more petite chest. Her tongue teased at her nipple but it also caused her pussy to get so tight that Night could almost barely move his dick in and out. Raising a hand to smack the mare’s ass, he was able to keep fucking her until he released himself into her fuck hole.

Shadow and Black were the opposite, barely working together as they seemed to fight over who gets fucked full of cum first. Switching on and off the thick shaft, the two mares continued this until they were both sporting swollen bellies of his hot spunk. But this was more a part of their plan. But Night did his best to keep it as even as possible. Black being the most eager was also being the most greedy with his cum, not getting off until he came in her more than once. But he did manage to somehow get the loads he released in Shadow to be heavier. So while the number of orgasms were not equal, the volume of cum being pumped into them was as close as possible.

After they both had heavy bellies, Shadow being the last one to feel her father’s hot cum pouring into her body, they adjusted at Night’s side, pressing their bellies against the side of his dick. The two were on their knees as they wrapped an arm around both their father’s back and their own as they rub themselves against his cum and pussy soaked cock. Noticing their plan, the stallion played along, placing a hand on each mare’s shoulder, thrusting up and down between the soft bellies. Keeping up a steady pace, Night splattered heavy ropes of cum between the two, almost making a mare sandwich, with his cum as the filling.

The family continued their displays of passion until far into the day, and deep into the night. They only stopped when they were struck by fatigue. The younger four were the first to drop from exhaustion, and even Silver and Dark would eventually drop to Night’s side too, but it was after their made out with each other while giving their father a double blowjob. When all his daughters were finally too tired to do anything, Night laid back, his mind racing back and forth. His body was sore from the hours of sex, even under the effect of the potion he drank from time to time, pleasuring six mares as equally as possible was still heavily taxing.

‘How did this happen?’ Night thought to himself, though he already realized the answer. ‘I can’t say I wasn’t hoping for this. But I think this was a little too soon.’ But as he thought, he turned his gaze from one mare to another. The sight of all six of them, bellies swollen, fresh impregnated wombs filled with cum, and pussies dripping out any excess. He couldn’t help but let out a small sigh, smiling warmly. ‘I suppose it wasn’t that bad.’ For a few more minutes, he just laid there, the afterglow of his countless orgasms washing over him. Seeing each swollen belly also brought out a new thought. ‘If Silver and Dark’s pregnancies were hard to endure, will I even survive all six?’