How Anon Stole Sexmas

by The saiyan brony

Rating: mature
Tags: Profanity, Random, Human, Main 6, Anon, Original Character, Porn, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Fetish, Spike, Comedy, Pinkie Pie, Sex
Length: 18493

Pinkie came up with a fantastic M-rated holiday, but there's a grumpy Anon who knows he won't be pleased...or pleasured.

Another year, another few favorite holidays passing. Pinkie, however, has come up with a new, raunchy holiday in Ponyville. Adults only, no foals, because this is a party not for young eyes. There will be gifts exchanged like Hearth's Warming, but they're quite naughty, and you wouldn't share that in a family gathering, truly a holiday everyone can love. However, a certain human, Anon, hates this new made up holiday because of a certain situation, but he has an awful idea to ruin every pony in Ponyville's sexy fun.

Warning: The following will contain crude humor, sexual themes, foul language. Also certain characters are aged up for this story

This was a story that I came up with for kicks and is in no way meant to make fun or insult anyone or anything. So please when reading this story do so with an open mind a good sense of humor

This is a collaboration with my editor Codex92

Published 2020-01-01 11:30:01 UTC
Last updated 2020-01-01 11:30:01 UTC

Too lazy to name this chapter

Author's Note

Sorry for the wait you guys what with my two jobs and lack of rest it took me way longer to get this finished. I orginally wanted to have this done before the new year, but something is better then nothing. This is also my first time trying this out so I hope you like what me and my editor Codex92 put together.

Also for later.

Red= me
Blue= Codex92

Too lazy to name this chapter

Hearth's Warming has come and gone, this year was quick and done. In the town of Ponyville, all the foals opened their every gift, but when it was mostly clothes, they were rightfully miffed.

With their holiday over, the foals ready to visit relatives with their pack, while the folks are waiting eagerly to go crazy in or out of the sack. The parents grew excited with their kids gone for the day, this annual event leaving them overly gay.

But just because the foals were gone, that doesn't mean the adults couldn't have their own fun, as a special holiday made by Ponyville's local sweetie Pinkie, had made up a new holiday that no one had missed known as Sexmas.

It was three years ago from today, when the pink party pony came up with this new holiday. A holiday for the grown and adults who were once young, a day for these young stallions to show how well they're hung. At first, it was a laughable idea that most thought was a joke, but when Pinkie explained in fine detail, some were left baffled, and some almost croaked. It came out of nowhere in the drop of a hat (ironically, she made up such a holiday like that, in fact) The ponies were skeptical at first, but then she sang a few catchy verses. The ponies were somewhat excited, including couples of the same sexes.

At first, it was messy, and a bit of a chore, but with some hard work and lube, everypony was having fun acting like a sex-crazed whore. The holiday was well loved, and a total success, and everyone didn't have to worry about sexual arrest.

(Now for those reading this far yes the rhymes are bad, which we know could make some of you sad, but don't be a prick and go suck a dick)

But not all were amused by this holiday of sexual lust, for two bachelor's found this day a total bust. Far off near the Everfree edge lived a fellow who house was closed to a ledge. In this house was no pony, and he definitely was no brony. It was a human man named anon, he wore a black shirt with a picture of Tron. He had grey pants that were covered in grime, with a face as green as a lime. He despised the holiday, the whole Sexmas lot.

Now please don't ask us why, we couldn't tell if we try. It could be that his pants squeezed his butt so much that he couldn't easily nut. Without any internet porn, he had nothing to sate his lower horn. But we think the most likely reason of all, was that his cock was too sizes two small.

But he wasn't alone, as another shared in the holiday dislike, that honor goes to one of his friends, a young dragon named Spike. Some would ask why this drake feels so much rage, but he was allowed to celebrate, considering his age. No, Spike was pissed outright, because the mare he liked was a total dyke.

Ok, this is getting a little bit frustrating

....dude what the heck I'm narrating?

Yeah, but do you have any idea how difficult it is to try and fix up your rhyming? I'm editing your "narrating", and I'm pulling my hair out seeing the lines going all over the place without any rhythm!

Uh….guys?

Bro come on I'm practically doing all the rhymes your just adding a few words to mine. Besides this a parody its fine if it suchs I even made that joke about the reader to go such a
dick.

You guys?

That's kind of rude, first of all. And second, I doubt you even look at a thesaurus to check which words you can use AND make a rhyme. You use the same word to rhyme, which I have to fix, I mull over other different rhymes to at least try to make it sound entertaining, and if Dr. Seuss were around to read this parody, he'd say you were a lost cause at being a poet.

Equestria to bronies?

Oh big talk coming from the guy who said he had a hard time coming up with some rhymes for any scene with Zecora for his KH story!!

GUYS!!!

WHAT, PINKIE!!!

WHAT, PINKIE!!!

Are we gonna continue the story? I want to get to the good stuff before the reader quits on us?

.......look how about we drop the rhyming thing and only use it when it's easiest?

...Fine. Saves me the trouble of finding the right words with the right meanings to make it sound like a decent rhyme…

....we good bro?

Yeah. Sorry, man.

It's fine, I'm sorry too dude.

*sniffling* That was beautiful, now kiss!!

Fuck no!! No homo!!!

Fuck no!! No homo!!!

"Ahh. Another fucking year of that stupid, ridiculous holiday." Anon groaned as he glares over at the town as they set up for the raunchy holiday.

"You're just angry ‘cause you can't get laid." Spike added as he brought over two cups of hot apple cider. "You really should just let it go dude."

"Says the dragon who can't except that the mare he likes is dating Applejack." Anon shot back with a smirk, causing the young drake to shot him a glare.

"Hey, if I had been the right age when I met her, I would have had a chance!!"

"Yeah, sure you would've. But let's not fight. I'm already upset that tomorrow is fucking Sexmas. I swear I need to do something about this stupid holiday." Anon fumed as the last two years played in his mind. The first was embracing as he had gotten drunk while hanging with Berry Punch and tried to hook up with one mare, who laughed at the size of his dick. The second year was a total flop as well when he tried to flirt with the two spa ponies, but was too nervous to speak, and all that came out was nonsense gibberish, then ran away in embarrassment.

"Well, tough, dude. Weather you like it or not, it's gonna happen tomorrow morning. Not unless you plan to steal the holiday so it can't happen." Spike chuckled at the notion that sounded incredibly ridiculous.

But for Anon, a light bulb lit up above his head. That's it!!" He shouted with joy. "We'll steal Sexmas!!"

Spike looked at Anon like he had grown a second head and pinched the bridge of his nose. "Anon, I was joking. How would we steal Sexmas?"

"It's simple, my scalie friend. When everypony goes to sleep tonight, we will sneak into their homes and steal all their gifts and toys." For the holiday known as Sexmas, ponies would exchange items for sex and pleasure. From cock rings to rubber dildos and lube, anything that involves sex would be exchanged come Sexmas morning. "Once we steal all their stuff, they'll be too depressed to fuck, it will be a blue balls Jambari!!"

Spike, while supportive of his friend since he was the only guy he felt like he could talk to, didn't feel too sure about this plan. He knew almost everypony in town and felt guilty just thinking about it. "I don't know, Anon. I get you hate the holiday, but don't you think this is taking it too far?"

Anon only smirked as he was about to pull out his ace. "You’re right, Spike. What was I thinking?" He said in a fake tone of shame. "After all, we both know how much Rarity loves this holiday."

"....What?" Spike asked, confused why his crush was mentioned.

"Yeah. You and I both know that she always looks forward to this holiday to show off her relationship with Applejack in public for the first time. And how she teases all the guys by only having sex with AJ."

And just like that, Spike was furious. He would remember all the times Rarity would flirt with him to help her or any other male for that matter, and now she was gonna have public sex with Applejack only. It was more than he could bear. "When do we leave?"

====================================
(Sweet Apple Acres)
At Sweet Apple Acres, Big Macintosh cuddled with his marefriend, Sugar Belle. Their start going out with each other was a bit awkward, but it was obvious they both had a crush on each other, and thanks to the stallion's little sister, Apple Bloom, and her friends, they got together and are happy with their relationship. Plus, this year, Sugar Belle was going to take part in this strange, yet fun adult holiday, Big Mac being involved due to the sexual frustrations he had pent up since he spent a lot of his time with his siblings and Granny Smith to keep their orchard going.

With Apple Bloom gone with Granny Smith to visit relatives in Appaloosa for the next few days, this gave the couple a chance to enjoy each other's company in private, along with the Sexmas holiday.

"I'm actually kind of nervous celebrating this type of holiday," Sugar Belle admitted, her cheeks bright red in embarrassment after being told what happens on Sexmas.

"Eeyup," Big Mac said with a timid chuckle.

"I mean, I was a little scared when I...lost my virginity to you," Sugar uttered timidly. "But, around other ponies? And in a huge group without any consequences? It's...so awkward...but I'm a little excited."

"You're...not upset Ah've taken part in this before?" Big Mac asked nervously.

"Well, you do get a little pent up from all the hard work you do on your farm." Sugar Belle gave her coltfriend a seductive grin, moving closer and brushing her hoof against Big Mac's chest. That hoof moved lower, gently giving a teasing rub around his large sheath, hitching the stallion's breath and let out a low groan in arousal. The tip of his member already began to peek out as she moved her hoof lower to caress his balls, filled to the brim with pent up seed as they were twice the size of her own hoof. "I guess I don't mind if there might be another mare who wants to give you a taste..." She leaned closer, brushing her lips against Big Mac's cheek to whisper in his ear. "And if I get to watch you ram that big cock of yours in their tight pussies."

Big Mac grunted, elicitting a delighted moan, never hearing anything like this come from his sweet, adorable marefriend. And he was eager to welcome a threesome, foursome, or even the huge orgy with his beloved unicorn baker.

"E-Eeyup?" he asked, shuddering from the teasing lightness of her hoof coaxing his massive stallionhood out of his sheath.

"Eeyup," Sugar Belle answered with a sensual purr, the farm stallion's simple yes and no answers rubbing off on her. He couldn't relish the thought, only to whimper when Sugar Belle's hoof moved away from his shaft, leaving him blueballed. "But, I want to know that you'll still be loyal to me even with another mare...Or, maybe a stallion?"

Big Mac's pained expression from being denied more pleasure quickly turned to a grimace, his boner quickly shrinking back in his sheath at the thought. "Nope! No stallions!" he quickly said with a shake of his head. "Didn't like givin'...or receivin'."

Sugar Belle giggled at her boyfriend's reaction, making sure to keep other stallions away from him and go for her if they want to join them. "Ok. But after the orgy's done, you and I will still be faithful to each other, no matter who we do it with in our pile. Right?"

"Eeyup," Big Mac said without any hesitation, nuzzling the unicorn to assure her he belongs to her.

===================================
(In town )

The couple headed out to enjoy the brisk evening air together. In the middle of town, Pinkie was bouncing around giving ponies lewd presents, spreading that Sexmas cheer. Joining her, looking around bashfully near the fountain was Pinkie's twin sister, Marble Pie. She and the rest of her family came over for Hearth's Warming to celebrate, though Sexmas came up from the more energetic Pie, which disturbed their parents a little. They knew she could come up with crazy ideas, and didn't judge her for spreading joy in a variety of ways, but they weren't comfortable with the idea of sexual intercourse with anypony other than their spouse. They may be old fashioned, but Marble was a bit curious and decided to stay with Pinkie for a while longer while their family headed back to the rock farm.

"Come on, Marble! 'Tis the season to be horny!" Pinkie cheered, plopping a present that was clearly in the shape of a dildo. The quiet, timid Pie dropped the toy, her cheeks burning red, still nervous about attending this strange holiday. "I know it's a little scary being with a stallion alone, but everypony's gonna be going nuts when they nut! So don't be shy, and get ready for lots of creampies!"

Pinkie giggled at her sexual rhyme as she continued going about with her gift giving. While looking down at the phallic piece of plastic coated in wrapping paper, Fluttershy and Cheerliee had a little chat as they strolled through town.

"I'm kind of surprised you want to take part in this crazy holiday this year, Fluttershy," Cheerilee said. "You're not the type who likes to take part in group activities."

"I know, but I think I managed to break through my timid shell," Fluttershy said. "Plus, I have been...a little curious...and with a lot of my animal friends...you know..."

"I see," Cheerilee mumbled, Fluttershy already beginning to blush as she looked at some of the stallions still out and about before another part of them was out and about. "This is the second time I'm doing this. I came down with the flu last year, and I missed out. I really needed the stress relief from all the teaching last year." As the pair approached the fountain, Pinkie bounded near them, tossing them a couple gifts, and they spotted Big Mac and Sugar Belle meeting up in the same place. "Oh, there's Big Mac. And who's that? I don't think I've seen her before."

"That's Sugar Belle," Fluttershy said, recognizing the unicorn after meeting her in the old village Starlight Glimmer ran when she was in her "equality saves friendships" phase. "She's Big Mac's marefriend."

"Well, I didn't expect him to be interested in unicorns," Cheerilee pondered aloud. "Good for him, though. She's probably going to be a bit skittish if she joins us all tomorrow morning."

"Are you jealous?" Fluttershy asked.

(Not too far off in the background, Anon and Spike were sneakily moving from house to house with Anon pushing a large wheelbarrow while Spike was close behind with a quill and paper.)

"Oh, no, Big Mac and I are just friends," Cheerilee assured the pegasus. "I mean, the first Sexmas, we kinda got a bit mixed up in a pile we were in, and I felt him enter me..." Cheerilee shuddered, letting out a groan, clenching her hind legs at the incredible feeling. "He is HUGE, Fluttershy. I'm surprised he managed to bottom out inside me. Maybe I am a little jealous, but I left it as us being friends with benefits. And what a benefit it is."

"Oh...my," Fluttershy uttered, feeling her wings flare as she imagined the farm stallion's length pounding deep into her pussy, maybe even smacking against her womb.

Marble overheard the two gossiping mares, letting out a small gasp when she glanced at Big Mac. When she also saw Sugar Bell walking beside him, the unicorn giggling as she told the stallion a funny story, her heart broke when she watched the couple affectionately nuzzling each other, their bodies close together to share their warmth in the cold air. Even though the Pies and Apples were probably related, it was a long distance that spanned several generations, so it wasn't wrong if they had gotten together. But any chance to be with the stallion was long gone, Big Mac choosing somepony else rather than her as his marefriend.

Big Mac looked over at the fountain while listening to Sugar Belle's tales about her life, freezing in shock when he noticed Marble watching them, tears in her eyes before she looked away and turned her back to him, trying not to break down and cry. It was a surprise seeing one of his supposed long-distance cousins from Pinkie's family here, both of them being the quietest in their families, and he wasn't afraid to admit he had a liking to her before meeting Sugar Belle for the first time. That look she gave him made him feel awful, sensing she must have had a crush on him, but was too afraid and too timid to tell him how she felt about him through words.

"And that's when my cousin accidentally set the stove on fire, so-" Sugar Belle continued, only to stop her storytelling when she noticed Big Mac wasn't next to her. "...Big Mac?" Looking behind her, she saw him staring at Marble, guessing she was someone he knew. "What's wrong? Do you know that mare?"

"...Eeyup," the stallion said, his tone hinting a pang of guilt.

"Who is she?" Sugar Belle asked.

"Uhh...Long-distant cousin," he said. "...Not sure how distant or if removed a number of times."

"Huh?" the unicorn questioned, raising a brow in confusion.

"Ah know, it's hard to tell," he said. "Mah family and Pinkie's family are related, but our geneology trees to prove it are smudged, so...we may or may not be cousins, but regardless, the Apples and Pies are distant family."

"...I see..." As odd of a statement as that was, Sugar Belle took it in stride, but was a bit concerned with the way Marble glanced at her before turning away and trembling in sorrow, not cold. "Is she upset? Why's she crying?"

"Oh, Marble's had a crush on Big Mac, even though we're cousins, but it's not incest since our lineage is reeeeeeaaaaaally really far apart, or we might or might not be related at all and overthinking things, but I forgot to mention to her he was going out with you with all the world saving and parties I've been planning, including Sexmas!" Pinkie said, coming completely out of nowhere as she stood next to Sugar Belle. Big Mac winced, Sugar Belle was a bit shocked, but felt sorry for the mare, and Pinkie's excited grin faded to a frown with a look in her eyes saying, "I bucked up." "...Oh...Oops."

Slowly giving Sugar Belle a phallic present, the unicorn ignored the sexually themed gift. She approached Marble, not wanting there to be any hard feelings between them if the quiet Pie sister felt any sort of spite toward her for stealing the stallion she fell for.

"Umm...hello," Sugar Belle greeted. Marble winced, keeping her long bangs facing the unicorn so she didn't look at her. "My name's Sugar Belle. And...I think Pinkie said your name was Marble...right?"

"...Mhmm," Marble whimpered, taking in a shuddering breath, unable to run away in her sorrow and struggled not to break down and get picked on by the mare who was dating her crush.

Seeing just how sensitive the earth pony was, Sugar Belle gently placed her hoof on Marble's shoulder, making her flinch and let out a sob. "Big Mac and Pinkie said you had a crush on him, and...I can tell you're a little upset about me going out with him." Marble nodded, releasing a pitiful whimper. "I'm sorry. Big Mac didn't mention you, and I don't think he realized what he was doing when he was unintentionally playing with your emotions."

While Sugar Belle talked and tried to console Marble, Pinkie sidled over to Big Mac. "Prepare to be in the doghouse, stud," she whispered, making the stallion leer at her since he didn't mean to upset Marble Pie. "Well, you have any idea how many shipfics there are with you and almost every single mare? Including me? Or even Applejack? Which is kinda weird, you perverted fanfic writers out there."

Big Mac whinnied in shock, at first wondering what Pinkie was babbling about before balking in disgust when she mentioned someone writing stories about him and his little sister. He was snapped out of his horror when they heard Marble crying, but instead of running away, she buried her face in Sugar Belle's chest, who held her as the two seemed to have made up while the unicorn comforted the upset mare. At least there wasn't going to be any bad blood between them, he hoped.

When Marble finally calmed down, Sugar Belle had an idea, glancing at Big Mac with a smirk before whispering to Marble. After she dried her tears, her ears perked up with a gasp. She quickly looked at Big Mac, a huge blush appearing on her face before turning back to Sugar Belle, who nodded with a sultry grin. Looking back at Big Mac, her cheeks glowed as bright as the stallion's coat before looking back at Sugar Belle, silently nodding to her. With their private agreement, Sugar Belle beamed excitedly, shocking Marble with a peck on the cheek, which made Big Mac's eyes widen.

"Uhhhh," Big Mac stammered.

"Don't worry. We made up, but I proposed a little something to Marble," Sugar Belle said. "Since we're going to celebrate Sexmas, I asked her if she wants to join us for the orgy tomorrow." Big Mac's jaw dropped, along with Pinkie's as hers literally hit the floor with a gasp. "I don't suppose you have a problem with Marble joining us to start our little group, do you, Big Mac?"

(In the background, Anon overheard and made it look like he was about to puke as he walked back home, Spike pushing a mountain of equipment and items in the wheelbarrow, barely able to see where he was going.)

The flirty tone, along with those bedroom eyes and her accepting the start of a threesome for tomorrow made Big Mac salivate. He glanced at Marble, who peeked through her bangs bashfully, then back at Sugar Belle, giving her a stunned, silent shake of his head, not minding adding Marble if it meant making up for not telling her she was seeing someone else. Marble was elated, a small smile on her lips with burning red cheeks, unable to wait for tomorrow morning. Gathering the lewd gifts Pinkie gave them, her cheer back as she continued giggling and spreading more toys for the adults, Sugar Belle and Big Mac headed back to Sweet Apple Acres to rest up for the long day of debauchery with the whole town after giving Marble a fun threesome.

====================================

Soon, the night was upon Ponyville, and all the ponies said their good nights as they head off to bed to get as much sleep as possible before the big day. As the last of the lights went out and all was silent, Anon and Spike set their plan in motion. The two sneaked through bush after bush with while they pulled a wagon in toe, as they made their way to the first house of the night: the home of Spike's former crush, Rarity.

"Okay, Anon, how are we gonna get inside? The ladder, or maybe we could use that crowbar we bought earlier?" Spike asked as he rubbed his hands together, ready for whatever it will take to get his revenge.

"Oh, no, Spike, I have a much easier way of getting in. One that no pony would have ever expected. Mwahahah." Anon chuckles evilly as he pretended to twirl his non-existent mustache.

"Yeah? How?" Spiked asked curious.

"We will enter through…." Anon paused for dramatic effect before reaching his hand to the door knob, twisting it and opening the door. "The front door."

"..........What…..what the fuck!?" Spike shouted abruptly, quickly covering his mouth from his sudden outburst before looking around to make sure he didn't wake anypony. "What the fuck? You mean we’re gonna use the front door?" He let out a whisper-like hiss.

"Just as it sounds. We are gonna get in by using the front door. Ponies around here don't bother locking their shit up anyways. So what's not to understand?" Anon asked with a shrug of his shoulders.

"What I don't understand is if we were just gonna walk through the front door, then why did we buy all that equipment from the department store earlier?" He asked in a low, yet loud whisper.

"Oh, I needed that stuff for when I had to fix up my house after the snow melted away this year. And you were free, so I had to ask for help." Anon smiled as he walked into the house with confidence, leaving Spike to smack his face with his hand and drag it down his face before walking in behind his partner.

As the two entered the building, Anon pulled out a large burlap sack from his pocket and made his way to the living room of the boutique. There, he saw presents galore: dildos, lingerie, and bottles of lube all tied up with bows. He made his way over and shoved them all into the sack and did a quick check. "Alright, next we should check the girls’ rooms for anything else." He whispered.

"Right. I'll go to Rarity's room." Spike answered before making his way to the stairs, only to have his tail yanked, causing the drake to fall flat on his face. Her turned to see anon with his hand gripping at the end of his tail. "Dude, what the heck?"

"Like I'm gonna let you go to Rarity's room. You'll either A: mess up and wake her up because of your crush on her, or B: do something to her while she's sleeping and wake her up." He released his grip on the dragon's tail. "I'll get Rarity's room, you can take Sweetie Belle's room instead." He ordered.

Though reluctant, Spike would do as he was told as the two carefully walked up the stairs, leading to the bedrooms. Anon tip-toed his way to a door with three blue diamonds on it while Spike carefully and quietly opened the door leading into Sweetie Belle's room. Inside, the unicorn mare slept soundly with her face turned away, gently breathing in and out as she slept. With as much stealth as he could muster, Spike tip-toed his way in, looking around for any possible gifts. When he came up empty, he assumed that she had none and the ones they had snagged were all that they had. But just before he left, he took one last look at the sleeping unicorn and spotted a red bow near the edge of her pillow. Unfortunately, from this distance, he couldn't make it out, but he knew that no gift could be left behind, so he made his way over as stealthily as a feline.

Once he got close enough, he saw the end of a dildo was poking out from under her pillow. What's more was that Sweetie Belle was too close against the wall, and so was her pillow, which meant Spike would have to get onto the bed to reach out and grab it. He carefully raised one leg onto the bed, letting it sink in completely before bringing the next one up and resting it on the bed, then slowly and gently crawled closer to her, his body low. Once he was close enough, he slowly reached his hand out to grab the end of the dildo and tried to pull it out. When he heard Sweetie mumble and saw her stir, he froze in place, hoping she would not wake. After what felt like hours, she laid still and had moved a bit off her pillow, allowing him to easily pull out the sex toy.

But when he pulled it out, he found himself shocked. Instead of a stallion shaped dildo, much like any pony would want, this particular cock was shaped like that of a dragon’s. Something he could obviously tell with his own anatomy. So many questions plagued the dragon’s mind, so much so that he failed to notice his own member slowly sliding out of its sheath. He glanced back down at Sweetie Belle and noticed that there was a card from where he pulled the sex toy from. He pulled it out from under her and read it to himself.

To Sweetie Belle,

I saw you staring at this particular toy as we passed the sex shop while out shopping. I hope you put it to good use and imagine the charming young drake who's cock you yearn for.

With love, Rarity

After reading the letter, Spike couldn't help but feel his face flushed red, as well as sending some of the blood flow down south.

Before he could get off the bed, Sweetie Belle tossed and turned in her sleep, causing the young drake to remain frozen stiff. She turned around, accidentally brushing her muzzle against his hardened cock. The mare sniffed for a moment and leaned in, gently nuzzling against the dragon cock. She let out a happy little hum before slowly opening her eyes. Spike felt his blood run cold as he saw that his cock was right in her face.

The young mare’s eyes were half open, and she didn't seem to have any intention of looking anywhere else as she moved a hoof to gently stroke along the shaft, making the drake it was attached to wince. "Mmm...Rarity must have gotten me that dragon dildo I wanted." She said in a dreamy tone as she leaned in and gave the head a slow lick.

Spike had to bite his bottom lip as he felt her warm, broad tongue lick against his sensitive member. On the bright side, she was apparently half asleep; the bad news was that he had to keep himself quiet for who knows how long until she either fully awakens or goes back to sleep…He was hoping for the latter.

Sweetie Belle hummed happily as she continued to lick the head while stroking the shaft. "Mmm... It's really warm and it twitches….I love it."

Before Spike knew or had time to prepare, he felt his cock engulfed in something warm and wet. When he looked down, he saw that his cock was now inside Sweetie's mouth. He could feel her hot breath against his shaft as she started to slide it in and out of her mouth, coating it in her warm saliva while her tongue licked the underside of his cock. It took every last ounce of his will power to keep himself from moaning out loud.

For the next three minutes, he endured her relentless blowjob as she bobbed her head up and down, swallowing his cock deeper the longer she continued. Her hums of lustful pleasure only added to the mind-blowing experience, causing his cock to vibrate in her mouth.

Spike was slowly beginning to lose all control as his cock throbbed, completely at his limit. He bit down on his bottom lip as he felt himself cum in the mare's mouth. Sweetie Belle squeaked as her mouth was filled with the warm, sticky seed. Once she felt that there was no more cum filling the confines of her mouth, she pulled back, letting the cock out pop of her mouth, tilted her head back, and swallowed.

Spike panted as quietly as possible as he watched her lay back down. "Mmm...Edible fake cum…Best present ever." Spike quickly got off the bed, scurrying away toward the door. "I just wished it was the real Spike." Spike stopped dead in his tracks, face flushed bright red as he heard her, but left while he still could.

As Spike closed the door behind him, Anon came walking out of the room with a sack with some gifts he must have found in Rarity's room. "Damn, that girl buys way too much shit. And don't get me started on the gift she was gonna give to AJ." He paused for a moment, noticing that Spike was a bit sweaty and out of breath. "You okay, man?"

The young dragon's eyes darted left to right as he felt too nervous to look Anon in the eyes. "Y-yeah, just trying my best to get the job done...bro."

Anon didn't give it much thought as he shrugged his shoulders, leading the way back down the stairs. But as Spike was about to reach for the door, he noticed Anon heading for the kitchen. "What are you doing?" He asked with a tilt of his head.

"I'm a bit peckish, and I wanted to see if Rarity has anything to nibble on." He answered as he made his way to a cupboard. "We’re already breaking and entering, plus theft, so what's a little snacking going to do?" But as Anom opened the cupboard, he heard a low, menacing hiss and saw a pair of green eyes. Those were the last things Anon saw as it pounced at him and his face and vision was obscured by white fur, feeling a set of claws scratching at his face. "Ahhhhh!!" Anon let out a muffled scream as he was attacked.

Spike watched the whole thing as Rarity's cat, Opalescence, latched onto Anon’s face and started to use it as a scratching post. He watched Anon flail around, trying to pull the demon cat off his face while it continued to scratched his face. When he had finally pulled the cat off, leaving his face covered in scratches, the cat was still hissing and flailing its claws out toward him. "Spike, help me out."

Spike looked around frantically for someplace where they could stuff the menacing feline. He spotted the trash can, popped open the lid, and motioned for Anon. "In here!"

Moving as quickly as possible, Anon ran over to the trash can and shoved the cat in, quickly slamming the lid back on and grabbed a few cook books that were on the counter, placing them on top of the lid. "I fucking hate that cat."

"Let's just hurry and get to the other houses before the sun comes up and everypony wakes up."

===================================

And throughout the night, the two did just that. They snuck into every home and plundered the ponies' houses, stealing everything from rubber dildos, to bottles, even gallons of lube, and to cock rings, whips, and all kinds of kinky things. House after house, the wagon they pulled continued to fill up with sacks of the ponies gifts, until finally, they came to their last stop of the night. It was a cozy little house which looked like it housed only one. "I'll take it from here, buddy. You wait by the wagon and get ready to go." Anon whispered to Spike, who nodded his head.

Deciding to change things up, Anon circled back around the house to go through the back door. However, like the front door, the back door frame was small, making the hole that much so, too. Anon opened the door and slowly pushed himself in through the hole. It was a tight fit, but with a few hard pushes, he was fully inside.

He tiptoed into the living room to see that there were a few gifts on the coffee table, a vibrator and some lube. He made his way over, quickly stuffing them into the sack and was ready to end them all. But as he placed the last item in the sack, he heard the creaking of wood and turned to see that he wasn't alone. With pink fur and a blonde mane tied back in a ponytail stood the mare who had started Anon's hatred for this holiday. Her name was Mindy Lou Who, she was twenty-two so nobody would sue. She stared up at Anon with eyes as big as dinner plates.

For Anon, he held great disgust for this mare who ultimately made him feel small and inferior in more ways than one. But his hate wavered only by fear, for he was caught red-handed stealing from her. One scream or call for help and Anon and Spike were as good as done.

The mare stared at him for a few more moments before turning her attention down to the floor, shuffling her hooves against the hardwood floor. "I-I’m sorry." She spoke, sounding timid.

For a moment, Anon was caught off guard that the pony he was currently stealing from was apologizing to him. "What?"

Her hooves shuffled against the floor a bit more before looking up at him. "I'm sorry for what I did back when we first met." Some tears began to form in her eyes as she continued. "Before I talked to you, my friends had slipped me some really strong alcohol that was more than I could handle, so I was shit-faced drunk when I spoke to you and laughed." She began to sniffle as her eyes let out a gentle stream of tears. "I never wanted to say any of what I said that day, and never meant a word. I tried to find you the next day, but I didn't know where you lived. And I wanted to try and find you on the next Sexmas party, but I had to go to Manehattan because a family member was sick." She wiped away her tears and stepped closer. "I'm so sorry, Anon. I never wanted to hurt you…and, if you're stealing all my gifts to get back at me for that, then I understand...I deserve it. "

Anon wasn't given a single second to process what had happened as the mare turned around and walked back up the stairs. When she reached the top, she looked back down to give him a weak smile before walking back to her room with her head hung low.

Anon stood there, alone in silence with much on his mind. He had not only successfully gotten away with stealing from the mare who made him hate this holiday, but also made her feel guilty about doing so. He should feel great and overjoyed, but he felt no such joy and instead felt an empty hole in the bit of his stomach. Was he feeling guilty? Was he wrong for doing all this? He quickly shook those thoughts away as he made his way out of the house, tossing the sack into the now full wagon.

Spike could see that something was amiss with his partner in crime as he helped him pull the wagon back to his home. "Uh, you okay, dude? You're looking a bit glum, and more so than usual."

Anon didn't answer right away as they pulled the cart home with the sun slowly rising on the horizon. "Yeah. Just a bit confused."

"By what?" Spike asked.

"Well, have you ever felt certain that once you had achieved your goal, that it was done and nothing else could change your opinion?"

Spike felt his face blush a bit as an image of Sweetie Belle quickly popped into his mind, but he shook his head to chase away those thoughts. "Uh…nope. Can't say that I do." He spoke nervously.

Anon didn't give it much thought as he pushed his feelings aside, the duo moving closer and closer to his house and near the large cliff beyond it. The cliff had been made thanks to one of the many villains that had often plagued this world. But with every step they take toward the cliff, the bigger the hole in Anon's stomach grew and grew, making his heart feel colder and his mood too much to shoulder.

After a few more pushes, they had reached the peak overlooking the large drop that would kill anything that fell over it. "So...this is it." Spike added as he glanced over the edge. "One push, and we ruin Sexmas this year."

Anon didn’t comment as he looked back at the town, the sun slowly peeking over the mountain, and he could almost hear the frantic ponies panicking as they wake up to their gifts missing. After a while, he saw ponies running out of their homes, looking around and chattering among each other, seeming distressed and upset. He turned away, feeling somewhat upset for some reason, and moved to prepare to push the wagon over the cliff. But just before he could, the faint sounds of moan could be heard, carried on by the wind. It was a moan of pleasure and it sounded quite loud, and must have been to travel this far out. Anon walked back to stare down at the town and faintly saw what was amiss, for down below in the town, he could see that Big Mac and Marble Pie were having quite the time.

Anon was puzzled as he stared down and watch, for even though he had stolen their stuff, they still had enough lust to continue on. But it made no sense to him, because their mood should be so down that they shouldn't give into their lust. And despite his efforts, he hadn't stopped it all; he hadn’t stopped Sexmas from coming. It came somehow, or rather, it came all the same.

"How could it be so? It came without ribbons. It came without dildos. It came without lube and cock rings."

He puzzled and puzzled, till his puzzler was sore. And then, Anon thought of something he hadn't before. Maybe Sexmas doesn't come from a store, or to be well hung. Maybe Sexmas perhaps meant something more.

"We have to take the stuff back." Anom spoke as he quickly ran to the front of the wagon and started to pull leaving Spike completely baffled, but all he could do was shrug as he followed along not bothering to ask why.

====================================

(Just before Anon head back to town)

As dawn was about to peek over the horizon, Big Mac's internal alarm clock told him to get up and greet the day. He sat up, stretching his limbs before patting Sugar Belle, gently waking her up to get ready for the Sexmas orgy. While sitting on the edge of the bed, getting himself motivated, the gifts Pinkie gave them that they left on his side table were somehow missing.

"Uhh, Sugar Belle? Where did the presents go?" Big Mac asked.

"Huh?" Sugar Belle groggily sat up, not used to getting up as early as her coltfriend. When she looked at the table, knowing that was the last place they left their lewd gifts. "That's...weird. I thought we put them there."

They soon heard an ear-piercing screech that came all the way from Ponyville, and it sounded like it came from Pinkie Pie. Quickly leaving the house, the couple hurried into town, seeing the rest of Ponyville in the center of town. Some were complaining, saying that their presents Pinkie got her were missing as well, and Pinkie was in a panic while everyone began yelling at her. She had special cupcakes baked for the stallions to eat only, filled with a secret ingredient that keeps them rock hard and enough stamina to last a day at most, like a viagra without the harmful effects of staying up for more than four hours, but they were too miffed to bother starting the orgy with the mystery of their missing sexual gifts.

"What the hay happened to our sex toys, Pinkie!?" a mare exclaimed.

"They're gone!" another whined.

"What, you all think I had something to do with all this!?" Pinkie shrieked, flailing her hooves while on the verge of a mental breakdown. "Mine and Marble's toys are gone, too! And I made sure I didn't peek at what I got myself! SOMEPONY STOLE SEXMAS!!!!!!"

Gasps rang out as Ponyville was all in shock. The holiday was ruined by a thief, who somehow managed to go through every house in one night to take every single Sexmas gift. Even the recent young ponies who had become adults this year were mad, unable to celebrate no thanks to the lowdown thief taking everyone's gifts. Those who knew what Pinkie's adult gifts were in the previous two years were far better than the usual novelty toys sold in sex shops, and no one is able to use them.

Everyone was obviously upset, and Big Mac was a bit miffed that he was not only not going to celebrate the holiday with his marefriend, but the unfortunate cancellation meant Marble was unable to enjoy spending an intimate moment with him and Sugar Belle. He wasn't going to accept that, knowing that these orgies usually don't need those toys for everypony to gather together, enjoying the throes of ecstasy without the consequences of cheating on a lover, and releasing the stresses of their daily lives and troubled times without hurting others.

Walking past the crowd, he approached the table of erotic cupcakes, snatching one and chomping it whole. Everyone watched in shock as the stallion munched on the cupcake, pulling out the wrapper to keep the baked good's form as it rises in the oven, tossing it aside as he swallowed his mouthful. Everyone murmured what the stallion was doing, ignoring their stares and wonderings as he approached Marble, taking her hoof, and guiding her over to Sugar Belle, both mares wondering what he was thinking.

"This holiday ain't ruined yet," he said. "Whoever took the presents, they can't ruin what really makes this holiday important. Like Hearth's Warmin', only in a different way." Big Mac could feel the effects of the cupcake, his cock dropping out and already beginning to stiffen to full hardness. Many of the mares who were close enough to see his girth gasped in awe, Marble letting out a squeak as she had a much closer look, fearing this monster cock of his was going to tear her apart. She let out another squeak when she was pulled closer to him, feeling his hard, hot shaft brush against her forelegs, her tail instantly flagging the moment she caught wind of his alluring musk. "Ah ain't lettin' some missin' toys take away what Ah promised for ya and Sugar Belle."

And to Marble's shock, Big Mac grabbed her cheeks and gave her a deep kiss, taking her breath and the surprised squeak she let out. Her face was bright red with pupils shrunken to pinpricks, clearly caught off guard as she was making out with the stallion that plagued her thoughts with erotic wet dreams. Her shock faded with a delighted moan, kissing Big Mac back, her hooves daring to reach down and finally touch the unexpectedly massive hard-on of his. She took away her own virginity with a toy so she was prepared to feel him plunge into her pussy all the way down to his balls, and she was going to savor this moment as long as she possibly can before the day is over.

Sugar Belle didn't want the holiday ruined either, following her coltfriend's example and joined in. She joined her hooves with Marble's, adding an extra pair to stimulate the stallion more. He pulled away with a small gasp, looking over at his unicorn lover, letting her move in to the stunned gray earth pony, barely recovering the best kiss she'd ever had to feel Sugar's lips pressing against hers, kissing a mare for the first time. Her shock wasn't as big as Big Mac's bold move, immediately kissing the unicorn back with a moan, the sexy display making the cock both mares fondled feel like a rod of pulsating steel. Sugar Belle used her magic to force her coltfriend down on his back, both mare's adding their tongues to their erotic makeout session, swapping saliva and exploring each other's mouths, making Big Mac's tip leak out pre from the gentle hooves pumping his shaft and watching two mares going lip-locked in sloppy kisses.

Fluttershy and Cheerilee watched on the sidelines with the rest of the flabbergasted crowd. They were hoping to have their needs filled by the burly stallion, and just like how he thought, toys and sexy gear or no, the orgy must go on for the sake of their sanity to destress with a good romp.

"Screw playing with myself with a toy," Cheerilee said. "Nothing can beat a real cock, and I need his bad." She approached the threesome, Marble and Sugar Belle teasing Big Mac some more with light kisses and soft licks along his shaft and balls. Marble was a little hesitant, but Big Mac was a patient stallion, giving the two mares servicing him grunts to show he was definitely enjoying the attention. Fluttershy joined in, her mind blanking out the crowd that would watch them, which would have easily made her back out and flee from embarrassment and either hoof herself off or use a dildo. Cheerilee tapped Sugar Belle's shoulder, distracting the unicorn away from her coltfriend's cock, wanting to get permission from her first before butting in without warning. "Mind if we join in with you two?"

Sugar Belle looked at Big Mac, who was a little surprised to have a couple more mares he seemed to know wanting to join in. "Not at all," Sugar Belle said with a smirk, moving lower and giving the stallion a long, agonizing lick from the base of his shaft to the tip, giving his head a light kiss and licking her lips of any pre-cum she collected. Marble was content nuzzling, kissing, and licking his scrotum, her mind lost in a haze of his addictive musk, relishing his scent for as long as possible. "There's plenty of cock to go around, and I've been tormenting Big Mac last night, so he really needs all the attention he can get."

Given the mare's consent, Big Mac giving his with a hasty nod and a buck of his hips when Sugar Belle wrapped around her lips around his tip, giving it a light suckle, Cheerilee and Fluttershy joined the threesome. Cheerilee laid between Sugar Belle and Marble Pie, treating one of his testicles with a lather of her own spit while Marble suckled on the other as it filled her mouth. Fluttershy hovered over the stallion, laying over him as she looked back, wiggling her rump in his face, silently demanding him to eat her soaking wet pussy. Big Mac was taken aback by Fluttershy's boldness, knowing she was a pretty shy pegasus, but she was a completely different mare at this very moment. He didn't mind, her arousal dripping from her needy lips and landing on his muzzle, gripping her flanks tightly and pulled her rump down, immediately burying his face in her cheeks and attacked her vulva with his tongue.

Fluttershy gasped, which turned into a low moan as her pussy was ravaged by the hungry stallion she sat on, joining her female fuck buddies in servicing the delicious cock she'd been imagining all last night. All four mares took their turns blowing Big Mac, being patient with each other while sucking and bobbing their heads on his cock. After each mare got a good taste of his leaking cockhead, his hips quivered, struggling not to thrust his hips in whatever mouth he was in, Sugar, Cheerilee, Marble, and Fluttershy simultaneously ran their tongues up and down along his rapidly twitching member, covering every inch of it with their saliva, and he was ready to blow from the muffled moans from Fluttershy's luscious rump.

He exploded when his mares reached his tip, tongues lashing at his flare while they had a four-way open-mouthed makeout session. Big Mac let out a loud groan, surprising the mares as his first spurt of cum shot out and coated their faces, letting out satisfied moans as they tried to catch each volley of virile farm stallion goo, shifting his pulsating cock around so everypony got a fair share. Thankfully, the cupcakes Pinkie made for this holiday also kept the stallions sterile for Sexmas, so any mares don't accidentally get knocked up if they don't want foals just yet. When Big Mac came down from his orgasm, still rock hard thanks to his pre-orgy snack, Fluttershy had moved off his face, he saw his mares licking off any strands of cum that hit their faces or kissing while swapping it around in their mouths, the scene so erotic that it made the stallion's tool stiffen harder in arousal.

"Mmm...Wow, his cum tastes so good," Sugar Belle commented after swallowing her load. "I've swallowed a load of his or two before, but it's never tasted like this."

"It's the cupcake he ate," Cheerilee explained. "I don't know what Pinkie uses to make them, but it makes a stallion's cum taste really sweet, almost to the point of being addictive." Fluttershy and Marble appreciated the taste as well, Marble going back down on Big Mac's cock to suck out anymore of his essence, and maybe take a load for herself. Cheerilee's ears perked up, looking around them to see that everyone was getting back into the Sexmas spirit, stallions eating their cupcakes, and Pinkie realized that the presents she gave everypony weren't what made the orgies so important after all, already diving into a group and sucking a random stallion with her incredible deep-throating skills. "Seems like we managed to snap everypony out of their funk and got this party officially started."

Sugar Belle and Fluttershy giggled in agreement. They looked back at Big Mac, noticing Marble trying her hardest to deep-throat the stallion, wanting more of his tasty cum.

"Hey, do you two mind of Marble goes at him first?" Sugar Belle asked. "She was a bit hurt last night when she found out Big Mac was going out with me, and I wanted her to enjoy today with him as much as possible to make up for her heartache."

"Well, she definitely looks like she's trying to savor him like it's the last time she'll see him again," Fluttershy pointed out when Marble began rubbing her snout back down to his musky baby makers, a forehoof reaching between her legs to rub her dripping cunt. "Well, I guess I don't mind. And I'll take him after?"

"Sure, and then I'll let you go after Fluttershy," Sugar Belle said to Cheerilee. "Finally, me, and we'll keep alternating in that order."

"Sounds like a plan to me," Cheerilee said. "And my name is Cheerilee."

"Sugar Belle," the unicorn introduced herself, holding out her hoof to shake the schoolteacher's, only to be caught off guard when Cheerilee kissed her instead.

"On this holiday, we greet with kisses," Cheerilee purred, locking lips with Sugar Belle again, adding a bit of tongue before pulling away with a strand of saliva snapping apart from their lips.

Sugar Belle grinned, already beginning to like this holiday. Getting back to celebrating, Sugar Belle had to pull Marble away from her coltfriend's privates, hearing her whimper with need as she laid her down on her back. Cheerilee sat behind Marble, gently pushing her hooves down on her shoulders, wriggling and squirming her hips as her arousal leaked like a faucet, her clit winking desperately for a nearby stallion to fill her. Big Mac sat up, flinching before letting out a moan, feeling his marefriend's magic aura wrap around his length, slowly stroking it while guiding him over toward the helpless rock farmer.

Fluttershy then straddled Marble, wiggling her hips to entice Big Mac more, but Sugar Belle was making sure he started with Marble first. Marble whined, wanting to see Big Mac's face as he fucked her silly, but Fluttershy gave her light kisses, helping her relax a little, but still left wanting. Cheerilee sat down in front of the two mares, her pussy winking for attention, guiding Fluttershy up a little closer, keeping Marble down, and bringing her face to her sex. Taking the hint, Fluttershy gave Cheerilee's lips a small lick, pleasing another mare for the first time and slowly ate the teacher out, getting pleasant moans from the mulberry earth pony mare.

Marble looked up and watched Fluttershy lapping at Cheerilee's vulva, letting out a gasp in shock and arousal when she felt Big Mac's cocktip slowly rub against her pussy lips. She heard Sugar Belle say something to Big Mac, hearing the couple kiss before gasping again, feeling his tip slowly push inside her. Thank goodness she was wet enough and his cock was lathered in enough spit, feeling like he was going to split her in half with incredibly amazing girth. Her preparations for this moment paid off, Big Mac giving a few thrusts before finally hilting inside of her. As soon as he began moving, her whimpers of pleasure began to escalate into loud moans, the loudest she's ever been in all her life, and she was loving it.

Sugar Belle was content sitting beside Big Mac, slowly rubbing her clit with her hoof while watching his cock push deep inside Marble's pussy, startling their group when they heard the mare who was quieter than Fluttershy moan to the heavens. She even heard Big Mac grunting, feeling himself being milked by Marble's tightly constricting vaginal walls, begging his member to stay inside her and never leave. Sugar Belle let out a moan herself, finding the sight hot as she rubbed her clit harder, leaning closer to her stallion and locked lips with him. Using her magic, she gently fondled his balls, stimulating him some more, even teasing Fluttershy's pussy, not wanting to leave the next mare who will take him next.

"How does she feel, Big Mac?" Sugar Belle whispered huskily. Big Mac let out a low groan, silently giving his response while still pumping in and out of Marble. "Is she better than me?" He paused slightly, stammering a little while trying to find an answer that won't upset the unicorn. She giggled, only teasing him, then continued her act, dragging Big Mac's cock out of Marble's pussy, then lined it up to Fluttershy's. "Or maybe you'd like Fluttershy's better?"

Forcing his hips to thrust forward, Big Mac grunted with pleasure in the new pussy he was in, Fluttershy letting out a surprised gasp, lifting her head away from Cheerilee's snatch for air. She tried to turn her head to look behind her, only to lurch forward as Big Mac thrusted repeatedly, making her moan before they were muffled, her head pushed back down to Cheerilee's pussy with a firm hoof. Marble whimpered, wondering why Big Mac pulled out and started doing Fluttershy next. Sugar Belle alternated her magic aura on Marble's clit, tweaking it and making her squeak.

She kept alternating Big Mac to fuck the two mares, catching them off guard when he switched while the unicorn teased both Marble's and Fluttershy's clits, hoofing herself faster as she watched her coltfriend's cock sinking into both mares. Marble was the first to erupt, letting out a loud moan as she squirted marecum, drenching Big Mac's groin and stomach, finding it hard for him to pull out as his balls began to clench, getting close to climaxing himself. He came deep inside Marble with a growl, sparking another mini-climax for the rock farmer, feeling his hot spung splatter deep in her core. Sugar Belle quickly pulled him out, then shoved his cock back in Fluttershy's pussy, making her gasp when she felt him fire more rounds in her, then came when Sugar Belle vigorously rubbed her clit, letting her walls milk out the last of Big Mac's seed.

Big Mac let out a relieved sigh, pulling his shaft out of Fluttershy, both her and Marble panting heavily, both their holes leaking his viscous cum with content smiles on their faces. He wiped his brow, but he wasn't going to get much of a break with two other mares ready for his cock. Shoved down onto his back once again, Sugar Belle climbed over him, her rump facing him, giving it a little wiggle.

"Mind giving me some attention, hon?" Sugar Belle asked with a sultry gaze.

Big Mac smiled, enjoying the view as he reached his hooves up, grasping his lover's soft, cushiony plot. "Nope," he said, pulling her hips down, letting her sit on his face and began licking at her pussy lips.

Sugar Belle let out a content sigh, grinding her hips against while getting a pleasant tongue bathing against her nethers from her beloved farm stallion. She eyed his twitching cock, moaning when she felt his tongue push inside, licking just the right spots to make her tremble in ecstasy. She was about to return the favor as she leaned forward, nearly falling backward and off the stallion's face when Cheerilee climbed over his waist, grinding her pussy against the thick stallion meat she'd been dying to get inside her after getting ill last year.

"Hello, old friend," Cheerilee murmured to herself, letting her winking clit give the underside of Big Mac's shaft light kisses. "I've waited so long to feel you inside me again. No toy as big as you is enough to satisfy me." Sitting up, the teacher guided the tip up to her entrance, then slowly sat herself down, moaning to the heavens as she hilted herself completely, grinding her hips against Big Mac's crotch, relishing the fullness as his tip ground itself against the entrance to her womb. "Ahhhhhh...I needed this so bad!"

Sugar Belle watched Cheerilee start to ride Big Mac's cock, not even starting slow as she pounded her hips down hard, full-length, deep strokes, letting out a yelp of pleasure with each impact. Big Mac's muffled moans vibrated through the unicorn's lower lips, enhancing the pleasurable sensations of his oral minstrations, letting him know she was enjoying herself with her own moans and gently running a hoof through his short, messy orange mane. Even though he was a big, burly stallion, she saw him as a big, lovable, quiet goof who's a far better gentlecolt than the nobles in Canterlot. Sugar Belle looked back at Cheerilee, riding the stallion like a bucking bronco, making her shriek and clench down on him in response, enjoying the ride as she climbed up that orgasmic peak she'd been dying for.

Fluttershy and Marble managed to catch their breaths, sitting up with their legs and pussies tingling from the most intense orgasms they've ever felt. Hearing Cheerilee cry out, they watched Sugar Belle lean over to her, making out with her, moaning in each other's mouths. Marble crawled over to them, her eyes focused on Big Mac's cock disappearing in Cheerilee's soaking wet cunt, her nose assaulted with his scent, and the juices of the mare currently riding him, Fluttershy, and her own, arousing the sheltered rock farming mare as her pussy dripped, readying her for another round. Once she reached his soaked crotch and bouncing nuts, she breathed in the intoxicating aroma of musk, sweat, and sex, licking the large balls, churning up more cum for all their delight while rubbing her own pussy, smearing what remained of his load he shot in her all over her crotch.

Fluttershy was content to rest and watch a bit, though it was tempting to eat out Marble with her rump raised, tail flagged with her plot presented for anypony to take her, and with delectable cum from the stallion they shared. Big Mac's thrusts grew erratic, his balls clenching tightly against his groin, ready to unleash his third orgasm deep inside Cheerilee. The dam burst, his hold on Sugar Belle's rump quickly switching to Cheerilee's, holding the mare down as he pumped his load deep in the teacher's womb, the warm seed making the mulberry mare cry out as she came from being painted white deep in her core, milking out every ounce of the stallion's limitless salvos thanks to those special cupcakes.

After having her fill, Cheerilee slowly removed herself, Big Mac's flare popping out of her cunt, rubbing her slightly distended belly from how much he filled her. Marble took her chance to taste more of his cum, startling the teacher when she felt a pair of lips eating at her used hole, which was still sensitive as she moaned and shivered from the eager lapping and suckling. Fluttershy moved up to the still erect cock, licking the shaft clean for Sugar Belle's turn. She wrapped her lips around it, letting out a soft moan as she bobbed her head a little, watching Sugar Belle stand up, panting heavily, her hind legs shaking as she was close to cumming.

The pegasus gave Big Mac's cockhead one last suckle before letting go with a pop, licking her lips from the sexual fluids that soaked the stallion's tool. "Your turn, Sugar Belle," she said.

"Big Mac, I'm so close," Sugar Belle whimpered. As he sat up, she presented herself to him, her winking clit begging him to stuff her full. Fluttershy crawled underneath the unicorn, helping give Big Mac a hint, spreading her cheeks and pussy lips, her essence leaking down on the animal lover's face, which she didn't mind. "Please...fuck me until I can't feel my legs."

"Eeyup," Big Mac said with a low, primal growl, unable to deny giving his lover the relief she needs.

Mounting his mare, he slid his cock inside her pussy without a need to aim, knowing just where to go to stuff her with his meat. Sugar Belle let out a needy groan, bracing her hind legs while lowering her face on Fluttershy's belly, grasping the pegasus's legs, spreading them, and gave her some attention with a few small licks on her clit. Fluttershy moaned in surprise, shifting her hips so Sugar Belle ate out her pussy, returning the gesture by flicking her tongue against the unicorn's clit, making her squeal while her coltfriend rut his mare like a wild stallion desperate to breed and impregnate his broodmare.

It didn't take long for Sugar Belle to finally reach her climax, the hard pounding along with her clitorus getting licked and smelling Big Mac's seed sticking around Fluttershy's vulva made her squeal and gush over the pegasus. It wasn't like the flood Marble unleashed earlier, but it was quite messy, drenching the pegasus mare as she drank her juices as she enjoyed the close-up show. Despite just cumming, Big Mac kept pounding away, prolonging Sugar Belle's orgasm as her body shuddered from the overload of sensations striking her every nerve in her nether regions.

Fluttershy grinded her hips against Sugar Belle's babbling lips, the unicorn's eyes rolling in the back of her head as her lover ravaged her insides in the best way possible. Big Mac's heavy balls slapped audibly with every fast and powerful thrust he made, feeling Sugar's walls clench tightly around his shaft in another orgasm, letting out an exhausted, but very satisfied groan, gasping for breath to try to stay conscious. He thought he heard Fluttershy goad him into cumming inside Sugar Belle and get her pregnant, even though it was impossible with the cupcake's effects. Big Mac adored Sugar Belle, holding his heart as he held hers, and imagined a life with the two of them together until the end of their lives, even raising a family with a foal or two.

Big Mac snorted, doubling his speed to try making that dream a reality, hearing Sugar Belle shriek and wail in overwhelming pleasure, her nonsensical babbling sounding it like was begging him to give her a baby. He complied, letting out a loud groan as he buried himself as deep as he could inside his mare. This orgasm was his biggest one, his first volley blasting right through the tight entrance of his lover's womb, filling her to the brim and sealing his cum inside, keeping it from leaking out. Sugar Belle cried out, reaching yet another orgasm, nearly losing her voice as it cracked, her soft vaginal walls milking out every single drop it can from his heavy, virile, tangerine-sized balls. Fluttershy watched Big Mac's cock pulse heavily, his cum bloating Sugar Belle's belly and nearly squishing her, making it look like she was only a couple months away from giving birth.

"Oh my," the pegasus uttered in awe, hoofing herself off as she watched Big Mac's balls twitch and clench with each pump of sticky baby batter flowing into he lucky mare.

As soon as Big Mac's latest load tapered off, he let out a shuddered sigh, holding Sugar Belle as the mare was struggling to stay conscious. Fluttershy crawled out from under them, letting them lay down and bask in their afterglow. Big Mac gave Sugar Belle light kissed along her neck and shoulder, giving her a breather while still buried deep inside her. When the unicorn recovered from the best sex she's ever had with her stallion, on a weird holiday where it could last the whole day, she rubbed her bloated belly, filled with so much cum, she giggled as she imagined herself being pregnant with Big Mac's foal.

"That was...amazing," Sugar Belle uttered.

"Eeyup," Big Mac agreed, nuzzling the mare's cheek affectionately.

"I'm so tired already," she said. "And...this orgy's supposed to last all day?"

"Eeyup," the stallion answered.

"...Is it ok to take a little break before getting back into it?" she asked again.

"Eeyup," Big Mac answered once again.

Sugar Belle sighed, snuggling with the farm stallion. "Good. I just wanna rest for a little." Tilting her head, she gave Big Mac a small kiss on the lips, wriggling her hips with a content sigh, still feeling his hard length nestled snuggly within her depths. "I love you, Big Mac."

"And Ah love you, Sugar Belle," he said back.

"HEY, PONYVILLE!!!!" Through the loud moaning and squealching noises coming from the massive orgy, everyone suddenly stopped and looked out in the distance.

Sugar Belle lifted her head curiously to see what was going on, only to gawk in surprise when everypony saw a strange bipedal creature in what looked like a wagon. In said wagon was all of the presents that had been stolen, which meant the one responsible for stealing their sexy presents was this strange creature.

"What in Equestria is that thing?" Sugar Belle questioned.

"Uhh...long story," Big Mac responded vaguely.

As Anon pulled into town with Spike in tow, he planted his feet firmly in the ground, stopping the wagon dead center in town. All the ponies stared at the resident human as he stood there, looking somewhat nervous as he looked around. "Hey, everypony." He spoke, sounding a bit hoarse. "I-I want to first say I'm sorry. It was me who stole all your gifts and toys." The crowd gasped, seeming shocked while others shot him some glares. "And second, I want to admit how wrong I was for doing that." Out of the corner of his eye, he saw Spike slowly coming around. "It was all me and I am to blame."

The crowd whispered among themselves as they spoke negatively about the bipedal creature. But before this could go on for long, Spike stepped behind his friend. "No, he wasn't alone. I helped him, too." The crowd let out a much larger gasp, with two ponies in the crowd gasping the loudest. "And we have our reasons. Both of them dumb reasons, of course." He said, looking up to Anon.

"It's because we hated Sexmas." Again, and overly done, the crowd of ponies gasped with one fashion mare fainting, her country marefriend catching her just as she fell. "I hated this holiday because my experience with this holiday ended in embarrassment with having my dick laughed at," One mare in the crowd lowered her head. "Or beginning to embrace it and try talking to two gorgeous mares." He extended his hand in the direction of the spa ponies who faintly blushed as they were complimented.

"And for one other." He gestured to Spike. "It was the pain of the mare he loved being with somepony else." On the ground, Rarity and Applejack looked to each other with what could be a little shame. "We had enough and couldn't stand to bear another year with everypony else being happy while we were left bitter and heartbroken. And I thought if we stole all the gifts and toys, we'd feel better seeing others as miserable as us." He stared out toward the crowd and sighed. "But I was wrong, because I learned something today. Sexmas isn't just about the mindless sex, or all the toys ponies exchange. It's not about having the biggest cock, or being jealous of somepony else. It's about the love that we share. Kinda sappy, but true." Some of the ponies nodded and shrugged as they admitted it was true.

"And I was too stupid and stubborn to see that, and I had almost ruined it for everypony here. So I want to say I'm sorry, and I hope you all have a happy Sexmas" He lowered his head in shame as he turned around and slowly made his way back to his home alone.

"Wait!!" Called out a voice from among the crowd. Everypony turned toward the voice to see a mare with blond mare and pink fur; it was Mindy Lou who. She walked through the crowd toward Anon, who stood dead in his tracks. "This is all my fault! If I had been more careful with how I had acted that first Sexmas day, then none of this would have happened."

She looked up to Anon once she was only a foot away from the tall bipedal ape with cheek as red as roses. "Anon, the truth is that, even before Sexmas, I secretly had a crush on you." This caused the human to blush a bit by the sudden confession. "The truth is, when I heard you would been attending that first Sexmas, I got both really excited and nervous. And when I saw that you were coming my way that day during the orgy, I asked my friend for a drink to help loosen me up, but instead, I drank something too strong and ended up saying something wrong and hurtful to you." She turned her gaze away with tears slowly welling up in her eyes. "I'm sorry, Anon. I'm the reason you hate Sexmas, which makes this all my fault."

For a while, no pony spoke a word or even uttered a sound. Mindy was left sniffling as tears flowed down her cheeks. Suddenly, she felt warmth embrace her and something gently wrapped around her. When she glanced up, she saw, to her surprise, that it was Anon giving her a hug. "I forgive you." He spoke softly as his arms caressed her back, helping to soothe her.

For a moment, she stood there stunned, but eventually she smiled and wrapped her hooves around him, nuzzling her muzzle into his cheek affectionately. "Thank you, Anon." The crowd that stood all around then let out an "Awww" as they bore witness to this display of love and affection.

Pinkie Pie, who was currently crying a river, blew her nose with a tissue, which made a rather large horn sound effect, walked up to the two. "Nonny, I think it's safe to say that anypony would have done the same thing if they were in the same position as you. Nopony should be alone or sad on Sexmas…or any other day of the year for that matter." She giggled along with everypony else. "And Nonny, since you brought everything back in one piece, I think we can forgive you, and we would really like you to join us for Sexmas too." All the ponies nodded their head in agreement.

While Anon was grateful, he was still burdened by one thing. "Yeah, I would love to, Pinkie, but I'm afraid that I wouldn't be able to compete with the other stallions here, and be put to shame." He said while glancing down at his crotch.

"I could help with that!!" A voice called out from the crowd. All the ponies parted ways as the Princess of Friendship, Twilight Sparkle, stepped forward toward the human. "I have a spell that can triple the length of certain appendages. And I may be able to apply it to your….eh hem, member." She gave a faint blush as she looked at Anon's crotch.

Though hesitant, Anon had nothing to lose and shrugged his shoulders. "Ah, fuck it. Go ahead. Not like it could get any worse."

"Well, okay. Just relax and I'll give it a try." Twilight closed her eyes and focused all her magic into her horn as she cast a spell onto Anon's crotch, the magic tingling making him flinch, along with a loud ripping sound as Twilight also appeared to fondle his junk with her magic aura.

Anon looked down at his waist in awe. He couldn't believe that the giant dick attached to him was really his. He should be a bit embarrassed that his newly enhanced length managed to rip his pants in half, but he was still dumbstruck that he was definitely several sizes larger than his smaller, pitiful-looking prick.

"...Holy hell," he uttered, then glanced at the alicorn who gave him this incredible gift. "You owe me a new pair of pants, princess. And one that'll fit THIS thing."

"I had to be sure that it really worked," Twilight said with a smirk, using a small flash of magic to flick Anon's stallion-sized cock, making it wiggle about while making him flinch at the magical contact.

He growled and leered at the princess, completely unaware of all the stares he's getting from all the mares. Especially from Mindy Lou Who, her mouth salivating at the exotically erotic human penis pointed straight at her.

"Celestia's royal plot," Mindy uttered, her tail flagging and her nethers getting soaked just at the size of her crush's new length.

Deciding not to let this moment go to waste, she stepped forward, sitting in front of him with her nose gently booping his tip, which made Anon look down. His breath caught in his throat as Mindy stared at his cock, her forehooves gently grasping the base of his shaft and slowly stroked it.

"Uhh...M-Mindy?" He tried getting her attention, but Mindy was too fixated on his cock. He stifled a moan as her surprisingly soft hooves ran over his meat, twitching in delight as he felt something else other than his own hand jerking him off. Mindy's blush intensified, her eyes glazing over as she moved lower, nuzzling against his scrotum, inhaling his masculine scent deeply. "Oook...I guess I can't really stop you if you're going this-"

He let out a small gasp, feeling the mare's broad tongue slowly lick his balls, letting out a shuddered moan at his taste. She went for another lick, this time scooping one of his testes in her mouth, swirling it around and coating it in her saliva. The pleasurable gesture to Anon's baby makers made him groan, his cock twitching as pre leaked from the strange mushroom tip the other ponies around saw, some of them getting back to the orgy now that Anon was joining in the holiday spirit.

Mindy let out a gasp, popping Anon's testicle out of her salivating mouth, then did the same to the other, giving it just as much loving attention as its twin. She moaned in need, moving a hoof down her belly and teased her drenched slit, one hind leg twitching as she toyed with her winking clit. Popping the other ball out of her mouth, she dragged her tongue up the large human penis, tracing the pulsing veins along the shaft until she reached his lower head. Mindy lapped up the leaking precum from his tip, swirling the clear, salty liquid on her tongue, savoring his essence, her taste buds demanding more.

Looking up at Anon, her eyes half-lidded, Mindy opened her mouth, then in one fluid motion, wrapped his cock around her lips and went all the way down to the end of his shaft. Anon let out a shocked moan, getting a deep-throating blowjob from a mare who accidentally insulted his masculinity, her snout pressing deeply against his pelvis, tasting and smelling his human musk, making her eyes roll in the back of her head. Her moans vibrated her throat, enhancing the pleasure Anon felt as he gently clutched Mindy's head, holding on to the unbelievable feeling of getting head and trying not to blow his first load with his new cock size too soon. He was surprised she didn't even choke, but she must have been practicing for him, or had other stallion dicks rammed down her throat that his is a bit different in girth that it was easy for her to take in.

Mindy finally started to move after what felt like hours, slowly bobbing her head up and down, moaning and suckling for the human's cum. Anon's tip stayed in her mouth, lingering on it every so often with light suckles that made his toes curl before taking him back down in her throat, swallowing deeply to constrict her esophagus around his length, squeezing it ever so tightly to make him throb and make him blow. Anon panted, his eyes fluttering from the incredible blowjob, slowly guiding Mindy's head to keep her from stopping while his hips reflexively thrusted as her tongue ran along the underside of his cock.

"Oooooooh ffffuuuuuuuuuuck," Anon groaned out. As much as he was enjoying Mindy's apology gift, he didn't want to end it too soon by filling her gullet with his cum. He gently pulled the mare off with a suckling pop, both of them panting, one from pleasure while the was for air. "Damn, Mindy...Your mouth is fucking amazing."

"I-I...practiced for you," she said, biting her lower lip as her one hoof down between her legs continued rubbing her pussy.

Anon noticed how needy she was, his cock throbbing hard at the sight, and he wanted to return the favor. "Face down, ass up, please," he said; not a question, but an order. Mindy obeyed, quickly getting up and about-facing, raising her rump up high with her front half lowered to the ground. Her tail flagged aside, panting heavily, her clit winking at him, begging him for his human meat to fill her like no other stallion ever could. Anon lowered down on his knees, being more than twice the height of the horny mare, grasping her plot with both hands, making her gasp and wiggle her hips at his touch. Mindy expecting Anon to stick his cock inside her, only to gasp when she felt his fingers teasing at her folds, then his thumbs spreading her pussy lips wide, making her tremble at the strange, yet pleasurable sensation of digits teasing her down there. "Damn, Mindy. You're leaking like a faucet down here."

Mindy uttered a whimper, letting out a squeal when she felt two of Anon's fingers push inside her vagina, easily sliding in thanks to her juices making quite a puddle where she once sat. It was an alien feeling, but it made her moan out, begging for more as she tried to push her hips against his hand, wanting to feel his dextrous fingers push deeper while they wriggled against her walls. Mindy's tail shot up with a loud squeak when he rubbed against her G-spot, followed by a loud groan, her eyes rolling in the back of her head with her tongue hanging out in pure ecstasy.

It didn't last long, to her disappointment, letting out a pitiful whimper when she felt Anon's fingers slide out of her wet snatch with schlick. "N-No," Mindy whined, turning her head to see Anon tasting her cum that soaked his digits. That aroused the mare as he seemed to enjoy her own essence, shaking her rump to get his attention. "P-Please, Anon. G-Give me that wonderful, HUGE cock of yours! Take my pony pussy and give me that load of human cum!"

Anon grabbed Mindy's hips tightly, holding her still as he lined himself up for the plunge. She froze, feeling his tip tapping against her butt a few times before finally finding his mark. Biting her lip, Mindy spread her hind legs slightly, feeling that mushroom-head of the human's mighty staff press against her flower. He pushed himself inside, both human and pony moaning out in bliss. She was finally feeling his length sink into her deepest depths while Anon finally lost his virginity, even if it was a pony, but he wasn't picky at this point. He managed to hilt himself balls deep inside the quivering mare beneath him, his tip kissing against the entrance to her womb.

The two stayed together like this for a moment, savoring the moment; Anon's throbbing cock being massaged by Mindy's vaginal walls, velvety softness, warm, and slick and wet. After Anon felt like he wasn't going to explode after the first thrust, he gripped Mindy's hips, then slowly pulled out. He heard her beautiful, desperate whimpers, feeling his cock escaping from her needy folds, her winking clit bumping against the underside while trying to pull him back in. He stopped when he felt the head of his penis threaten to pop out, Mindy trying to push her hips back against his, silently pleading him to come back inside, but his strong grip, along with his palms needing into her plushy buttocks keeping her still, she got what she wanted as he thrust back inside. Mindy yelped from the unexpectedly quicker thrust, which droned out into panting moans as Anon began pumping his hips in and out, finding himself a good rhythm while she let him take her dripping sex as much as he wanted.

"Y-Yes...Yeeeessssss!" Mindy cried out. "Take me, Anon! Fuck me! Fuck me with that huge, fucking cock! I love it! I love you!"

Anon grunted in exertion, slapping his hips against Mindy's, his balls swinging and clapping against the mare's clit when it winked out, making her legs tremble and squeak at the sensation. Pressing himself as deep as he could, he paused for a moment, wrapping his arms around Mindy's barrel, giving her teats a few gentle squeezes and rubbing his thumbs along her perky nipples. Her moans were music to his ears, the couple slowly grinding their hips together as they relished in the close intimacy they shared.

Anon began moving again, pounding himself harder and faster as he held onto Mindy tightly. The mare panted, yelping and crying out in pleasure, her words turning into jumbled, incoherent babbling as she was rutted by the only human in Equestria. Her internal walls convulsed, feeling his cock grow stiffer, milking him for every ounce of cum churning in the hairless sac mashing her love button with every impact of his hips against her rump. Her screams continued rising an octave, squeezing his cock harder until she let out one long, orgasmic cry, cumming over the member still pounding into her. Her back legs grew stiff as her marecum gushed out of her abused cunt, Anon picking up his pace with the added lubircant in Mindy's orgasm, who let out breathless gasps, eyes rolling in the back of her head as she rode cloud nine and beyond.

"S-Shit! C-Cumming!" Anon warned before letting out a long groan, pushing himself as deep as his hips would allow him.

His cock pulsed, shooting out thick ribbons of sticky, hot cream deep inside Mindy, making her scream and prolong her orgasm further. Each shot splattered the inside of her womb, his tip kissing against her cervix as he unloaded every ounce of semen built up in his contracting balls, filling the mare to the brim. It may not be as volumous as a stallion's, but Mindy didn't care, subconsciously rubbing her belly, feeling his warmth fill her inner core.

Anon let out a breath he didn't realize he was holding, sighing in relief as he experienced one of the best orgasms in his life. Slowly, he dragged his softening member out of Mindy Lou Who, falling on his butt when he fully pulled out, watching the gaping hole in her abused pussy leaking out his cum. Mindy seemed frozen in place, falling over on her side, her legs finally giving out and twitching like jelly.

"Phew...I must have been really good if I made her pass out," Anon said to himself. Getting up on his feet, he let Mindy Lou Who take a breather, looking around at the huge town orgy that resumed. He wondered why the stallions were still able to keep on going until a cupcake flew toward him, quickly catching it before it splattered over his shirt, the only bit of clothing he had left on him.

"Eat that!" he heard Pinkie shout before somehow able to hear her swallow some stallion meat with a muffled "You're welcome!" from the random pony.

Anon shrugged, eating the cupcake until every crumb was devoured. It was surprisingly sweet, tasting almost similarly to pineapples. Within seconds, he felt reinvigorated, gaining his second wind with his cock rising back up to full hardness.

"Huh. So that's what those weird cupcakes do when everypony gets into these orgies on Sexmas." While lost in thought, he saw the spa twins eyeing him over at their place of business, giving him come hither gazes before walking inside, both mares swaying their rumps at him, which easily got his attention. Grinning toothily, he was about to have his fantasy threesome with the twin mares on the sexiest holiday of the year. "I take back everything I said; Sexmas is awesome."

Spike watched Anon run off to the spa, with his new, enhanced dick size to finally screw Aloe and Lotus in the threesome he's salivated over for the last year. Even though the human was happy and in the Sexmas spirit, Spike obviously wasn't. Glancing over at where he crush was, she was too busy making out with Applejack, being oggled at by other stallions, who were stroking their cocks while watching the two lesbians go at it in the open. There was no chance for him to get with the fashionista anymore, even after his plans of getting revenge for being her little servant for years forgotten, too heartbroken to do anything but crawl into bed and be miserable.

Before he decided to just go back to the castle and hide under his covers, he felt a tap on his shoulder. Turning around, he was surprised to see Sweetie Belle getting his attention, her cheeks with a pink blush, and she held the dragon dildo Rarity got for her.

"H-Hi, Spike," she greeted bashfully.

"...Hey," he said back. "So...That's an...interesting dildo you got."

"Yeah...but, I think I'd rather have the real thing instead." Sweetie Belle tossed the toy aside. Spike was confused, only to recall what happened earlier that night when he heard Sweetie sleep talk, wishing the "toy" she sucked off was really his cock. Blushing in embarrassment, he wasn't paying attention to Sweetie Belle, feeling him wrap her hooves around him, bumping her snout against his. Her blush turned a bright red, biting her lower lip nervously. "I've...had a big crush on you for a while, Spike...And, I was wondering...if you would want to celebrate Sexmas with me...and be my coltfriend?"

Spike's mouth hung open, speechless, baffled, his cheeks turning red as well. When he finally found his voice, he uttered a squeak, but nodded his head. Pleased with his response, Sweetie Belle made him squeak again with a kiss. On the lips. Spiraling with confused emotions, being asked out by his former crush's sister, and being kissed by her while proposed with having sex with her for this special holiday. With his brain still blanking out, Sweetie Belle dragged the stunned drake off to the boutique to spend some long awaited quality time with her new coltfriend, snatching one of the many cupcakes Pinkie made for the stallions to keep them in a rutting mood all day.

When Spike landed on Sweetie's bed, he finally snapped back to reality, watching the young unicorn straddle his waist with a seductive, but nervous gaze. "...Uhh, I think I blacked out. What happened?"

Sweetie Belle giggled, leaning her muzzle closer. "This might help you remember." She kissed Spike again, getting a little more bold with a deeper one. Spike's eyes widened, hearing the unicorn moan against his lips while feeling her hooves rub his scaly chest. His eyes grew half-lidded, his mind finally catching up to him, kissing Sweetie Belle back, bringing his hands up to hold the young mare, cupping her cheek with one while running the other along the soft fur on her back. The two slowly pulled away, breathing heavily, Sweetie rubbing her nose against Spike's. "That help?"

"Y-Yeah," Spike said, a big grin on his face. "I...never thought I'd ever be able to kiss a mare. Nor did I think you had feelings for me."

"Yeah, but I'm glad I finally told you after so long," Sweetie said. She brushed her tail against Spike's groin, surprising him with a moan, teasing his draconic tip out of him. "And I get to have your big, hard dragon cock to myself." Laying over Spike, Sweetie Belle scooted back to feel his growing member rise along the crack of her soft, squishy plot, letting out a moan as she grinded up and down on it slowly to full hardness. "I've been dreaming about this forever, and I'll finally feel it inside me."

Spike grimaced, needing to tell the unicorn something important before she really thought this would be the first time she'd take his cock anywhere. "Uhh, eheh, Sweetie, I kinda need to ask you something first."

"Hmm?" The unicorn stopped her teasing, looking down at the dragon curiously.

"Umm...You know Anon and I snuck into everypony's houses and took everypony's presents, right?" he asked. Sweetie nodded after everyone saw them return them, so it was no harm, no foul. "Well...when we snuck into your rooms...do you remember...sucking on that 'dildo' Rarity got for you?"

Sweetie Belle sat up, humming in thought. "Well, I do remember I had a really vivid dream," she said. "I don't know if I was still dreaming or not, but the dildo felt real and fleshy, not plastic. It twitched, it was warm, and it shot some of that edible fake cum used for those kinds of dildos that squirt-" Slowly, it dawned on Sweetie Belle why Spike asked such a question. Her face turned a bright red in embarrassment, looking down at her new coltfriend with a look of shock: he snuck into her room to take her dildo, and what she thought was her new toy was actually the real thing. "...Y-You mean...I-I-I actually..."

"Y-Yeah," Spike said with a sheepish grin. Sweetie squeaked, covering her face as she leapt off of him, turning away shyly after the realization. He sat up, grabbing the unicorn by her waist, making her squeak again with her tail curled up to her stomach, held in the drake's gentle embrace. "I didn't say I didn't like it, but it caught me off guard. You have no idea how hard it was for me to stay quiet to keep you from waking up."

"Oh my gosh, I'm so sorry," Sweetie apologized. "Rarity told me I once sleepwalked into her room, took one of her many extravagant toys in her collection, and took away my own virginity with it."

Spike snorted, finding the scene a little hilarious, much to the mare's chagrin as she pouted, her cheeks bulging cutely. "Well, at least I won't have to worry about popping your cherry."

"S-Shut up," she grumbled.

Spike hummed, holding Sweetie Belle while running his claws over her soft fur, peppering her neck with light kisses. Sweetie moaned, shivering at the sharp nails gently brushing her coat, tilting her head to expose more of her neck for the dragon to lavish. She felt helpless in his arms, the dangerous predator clutching his prey, but the gentleness in his touch and soft kisses made her feel safe, uncurling her tail and spreading her legs to allow him access to explore every inch of her.

"Mind if I return the favor for last night?" Spike asked, whispering in her ear as his hands slowly headed south, his fingers gently kneading the mare's teats.

"Mmm...G-Gentle?" Sweetie moaned, letting out a gasp when she felt his fingers teasing her nipples. "I-I don't want you...scratching me with those claws."

"Hey, I'm not THAT kind of dragon," Spike assured, then let out a low growl in her ear, giving her nipples a light pinch, making her gasp more and flex her hips up. "Unless you want me to be a little rough as we go on?"

"M-Maybe," Sweetie panted. She levitated the special cupcake for the holiday in front of his face, taking off the wrapper and throwing it in her trash bin nearby. "D-Don't forget your snack, Spikey."

Spike almost forgot about the cupcake. He wanted this moment to last as long as possible. Sweetie fed him, taking a few bites before chewing each mouthful, his cock pulsing against her buttocks as he felt the sweet's effects begin to kick in. She moaned as she felt it twitch, wriggling her hips to tease her coltfriend while he gently fondled her tiny pony breasts.

"Not as delicious as a sapphire cupcake, but it's not bad," he said.

He leaned his closer, tilting Sweetie's head toward him and gave her a passionate kiss. Sweetie Belle moaned, meeting his tongue with hers in a Prench kiss, submitting to his versatile, reptillian tongue. Her hips shifted around, silently begging his hands to stop teasing her nipples and move to her needy pussy. Her request was granted, gasping in her dragon's maw as she felt his fingers slowly run up and down her soaked lips. Sweetie brought a hoof down on top of Spike's hand, whimpering with need as she experienced something else besides her own hoof rubbing at her folds. Spike's digits were able to split her vulva, revealing her moist, pink insides, even tease her winking clit to add to the incredible sensations in her most sensitive of nerves.

Sweetie Belle gasped, feeling Spike gently plunge a finger in her depths. She broke the kiss, tilting her head back with a loud moan, feeling his lips and tongue caress her neck, pushing his digit deeper inside to help scratch that burning itch deep in her core. He suddenly pulled out, making her whine and raise her hips to try to get it back inside her. She watched him bring his soaked finger to his lips, giving her juices a taste.

Spike hummed in delight, giving Sweetie a toothy grin, making her nervous, but excited all at once. Laying the unicorn down on her bed, Spike crawled over his new lover. Sweetie gulped nervously, watching him move lower, dragging his tongue along her belly, giving each nipple a teasing flick, then stopped when she reached her hind legs. Sweetie panted in anticipation, spreading her legs, inviting the drake to dive right in, which he did with gusto.

Giving Sweetie's pussy a few teasing licks, he brought his hands up to her hips, spreading her lips with his thumbs, then licked his lips and moved in. Wrapping his mouth around her mound, Spike plunged his thin tongue deep inside, making Sweetie Belle moan and writhe in ecstasy, her forehooves instinctively clutching his head to hold herself to reality while the versatile organ lashed every inch of her vaginal walls to send her to cloud nine.

"Ohhhhhhhh Spiiiiiiike!" Sweetie cried out. That long tongue wiggled its way about, brushing against her G-spot and made her scream out louder, and she could swear she felt the tip of that forked organ reach the tight entrance to her womb. She gripped his head tightly, crushing Spike's head between her legs to keep him there while her stomach tightened and her clit winked rapidly. "A-A-Almost...!"

Spike doubled his efforts, making the unicorn squeal and scream, his tough scales barely feeling her thighs trying to crush his skull as she clung onto the ride of orgasmic bliss. Sweetie Belle reached her peak, letting out a loud gasp as her back arched, gushing marecum in the dragon's mouth. Dragging his tongue easily out of her clenching walls, he coiled it around that heart-shaped love bead, keeping it from hiding back in the unicorn's quivering cunt, gently suckling it to prolong her orgasm. Sweetie let out soundless screams, panting heavily as all her nerves were spasming wildly, left no choice but to ride it out until Spike finally stopped.

He relented after what felt like an eternity, letting go of her sensitive clit with a small pop, giving it one last flick of his tongue before sitting up. His face and chest were drenched in her essence, letting out a primal growl at the taste. Spike watched Sweetie Belle recover from her high, her right hind leg twitching with both legs still spread, he head fallen back on her pillow with a wide, open-mouthed grin, her tongue lolling out of her mouth, letting out desperate gasps of air and light moans from the tingling sensations she still felt tickling her nerve endings.

Feeling his cock throb with needing, being patient while teasing the beautiful young mare before him and eating out her delicious cunt, he crawled back over Sweetie Belle, making her gasp when she felt his hard dragon dick rub along her pussy lips. "Spike want," he uttered in Sweetie's ear, grinding the bottom of his hot, rock hard member against the soaking wet, even hotter pony pussy, making the unicorn shudder and moan from his demanding, predatorial tone.

"S-Sweetie want," Sweetie Belle said, giving him permission to use her as he saw fit. Using her magic to guide his tip, lining up with her dripping sex, she wrapped her forelegs around his neck, ready to feel that long, exotic shaft plunge deeply in her depths. "T-Take me. Fill me. Breed me."

Spike's cock twitched at the unicorn's last request - no, her last demand. Restraining his inner carnal beast, he slowly thrust his hips down, easily slipping inside with his tapered tip. He let out a groan, feeling her slick, ridged inner walls caress his dick, feeling them tighten around him, sucking him deeper inside while Sweetie Belle released whimpered moans, still sensitive from her orgasm, but she waited for this moment and wanted more of him. Once he bottomed out up to the bulbous knot at the base, Sweetie Belle squealed at the sensation of something kissing up to her innermost depths, Spike's thin tip twitching slightly at the entrance to her womb, just the right size to poke through and deposit every ounce of seed his inner balls produced.

Spike held himself still, tongue lolling out of his mouth at the most incredible feeling he'd imagined since hitting puberty. Unlike Sweetie's mouth, her pussy was much warmer, clenching rhythmically to her excitedly racing heartbeat. He thought he was going to cum when she sleep-sucked him after a few minutes; being inside her soaked, dripping pussy, he almost blew the moment he buried himself into her up to the knot, still sticking out since it was so thick, he probably wouldn't be able to fit it inside her from how tight she was.

He got used to the feeling, panting slightly as he looked down. Sweetie Belle's eyes rolled in the back of her head, squeaky moans escaping her opened mouth. Leaning closer, pressing his belly against hers, his movement snapped her out of her daze, her hips twitching as his member shifted around in her sensitive walls. She was met with a kiss, her half-lidded eyes shutting closed with a moan, her plea to be bred like a slutty whorse forgotten, content for her and Spike to enjoy a soft, romantic, pleasurable bout of passionate sex.

Spike started off slow, his cocked slowly retreating out of the warm cavern of velvety flesh, then pushed back in when his tip threatened to pop out. The couple moaned in each other's mouths, their respective limbs holding each other closer while sensually rubbing their lover's bodies. They took a few moments to take a breath of air before locking lips over and over, but didn't separate too far, their tongues staying connected as they swapped spit while their differently shaped organs wrestled playfully.

Spike sped up after a minute trying to find a good rhythm pumping in and out of Sweetie Belle, making the unicorn squeak as the harder thrusts inside caused Spike's dragon tip to press repeatedly against her womb. She wanted him to push himself deeper inside, up to the knot, and FEEL that thin head penetrate that much tighter entrance and feel it throb, trying to spread the inner sanctum of her reproductive organs and flood it to the brim with his cum. Her wish was going to come true, feeling Spike's cock twitch harder, the length growing bigger and flexing, and his feral growls telling her he was about to cum.

"S-Sweetie Belle," he tried to warn, but she pulled him back down and kissed him deeply.

"D-Deeper," she whined, trying to wrap her hind legs around Spike's waist and pull him closer. "P-Put that...big knot inside me, dragon boy!"

Spike pounded harder, forcing the base of his throbbing member inside the already tightening confines of Sweetie Belle's clenching vaginal walls, her clit kissing the bulbous knot with each powerful thrust, begging it to get it inside. With a growling grunt, Spike gripped Sweetie Belle's hips, pulling her hips closer and thrust hard once more, managing to slip his knot and tying himself inside. Sweetie Belle screamed out in ecstasy, her entrance sealed up, but the dragon dick had actually run right through her womb, making her cum and clench down like a vice, milking the drake for his cum. Spike grunted, clenching his teeth as his cock throbbing, shooting globs of hot, white jizz deep inside his mare, which made Sweetie Belle screech, sending her into another orgasm while mid-orgasm. The amount Spike unleashed inside managed to bloat Sweetie's stomach, making her look a few months pregnant before his spurting dick slowed to a trickle, his knot keeping their combined sexual fluids inside the mare.

Spike sighed in relief, relishing the intimate closeness they were in. When he looked down at Sweetie Belle, she was still twitching, gasping for breath as she saw white. The drake giggled sheepishly, seeing he might have overdone it when he looked further down at her distended, cum-filled belly.

"Wow. Whatever was in those cupcakes Pinkie makes, I think I came more than when you sucked me off," Spike uttered. He tried to pull out, his knot keeping him firmly tied inside Sweetie. Grasping her hips, he pulled his hips back hard, making her moan out and squirm, still riding out her poist-coital high and clenched onto his dick desperately to keep him lodged deep within her. He finally managed to pop out, releasing a deluge of their juices and spill out on Sweetie's bedsheets, mattress, even her anus and tail. Sighing, his cock still hard thanks to the special cupcake, Spike laid down beside Sweetie Belle, draping his arm around her while she came back down to Equestria. "You ok?"

She rolled on her side, opening a tired eye, but gave Spike a dreamy smile. "You...felt so good," she uttered, her panting slowing down as she inched closer, nuzzling his chest with a hum of content. "I love you, Spike."

"...Love you, too, Sweetie Belle," Spike said with a smile. He may have lost his chance with his crush, or never had one from the start, but he had been searching for fish in the wrong sea. He had noticed Sweetie Belle looked quite beautiful compared to her older sister, and she didn't even need any makeup to enhance it more while still retaining that cuteness as a filly. His loving gaze quickly turned into shocked pleasure, feeling something slowly stroke his still stiff shclong. Looking down at his dick, a light green magic aura surrounded it, a brighter pulse within it moving up and down, the source of the mysterious stroking. Glancing over to Sweetie Belle, her horn was glowing, giving him a playful smirk while magically teasing his length. "...Up for another round?"

"I'm still feeling a little sensitive after that wonderful tonguework and feeling so stuffed with your amazing cock. But you're obviously ready for one." Sweetie crawled backwards, feeling his cum slosh around in her womb, even moaning a little as she pressed her belly against the bed, letting some of his baby batter leak out of her gaping cunt. She laid between his legs, her magic still gently stroking his cock, taking a whiff of his musk and their mixed cocktail of scents from their cum, letting out a husky groan, feeling her clit wink and her pussy leak out more of that precious dragon semen. "If you thought my mouth was good while I was half-asleep, let's see how much better it feels when I'm fully awake."

Sweetie Belle lowered her face to the base of Spike's cock, licking the slightly inflated knot, moaning at the taste of their juices blended together. As she rose up, licking his shaft clean, Spike had a dopey grin on his face, getting another blowjob from Sweetie Belle, and it was a bit better with her magic added in with her wonderfully soft lips and broad tongue.

"Best. Holiday. E-" Spike let out a long groan as Sweetie Belle slowly engulfed his cock in her mouth, her moans causing a vibrating feeling through his cock to enhance his pleasure as she began to bob her head up and down with light suckles. "...Ever..."

And from that day on, both Anon and Spike had the best Sexmas ever.

The End