Author's Note

A big shout out to Frostguardian for helping me out big time with this story and Adrian who asked for this story and deserves this story altogether after everything he's been through. Thanks for your patience and support, remember to stay tuned and keep bronying on.

Broken Dreams of Love Restored

Some time passed since Frostbite and his 8 girlfriends had their little get-together in the barn. An orgy like that was something only a handful of men dreamed of having and he felt lucky that he actually let this sort of thing happen to him. If his exes could see him now, they'd be extremely jealous and regret they ever messed around with him. The very thought of it thrilled him more than anything in the world.

He wondered if somehow, AJ's family had planned all of this from the start. So one day, when they all came home, he asked them if it was their plan to get him and AJ alone together. Pear Butter couldn't be more obvious when she gave a sly smirk.

Bright Mac was an open book and admitted that his oldest daughter should have some alone time with Frostbite. Granny Smith even approved of this decision since she knows her own grandchildren were growing up.

Life certainly had become wonderful for Frostbite. Even after that heavenly orgy he still can’t believe that he had won the hearts of so many amazing women. Every day when he woke up, he was always smiling. He assumed Pinkie’s mission: making everyone smile’ had something to do with it.

Sometimes when he gets home from work he’s greeted by Pinkie and Derpy, covered in chocolate syrup and whipped cream. Teasing Frostbite by skipping his dinner and immediately starting with dessert. Indigo visits sometimes as well to escape from her dad’s reign whenever he wants her to try on some of those girly froufrou stuff. Frostbite was happy to oblige and they sometimes go to the fitness together for a good workout which ended with steamy moments in the shower. Sunset and Twilight sometimes invited Frostbite over to help them with ‘their study session’ at Twilight’s home.

Every now and then Frostbite comes to CHS to give the senior students a presentation on what they should do after graduation. But secretly, he would visit Celestia in her office for some private time and even help her to get rid of some stress. Though at one point, she almost got caught by her little sister, Luna. She can be scary sometimes, even Frostbite thought so, too. Gloriosa once visited CHS to announce the students about their yearly trip to Camp Everfree when Frostbite was there as well. It was a heavenly threesome that day, in Tia’s office.

But Gloriosa surprised him the most when she stood naked in his kitchen, preparing breakfast for them on his days off, wearing nothing but an apron for him. Frostbite couldn't help himself but give her a big sausage for breakfast and Gloriosa loved his big, juicy sausage.

Ever since these girls had come into his life, he's felt his whole world go from bad to better. It's like life has done a 180 in his favor. Now a part of him wanted to pay his girlfriends back for all the good they've done for him. So, one day, he gave Applejack a call to have her invite all of the other girls over to his house. Nothing wild like last time, just a nice, normal get-together with some pizza, snacks and watch some movies. She agreed and would arrange a date for the other girls to come over.

Another week goes by and another weekend is starting again. AJ and the others were heading off to Frostbite's house. Frostbite had finished ordering some pizza over the phone and was about to get one of his snacks out.

He heads into the kitchen and opens up the pantry, taking out a bag of Doritos and barbequed potato chips, bringing them into the living room. With some time on his hands, he took it upon himself to clean up the house a little bit. Frostbite sometimes thought about how much of an idiot he felt when he ran out on AJ during high school. It still bugged him that he never got the chance to dance with her and probably never will. On the bright side, at least he has her now as his girlfriend.

Getting back to the business at hand, he resumed cleaning up his house, getting the dishes washed up, his clothes put away and a little vacuuming here and there. This all took a mere 15 minutes before there was a knock on the door. Frostbite jumped up from his couch and ran over to the door, opening it up. AJ, Twilight, Sunset, Pinkie, Celestia, Derpy, Gloriosa Daisy, and Indigo were all present and accounted for.

"Good to see you girls. Come on in, I've got some snacks ready and a lot of movies to choose from to start off our night," Frostbite said happily, letting his ladies in before closing the door. Frostbite saw in Pinkie's hands a couple of snacks she brought along with her. "Good thinking there, Pinkie. The more snacks, the better," he said. Pinkie smiled at him and squeed, almost killing him with her cuteness.

"Only the yummiest treats for my man," Pinkie cutely replied.

“Aw, you really shouldn’t have,” Frostbite winked at her. “As long as I can share them with you and the others, because I can’t eat all that by myself.”

“Of course, silly-willy! You also brought enough sweets and treats for everyone!” Pinkie pulled another giant bag of snacks out her poofy hair this time, all filled with chips, muffins, and other delicious junk food.

"Muffins!!!" Derpy called out, cupping her cheeks and smiling like a kid in an ice cream parlor. "How'd you know I love muffins so much?" she asked.

"You used to bring muffins with you to school, whether it was during lunch or other periods. It's not all that hard to deduce how much you love them, Derpy." Sunset pointed out.

“Not to mention that Pinkie Pie has a secret chamber where she keeps all her files from everyone she’s ever met with all the things they like for their parties.” Twilight added, “It’s really fascinating that she knows all this about us when you think about that.”

“Does that mean she also has a file about me?” Frostbite whispered at Twilight.

"Yup-a-roonie!" Pinkie popped out of nowhere, spooking Frostbite.”I also have files of Principal Celestia, Vice-Principal Luna and from everyone at Crystal Prep!”

“No wonder my last birthday party was amazing!” Indigo realized, before taking a Dorito. ”You had it all arranged that day, my favorite music, snacks, drinks, and all my friends were there.”

"That's our Pinkie Pie for you. The gal knows how to get the job done," AJ commented. "So, Frostbite, when's the pizza gonna get here?"

"In another 10 minutes. While we wait, how about I put on a movie for us? I've got my combo VCR/DVD Player up and ready," Frostbite said.

"Wonderful! I've been wanting to watch a good movie from time to time," Gloriosa said delighted.

"In that case, why don't we all start with a timeless classic movie like Homeward Bound: The Incredible Journey" Frostbite said.

"Really? That's one of my favorite movies!" Celestia said joyously. "It's been a while since I've watched such a touching movie."

"Same here. I have a soft spot for animals as well as my own camp," Gloriosa said.

"Speaking of camp, is your brother looking after it while you're away?" Sunset asked.

"Yup, but there's no need to worry. He's getting a little help from his brand new girlfriend," Gloriosa replied.

"Whoa, he's with someone else now? I didn't know that, who is his new girlfriend? What's she like and how'd they meet?" Frostbite asked.

"I forgot her name, but just between us, she used to date some random guy who treated her like shit and only cared about his video games. Thankfully, after she broke up with the guy and her father beating him up, she found love with my brother. I've never seen any couple so happy before in my life," Gloriosa explained.

"Aww, that's sweet. Well, if you see him, can you tell him I send my best wishes to him and his new girlfriend, please?" Twilight asked.

"Of course, I'll give him the message," Gloriosa said.

"If you guys are done chit-chatting about boyfriends and girlfriends, I'd like to get on with the movie, please." Indigo chuckled. Everyone agreed and huddled up on the couch or sat down in front of it while Frostbite started the movie. Once it started, Frostbite and his lovers munched on some of their snacks. AJ made herself comfortable, cuddling up closer to her boyfriend and rested her head on his shoulder.

A couple minutes later, another knock on the door was heard. Frostbite got up from his seat and walked over, opening up the front door. The pizza delivery guy finally arrived and Frostbite paid the man in cash before taking his pizzas and bag of soda. He walked over to the girls and set the pizzas down on the coffee table along with the sodas.

"Who's hungry for some pizza?" he asked eagerly.

"We are!" the girls shouted in unison. Opening up the first box, each girl got a slice of pizza, including Frostbite, leaving the box itself almost completely empty… almost. Frostbite ran into the kitchen and brought out some cups, handing them to each of his girlfriends. He then poured each of them a cup of soda of their choosing before sitting back down.

Frostbite then wrapped his arm around AJ and held her close to him. AJ inched herself in closer, wanting to feel both the soothing, comforting warmth and protection of her boyfriend. The group shared some laughs while watching the movie and eating their pizza. Then, once the movie was over, Frostbite got back up from his seat and asked his girls, "Alright, whatcha wanna watch next?"

The girls conversed with each other and all decided on watching the sequel: Homeward Bound 2. Nodding, Frostbite took out the first movie from his VCR/DVD Player, putting it back in its case before putting it away. Then he grabbed the 2nd movie from the shelf, then put it in the VCR/DVD player and was about to sit down with the others. But then, he got an idea and walked over to Applejack.

"Somethin' wrong there, sugarcube?" she asked.

"AJ, can we talk… outside for a few minutes, please?" Frostbite whispered in her ear.

"Sure, what for?" she asked.

"I… just want to get something off my chest," he said, scratching the back of his head uncertainly.

"Well, Ah suppose it wouldn't hurt," she agreed. "we'll be right back, gals." The apple farm girl got up from her seat. The two were about to walk out the back door.

"Where are you going?" Indigo asked.

"Is there something wrong?" Celestia asked.

"We’re just heading outside. I need to talk to Applejack about something I’ve wanted to tell her for a while.”

“Alright then you two, but don’t stay out long. Or you’ll miss the best parts of the movie,” Celestia said in understanding.

"Don’t worry, Tia. We won’t be long." Frostbite nodded before he and AJ walked away and closed the door behind him.

Outside, they both saw the beautiful, full moon shining down on them, along with the twinkling stars, showing the amazing beauty of the nights. Frostbite grabbed AJ’s hand and guided her to his cozy hanging chair with some soft pillows on it. Sitting down, it was big enough for just the two of them. Silently they looked in each others eyes for a while, hearing the sounds of crickets in the bushes and some fireflies flying around them, created a relaxing atmosphere for the couple.

"Okay, Frostbite. Ya got me out here, so what'd ya wanna talk about?" AJ asked.

"Applejack, I've probably brought this up a million times, but I still feel like shit knowing that I never got a chance to dance with you during the senior prom. I really wanted to dance with you, but I was just too shy and scared that you might reject me. Even now, I feel stupid for running out on you like that," Frostbite said rather shamefully.

"Aww, Frostbite, Ah'm sorry. If it helps… Ah never went to the senior prom either. Ah knew it was mostly couples who went, which is the reason why Ah stayed home. If ya'd like, we can have our own private senior prom out here. Would that make ya feel better?" she suggested. Frostbite's heart pounded when he stared into AJ's beautiful, emerald eyes. But now that he wasn't afraid anymore, he made his move.

"In that case, Applejack… would you care to dance?" he asked, extending his hand out to her.

"Frostbite… Ah thought you'd never ask," AJ replied. She accepted his hand and got in close with her boyfriend. Frostbite used his other hand to reach into his pocket and took out his phone, starting up some music before they both started their elegant dance under the glorious light of the moon. Frostbite then had both hands on his lover. One hand was holding her hand and his vacant wrapped around her, touching her back.

Applejack and Frostbite kept their eyes locked on each other, smiling warmly and passionately. AJ felt her cheeks heating up the more she stared at her handsome man. She felt like the happiest girl in the world to finally have this moment. She had only dreamt of doing something like this for a long time.

Even Frostbite could share this kind of enthusiasm with her. It was hard to imagine that she never went to the senior prom. But now, it felt like time had reversed and they felt like they were back at high school, everyone's eyes were focused on them. Smiles of approval from every direction, they were the center of attention. Both lovers still kept their eyes locked on each other, then AJ leaned her head on Frostbite's chest, nestling into him. Frostbite had never seen her look so fragile and vulnerable before and so beautiful.

This only gave him more of a reason to want to stay by her side. If he never knew or met her, he wouldn't know where his life would be heading. AJ felt this same way. All her life, she never felt or experienced the joy of finding love in another man.

She always thought she never had what it takes to be a good girlfriend, but Frostbite proved her wrong and now she was happier than ever before. His genuine feelings for her gave her more of a reason to keep going. AJ was so happy, tears of joy ran down her cheeks. She shook a little, obviously getting Frostbite's attention. When he saw her tears, he gently wiped them away and hugged his lover just as the song ended.

The sound of small applause was heard from the nearby window. AJ and Frostbite opened their eyes and saw their lovers cheering for their amazing dance. Frostbite smiled thankfully while AJ gave a small chuckle at them.

“Ah guess we won’t have ta worry about being alone anymore, right, Sugarcube?”

“Our lives have changed, in a very amazing way, Applejack,” Frostbite said holding onto AJ's hand and keeping her close to him. “This is only just the start of our new lives together.”

“Eeyup!” AJ agreed with her lover. “An' Frostbite. There’s something Ah need to confess to you as well.”

"What is it?" Frostbite asked with a raised eyebrow.

"Ah'm embarrassed to admit it, but yer actually mah very first boyfriend. Ah never knew what it was like to be in a relationship," AJ said.

"Never in your life?" Frostbite asked surprised. AJ shook her head. "This might sound messed up, but why didn't you have a previous boyfriend? You're beautiful, honest and you work hard."

"Ah know an' Ah appreciate how highly ya think o' me, but not a lot o' boys were into me, seeing how mah strength was too intimidatin' fer them. It was extremely hard fer a gal like me to find the right man," AJ said.

"I see. Well, it's their loss and my gain. If it makes you feel better, I like a girl who's got a little bit of muscle on her and I was fortunate enough to bring you into my life, my sweet apple dumbling. If the other guys can't see past what's on the surface, it's their fault for not giving you a chance," Frostbite said.

"Aww, that's mighty sweet o' ya to say that, Frostbite. Ya sure know how to make a gal feel special when she's feelin' fragile," AJ said. "Believe it or not, no guy's ever made me feel this fragile or vulnerable except you. An' ya made me feel protected, even if I can handle mahself sometimes, Sugarcube. Mah family was right to trust you with me."

"I should be thanking you, too, AJ. If I never had met you, I'd probably still be looking for a job and Seth and his gang would have beaten me up. Not even my own family would do anything to help me. Meeting you was the absolute bestest thing that's ever happened to me. And I don't want our relationship to deteriorate.”

AJ quickly placed her finger on his mouth. “Don’t think about what could’ve happened, Sugarcube. It ain’t healthy fer thinking that way. Be grateful fer the great things that did happen in yer life.”

“Like having you and the other girls as my girlfriends?” Frostbite sincerely smiled. "I'm gonna be honest, AJ, having one girlfriend would make a man happy, but having 8 of them is like dying and going straight to heaven. But no matter how many girls I've got, you'll always be my alpha female, even after I'm gone from this world."

“Thank ya, Sugarcube, now, there’s just one more thing!” She released herself from her boyfriend’s grip and took off her brown stetson hat, placing it on Frostbite’s head. “There, that makes it more official. Welcome to the family, Frostbite!”

"Heh, thanks, AJ. Now it's time for me to give you something," Frostbite placed a hand under her chin, then leaned in closer to AJ. She also leaned in close and planted her lips with his. Having finally confessed their feelings and dropping a huge weight off their shoulders, the two lovers embraced each other as the moon shined brightly upon their everlasting love. Now at long last, it seems like their broken dreams of love have finally been restored as they should always be.