You and Fluttershy have a pretty great thing going on. Without any kids. And when your condom breaks, you are so not ready for that situation to change.
Luckily, there's an emergency contraceptive, just like back on Earth! You've heard the side effects aren't even that bad...

WARNING: Contains sex, pregnancy scare, blood, vaginal fluids, vomit, swearing, violence, and death. For laughs! :)

Art by CountessMRose. Will take down if requested!