Two Toppings

by Jest

Rating: mature
Tags: Porn, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Fetish, Cozy Glow, Romance, Sex, Profanity, Diamond Tiara
Length: 2928

In an alternate universe a slightly different Cozy Glow and Diamond Tiara go on a date. It does not go well, or does it?

In an alternate universe a slightly different Cozy Glow and Diamond Tiara go on a date. It does not go well, or does it?

Kinks two doms duking it out, futa on futa, inflation, slight bulge, bullying and probably more I'm forgetting.

This was a request for a patron and was viewable earlier for said patrons. Head over here if you want a chance of getting a story like this for just 5$ or to see stories early for just 3$!

Published 2020-01-18 22:40:01 UTC
Last updated 2020-01-18 22:40:01 UTC

Dominance

“This movie is stupid.” Diamond Tiara growled, tossing a hoofull of popcorn at the screen only for the food to land in the mane of the pony sitting in front of her.

Beside her Cozy Glow nodded along with her date. “I can't believe this stupid town only has a movie theatre with two screens.” Lamented the other filly while ignoring the glares from her fellow movie-goers.

“You know it's not too late.” Diamond Tiara began. “Maybe Lassy isn't as bad as curse of the killer space rutabagas.”

“Augh, anything would be better than this.” Cozy Glow agreed. “I can't believe I’m regretting choosing this movie or that stupid cash grab remake garbage.”

Diamond Tiara smirked and leaned towards the other filly. “Say, my parents aren't home, why don't we ditch this whole thing? I got a TV and a DVD player in my room.”

Cozy Glow pretended to think about it while batting her eyelashes. “I don't know. My mother always said to never trust strange ponies who invite you over to their house.”

Both ponies exploded with laughter, and earned themselves twice as many glares from the ponies around them. “Would you two be quiet? Were trying to watch a movie here.” Growled a stallion who leaned over the seats to glare at the fillies.

“Buzz off, dickcheese.” Diamond Tiara replied flippantly.

“Were on the way out anyway, loser.” Cozy Glow added, the filly dumping her soda on the stallion’s head as they walked away.

Together the two fillies laughed at the pony’s misfortune while trotting away, brushing past a stuttering teenage usher without a second thought. “Come on Cozy Glow, let's blow this popsicle stand.” Diamond Tiara remarked with a smirk.

“Popsickle stand, what are you ninety?” Cozy Glow replied with a smirk of her own.

“No really. Do you want to blow over Button Mash’s popsicle stand he had outside?” Diamond Tiara answered, gesturing towards the exit and where they could see a proud colt standing behind his homemade popsicle stand.

“You, I like.” Cozy Glow declared, a cruel smile spreading across her face. “Let's do this.”

The two ponies laughed haughtily to one another as they trotted through the door to Diamond Tiara’s room, each one holding a popsicle. The magenta filly bit through the last bit of her icery treat and chewed it noisily before lazily chucking the stick at her garbage, not looking to see if it went in or not. An act that Cozy Glow quickly followed suit in replicating, the pegasus fluttering her wings and landing on Diamond Tiara’s bed.

“Nice place you got here, princess.” Cozy Glow remarked, pressing a hoof into the large plush mattress, and looking around the spacious room that was filled to the brim with everything a filly could ever want.

“Thanks, peasant.” Diamond Tiara replied, flashing the pegasus a wink.

“Cute.” Cozy Glow muttered while rolling her eyes.

“So what movie do you want to watch?” Diamond Tiara asked, turning towards the veritable wall of dvds. “Cus I got everything released in the last four years, including all the rated R movies daddy doesn't think I have.”

“Oh I think we both know where this is really going so let's just skip the talk.” Cozy whispered from atop the bed.

Diamond Tiara lifted an eyebrow and glanced over at her date, only to stop and stare when she realized the filly was laying on her back, legs spread and stiff cock exposed. “You have got to be kidding me.” Diamond Tiara deadpanned.

“Why would I kid about something like this? I saw you checking me out all night.” Cozy Glow purred, giving her hard cock a little shake. “From the very second we walked into that stupid restaurant you couldn't take your eyes off me.”

“That's because I wanted to fuck you, you idiot.” Diamond Tiara growled, lifting her right foreleg and exposing the equally hard dick that poked out from her own waist. “You got a nice, fuckable ass.”

Cozy Glow blinked, temporarily taken aback only to sit up and cross her hooves over her chest. “Well this is just great, here I thought you wanted this dick. Now I’m blue balled.”

“Fuck this talk.” Diamond Tiara muttered before leaping up onto the bed and shoving the slightly smaller pony onto her back.

“Wait, what are you doing?” Cozy Glow yelled. “I’m supposed to be the one doing the fucking here!”

“Not right now you aren't.” Diamond Tiara growled, her right forehoof holding the filly down while she lined up her cock with whatever hole was closest.

“Stop, you idiot.” Cozy Glow shouted, trying and failing to push the heavier earth pony off of her. “I’ve got a dick you dope.”

“You also got holes to spare.” Diamond Tiara shot back, her hips surging forward and roughly banging her cock against the filly’s unyielding hole. “So I don't see a problem here.”

“That's ra-PE!” Cried the pegasus, voice rising several octaves when Diamond Tiara’s thick cock speared through her defences and slipped inside her tight anus.

“Fuck your tight.” Diamond Tiara grunted, thrusting her hips forward slowly, seesawing more of her dick into the tight confines of the other filly’s body.

“That's because your in my ass you half wit!” Cozy gowled, a hoof weakly smacking the earth pony in the chest.

Who merely shrugged and readjusted her grip on the other pony’s chest. “A hole’s a hole. Besides, your not so tight as I would have expected.” She smirked. “My dick ain't the first thing to be shoved inside of this hole huh?”

“N-no!” Cozy Glow blanched. “I mean, yes, it is the first thing now would you-”

“Stop pretending like you aren't enjoying yourself. I can feel you moving your hips.” Diamond Tiara replied, chuckling at the blush that spread across her partner’s face. “You may be a liar, but your body is not.”

The pegasus couldn't muster a response before she felt Diamond Tiara thrust forward, pushing more and more of her cock inside her. Until finally her balls rested against Diamond Tiara’s chest, and the other filly’s slightly larger testicles rested against Cozy Glow’s ass. “Fuck this is hot.” Diamond Tiara murmured, her eyes closing briefly.

“If you are going to fuck me, you are going to do it properly, you pussy.” Cozy Glow growled angrily, her forehooves grabbing Diamond Tiara by the shoulders and giving her enough leverage to thrust back against her.

The other futa filly’s eyes quickly shot open and she glared down at her partner. “I was enjoying that you prick. I’ll show you who's a pussy.” She grumbled.

Hips connected with a wet slap, both fillies fucking one another with all the strength they could muster. Each one glared into the other’s eyes with unbridled fury, promising a swift end if the other stopped, or at least, they both wanted to think that anyway. Neither seemed ready to admit that they were both enjoying this far more than either had first let on.

Either way, they continued to fuck in silence, both ponies staring into one another’s eyes and unwilling to moan or show any signs of enjoyment before the other did first. Which meant the room was strangely silent with only the clap of flesh meeting flesh and the sharp quick breaths coming from both parties filling in the silence. The rhythmic slap of their bodies meeting grew quicker over time, one party increasing their pace slightly only for the other to match, and exceed it slightly.

This continued over time until both ponies were moving as fast as they could, their hips becoming a blur as they continued to fuck and be fucked in turn. For minutes they kept going at it in silence, until finally Diamond Tiara was the first to break the silence by grunting. “Fuck, I’m cumming.” She muttered.

“Pathetic, I bet your load is going to be tiny and weak, just like your dick.” Cozy Glow insulted, ignoring the fact that her own cock was twitching madly against her chest.

“Fuck no it isn't, I’m gonna fill your ass with my cum.” Diamond Tiara replied, only for her eyes to roll back in her head for a second as she came hard in the other filly’s butt.

Rope after rope of hot cum splashed deep in the filly’s insides, which felt strangely good to both domineering fillies. So good in fact that Cozy Glow couldn't help but cum as well, her own orgasm shooting all over her neck and face and shocking Diamond Tiara with it's sudden occurrence almost as much as much as it shocked Cozy Glow herself. Both fillies were so stunned that they ended up looking at each other and saying nothing, their orgasms slowly petering out. Until Cozy Glow’s face and chest was covered in seed, and Diamond Tiara had dumped every drop into the pegasus’ behind.

Then when their orgasms were over, the collective dam burst, and Diamond Tiara pulled back, laughing hysterically. “Oh my gosh that is so funny. I can't believe you came from getting fucked in the ass!”

“I was not… It wasn't…” Cozy Glow growled dangerously, hopping up to all four hooves and glaring down at her partner who was rolling on the bed, laughing her ass off. “I did not enjoy that!” She shrieked.

“You fucking loved it you freak!” Diamond Tiara yelled back between bursts of laughter. “Stars above I think I might run out of air!”

The pegasus filly’s cheeks grew hot as a blush slowly spread across them, shame and defeat warring in her heart. For a moment she readied a hoof, wanting to utter some kind of rebuttal, only for the limb to fall once more, and the filly to grumble silently. Then, in a sudden fit of rage, she leapt forward, and in one swift motion, landed on Diamond Tiara’s back, and pinned the other filly under her.

“Now it's your turn to get fucked!” She shouted.

“You might have managed to pin me, but how are you going to fuck me?” Diamond Tiara shot back, smirking in apparent victory.

“I’m a pegasus, don't you know were flexible?” Cozy Glow replied, flashing a smirk of her own.

Diamond Tiara had only a few seconds to ponder what that meant before she felt Cozy Glow’s dick slide into her wet pussy in a smooth, slick motion without the assistance of her hooves. “H-hey!” Diamond Tiara shouted, struggling against the other filly half heartedly.

“Now your mine!” Cozy Glow declared, the filly ramming her hips forward and pushing the entirety of her cock into the other filly’s cunt.

“I’ll get you for this you bitch.” Diamond Tiara shot back.

The pegasus shrugged. “I think we both know that's a lie.”

The earth pony grumbled, but said nothing, her weak resistance melting even more until it was little more than a mere token effort. Leaving her open for Cozy Glow to push forward and begin to thrust in and out of her dripping cunt enthusiastically. With a smirk on her face, the pegasus ran a hoof down her lover’s back, smiling a little wider when she felt the other filly twitch under her.

“You like that, don't you slut?” Cozy Glow shot between thrusts.

“Fuck no, I’m just getting you off so I can get back on top.” Diamond Tiara replied, with as much false vitriol as she could muster. “Then I’m going to show you how it's really done!”

Cozy Glow scoffed, her thrusts speeding up and making the entire bed shake, the headboard tapping against the wall with every thrust. “Like you know how it's done, I bet you were a virgin until you fucked my ass.”

“Ha, you wish you were that special, whore!” Diamond Tiara shot back, the filly now actively pushing back against the other filly, who no longer put any effort into keeping Diamond Tiara down.

“I bet it was that dumb bitch Silver Spoon, that hardly even counts.” Cozy Glow remarked dismissively.

“She's straight, and isn't dumb.” Diamond Tiara deadpanned, shooting a glare over her shoulder.

Cozy Glow’s thrusts slowed for a few seconds before she shook her head and continued pounding the filly’s pussy. “Whatever, you probably just bought a prostitute or something anyway. Like the total princess you are.”

“Nope. I fucked Silver Spoon’s older sister though.” Diamond Tiara replied, the two ponies having reached an equilibrium where their thrusts were in sync, and their desires intertwined.

“Shut up.” Cozy Glow muttered in a shocked tone, slapping the other filly’s shoulder. “There is no way you fucked her. She's like the hottest mare in the whole school.”

“She moans really really high pitched when she cums.” Diamond Tiara replied, the filly biting her lip when she felt the other filly’s cock rub a particularly pleasurable point inside her.

“You are so telling me about it after I fill you with cum.” Cozy Glow snickered.

Diamond Tiara shrugged. “Just do it already, my last heat was a week ago so I’m safe.”

The pegasus grumbled when she noticed how little Diamond Tiara seemed to be enjoying herself, and not wanting to get shown up, Cozy Glow shifted her hips and really laid into the other filly. Her forehooves moved back to the other pony’s hips, allowing her a better position to fuck her, and really hit where she wanted to. The result was immediate, and Diamond Tiara began to moan louder, and lewder, her counter thrusts disrupted by just how good Cozy Glow’s dick felt inside her.

Noticing this, Cozy Glow decided to keep her mouth shut, and her hips moving, thankful that the new position gave her the leverage she needed. In a few more thrusts and it was clear that Diamond Tiara was growing close, meaning the domineering pegasus no longer had to hold back her own orgasm. Something she had been doing for the last few seconds by biting her lip and trying her best to think unsexy thoughts.

Pleasure all but flooded through the pony’s body and nearly pushed her over the edge, but she refused to let it arrive yet. Holding on for a few more seconds, Cozy Glow resisted the siren song of her coming orgasm until she felt Diamond Tiara’s cunt begin to squeeze down around her, signalling that the other pony was cuming as well. When that happened she sped up until she came deep inside the other filly, Cozy Glow lurching to a sudden stop when the second pulse of seed shot inside the earth pony.

The two fillies cried out in pleasure, Cozy Glow’s wings flapping sporadically as she came harder than she had in a long, long while. Then when it was over and she pulled out, flopping onto her back beside her partner, sweat dripping down her body as cum dribbled from her asshole. “You got a nice tight pussy, I’ll give you that.” Cozy Glow muttered, legs splayed in all directions.

“I’m glad you like it, because I’m about to see if yours feels as good as your ass does!” Diamond Tiara declared, hopping up and onto the other filly, her semi hard cock flopping against the pegasus’ hole.

“I’d like to see you try.” Cozy Glow declared coldly while leveling a glare at the other pony.

“Watch me.”

Two fillies lay on their backs, limbs splayed in all directions, fur matted with wet cum. Cum which dribbled from both ass and pussy of both filly’s pooling beneath them on the now quite disgusting bedding. For a few seconds they just lay there, too exhausted to say or do anything, their bodies aching from the abuse they had taken, and dished out.

Then Cozy Glow suddenly spoke up. “Bitch.”

“Slut.” Diamond Tiara fired back with the same half hearted anger.

A few more seconds passed in silence before the earth pony turned to her partner, and flashed her a smirk. “So, wanna meet up tomorrow for another movie?”

Cozy Glow turned to the other filly and smirked. “That depends. Are we actually going to watch something next time?”

Diamond Tiara chuckled. “I doubt it. After all you can't resist this gorgeous ass of mine.”

“The only thing amazing about your ass is how fucking tiny it is.” Cozy Glow pointed out.

The earth pony rolled over and mounted the other filly in a swift motion, uncaring to how sticky and disgusting their bodies had gotten. “So, down for round thirteen?” She asked, already knowing the answer.

“You know it, slut.”

Author's Note

If you want to read the next updates for my biggest stories at the begining of the month rather at the end, or want to get a commission from me as well as access to patreon exclusive content, and the chance to submit story requests every month, head over to my patreon!

Join me over on patreon and get instant access to exclusive content and early looks at new stories, patreon only stories and other great stuff! Check it out!
Or just join the discord to ensure that you dont miss an update.
This update was made possible by the wonderful support of readers like you: Anonymous, Apollyon, Astor, Blade Tech, Brendan, Canary in the coal mine, ceepert, chris, craig, dale, diokyo, doomgooey, egery, facinus, free, ghidrah, grub, I am unknown, Ivar, Jeffrey, Kali, M, Makani, Megatyrant, Menthol Qtip, Mike, Mikhalia, Mirvra, Nathan, Neverborn, Nfreak, Nicky, Octavia, Pacsik, Peter, Random Reader, Renegade, Soundtea, Sparkizeil, Starless, Steven, T Sparkle, Tiwake, Todd, Travis, Vigilant Watch, aaaand Xvos!