The next day, Star had come into work with a distinctly nervous feeling. Four pregnant mares… Surely somepony must have noticed something by now. He was sure today would be the day he’d get called out on it, the day it would all come crashing down around him.

But no… It had been a perfectly normal day. And since the day had been a bit overcast and drizzly, there hadn’t even been much business at the spa. The lack of business, though, meant that Aloe and Lotus weren’t overly busy … which meant they were able to take care of all the massages – including the heat treatment massages – all by themselves. Star had found himself demoted back to towel-boy, and it rankled a bit. After the incredible experiences of the past two days, it felt weird and a little bit degrading to just do his ordinary job all day again. It wasn’t until the very end of the day that things got interesting…

Just as Star was folding up the last load of towels and heading to switch off the lights in the main hot tub room, Aloe and Lotus came up to him.

“Ah, there he is, Sister.” Lotus pointed right at him.

“Me?” he said, a sudden attack of nerves hitting him. Had they noticed something amiss in the massage room? Were they about to finally come down on him?

“Oh no!” Aloe said. “Look how we are paining him so – we cannot impose so much. I am sure he has many things planned to do later in the day.”

Aloe was already turning to go, but Lotus reached a hoof out to block her path, keeping her there for the moment. “It will not hurt only to ask. He can always say no to us.”

Slowly, Aloe turned around. “Er… Star, my sister and I have one small request of you, if you could, before leaving for the rest of day…”

Lotus rolled her eyes. “Really, Sister. This is not so big of a request that you must talk so.” She looked directly at Star. “We want to know if perhaps you would be willing to help the two of us today. You see … we also are needing the heat treatment.”

Star’s eyes went wide. No… No way… This could not be happening!

Aloe nodded. “Usually, we do this for each other, one at a time … but this is very time consuming. It takes all of the evening.”

“But since you are here and you have done so well with the other mares…” Lotus looked at him hopefully. “Would you help us with it, and then we can all go home earlier?”

“You do not have to if you do not want,” Aloe was quick to add. “We do not want to take away your personal time. We only ask you this as a personal favor…”

Star struggled to keep his growing grin at polite, friendly levels … rather than the manic creepy levels it wanted to reach. “Of course I’ll help – I’d be happy to. And I’ll do my very best!” Hopefully it wouldn’t show in his face how he was already imagining the two perfectly-matched sisters in the kinds of situations he’d put Fluttershy and Rarity in yesterday...

“Excellent,” Lotus said. “You see Aloe, I told you that he would be happy to help us.”

Aloe just smiled and shrugged, pressing herself side-to-side against her sister in the way these two often showed affection for each other.

Lotus waved him closer and began to explain, “My sister and I have already prepared the sauna room with the correct herbs and temperature, but you will need to come open the door in one hour and get us out of it.”

Aloe nodded alongside. “This is very important! You must not leave us in there for too long, or it could take us days to recover! We do not even know what the effects of that might be.”

“And who then would do all of the massaging and the spa treatments?”

Star would have liked to confidently tell them that he could do it if they took a day off … but he knew he couldn’t. He knew the basics now, but there were still a lot of complicated treatments done here that he knew almost nothing about. Cucumber Slice could probably help with a lot of it, but there were surely things he didn’t know either. The place would simply have to shut down without Lotus and Aloe running it. “Exactly one hour. Got it,” he said solemnly.

Aloe lowered her voice a little. “When we are done with the sauna treatment we will be a little bit, eh…”

“We will be in the trance state,” Lotus said more bluntly. “I am sure you have seen it with the other mares.”

Star nodded. Oh, if they only knew just how familiar he was with that trance state by now.

“But this will not be any problem,” Aloe said brightly. “You need only to ask us politely to go to the heat treatment room, and we will do it.”

“Say nothing else,” Lotus added firmly. “You say ‘Please go to heat treatment massage room’ only.”

He nodded again. “Sure. Are you starting right away?”

Aloe nudged her sister. “We should. After all, we do not want to keep Star here longer than is necessary.”

“Yes of course,” Lotus said. “We will start right away. Make very certain you come get us out of the sauna in one hour, Star.”

“I will.”

The two mares turned around in an oddly symmetrical way, then headed back into the main hallway, turning right – toward the sauna.

And just at the same moment, Cucumber Slice passed the same doorway from right to left, squeezing past the sisters. He glanced inside and gave Star an odd, squinty look before continuing on his way.

What did that mean? Was Cucumber Slice getting suspicious, or was he just jealous? Or was it something else entirely?

Well, no matter what, Star wasn’t giving up his chance with the spa twins if he could help it! Quickly, he glanced at the clock high up on the wall. Okay, an hour from now … and then things would get interesting.

* * *

It was weird, seeing the spa so empty and quiet. Even in the morning before opening or in the evening after closing, there would still be the bustle of cleanup or preparations going on. But now there was just … nothing. The place was actually a bit creepy all empty like this.

Star hadn’t seen Cucumber Slice in quite a while. He hadn’t actually seen the other stallion leave, but it was probably safe to assume that Slice had gone home for the day … just as Star normally would have by this time of the evening.

He checked the clock again. Fifty-nine minutes. By the time he made it from the lounge chair he’d appropriated in the hoof polishing area to the sauna, it would be time to get the twin sisters out. His cock twinged, and a little nub protruded out from his sheath, just from the anticipation of what was to come. Star didn’t bother trying to hold it in. There was nopony else in the spa, right? Nopony to see him.

Grinning, he got up and made his way down the hallway to the sauna. It wasn’t very far.

The view of the sauna room was a familiar one – after all, it was used all throughout the year, and for many things other than heat treatments – with its rustic-looking wooden plank walls, smooth wooden benches, and big brazier in the middle.

What wasn’t familiar was seeing Aloe and Lotus in there, sitting on towels on top of the slatted wooden benches … and just staring blankly at the herbs smoking on the brazier. They were so motionless, their eyes so vacant… Not to mention the smell of the herbs when he opened the door – so acrid! – it made his eyes water and made him want to cough. How did these mares stand it? And was this really better than being in heat? It gave him a new appreciation for how bad being in heat must be.

“Come on out, ladies,” he said cheerfully … once he’d cleared the strong-smelling steam out of his lungs. “Time to go to the massage room.”

“Come … ladies … massage room,” Aloe mumbled, slowly getting up from the bench.

Her sister rose as well, her voice just as distant and dreamy. “Ladies time … massage…”

He didn’t actually have to lead them there as he’d thought he might need to. Even in their dazed state, they knew this spa down to the very last detail, better than anypony.

And that was all good for him. It meant that instead of walking in front of them, he was able to walk behind them … which gave him a much better view along the way. Under normal circumstances the two of them would almost always angle their tails just the right way if a stallion was walking behind them, for the most part keeping their most interesting bits hidden from view. Of course, in the short while he’d been working here, Star had been able to sneak a few glances under their tails, but he’d never had the luxury of taking this much time to do so. With both mares paying him no mind and just carrying their tails neutrally and comfortably, he was able to look at them as much as he pleased … and he pleased to do so pretty much the whole way to the massage room.

These two really were identical down to the last little detail, weren’t they? The only thing different about either of them was their color. Under Aloe’s blue tail, there was dainty little pink bulb of a pussy, slightly darker pink than her coat … and under Lotus’s pink tail was a perfectly matching one, but in blue. Each pussy was smallish and tucked deep in between the mare’s ass cheeks, and both of them looked the same sort of delicately soft. He could swear they even had the same pattern of subtle wrinkles between their slits and assholes. He’d have to admit that Lotus’s was the more visually striking of the two: while Aloe had a little hint of deeper pink between her already pink pussy lips, the little sliver of pink he could see in Lotus’s slit stood out vividly against her delicate blue skin and fur, matching her tail perfectly.

He was halfway tempted to just take them both right there in the hallway. After all, his cock was already slipping out and swinging between his legs with every step. All he’d have to do would be to hurry for a few steps then lift himself onto one or the other’s back. Not yet, though… He’d wait for the massage room first. The three of them were almost there anyway, despite how slowly the mares walked.

Once everypony was inside the massage room, Star didn’t waste one moment on any pretense of massages. “Stand side by side and lift your tails,” he told them.

They were much better at carrying out his instruction than repeating it. Their words came in a jumbled mess as they talked over one another, but they were perfectly coordinated as they bumped their rumps together, each one lifting her tail high and to the side, away from the other. They made such a pretty picture – Aloe on the left and Lotus on the right. Had they posed for stallions this way before? That would explain why they were so good at it.

And oh, that little spot where their cute round asses pressed against one another! He couldn’t help but rush up to them and start touching them anywhere and everywhere he could. With one hoof he touched Aloe’s buttery-soft pussy; with the other he traced the lovely curve of Lotus’s ass. Then he’d switch, and switch again, running his hooves over every bit of them, all the way from the docks of their tails to reaching down between their warm inner thighs to tickle their teats.

And since the herbs still hadn’t quite had their full effect yet, they were both still mares in heat, and they responded like it. Both grew from a few furtive winks into winking at him desperately, each of them dripping juices down into two matching puddles.

He couldn’t take it anymore – he just had to have them! His achingly hard cock needed to be inside a mare’s pussy right now, but he still just couldn’t choose which one to have first!

As breeding instinct overwhelmed him, he ended up lunging for Lotus first … maybe just because when she winked, the little teardrop shape of pink that flashed out was just so visible against her blue body, compared to Aloe’s equally fervent – but less noticeable – flashes of pink on pink.

His left hoof forced the twin sisters apart from each other a little bit as he shoved it between the two of them and mounted Lotus. He moaned to himself in anticipation as his chest slid up over Lotus’s rump, as the tip of his cock pressed against the hot, winking softness of her pussy lips. Aloe looked on, her face passive and pleasant.

Lotus gasped a little as he pressed his cock into her. Oh wow – he hadn’t been expecting how good it would feel to tease cute little sounds like that out of his bosses. This was going to be fun! Every little gasp and cooing moan he teased out of her only drove him to want more. Quickly, quickly, he worked his way all the way in, hilting himself inside her. She was so smooth and supple inside – now this was a spa treatment! Nothing could beat having his employer’s warm inner walls tightly wrapped around his cock, her entrance winking over and over again right next to his sheath.

There was another sound that tweaked his ear, though – a subtle little squeak from Aloe.

Oh, did she want some, too? Star himself didn’t have any brothers or sisters, but he was still pretty sure that one of the most important lessons from having one was that siblings should share… Lotus would just have to let Aloe have a turn. It was only fair.

Maybe Lotus hadn’t learned that lesson, or maybe the herbs had made her forget it, because she let out a plaintive, wordless whine when he pulled his cock out of her. He wouldn’t be persuaded by the likes of that, though. Aloe needed him too.

Star switched over to Aloe’s back without even really dismounting – he just had to shuffle to the side a little bit, pulling himself onto Aloe’s back instead of Lotus’s. Once he’d gotten his cock lined up with her, it was even easier to push it inside Aloe than her sister – after all, his shaft was already well-lubed with her twin’s juices.

Was it weird that he enjoyed the idea of spreading one sister’s juices inside the other? A little bit incestuous, somehow? He decided not to worry about it. After all, they’d probably done all this before, right? Rumors abounded about the spa’s off-menu ‘special deluxe treatment’. Every time some other stallion found out he worked here, they’d always ask about it. He’d never seen anything while working here to suggest the rumors might actually be true … but they must have started somewhere, right?

And anyway, he was quite distracted from questions like that by the sheer feeling of Aloe’s pussy slipping around his cock as he eased his way into her. It was just like slipping into her twin sister, except easier and smoother this time, since his cock was already slippery. Quickly – quickly enough to earn him a strained little gasp from Aloe – he had his entire cock inside her, his tip pressing against her innermost depths.

The door opened.

Star’s heart slammed in his chest as he frantically pulled himself out of Aloe’s pussy. She squealed indignantly as he slid off of her, but he ignored that, instead turning, his face aghast, to see…

Cucumber Slice stood silhouetted in the light of the doorway, a look of outrage and confusion in his eyes. “What the fuck, dude! What do you think you’re doing?”

As the twin sisters dazedly repeated what Slice said, Star tried to get his mouth moving … and once he’d managed that, he tried to get coherent sounds to come out. He wasn’t very successful. Oh, there would be no playing this off – Slice must have seen everything, and Star’s cock was still hanging out, wet with both sisters’ juices.

“I… I can explain!” He couldn’t – he absolutely couldn’t. But he had to say something.

“You can explain to the guards and to … to … Princess Twilight!”

Oh no! Anypony but her! Star could just imagine it now, Twilight’s clever mind putting the puzzle pieces together and figuring out that Star might have very well done the same thing with her… “Don’t!” He dropped to his knees in front of Slice. “Please don’t! I’ll do anything!”

Slice shook his head and backed up a little bit. “What the heck would I want from somepony like you?”

Star looked back at the twin sisters, still standing there with their tails raised and their wet pussies winking as they softly repeated almost every word of the confrontation.

“What the actual fuck, dude! You’re offering me them?”

Star shrugged. What else could he do?

“No way. Not going to happen. We’ll both end up getting caught. How can you be so stupid? They’re going to remember everything when they wake up, and then you’ll be in for it!”

“No! They do whatever you say … and if you tell them to forget everything, they will! They won’t remember a thing!”

Slice’s face scrunched up. “How can you know that?” Then his eyes went wide. “Oh you fucking bastard! You’ve done this before, haven’t you – with other mares!”

It was true, but Star wasn’t about to admit to it if he didn’t have to. And even though it didn’t sound like he was winning Slice over, he could see Slice’s cock beginning to slip out and hang below his belly. The sight of the twins like this was getting to him, and maybe – just maybe – that would be enough.

“You’re … you’re sure they won’t remember?”

Star fought to keep himself from grinning. “Uh-huh.”

But Slice shook his head, as if trying to rattle his own thoughts loose. “No … no – this is too fucked up!”

Star knew he had to convince Slice somehow. If he couldn’t get Slice in on it, Slice would surely tell somepony … and then Star would be busted for sure.

Thankfully, he knew where he could get a little help with that convincing. He got up and darted back over to Aloe and Lotus. Running one hoof up the curve of Aloe’s pink rump, he looked back at Slice. “You’ve got to try this, though. They’re so good!”

“I don’t know, dude…”

Moving over to Lotus, Star put on an even more blatant show, grabbing both cheeks of her nice blue ass and spreading them a bit, pulling her pussy open slightly. And Lotus helped, too – her pussy winked open even further, trickling a little bit of her juices from the dark, inviting gap between her hot pink inner walls. Star knew the way Lotus’s pink insides contrasted with her blue body and matched her pink tail was just too striking to look away from … and when he saw Slice’s cock rising fully erect, he knew he’d managed to sway the other stallion.

“Well, um… I guess … maybe just this once?” Slice tore his eyes away from Lotus’s pussy for a moment, just long enough to glare back at Star. “But you’d better not do this again! If I ever see you with the heat treatment mares again, I’ll… I’ll… You’ll wish I just told the guards and had them drag you in front of the nearest Princess!”

Star nodded quickly and fervently, then patted Lotus’s rump enticingly, making it jiggle a little.

Giving him the stink-eye as he came, Slice nonetheless trotted up behind Lotus eagerly enough … and once he was there, he seemed to forget about Star entirely. Every bit of his focus was centered underneath Lotus’s tail as he lifted his hoof up, caressing her blue pussy lips reverently.

And as for Star himself… Well, he had a mare of his own to concern himself with, didn’t he? He had to go all the way around behind Slice in order to get to Aloe, but of course it was worth it – she still stood there, her hind legs braced and her tail raised just as she’d been when she was ready to take his cock, and he wasn’t about to make her wait any longer than she already had.

Well, except for one little detail. “Move a little to the side, Aloe.”

“Move … to side…” Aloe shuffled over a little bit away from her twin sister, giving Star room to mount her without awkwardly bumping into Slice’s side as he did so.

It was only after mounting her that he realized his cock wasn’t quite as hard as it had been before Slice opened the door. It swung up underneath his belly, bumping up between Aloe’s legs – which made her tail twitch upward and her pussy wink like crazy – but then his cock swung back down, hanging between him and her. Well, arguing with Slice hadn’t exactly done wonders for his arousal.

What was helping, though, was the feeling of warm, soft fur underneath his chest and between his forelegs, the feeling of Aloe’s tail tucked up against his body, and the slight sound of her breathing quickening as she anticipated his cock entering her. Quickly, his cock began to rise back up to the occasion.

Slice beat him to it, though, mounting up onto Lotus in a hurried shuffle. Star’s eyes went wide as he watched the other stallion’s cock prodding and poking around under Lotus’s tail, searching for just the right spot … and then sinking in, her pussy lips pressing inward a little bit and stretching around him.

His own tip rose high enough to touch against Aloe’s pussy lips. And with the sight of Slice doing the same still fresh in his mind, he pushed forward, sinking his tip back into Aloe’s wonderful little pussy. For a little while, that was the only thing that mattered to him – the heat of Aloe’s inner walls slipping over his shaft once more, enveloping him from his tip slowly all the way down to his base, hilting himself inside his own boss again.

A little feminine squeak caught his attention … and he didn’t even know which of the twins made it. They sounded so much alike! He could very much still enjoy thrusting away into his own mare, though – and he very much did. Oh, the feeling of her pussy sliding up and down his shaft! This was absolute bliss! And, really, having double the amount of little gasps and moans was all for the better. Even if he was only causing half of them and he wasn’t quite sure which half, those desperate little sounds had a way of shooting right into the most primitive part of his brain.

Both sisters rocked back and forth under their respective stallions, making their little unconscious sounds of passion. But what really made Star’s eyes go wide was when he noticed the two sisters looking at each other. Each of them had a dopey, satisfied-looking smile, with big grins and half-lidded eyes … and they stared right into one another’s eyes, making continuous eye contact with each other as each of them got rutted by a different stallion.

It was starting to get to him. Between the sight of the sisters sharing their barely-conscious moment, the feeling of Aloe’s warm pussy wrapped around his shaft, and the knowledge that he was finally getting to ‘stick it to his boss’ in the most literal way possible, he could tell he wasn’t going to last very much longer. His flare was already beginning to grow a little inside her.

But he tensed as hard as he could and actually slowed down his rhythm a little bit. Even though he’d already had some stimulation before Slice even came into the room, he was perversely committed to lasting longer than the other stallion, as a strange point of pride. After all, he was used to this, right? He should be able to keep himself going way longer than Slice!

It wasn’t easy. No matter how much he tried to hold himself back, the feeling of Aloe’s inner walls rippling over his medial ring, the feeling of her entrance winking around his base, and the feeling of her soft warm depths molding around his tip wasn’t easy to resist. Despite everything he did, his flare grew out to its full potential, filling Aloe deep inside and only intensifying the sensations for him as her innermost places were stretched tight around him. Oh, it was coming – he wouldn’t be able to hold out much longer, not anymore…

Maybe he wouldn’t have to, not to ‘win’ this little contest in his head between himself and Slice. Because Slice sure seemed to be getting really into it – he was hunched down low over Lotus’s back, biting down viciously on the base of her mane as his body scrunched again and again, pulsing himself deeper inside her. He barely pulled out at all before ramming himself back in again, and again, and again. His eyes squeezed shut, and he let out little groaning sounds with each struggling breath.

Star himself couldn’t help but make a few groans of his own as he tried to hold himself back just a little longer … just a little more…

Suddenly, Slice yanked his cock out of Lotus’s pussy – all the way out, jamming the flare of it back between her flank and his own hoof as his body spasmed through a couple more involuntary thrusts. His cum jetted out between Lotus and Aloe, squirting out in long lines onto the increasingly stained massage room carpet.

Finally, Star could let himself go. It felt like finally being set free … and after only a couple more uninhibited thrusts inside Aloe’s pussy, he hilted himself inside her one last time.

Slice was already sliding off of Lotus’s back when he looked over, no doubt seeing the pulsing of Star’s cock as he pumped stream after stream of his cum deep inside Aloe. Slice’s jaw dropped.

But Star paid him no mind. All he cared about in this moment was filling the beautiful pink mare beneath him, giving her everything he had. His cum poured into her, sloshing right into her waiting womb. Yes! Now this was more like it – this was the feeling he’d been craving. There was nothing like it – nothing like cumming inside a mare in heat, knowing he’d get her pregnant. Would Lotus get jealous of Aloe’s swelling belly? Would that make her want a dose of her own? Star could already imagine giving it to her as well, spreading the love to any and every mare who so much as winked at him.

His orgasm seemed to go on forever, making up for Slice’s pulling out of Lotus by giving Aloe enough for two … enough for a dozen! But eventually, it did subside. He shuddered with pleasure as he pulled out of her, letting his now-limp and very messy cock swing under his belly as it plopped out. A little gush of white cream followed him, smearing down over Aloe’s hind legs as it splashed down to the carpet.

“What the fuck, dude? You came inside her? The heat treatment herbs don’t make mares infertile – they just kind of take away the desire… You’re gonna get her pregnant!”

Still breathing heavily, Star shrugged. The sight of his cum leaking from Aloe’s pussy was more important than any future trouble he might get into.

“Oh crap, oh crap – we have to get this cleaned up. What the fuck were you thinking, dude? When Aloe turns up pregnant, they’re gonna figure out what happened for sure! We’ll both get thrown in the dungeons forever!” Slice began nervously pacing back and forth, his hooves beating against the soft carpet.

“Relax, relax!” Star said, trying to calm the other stallion. It didn’t work very well on him, but both sisters visibly slumped into utter relaxation after repeating the command.

“But dude, they’re gonna—”

Star grabbed him by the shoulders and forced him to stop pacing. “Nothing’s going to happen. And if it does, I’ll take full responsibility. I’ll say you didn’t know anything about it.” He tried to ignore the two mares softly repeating all of that.

“But—”

“It’s going to be fine. Just swear to me that you won’t tell anypony.”

Slice glanced at the two mares again, then looked back at Star. “I don’t know, dude… What’s your plan for when Aloe finds out she’s pregnant? We’re gonna be busted for sure.”

“I’ll figure something out.” It didn’t sound very convincing, even to Star. He knew that was a weak point in what passed for his plan. If he was a smart pony, he wouldn’t be doing this stuff in the first place. “But you have to swear you won’t tell anypony.”

“Um, um…” Slice glanced at the mares again. “Oh crap, dude… Oh crap…”

“Come on, snap out of it!”

Slice shook his head violently, then took a step back, seeming to come back to himself a little bit. “Alright, alright. I… I won’t tell anypony. But you have to promise me – promise me you won’t ever do this again, alright?”

Star took a deep breath. “Okay, deal.”

“So…” Slice took a look around, his eyes growing a bit desperate again as he looked at the scene in front of him. “W-what the fuck do we do now?”

“You grab some towels and clean up that mess you made on the floor. I’ll clean up the mares and tell them to forget all this and not to tell anypony even if they do remember. Then we just get them on the massage tables and finish the heat treatment like nothing ever happened, got it?”

Slice nodded rapidly. “Yeah. Yeah. Okay. I can do that. It’s gonna be okay. It’s gonna be okay, right?”

“Right.” As Star started wiping his cum away from Aloe’s pussy, he surreptitiously watched Cucumber Slice. This was bad… The mares, he could be sure of. They’d do anything he asked. But Slice? He wasn’t under the influence of any herbs. There was no way Star could trust him to keep this quiet, not with this much at stake.

He’d have to make his exit soon, before all of this could blow up in his face. Move to a new town or something. Heck, maybe he should get out of Equestria entirely, somewhere the Equestrian law couldn’t track him down… Maybe go live with the hippogriffs or something? Ooh! or the changelings – they were supposed to be nice now, right? And he wouldn’t mind feeding them some love, especially if they transformed themselves into pretty pony mares first…

Author's Note

This story is a commission for iguanaonastick. If you'd like to get a commission of your own done, go to my Commissions Page. And remember, Patreon supporters get big discounts on commissions!