A Heaping Spoonful of Peanut Butter

Deciding to surprise his mare Night Light, shortly after leaving his friends in his journey home sent Velvet fallacious letter in hopes that she’d fall for it, get disappointed, only for him to raise her hopes back up in some sappy romantic gesture. It was stupid, but he knew how much she adored the stupid things he did for her, and for whatever reason he had noticed that Velvet seemed to be a bit more withdrawn than usual.

Opening the door, still slightly drunk, Night Light swaggered through the hallway towards Velvet and his bedroom with an only slightly drank bottle of expensive red wine and roses in magical tow. “Sweetie, I’m home early.” He said lovingly, assuming that she must have already been asleep upon receiving no response.

Smiling to himself Night Light continued to make his way towards the bedroom, imagining all the ways that he could surprise his beautiful mare, until he reached the living room and heard some light snoring coming from the couch. Trotting up behind the couch Night Light gingerly snaked his hoof over the towards the cute mare lying upon it, lovingly caressing her soft mane as he made his way around the couch so he could embrace her.

Noticing Winter sleeping soundly behind her he ran his hoof over the dogs soft fur before he silently climbed onto the couch, taking Velvet in his strong forehooves as he began to stroke along soft belly, receiving a few quiet cooes as a reward. He then lay one forehoof gently under her neck as he began to nuzzle and lay gentle kisses down his sleeping mares beautiful face, slowly tracing the other hoof down her belly as he reached for and beyond her thighs, imagining that she’d get a rather pleasant awakening.

Kissing behind her ear Night Light snuck his hoof down the mares soft thighs as he reached affectionately towards her marehood. Brushing past the mares supple teats Night Light’s eyebrows raised in confusion as he felt a hard bulbous mass where his wife’s marehood should have been. Looking down in confusion his eyes quickly became wild in shock as he saw the source of what he had felt. Winter, his dog had his cock firmly buried within his wife’s marehood, the firm bulbous mass he had felt having been the result of an animal who had happily satisfied his female and had taken her tight pussy captive with his massive knot in order to ensure that she’d have a full womb of his seed, and that no other male could mount her.

He instantly panicked and pulled his hoof far away from Winter’s cock, accidentally hitting his wife in the face with his other forehoof, causing her to stir in her sleep before opening her eyes, only for her to panic in turn. “V-velvet? What are you doing?” He said hesitantly.

A thick bead of sweat ran from Velvet’s forehead before she finally mustered up the courage to respond apprehensively. “Um, nothing dear. I’m just sleeping wi….besides Winter.” She said, trying to cover the dogs offending appendage with her tail.

Not knowing how to respond and still shocked Night Light desperately tried to defuse the situation before things got nastier than they needed to, from either side. “Please, sweetie, don’t lie to me. I saw. Now please, get up, I think we should talk about this in private, away from him.” He said, looking down at her with a somber expression of disappointment rather than one of anger as he gestured towards Winter.

Velvet’s eyes merely burst in guilt as she stuffed her face into the couch and sobbed uncontrollably, cursing herself being such a ‘bad wife’, for being a ‘slut’. “I’m so, so sorry Night Light! I couldn’t help myself! I’m a horrible adulterous wife, and with a dog no less!” She screamed over and over again into the soft fabric of the couch.

Still taken aback, but concerned for his mare Night Light placed his head beside hers, nuzzling her comfortingly as he whispered into her ear. “Look sweetie, I don’t know what could possibly drive you to do something like this, but I still love you, you’re still my beautiful mare. But, we’re going to have to talk about this sweetie. If there’s something wrong you’re going to have to tell me. I’m sorry, but you can’t just keep this from me, we need to talk. I love you Velvet.” He said, a single tear running down his own cheeks as he whispered those last four words into her ear and felt her own wet tear ridden fur rub against his.

Helping her up, Night Light tried not to cringe as he heard the sound of Winter’s knot releasing itself from his wife’s pussy, although it was clear to him that this was causing her a lot more emotional distress than himself. “Just lean against me and we’ll head towards the bedroom. I don’t want to punish you, but we need to talk about this.” He said, nuzzling against the mare as she leaned hard against him for comfort, hiding her face in his mane as they made their way towards the bedroom.

Arriving at their bedroom Velvet was no less distort, finding it hard to gain any sense of comfort in the embrace of the stallion who she had so shamelessly cheated on, who’s trust she had so mercilessly shattered. She felt like a worthless harlot, willing to raise to her tail for any animal who excited her at a moment's notice, not to be trusted by an honest stallion, not worthy of such love or respect, and it was all her fault.

Night Light sat his mare gently down on the bed before sitting directly in front of her, giving her soft muzzle an affectionate kiss before holding a forehoof against her cheeks, and staring somberly into her eyes. “Look, I don’t how this happened, but I’m trusting you, as my wife, to be honest with me. What happened sweetie? I won’t judge you until I’ve heard every word.” He said, looking affectionately into her eyes.

Velvet hesitantly looked up to her stallion’s warm accepting face, with tears still running down her cheeks. “I, I don’t know. A, a few weeks ago, the day before I asked you to eat me out, I was lying in bed and I felt a warm tongue lapping away at my marehood. I assumed it was you and got really excited, because you rarely if ever touch me without me having to beg for it first. H-he seemed so eager, so excited. It wasn’t the actual feeling of the do….of its tongue on my marehood that I enjoyed, it was the thought of my stallion surprising me like he used to, eating me out for no other reason than that he was horny and wanted to pleasure me, not because I asked, not because he felt obligated, but because he loves me, because he lusts after me. After realising that I was mistaken and Winter was the one eating me out I naturally felt disgusted, which turned into a sinking feeling of loss when you came into the bedroom and just fell asleep, and I suppose at some point loss turned into longing, and after having you out of the house for a few days longing turned into lust, which overpowered any disgust I may have felt.” She said in her stallion’s protective forehooves as she began to lean into him, and wept lightly. “I’m so sorry.” Was the last thing she said to him before stuffing her face into his chest.

Night Light gently patted his mares face as he tried to comfort her. “No, I’m sorry sweetie. Don’t get me wrong, what you did was wrong, and I’d personally go as far as saying that it disgusts, but I can understand how you feel. I’ve not been seeing to you properly, to my mare properly, to the extent that she’d consider degrading herself in such a way, and that Velvet is something I should be apologising to you for.” He said as he began to kiss along her face in a sensual manner, laying one of his forehooves on her supple rump. “Velvet, will you allow me to apologise to you?” He said as he gave her rump a firm squeeze and lay a sloppy affection kiss on her lips.

Velvet looked up at him in confusion as he kissed her and began to grope and caress her body. “I-I thought you just said that you were disgusted by me.” Velvet said in apprehension.

Night Light held her head up with his hoof as the other continued to sensually explore the mares body. “Velvet, I love you, but as you said, I’ve not been treating my mare properly. What you did was disgusting, and my failure as a stallion, as a husband are the only disgusting things I can think of, but you are anything but.” He said as his hoof snuk towards the mares tail. “Now, I’m going to ask you one more time, do you accept my apology, Velvet?” He said, affectionately kissing her once more.

Velvet couldn’t but smile up at him as an entirely different stream of tears ran down the mares face. “Yes, Night Light, yes. I need my stallion.” She said wrapping her hooves around his chest. “But first I want to get something. You wouldn’t mind me being away for a few seconds, would you sweetie?” She said, looking up at him with a thankful expression.

Night Light smiled back down at her before giving her a firm, but sexy smack on the rump. “Be quick sweetie, don’t keep me waiting.” He said, nuzzling against her shortly after releasing his beautiful mare, allowing her to to run off.