Miles Edgeworth Investigations: Crimes of Equestria

by Tethered Soul

Rating: teen
Tags: Violence, Princess Celestia, Crossover, Death, Alternate Universe, Anthology, Main 6, Princess Luna, Original Character, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Mystery, Other, Ace Attorney, Suicide / Self Harm
Length: 3081

When Miles Edgeworth and Kay Faraday are whisked away from Edgeworth's office, they find themselves involved in a number of strange cases.

Shortly after being restored as a Prosecutor, Miles Edgeworth was relaxing in his office. As he sipped his favorite tea, an old friend in the form of Kay Faraday arrives to chat.

Just then the two are whisked into Equestria, and into the middle of a crime scene.

Will Edgeworth's cool logic and Kay's Little Thief find both the truth and the culprit who brought them there?

Only time will tell.

Rated Teen for descriptions of crime scenes and violent actions. And implications of suicide.

Kay Faraday and Miles Edgeworth belong to Capcom.

MLP characters belong to Hasbro.

Original Characters will be credited as they appear.

Published 2020-03-27 00:20:01 UTC
Last updated 2020-03-27 00:20:01 UTC

The Otherworldly Turnabout: Beginning Part 1

Edgeworth's Office
March 18th, 12:25 PM

Miles sighed softly as he took another sip of tea. As the taste danced around on the prosecutor's mouth he mulled about recent events.

He had helped bring down a smuggling ring, was reunited with an old friend. He even quit being a prosecutor at one point.

But now his path was clear, he was a man of truth. Guilty, not guilty. The verdict didn't matter. Only the truth did.

Eventually he found his tea had run out, and he set the cup on his pristine, ornate desk.

Standing and stretching he glanced around his office. Mementos of the past laid on a shelf in front of the window. Most were obscured by flowers from a woman that made Miles shudder with just a single thought.

Miles snapped out of his stupor and adjusted his brilliant white cravat. He straightened his black vest and dusted off his red suit pants and coat. He didn't have plans today, but he was expecting a local detective to stop by. As usual, said Detective took his time with it.

Just then a knock sounded on his door. Clearing his throat a little Miles spoke.

"You may come in."

The door swung open to reveal not the detective he was expecting, but a young woman. Her long black hair done up in a pink braid. A golden key was stuck through horizontally. Her green eyes sparkled with excitement. She wore a pink shirt sleeved shirt with white cuffs, and a short blue skirt. Her neck was covered by a blue scarf with a single golden Raven pinned on ot. As she strode in, she adjusted her brown leather gloves.

This woman is Kay Faraday. Miles thought to himself. I met her a long time ago. She is the heir to the title of Yatagarasu, the so-called Great Thief. Despite that, she actually hasn't stolen anything yet. Instead, she's helped me find the truth on a number of occasions.

"So what brings you to my office?" Miles asked carefully.

"I'm delivering a message from Gummy. He's been tied down at the precinct. Something about reviewing an unsolved case." Kay explained, before raising her fist to the air. "So once again, the Great Thief has stolen the truth."

"Stolen indeed." Miles smirked. "Well, I suppose I'll be waiting longer then. Would you care to share a cup of tea with me? I was planning to brew myself another pot."

"That would be great Edgeworth! A Great Thief needs to keep herself hydrated after all!"

Miles turned and picked up his teacup, ready to carry it to it's tray. However, as the teacup left the desk, he found himself going rigid. It was almost as if his body had stopped responding all at once. He watched helplessly as the teacup fell from his hand and hit the ground.

By some stroke of luck the cup didn't break, but the little bit of tea inside had hit the floor. Surely, his office would be stained now.

"Edgeworth?" Kay asked, her voice sounding frightened. "Are you-" her voice suddenly cut as she too went rigid.

Edgeworth watched in horror and surprise as his hands started to fade away. The rest of him quickly following.

The last thing he saw was the stained floor of his office before his whole world turned black.

???
??? - ???

Edgeworth groaned softly as he woke. The first things he noted were the temperature and the floor.

Both were freezing.

After making sure he had control of his body, Edgeworth sat up. Not far from him laid Kay. Thinking it best to understand his situation, Edgeworth stood and looked around the room.

The ceiling was high, the doors on his left were ornate. A couple of couches and a coffee table sat in the middle of the room.
And a grand window looked outside on his right.

However the strangest part was that everything was made out of the same material. Edgeworth strode over to the wall and touched it. He was shocked to find that not only did it look like crystal. It appeared that it was indeed a crystal room.

While near the door, Miles decided to try the doorknob. Unfortunately they were locked in.

Then he turned back towards Kay, who was now sitting up.

"Whoa. This place looks fancy. I bet there's loads of treasure here." Kay giggled to herself.

"Treasure hunting will have to wait." Edgeworth sighed. "We're locked in." And I'd have to bring you in if you tried to "treasure hunt".

"Aw man. I guess that means we'll have to break out. Just like at that theme park!" Kay nodded before walking over towards the window.

Before Miles could respond, he finally noticed a lump of something sitting over near the corner. As he approached it he noticed that it was a cloth draped over something. He also noted that as he approached, the air held a familiar scent.

"Kay. I think we have a bigger problem than escaping." Miles spoke, ushering the girl over. He pulled the cloth aside to reveal a dead pony. A bloodstained crystal dropped to the floor as he peeled the cloth back.

"I don't understand." Kay muttered. "What's a dead pony doing in a place like this?"

"I have no idea." Edgeworth mumbled as he pulled out his organizer and wrote down some notes. "But this seems like some sort of sick joke."

Just then the door let out a click, and a voice could be heard screaming.

"HELP! MURDERER!"

To be continued. . . .

Author's Note

So. A few notes before I do the usual stuff that goes with this kind of story. Unlike an Ace Attorney fic where cross examinations happen in court, these will be happening on the crime scene. Just like in Miles Edgeworth Investigations, on which this is based. Testimonies will be written in dark green. Light green is a piece of logic that is added.

At certain points Edgeworth will stop and either do a cross examination or combine some logic. All information (logic/evidence/profiles) will be found here in the author's notes.

Without further ado, the Court Record! Or, as it'll be called for this book: The Organizer!

Organizer:

Profiles:
Kay Faraday: Age 17. The self purported "Great Thief" and an old friend.
Pony: A dead pony. Not sure what relevance it has to anything.

Evidence:
Crystal: A bloodstained crystal. Most likely the weapon used on the pony.

Logic:
Transported: We were transported here. Unsure of the method or motive.

Otherworldly Turnabout: Beginning Part 2

???
March 18th 2:00 PM

Edgeworth wasn't sure what was worse. The fact that he was being accused of murdering an animal. Or that the one accusing him defied all logic.

The one who screamed was a pony. A purple pony with wings and a horn. A darker purple mane with pink highlights.

"Well?" The pony growled angrily. "What do you murderers have to say for yourselves?"

"Mr. Edgeworth." Kay spoke. "I know I have crazy flights of fancy sometimes. But I think that pony just talked."

"So it seems." Edgeworth muttered, before bowing to the pony. "My name is Miles Edgeworth. I am a prosecutor. Not a murderer."

Kay followed Edgeworth's lead and introduced herself as well. "And I'm Kay Faraday! I'm the- Edgeworth's assistant."

The pony stared in confusion for a moment before introducing herself. "My name is Twilight Sparkle. . . .and that pony there was one of the politicians that were visiting here." She gestured to the body.

Miles studied Twilight before a clever smirk crossed his features. "I suppose you won't drop the notion of us being involved so easily."

"Nope. You were in this locked room for who knows how long. And you were found crouched over the body. When Celestia gets here with the Detectives, you'll be found guilty and banished." Twilight explained.

"Then how about a deal?" Miles proposed. "Allow me to investigate this room, and show you why we couldn't be the murderers. Perhaps then we can have a more civil discussion?"

Twilight mulled it over. "I'll have to watch you closely to make sure you don't try to destroy any evidence."

"Of course." Miles agreed. "I expected no less."

Twilight closed her eyes and took a deep breath. "Then go ahead. Investigate. But I assure you my logic is solid!"

"We'll see." Edgeworth tapped the side of his nose before facing the room. The first thing I need to do is gather information from the crime scene. My life, and Kay's, rides on this.

Investigation
Start

The first thing Edgeworth did was scan the room for anything else that stood out. Unfortunately, it was spotless.

"For the scene of the murder, the room is unusually tidy" Edgeworth noted.

"Perhaps the victim was caught unawares?" Kay guessed.

"Perhaps. Or perhaps not." Edgeworth replied, before his eyes landed on the window. How he missed it before he didn't know. But the window was wide open.

Edgeworth examined the door that Twilight had entered from. "Besides the obvious, there's nothing new here." He muttered to himself. "The room was locked when we woke."

Twilight was following Edgeworth's progress around the room, but was surprised when he approached her.

"Excuse me, but I have a few questions about. . .well everything really." Edgeworth admitted.

"I suppose I can answer a few." Twilight stated. "But don't stray too far off topic."

"Of course." Edgeworth agreed. "So first: Where are we?"

"You are in a meeting room in the Crystal Palace of the Crystal Empire." Twilight explained. "Judging by your lack of knowledge, you must be from a different world."

"An astute observation." Edgeworth spoke, a little sarcastically.

"But just because you're from somewhere else doesn't mean you get off the hook that easy!" Twilight retorted.

"I figured not." Edgeworth sighed. "Next question: What kind of pony are you?"

Twilight paused for a moment before pulling a children's book out of thin air in a flash of purple light. "Please. Read this. . .encyclopedia. It details all forms of ponies, and then some."

"It's. . .a children's book." Kay pointed out.

"Well I'm sorry! This is very basic stuff here!" Twilight huffed.

"And I'm glad to have any information." Miles assured Twilight. Because I'm going to need all this information and then some to escape this strange dream.

Edgeworth gently opened the book and looked inside. Each page detailed the different races of ponies, and their attributes.

Page one had an illustration of a normal looking pony pulling a plow. It explained that this was an Earth Pony, which had the ability to farm and manipulate rocks in some cases.

Page two showed a pair of winged horses flying through the sky. One carried a storm cloud. These are the Pegasi, who can fly and manipulate the weather.

Page three was a pony levitating objects with magic from it's horn. It was a unicorn. Unicorns all have different levels of magic, but levitation is the most basic spell.

The fourth page showed a pony more closer to Twilight. Both wings and a horn. It was labeled "Alicorn". Alicorns have the ability of all three pony races, but only four known alicorns currently exist.

"Wow. Who knew ponies were capable of being so awesome?!" Kay gasped as she read over Mile's shoulder. "I could use a pegasus to help in some of my heists. Heck, I could be a true Yatagarasu if I had wings of my own!"

"And then I'd have to make Gumshoe haul you in." Edgeworth pointed out.

"Well you'd have trouble if I was a pegasus. I'd be able to outrun, or out fly, Gummy." Kay retorted.

Edgeworth jotted down the book in his organizer. "Either way, this book is a great help."

After putting the book away Edgeworth moved over to the crime scene. Besides the cloth, everything was still untouched.

"This crystal is definitely covered in the same blood as the cloth. It's no long stretch to say that it is the murder weapon." Miles noted aloud. "Furthermore, it seems this cloth was used to absorb some of the blood."

Edgeworth scanned the pony. It was white furred with a greying blue mane..He had only one puncture wound on the back of his neck. Most of the blood there was dry at this point. More interesting was the fact that the ground underneath the victim was spotless.

"Well, Mr. Edgeworth." Twilight broke the silence. "It seems you're nearing the end of your investigation."

"So it seems." Edgeworth returned to Twilight. "I assume you've prepared your logic?"

"I have." Twilight smirked. "I imagine you wish to. . .what was it. . .examine me?"

Edgeworth paused for a moment before correcting her. "You mean a cross-examination?"

"Yes. That." Twilight answered quickly. "Now, hear my sound reasoning Miles."

ARGUMENT

Twilight's LogicA

"The logic here is simple."
"This room was locked the entire day. No one could get in or out without permission."
"When the victim came here, it was to presumably take a break."
"However, shortly after that, you two arrived here, and one of you struck him from behind, out of fear."
"That's when I came in, to see you hiding the body."

END

"So you believe our motive is fear?" Edgeworth asked.

"Correct." Twilight replied. "You are strangers in a strange world. The victim most likely startled you."

"I. . .suppose that is one explanation of events." Edgeworth shook his head. "But I do not think it is the most likely explanation."

"Then show me Edgeworth. Show me what is likely." Twilight rebutted.

Edgeworth bowed in response. "Of course."

REBUTTAL

"This room was locked the entire day. No one could get in or out without permission."

"Permission?" Edgeworth questioned. "From who would one get permission?"

"Princess Cadence, ruler of the Crystal Empire. Or the captain of her guard. Only they had the ability to grant permission." Twilight explained.

"And no one else could freely enter this room besides those two?" Edgeworth pressed.

"Just them and the cleaning crew. But the cleaning crew only works in the early mornings." Twilight explained. "So you can't just pin this on the maid."

"Of course." Edgeworth smirked. "Now, if you would continue your testimony.

"When the victim came here, it was to presumably take a break."

"He came here to take a break? And the Captain of the Guard let him?" Edgeworth pressed.

"Of course. This room wasn't scheduled for use today, and all the politicians here were to be treated as our honored guests." Twilight countered. "If it bothers you so much, just ask the guard who let him in."

"In time, I plan to. But for now, I wish to hear the rest of your logic." Edgeworth requested.

"However, shortly after that, you two arrived here, and one of you struck him from behind, out of fear."

"So, you believe that our motive was fear?" Edgeworth pressed.

"Correct. You are new here. You'd have no other motive." Twilight confirmed.

"You would be correct that we had no motive." Edgeworth agreed. "However, if we were afraid, how do you explain our demeanor now?"

"Perhaps you two calmed down and got a grasp on your situation." Twilight argued.

"I don't think that's likely." Edgeworth disagreed. "But I digress. Arguing motive changes nothing. Please, let me hear the last of your logic."

"That's when I came in, to see you hiding the body."

"So, if I have your logic correctly. . . We were in the middle of hiding the body when you got here?" Edgeworth pressed. "Meaning the murder just happened?"

"Clearly." Twilight confirmed. "You must not have had time to move the body."

So Twilight thinks that this murder just happened. Do I agree with this? Edgeworth thought to himself.

"I'm afraid this is where your logic falls flat." Edgeworth shook his head. "But if you had observed the crime scene as I had, you'd notice the blood on both the victim and cloth is dry. Meaning that this murder couldn't be recent."

"So the time of death changed." Twilight huffed. "Does that change anything?"

"Not at first." Edgeworth admitted. "Not until we begin asking some questions. First: when did the victim die? Secondly, where is the rest of the blood from his wound? As you can see, the floor is spotless."

"So you cleaned it up with the cloth. Case closed." Twilight smirked.

"The cloth appears to have some blood yes. But there would still be off-colored streaks on the floor. And the cloth itself should have more blood on it." Edgeworth countered.

"Then. . . What is the answer here?" Twilight sighed in defeat.

"The answer, is that there was indeed, a third party." Edgeworth finished his argument.

"So now what?" Kay asked the now quiet room. "Do we just stand around and wait for the police?"

"That would be for the best." Twilight agreed. "Perhaps they'll give us some insight we don't have."

Edgeworth nodded. "In the meantime, I think I have enough logic to answer some of my pressing questions. So, a moment of silence please."

Edgeworth closed his eyes as he began to compile all that he learned of this crime.

"What's he doing?" Twilight asked.

Kay grinned, "just wait, he's gonna blow your mind."

To be continued. . .

Author's Note

I apologize for the simplicity of this first case. I needed it more simple in order to make sure I had the more mechanical parts (rebuttal, argument and logic) down.

Organizer:

Profiles:
Kay Faraday: Age 17. The self proclaimed heir to the title of Yatagarasu.
Twilight Sparkle: Age ??. The pony who discovered us on the scene of the crime.
Pony(Victim): A politician who was visiting for some meeting. He is a unicorn.

Evidence:
A Guide to Ponies Vol 2 Alicorn Edition: A children's book that depicts the main races of ponies.
Crystal: A bloody crystal. Most likely the murder weapon.
Cloth: Found over the victim. Stained with his blood.
Crime Scene notes: Victim appears to have been hit once with the sharp end of the Crystal. The ground is spotless.

Logic:
Transported: we were transported here. But how and by who?
Tidy room: The crime scene shows no signs of struggle.
Open window: The window is open. But why?
Spotless Floor: The floor is oddly devoid of blood for a crime scene.