A New Year's kiss

by TheBronyKnight

Rating: mature
Tags: Sex, Hoity Toity, Comedy, Rarity, Equestria Girls, Porn
Length: 2668

A party is being held for New Year's and Rarity wants to land the boy of her highschool dreams. Can the plan work?

Rarity planned to use Pinkie Pie's party as a way to get with her high school crush, Hoity Toity. When stuff gets heavy in the bedroom, a heavy choice must be made.

Blowjob and choice hijinks

https://www.fimfiction.net/group/214700/dirty-little-secrets-dirty-little-contest

Published 2020-03-31 03:40:01 UTC
Last updated 2020-03-31 03:40:01 UTC

The dance before midnight

“So this is Pinkie’s version of a small get together huh?” Rarity said as she sipped her glass of Merlot as she looked at Hoity Toity in the flashy lights of the cramped living room. “Yeah it would appear so Rarity. I mean how much smaller can you get from inviting all of Canterlot high, Crystal Prep, and some unknown rock band that is most likely on SoundCloud or Jamendo?” Hoity said as he sips his orange soda as the pair examines the band playing at the epicenter of the rave of teenagers and miscellaneous that was given free admission. The band known as “God’s feathers” is playing a thumping dance sound using instruments and EDM tracks layered on each other.

“The music can be better, but honestly I can’t stand this crowd as of late” Rarity said as she looked at Hoity with a shaking glance. “But the needs of the many out way the needs of the minimum I suppose”

“Nicely put Rarity. I see that your funny sass filter has not needed to be changed” Hoity said as he giggled at the small wit. Rarity looked at the boy and blushed a bit as she tried to hide herself in her hair. Hoity is her crush and Rarity have the hots for him badly. The emotions weren't always this strong and bold in her mind. However ever since Pinkie got her to spill the beans in Truth and Dare last month, the group came up with a plan to hopefully help Rarity score the boy. The first part is to get him to the party and now Rarity is engaging in small talk while she waits for part 2 of the “hook-up, cook-up” as Dash puts it. Hoity however doesn’t need much stalling because this seems to be the place to be.

“I must admit that I am glad to be out of my house. My parents are having my aunt over and-can I be bold with you for a hot second?” Hoity asked while he fist his available hand in his pocket; awaiting Rarity’s answer.

“Of course you may. I am good when it comes to secrets” Rarity said ready to hear him let out his inner feelings.

“I got family over that I personally disagree with so… This is the best escape I have at the moment. I am genuinely glad I get to spend the New year with you Rarity.” Hoity said as he flashed a smile. “I normally spend it with my parents but you and I go way back. You are family to me” Hoity said as he sipped his soda.

Rarity was awestruck at the revelation. “Why, Hoity, thank you for coming out to me. Don’t fret even a little. New years are about new beginnings and this may be weird for you but I promise it can be thrilling.” Rarity choked out her nervousness crept into her speech. I hope Hoity doesn’t notice she thought.

“Nicely put Rarity.” Hoity paused to take a drink. “And there is something I wish to tell you as well.” Hoity took off his sunglasses as his lime-green eyes stared into Rarity’s blue ones. Rarity is a bit shocked that his eyes are peering into her very soul; searching for a mystery that needs to be solved. Her intrigue is piqued by this action. So bold. So masculine!
“Rarity I-” A strong voice began to overpower Hoity as an announcement boomed through the living room’s stereo systems.

“Everyone! The moment you all have been waiting for! Time. For. The. Slow. DANCE!!!” Pinkie’s distinctive voice said through the speakers. “And remember fellas: You do the hump, you make her plump. Bowl of condoms in the bathroom.” Pinkie said in a baritone voice to reinforce the message all responsible teenagers should follow like a verse from a holy scripture. As soon as that message came out, a smooth bass line can be heard throughout the space and teens that don’t normally pair up with each other are making odd ball pairs. You got Bulk Biceps and Sour Sweet dancing slow, Point Dexter and Derpy, Red Hot and Chili Pepper from the science club and.. Fluttershy and janitor Discord?!?!

To think I saw all the odd balls dancing Rarity thought as a hand was reached out to her side.

“Pouvons-nous valser?” Hoity said in french with a strand of hair blocking out half of his left eye.

“Sûre” Rarity stretched her hand and took hold of his. Nervousness eating at her vocabulary again.

The dance was long, hot, and sexually torturous. The feeling of his front on her hips, back, and crotch. The closeness with the flickering lights in the background. The heat of hormonal teens being cramped in one space has increased thrice-fold. A girl moaning loud enough for people in Rarity-Hoity's corner can hear only adding to the thick tension this slow dance is adding. Rarity and Hoity are now dancing to the soft and slow rhythm of the bass and drum groove. The instrumental slowly began to pick up in speed as the movement increased with the tempo change. Grinding is now the only way to keep up and so she grind her crotch on his front a bit.
I hope it isn’t too slutty. Rarity thought in worry. Hoity however seemed to like it as he returned the grind in vigor.

“Alright everyone. I am the lead singer of the Blank Checks and now is where the singing begins” The vocalist says as he cleared his throat and began to sing.

Harmony is the circle
For which humans hold themselves together
These the words of a girl
That I loved in youthful summer
Kindness will be kindness
And happiness in true
With generous intelligence
Two words combined speaks volumes
The singer sang as the crowd became quiet in acknowledgment.

My head lay in the cuff of Hoity’s neck; smelling the cologne mixed with the sweat and natural musk as they swayed in unison. This was the perfect moment to seal the deal with her crush. As if the universe was going to add more to this potential romance, Rarity sees Fluttershy kiss janitor Discord while he grabs her buttocks out of the corner of her eye. I suppose love has no biases. Nicely done Fluttershy Rarity smiles as her friend gives her the courage to take the risk. Rarity looked up at Hoity and looked at his lips. As his eyes slowly opened, Rarity dove her head and stole a quick kiss from the unsuspecting boy.

Rarity closed her eyes as the leap of faith has been initiated. Only now can his actions give her the response she wants. After a few short seconds, Rarity feels Hoity kiss her back with his smooth, hydrated lips. The sensation of his lips against hers gave strong womanly feelings throughout Rarity’s mortal core; tingling in her spine as if she was going to go paralyzed or the curling of her toes as her crotch grew even hotter by the second. The kiss was truly magical. As the duo partied their lips and looked at each other, only one phrase could be uttered as they smiled at each other.

“Magnifique” They both said as they danced while kissing again.

Yes! Part one is done. Now I just gotta lure him to the bedroom upstairs. Rarity detached her lips from the pose boy. “I know the girl that lives here and she owes me a favor. Wanna go to the bedroom and spend the rest of the eve together?” Rarity flashed her eye lashes in hopes that the boy would bite the bait. If not her eyes, then Rarity placed his hand on her right hip as she swayed in the same direction, further pronouncing her bodily curve, and to increase his eagerness for the main event.

Hoity Toity visibly swallowed a wad of spit and croaked out a quick “Sure” as a response. Rarity wasted no time and took his hand as they ran through the crowded space giggling. Bumping into Discord as they passed him and Fluttershy.

“Hey! Watch the manners buddy!” Discord said as he looked angrily at the running couple.
“Oh calm down Dissy. They are just celebrating New Years” Fluttershy said. “In fact, I think we should have our own chaotic celebration for the coming year. Wouldn’t you say~” Fluttershy whispered in an uncharacteristic raunchy voice as her hand gripped Discord’s crotch.

“Woah.. thank goodness I am only 6 years older than her and she is 18 huh readers” Discord whispers to himself

Rarity and Hoity Toity are kissing fools as they reach the door to Pinkie’s bedroom. Hands groping and feeling all around each other’s developing bodies. Rarity was quick to find that Hoity is buff. His chest is thick with muscle and the feeling of his nipples through his button shirt was only making her more aroused. Rarity has always been a fan of male nipples and how they add a weird definition to masculinity to have femininity. Whenever dress shirts are being made in her shop, Rarity would always add extra attention to the main nipples and how she can make the shirts to pronounce those little beauties. Rarity managed to push Hoity back enough for him to fall on the bed. Rarity quickly got on top of him and unbuttoned his shirt to see his chest in full detail. As the shirt opens and the night moon illuminates his grayish skin, Rarity looks in fascinated lust as this Adonis of a teen has a chest of a varsity athlete. Not wanting to waste time, she had to get a taste. A lick on his nipple happened and then down to his abs. Making it a job to lightly nibble on each abs as Rarity continues going down. Tracing the man with her tongue and saliva as she reached his pants, looking up at Hoity for confirmation before continuing her trek downward. Hoity gave a slight nod and Rarity began to open his pants slowly before her prize was slowly unveiled.

I know in movies, the first date should never have sex in it. But to hell with tropes, it's the 21 century as Rainbow Dash puts it. Time to see what this man has underneath the layers Rarity affirmed her resolve to follow through with the lusting ritual. As she unbuckles his belt and it flops to the floor, a thick meaty dick springs from the fabric like a zombie from the grave. Standing tall with thick musk hitting Rarity’s nostrils as she looked hungrily at the thick treat. Ready to indulge, Rarity gave the base of the dick a strong lick.

“Ahuyk” Hoity Toity hacked out as he was surprised by the new sensation. “Rarity be truly careful. This is my first time receiving ahh~ fellatio” Hoity said as he gave out a deep sigh.

Rarity smiled as she continued to consume more of the teen. Making it her personal pleasure to enjoy all the gasps and groans she can get out of Hoity just to tease him. After about 3 minutes of this game of bondage, Rarity decided that the main event for tonight must happen and so she slid up to where the head of his dick was and opened her mouth as she went down upon him.

Hoity let out a strong moan of relief as her cock was being sucked. Going so far as putting his smooth, lotioned hands on the young fashionista’s head as she continued her task. Rarity was having a bit of trouble taking all of his penis into her hungry maw as she went down on him. The fullness of his penis in her mouth was superior to all of her dildo practice at home when she wanted to test her gag reflex for when she got a boy she really liked. The biggest in the house was only 6 inches while Hoity was doubled that. Rarity tried to push more of himself into her mouth, but a warning cough and gag was all she needed to hear and feel as the size was merely too much; a beautiful moment aside, all she can do is suck on half of his penis while she teases the balls with her manicured hands.

Up and down the mouth goes, don’t go too deep or upchuck flows Rarity recounted as she remembered her first time gagging up. The feeling of the bulbs of Hoity’s head gave Rarity weird bumpy feelings against her tongue. She read that the bulbs have multiple nerve endings and they are essentially the bulbs to her Clitoris. Ready to experiment, Rarity circled her tongue around the bulbs on his head as she retracted her mouth a bit. Hoity moans and jerks his crotch up a bit at the sensation. Rarity was delighted for the results and continued to lick each section of bulbs. The first was on the bottom naturally. She feels the bulbs and the crease of flappy skin on the front of Hoity’s erection. The licking must have gotten to the boy because he is grunting like he has a stubbed toe, the jerkiness of his hips, and the feeling of his hands on her head. The next section was when Rarity began to swirl her tongue around the organ, lapping up musk and pre-cum on her tongue. Rarity felt a bit dirty but this was the kind of dirty she would never mind. The natural filthiness of being on her knees was more a thrill than a repulsion. The last place was the back of the penis (Or front from a boy’s perspective) must be the most sensitive of the penis. Probably a developed rub spot from masturbating. Out of the two main ones, that spot was hard for the tongue to reach-especially with the buffet Rarity has in her mouth! Reaching that spot is only possible when the retraction happens and when she goes back down, the tongue needs to move to the bottom of the penis: Rarity’s strategy.

5 total minutes of this blowjob later and Rarity can feel a rush of pre-cum and multiple levels of groans from Hoity. His hips becoming more reckless as well as he’s now pushy hands.

This is it! The moment is almost here, he is gonna cum! Rarity thought as she picked up the pace. What am I gonna do? What can I do? Should I let him out in my mouth? Should I get of-

“Rarity!!” Hoity screamed as he thrusted his hips into Rarity’s face.

All Rarity can feel in that moment was her cock rubbing her tonsils and a strong surge of cum blasting into her unexpected throat. Milky white streaks of semen came out of her nostrils as the rest filled up her mouth halfway. After dying down from his orgasmic ejaculation, Rarity removed herself off of his dick with Hoity’s white gold still in her mouth

Which posed a moral question

What should I do now?! Rarity mentally panicked as she weighed her options. Hoity’s eyes on her face.

I am in quite the rut right now! I only have 3 options. If I spit, then I would appear as a prissy bitch. If I swallow, then I would be a submissive bitch, if I show him, then I would be a slutty bitch! So this is why it's called the oral dilemma!

Rarity began to sweat as the options became harder to choose. Hoity is looking right at her and she can only do one of the three. What will the end results be if she did one of the three? Time continues to click as the options still weighed in her mind. Only 2 minutes left to midnight as the choice still remained in the air.

Author's Note

If there are any grammatical, vocabulary, or narrative errors in the story. Please feel free to leave a comment.

Thank you and Head bump!