The First Time

After Twilight and Starlight finished their story, they noticed that a decidedly sexual atmosphere had invaded the room. The carpets seemed to moisten under the heavy weight of the steam. Fluttershy and Rarity were trying very hard not to openly masturbate, but Pinkie and Applejack had given in to the urge. They moaned away as they rubbed at their vaginas, not caring who saw nor what kind of judgment was pronounced upon them. In fact, the complete lack of cover created even more pleasure.

“Whoa, looks like AJ and Pinkie are feelin’ it,” Dash chuckled.

“Yes! Yes, fuck me! Oh, yeah!” Applejack moaned, “oh…I need this! Ugh! Ugh! Oh, it feels amazin’!”

Twilight and Starlight smirked at each other and then began kissing. Their tongues wrapped around each other as they joined in the spontaneous orgy. Twilight reached her hoof around to her former student’s pussy and began to gently tease at it. She drew circles around the puffy lips, and then flicked her hoof nail across the clit. She loved the urgent groans from her friend, and broke their kiss in order to begin biting her. It was commonplace for ponies to mate with their teeth as well as everything else. She drew a bit of blood from her bite, but knew enough to where she didn’t penetrate deeply.

“Oh…Twi…” Starlight groaned, “…that bite was amazing…and your hooves…oh…”

“I’m glad you like it,” Twilight cooed, “but I think there’s somepony here who needs some attention.”

Twilight let go of Starlight and the two slowly made their way over to a very confused Rainbow Dash. The Pegasus looked completely lost, as if she had been dropped into The Everfree Forest with a compass and a sandwich and ordered to find her way home. Twilight didn’t say anything, but wrapped her hooves around Dash from behind. Starlight attacked from the front, and their two-pronged assault worked. Dash started to sigh as content played with her mind.

“So, Dash, allow me to turn the question on you,” Twilight whispered, “have you ever been fucked?”

“No,” Dash admitted, “I haven’t. But I’ve longed for a stallion or mare to take me. I just…wanted to hear what it was like.”

Twilight smiled and cutely nibbled on the top of Dash’s ear, earning some soft moans from her friend. “Well, then, let Starlight and I introduce you to this brave new world.”

With that, Twilight massaged Dash’s shoulders while Starlight bent downward and began sucking on her beautifully blue areolas. Dash’s groans were magnificent, and Twilight thought that she had excellent technique for a beginner. She continued her sensual massage, going lower and lower until she finally arrived at Dash’s rump and the beautiful crevice that separated her hind legs. She knew what hid in the cave, and she was eager to taste it. So, she dove right in.

Dash squeaked in excitement, eliciting giggles from her two partners. They had never heard her make that particular noise before, and they became excited at the prospect of sleeping with her. Starlight moved lower and sucked away on Dash’s clit, garnering more intense moans from above. Twilight took the opportunity to float a small piece of a nearby curtain over and wrap it over Dash’s eyes.

“You don’t mind, do you, Dashie?”

“No,” Dash responded in a daze, “I don’t wanna know which of you fucks me first. Frankly, I don’t care. Just fuck me!”

Twilight smirked again and zapped herself, recreating the same faux stallionhood that she’d used on Starlight. Her former pupil became very excited by this, and quietly began to suck on both it and Dash. Twilight set it across Dash’s stomach, earning a shudder from the blinded Pegasus, and a small smile from Starlight. This way, the light purple pony could have fun with both of them at once. She suckled and licked at Dash’s privates, loving every single vocalization that came with it. She brought Dash to the brink of climax, and then tortured her by moving away. Dash groaned and squirmed on her back, wanting desperately to experience an orgasm. True, she’d had them before while masturbating, but she’d never had one given to her.

Suddenly, Twilight turned and shoved her dick deep into Dash’s throat. Dash chuckled, ecstatic at knowing that she was sucking on one of her friends, but not knowing which one. She bobbed up and down on the shaft, enjoying its taste. Drops of precum emerged from the tip, using her tongue as their own personal playground. She thought of herself as being rather proficient in this sexual regard, so she tried an advanced maneuver. She’d seen it in the multiple secret pornographic video recordings she hid away from the general public. She slammed her head all the way down to whoever’s hilt, and the pony did a great job of remaining quiet.

But on the outside of the blindfold, Twilight was having a very difficult time not moaning. She couldn’t let Dash figure out that it was her who she was playing with. The feel of Rainbow’s smooth tongue and amazing, wet mouth nearly blew her cover. It didn’t help that Starlight came up behind her and began rubbing her throbbing vagina behind her fake balls.

“Do you have to do that, Starlight?” She whispered.

Star chuckled. “Come on, Twilight, you know you like having your pussy rubbed.”

“Yeah, when we’re having sex alone! In case you hadn’t noticed, Dash doesn’t want to know which pony she’s having fun with.”

Starlight rolled her eyes and left Twilight’s nether regions alone. She got down and kissed Dash’s cheek, before rolling her tongue along to her ear and sticking it inside. Dash became mad with excitement and sucked Twilight even harder. The Princess kept all of her moans down, even though it wasn’t easy at all. She had Dash sucking her, Starlight giving oral to her ear, and her friends were moaning and grunting around them as the wild orgy continued.

Ugh…this is your fault, Dash! She cried internally, you and your Truth or Dare game! Oh, sweet Celestia, if you suck me any harder, I’ll CUM!

At that moment, Dash unleashed her most ferocious penile attack of all, driving Twilight deep into her gullet. The Princess couldn’t hold herself in any longer, and with a shriek of pleasure, released her load. A sense of absolute satisfaction swept over her as she saw Dash swallow every last bit of her cum. She pulled her penis out, turned it back into a vagina, and ripped the blindfold off of Rainbow Dash.

“Oh, fuck the blindfold!” She thundered, “Starlight, give yourself a cock and rip her apart! I’ll take care of her rump hole.”

Dash’s smile went from ear to ear as the Princess and her friend took complete control over her. She became their ragdoll, and she felt herself being forced into a sitting position. Once there, Twilight cast a spell on her that forced her forelegs up over her head. A small rope then floated over and tied them there. Twilight then focused on her hind legs, spreading them and revealing Dash’s jewel to the world. Twilight breathed heavily as she began kissing Dash, reveling in the flavor of her own cum that hit her tongue.

Then, Starlight came over and Twilight graciously sucked on her new cock. It became as stiff as a board, and Twilight moved around behind Dash so Starlight could use it properly. The sudden hermaphrodite plunged into Rainbow, leaving behind a trail of blood and screams. She fucked her without mercy, loving every last shriek and beg that Dash made. The Pegasus squealed in delight as Starlight pounded away at her crotch, continuously asking for more and more.

“Mm…you’re greedy for this cock, aren’t you, you little slut?”

“Yes!” Dash cried, “yes, I’m a greedy bitch! Fuck me, Star! Fuck me, baby!”

“If you think that was good, you ain’t seen nothin’ yet!” Twilight howled.

She proceeded to begin her own pounding session with Dash’s delicate asshole. The Pegasus screamed to the heavens as her friends made love to her, feeling the most elated she had ever felt. Nothing topped this, not even her first day as a full-fledged Wonderbolt. She cried and squealed and shrieked, and her friends wouldn’t let up. They called her names, and told her that she was a worthless little foal. Still, she cried and screamed. In contrast to her normal independence, when it came to sex, she loved being led around by a dog collar.

“OH! OH! OH! FUCK ME! FUCK ME!” She squealed.

By this point, the other ponies had stopped banging each other and now looked towards the crying, screaming Pegasus. They noticed that tears of joy were rolling down her cheeks with each new powerful thrust that her two partners made. She was trapped in the middle of passion and rage, and she wanted to become even further entangled in the vines. Her eyes rolled back in her head as she felt her climax approach.

“OH! OH! OH! I’M GONNA CUM!”

“Yeah, you’re gonna cum!” Starlight mocked, “I know you’re gonna cum! You’re such a good slut! You’re our little whore!”

“YES, I’M YOUR WHORE! I’M YOUR FILLY! FUCK ME! FUCK ME! OH! YES! YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEES!”

Rainbow Dash finally reached that elusive summit and shot her liquid all over Starlight’s crotch. For her part, Starlight rammed herself in even faster than before until she acquired her own happy release. Her scream was just as loud as Dash, and the Pegasus felt warm liquid envelop her very womb. While she knew she could never get pregnant by it, it was still a beautiful moment. The two panted as Twilight grabbed Dash’s waist and began slamming her naked crotch against the rainbow maned pony’s soft, gentle anus. She went harder and harder, earning more moans from Dash. Suddenly, the two cried out and came together, falling into each other as the gorgeous event passed them by. It was only a few seconds, but to Rainbow Dash, it felt like a wondrous eternity.

“That was amazing, darlings!” Rarity exclaimed, “good grief, I didn’t know you could mate like that, Twilight!”

“Yeah, well…you should come over some night.”

Everypony laughed at this and snuggled close to each other. Their former fatigue had been completely forgotten in the light of this grand sexual adventure, yet it suddenly returned in the afterglow. They had never had an orgy before, but they each silently agreed to do it again sometime. It had been an absolutely magnificent evening, and everyone fell asleep satisfied. But none were more so than Rainbow Dash, who curled up in Twilight and Starlight’s embrace and slumbered more peacefully than she ever thought possible. She could be completely happy now. She had her own “first time” story to tell.