Hooked

The club, one that Applejack had gone to many times as a single mare, flashed yellow bright letters that said Forbidden Temptations for all to see during the late hours of the night. One mare knew of Applejack’s trips here, and it was not the yellow pegasus beside her. That fact alone made Applejack’s body even more cold and tense, the gut feeling that she was falling into the fangs of a predator that once it got its hold on her, would never let her go. She leaned even closer to Fluttershy, trying to gain hold of her familiar vanilla scent as much as possible, before Fluttershy presented her ID to the security guard and entered the building. The guard looked at Applejack expectedly, and she did the same before gulping and entering the club.

Fluttershy already hopped onto the barstool, wiggling with a big smile as she waited for the bartender to arrive. She then patted the stool next to her, and after surveying the whole area, determined that it was safe to sit on the stool. A hot pink pegasus with a long purple mane flew over and smiled at the two.

“Wait, haven’t we seen ya working at a bunch of places before?” Applejack’s face scrunched up as she took in the mare’s features from her emerald green eyes to her blank flank-

“I mean, I’ve worked at a couple of places around here,” the bartender rolled her eyes as she placed menus in front of the two mares. “In alternate universes even…”

“Wait, what?” Applejack’s eyes widened.

“Nothing!” the mare smiled wide. “My name is Fuchsia Sky, do you two need time to look at the menus?”

“No need, ah’ll take the Forbidden Apple!” Applejack smiled at her quick decision, but then realized her error as she saw Fluttershy narrowing her eyes at the earth pony. “Ah…ah mean, whatever apple drink ya got, missy.”

“Hmm,” Fluttershy returned her gaze to the menu and placed her hoof on a description on the menu. “I think I’ll try the Jasmine Flower, that sounds quite lovely.”

“Right on it, ladies!” Fuchsia winked before flying off and throwing together the two cocktails. Applejack mentally prayed to every alicorn in existence as Fluttershy slowly returned her eyes to her.

“So, you knew what you wanted really quickly,” Fluttershy commented. “Did you even look at the menu?”

“C’mon now, Flutters. What are you even implying?” Applejack firmly stared into Fluttershy’s eyes, challenging her. And Applejack could wave the truth in front of Fluttershy like a owner waving their toy at a cat, and the pegasus would crumble like a house of cards. Fluttershy’s eyes widened, and Applejack felt a pang in her heart as she wondered if her marefriend would break down into tears. Instead, Fluttershy closed her eyes and took a deep breath before smiling at Applejack.

“Nothing, sweetheart,” Fluttershy placed her hoof on Applejack’s. “It doesn’t matter anyway, watching these strippers isn’t going to change us anyway. Right?”

“Right, I’m not interested in the strippers here,” Applejack puffed out her chest as she surveyed the semi-familiar mares performing in the lesbian strip club. She’d see a body or two that she recalled being underneath her in bed, but nothing that quite made her cold and tense. Fuchsia came back with their drinks, and Applejack didn’t hesitate in taking the drink that she’d had many times before and tasting it. Far better than it had any right to be, Applejack wondered how any cocktail could compare. Why, any cocktail beside it wouldn’t taste right. It was addicting from the moment it touched her lips to the moment it sent warm tingles throughout her body. Applejack drank half the cocktail in one go, smacking her lips with her tongue and thanking the bartender as she brought her and Fluttershy glasses of water to accompany their alcoholic drinks.

“So what we established is both of us can watch the strippers and get lap dances from them, but no more than that,” Applejack explained. “Did I get that right?”

“Yup, no actual scissoring,” Fluttershy nodded. “Just give them a safeword, and it should all be good! That’s what I’ll be doing.”

“Okay,” Applejack took a sip of her water before turning and looking at the strippers. “See any that catch your eye?”

“Hm,” Fluttershy glanced at all the mares, before pointing her hoof at a toned zebra mare with long dreadlocks and deep pink eyes. She was easily twice Applejack’s height, and had many tattoos between her stripes. “I’d like to watch her for a bit~”

Applejack felt her body itch as she watched Fluttershy ogling the stripper so quickly, despite the growing hot feeling she felt at doing the same, when she saw a white mare zip across the stripper and rushing up the stairs to the second floor of the club before using a teleportation spell to disappear from sight. Applejack’s jaw dropped as she could’ve swore that she saw a trio of diamonds on the secret mare’s flank before she disappeared.

“Did ya see that?!” Applejack gasped.

“See what, dear?” Fluttershy frowned as she tried her Jasmine Flower. “Oooh! Such a subtle taste, I love it.”

“Er, nevermind, just thought ah saw somepony we know,” Applejack shrugged. “Say, why don’t ya finish your cocktail and check that stripper out? Ah’m gonna use the restroom, sugarcube.”

“Do you need help finding it?” Fluttershy asked.

“Nah, ah’m sure ah know where ah’m goin,” Applejack felt her hooves as dirty as if they were in mud as she got off the stool and walked up the stairs. She saw the restroom door closing, a dark purple tail disappearing behind it before the door closed. Applejack looked downstairs, seeing Fluttershy finishing her cocktail and skipping over to the zebra stripper with her wings fully out. Applejack felt her face get flushed, and wondered if she had ever made Fluttershy’s wings spring out that quickly. Glaring down at Fluttershy and finding her decision easier, Applejack pushed the door open and walked in…to see the restroom empty.

“Is this…really that bad that ah’m imagining her now?” Applejack felt her body shaking as she shook her head. “Oh for Celestia’s sake, Flutters is the sweetest mare ah’ve known…but….”

Applejack’s ears flattened as her eyes started watering, her heart breaking as she found herself facing her Element in the most twisted and grotesque way possible. She never thought her Element would turn on her, stabbing her insides as she stared at the empty stalls in front of her.

“She isn’t Rarity,” Applejack felt her insides churning and her head spinning as if she was going to throw up, and felt her body seizing up as she heard a deep laugh behind her. Turning around, she was face-to-face with the white unicorn herself. Those sapphire blue eyes that once felt innocent felt like eyes she would drown in and never escape. She should feel nothing but contempt for the unicorn after what she had done, but the excited filly-like rush of adrenaline that moved throughout her body tuned out any such feeling. It was like she had stared into the eyes of her first love all over again, and Rarity’s smirk widened even more as she glanced up and down Applejack’s outfit.

“So I see you’ve chosen the outfit that I’ve lovingly crafted~” Rarity’s sonorous and feminine voice had graced Applejack’s ears, each word dancing on her heart with equal parts euphoria and pain. “Ah could say we agree on one thing, darling. Fluttershy is such a sweet mare, but the allure of how I can work your body and play your heart is something that could never be replicated. Would you agree, darling?”

Applejack felt shivers coursing down throughout her body, her tail flagging up at nothing as she reminded herself with graphic detail the day of their breakup. Gritting her teeth, Applejack willed her tail down as she mustered her best glare at the unicorn.

“The way ya fuckin’ played my heart was disgusting,” Applejack sneered. “Lyin’ to me at every twist and turn, finding out ya played me and told ponies that I was the one who cheated on you. Ah nearly lost all my friends.”

“They all sided with you at the end, didn’t they?” Rarity scoffed, flipping her mane and shrugging. “I’m the one who actually lost them, save for the occasional visit from Pinkie. Celestia bless her heart. Anyways, you think I’m so terrible? There’s the door, darling.”

“G-Gladly,” Applejack stammered, walking out of the restroom with her head held high. Sure, she’d be walking right back into the relationship of half-truths and hidden lies, but she was a good marefriend making the right decision. She’d rush right down to Fluttershy, kiss her and tell her what a terrible idea this all was, and laugh it off over apple pie back at home. She looked over the balcony, and felt her insides dying at the sight beneath her.

Fluttershy was leaning against the pole, her eyes rolled to the back of her head and her tongue lolling out as the zebra stripper twerked her generously sized booty onto Fluttershy’s crotch, only the zebra’s thong separating their pussies from actually scissoring.

“Now sweetness,” the zebra mare purred. “Masozi won’t stop until you use that safeword, or if you admit that zebra mares have the best touch~”

Applejack froze up, watching Fluttershy’s expressions contort in ways she’d never seen before, as if her thoughts were far gone into the sea of pleasure and cheers from the audience. She thought her marefriend would stay that way forever until she saw Fluttershy retrain her focus on the zebra mare dancing up against her.

“Z-Zebra m-mares have the b-best touch,” Fluttershy whimpered.

“I’m sorry, what did you say?” Masozi snickered, pressing a hoof to her ear as she leaned closer.

“I SAID ZEBRA MARES HAVE THE BEST TOUCH!” Fluttershy howled, her eyes rolling to the back of her head as her entire body shuddered. Applejack felt her body become colder than ice, her ears flattening as she watched Fluttershy squirting all over the zebra’s backside. Realization came crashing down as she watched the scene before her, and she felt a wildfire throughout her whole body as she threw her head over the balcony.

“YOU LIAR!” Applejack screamed, everything falling together in her brain. They had both apparently been faking their orgasms for each other, and Applejack saw the evidence on the stripper’s backside herself! She didn’t give a chance to even check if Fluttershy heard her, turning back into the restroom and kicking the door open. Rarity barely even had the time to smirk when Applejack slammed the unicorn against the wall and pressed her lips against Rarity’s lips in a tight lip-lock, their tongues wrestling almost immediately as Applejack felt her needs being fulfilled, her heart being mended by the last mare she expected. She pushed into the kiss with the fire and passion of a colt kissing a filly on prom night, only stopping when Rarity used one of her magic spells to push Applejack away to the side and trot to the door. Using her magic to pull the “Out of Order” sign from next to the sinks, Rarity brought it to the door handle from the outside before closing the door and ensuring it was locked with another magical spell.

“Now, you tell me you don’t love the games I play~” Rarity giggled, standing on the sink counter with her forehooves as she moved her tail to the side, wiggling her tush from side to side as she smirked at Applejack. “Why, as soon as you heard I fucked that stallion, I bet you just wanted to-OH!”

Rarity gasped and threw her head back as Applejack lunged and bit her butt, then licked up her flank as if Rarity’s flank tasted like the finest chocolate. As Applejack inhaled the cinnamon-berry perfume Rarity wore, her eyes rolled to the back of her head as she gave in to Rarity’s taunts. If her and Fluttershy didn’t really love each other after all, then what was the harm in getting a head-start on mending everything with the unicorn she was currently with? Applejack pulled away from Rarity’s flank, focusing her gaze on the lavender purple winking clit that had been away from her for far too long. As she licked her lips, she heard a familiar voice from outside the restroom.

“Applejack? Where did you go? Oh my hoofness, please let me explain myself!” the shaky voice dropped in volume as Fluttershy presumably looked elsewhere for her marefriend. Applejack glared at the door, and Rarity sighed as she glanced down at her ex.

“Are you going to go back to her?” Rarity scoffed. “At least I didn’t pretend to be a good pony, you always knew I was a whore for the drama. But her? She betrayed your Element and her own. What does that say about her?”

“Forget about her,” Applejack growled. “She’s the last pony on my mind right now.”

“Oh my!” Rarity giggled. “That’s what Miss Rarity loves to hear!”

Applejack lunged, pressing her muzzle first against Rarity’s pussy and then reaching her tongue out and licking the unicorn’s clit. Rarity’s moan shook the room, and if she was performing for anyone outside, Applejack couldn’t give a fuck. She’d drop every other mare on the planet just to spend the rest of her life eating out Rarity’s pussy. And she’d spend every day of the rest of her life proving just that. Rarity’s pussy smelled like the most intoxicating flower Applejack could imagine, the mare’s genitals singing to her as she groped Rarity’s cheeks with her hooves and inserted her tongue inside.

“OoooOooh, by Celestia’s tits you are so good at this,” Rarity moaned, another rush coursing throughout Applejack as she felt her ex-lover’s body shuddering beneath her touch. Applejack pulled one hoof back, holding it in mid-air, before sharply smacking Rarity’s cheek with a resounding smack. Rarity howled and Applejack closed her eyes and gulped down the fountain of marecum that tasted like fine wine. The farm pony pressed her face further against Rarity’s pussy and loudly gulped each amount of Rarity’s love-juices provided to her like it was her last meal. As Rarity finished her orgasm, Applejack pulled away and licked her lips before getting onto her hind legs and pressing herself up against Rarity, nibbling the unicorn’s ear and pressing her toned figure up against the smaller unicorn, her soaking wet pussy grinding against Rarity’s cutie mark.

“Hwa…oh great stars~” Rarity huffed between breaths. “A-Applejack, if you had spent much more time servicing me like this instead of bucking a-apples…well, I never would’ve turned to him for pleasure. You know that, don’t you?”

Applejack felt her head and heart ache in unison as she nearly slumped against Rarity, tears forming in her eyes as she pressed her face into Rarity’s mane. She thought of day and night of bucking apples, tending to her family, and making sure Sweet Apple Acres made as much money as possible while Rarity spent many afternoons and evenings waiting on her. “Not tonight, Rarity” were three words uttered too often, and Applejack lifted a hoof to Rarity’s cheek and slowly nodded her head as she stared into Rarity’s eyes.

“Ah…ah know,” Applejack gulped. “But Apple Bloom is nearly an adult now, and Sugar Belle has been helping us a lot more! Ah promise they’ll understand and ah can have more time with you, and maybe we could have foals to help out too someday?”

“Well, that does sound quite lovely,” Rarity smiled for a second before she frowned. “But you’d kind of have to cut off your current relationship first, don’t you think?”

“Oh shucks, ah almost forgot!” Applejack’s eyes widened as she jumped off Rarity and rushed towards the door. “Let me talk to that mare for five minutes, and ah promise ah’ll come back.”

Rarity nodded, her horn lighting up with a blue energy that surrounded Applejack’s entire body. Applejack didn’t have to wonder about the magic’s purpose for long as Rarity spoke.

“This is a timed teleportation spell, it’ll teleport you outside of this bathroom for five minutes before teleporting you back to this spot,” Rarity explained. “Understood?”

“Y-Yes, Mistress,” the word slipped out of Applejack’s mouth without her thinking twice, and she shuddered as she realized what kind of relationship she’d be returning to. “Ah’ll do anything ya ask, my precious diamond~”

“Oh you silly mare,” Rarity giggled before her eyes narrowed and her smirk widened. “I know you will~”

And with that, Applejack was teleported right outside of the bathroom walls and back into the club.