Winner Takes All

by hemoptysis

Rating: mature
Tags: Sex, Twilight Sparkle, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Applejack, Porn, Rainbow Dash
Length: 2442

Twilights' called to referee a fight between Applejack and Rainbow Dash. Everypony wins!

Twilight was no stranger to her marefriends squabbling. Applejack and Rainbow Dash seemed to use pointless arguments as a cornerstone of their relationship! Still, she didn't mind being called out to oversee an impromptu wrestling match between the two of them. Really, watching two beautiful mares tangle their bodies together was... hardly an issue.

Editing done by a friend who would probably prefer to be left anonymous.

Published 2020-04-09 14:20:02 UTC
Last updated 2020-04-09 14:20:02 UTC

Everyone Wins!

“You two don’t really need me here, do you?”

The look Applejack gave Twilight was like she had suggested selling the farm. “Of course we need you here, Twi. You’re the most impartial out of all our marefriends.”

Rainbow blew a lock of mane out of her eyes, shifting her weight from one side to the other. “What AJ said. Fluttershy and Rarity are both more than a little biased. In my favor, of course.”

Applejack and Twilight rolled their eyes in unison. “So here I am, because clearly I love you two idiots equally.”

Applejack and Rainbow Dash ears shot up and eyes grew wide at the insinuation that either of them we’re idiots but it was Applejack who spoke first, stetson placed across her chest. “Now Princess, it’s not right to call your marefriends idiots. If it was just Dash, however…”

Rainbow growled, issuing a challenge. “So you’re telling me you’re ready to wrestle then?”

Twilight blinked. Wrestling? What the hell were they trying to prove? She didn’t have much time to dwell on the thought as Applejack and Rainbow Dash collided. A younger, less knowledgeable Twilight would’ve bet her entire private library on Applejack but after experiencing first-hoof how Rainbow could carry the two of them in flight it seemed like an even split.

She didn’t care who won, really. Just watching the two of them literally tangle their bodies together in a desperate scrabble for dominance was enough of a treat. Applejack currently had Rainbow pinned beneath her forehoof, pressing into the spot just to the right of her collarbone. Twilight's eyes followed the bright orange of Applejack’s coat up her foreleg to her meaty shoulder, where muscles flexed and strained. In the afternoon sun her coat shone with a layer of sweat, falling in thick droplets as it shook free from the struggle.

Rainbow’s core strained as her hips swung forward, grunting in exertion as hindlegs wrapped themselves around Applejack’s trunk of a neck. Twilight felt her face flush at that maneuver — a familiar one to her and definitely a favorite. If only Twilight could trade places with Applejack for a moment, she’d bury her muzzle in Rainbow’s muff in an instant. She supposed that wasn’t a fair tactic though. What was a fair tactic was using Applejack’s own weight against her as Rainbow twisted her hips and sent Applejack crashing to the ground.

Rainbow didn’t waste any time pressing the advantage as she leapt on top of Applejack. The contrast here made Twilight’s heart skip a beat. Beyond just the sharpness of Rainbow’s pale blue coat against the vivid orange of Applejack there was the sheer difference in size. Rainbow was small, built by the Sky for speed and speed alone. Applejack was a working pony, her stature mountainesque. Twilight considered for a moment the unstoppable force and the immovable object, the blue blur and the honest apple.

Twilight wasn’t sure what Rainbow’s plan here was. She seemed to be trying to get Applejack onto her stomach for a pin but she just didn’t have the raw strength required to move a pony like Applejack. She did, at least, have the strength to match Applejack’s struggle with her own. Rainbow growled through gritted teeth, an animalistic sound that reverberated in her chest before bouncing around in Twilight’s head. It took a lot to get Rainbow to growl like that. The cold metal of a bridle in her mouth usually did the trick.

Applejack let out a loud whoop as her knee connected with Rainbow’s gut. Now it was Applejack’s turn to go for the pin. Rainbow resisted as hard as she could and Applejack grunted, mumbling countryisms out of sheer effort. Twilight was amazed Applejack could find purchase at all given the way Rainbow’s body writhed underneath her. The smell of musk and dirt caught in Twilight’s nostrils and the stirring in her stomach escalated into a maelstrom. That scent brought to mind sweltering summer nights tangled in her sheets, trying desperately to express her love for Applejack through the flawed medium of two bodies intertwined.

Twilight was entranced at the sight of Applejack’s broad, strong body pressed against Rainbow Dash. She traced her silhouette with her eyes, the rise of Applejack’s hips to the dip in her back to the bunched cords of muscles in her shoulders down to her beautiful face. Twilight followed the curve of her chin down the slope of her neck to her chest and barrel which were being used to nearly smother Rainbow. The way Rainbow arched her rear and flattened her chest and stomach against the cool earth wasn’t lost on Twilight. It was like she was waiting for a strap-on that wasn’t likely to come. Oh that wasn’t a mental image Twilight needed to grapple with right now. As much fun as it was to watch, if this little spat wasn’t over soon she was going to have to end it for the both of them.

End it did as Rainbow’s head jerked her head upwards, a sharp crack splitting the air as hard skull connected with soft muzzle. Rainbow rolled onto her back just in time to catch the first droplet of blood from Applejack’s broken nose. Twilight moved to intervene but she felt herself glued to the spot out of an aroused curiosity. This curiosity would find itself satisfied as Rainbow hooked a foreleg around Applejack’s head and brought their muzzles just inches apart. A broad tongue lapped at the blood now spilling freely from Applejack’s snout, a moment of tension hanging in the air before their lips met in earnest.

They were kissing. Not the response she expected but then again, maybe she wasn’t the only one who was feeling a little wound up. She let herself enjoy the show for a moment, Applejack and Rainbow’s mouths tangling as their bodies had been just moments prior. Applejack moaned against the stark crimson of Rainbow’s lips, a breathy vocalization of raw pleasure cut with pain. Oh! Pain! That was something she could fix.

Twilight reached out and seized them both in her magic, carefully pulling the pair apart. She focused on the spellform of an old healing spell Celestia taught her before she even left for Ponyville. The spreading cool of the healing spell was a stark contrast to the fire burning in her loins. Pale lavender magic arced from her horn and caressed Applejack’s snout, setting bone and closing split veins. Now that that had been taken care of, she had other more pressing matters to attend to. Matters that required both Applejack and Rainbow Dash to be in attendance.

“Well!” Twilight drew herself to her full height, a good head taller than Applejack and at least three taller than Rainbow. “I’m not sure about the two of you but I think you both fought valiantly. Being as impartial as I am, I’m afraid I cannot choose a single winner so you both get a reward!”

Before either of the mares could get back into it she pulled the winds of magic around them. One moment they were standing in some worn patch of grass in Sweet Apple Acres, the next they were in her bedroom at the castle. Applejack and Rainbow tilted their heads as Twilight clambered onto her bed. She heard an understanding “ooooh” from them as she spread her wings and her legs, sitting facing her feuding marefriends.

“Your reward is me.”

The look on their faces was so worth the practice she had put into that line. Rarity had helped her perfect the husky voice that she knew made both of them weak at the knees. She certainly didn’t expect them to acquiesce so easily. Well, maybe Dash but Applejack was typically a little more reserved. She considered for a moment the perks of princesshood as the body heat and sweet musk of two mares washed over her. They were so close! Rainbow was running her muzzle through her ventral feathers and Applejack was planting kisses up and down her thighs and it was all she could do to squeeze her eyes shut.

With her eyes closed, she could at least focus on one thing at a time. Her mind settled first on Rainbow. She had hooked a foreleg around Twilight’s chest to keep her steady as she combed delicately through her still-growing feathers. Twilight’s wings always seemed so sensitive, so eager to feel the touch of her lovers lips. They rustled at the attention, the warm wet spit sticking to her coat as Rainbow moved to lick the wing arms themselves. That always set Twilight’s heart aflutter; something stirring in her stomach as Rainbow trailed down to nuzzle against her shoulder blades. The soreness that came with long nights hunched over a reading desk melted as Rainbow kneaded circles into her back.

She let out a contented sigh as Rainbow busied herself with the massage. That sigh trailed into a moan as an insistent heat between her legs reminded her of Applejack’s presence. There was a comforting rhythm to what Applejack was doing. Kiss, nip, suckle, kiss. She repeated this across the soft flesh and curly coat of her inner thighs and Twilight let a serene bliss wash over her. Princess Celestia, drunk off three barrels of Canterlot champagne, had once regaled her with stories of princesshood gone by; of the herds she used to keep. Twilight imagined this was sort of what it felt like back then.

Herd be damned as Twilight felt wandering lips caress the base of her horn. No sooner did the first syllable of Rainbow’s name tumble from her lips did Applejack finally find her soaking-wet marehood. She leaned back as Rainbow set her front hooves on her shoulders and set to work bathing Twilight’s long, slender horn with her tongue. Applejack pressed her broad tongue against Twilight’s opening, seemingly testing the waters before she chose to dive in. The heat of her breath and the wetness of her tongue alone were enough to set off fireworks in her head.

Now it was impossible to choose from either sensation as Rainbow took Twilight’s horn into her mouth completely and Applejack pressed her tongue into her aching sex. She felt like she was being torn apart, nearly splitting at the seams with pleasure too great for a pony body to contain. Even given the frankly outlandish number of partners Twilight had, it was rare for more than one of them to be in the same bed and focused solely on her. She supposed that’s what she got for playing referee.

Her only respite came as Applejack pulled her tongue away from it’s duty, her blood-stained face now caked in marecum. “Anything you need me to do, just tell me Twi.”

That was it. That was the moment that Twilight truly fell in love with Applejack. She had felt this same moment pass over her countless other times but this one, this one was special. “Yes. I need you to” oh stars it was so hard to focus “you need to get back to work. Don’t stop ‘till I say so, okay?”

Maybe Applejack returning to her spot between her thighs was the truly special moment. It certainly felt that way, given the almost religious reverence Applejack was treating her tender folds with. Twilight understood the dictionary definition of the word worship but this, this is what worship felt like. Rainbow Dash and Applejack were worshipping her in the only ways they could. Applejack had abandoned toying with Twilight’s lips and had settled into a comfortable routine of deep, long tongue strokes.

Rainbow was well-versed in treating Twilight’s horn well. It was a favorite pastime of hers, sneaking up on Twilight while she was reading only to plunge her soft, wet lips over her horn. That was another part of her body that remained frustratingly sensitive as she slowly grew into princesshood. Frustrating was an apt word to describe the sensations that sank into her forehead and spread throughout her body. The way Rainbow’s tongue traced the grooves in her horn, following the spiral down down down to the base only to ride it right back up.

Her lips came free from Twilight’s horn with a pop and she could practically hear Rainbow smiling as she spoke. “You enjoying this, Princess?”

Yes, you beautiful fool. A thousand times yes! Twilight wanted to scream her praises until she was hoarse but all she could manage was a quiet “Mmhm” in response.

“Good, cause I’m not stoppin’ till you finish.” Twilight usually didn’t put much stock into Rainbow’s promises but this time? This time she believed her.

Her body reminded her that maybe ‘till you finish’ wasn’t too far off as a goal point. The pressure that had been building in her stomach since this whole thing started was reaching a breaking point. Her limbs felt heavy, weighty with pleasure as her body tried to contain the sensations she was feeling. It tried and failed catastrophically as the first spike of raw lust cut through her hazy thoughts.

“Girls! Girlsgirlsgirls—” Twilight dug her forehooves in her silken bed sheets as she tried to contain herself.

“Use your words, Twi.” Came the admonishing voice of Applejack, pausing a moment to speak before returning to suckling lovingly on her clit.

“Yeah Princess, I know you got plenty of ‘em!” Rainbow’s ability to talk with something in her mouth never ceased to amaze Twilight.

Oh sweet summer sky she could hardly hold herself together, just barely managing to spit out a sentence. “I’m cumming!”

White hot pleasure coursed through her veins as she allowed all the stress and troubles of the day to drain from her aching body. She felt her body split in two as her marefriends ministrations slowed. Rainbow caught a mouthful of magic runoff while Applejack dutifully swallowed a gush of hot marecum. The pair slowed but neither stopped fully, bringing Twilight to a second then third climax shortly after. Where the first peak was a kick in the stomach, these were the tender kisses that followed. Her heart fluttered and exhaustion settled into her chest.

Twilight collapsed on her back, trapping Rainbow Dash underneath her. She heard no protest as she closed her eyes and let the last of the idle energy leave her body. Applejack pulled herself up to settle against Twilight's stomach, the warmth and weight of her body nearly lulling herself to sleep.

Twilight stared at the ceiling, eyes hardly able to focus on the chandelier above her. “If you girls ever need a referee again, just let me know.”