Five nights at Pinkie's: the murders

by Northguard

Rating: mature
Tags: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark, Alternate Universe, Other, Horror, Slice of Life, Crossover, Death, Five Nights at Freddy's, Main 6, Gore
Length: 1176

Five friends visits their favorite restaurant. What could go wrong? Everything. This day will soon turn bloody.

Twilight, Rainbow Dash, Applejack, Pinkie Pie and Fluttershy visits their favorite pizza restaurant for Pinkie's birthday. They have fun until an employee dressed as one of the animatronics lures them to the backroom.

P.S: You are open to correct mistakes.

Published 2020-04-12 16:50:01 UTC
Last updated 2020-04-12 16:50:01 UTC

The Fazbear Murders

"Come on AJ! We're gonna be late!" Pinkie said jumping up and down expediently.

"Ah'm comin'!" Applejack shouted while running to catch up with her friend.

"Where's Twilight, Rainbow Dash and Fluttershy?"

"They're already at the pizzeria!"

"Then let's get goin' already, its your birthday!"

Meanwhile at the pizzeria.

"What is taking them so long? The show is about to start." Rainbow Dash said impatiently.

"You know that those two usually come right on time. They have 2 minutes left." Twilight reasoned.

"It's just annoying. What makes it worse is that Pinkie is running late to her own birthday party." Rainbow Dash whined.

They waited a little longer and just before they were going to the show stage Applejack and Pinkie Pie came crashing through the main entrance.

"Made it!" Pinkie shouted.

The mane 5 spent the next few hours watching the show, playing in the arcade and eating pizza together. This was the best day of their lives, although it wasn't meant last.

"Hey there kids. Do you like cake?" a stallion dressed in a mascot suit said as he approached the five friends.

"We love cake!" they said in unison.

"Then come with me." the stallion said as he began to make his way towards the parts and service room.

As they were beginning to follow the mascot, Applejack was called by name.

"Applejack! It's time to go home!" she heard Granny Smith say.

Applejack told her friends to wait for her before she ran up to her family.

"Granny, one of the animatronics here just offered me and my friends cake. Can ah please stay a little longer?" Applejack pleaded.

"Hmm. Ah don't know" Granny Smith said.

"Please?" Applejack said with puppy eyes.

"Okay then. Eat your cake and then we can go home."

Applejack was so excited by this that she ran so fast that her hat fell off and she didn't even notice.

Applejack caught up with her friends and they all went into the back room.

"Wait here and i'll get the cake." the mascot said and walked into another room where he took off his costume.

He pulled out a knife from a bag he had placed on the floor behind a shelf and returned to the five foals.

"Who are you and where did Goldie go?" Rainbow Dash asked the menacing purple stallion.

"Oh, I'm afraid 'Goldie' ran into some problems on his way." he said in a creepy tone.

"I-is that a kn-kn-knife?" Fluttershy stuttered.

"Nah, it's a tooth picker.. OF COURSE, IT'S A KNIFE!" he said angrily.

"What are you going to do?" Twilight asked nervously.

"Come over here and let me show you." he said with a very fake soft tone.

"How can I trust you?" Twilight asked.

"Smart for a little filly ain't ya." he said and put down the knife. Easing the tension.

Twilight carefully walked up to him, while looking behind her a few times until she was just outside his reach.

"Here, maybe a hug could calm things down and show you that I'm harmless." he said stretching out his front hooves.

Twilight slowly came closer to him and gave him a hug. Making everyone calm down for a few seconds. Then, without warning, the purple stallion reached for his knife and before anyone could do anything he stabbed Twilight in the back. Twilight screamed in pain but was then silenced by another stab in the back. She fell limb onto the floor in a pool of her own blood.

Everyone panicked and ran for the exit, but it was locked and to make things even worse was the fact that the door was soundproof.

Fluttershy had curled into a ball and was sobbing on the floor, but the purple stallion used his knife to stab her in the leg, forcing her to uncurl herself and before she knew it, she was stabbed three times in the heart. Fluttershy managed to stay alive just long enough to see the wounds on her chest and the blood streaming out of her before death embraced her.

Pinkie Pie tried to hide, but the stallion found her. Her mane had completely deflated, and she was sobbing. She was put out of her misery with a couple of stabs in her side and she quickly died of blood loss.

Rainbow Dash did her best to avoid the stallion, but due to the tight space she was in it was impossible for her to pick up speed. The stallion put the handle of the knife in his mouth and jumped around to catch the blue filly. He eventually did and pinned her to the floor before taking the knife and stabbing her left eye out.

"There we go. Now you are a little pirate." he said menacingly before stabbing her chest barley missing her heart. This allowed her to fight back. Before the stallion could pull the knife out, she punched him in the face making him back off. She rose up and looked at Applejack who was kicking the door non-stop.

"Applejack! You must kick harder. I'll hold him occupied..." she paused looking down at the knife in her chest. "...as long as I can." she finished. To Rainbow Dash's credit, she managed to distract the stallion very well despite the pain and the knife stuck in her chest, but the stallion eventually got a hold on her tail, he then pulled her to him and held her in his hooves. He then grabbed the knife, pulled it out and gave her a fatal stab to the heart.

Applejack had been kicking the door and was now begging to hear the lock coming loose. This filled her with hope, but she was then pushed to the side falling on the floor next to Rainbow Dash's dead body. She looked up and locked eyes with the murderer. He got a creepy smile and then covered her mouth.

"Sleep." he said before bringing his knife down and stabbed her five times in the side. She looked up at him and managed to find the willpower to speak one last sentence.

"Ya won't not go unpunished for this." she said weakly before she drew one last breath and then went limp.

"You did it again Afton. You did it again." he said to himself before exiting the room.

A while later a figure stepped into the room and gasped at the sight of the five dead foals.

"No...how could it happen again?" it said before walking up to them and putting a mask of the animatronics on their heads. It then put a gift box in front of each of them and a flash of light appeared. When it faded each of the dead foals was replaced by an animatronic. The figure put all of them in a seated position against the wall. It looked around and then teleported out of the room.

Author's Note

I just killed them off. I'm insane, I know:pinkiecrazy:

Sequels will follow so don't worry.