Fluttershy Will Be Our New Lead

by AndwhatIseeisme

Rating: mature
Tags: Fluttershy, Sex, Princess Celestia, Porn, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Fetish
Length: 4126

Celestia really enjoyed seeing Fluttershy play her during her ones-versary play. Now she invites Fluttershy to her castle to enjoy it further.

Fluttershy is a little confused when she receives a summons from Princess Celestia to visit her palace in Canterlot. She's even more confused about why the Princess has asked her to come wearing her costume from the play Fluttershy and her friends had put on recently. But the last thing she wants to do is disappoint her princess, so she flies to Canterlot decked out in her full Celestia outfit, wondering what the real Celestia has in mind.

Warnings: Mare on Mare sex, princess/servant roleplaying, Fluttershy being a surprisingly good dom.

Contest entry for Dirty Little Secret's Dirty Little Contest.

Published 2020-04-23 23:00:01 UTC
Last updated 2020-04-23 23:00:01 UTC

Oh, My. Me? Playing You?

Fluttershy landed at the entrance to the Canterlot palace. She felt a little awkward as she landed, and not just because she had come alone to the most important building in Equestria to visit its ruler. She had met Princess Celestia enough by now that a personal visit with her only caused her the normal, mild level of anxiety she had meeting any pony instead of the crushing, paralyzing anxiety it once triggered. No, what was really making Fluttershy uncomfortable was the fact that she was currently dressed as Equestria's sovereign.

Blue, green, and pink extensions wove through Fluttershy's mane and tail, patterned with stars to mimic Celestia's own mane. Upon her hooves she wore near-perfect replica's of Celestia's own shoes, and around her neck was an equally impressive likeness of the princess's peytral. Topping the outfit off was a replica of Celestia's crown, with a fake horn attached to compliment Fluttershy's own wings and complete the alicorn look. The outfit certainly wasn't going to fool anypony, but it was certainly drawing some strange looks from the ponies she passed as she walked through the main gate of the palace and up to the first guard she could fine.

"Umm, excuse me," she addressed him, "my name is, umm, Fluttershy. I was invited here by the princess..."

"Ah yes, miss Fluttershy. We've been expecting you," the guard said, bowing slightly out of respect for one of the holders of the elements. "We received very specific instructions from the princess to lead you straight to Her Highness when you arrived. Please come this way."

He bowed again and began to lead Fluttershy as instructed. All the while, he was doing his absolute best not to eye up the beautiful pegasus speaking with him, dressed in royal regalia and visiting the palace for a very specific purpose that Celestia didn't even bother hiding from her guards. He paused when he heard her voice behind him.

"Oh, that's alright. I've been here enough that I can find my own way to the throne room. I'd hate to be a bother." Fluttershy spoke softly, always feeling uncomfortable when other ponies went out of their way to serve her.

"We're not heading for the throne room miss," the guard said, "I'm to lead you directly to Her Highness's personal bedchambers."

"Oh," Fluttershy said with mild surprise. Then her brain caught up with what she had heard and she blushed brightly as Celestia's reason for inviting her clicked into place. "Oh, um, well, in that case, um..." she was stuttering and tripping over her words, wondering what kind of mare this guard must think she was.

"It's quite alright, miss Fluttershy," he reassured her, "I've been serving in the guard long enough to have seen ponies of all sorts pass this way. No one turns down this sort of invitation, not even an element of harmony."

"I see..." Fluttershy said, still kind of embarrassed but understanding that this was probably just part of the job for the guard. "Well, um, lead the way then, I guess," she smiled.

The two walked in silence as the guard led her to Celestia's room. Fluttershy was reassessing what she was getting herself into now that she understood the purpose of the princess's invitation. This wouldn't be the first time she had been with Celestia, of course - nor the second, fifth, or tenth time - but it would be her first time alone with the princess one on one. In the past, she'd always been with all of her friends, but now she would have Celestia's full attention. The thought was making her more nervous than she had been when she had arrived, but she could also feel the fur under her tail growing damper as she thought of spending such intimate time alone with the princess was getting her juices flowing. She hoped the guard in front of her didn't notice her scent, but she also found herself caring less if he did with every step.

Just before they reached their destination, Fluttershy had another thought rise to mind as she remembered for the first time how she was dressed. Celestia had invited Fluttershy to come have sex with her, while dressed as Celestia? Fluttershy wasn't positive what the purpose of her dressing like this was, but she wondered if this was similar to that time she was younger when Dashie had asked her to dress up in a Wonderbolt uniform and let Dash call her Spitfire while they fucked. Fluttershy hadn't been a big fan of that, and Dash had never asked her to do it again. Hopefully dressing up for Celestia wouldn't be quite so awkward afterwards.

"We're here, miss Fluttershy," the guard said suddenly, snapping Fluttershy out of her thoughts. She looked up and swallowed a gulp as she stared at the large double doors before her.

"Oh, um, thank you very much," Fluttershy said as her pushed a door open enough for her to walk in.

"Have fun," he smiled a knowing grin as she walked past him into the room. He took a deep whiff of the air as she passed, breathing in as much of her aroma as possible as he caught a peek underneath her tail. He knew what he'd be doing later tonight once he got some private time back at the barracks.

Fluttershy walked timidly into the bedroom, eyes darting around until they landed on the majestic figure lying on the bed. Celestia wore nothing but a demure smile as she watched Fluttershy enter, bereft of her normal regalia. As the door shut behind Fluttershy, Celestia rose from the bed and bowed to the pegasus.

"Welcome back, Princess," the alicorn bowed as she spoke, "how may I service you today?" she asked.

Fluttershy's eyes went wide as the princess addressed her as such. She stood frozen in place as her mind raced to process her words, and Celestia walked toward her, swaying her wide, luscious hips as she approached. Celestia lowered her mouth to Fluttershy's ear and whispered into it.

"Don't be nervous, my little pony, just go along with it and do what comes natural. I've been wanting to do this with you since I first saw you wearing that outfit; just think of it as another play. Let us see who is the better actress when its just the two of us," Celestia spoke reassuringly into Fluttershy's ear, giving her a gently lick as she finished. The princess then stepped back again and took a more submissive stance, bowing before her. "I ask again, You Highness, how may this lowly mare service you today?" Celestia asked.

Fluttershy felt like a faun surrounded by a herd of timber-wolves as she at last understood the scenario the princess had envisioned for them. Celestia wanted Fluttershy to pretend to be her? To order Celestia around and make her service her however the pegasus wished. To dominate and subjugate the most powerful pony in the realm? To force the princess of Equestria to lick her and suck her and let Fluttershy fuck her like a common servant mare? To bend Celestia over on her own bed and fuck her every hole as she smacked her royal ass hard enough to turn those delicious white orbs a throbbing, scarlet-"

"Umm, Princess?" Celestia interrupted, trying to stifle a laugh as she struggled to maintain character while watching Fluttershy's emotions play across her face, "You're dripping, Your Highness."

"Oh," Fluttershy snapped back to reality as she noticed the puddle slowly beginning to form under her dock. She was getting wetter than she had imagined, thinking of making the princess service her. She decided it was time for her to get into character.

"Well, what are you doing just standing there, watching your princess's juices land wasted on the filthy ground?" her voice suddenly filled with as much royal authority as she could muster, "Clean it up!"

Celestia was taken back for a moment by the sudden shift in demeanor by the shy mare.

"If, um, you don't mind," Fluttershy added quickly, hoping she didn't overstep her bounds.

"Of course," Celestia moved around Fluttershy and lowered her head to the puddle on the floor, "as you command, Your Highness."

Fluttershy gasped as she watched the ruler of Equestria begin to lap her arousal off the ground, her tongue running across the floor until all signs of Fluttershy's spilled juices had vanished, replaced by a thin coating of royal saliva. Fluttershy fought to resist touching herself to the sight as Celestia worked. This was really happening, and Fluttershy was going to make the best of it.

"Good job, servant," Fluttershy praised Celestia's work, "now, from now on you shall address me as either Princess Fluttershy or ma'am. Do you understand?"

"Yes, Princess Fluttershy," Celestia spoke, casting her eyes down to the ground.

"Good. Then, um, follow me to the bed and -- and remove my shoes," Fluttershy commanded her servant, "and um, do it with your mouth only."

Fluttershy climbed onto the mattress and presented her forehooves to the princess first. Celestia smiled to herself as she approached the pegasus. She had been worried that Fluttershy was too timid to get into this the way Celestia wanted, but it turned out Discord had been right when he'd advised Celestia that Fluttershy could be sufficiently aggressive in bed if given a push in the right direction. She'd have to invite the draconequus over some time to thank him properly for his advice.

Turning back to the task at hand, Celestia manipulated the shoes on Fluttershy's forehooves, undoing the straps and pulling them off with her mouth like a common earth pony. Fluttershy was somewhat surprised at how well practiced Celestia was at this, until she remembered what Twilight had mentioned about Celestia and Luna's relationship. After removing a shoe, Celestia took the time to lick Fluttershy's hoof clean, slathering each one with her spit in turn. Once she had undone the two on Fluttershy's forehooves, Celestia moved to the hind two. Fluttershy moved her tail out of the way as the princess worked on her hooves, presenting Celestia a fine view of how much Fluttershy was enjoying what the princess was doing. When she had completed her work on all four hooves, Celestia once again bowed her head to the ground and begged for further instruction.

"What may I do for you next, ma'am?" she asked.

Fluttershy pondered a moment, a whole slew of images flashing to mind of what the alicorn could do, and Fluttershy struggled to pick just one order at a time.

"Well, you did a passable job cleaning my hooves, but let's see what else that tongue is capable of," Fluttershy spread her hind legs, lying on her back and presenting herself fully to the princess, "lick me, my pet."

Celestia moved her head between Fluttershy's legs, causing the pegasus to squirm slightly as she felt her warm breath agaisnt her lips. Celestia extended her tongue and made a single, teasing lap up Fluttershy's slit. Then she pulled her head away and looked back at the mare.

"I've licked you, ma'am. What would you like next, Princess Fluttershy?" there was a hint of mischief in Celestia's eyes. Even in these circumstances, she couldn't help but be a bit of a tease.

Fluttershy stared at the princess for a moment in sheer disbelief that they were really playing this game, even now. Memories of her being led to believe she had killed Celestia's pet phoenix came to mind as she felt something rise within her. This wasn't just about sex anymore, this was about teaching the thousand year monarch a lesson in humility. And Fluttershy had a whole lifetime of humility to draw from.

Sitting up, she raised a hoof and struck Celestia across the face. The blow wasn't hard, but it was enough to shock the princess. She looked at Fluttershy, who stared back at her with deadly seriousness.

"Do you think this is a game, you little slut?" Fluttershy asked, raising her voice as best she could. "You know what I meant when I told you to lick me, but let's get more specific if your simple mind isn't capable of understanding my orders," Fluttershy was getting into it now, and Celestia could feel her juices flowing as she listened to the pegasus scold her. "Now, you're going to eat my royal pussy until I cream all over that stupid face of yours. Then, you're going to flip me over and lick my ass out until I cum again. And after that, if you can get this far without screwing up, you're going to go back to licking my rear hooves until I deign to give you another command. Do you understand?"

"Yes, Princess Fluttershy. Please forgive this foolish mare," Celestia was enraptured as she listened to the shy little mare order and demean her, all while dressed up in facsimile of herself. She got ready to go down properly on Fluttershy, but was interrupted by one last command.

"And no touching yourself until I give you permission," Fluttershy decreed.

Celestia's heart fell.

"But, please ma'am, can't I pleasure myself while I eat you?" Celestia begged.

"Nope," Fluttershy replied bluntly. "If you had been a good mare at the start, you wouldn't have this problem. But you had to be a little tease, and now you see where that attitude gets you. You're going to finish servicing me, and then maybe, if I'm feeling particularly kind, I'll let you beg me for release afterward. Is that understood?"

"Yes," Celestia replied, downtrodden.

Fluttershy's tail cracked across Celestia's face, whipping the princess with surprising force.

"Yes, what?" Fluttershy asked.

"Yes, Princess Fluttershy," Celestia corrected herself.

"Good, now enough talking. You have your work cut out for you if you want to earn the right to cum today, so I would get to it if I were you." Fluttershy ordered.

Celestia shivered in excitement at the way she was being treated. This was exactly what she wanted; being bossed around by one of her own subjects and reduced to nothing but a plaything to another's will. She dove into Fluttershy's dripping cunt with a fervor, desperate to earn her right to pleasure. She buried her muzzle between those delectable lips and drove her tongue deep inside the other mare. She delighted in Fluttershy's flavor as she lapped greedily against her inner walls. Fluttershy's hooves landed on her head and pushed her in deeper as the pegasus moaned in appreciation. Celestia struggled to breath as her face was mashed against Fluttershy's crotch, encouraging her to try even harder to pleasure her mistress. Celestia's tongue wriggled and thrust inside the yellow mare, pushing her ever closer to her peak. Just when Fluttershy thought she couldn't feel any better, Celestia's horn lit up and her magic gently pinched Fluttershy's clit, triggering her climax and unleashing a flood of mare juice all over the alicorns face. Celestia did her best to drink up what she could, the rest soaking her face and bed in Fluttershy's cum.

Fluttershy's hooves released their grip on Celestia's head, allowing her to pull back from between Fluttershy's legs and take a much needed breath of fresh air. She took a moment to admire her work, watching the smaller mare recover from her climax. She wasn't allowed to observe for long before she received another smack from Fluttershy's tail.

"Excuse me, but what do you think you're doing there just staring at your princess?" Fluttershy asked. Her crown and horn had fallen off her head, ruining the illusion of her costume slightly, but the look Celestia saw in the mare's eyes as she stared the princess down was all Fluttershy needed to maintain the authority she held. "I believe I already gave you instructions for after you finished with my cunt, servant!"

Celestia remembered, and she used her magic to lift the pegasus up off the bed and turn her over, laying her back gently on the mattress with her butt pointed up at the alicorn. Her tongue flashed hungrily across her mouth as she eyed her next meal, the plump yellow cheeks hiding her prize. Celestia leaned down and let her tongue move between those cheeks, licking from cleft to tail in one slurp. After a few such lascivious licks, she moved to Fluttershy's puckered anus and focused her attention there. Her tongue lapped and prodded the mare's ass, trying to push its way in. She didn't encounter as much resistance as she might have expected, but reflecting on the pony's relationship with Discord, it didn't surprise her too much that her ass had probably seen a good amount of use. At least she kept herself clean back there, Celestia mused as she drove her tongue deeper inside the mare.

"Hoof me while you lick, slave," Fluttershy ordered, panting as she struggled to last under Celestia's masterful tongue work.

Celestia grinned as she continued to lick, now raising a hoof to Fluttershy's snatch and slowly teasing her way inside. Her hoof passed between Fluttershy's lips and began to push it's way inside of her. Fluttershy whimpered and squeaked as the hoof penetrated her began to move in and out of her. Celestia's hoof was larger than an average pony's, certainly larger than any of her friends', but enough nights with Discord and those few times with Big Mac meant Fluttershy was fully capable of and accustomed to taking larger things inside of her. She barely felt the pain of her walls stretching as her mind was occupied trying to process the immense pleasure she was receiving from both her rear entrances. It took only a few more minutes of Celestia tongue fucking her ass while hoofing her snatch before Fluttershy reached her second orgasm of the day, soaking Celestia's hoof with her mess.

This time, Celestia didn't need to be reminded of her orders, withdrawing her mouth from Fluttershy's anus and immeadiatly moving back to worshiping her hooves. Celestia's own damp hoof went unattended, desperate to touch herself and feel Fluttershy's juices mingling with her own, but not daring to risk upsetting her princess when she was so close to having earned her reward.

Fluttershy basked in the afterglow of her orgasms, taking a break to enjoy the feel of Celestia's tongue slobbering over her hooves as she rested. Once she felt ready to continue, she ordered Celestia to stop and sit at the base of the bed. Fluttershy stood up and looked the alicorn over, now drenched in Fluttershy's cum.

"Well, I suppose you did okay with your orders, slave," Fluttershy stated, "but do you think you deserve a reward?"

"Oh please, Princess Fluttershy, I'm so wet. Please let me cum," Celestia pleaded as her princess stood over her and looked down at the whimpering alicorn begging for release.

"Very well, just as it's a servant's job to please her princess, I suppose it's a princess's job to attend to the needs of her subjects," Princess Fluttershy ordained. "Turn around and present your hind quarters to your princess, and we will see what we can do to attend to your base desires, wrench."

Celestia didn't hesitate to turn around and raise her ass up to her princess, moving her tail to the side as her tongue fell out of her smiling mouth, panting like a happy dog. Fluttershy moved to inspect her slave's rear, sniffing at her arousal before giving a hard smack to one of Celestia's cheeks with a hoof.

"Ugh, you're so wet back here it's almost embarrassing," Princess Fluttershy declared with a sneer. She spanked the other cheek, causing ripples to spread across the celestial globe. "I almost feel dirty touching something that's surely been used by countless commoners before, but duty calls, I suppose. Prepare yourself, slave. And do try not to make me exert myself for too long. Just cum like a good slut and let us be done."

With that, Fluttershy raised a hoof to the entrance of Celestia's ass, and pushed her way forcefully inside. Celestia yelped and grunted at the surprise intrusion, not expecting her princess to use that hole. Fluttershy's hoof pushed its way deep inside, until she was up to her elbow inside of Celestia's ass. She paused a moment inside her to use her free hoof to smack Celestia's cheeks a couple more times, drawing forth the delightful red tinge that Fluttershy had envisioned earlier. Fluttershy brought her free hoof down between her legs to rub herself as she began to pump the one inside Celestia in and out of her. Fluttershy's mouth went to Celestia's twat, latching onto it and drinking deep the alicorn's dripping arousal as she fucked her. Once she had her fill, she moved her mouth away and brought her wingtips to the alicorn snatch, teasing and prodding it as she hoof-fucked the royal ass.

Celestia's mind was on fire as she gave herself over utterly to the mare behind her. Was this the same Fluttershy she had once seen literally hide from her own shadow? Did Twilight know about this side of her, and if so, why had her pupil kept it a secret from her for so long. No wonder Discord had given up his old habits and reformed if this was what he was getting in return. She gasped again as Fluttershy's mouth latched around her clit, sucking gently as her wings parted Celestia's folds and her hoof sped up inside of her. If Fluttershy had asked it of her at that moment, Celestia would probably handed her throne over to her for real just for the chance to experience this more often.

After what felt like both an eternity and a fleeting instant of overwhelming pleasure, screamed Fluttershy's name out as she came. The alicorn's legs gave out, falling to the floor and sliding off Fluttershy's hoof. The princess lay gasping for air as she tried to recover her senses, all thoughts having fled from her mind as her orgasm crashed through her like a tidal wave upon the shore.

"Oh my goodness! Are you okay, Princess?" a soft voice full of concern asked.

Celestia looked up to see Fluttershy looking back at her, face full of worry. Gone was the domineering look in her eyes that had made her legs quiver and her body shudder. She was back to the Fluttershy the rest of the world knew, kind and fretful. The steel and grit within hidden again from view.

"Yes, Fluttershy, I am fine," Celestia spoke as she attempted to stand. She got it on her third try. "That was quite an amazing performance. I must concede again that you are indeed the better actress." Celestia spoke with a soft smile, a wing extending to caress Fluttershy's face and stroke her mane.

Thank you, You Highness," Fluttershy spoke as she leaned into the petting wing.

"Now, my dear, I still have a few duties to attend to before the day closes and I'm sure you could use some rest. Let us part for now. You may rest here tonight and I will see that you have transport home tomorrow morning."

"Okay," Fluttershy looked away as she kicked a hoof idly against the floor. Celestia watched her, waiting for her to voice what was on her mind.

"Um, princess?" she spoke at last, "Do you think, um, maybe we could, you know, maybe do that again sometime?"

Celestia' smile widened as she picked the pegasus up and tucked her into bed.

"Of course, my princess," Celestia said with a knowing wink, "I would love to serve you again. But for now I think it best that you get some rest."

"Mmmm, rest sounds good," Fluttershy said as Celestia turned to leave the room. "I am looking forward to spending time with you like this again, though." she added as Celestia reached the door.

"Me too, Fluttershy, me too," Celestia spoke as she left. She was just about to close the door behind her when she heard Fluttershy speak one last sentence that sent an eager shiver down her spine.

"Next time, I'll bring some of my toys."

Author's Note

This was a lot of fun to write. These two are not really a pair up I would normally consider, but thanks to DLS adding a surprise bonus round prompt to his contest, I ended up with what I think turned out to be a pretty good fic. I always thought Fluttershy looked adorable in her Celestia costume, and the thought of her being with Celestia while wearing that get up is what inspired the rest of the story.

Hope you enjoyed it.