“Alright now spill. Just what is going on here?” The mare known as Cookie Crumbles demanded, having sat the three teens down on the couch. Button sat in the middle with a “Sweetie Belle” on either side of him. One looking like she wanted the ground to open up and swallow her, and the other still trying to stifle her sneezes from a runny nose. The ‘well’ looking one was dressed in a blue sweater top, along with a pair of ‘borrowed’ fresh panties from Sweetie’s drawers. A fact the sickly Sweetie wasn’t happy with. The sickly one on the other hand was dressed in a proper nightie, understandable given her condition. Neither looked all that happy at the moment, though Cookie couldn’t help but notice that one of her ‘daughters’ looked more cross then the other at this entire situation.

“That’s what I'd like to know!” Said daughter huffed, giving the stink eye to her doppelganger. Button was worried a lot of it was directed at him as well.

“I-I just came over to deliver some soup a-and see how Sweetie was doing w-when uh…” He sighed. There was no point in being defensive about it. He’d done the deed, now he needed to stallion up to it. “One thing lead to another and… I didn’t stop it. We had sex.”

“I get that darling, and it’s not you I’m upset with.” Cookie said with a sigh, this caused Button to blink, and the sniffling Sweetie to balk.

“Wait what? Why not!?”

Cookie rolled her eyes. “Sweetie, you’re both eighteen years old. The fact you went this long without having sex is a testament of will don’t ya know. You’re both adults now so it’s gonna happen, just make sure you use your protection spells got it?” She thought for a bit. “Or don’t actually, I wouldn’t mind being a grandma all things considered.” This caused the sick Sweetie to blush.

“M-mom?” Despite how upset she was, she couldn’t help but give an eager look toward Button. She wasn’t sure she was really ready to be a mom, but given the fact she was just told it was okay to have sex was something in it’s own.

“W-what!? Cookie you can’t be serious!” The other Sweetie shouted, before catching herself. It was very clear to Cookie that this girl didn’t want to upset her anymore then she may already be.

“And what makes you think you have a say in this missy? I still don’t know who you even are!” Now despite her words, Cookie Crumbles wasn’t dumb. The lack of a certain individual in the house, and the way this new Sweetie was acting, along with calling her ‘Cookie’ gave her a pretty good idea who this might be. Though truth be told, her mind could barely believe it.

“Yeah, who are you? You can’t be my friend Ocellus, she’d never do something like this! So what? Some other changeling? Why me? Why MY boyfriend!?” The sick Sweetie yelled before having to stop and catch her breath. About a half hour or so of sleep was certainly not enough to allow her to get better, and even now her body was making it very clear it wanted to be back in bed. She just wasn’t budging until she got the full story.

“I-I’m not a changeling I’m.. uh… well that is to say now…” She stammered actually poking her fingers together. Oh good grief.

“Hondo is that you?” Cookie just came out and said, causing said “girl” to do a double take.

“Y-You know!?” The moment those words left her mouth, all Tarterus broke loose.

“D-Dad!?” Sweetie cried, staring at her double in disbelief. She had been wondering what had happened to him, partially worried that he was stuck in some green cocoon if this was a "changeling" but... but to find out the girl was really him!? How? Why?!

“No way… there’s no way…” Button said, staring at the girl in horror. This was Sweetie’s father!? He… he had just lost his virginity to her dad?!

“I-It’s all just a mistake! A big horrible mistake!” Hondo cried to the ceiling, wishing she could disappear. Why couldn’t she be good at lying? Anything would have been better then them discovering this!

Cookie sighed. “I have to admit darling I wasn’t being completely serious with that guess, but you were acting a bit like him, er you.” She rubbed her temples. What did it say about your life that this only gave you a ‘minor’ headache? With everything that went on in this town, and especially how often it seemed to involve at least one of her daughters, she felt this wasn't as shocking as it should be.

“Dad that’s really you in there?” Sweetie asked still trying to process what she was hearing and seeing. Meekly the copy of her slowly nodded her head.

“H-Hey pumpkin. L-Look I can explain alright?”

“You darn well better there missy.” Cookie growled, her expression steel. “Start from the beginning, but your story better explain why I’m looking at twin daughters and why I caught the one that was my former husband being plowed by the sweet confused Button.”

Button couldn’t help notice how she was referring to him. It was a bit of surprise still that no anger seemed to be present in her voice toward him. After all, he had just… Gah! He had had sex with Sweetie’s father! Her father! What’s worse is he felt this should sicken him, but all he felt was some mild discomfort. As much as he hated to admit it, looking at this girl beside him made it very difficult to see her as anything but a sexy eighteen year old hottie who had just recently been begging for him to fill her. Shit he was almost getting hard just remembering that! This was messed up!

“I-I know. I will um…” Hondo sighed. Why couldn’t she have just said she was a changeling and run away? This would be so much simpler! “Well, remember that talk with Rarity I told you about where she mentioned clothing keeping the memory of one who wore it? Well…”

* * *

“So let me get this straight…” Cookie said, her face emotionless. “This was supposed to be a treat for me, but because of happenstance, you accidentally used panties that she enchanted to be a gift for Button Mash.” She pointed to the real Sweetie Belle who blushed and avoided her gaze. “Which turned you into an exact copy of our daughter, and led you to get so worked up you jumped this poor boy’s bones?”

Hondo winced at that description, but nodded. “Yes, that um… sorta sums it all up.”

“I see…” Cookie said, her face unreadable. Hondo steeled herself, her heart hammering in her chest. She didn’t think this would lead to...breaking up, but at the very least she’d be on the couch for a while. At least she hoped that was all that happened. Well, at least she’d be able to drink the antidote soon.

“Bwa ha ha ha ha!” Cookie suddenly erupted into laughter, gripping her sides. To say the rest were stunned was an understatement.

“M-Mom?” Sweetie inquired, rather worried about her mother’s mental state. Button wasn’t sure what to feel, still trying to come to terms with what he had just done. Hondo, Hondo was too frazzled to properly think anything.

“Oh dear Celestia that’s a whopper!” Cookie screamed trying desperately to get a hold of herself.

“I-It’s not funny!” Hondo finally managed shivering. “I-I cheated on you!”

“Yeah! As my daughter with a boy! Well I mean he is a cutie. Our Sweetie has good taste. I tells ya, if I was a good decade or so younger myself!”

“M-Mother!” Sweetie yelled standing up before feeling herself get dizzy. Without thinking Button helped hold her, surprised she didn’t flinch away. “This is serious! D-Dad stole my first time!”

“Oh please Sweetie, you’ll still have your first time when you get better.” Cookie said with a roll of her eyes. “Besides, I’ve known a few twins who’ve shared a guy. I doubt Button here would mind.” Button’s eyes bulged.

“W-what!?” He stammered looking from Sweetie to… the other Sweetie. Was it his imagination or did the former ‘father’ have a healthy blush upon her cheeks?

“S-Share? Dear what are you saying!?” Hondo cried standing up herself. Damn it why did her body heat up at that thought? Even now the events of the past hour began to replay through her head, her libido combing back strong. What was wrong with her? She couldn’t seriously want to do that again did she? It was bad enough it had happened at all!

“Just what I said honey. You and Sweetie can share him. Imagine a threesome with these two, sounds rather nice don’t it Button? I’d take the time to claim Sweetie’s virginity first though.” Now Button was really confused. Confused and admittingly getting horny.

“I-I what? But, I had sex w-with your husband! Shouldn’t you all like, hate me or something?”

Cookie shook her head. “Maybe some mares would, but I’m not your typical mare don’t cha know. Hondo and I have… had fun with others before. This ain’t that different. Though I admit it ain’t up to me to decide.” She looked at the real Sweetie.

“Y-You can’t be serious mother!” Sweetie cried, a bit of Rarity’s speech pattern showing through. She did spend an awful lot of time with her older sister. It was cute to see how much of her was rubbing off on their little Sweetie Belle. She’d be an elegant lady just like her before she knew it. Though maybe not as high strung.

“Button is MY boyfriend!” Sweetie added, pulling him close.

“Wait, you still want me as your boyfriend?” Button blurted out before he could stop himself. He didn’t want to jeopardize their relationship anymore, but couldn’t help but want to know if it was over already.

“Yes I still love you and yes I’m mad at you!” Sweetie cried, gripping his shirt. “You had sex with another girl and that pisses me off, but I know I shouldn’t be mad because she looks exactly like me and there was no way you would know!” She groaned. This was so frustrating! Why couldn’t she have just not gotten sick! Why was all of this happening?

“S-Sweetie I… I’m so sorry.” Button said, putting his arms on her shoulders. He wanted to hug her, but was still afraid of her changing her mind and slapping him. He felt he certainly deserved it.

“Damn it Button, why are you so thoughtful?” She cried pressing into him. This time Button did wrap his arms around her. He could hardly believe it, but it looked like his relationship with her wasn’t over. At least not yet.

“So Honey, how do you feel about all this?” Cookie asked, turning her attention to Hondo. “Do you want to dump me for a colt?”

“W-what!? No!” Hondo cried in horror. “I told you this was a mistake! I-I couldn’t think clearly!”

“And I know that.” Cookie said with a grin. “Dear I love you and don’t forget I had that same spell put on one of my own panties once. I know what it does, and I know what happens when you go messing with strange magic.” She raised an eyebrow. “Or do ya really think I thought you would turn yerself into a copy of Sweetie intentionally just to have sex with her boyfriend?” Hondo’s face flushed.

“W-well when you say that, but I mean… I was worried….”

“I know Honey, I know.” Cookie nodded. “If I’m ta be honest with ya, I’m a bit miffed I missed out on the real plan, but all things considered. If this had happened ta someone in a story or something it’d be pretty funny!” Another round of giggles escaped her lips.

Hondo felt relief at her words. She still felt terrible for what had happened, but she was glad she wasn’t about to lose a wife from it. Still she knew some sort of punishment was likely in order. Hopefully it wasn’t too scary.

“Still I can’t believe you dad!” Sweetie cried, giving her the stink eye again. “Ugh it’s so weird calling you that when you look like me!”

“H-Hey! It was because you love him so much t-that this body craved it! I-I tried to fight it I really did!”

“Really?” Sweetie asked. She wanted to be more skeptical, but in truth she also saw the logic in her mother’s words. It didn’t seem very likely her own father would want to become her twin just to steal Button away.

“Of course Sweetie! I’d never!” Sweetie could see just how much this was tearing at her twin. As angry as she was, she was no stranger to magical mishaps making ponies do stupid things. It’d bug her for a long time, but she supposed she’d eventually get over it.

“Fine, but you OWE me.” She said turning away. She couldn’t see her, but had a feeling her twin’s face had a look of relief.

Her twin. It was weird thinking of her that way, but it was just too much to try and see that girl as her dad. Her twin, while weird, was at least easier on her psyche.

“L-Look this will all be over once I get that antidote in me. T-Then I’ll do whatever you want.” Hondo said, feeling slightly better. Things were going to be awkward as shit for a while, but at least it looked like their family would survive it.

“Speaking of which. All of you stay put.” Cookie announced, getting up and heading toward the laundry room. They did as told and remained in place as Cookie returned a few minutes later with a vial of white liquid in her hands.

“Is this the antidote?” Hondo nodded her head frantically.

“That’s it!” She said holding her hand out. Finally she’d be back to normal and these… feelings she was still having could go away!

“Good.” Cookie said with a smirk as she shoved the thing down her cleavage. “I’ll hold on to it during the duration of your punishment. If you want to think of it as one.” All three eighteen year olds stared at her confused.

“W-What are you saying? D-Dear give me the antidote!” Hondo cried stepping forward. What was she doing? She thought Cookie had understood the situation!

“Now that’s not the proper thing to call me.” Cookie chided while wagging her finger at her. “Thankfully I know a good prank spell from the school days. Oh boy I haven’t had ta cast this in a while.” Her horn began to glow. “Better make it times three ta get what I’m thinking.” The horn aura brightened. “Actually make that four.” Brighter still.

“C-Cookie what are you doing!?” Hondo cried taking a fearful step back. She didn’t like where this was heading.

“M-Mom?” Sweetie asked with a mixture of confusion and concern. She may still be mad at her mirror image here, but that didn’t mean she wanted harm to come of them! Her mother on the other hand, just winked at her.

“Don’t go getting your panties in a twist, it’s just a harmless prank spell.” She said before letting it go. Hondo felt it wash over her, but otherwise she couldn’t tell anything else had occurred. She didn’t feel any different.

“M-Mom what did you do!?” She cried out before her hands slapped over her mouth. What had she just said!?

“W-wait why did she just call you mom, uh mom?” Sweetie asked, starting to feel faint. The excitement of all this was only able to keep her mind off of being sick for so long.

“Just having a bit o fun is all.” Cookie said with a giggle. “Till I feel like having my husband back, I now have a total of three lovely daughters. Rarity, Sweetie Belle, and her twin… Well wadda ya know? I cast the spell for her to say her new name, but I forgot to actually give her one. Any suggestions?”

“Wait wait, what?” Sweetie cried feeling a headache coming on. “Why is she suddenly my twin sister? Mom what are you thinking?”

“It’s simple. Your ‘sister’ here.” She said putting an emphasis on ‘sister’ that Hondo didn’t think she cared for. “May have had good intentions, but she still gave in to her feminine desires, and well. Truth be told I find this entire thing a riot! It could be fun seeing her have to deal with being a teenage girl for a while. Plus gotta admit I’m curious as to if she’ll learn a few tricks from having a female body that she can use when this is over.” She winked at Hondo, causing her to feel half embarrassed and half horrified.

“Ugh, I don’t think I wanted to hear that last part.” Sweetie groaned. Her dad her twin sister? This was all sorts of messed up. Her mom didn’t really think this was a good idea did she?

“I don’t like this anymore then you sis!” Hondo cried before covering her mouth in horror again. Sweetie hated to admit it, but seeing her do that was just a tiny bit funny.

“Wow she really can’t help but call you her sister?” Button asked staring over at Sweetie’s Twin. Ms Cookie Crumbles was right. They needed a name for her if they were to refer to her in her new form. He couldn’t just call her ‘the other Sweetie’ after all, and he still didn’t want to think of her being Sweetie’s father.

“Yep! It’s a neat little prank spell that went around back in my teen years.” Cookie snorted. “It forces you to say a different word whenever you think of a certain thing. As you might have guessed we made our classmates say dirty words instead of what they meant to say all the time! Got so bad the teachers put counterspell stones in the walls, preventing it from occurring at all.” She walked over to Hondo.

“Guess in time it became forgotten since ya couldn’t cast it anymore. Not that it was hard to break even without magic, any fool could will it away if they tried hard enough, which is why yer gonna promise me not to do that. Right Honey?” The look she gave Hondo was one of playful mirth, but held just enough weight to let her know that she’d be rather disappointed if she did.

“M-Mom you can’t be serious! W-Why do I have to stay this way?”

“Oh please, you act as if I’m grounding you. Is being a cute girl like Sweetie all that terrible?”

“I-It is when I’m a copy of my own sister!” She cried, cringing mentally at what she had just called Sweetie. This wasn’t happening. This could not be happening!

“You didn’t seem to mind earlier when you were enjoying what that body has ta offer.” Hondo blushed.

“T-That was… I told you!”

“A mistake I know.” Cookie said, placing her hand on Hondo’s head. “Honey listen to me. I know this is weird, but we’ve done some crazy things in the past haven’t we? So tell ya what. To show you I’m not furious with you and that I do appreciate what you tried to do. If you put up with this for a little while, I’ll return the favor.” Lowering her head she whispered in Hondo’s ear.

“In any way you want. Like perhaps I drink a potion from Zecora and make myself look like that teacher all the colts had a crush on back in the day.”

If Hondo still had a dick, it would have twitched at that. There wasn’t a stallion alive who had been in Ms Heart Throbs class that hadn’t daydreamed of her in naughty ways.

"I-I don't know, this is Sweetie's body! What are we going to tell everyone?!"

"Well it's not what I'd have picked fer certain, but I'm sure I'll think of something to tell the neighbors." She tightened her grip on her shoulder, her expression dropping the mirth to adapt a serious expression. "And after a couple of days, if it's clear this is really troubling you, I'll hand the antidote right over ya hear? I just think this could be fun for a bit, that's all."

Hondo stared into those eyes of hers, seeing an excitement in them that he hadn't seen in such a long time. This wasn't what he had in mind, but it seems it had a possitive effect regardless.

“I-It’ll just be a little while right?” Hondo couldn’t believe he was even considering this, but truth be told, he did want to make his wife happy and... well the reward was very tempting. Though... there was a deeper reason for her giving in that she was ashamed to admit.

The truth was she hadn't forgotten how she felt when she had sex with Button. She hadn't forgotten the feelings she got when she stared in the mirror as saw this beautiful filly instead of his fat old body. Though she wished it wasn't true. A small part of her was excited to explore these possibilities. At least until Rarity found out about her...

“Of course Honey, of course.” Cookie said standing up straight. “Now we just need a name for you. How about it Sweetie? Got a name for your new younger sister?”

“Younger!?” Hondo cried, feeling indignant. “I’m middle aged!”

“Oh are you?” Cookie chided. “Because you look like an eighteen year old to me.”

“You know what I… Fine but I’m her twin then! We're the same age!”

“Well yes, but one of you has to have come first, and well Sweetie has been around a lot longer than you Honey.”

“T-that’s not! That doesn’t… MOM!” Hondo cried, stamping her foot much like Sweetie did when frustrated. Despite all that had happened, Sweetie couldn’t help but let out the slightest of giggles.

“Aw come on little sis. Don’t give mom a hard time. Also what have I told you about borrowing my stuff?” The look on her twin’s face was priceless. Perhaps this could be fun after all.

“D-Don’t you start!” Hondo cried, fixing Sweetie with a glare of her own. “I may be stuck like this but I'm still your sister!" Her cheeks turned red. "I mean my name is still-”

“Honey!” Button suddenly blurted out, causing all to stop and stare.

“W-What?” The twin of Sweetie asked, looking very confused. Button gave a sheepish grin, rubbing the back of his head.

“W-well I mean your name. Honey Belle. I dunno, it’s just you kept getting called “Honey” and I thought it sounded nice.”

“That’s it!” Cookie cried in complete glee. “I love it!” She snapped her fingers. “Your name is now Honey Belle!”

Honey Belle felt herself shiver, knowing full well that if she tried to say her real name of Hondo Flanks, it’d come out as this new one instead. Damn you Button! Damn you and your sexy body and big juicy dick!

“Well that’s settled.” Cookie said clapping her hands together. “Now Button, if you could be a darling and put poor Sweetie to bed, she needs to rest so she can get better. In the meantime I’m going to find an outfit for Honey to wear here, so I can take her out for her new wardrobe. Also could you be a dear and hang around till we get back? I'm sure you can take care of anything she needs."

She gave Button another wink that caused his head to spin. This was not the Hearts and Hooves day he had expected to get when he woke up.

"Uh y-yeah sure. My mom isn't expecting me back for a few hours I guess..."

"Perfect! Help yourself to anything in the fridge, and don't worry about what happened today. I'll keep it a secret from your mother alright?" Cookie smiled, but inside she was laughing. She knew Cream Heart from her school days, and knew she had no say in things given how early they'd lost their virginities back in the day. If anything she'd likely be proud of her son for holding out for so long.

“Hold on, new wardrobe?” Honey repeated in shock. “Why do I need that? I-I’m not going to be like this that long am I?”

“Well long enough you’ll need your own clothes. You can’t share everything with your older sister now.”

“Have fun sis!” Sweetie added evilly as she walked down the hall with her boyfriend. Maybe it was because of all the things her and her friends did that made this a bit less strange to her, weird as it all still was, or maybe she was just too sick to care. Either way she didn’t care at the moment. She just wanted to sleep and get better. The sooner she was, the sooner she could check something off her bucket list.

“Hey Button Mash” She whispered as they got near the door to her room. Said colt twitched a bit at her voice. Poor thing, he probably still feared her wrath. Well, he’d pay for this, but likely not in the way he thought.

“Y-Yeah?”

“I’m going to get some rest, and when I’m well enough, you and I are going to have sex. Wild passionate sex, and you better make me scream. Got it?” She grinned at the enlargement of the ‘bump’ in his pants. New younger twin sister or not, Sweetie was going to show Button what the real Sweetie Belle could do!

“Got it?” She repeated more fiercely. This sparked a proper response.

“Y-Yes ma’am!”

“Good.” She said, giving his cheek a kiss. “Till then lover boy.” With a wink she entered her room and quickly rushed to her bed to collapse. Ugh, she’d think about this properly in the morning.

Button in turn was frantically trying to calm himself down, a very obvious tent in his pants telling him it was going to be a painful few hours. Maybe he could borrow their shower? A nice cold one sounded nice right now. As he pondered this, he made his way to their bathroom, thoughts of his girlfriend flooding his mind. I-If... Honey felt that good, then a filly who had grown up into a mare...

His dick seemingly cried out in need at the mere thought. Damn it, he needed to stop thinking about this. How could he be horny at a time like this anyway? He just found out there were two of Sweetie! One that was her, gah!

"Two." His mind repeated, images of them both appearing in his mind. Both giving him those sexy bedroom eyes, wearing nothing but their birthday suits, beckoning him toward the bed.

He groaned at the sudden twitch of his dick. Yep. That's it. Cold shower NOW.

As for Honey Belle, she let her temporary ‘mother’ dress her up in some of Sweetie’s clothing. Letting her keep what she already had on, and adding some stockings and a skirt that was much too short for her liking. Thankfully Cookie didn’t insist she wear heels for this little outing. Though part of her feared it was coming. Especially when Rarity found out about her. Imagines of her being dressed up in outfit after outfit haunted her thoughts.

Weird interest in this or not, she was going to do her best to convince Cookie to give her that antidote. With luck she'd only be this way for a few days tops! Holding on to this resolve. She let her new 'mother' lead her outside for their first 'mother daughter' date.

* * *

Poor Honey Belle. Poor, poor Honey Belle. Nopony knew it, but she would be in this body for a long long time. For what neither of them saw, was the white potion slowly turning clear. It’s magic fading away due to the fail-safe all transformation magic had.

Transformation could be a dangerous magic after all. If used improperly it could hurt the one it transformed, and therefore any magic user worth a damn made sure there were plenty of fail-safes in their spells or potions that prevented any transformation from harming life.

So it made perfect sense for the antidote to disable itself so as to not harm the little egg inside Honey that had just been fertilized by one of Button’s many seeds pumped into her. Her body even now getting ready to let it grow.

Yes poor Hondo Flanks was in for a very long ride as Honey Belle indeed.

Author's Note

There will be more with Honey Belle, I'm just not sure when. Perhaps if I write that story that deals with Diamond Tiara's family, Honey will show up as a friend. After all, why have only Hondo Flanks get to enjoy becoming your daughter's twin?

So this had no real place in the story, but I think for this universe/headcanon, Cookie Crumbles is a health inspector, and that's what she was called to do today. Perhaps a restaurant was reported to be in disarray, but upon her arriving it turned out to be a false claim from a jealous competing restaurant, and thus she was able to come home early.

Now some of you might be thinking about the one time we got to hear them talk and how she said she was giving Sweetie Belle lessons on cooking, and just how Sweetie Belle's food looked.

Yeah for that instance I'll say she was joking.

Not sure what Hondo Flanks does. Probably a stay at home dad.

I'm also going to admit that I'm not sure what I want to do with Cookie Crumbles in this universe. We obviously just made Honey Belle pregnant, so she's likely not going back. So that leaves Cookie technically single.

I'm half tempted to have her join someone's herd. Possibly having them with a daughter themselves, letting Sweetie and Rarity gain even more siblings.

Though I'm also half tempted to have her drink some potion and become a teen. Don't know if I'd want her with Button, though it could be funny if he ends up with a harem consisting of the entire family. Rarity included.

Or I could have her do something that makes her a Rarity clone who decides Spike deserves a happy ending...

Well if you have any other inquiries, please feel free to share them in the comments!