Fluttershy's Biggest Secret

Fluttershy woke up in her bedroom and immediately realized something was off. Not only was she resting on the floor, judging by its hardness, but she smelled a heavy scent of musk around her. When she got around to lifting her eyelids and looking at her surroundings, she noticed a heavy white splatter on the wall opposite her, and it seemed to be covering a pony. She looked at it for a moment before remembering the events prior to her unconsciousness, inhaling sharply at the memories, causing her to cringe at the pungent scent still permeating the room.

The pegasus stood up and glanced over at the window near her and noticed it was still bright out. “At least I wasn’t out for too long...” She sighed and looked back at the plastered white mare whom she remembered used to be a pale blue. “Trixie...” Fluttershy thought before moving towards her. She touched her hooves to Trixie’s sides and found that the cum was still rather sticky. She sighed again. “What have I done?”

The yellow mare then picked up the wet unicorn with her forelegs and stood up on her hind legs and started walking to the door. She opened it with one of her wings, stepped through and continued walking towards the bathroom.

When Fluttershy entered the bathroom with Trixie in-hoof and closed the door, she paused for a moment. “This is going to take a while to get out,” She thought while looking down at her friend. The pink-maned pony resumed movement towards the shower, then stepped inside and set the other mare down, and she now found it fortunate that the shower was large enough to easily fit multiple ponies.

The yellow mare turned the shower handle and let out a small ‘eep’ as the cold water struck her. She then started to rub Trixie with her hooves, trying to get the ludicrous amount of cum out of her coat.

She rubbed Trixie’s side for a while before her sapphire coat finally began to show through the white plastering. “Even that little section took so long; this is really going to take a while,” Fluttershy lamented. She let the water flow over the former showmare, aggressively rubbing across her entire barrel in an attempt to wash the cream out, also forcing a light amount of it out of her belly that she now remembered she had pumped into her.

She was at that for more than 10 minutes, just forcefully cleaning Trixie’s coat and draining her stomach, starting at the barrel, moving to the forelegs, the back, and then the hind legs. She noticed Trixie’s soft moaning over the sound of the running water as she cleaned between her hind legs. She started fantasizing about screwing Trixie again, but had to stop herself before she ended up making the situation worse. “No! Bad Fluttershy!” She scolded herself. “You can’t rut her when she’s unconscious like that! Especially when rutting her is what made her go unconscious in the first place.”

Fluttershy then started to clean Trixie’s neck and head, this time noticing a slightly disappointed sound coming out of the partially plastered pony. The pegasus once again pull herself out of her sexual fantasies of thoroughly fucking the helpless mare in front of her.

She then moved on to the mane and tail, thankfully easier to clean than the rest of her as she took no more than a minute on each part. After the yellow pony was done with cleaning the cum off of her friend, she took the bottle of conditioner and squirting some on her hoof before pressing it into the sapphire mare before rubbing it over her in the same movements she used previously. The whiteness of the conditioner once again had her imagining things, such as splattering her cum all over Trixie again, or shoving her fully erect shaft into her pussy and inflating her so much she could hardly be described as a pony anymore. Oh Celestia, that image; so big, so full, so fucking- “Stop!” Fluttershy yelled at herself.

She closed her eyes and sat down for a few minutes in the relative silence of the shower, just calming herself down from the sexual high she nearly became enraptured by. “Okay, you seriously need to stop thinking so sexually; she came to you for help and now she’s like this because of your stupid libido.” She inhaled deeply and opened her eyes to view whom she met not more than a few hours ago. “Control yourself, Fluttershy,” She thought to herself as she started moving her hooves back to Trixie to finish cleaning her.

Fluttershy finished cleaning and rinsing the unicorn’s head before she grabbed the shampoo bottle and squirting some on her hoof. “Alright, let’s not get out of hoof this time.” She then started to coat the off-white mane belonging to former showmare. “There’s nothing sexual about this. I’m just helping a friend. A friend who I knocked out with my stupid dick.” She sighed heavily, beginning to regret ever meeting Trixie.

“No! You can still help her!” Some part of her mind called out.

“How? The first thing thing I do to her is force her down my cock and slam her into a wall with my cum.” She responded.

“No, the first thing you did was promise to her that you would help her. Even when she was blowing you, she initiated that!” That side of her mind called out again.

“Yes, but-”

“No! No buts! You do need to apologize to her for what you did, but you are not irredeemable, and neither is she for that matter! She still needs your help, and if you don’t give it to her, Celestia only knows what she’ll do!”

“...You’re right. She is still my friend, and needs my help.” Fluttershy resolved.

Once she was finished cleaning Trixie’s mane, she began to clean herself, going through similar motions to how she cleaned the other mare, albeit more animatedly and with the addition of her wings.

After cleaning herself off, she turned off the water and picked up the sapphire mare with her forelegs once again and brought her out of the shower. She then reentered her bedroom, placing Trixie upon the bed making a mental note to clean the cum splatter on the wall later that day.

Fluttershy finished feeding all of her animals and sat down on the couch in the middle of the main room, deciding to leave Trixie to her devices for the time being. “So, how do you want to break the news to them?” She asked herself, ‘them’ referring mostly to her friends (whom she remembered being predominantly anti-Trixie).

“Well, I should probably start with Twilight, she’s pretty understanding and I don’t think she would hold a personal grudge against her, I just have to tell her the way Trixie sees things,” She reasoned. “Then maybe Pinkie, there’s no way she would be so resentful as to not forgive her,” She thought before inhaling deeply in anticipation of having to deal with the rest of her friends. “I think maybe Applejack next, she wouldn’t be as grudgeful as the others. I suppose I should just give her time with it. Then Rarity and Rainbow Dash,” She sighed with a slight groan. “They’re going to be very difficult.”

“But, I don’t think I should tell any of them that, or at least not yet.” She chuckled and blushed lightly at the thought. “‘Hey girls, do you remember that showmare who showed up in Ponyville a few years ago and later nearly took over Equestria with the Alicorn Amulet? Yeah, she came to me to talk about it and we ended up making out and I shoved my massive futa cock down her throat and ejaculated her into a wall.’ Yeah, not awkward at-” She jumped forward in her seat as she was interrupted by a knock at the door.

The yellow pegasus sighed and reluctantly got up to walk over to the door. She opened it a crack and saw a certain fashionable white unicorn with a smooth purple mane. “Dang it, I have to do this now!?” She lamented before opening the door a bit more and saying “H-hi, Rarity.”

“Are you alright, darling? You were supposed to meet me at the spa an hour ago.” She replied, slightly concerned.

“Oh!” Fluttershy said, remembering that her spa date was today. “Um, sorry. I was as little busy.” She finished, looking slightly guilty.

“I hardly think whatever you were doing made you just a ‘little’ busy, darling. These appointments are supposed to be important!” The white mare pressed.

“Y-yes, well-” She gulped, “I met somepony, and she was really sad so I had to talk to her for a while. She was still so sad, even after I agreed to help her with her problems, so I allowed her to stay here for as long as she needed and she’s kind of sleeping in my bed right now.” She said rather quickly, slightly looking away in remembering how sad her guest was.

Rarity narrowed her eyes a little, clearly suspicious. “May I ask who ‘she’ is?”

Fluttershy closed her eyes for a second, preparing for the backlash of who she was going to mention. “It’s T-” She gulped. “Trixie.”

The other mare’s eyes grew wide and her mouth went slightly agape in shock. “Trixie!?” She shouted. “You mean the showboating unicorn who humiliated me and two of our friends in front of the entirety of Ponyville, and then nearly enslaved them with the Alicorn Amulet!? Her!?” She asked, mostly rhetorically.

“There it is,” The shy pony thought before quietly responding “Y-yes... she-”

“How could you possibly help her!?” The unicorn began shouting again. “And you- wait. What do you mean she’s ‘kind of’ sleeping in your bed? You didn’t have sex with her, did you?” She asked, clearly peeved.

Fluttershy recoiled slightly at the accusation, knowing its truth. “I-umm...” she replied, unable to get any coherent thoughts out, but her rising blush told Rarity everything she needed to know.

“You did! Oh Celestia, I can’t believe you!” She yelled back, somewhat louder this time. “How could you!? You betrayed us!” The seamstress continued, completely unable to fathom how somepony so seemingly evil as Trixie could actually get one of her friends to help her.

“Rarity, I-” The pegasus started with her eyes beginning to tear up, only to be cut of by the white mare still in front of her.

“No! You don’t get a say in this anymore! I can’t forgive you for what you have just done!” She said before starting down the path back to Ponyville.

“Rarity, wait! I can explain!” Fluttershy shouted back at her friend, but no response came. “She would have killed herself if I didn’t help her!”

Rarity stopped mid-stride for a few seconds before turning around to view the mare she was just walking away from.”What?” She said in doubtful confusion.

“She- she wants to apologize,” The other pony responded.

The alabaster unicorn stared at Fluttershy in an eerie silence for what seemed like hours before she began to slowly walk back to the house.

The silence, punctuated only by the sounds of wind and hoof-falls, lasted until Rarity stepped before the door to Fluttershy’s home, when she quietly said “Okay. I will give her a chance.” She then looked behind the yellow mare to see a sapphire-colored unicorn standing at the base of the stairs.

Fluttershy realized her friend wasn’t looking at her, to then turn around and see Trixie, silent, with her eyes darting between herself and Rarity. “W-well?” She asked Trixie.

The blue mare opened her mouth as though to speak, but quickly shut it and closed her eyes to compose herself. She then opened her eyes and moved over next to Fluttershy, looking at the other unicorn all the while. “Trixie is sorry,” She started, but was interrupted with a sniffle coming from how she looked to be affecting her only friend’s relationships, “For humiliating you in front of Ponyville and- and for everything she did with the Alicorn Amulet.”

Rarity closed her eyes for a moment and nodded slowly. “Thank you,” She replied before looking back at Fluttershy. “And, I suppose I should let you tell the others when you’re ready?”

“Y-yes, I would appreciate that,” The pegasus said and Trixie nodded in agreement.

“Okay, then I guess I will let go back to, umm...” The fashionable pony responded and finished with a rosy blush covering her cheeks. This blush was reciprocated by another on the other mares as they looked away in embarrassment. Rarity then turned away and closed the door with her magic, before walking down the path and trying not to imagine what those two ponies would get up to.