The Surprise Closet

Rainbow Harmony moaned deeply.

Today had been, in a way, a really good day even despite the bumpy start. She’d gotten to cum twice now, she’d learned what that weird itch was, and how to take care of it. She even knew her body a little bit better. And now she was even learning how to make other ponies cum. That was fun. Especially because Starlight tasted so good. Every time she licked up some more of that juice that pussies seemed to like leaking, she wanted more. It was like she was thirsty, but the more she licked and drank the plummy vanilla pussy juice, the thirstier she got. She even felt it in her stomach. Or maybe that was just the horniness. In a way, she was learning to like it. Thrusting at the air, leaking her own juice, and making someone feel really good – it made her feel really good. Sure it made her feel out of breath almost constantly, her face hot, and her entire body hot and shaking at random times...but it made her feel alive.

And somehow, she managed to feel even more alive as she felt something sliding into her. The something was at first just a little bumpy, but she noticed as it slid it was kind of slowly bringing a tingling feeling with it. It started small, but seemed to grow the further it went in, making her insides feel somehow extremely hot and cold at the same time...but in a good way. She didn’t even care exactly what it was, all she knew was she wanted it in deeper...she wanted it to move faster like the tentacles had, like Starlight’s tongue had. But as it seemed to be moving too slowly, she instead settled for gyrating her hips up and down. That seemed to do the trick; almost immediately she felt that huge wave coming up again. Was she going to cum already? She didn’t know.

All she knew was that everything was getting super intense again. The vanilla-plum juice danced on her tongue, tasting better than anything else she’d ever eaten. She drove her snout even deeper into Starlight’s pussy, only pulling out to breathe and think of another word to spell before diving right back in. Every time she returned, the tingling cold heat radiating from the thing in her pussy flared up. She loved it. Her legs couldn’t move fast enough to bring her down on that thing, her tongue couldn’t swirl around in and on Starlight’s pussy fast enough, or lick that little ‘clit’ thingy that poked out every now and then. Bounce, bounce, bounce, moan, gasp, lick, shiver, slurp...everything was just amazing. How was this the first time anypony had bothered to show her what this stuff was?

“Haaaah...H-harmony, waaatch...the – my hhhoooorn…slow...mmmmhngg!”

Oh. So that thing was Starlight’s horn. And that tingly stuff was...magic? Was that what it felt like? Nonetheless...even though she heard Starlight, it seemed like her body didn’t actually want to slow down. If anything, she only sped up, humping the tingly magic horn for all it was worth. Her brain wasn’t even in control anymore, but her legs were, sending her flying up and down, with Starlight’s horn giving her huge bursts of hot goodness and tingly cold shivers. She could barely breathe fast enough to sustain herself by this point as she continued eating Starlight’s delicious pussy. She could see why it was called eating out...she just couldn’t get enough of it. Every taste not only made Starlight moan, or sigh, or squirm, but her as well, in the best of ways. She wanted to keep doing it forever. Her wings just couldn’t sit still and she just couldn’t stop making sounds she never thought she’d be making.

But then she felt what she’d been looking for, that encroaching peak. It started deep within her pussy and spread out, making her muscles shake. She could feel her juice-soaked muzzle scrunch up as she dove even further into Counselor Starlight’s pussy, doing her best to make her feel as good as she was. Whether intentionally or not, the horn with its sparkly magic energy or whatever was returning the favor. Her pussy almost felt like it was on fire and underwater at the same time in a confusing mix of sensations. But there wasn’t much time to think about it; her chest was growing tighter, her involuntary squeaks rising in pitch, her legs trembling even more. No doubt about it, this was going to be her biggest cum yet…!

“Mnnnnnnnnnnahhhhhh!”

And there it was. In an instant, it felt like the world was spinning and fireworks were going off in her vision, even though she couldn’t quite see them. Her hind legs buckled, only barely catching her before she fell all the way down Starlight’s horn. She could feel her pussy gushing juice and contracting tightly around the horn, which seemed to respond in kind with the coldest ice and the hottest heat. The pleasure didn’t level off like before; it managed to grow as she felt odd little pokes and squishes as more magic stuff happened inside her. Every second she felt another icy-hot bolt in her pussy, and another full-body electric sort of tingle as every bit of her body sang out happily. All she seemed to be able to do was keep humping and squeaking every time her pussy came to an abrupt halt on Starlight’s forehead.

Her ears twitched, seemingly unable to decide whether they wanted to be perked up to listen, or flattened down to ride the intensity of the cumming. She could just barely make out the sounds of Starlight getting louder too, before suddenly there was a lot more vanilla-plum juice bubbling into her mouth. Apparently Starlight’s special place didn’t quite do the same squirting thing that hers did, but the raw heat coming from it as Starlight seemed to cum too was almost dizzying. All she could do was keep licking, teasing around Starlight’s clit and shoving her tongue into her wet, quivering insides as they both cummed together for what felt like minutes.

Finally, things seemed to calm down. Her wings stopped flapping uncontrollably, and her legs managed to stop buckling long enough for her to stand up straight. The tingly icy-hot bolts shooting through her pussy slowed down and eventually stopped entirely, reduced only to tiny little sparks as she slowly pulled herself back up to her full height. Her panting slowed as her eyes refocused, and she lifted her muzzle out a bit from between Starlight’s legs. Multiple trails of juice were still attached to her face, but she didn’t bother breaking them for the moment. She just made sure to breathe in and out deeply, recovering from the overwhelming feelings that were still subsiding.

The itch – or the horny, she guessed – was mostly gone now. Somehow, it was still there, unlike last time...but she needed a break now. Now that she wasn’t buried in Starlight’s pussy, she almost felt kind of tired. But the horn still lodged in her pussy still felt tingly, keeping her energized enough to not just fall over.

“Did...did you have fun?”

Harmony felt her ears twitch as Starlight said the first full sentence out of the two of them in a long time. She felt like her brain had to work extra hard before she could respond and move her lips the right way. “Y-yeah...lots.” And she had. Who would have thought that her first day at school would have ended up feeling so good…?

“I’m glad to hear that…” Starlight sighed happily. Harmony felt a sudden movement down below, and squeaked as Starlight’s horn slid out with a little pop and an accompanying extra wave of warm goodness. She arched her back a little as it traveled down to the tips of her hooves, but then relaxed and sighed happily in turn as the pleasant memory of its journey remained.

They both just sat there for a bit longer, panting alternatingly as they thought about things – or at least, as she did. Who knew what Starlight was thinking about, if anything. But apparently she was thinking something, because soon Harmony found the unicorn’s pussy sliding down out of view, far below her, and then the attached rump hitting the floor with a gentle thud. Gratefully, she returned to all fours as Starlight scooted out from under her – standing on all fours was way easier than just on two and two on the wall. But then, that wasn’t something she did much. Maybe she’d have to practice that.

“So...what did you like about it?” Starlight asked as she stumbled behind her desk and took a seat, nodding towards the other seats as if to say she should do the same. Harmony complied, wobbling over on her newly weak legs and sinking onto the nearest chair with a floomph. She had to hold back a giggle as she realized how messed up Starlight’s hair was now. It was all frizzy and sweaty, to the point she almost looked like a weird clown. Then her better senses took over, and she realized she probably looked pretty similar; being made to cum was kind of an intense experience, even if you’d done it before. Probably. Those were questions for later. For now, she had to answer a question. What did she like about it?

“...does everything count?” she asked, grinning sheepishly. Starlight did giggle, but still shook her head. “Okay, well...I think it was fun to try that eating out stuff.” And it was fun. She could still taste Starlight’s sweet pussy juice when she licked her lips.

Starlight nodded. “I enjoyed that too. You really did a great job for your first time, Harmony.”

Harmony found herself blushing at the compliment, even though she wasn’t quite sure why. It did feel nice, though. What else had felt nice? “And...the horn stuff was fun. It was tingly and like, hot, but cold, but...good too.”

“Really, now?” Starlight leaned forward and propped her head up with her hooves. “Tell me more.”

More? What more was there? “Uh...well...it was kinda… you know…”

“Where did it tingle? How much? What were the best parts of it?”

Oh, at least she had something more specific to focus on now. “Well...mostly all inside, but a little bit at the front?” Come to think of it, she was almost certain that not all of Starlight’s magic had stayed inside her. She briefly remembered one moment where it felt like some even managed to hit her clit, which was decidedly not part of her insides. “And it was a lot of tingling, but kinda...mm...well, the weird temperature stuff was the best part of it. The tingling did remind me a bit of the tentacles, too.”

“Interesting.” Starlight smiled, leaning back before blowing a tuft of stray mane out of her face. “Well...any questions while we wait for the next round?”

“Um...yeah, a few.” More than a few, actually, that had been in her mind ever since they’d started off in the office. Some were more burning than others, but one was burning the most, so she asked it: “What...is all this stuff we’re doing?”

Starlight seemed like she didn’t want to answer for a second; she pursed her lips and stared out into nothing. She even used her magic to start the cocoa machine over on the side of the room. But then Harmony did get her answer, even though it made little sense, at least at first. “Well...when two ponies enjoy each other’s company a lot, they might do things like what we’ve been doing to feel good. Everything has its own name, but all of those things fall under one name: sex. Usually it’s done between special someponies, but not necessarily.”

Ohhh, so that’s what a sex was. She’d heard the word before, but never really knew what it meant. But wait...they weren’t special someponies. Unless...were they…

“Are we special someponies, then?”

Starlight’s face turned super red almost immediately. Granted, it had been a little red already, but now it basically became a tomato as Starlight just about hid behind the desk. “N-...no, Harmony. We just...I’m just helping you out because Jeffrey made you horny. Nothing more.”

“Oh.” Harmony hmmed as she stared down at the floor. It made sense; after all, they’d barely spent any time together. But then that made her curious, and possibly a little disappointed, about what that meant: “So...will we not get to do the sex anymore?” She really wanted to keep doing it. It felt good, and it made Starlight feel good too, apparently. Given that, why couldn’t they?

But somehow, Starlight just turned even redder, and even began sweating a little bit. She didn’t say anything for a good ten seconds, and even when she did, it was just to correct her on how to use the word sex, apparently: “...have sex, not do sex.”

“Oh. So…”

Starlight sighed, finally becoming a bit less red as she did. “First of all...yes, we can have more sex today. It’s only proper that I help relieve you so you can succeed in your future studies.”

“But what about tomorrow? And after that?” Heck, why not every day? Sex was great. Sure, she had classes and stuff, but she could easily see spending a lunch break or two to nip on over to Starlight’s office and have a quick sex break instead. She didn’t understand why Starlight didn’t seem as eager about it all.

“I...don’t know, Harmony,” Starlight eventually managed, swallowing extra hard. Harmony frowned in turn, feeling her insides swirl a bit for reasons she didn’t quite understand, other than maybe disappointment. She liked Starlight, and she liked when they did – er, had sex. Was it possible that…

“Do you not like me enough for more sex?”

Another sigh. Starlight sure seemed to like sighing. But she finally became a good bit less red in the cheeks, and stood up to walk around the desk. She knelt down and made sure that they were making strong eye contact before answering.

“I do like you, Harmony.” Harmony glanced down as she felt Starlight take one of her forehooves in both of her own and gently squeeze it. “I like all the students who come to me for guidance, in one way or another. In fact, though it didn’t start this way...I’ve come to like you a good bit more than some of the other students. You’re such a fast learner, you’re polite, and...I won’t lie, you’re a bit cute too.”

Now it was Harmony’s turn to blush. Nopony had ever called her cute before besides mom and dad...but Starlight just had, and she kept talking and saying nice stuff too. “If it were up to me, you’d be welcome to swing by my office anytime you need some stress relief, and we’d blow off some steam.”

Rainbow Harmony blinked. “Is...it not up to you? You’re...the counselor and stuff.”

Starlight shook her head. “No, it isn’t. Some ponies...don’t like when older ponies like me have sex with younger ponies. Even just being a little romantic is kind of...frowned on.”

“Why?” It didn’t make sense to Harmony. If it felt this good, why couldn’t anypony and everypony do it? Heck...she wanted to do some more now. Which was apparently fine, but what would the future hold?

“I…” Starlight finally just stood up and shook her head. She smiled weakly, too, before levitating over some hot cocoa for both of them, the machine already done with its drink-making process. Harmony took a quick sip, enjoying the just almost scalding temperature as Starlight opted to not sip hers for the moment. “Listen,” she said, leaning back against her big white desk. “It’s...complicated. Everything about this is, to be honest. If you want to talk more later, you’re more than welcome to come to my office tomorrow during any of your free periods. But for now...let’s just enjoy the time we have, okay?”

“Okay.”

Rainbow Harmony knew she wouldn’t really get any more answers from Starlight after that, especially with the way that red tinge on her red cheeks seemed to never quite fade away. So she was somewhat content to just sit there and quietly take turns sipping on hot cocoa. She sipped, Starlight sipped. She sighed, Starlight sighed. It was a silent game of charades where nopony really won. All that happened was occasional sips of chocolatey goodness, and the resultant heat growing in her belly from it. Come to think of it, that heat seemed to be spreading down to her midsection, out to her legs, and to her...oh. There it was again. But it was weaker than the other times before, so maybe she could ask one more question before they got into sex itself once more.

“Um, Starlight?”

“Hm?” The unicorn peeked around her mug, as she’d been mid-sip when addressed.

“Well, you know how when you make someone cum, or the feeling when you are cumming...does that have a name?” It felt kinda strange to just call it a cum after all. It felt a little too...understated?

“Oh! There’s a couple of names for that,” Starlight said once she’d lowered her mug. She seemed to be back to her usual happier self, at least. “Some ponies call that an orgasm, others call it a climax. They’re used slightly differently, though. Such as when somebody cums, they’re having an orgasm, because they’ve reached their climax. Does that make sense?”

The filly nodded. “Uh-huh.” Those words felt better. She didn’t like having cums, but instead having orgasms. It rolled off the metaphorical tongue a lot easier. Sip. Mmmhhh...hm. Okay, she had another question after all. “You remember the tentacles – um, Jeffrey?”

Starlight chuckled, finishing off her cocoa and setting the mug aside. “I’ve known it for a while. What about it?”

“Well…” Harmony felt her cheeks grow hotter as she recalled her time in the surprise closet, the feelings it brought back only made stronger by the afro-whatever-it-was. “I...had a bunch of the things in my mouth and butt. Was that sex too? It felt kinda like what we’ve been doing, but...different.”

Starlight paused, and seemed to think of her next words carefully...but then she nodded and sat on the edge of her desk, wiggling her rump back to make sure she wouldn’t fall off. “Yes, actually. Sex with your...butt, as it is, is called anal sex. And sex with your mouth is called oral sex. That one also includes eating out and stuff like that.”

“Oh…” It did make sense. She hadn’t known what all that was about earlier, but it turned out it was just another form of sex. She had to admit she really liked it, and was a bit surprised they hadn’t done anything involving it yet. But more to the point...she found herself wishing they could go back there again. She said as much; maybe they could dip down there, provided they were still in a period where nopony else would be around to interrupt them. “So...can we go back to the closet? I wanna play with the tentacles again.”

Starlight started to nod, but then Rainbow Harmony saw her stop, and a small smirk form on her lips. “Actually...why leave? We can play with some tentacles right here.”

“We can?” The filly looked around the room, as if she thought tentacles would soon materialize from any of the innocuous openings in the area. Disappointingly, they didn’t.

But un-disappointingly, Starlight nodded eagerly, with a weird sort of glimmer in her eye. Maybe that was where her name came from. “Yes. In fact...I’ve been thinking of how best to really scratch every little bit of your horny itch, as we’ll call it. Heck, we might be able to get you into your fourth period with everything taken care of. All it’ll take is you, me...and a whole lot of magic. But I’ve got more than enough to spare on the thing I have in mind.”

Harmony had never really understood how magic worked, but she was aware of the idea that each unicorn had only a certain amount they could use, just like every pegasus had a different flight time. She wondered briefly what the comment had to do with tentacles as she drained the last of her cocoa, but then her jaw dropped as she realized: “No way...y-you can just make sex tentacles?!”

Starlight laughed out loud for probably the first time Harmony had ever heard. It was light, airy, and full of joy. She didn’t really get what was that funny at all, but eventually Starlight quieted down to answer. “Well, I mean...any kind of tentacles I want. But that does include ones to be used for sex.” Almost as if just noticing that she was done, Starlight grabbed Harmony’s cocoa cup with her magic and gently placed it with the other emptied one on her desk. “So...what do you say? Are you ready for some more fun?”

Harmony beamed, feeling her heart rate pick up in anticipation, and her wings flutter in excitement. More of her newest favorite thing? Don’t mind if she did! Even her pussy joined in the excitement; it seemed to already be warming up in anticipation as she signaled her approval:

“Heck yeah!”

“Wonderful.” Starlight pushed off from her seat on the desk, landing with a gentle series of clips and clops. “So, here’s what I have in mind…”