Blood Day- Fluttershy’s First Murder

by Mystoriessucklolyeet

Rating: teen
Tags: Dark, Alternate Universe, Fluttershy (EqG), Rarity (EqG), Equestria Girls, Horror, Profanity, Violence, Death, Human, Gore, Pinkie Pie (EqG)
Length: 1719

Fluttershy goes batshiz crazy, and meets Pinkie Pie

Fluttershy goes batshiz crazy and gets put in a mental asylum, where she meets Pinkie Pie.
Contains: Blood, Death, Swearing, Gore, Mental Facilites, and that’s it.

Published 2020-06-02 13:40:01 UTC
Last updated 2020-06-02 13:40:01 UTC

Fluttershy Did What?!

It was like any normal morning in the city. Fluttershy woke up and fed her pets. When finished, she went and brushed her teeth and did her hair. Then, Fluttershy grabbed her phone and ran to the door. She first put her sweater on since it was a bit cold. Fluttershy then picked up Angel Bunny, put him in the backpack, and walked outside.

She opened her phone and checked her messages. She had only one of them. She opened it and it was from Rarity. It read: “Hello Fluttershy darling, I have the collar for Angel ready. Come pick it up when you get here. Fluttershy quickly replied: “I will Rarity, I’m on my way right now actually.” and put her phone back in her pocket.

When she got to school, Fluttershy did as promised and went to grab Angels new collar. As they were putting it on, Rarity looked up and asked “Fluttershy sweetie, why are your eyes red?” Fluttershy just said “What?!” “Darling,I’ll brush Angels fur while you get some rest. We have a while before class begins” Rarity told her.

Fluttershy didn’t hesitate to go back to sleep. Rarity got her a blanket and told her she could sleep behind the counter. Once Fluttershy was asleep, she brushed out Angel Bunny’s fur carefully. Rarity then called everyone for a group chat to explain what was going on with Fluttershys eyes.

The girls all panicked instantly. “What do I do?!” yelled Twilight. They tried to calm her but they just couldn’t do it. Fluttershy woke up after the meeting was done to find that she had longer nails, and Rarity flipped out and got her something with long sleeves to cover it.

Fluttershy went home that day and accidentally ripped a blanket with her nails. She had to bring it back to Rarity to get it fixed. “Darling, there is maybe something wrong.” Rarity said. “I know, Rarity, but I don’t know why it’s like that” Fluttershy replied. “Maybe it’s just part of your magic?” Rarity asked. “No, I don’t think so.” Fluttershy responded.

Fluttershy went to school the next day, wondering whether she would be ok. As she walked through the halls, she noticed Lyra and Bon Bon standing near the lockers. She had no idea what came over her, but she walked up to them, removed her own sleeves, and started clawing Lyra. Bon Bon screamed and pulled Lyra away as she bled across the chest.

Fluttershy returned to normal just as a student ran to get the principal. She looked at her hands and saw blood. When Fluttershy looked up, she could see a very angry Bon Bon and a bleeding Lyra. Instantly panicking, Fluttershy tried to get away, but Bon Bon shoved her up against a locker.

“ FLUTTERSHY! WHAT HAVE YOU DONE!?” screeched Bon Bon as she held Fluttershys neck. “I-I don’t know! I didn’t mean to! I don’t know what happened....” whispered Fluttershy. “Oh sure you don’t, you lying BITCH!” Bon Bon said, rolling her eyes at Fluttershy.

“Principal Celestia!” yelled Scootaloo in a panic. “Fluttershy....she has claws! She scratched Lyra and Bon Bon has her against a locker!” This sent Celestia into a frenzy as she called for police and an ambulance. Soon, medical workers were at the school and taking Lyra to the ambulance outside.

Cops arrived and found Fluttershy being held down by multiple students who had witnessed the attack. They figured out fast that Fluttershy was in fact insane and so they called a restraint team to the school. Soon, there was a van with a cage parked out front and a whole group of people running at her.

They handcuffed her as fast as they could. They also gem gagged Fluttershy as she was pushed to the ground. She was soon sitting there, legs pushed up and tied together. As they dragged her away, Bon Bon screamed “FUCK YOU, FLUTTERSHY!” And then she was gone.

They put her into a cage and held her arms up, cuffing them in the air and slamming the cage door. They locked it and soon, Fluttershy had been put to sleep, ready for a 10 hour trip. They drove for 4 hours and then took a plane to the facility. Fluttershy was awoken by the group of people dragging her into the elavator.

She was tossed gently into a large room, and just sat there, until she noticed a girl, at the barred window, staring down into the nearest road. She had a white hospital dress, pink, curly hair, and light pink skin. She heard the girl speak “Ooh, humans!” and thought she knew the voice.

When it sang, she knew. It went like “ Better run, better run, soon your num-ber will come” She sang the next part, as the girl went quiet. “ So happy, so happy, won’t you make cupcakes with me!” The girl whipped around, with a look of shock and fear, a pair of bright blue eyes staring at Fluttershy.

“H-how did you know that song?!” the girl yelled in surprise. “Well,” said Fluttershy, “I couldn’t sleep a few years back, and so I was laying in my bed when I heard that song. The next day, my neighbor was gone and no one ever found her...”

“Whoops! Sorry, that was me!” said the strange girl. “What’s your name? I’m Pinkie Pie, full name Pinkamena Diane Pie, but please, call me Pinkie!” Fluttershy responded “The names Fluttershy, what are you here for?” “Well...I kinda killed people and...made them into cupcakes.” Pinkie told her.

“Oh, I clawed a girl and I think she’s dead. I have these weird nails and I don’t know why” Fluttershy replied. “What do you do for fun?”

“Oh, well I sometimes look out the window, sing that cupcake song, and talk to the nurses. Most of them are really cool!” said Pinkie. “Hey Pinkie?” “How long have you been here?”

Pinkie just said “Two years.”

“Oh my!” was all Fluttershy could muster. Suddenly, a nurse came by and knocked on the door. Pinkie, for some reason, got super excited and rushed to greet her. “Hi Nurse Groove!” Pinkie yelled. “Hello Pinkie, I heard you have a friend here?” she asked. Fluttershy stood up and put her hands behind her back, walking over to the nurse.

“Hi sweetie! You must be Fluttershy!” Nurse Groove could see Fluttershy shaking a little and moving away. “It’s ok honey, all of the nurses on this floor are super friendly.” Nurse Groove reached out her hand, only to see a claw reaching for her instead. “Gah!” she screamed as she jumped back.

“S-sorry...” whispered Fluttershy. “No,no, it’s alright I just got a little scared, that’s all!” said Nurse Groove.

“Hey Fluttershy” said Pinkie. “Blood Day is tommorow. It’s basically when all the mental patients get knives and a bunch of prisoners are thrown in here and we get to murder them! It’s really fun! But it’s bedtime, we should get some sleep!”

As Fluttershy was falling asleep, all she could hear was “Better run, better run, soon your num-ber will come”

She woke up the next morning to Pinkie at the now open cell door, holding a 7 inch knife. “Cmon, silly! Get a knife and go!” Fluttershy grabbed a small, 3 inch knife and ran out the door.

As she walked out, she felt scared seeing so much blood. But then, a girl ran by her, cutting her hip as she did so. Suddenly Fluttershy’s footsteps were pounding against the floor whilst she rushed to one of the prisoners. She grabbed her, yanked and spun her, and shoved her into the wall. Fluttershy then slit the girls throat with no remorse.

Now bloody, Fluttershy ran at another two people, one of which was pinning the other against the wall. Fluttershy stabbed her three times in the back, threw her aside, and cut the tip of the other girl’s tongue off. She then cut the girls vocal cords by shoving the knife down her throat.

She and Pinkie shoved a girl against the wall again, and cut her right down the middle, chest to belly button. As Pinkie ripped out all the organs, Fluttershy removed both her eyes and said to Pinkie “Why don’t we get outta here, we could do whatever we want!”

Pinkie agreed, so that night, when they were back in their cells, Fluttershy clawed her way out, and they scaled the wall, all the way to the ground. They swiftly escaped with no problems. They knew that if they didn’t put on disguises, they’d be caught. So they went and robbed a nearby clothing store, killing the 3 employees in the process. No one saw them do it, the only ones who did were dead!

Pinkie donned a light blue wig, looking kind of like Lyra. She also put on a brand new t-shirt and shorts, and Fluttershy did too. Fluttershy also dyed her hair light-ish red, and re-named herself to Rose. Pinkie, meanwhile, took the name of Stella. Fluttershy also dyed her fur light red, while Pinkie dyed hers a purple color.

They needed somewhere to live, so they went and took residence in a forest, close to town. The next morning, Fluttershy went to town with her knife and gun, and told Pinkie to wait outside. She climbed in through the back window, into the bathroom. She opened the door carefully, and stepped quietly into the hallway.

Fluttershy slipped down the hall, and opened the door to the childs room. She then shot the girl, and climbed back out the window. She met Pinkie outside and they ran to the woods. “How’d ya do?” Pinkie asked. “Didn’t leave a mark!” Fluttershy told her.

“I hope we aren’t found” Fluttershy said.

They never got caught...

Author's Note

Ah yes, my two favorite characters both being insane. Perfect. I’m scared for my sanity at this point. Running a youtube channel and an FIMFiction account gets stressful sometimes. If you’d like, check out my YouTube ( Corrupted Alien) if you can’t find me, look up Area 51 Gacha, find a vid for me, and check the comments. I also may do a reading on there! Not of my story, of course, but of a random one!