The Goth, The Bat, The Hipster, And You

You stare at the mare in goth attire as she approaches you. Was this really the same shy mare you came here to see? She sure didn't seem like the same one. As she gets closer, you look her over. She sure looks pretty sexy all in black.

"See something you like?" She asks in a deep, demanding tone. "You can look, but you better not touch. At least... not yet."

"Uh... Yes, ma'am?" You say questioningly.

She stands in front of you with a hand on her hip. "Tell me... How badly do you wanna fuck me?"

Pretty direct for Fluttershy, you think. "Um... I really wanna fuck you?"

"Pfff," the mare scoffs. "Is the big boy scared of little old me?"

"You are being pretty intimidating right now..." you point out as you just don't know how to respond to any of this.

"Pathetic," the mare groans, before turning her back to you and moving her tail to the side. "Why don't you make yourself useful?" She asks, though it sounds more like a demand. She then places her hand on her butt and pulls her cheek aside so you can see her tight butt hole. "Make me feel good and I may let you fuck me with that big cock of yours." Without hesitation, you grab her ass and lean in, about to start licking when she pulls away. "I said no touching," she orders. "Try again."

You stare at her for a second before placing your hands on the couch. You then wait for her to press her crack to your mouth before you start licking. You start with a rimjob before you push your tongue inside, licking around the inner walls of her anus. As you do, you hear her groan deeply.

"That's it, big boy," she coos. "Lick my ass." She then shakes her butt up and down and you can feel her ass jiggle against your face. "Do you like my ass?"

You pull back and smile. "Oh, yeah."

Fluttershy hums and looks over her shoulder at you with half-lidded eyes. "Good boy. Now, grab it and eat it."

Smirking, you grab her butt and dive in, licking all around inside the hole before giving her butt a hard slap. You hear her grunt and let out a deep moan. Pulling out you give repeated upward licks to her crack before pulling back to give her butt another slap.

"How much do you like my ass?" The goth mare asks you as she presses her butt to your chest.

"I-I really like it," you reply. "It's nice and... grabbable?"

"Grabbable?" She asks with a scoff. "That's the best you got?"

You shrug. "I mean, it's... great for smacking. Nice and bubbly and bouncy. Plus you have a deliciously tight hole back here."

She smirks at that. "Much better. I guess you can be trained." Lowering her butt even more, she presses her crack to your shaft and starts hotdogging you. "Would you like to fuck my ass?"

You let out a soft gasp as you feel her butt move up and down against your cock. "Of course I would. Why would you even ask that?"

"I like to hear you say it," Fluttershy says, before standing up and turning to face you. "But, you have to work harder for that," she says, before looking down at her own body. "Maybe, I'll make you lick my pussy next..." You smile and lean in to start, but she lifts her foot up and places it on your chest, pushing you back. "Ah ah... I think that's still too good for you. Get on the floor."

As she removes her foot, you slide to the floor, getting on your knees. Fluttershy then takes a seat on the couch and wiggles her toes at you. You stare up at her as you position yourself in front of her. You keep looking in her eyes as you pick up her right foot with both hands and give the toes a kiss. Taking her other foot, you bring it up next to her right one and ran your tongue back and forth across all ten toes.

"That's it..." Fluttershy moans, squeezing her tits. "Your tongue feels good on my toes... Maybe you are ready for my pussy..." You keep licking her toes before she pulls her right foot away and presses the sole to your face. "Mmm... Your face beneath my foot turns me on... Now, start eating," she says as she spreads her legs.

Smiling, you sit up and scoot forward so you're up against the couch. Leaning in, you give her wet slit a sniff. You look up at her as you stick out your tongue. Pressing it to her pussy, you give a long, slow lick. She lets out a soft moan and grips her tits a little harder. She seems to like it. You then continue to lap away at her marehood, enjoying the taste as you heard the mare try her best not to let out loud moans. It seems that sweet Fluttershy was having a hard time staying in character.

Going further, you push your tongue inside and lick around. It's such a nice contrast from her anus. This hole is very wet and very sweet and you feel like you could lick it for hours. Placing your hand above her crotch, you use your thumb to rub her clit, making her moan even more. You watch her tilt her head back and pant heavily. It isn't long before she wants to change places again. This time, it was for some real fun.

"Sit on the couch," she tells you, standing up and stepping aside as she continues to rub herself. "I need you inside me, big boy," she pants, clearly super aroused.

You get up and take a seat on the couch once more, before the mare quickly straddles your lap. She then lifts her butt up before bringing her pussy down on your cock with a loud moan and wet slap. You, too, let out a moan when you feel her warm pussy squeeze your cock. You grab her by the hips and lean in, kissing her neck. She moans out and grabs the back of your head before she begins bouncing up and down.

To finally have the shy mare you've been crushing on riding your cock feels amazing. Her tight, wet walls squeezing your shaft as she moved up and down. She must be extremely aroused, because your dick has a nice sheen of juices and, every time she went up, you see strings of her juice connecting her pussy to your rod. Then, suddenly, she lifts up her left breast and pulls your face to it. You take the hint and start sucking on her nipple.

"Don't cum yet..." the goth mare warned with a deep moan.

"B-But, I'm so close..." you grunt as the mare slams down harder and harder. "Ever since you deepthroated me."

The mare rolled her eyes and pulls you more into her breast so your face sinks into her mound. "Just don't fucking cum," she orders you again.

She continues to ride you for a few more minutes, her moans increasing before she pulls off. She stays hovering above your cock as she quickly rubs herself, before moaning loudly as she sprays your pole with her juices. It looks like a waterfall pouring from her pussy and coating your shaft. The feeling of it hitting your stiff skin is almost enough to make you blow your load. But, you manage to hold off.

"Good boy," Fluttershy coos, sitting on the couch and using her feet to squeeze your cock. "Don't cum..." she moans again, giving you a footjob.

Now, it's starting to be a little too much for you and you feel your orgasm nearing the tip. Trying to hold back now seems futile as her soft feet feel just way too good. It doesn't help when she moves her right toes the tip of your cock to rub the head. What's the worst that could happen by cumming now? Would she actually stop fucking you? Or, would there be another punishment. You're curious either way and decide to just give up. Not able to hold back any more, you let it out.

You hear her gasp as strings of cum shoot up between her toes and lands all over her feet. It's a pretty big load as you've been holding back for a bit now, and you manage to cover a decent amount of her right foot. You can see your cum between her toes and all over the top.

"Oops," you say jokingly, looking at her. "Guess I couldn't... hold back anymore..."

The mare is staring at you, eyes so narrowed they're almost closed. She doesn't look amused. "You just fucking came all over my foot," she says. "Guess that means our time's up. But, before I go..." She then lifts her right foot to your face. "Lick it clean before I leave."

You stare at her before looking at her foot... with your cum on it. "Um... Do I have to?"

"I told you not to cum, but you did anyways," the mare says with an irritated sigh. "Now, clean it up."

Taking a deep breath, you nod and take her foot in your hands. Leaning in, you begin to clean off the top with your tongue. Once it was clean, you begin to lick between her toes. You've never tasted your own cum before and you're surprised by how salty and tasteless it is. Once the foot's clean, you pull back just as Fluttershy gets to her knees and leans in to kiss you. You moan out when you feel her tongue licking all over yours, trying to get the cum you just licked up.

When she pulls away, she gives you a devious smirk. "Stay right there, big boy..." she says as she gets up. "I have something else for you..."

"Wh-What about your ass?" You ask, making her look over her shoulder as she walks away.

"Just wait..." she coos. "While I'm away, try getting hard again. I want you to be nice and stiff for when I return..."

You watch her butt jiggle and sway as she walks away, leaving you alone again. Leaning back on the couch, you look down at your messy cock. It's still covered in her juices from when she burst all over you. Letting out a sigh, you attempt to get hard again and catch your breath. It's pretty easy to become aroused in this situation, but you soon feel nervous when you see the mare come back down the stairs.

She doesn't have any of her make-up or black clothing on. But, she does look different. More bat-like. Her ears are bat ears and her wings are bat wings. Not to mention she has bat fangs now and her hair looks messy. She just grins at you at reaches up to a light switch and flicks it, turning the lights off in the room. Things are about to get wild...