The Goth, The Bat, The Hipster, And You

by Pinkamena666

Rating: mature
Tags: Romance, Fluttershy, Porn, Sex, Profanity, Alternate Universe, Human, Anthro, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Second Person, Fetish
Length: 7981

Fluttershy asks you to come over for a second opinion on some clothes she bought. When one of them rips and exposes her, you confess your feelings to her and she reciprocates. However, you soon realize she's way more kinky than you thought...

If you thought that Futashy And You needed absolutely no futa, then this is for you!

Fluttershy asks you to come over for a second opinion on some clothes she bought for a night out with the girls. When one of them rips and exposes her, you confess your feelings to her and she reciprocates. However, the story doesn't end there as you soon realize she's way more kinky than you originally thought...

Contains: Large Breasts, Multiple Orgasms, Role Play, Rough Sex, Sub/Dom

Same universe as The Sub, The Dom, The Emo, The Psycho, The Sorceress, And You

Published 2020-05-26 01:20:01 UTC
Last updated 2021-01-28 20:46:34 UTC

Fluttershy

Author's Note

I had an idea for a fic called The Many Faces Of Futashy and thought that maybe my readers would like something not involving futa for once. So, I took that basic concept and merged it with the style of The Big One and Futashy And You to get this! A second-person non-futa Fluttershy clopfic where she has sex with you!

I also wanted to upload this with all four chapters completed, but I hate waiting. Just know that I will be working on this one for the next couple days as it is fresh in my mind.

Fluttershy

You arrive at Fluttershy's cottage to hang out. She had invited you over the day before and there was no way you'd turn down her offer. After all, you have wanted to ask her out for quite some time, but you never found the right moment to do so. Now, was your time! As of right now, you are stepping up to the front door. Knocking on it, you take a step back and wait.

After a brief moment, the door opens as the yellow pegasus smiles at you. She's wearing a long sweatshirt that hangs past her crotch, hiding most of her shorts which made you, at first, think she was only wearing a sweatshirt. Another feature you particularly enjoyed were her enormous breasts. They must've been F or G-cups at least. Maybe even bigger. She's also wearing nothing on her feet.

"Glad you could make it," she said before heading inside.

"So, you needed a second opinion on something?" You ask her as you enter and close the door behind you.

"Yes," the mare replies, walking over to the couch where she had laid out some clothes. "I'm going out with the girls tomorrow and we have to get dressed up. I want whatever I pick to be a surprise so I'd like to see what you think."

"Oh," you say with a light smile. "I could do that, yeah..."

The mare gives you a smile in return and takes the clothes. "Be right back," she says as she heads off to the bathroom.

You take a seat on the couch and wait. It isn't too long before the mare returns. Now, she's wearing a long whit dress with thin shoulder straps and looks smooth to the touch. On her feet, she wore white high heels and knee-high white socks.

"I was going for a white theme with this one," she explains. "I hope it's not too white?"

You look her over and smile. "That is a lot of the same color," you say with a light chuckle. "What else you got?"

"Oh. Yes," she said, walking off back to the bathroom. When she returns, she has on a tight red dress with no shoulder straps. On her feet, she had on red high heels and the same white knee-high socks. "How about this one?" She asks with a light strain in her voice.

"Uh... You okay?" You ask her, noticing her nipple bumps through her dress. "Is that... too tight?"

"Now that I'm wearing it..." Fluttershy begins with a blush. "it does seem a little too small..."

"Try on the next one, then..." you tell her, imagining how her tits must've been extremely squished in there.

As she turns to leave again, you both hear a loud rip before the dress falls to the floor. The mare freezes as her face turns red. She then lets out a loud squeal, drops to her knees, and tries to cover herself up. You look away to give her privacy but she also seems too embarrassed to get up. You could leave, but then later interactions between the two of you may be supremely awkward. Even if you helped cover her up, there would still be that tension. The only option was to go to her. Standing up, you slowly make your way over to her. When she sees you approaching, she blushes hard and squeezes herself tighter.

"D-Don't look!" She squeaks shyly.

You kneel down beside her and keep your eyes on her face. When she sees you looking at her, she lets out a quiet whimper of embarrassment. "Fluttershy..." you begin. "There's something I've wanted to tell you for a long time... Never knew the right time to say it, but..." You have her attention now. "Hopefully this makes this situation less awkward, but... I've sort of... had a crush on you for a while now..."

The mare stares at you for a few seconds before responding. "R-Really?"

You nod. "I think you're the sweetest mare I know and I would love to gout with you. And, if there's any way I can help you relax right now, just let me know. Okay?"

Fluttershy continues to stare at you with a blush. "U-Uh... Wow... Um..."

"I'd like to try something," you say suddenly. "If you refuse, I'll stop..."

Before the mare could ask, you put your hand on her cheek and lean in to kiss her. Keeping your eyes open, you see her go wide-eyed in response but she makes no attempt to push you away. After another second, or two, you pull away to look her in the eyes. You then wait for her to say something.

For what felt like forever she just sat there, speechless. But, to your delight, she soon replies with, "W-Wow... That was..."

"Good?" You ask with a smile.

"That was my first kiss," she tells you with a huge blush. "You really... like me?" When you nod, she smiles. "Can you... do that again? But... longer? I-If you want..."

You chuckle and lean in again, kissing her on the lips. You wait for her to close her eyes before you close your own. This time, the kiss lasts for what felt like a minute. When the two of you part, Fluttershy bites her lip before looking down at her body.

"I-I kinda wished this happened differently..." she mutters.

"Me, too," you agree. "But, since I've already seen you naked... and, we're a couple now... would it make you feel better if... I was naked, too?"

"Oh, gosh," Fluttershy exclaimed cutely while covering her mouth with the hand she had over her crotch. Since she's wearing panties, and kneeling, you still can't see her marehood. "I-Isn't that a little fast?"

"These are unique circumstances," you say as you pull off your shirt and toss it aside. Fluttershy keeps her hand over her mouth as she eyes your body. She doesn't make a move to stop you, so you keep going and start slipping out of your pants. Once you had your pants off, you kicked them away and got to your knees beside the mare. "Just one thing left to do..." you say as you start to pull off your boxers.

"Those, too?" Fluttershy asks you. "But, we're both topless."

"True," you say with a light smile. "But, you have breasts. I don't. So, to make it even..." you say, slipping your boxers off.

When you do, Fluttershy looks away for a brief moment but then slowly looks down at your crotch. Reaching out, you gently take her left hand, which was just sort of hovering in front of her mouth. Letting out a soft gasp, she lets you take it and guide it to your cock. The second her fingers brush against your shaft, you hear her breath catch. Smiling at her, you bring her palm to your rod. As you do, you can feel her slowly wrap her own fingers around it.

"Oh, my..." she shudders, feeling your warm, throbbing cock.

As she feels your dick, you lean in and kiss her on the lips. She kisses back and starts to lightly stroke your meat pole, letting soft moans into your mouth. With your left hand, you reach over to gently pull her left hand off her right breast. Feeling your attempt to expose her, she moves her arm out of the way on her own. Smiling, you gently grip her tit. This makes her pull back from the kiss with a sharp gasp and large blush. She also pulls her hand off your cock out of surprise at the feeling.

Guiding her hand back to your shaft, you lift up her breast and wrap your lips around the nipple. The sudden sensation causes her to speed up her handjob. Letting out soft moans one after the other, her hand picks up speed the more aroused she is. With both tits fully exposed now, you grab both and squish them together, making the nipples rub together before sucking on both at once.

"Oh!" Fluttershy gasps, making you stop and look at her. "There's... something I'd like to show you, but... I may need to get used to... this," she says with a blush as she squeezes your cock.

You smile at her and nod, reach down to grab her panties. "Then, let's get these off."

The pegasus sat on her butt and lifted her legs, allowing you to pull the panties off. After you set them aside, she turns to you and climbs in your lap. You two lock eyes as her breasts squish up against your chest. Reaching down, you grip her ass as she leans in to kiss you.

While you make out, you feel your hot rod twitch against the mare’s hotter pussy. As it does, Fluttershy pulls away and looks down with a light gasp of surprise.

“Oh, it’s so eager...” She sighs, before rubbing her pussy against your shaft. “Can you hold it for me?” She asks, before placing her hands on your shoulders and raising her butt.

You can now feel her marehood dripping on your cock. Smiling, you nod and hold your rod in place. Fluttershy smiles back before lowering her wet slit to the tip of your dick. She takes a deep breath before dropping all the way down with a loud, wet slap.

You go wide-eyed as she lets out an even louder squeak. “A-Are you okay?” You ask, worried she may have hurt herself.

She panted heavily before looking at you with a breathy chuckle. “I’m great... It’s just I’ve wanted to feel this for so long...”

Without any more hesitation, the mare starts to move her hips up and down, letting out moan after moan. It is surprising to you how quick she was to have you inside you. Perhaps she was a tad more kinky than she initially appeared to be. After all, she let you strip naked in front of her before pulling her panties off. What was this mare really like once she got going?

You let your fingers roam over the smooth curvature of her butt, your right hand sliding to the base of her tail and gripping it. This makes her moan out a little louder as she starts to drool a little. With your free hand, you slip it to her butt crack and slip your middle finger inside her tight hole. The mare gasps sharply before resting her forehead on your left shoulder, moaning loudly and deeply.

"Oh, I'm... I'm getting close..." you warn the mare once you feel your cock twitch as if it was preparing to shoot its load.

When you say this, Fluttershy gasps and pulls her head back, stopping her movements. "Wait! There's one more thing I'd like to get used to before I show you the surprise..."

You pull your finger from her ass and give the bubbly ass a light pat. "What is it?"

The pegasus smiles and bites her lip before pulling off your cock. Sliding back, she got to her stomach with her face near your shaft. "I still need to get the hang of this..." she coos. Leaning in, she presses her face to where your rod met your balls and sniffs. "Mmm... So, that's what a real one smells like..." she hummed, implying she's seen fake ones. Has she used toys before?

She then sticks her tongue out and licks up your shaft to the tip, before wrapping her lips around the head. Instead of giving you a blowjob, she just starts taking more and more of your rod inside her mouth. Given that she was an anthro pony, she probably didn't have a gag reflex, but she still probably had to get used to the size. She places her hands on your inner thighs and begins going lower and lower. You feel your meat pop into her throat as she lets out a wet glug sound. Scooting closer, she props up her upper half to get a better angle. Closing her eyes, she continues to lube your shaft with a flood of her saliva while she attempts to take your whole cock.

"Holy shit," you moan, placing your hand on the back of her head.

She eyes you as best she can while she pushes herself to go lower until you feel her lips on the base of your rod. Reaching her destination, the mare stops and just swallows. After about a minute, she pulls off with a loud gasp, dozens of strings of saliva connecting your cock to her mouth. She giggles and wipes her mouth with her arm. "Mmm... You're a big boy," she gasps, catching her breath. "But, I can manage..." She then stands up and looks down at you. "Um... Take a seat on the couch, okay? I'll be right back." With that, she turns and heads upstairs to her bedroom.

Staring at her as she left, you can't believe what just happened. Looking down at your saliva-soaked dick, you let out a chuckle. "Wow..." You then get to your feet and head over to the couch, taking a seat. "So, what's the big surprise?" You ask out loud, not expecting an answer.

It took a little longer for the mare to return but, damn, was it worth the wait. When she came down the stairs, you first saw her bare feet with black-painted toenails, black lace leggings, black wrist sleeves and black-painted fingernails, pierced nipples, black collar, black-painted eyelids, and two metal studs in her left ear. When she arrives at the bottom of the stairs, she leans against the railing and crosses her arms. Even her facial expression seems more serious and depressing.

"Are you ready, big boy?" She asks in a deep, seductive tone.

You go wide-eyed at her sudden change in appearance and character. "Oh, boy..."

Fluttergoth

You stare at the mare in goth attire as she approaches you. Was this really the same shy mare you came here to see? She sure didn't seem like the same one. As she gets closer, you look her over. She sure looks pretty sexy all in black.

"See something you like?" She asks in a deep, demanding tone. "You can look, but you better not touch. At least... not yet."

"Uh... Yes, ma'am?" You say questioningly.

She stands in front of you with a hand on her hip. "Tell me... How badly do you wanna fuck me?"

Pretty direct for Fluttershy, you think. "Um... I really wanna fuck you?"

"Pfff," the mare scoffs. "Is the big boy scared of little old me?"

"You are being pretty intimidating right now..." you point out as you just don't know how to respond to any of this.

"Pathetic," the mare groans, before turning her back to you and moving her tail to the side. "Why don't you make yourself useful?" She asks, though it sounds more like a demand. She then places her hand on her butt and pulls her cheek aside so you can see her tight butt hole. "Make me feel good and I may let you fuck me with that big cock of yours." Without hesitation, you grab her ass and lean in, about to start licking when she pulls away. "I said no touching," she orders. "Try again."

You stare at her for a second before placing your hands on the couch. You then wait for her to press her crack to your mouth before you start licking. You start with a rimjob before you push your tongue inside, licking around the inner walls of her anus. As you do, you hear her groan deeply.

"That's it, big boy," she coos. "Lick my ass." She then shakes her butt up and down and you can feel her ass jiggle against your face. "Do you like my ass?"

You pull back and smile. "Oh, yeah."

Fluttershy hums and looks over her shoulder at you with half-lidded eyes. "Good boy. Now, grab it and eat it."

Smirking, you grab her butt and dive in, licking all around inside the hole before giving her butt a hard slap. You hear her grunt and let out a deep moan. Pulling out you give repeated upward licks to her crack before pulling back to give her butt another slap.

"How much do you like my ass?" The goth mare asks you as she presses her butt to your chest.

"I-I really like it," you reply. "It's nice and... grabbable?"

"Grabbable?" She asks with a scoff. "That's the best you got?"

You shrug. "I mean, it's... great for smacking. Nice and bubbly and bouncy. Plus you have a deliciously tight hole back here."

She smirks at that. "Much better. I guess you can be trained." Lowering her butt even more, she presses her crack to your shaft and starts hotdogging you. "Would you like to fuck my ass?"

You let out a soft gasp as you feel her butt move up and down against your cock. "Of course I would. Why would you even ask that?"

"I like to hear you say it," Fluttershy says, before standing up and turning to face you. "But, you have to work harder for that," she says, before looking down at her own body. "Maybe, I'll make you lick my pussy next..." You smile and lean in to start, but she lifts her foot up and places it on your chest, pushing you back. "Ah ah... I think that's still too good for you. Get on the floor."

As she removes her foot, you slide to the floor, getting on your knees. Fluttershy then takes a seat on the couch and wiggles her toes at you. You stare up at her as you position yourself in front of her. You keep looking in her eyes as you pick up her right foot with both hands and give the toes a kiss. Taking her other foot, you bring it up next to her right one and ran your tongue back and forth across all ten toes.

"That's it..." Fluttershy moans, squeezing her tits. "Your tongue feels good on my toes... Maybe you are ready for my pussy..." You keep licking her toes before she pulls her right foot away and presses the sole to your face. "Mmm... Your face beneath my foot turns me on... Now, start eating," she says as she spreads her legs.

Smiling, you sit up and scoot forward so you're up against the couch. Leaning in, you give her wet slit a sniff. You look up at her as you stick out your tongue. Pressing it to her pussy, you give a long, slow lick. She lets out a soft moan and grips her tits a little harder. She seems to like it. You then continue to lap away at her marehood, enjoying the taste as you heard the mare try her best not to let out loud moans. It seems that sweet Fluttershy was having a hard time staying in character.

Going further, you push your tongue inside and lick around. It's such a nice contrast from her anus. This hole is very wet and very sweet and you feel like you could lick it for hours. Placing your hand above her crotch, you use your thumb to rub her clit, making her moan even more. You watch her tilt her head back and pant heavily. It isn't long before she wants to change places again. This time, it was for some real fun.

"Sit on the couch," she tells you, standing up and stepping aside as she continues to rub herself. "I need you inside me, big boy," she pants, clearly super aroused.

You get up and take a seat on the couch once more, before the mare quickly straddles your lap. She then lifts her butt up before bringing her pussy down on your cock with a loud moan and wet slap. You, too, let out a moan when you feel her warm pussy squeeze your cock. You grab her by the hips and lean in, kissing her neck. She moans out and grabs the back of your head before she begins bouncing up and down.

To finally have the shy mare you've been crushing on riding your cock feels amazing. Her tight, wet walls squeezing your shaft as she moved up and down. She must be extremely aroused, because your dick has a nice sheen of juices and, every time she went up, you see strings of her juice connecting her pussy to your rod. Then, suddenly, she lifts up her left breast and pulls your face to it. You take the hint and start sucking on her nipple.

"Don't cum yet..." the goth mare warned with a deep moan.

"B-But, I'm so close..." you grunt as the mare slams down harder and harder. "Ever since you deepthroated me."

The mare rolled her eyes and pulls you more into her breast so your face sinks into her mound. "Just don't fucking cum," she orders you again.

She continues to ride you for a few more minutes, her moans increasing before she pulls off. She stays hovering above your cock as she quickly rubs herself, before moaning loudly as she sprays your pole with her juices. It looks like a waterfall pouring from her pussy and coating your shaft. The feeling of it hitting your stiff skin is almost enough to make you blow your load. But, you manage to hold off.

"Good boy," Fluttershy coos, sitting on the couch and using her feet to squeeze your cock. "Don't cum..." she moans again, giving you a footjob.

Now, it's starting to be a little too much for you and you feel your orgasm nearing the tip. Trying to hold back now seems futile as her soft feet feel just way too good. It doesn't help when she moves her right toes the tip of your cock to rub the head. What's the worst that could happen by cumming now? Would she actually stop fucking you? Or, would there be another punishment. You're curious either way and decide to just give up. Not able to hold back any more, you let it out.

You hear her gasp as strings of cum shoot up between her toes and lands all over her feet. It's a pretty big load as you've been holding back for a bit now, and you manage to cover a decent amount of her right foot. You can see your cum between her toes and all over the top.

"Oops," you say jokingly, looking at her. "Guess I couldn't... hold back anymore..."

The mare is staring at you, eyes so narrowed they're almost closed. She doesn't look amused. "You just fucking came all over my foot," she says. "Guess that means our time's up. But, before I go..." She then lifts her right foot to your face. "Lick it clean before I leave."

You stare at her before looking at her foot... with your cum on it. "Um... Do I have to?"

"I told you not to cum, but you did anyways," the mare says with an irritated sigh. "Now, clean it up."

Taking a deep breath, you nod and take her foot in your hands. Leaning in, you begin to clean off the top with your tongue. Once it was clean, you begin to lick between her toes. You've never tasted your own cum before and you're surprised by how salty and tasteless it is. Once the foot's clean, you pull back just as Fluttershy gets to her knees and leans in to kiss you. You moan out when you feel her tongue licking all over yours, trying to get the cum you just licked up.

When she pulls away, she gives you a devious smirk. "Stay right there, big boy..." she says as she gets up. "I have something else for you..."

"Wh-What about your ass?" You ask, making her look over her shoulder as she walks away.

"Just wait..." she coos. "While I'm away, try getting hard again. I want you to be nice and stiff for when I return..."

You watch her butt jiggle and sway as she walks away, leaving you alone again. Leaning back on the couch, you look down at your messy cock. It's still covered in her juices from when she burst all over you. Letting out a sigh, you attempt to get hard again and catch your breath. It's pretty easy to become aroused in this situation, but you soon feel nervous when you see the mare come back down the stairs.

She doesn't have any of her make-up or black clothing on. But, she does look different. More bat-like. Her ears are bat ears and her wings are bat wings. Not to mention she has bat fangs now and her hair looks messy. She just grins at you at reaches up to a light switch and flicks it, turning the lights off in the room. Things are about to get wild...

Flutterbat

You look around the pitch black room, trying to see if you can see... anything. You can’t. Then, as you start to get up to get the lights, a pair of red eyes drops down in front of you. You let out a yell of fright and jerk back.

“F... Fluttershy?” You ask the eyes.

“My friends call me Flutterbat,” the mare’s voice came, sounding slightly raspy.

Your eyes are starting to adjust to the darkness and you can make out the faint outline of the mare. “I think I have the hardest fear boner right now...” you mutter.

“Oh?!” Flutterbat exclaims. “Lemme see!” She then flips around upright before dropping to the floor with a very light, almost inaudible, thud. You see her red eyes get closer and closer to your cock. “Oh, it does look really hard...” You then feel something wet and long wrap around your shaft, coating it in what feels like saliva. Was that her tongue? It feels like it’s at least a foot long.

“Is that your tongue?” You ask her with a light moan.

You hear her giggle and feel her tongue pull away. “Yeah... Want a closer look?” She asks, before her eyes are directly in front of yours. “Open wide.”

Before you can say anything, you feel her tongue pressing against your lips. When you part them, you feel the long tongue slide into your mouth. The bat mare then leans in and kisses you, her tongue slipping down your throat. She also seems to be avoiding your uvula so you don’t accidentally throw up all over her. That’d be a mood killer. You then feel her tongue leave your throat and wrap around yours. Her tongue also seems wetter than normal.

When she breaks the kiss, you both let out a loud gasp as spit flies everywhere. "Mmm... I hope you have a lot of cum for me," she moans, leaning in and licking your neck. "I hope you can cum over and over and over..." Her eyes then dart in front of yours again. "and over..."

"Um..." you mutter softly. "I can try? I mean, it shouldn't be too hard, 'cause... you're pretty sexy..."

"Good..." the mare hissed, before getting up and standing beside you. Bending over, she places her hands on the back of couch. "Now, come take me."

Getting up, you reach over until you feel her butt. Grabbing it, you position yourself behind it and grip your cock. Pressing the tip to her pussy, you give a shove as you both let out a moan. Gripping her other butt cheek, you begin to thrust inside her. "Shit..." you moan. "You're so wet..."

"I'm always wetter... in this form," the mare moans out before letting out a deep grunt. "Oh, fuck, yeah... Fuck me harder!"

You chuckle softly and grip her ass tighter, adding more power to your thrusts. After about every ten thrusts, you give her ass a hard smack. "Damn, you're so fucking hot," you grunt, feeling her pussy leak all over your rod and balls.

"Pull on my tail!" The mare moans out. "Fucking yank it!"

You still can't believe how lewd and vulgar she's being all of a sudden, but it's probably the sexiest thing you've ever experienced. You do as told and grab her tail with your left hand, pulling back on it hard while you continue your hard thrusts. "You like it rough?" You ask, smacking her ass again with your right hand. "You like it fucking rough?"

"Oh, I like it fucking rough!" Fluttershy moans out loudly, before quickly standing up and knocking you back. She then grabs you and pushes you onto the couch in a seated position. Turning her back to you, she squats a little and slams her pussy back down on your cock. She then begins to repeatedly lift her butt and slam it back down. "Fuck, yes!"

You grunt, too, and watch her ass bounce in front of you. Deciding to take it further, you stand up and knock her to the floor. Getting to your knees, you push your way inside her again and begin fucking her doggy-style. She seems to enjoy the roughness as she moans deeper and grunts heavily.

"Don't forget... to cum..." she moans. "I wanna feel your jizz deep inside me!"

You smile and ram your rod deep inside her, staring to empty your balls of all your cum. As soon as you do, you hear the bay mare moan out deeply, her bat wings flicking at the air a couple times. Gripping the base of her tail, you give one hard thrust inside her. You feel her pussy spasm and squeeze your cock, before you feel a flood of cum pour from the wet hole.

Pulling out, you let your cum and more of her juices pour out. "Damn..." you sigh. "You really wanted that."

"Mmm..." she moaned, slowly waving her ass at you. "There's another hole..."

You smirk and use the fingers on your right hand to wipe the cum off your shaft. "If you want me to fill your ass with more cum, I'll need you to get me hard again," you say, sitting back down on the couch and spreading your legs. "Kneel in front of me."

The bat mare looks over her shoulder at you with a grin, before turning around and crawling towards you. "What does master want me to do?" She coos, her tits dragging across the floor.

You wipe more cum off your cock with your fingers. "Open your mouth and stick out your tongue."

Fluttershy smiles sensually and then slowly opens her mouth, letting her dripping wet tongue hang out. Her sharp fangs look dangerous but you had complete trust in her. You reach out and rub her tongue with your sticky fingers before sliding them in her mouth. She moans and wraps her lips around your fingers, sucking on the digits and licking all over them with her tongue. The whole time, she stares up into your eyes.

When she finishes, she parts her lips a little. You pull your fingers out and rub her cheek. She nuzzles your palm and keeps her lips parted slightly so you can see her fangs. Smiling at her, you scratch behind her left ear, making her smirk and tilt her head a little for you. Pulling your hand away, you use your left hand to pull your cock up so it rests on your belly. You then move your right hand from the bat mare's cheek to the back of her head and pull her face into your balls.

You hear her moan before she starts sniffing deeply. The mare then opens her mouth and licks at your nuts a few times before sucking on your right orb. She eyes you with a smirk before you feel her poke your nut with her fangs. You jump a little at the feeling, before realizing she was only screwing with you. Of course she was. This was still Fluttershy.

The mare giggles at your reaction and continues sucking your balls. Moving to the center again, she nuzzles your sack and then licks up to the base of your rod. You push your cock forward so it falls on her face with a light, wet slap. She moans and licks up your flaccid cock, letting the tip rest on her tongue with her fangs hovering just above the skin. She gives a wink before diving forward, her lips kissing your crotch. As she swirls her tongue around your rod, you feel it get harder and push its way down her throat. The mare lets out a light cough as her throat bulges a little.

When you're fully hard again, she begins bobbing her head. Moving to your tip until your tip almost leaves her mouth, she slams her mouth back down to the base of your shaft. Repeating this over and over brings you closer and closer to another orgasm.

"I'm gonna... fucking... cum again..." you moan out, making the mare exhale deeply.

You feel her breathing intensify as her throat and mouth heats up. Her tongue also begins to salivate more at the thought of you cumming in her mouth. She places her hands on your inner thighs and speeds up her movements. With each thrust forward, Fluttershy lets out a lewd GLURK sound as spit runs down her chin.

It isn't much longer before you let out a grunt and start unleashing your load down your throat. The second you start cumming, the mare pulls back so your rod sat on her tongue, your cum filling her mouth. Soon, though, your cum begins to burst from her lips and run down her chin. She cups her hands beneath her mouth to catch your cum as more and more leaks out. By the time you finish, she has cum all down her chin, neck and breasts with a small pool in her palms.

When you pull out, Fluttershy closes her mouth and swallows a few times to get all the cum down. Once her mouth is empty, she takes a deep breath before licking up the cum in her hands. Leaning back, she tilts her head back and swallows. You can see your cum all over her neck and breasts. Then, if she couldn't get any sexier, she rubs the cum still on her hands all over her belly before rubbing in the cum on her tits as if it was body lotion.

"You came a lot for me," she moans. "Was it something I did?"

You chuckle and let out a deep sigh. "Well... You're just so... damn... sexy..."

The bat giggles and licks her lips before grabbing your knees. Pulling herself up, she leans in close to your neck and gently runs her fangs across your skin. You lean your head back and relax, letting the mare do what she wants. She then licks up to your ear and blows a breath of warm air. "Mmm... I think it's time you met my other friend..."

"Y-You have another personality?" You ask her. "But, I didn't fuck your ass, yet."

"Oh, save it for the next one," the mare coos. "You'll want to punish her for being a bratty, disobedient girl. Teach her manners by ripping her clothes off and fucking her ass with your big, yummy cock."

"You want me to... get rough with you?" You ask, making sure you're hearing correctly.

Fluttershy nods before kissing you on the lips. "Be rough with me." She kisses you again. "Teach me a lesson." Another kiss. "Make me behave. Make me yours." She kisses you three more times before pulling back and walking away.

"Um... O-Okay!" You call after her. "I will... fuck the shit outta you!"

"Good!" You hear her call back. "Make me your bitch!"

You chuckle softly and relax on the couch. She takes even longer this time to get ready, probably because clothes are involved. When you hear her coming back down the stairs, you stare at what she looks like now; a total hipster. She's wearing a baggy purple sweater, tight pink shorts that barely reach her knees, a sea green scarf with white polka-dots, magenta glasses, and a purple hat with a white strip.

"The fuck?" You ask, watching her turn the lights on.

She has a plain look on her face before she turns and heads into the kitchen. When she doesn't come back out, you decide she wants to move the fun in there. Getting up, you make your way towards the kitchen, ready for the next round of fun...

Author's Note

Next chapter currently at 388 words

Hipstershy

When you enter the kitchen, you see the mare getting a cup of coffee from the coffee machine before going to sit at the kitchen table. She lets out a sigh and scoots back in her chair to put her feet up on the table. You walk up to her and look her over. When you do, she eyes you before eyeing your dick.

"Ugh, why is your dick showing?" The mare asks in a valley-girl tone.

“Because, I’m naked,” you say, before coming up with a plot in your head. “Why don’t you get your feet off my table?”

The yellow mare hesitates, probably trying to figure out what you’re up to. When she seems to understand, she lets out a scoff.

“Like, what are you gonna do about it?” She asks, before taking a sip of her coffee.

You pull up a chair and sit down. “Well, I guess if your feet are on my table, then your feet are now mine,” you say, grabbing her feet. You pull them off the table and bring them to your cock.

“Oh, like... gross...” the mare gasps, feeling your sticky dick on the soles of her feet. “Why is it so sticky?”

“Don’t worry about it,” you say, moving your hips. “Just stroke it with your feet.”

“Ugh,” Fluttershy groans. “You’re sooo disgusting, it’s almost totally unreal...”

“If you’re gonna be this disobedient,” you say with a smirk. “I guess I’ll just have to punish you.” You reach out and grab her scarf before pulling her towards you. Catching her in your arms, you gently lay her across your lap. “Time to teach you a lesson...”

“Wh-What are you doing?” She asks, squirming a little.

Gripping her shorts, you pull them down to her knees to expose her butt. “Giving you a spanking,” you say, before slapping her ass.

Fluttershy lets out a sharp gasp before you spank her again. Reaching underneath her with your other hand, you rub your sticky rod with two fingers before reaching over and putting them in her mouth. You then spank her again, making her gasp and groan. You can feel her tongue trying not to lick at your fingers, as if the real Fluttershy wants your cum but her current persona doesn’t.

Once her ass is nice and red, you stop. Smiling, you slide your fingers from her butt to her crotch and rub a little. You feel drool leaking from the mare’s mouth as she moans softly. Deciding you really want entrance into her naughty womb, you grip her pants and pull them all the way off before tossing them aside.

“Alright, let’s get you in my lap,” You day as you help her to her feet.

“Why, so you can stick that disgusting thing inside me?” Fluttershy asks with a scoff as she pulls away from you. “I think I’ll pass. Now, where’s my pants?”

You chuckle and grab her by the hips, spinning her around. “You haven’t received your punishment yet.”

“What?!” The mare gasps, looking over her shoulder at you. “But, the spanking!”

“That was a warmup,” You reply as you align your rod to her butt hole. “This is the real punishment.”

You slide your way inside her tight hole, making her let out a prolonged deep groan. Thank god your rod is still smeared with cum and juices, otherwise it may have hurt the mare a little. You grab the base of her tail and gave her ass a smack as you continue to slid your cock back and forth. You watch the mare rest her cheek against the tabletop and moan as you pound away at her backside. Her hands struggle to find something to hold onto, but she only manages to knock a candlestick holder onto the floor.

"You're so tight back here," you grunt out, feeling her tight anal walls squeeze your shaft. You slide your right hand to her right thigh and grip her tail tighter before you begin to pick up pace. Ï could fuck this ass for hours."

The mare squeaks and lets out a moan with every one of your thrusts. "Do-on't yo-ou da-are," she weakly threatens.

You feel like honoring her wish and keep up your thrusts for a bit longer before you ram hard inside her ass, your cum filling up her hole and spurting back out around your cock. As you feel her backdoor overflow, you hold her butt firm against your crotch. When you are done, you slid your way free from her hole and let your cock dangle between your legs. You pull her off the table and gently lower her to her knees. She is still panting heavily as her ass leaks cum all over the floor.

You step up beside her and pull her hat off, setting it on the table. You then reach down with your left hand and gently turn her head to the right as she looks up at you, her mouth open and tongue hanging out. You give her a smile and take your cock in your right hand and stroke gently. When it starts to get hard again, you push it inside her gaping mouth. She doesn't resist as she moans upon its entry. You feel her tongue lick around your shaft as she obediently cleans it for you.

You then grip the sides of her head and begin to fuck her throat with fast and hard thrusts. She makes lewd glurk and gluck sounds as spit runs down her chin and splashes your crotch. She sticks her tongue out and blushes hard as she lets you use her mouth as a fucktoy. She must really trust you if she's letting you use her like this. You smile down at her and pull out. Reaching down, you help her to her feet and turn her to face you. Gripping her ass, you hoist her up onto the table and spread her legs.

"Just make it quick," she says with a blush, keeping her legs spread for you. You nod and reach out, undoing the buttons of her shirt and opening it up so her tits hang out. She lets out a disgusted scoff. "Fucking pervert."

You aren't sure if it was her use of pervert or her vulgarity, or both, but it makes you instantly rock hard. Perhaps she knew that would get you going and it was on purpose? Either way, you're nice and hard again. You hold her hips and shove your wet cock into her pussy, making you let out a grunt as the mare moans with a squeak. You begin to quickly thrust into her as you watch her tits bounce. The mare reaches back and presses her hands against the tabletop.

"Oh, fuck..." the mare moans, panting and moaning loudly as spit occasionally drips from her chin. She tilts her head back and swallows before panting more and more.

Leaning forward, you press your chest to hers and place your hands on the table near her butt. You then nuzzle her neck as you continue to ravage her pussy. You feel her legs loosely wrap around you as you kiss her skin. Pulling back from her neck, you grip her tits as you feel her pussy start to leak with juices. Leaning in, you wrap your lips around her left nipple and suck hard. This makes Fluttershy moan deeply as she splashes your crotch and balls with her juices.

Wanting to join her in an orgasm, you speed up and edge yourself to the edge before you ram all the way in. It isn't long before you start mixing your semen with her juices inside her pussy. Both of you moaning, press your face into her tit as her legs hug you tighter. When you both finish, her legs loosen up and you pull out, the mixture you both concocted inside pouring out onto the floor.

The mare pants heavily and weakly removes her glasses and pulls her scarf off, setting them on the table. A small smile spreads across her face before she leans in and kisses you on the lips. She slides off the table and stands in front of you before hugging you tightly. You kiss back before she pulls away with a blush.

"Thank you," she coos, throwing her arms around your shoulders. "That was amazing."

"It sure was," you say with a chuckle, seeing that Fluttershy was back to normal self.

Epilogue

After helping Fluttershy out of her top, you walk her over to the couch in the main room. She plopped down with a sharp gasp, making you worry slightly. You sit beside her on her right.

“You okay?” You ask, rubbing her leg.

“Mmm,” the mare replies with a nod as she smiles at you. “Stings a little bit, but... knowing that it’s because of you...”

Leaning over, you kiss her on the lips. “I think I love you, Fluttershy.”

The mare giggles with a blush. “Um... I love you, too.”

“Think I’ll be seeing your other selves again?” You ask, gently rubbing her left breast.

She moans softly with a smile. “If you want. Anyone in particular?”

You shake your head. “Surprise me.”

Blushing more, Fluttershy leans into you. “Okay.” Then, without warning, she turns and straddles your lap, her arms wrapping around you.

You chuckle and rest your hands on her butt. “Just make sure I get to see the sweet Fluttershy at least one a day, okay?”

The mare nods and kisses you on the lips. As your tongue wrestle for dominance, you feel her hand move to your rod. This mare was even more insatiable than you thought. It was perhaps a mixture of pent up sexual energy and happiness.

Once you’re hard, she slips your meat inside her pussy and begins to ride you. This continues for the next couple hours until the mare was too tired to continue. After your fifth orgasm, the pegasus collapses against you with soft, calm breaths.

You help her to her feet and lead her to her bedroom. Helping her lay down, your feet in bed beside her before pulling the covers up. Once you settle in, the mare slides up against you and puts her arm around you. You smile and do the same, the both of you cuddling until you fall asleep, wondering what was in store for you tomorrow...

To be continued in
Flutterbat And You