Are you an angel?

by PRlNCESS CADENCE

How it would have ended

Previous Chapter

This story has been cancelled. Everything that comes next is a legitimate spoiler for how the story would have ended. If you want to hold out hope that the story will be continued in the future, I wouldn’t recommend reading the next section, but I sincerely doubt that I will ever finish.

After Vignette tells Anon that she doesn’t want to be friends anymore, Anon tells Cozy Glow about Feather Bangs but keeps Vignette a secret from Cozy Glow and instead brings all of her problems to Silver Spoon, leaving out the part where Feather Bangs confessed his feelings to her. Anon and Silver Spoon have a cute little dating scene, and then Anon comes home to find that Cozy Glow wants to talk.

Cozy Glow reaffirms the question she asked earlier about how Anon would never do anything to hurt her, and then Cozy Glow announces that she has a crush on Silver Spoon, still unaware that Silver Spoon is currently dating Anon. After that, Anon starts to feel conflicted and begins hiding her feelings from Silver Spoon. Then, when Silver Spoon asks Cozy Glow if everything is alright with Anon, Cozy Glow lets her know that Feather Bangs confessed his feelings to her. While Silver Spoon is still in shock, Cozy Glow confesses her feelings and is told, “I’ll need some time to think about it.”

Then, when Silver Spoon returns to Anon, both of them are suddenly feeling very awkward, neither one telling the other what they know. Silver Spoon, however, feels like the only reason that Anon is dating her is because she feels sorry for her and that Anon would be much happier dating Feather Bangs. Finally, Silver Spoon tells Anon about Cozy Glow’s confession and announces that she’d rather date her sister instead. The two break up.

Fast-forward to three weeks later. Cozy Glow and Silver Spoon have been dating, and Anon hasn’t been picking up her little sister from school. When Anon comes home, she goes straight to her room and stays there until school the next day. Then, once she realizes she’s at the end of her rope, she contacts Vignette Valencia and tells her to meet her at Sugarcube Corner.

Vignette is still hard-hearted at first, but once she sees Anon break down in front of her, they decide to put their fight behind them and make up. Anon explains that the reason she didn’t tell Vignette about her crush earlier was because Silver Spoon was really a nine year old girl. Vignette tells Anon that she understands and doesn’t judge her for hiding it from her. Anon, now filled with sudden confidence, tries to convince herself that she still has a chance with Silver Spoon and pulls her phone out to message her, but Vignette stops Anon at the last second and says, “I know you love her, but it’s over. It’s time to move on.”

Change perspectives to Silver Spoon. After a play date with Cozy Glow, Silver Spoon calls her friend Diamond Tiara. She tells DT about all the things that have been going on and how she still loves Anon. Diamond Tiara calls Silver Spoon an idiot for rushing into breaking up without asking Anon first. Silver Spoon asks what she should do, and Diamond Tiara tells her to be a good girlfriend to Cozy Glow for now.

Later, Cozy Glow mentions that she wants to talk with Anon. She tells her that Silver Spoon has been acting weird since the two of them started dating and asks if Anon has any advice. Anon realizes that this means she might have a shot with Silver Spoon after all, but puts her sister first and says, “Keep trying. Do your best.” Once Cozy Glow leaves, though, Anon begins to wonder if she made the right choice. That’s when Anon realizes that she isn’t doing her best either, and even if it ends up hurting her sister, the one thing she promised she would never do, she has to tell Silver Spoon the truth and give herself one last chance.

The next day, Anon waits by the park to pick up her sister from school just to find out Cozy Glow isn't there. She then gets a message from Cozy Glow saying that she went over to Silver Spoon’s house and immediately starts running as fast as she can. Finally, once she arrives at Silver Spoon’s house, she apologizes to Cozy Glow and proclaims her love for Silver Spoon. Silver Spoon cries tears of joy and tells Anon that she loves her back. Cozy Glow, meanwhile, cries about how they’ll never go back to normal and that she screwed everything up when she confessed to Silver Spoon, but Silver Spoon tells her that no matter what, she’ll always be Cozy Glow’s friend. As hurt as Cozy Glow is to lose her girlfriend, she inherently knows that she was much happier back when it was the three of them.

Fast forward nine years later. Anon is in a wedding dress with her sister in a brides maid outfit. Cozy Glow brags about how she was the one to introduce the two of them in the first place. Then, Silver Spoon walks down the aisle and the two of them share their first kiss. “See?” Silver Spoon says. “I told you I’d kiss you for real one day.”

Thank you to everyone who supported me in writing this story. I’m sorry that this was the best I could do.