The second story of this series takes place in the Canterlot Mental Home for the Criminally Insane, one of the Patients, named Fluttershy is one of the most mentally unstable patients after being overdosed with a drug that can make you see your worst fears by her crazy scientist Aunt who was using it in order to rid the world of all fear. The doctors said that there is so much of the drug pumping through her that it has become incurable, and the staff has labeled her as incurably insane. After cronies from Sombra, one of the biggest crime bosses in the city, give the doctors money in exchange for Fluttershy, as they want to find her Aunt's toxin so they can use it to get rid of competition, such as Tirek and Chrysalis, they lock her in a dark room full of flesh-eating flies and moths, as she had nyctophobia and severe insectophobia, but she then allows her phobia to consume her so she can face her fear and defeat it. After doing so and escaping from the room, she puts on more gothic attire and becomes Madame Fright. After one of the henchmen comes back, he notices that Fluttershy is gone, only for her to ambush him from behind and inject him with fear toxin, revealing Fluttershy in a more demonic form. Can Daydreamer defeat this new threat, while also facing her own personal demons?