Less than a year later, Comet and I, as well as the rest of those in our high school class, graduated. It was quite a big day for all of us, even though there were only 20 of us in the Class of 2025. Nevertheless, we were up on stage in front of all of our parents, relatives, friends, and others, everyone was clapping and cheering for us, we were all given our diplomas, and we were finally done with high school.

"And the best part is that now that a year is almost up, and we've been with the Deepwood Power Plant for all this time, and with us graduating now, we're finally eligible to potentially leave the basement furnace rooms, and work upstairs in the turbine hall, or even with the generators in the generator room! We might not have to work in the basement anymore!"

I agreed. "Yeah, you're right Comet. If we were working upstairs, it wouldn't be nearly as hot, we wouldn't be choking on coal dust, and the labor wouldn't quite be as backbreaking as it is now. However, that is of course assuming that they send up upstairs. Remember, everyone in the basement wants upstairs, but there's only a limited number of spaces. We're on that waiting list of sorts, but there's probably a lot of other guys ahead of us. I don't think that they'll be sending us upstairs anytime soon."

Comet sighed. "Yeah. Unfortunately, I have this nagging feeling that you're right, Arctic. But we can always hope."

"Yeah, we can."

Unfortunately though, I was right. While we were eligible to finally be moved upstairs to where the turbines, and the generators were, there were others that were higher than us in the pecking order who were sent upstairs, leaving Comet and I still down in the basement stoking the furnaces.

"Well, give it another 6 months or so", I told Comet over the roar of the furnace that I was stoking while he shoveled coal into it, "Then maybe it'll be our turn. Heck, maybe our superiors are even testing us to see how good of workers we are before moving us upstairs."

Comet sighed. "Yeah, maybe. But still though, it's just so hot, and hard to breathe down here, not to mention the fact that we're shoveling coal and stoking furnaces for up to 10 hours a day, 5, sometimes even 6 days a week!"

"Yeah, no kidding! I'm just glad that my sister Starry knows how to massage my muscles after I get home from work. That's the only reason that I'm not hurting the next day. Somehow she knows just how to massage all of the knots, aches, and pains right out of me."

"Wow. Donna does that for me, but she's not very good at it, so I still come to work with pains sometimes. And you still haven't found a marefriend yet, have you?"

I shook my head. "No, but now I have a sneaking suspicion that I know why."

"Do tell."

"I think that my Sisters have something to do with this. I'm not fully sure why, but for some reason, they keep looking at me like I'm supposed to be their mutual coltfriend, and I'm pretty sure that they've been scaring off all other mares and girls too."

Comet gave me a concerned look. "You might not be as crazy as you think, Arctic. Donna told me a few days ago that she'd heard from one of her friends that tried to flirt with you recently, only to be run off by one of your sisters....Dawn I think it was. Apparently, Dawn told her to stay away from you, or there would be trouble."

I was troubled by this revelation. I knew that I had to put a stop to this before it escalated any further, and I was planning on doing just that once I got home that night.

"That's....that's really not good Comet. I'll deal with this tonight when I get home, as this isn't good for anyone or anypony."

The rest of that day, I made sure to pace myself so that I would still have strength later to deal with my Sisters when I got home, and I really hoped that this whole issue could be resolved that night.

When I got home that night, I found my sisters in the living room watching TV. All of then got up and hugged me, even though I was still dirty from work, and I said that I needed to talk to them about something when I got back from taking a shower. They said that they'd wait, and I ran upstairs. After I got out of the shower though, I noticed that my work clothes, which I had left lying on the bedroom floor, were now suspiciously absent, and I knew where they'd gone.

"Well, at least I don't have to worry about my clothes not getting washed." I thought as I pulled on boxers, a T-shirt and a pair of sweatpants. "Now if only I can get the rest of this under control before it escalates any further. I mean yes, all of my Sisters are really cute, and perfect marefriend material, but we're siblings, so it needs to stop."

"Only because you're adopted!" The Little Devil reminded me.

"Adopted or not, it's still incest, and incest is wrong!" The Little Angel corrected him.

"Yes", I agreed, "Which is why this needs to stop, and stop now!" I then went back downstairs.

Sure enough, I could hear the washing machine running, and I knew that that was probably where my clothes went, so I went back to the living room. Sure enough, all 4 of my sisters were still there, and once I was by the couch, Stella confirmed that my clothes were in the washing machine.

"Well, thanks for that, Stella, but Girls, we really need to talk about something."

"What?" Cherry asked.

"We need to talk about your behavior as of recently."

"What do you mean, Arctic?" Starry asked.

I sighed. "While I can appreciate you guys helping me with my laundry, cooking for me, and especially you helping me massage my muscles after work, Starry, I was recently made aware by a Little Bird of some revelations that rather alarmed me. I was told that you Girls have been threatening other mares and girls who would try to flirt with me, or even ask me out....."

"That's because those girls and mares were sluts, Arctic!" Starry interrupted. "We didn't want them anywhere near you, so we chased them away!"

"All of them though?" I asked. "I heard that you chased away any mare or girl who got too close."

They all looked at each other, and shrugged.

I sighed. "Anyway, I've also noticed the...eh...predatory looks that you've all been giving me, which have REALLY made me uncomfortable, not to mention how touchy-feely you've all been getting with me, and how some of you have been sharing a bed with me, and for some reason wearing only your bikini instead of pajamas. I've also begun to notice more of my underwear going missing, only to later turn up in my room, despite me NOT sending it down with the laundry, or telling you to take them down, and several times I've noticed what seemed to be movement outside the bathroom door while I was in the shower." I then looked all around at my Sisters. "I'm not pointing any fingers, but Girls, this is REALLY f@#ked up here. You all need to leave me alone, leave other girls and mares alone, and find coltfriends for yourselves. Dote on them for a change, and not me. We're siblings. Yes, by adoption, but still siblings. Now I'm not saying that you don't have to dote over me at all anymore, but just try to limit it to laundry, cooking, and the occasional hug. So can you guys do that please?"

For a while, there was only silence. All of the Girls looked at each other, whispered among themselves for a few minutes longer, then Dawn spoke up.

"For the record, why have some of our dirty panties been going missing, only to have been found in your room, Little Brother?" She asked smugly. "We've also noticed you getting hard around us, and you never really complained before when we'd get all touchy-feely with you. Plus, you DID mutter to Starry that you wished that she wasn't your sister, as you really wanted to f@#k her. Right?"

And just like that, my ENTIRE speech about getting them to stop wholly collapsed around me. Somehow I should have known that they wouldn't go quietly with this, but I didn't think that they'd stoop as low as they did now. I tried to counter with, "This isn't about me, this is about you all! I'm not the one keeping you from getting coltfriends of your own!", but it fell on deaf ears.

Starry crossed her arms. "We don't WANT coltfriends of our own!"

"Yeah, we want YOU, Arctic!" Dawn whined.

"Plus, you're only BARELY our brother!" Stella added.

"I've tried to date again, but it hasn't worked out at all." Cherry said dejectedly. "Other guys just don't treat me like you do."

I slammed a hand over my face. Clearly this conversation wasn't going to go anywhere easily, but I knew that Mom was in the kitchen, so hopefully she would have answers for me. I then said something about going to the kitchen to get something to eat, and left. However, I failed to notice all 4 of my sisters smirking at me once my back was turned. They knew what was up, and that the time was growing very near for them.

Once I was in the kitchen, I said hi to Mom, and she heated up a plate of leftovers from dinner for me. There was fried chicken, mashed potatoes and gravy, green beans, buttermilk biscuits, and cream corn.

"Mmmm, this really hits the spot just like always, Mom. Thanks!" I then added a bit of salt from the black salt-shaker to my corn.

She smiled as she sat down at the kitchen table with a plate of her own. "You're welcome, Arctic. And what do you think of the orange juice?"

I looked at the glass of orange juice next to me. "Oh, it tastes a little bit different than usual. Not bad, but just a little bit different than usual."

"I made some of my own a little bit earlier today. I bought some oranges, and used the juice-press to make orange juice for all of us."

"Well, you certainly did a great job, Mom. It tastes great! You'll have to make it again sometime!"

She giggled a bit. "Yeah, I will, won't I?" She then got up from the table to put the pitcher of orange juice back into the fridge, as well as a small bottle of something back into one of the kitchen cabinets.

Once she sat back down at the table though, she looked directly at me. "Something on your mind, Hun? You were sure lecturing your sisters on something a little while ago."

I then sighed, and explained everything that had been happening with them. "I really don't think that they should be doing that, Mom, they're my Sisters. Adopted yes, but still, wouldn't that be considered incest? They need to find coltfriends of their own, and move past me!"

Scarlet seemingly thought long and hard about that. She'd seen at least some of what I'd been telling her, and now she was trying to come up with an answer for me. "Well, Arctic", she said at last, "Now that I think about it, yes, I have seen at least some of what your sisters have been doing, and I'll have a talk with them about it. However, please bear in mind that none of them want to hurt you, or see you hurt. They were chasing off those girls, and doing all those things for you because they care about you. I'll talk to them once we're done here though, and hopefully we can come to an understanding."

"Yeah, I hope so too Mom." I then finished my food, put my dishes in the dishwasher, and began to leave the kitchen.

"And you're off tomorrow, right Arctic?" Scarlet asked me.

I nodded sleepily. "Yeah. I'm off tomorrow, and the next day. Then I have to go back to work until Sunday." (Today was Monday).

"Ok. Hopefully we can do something fun."

"Maybe. Anyway, goodnight, Mom."

She hugged me. "Goodnight, Arctic."

I then walked through the living room, and hugged all of my Sisters. "Goodnight, Girls."

"Goodnight, Little Bro!"

I then walked upstairs, said goodnight to Maxi, as well as Sandy, and then went to bed myself. However, once I was asleep, Scarlet went to talk to the Girls.

"Did he use the black salt-shaker, Mom?" Starry asked.

"Why do you have to be so blatantly obvious about this?" Scarlet asked instead. "You're scaring the poor guy with your aggression!"

"We can't really help it!" Stella told her.

"Yeah, it's hard NOT to act like that around him, or chase off other potential rivals!" Dawn added.

"Such deviant little daughters I raised." Scarlet muttered.

"What was that, Mom?" Cherry asked.

"Nothing. Anyway, yes, he did use the black salt-shaker, but it'll take a while for it to work. Give it until tomorrow night, and then he'll need you."

The Girls all smirked, before hugging their Mom. "You're the best Mom ever!"

"Yeah, and the most tolerant too!" Cherry added.

Scarlet smirked. "Yeah, I know Girls. Just be careful. This could end badly if Arctic finds out too early!"

The Girls all promised to be careful, and they then began to discuss their plan for the next night.

The next afternoon, I was chopping wood for the woodpile. As I worked, I thought back to the day when Cherry was chopping wood, and I was helping her by chopping up the sticks.

"Heh, I waited so long until I was finally able to chop wood myself, but in the end, it was totally worth it! I still remember when Mom showed me how to swing an ax, and every day I've chopped wood since, I've been so happy. It's great exercise, and I really love doing it."

As I worked though, I began to feel a bit hot. I brushed it off, as it was close to 80 degrees outside, and I'd been chopping wood for nearly an hour, but looking back, maybe I shouldn't have. It came in waves instead of being constant, which it would have been if I'd just been working up a sweat, but I still didn't think anything of it. I finished chopping the wood, brought it all over to the woodpile, stacked it up, and then went inside. After dinner, I hung out with my sisters for a bit, all of whom were a lot calmer and more gentle. They'd been this way since last night when Mom talked to them about what they'd been doing, and that had hopefully straightened them out. Once it was time for bed, I went to my room, though instead of sleeping on my bed, I decided to sleep hanging upside down from the wooden rack in the corner of my room.

"Might as well. It's kinda hot tonight, so I won't need covers." I then stripped down to my boxers, opened my window a bit to let in some air, took flight a bit, wrapped my tail around the top bar of the rack, and then hung upside down from it, before settling in, and wrapping my wings around myself.

"Mmm, perfect!" It wasn't too long before I was asleep.

However, an unknown amount of time later, I suddenly woke up. It was still dark, and I was still hanging upside down from the rack, so I wasn't sure what woke me up. I glanced over at the clock on my bedside table, and the time showed that it was 1:52am. I glanced around my room, but aside from Maxi sleeping on my bed, there was no one else there.

"Weird. What woke me up then?" I then realized that I was soaked in sweat, and my stomach wasn't feeling so great. "Oh shit, I gotta shit!" I then swung forwards, let go of the rack, landed on my feet, ran to my door, opened it as quietly as I could, and ran down the hall to the bathroom, before opening the door, and going inside.

Because I was so focused on getting to the bathroom, I failed to notice the 2 pairs of glowing blue eyes, and the 2 pairs of glowing green eyes peering at me from 2 slightly opened bedroom doors. Once the bathroom door closed, the 2 doors opened, and 4 figures silently crept out of them, shutting the doors behind them, before sneaking over to my room, and going inside.

Meanwhile, inside the bathroom, I was feeling weirder than I'd ever felt in my life up until that point. I felt like I was burning up, but yet was cold at the same time, my stomach felt like fireworks were going off inside, but yet I didn't puke or poop, and my head felt all fuzzy. I also felt a burning sensation in my groin area, and I checked myself, but I didn't see anything out of the ordinary.

"What is wrong with me?!" I was getting close to panicking.

However, all of a sudden, all of the sensations stopped. I stopped feeling hot and cold, my stomach settled down, and the burning in my groin stopped. I suddenly felt almost completely normal again, though my head still felt a little bit fuzzy.

"Ok...that was....that was really weird." I then used the toilet to pee, then used a towel to wipe off the excess sweat that was still on me, splashed a little bit of cold water on my face, before deciding to head back to bed, and hopefully sleep it off. However, nothing could have prepared me for what I was going to find when I reached my room again.

When I arrived at my room, I walked inside, and shut the door again. However, I heard a slight movement behind me, and when I turned around, I saw 4 dark shapes sitting on my bed facing me, all 4 of which had glowing eyes!

"What the hell?!" I half-whispered, almost yelled.

I then flipped on the light switch next to me, instantly flooding the whole room with light from the ceiling fan. Once my eyes had adjusted to the sudden bright light, I looked back at the bed, and my jaw hit the ground. On it was none other than my 4 sisters, all of whom were wearing their bikinis, and had their hands over their faces to protect their eyes from the bright light.

"What the hell are you guys doing in here?!" I hissed at them. "Are you trying to give me a heart attack?!"

"No, we just couldn't sleep!" Starry hissed back.

"Yeah! We wanted to see if you were still awake, and when we saw that you were in the bathroom, we waited for you to come back!" Dawn added.

I wasn't buying it. Starry always slept like a rock, Cherry was a pretty heavy sleeper too, as were Dawn and Stella. Why were they just now having sleeping problems, and why were they REALLY all in my room? Before I said anything though, I flipped on the lamp on my bedside table, and turned the ceiling fan light off, so as to not hurt our eyes as much.

"Hmmm, I'm not buying your answer. What are you girls REALLY doing in here? And I'm not sure if you should be near me or not. I just had the weirdest experience in the bathroom, and I could be really sick."

Cherry sighed. "Ok, yeah, you got us. That's why we're really here. We heard you run to the bathroom, and we got really worried about you. You feel ok now though, right?"

I nodded. "Yeah, for the moment, though my head still feels a bit fuzzy. Maybe some sleep will help." I then looked at the bed, hoping that the 4 Girls would leave, but none of them budged. "Um...aren't you Girls going to leave?"

They shook their heads. "No, not with you not feeling well." Stella told me. "We'll stay here until you fall asleep."

"All 4 of you?" I asked suspiciously.

All 4 of them nodded. "Yeah, all 4 of us." They said together.

I blinked a few times. "Ok, it's WAY too early in the morning for bullshit, and I don't have time for it. Tell me why you're REALLY here, or I'll be forced to take matters into my own hands! Talk fast, and don't lie to me! One or more of you spiked my drink or food with something to make me feel weird, and then you'd 'magically' come to my rescue to help me recover, right?!"

The 4 Girls then whispered among themselves for a few moments, before turning back to me. Cherry then spoke up. "Yeah, we did do that. We slipped it into the black salt-shaker on the kitchen table. And before you freak out, no, it was NOTHING serious! It was just a little something to make you feel weird. It's completely harmless, and the effects have already worn off, and that fuzziness should be gone soon too."

"Why did you do it? You promised Mom that you'd leave me alone!"

"We never promised that, actually. We just said that we'd be more discreet."

"Be more....what?" I was getting confused. "Discreet with what?"

"Discreet with how we take our new relationship. Or at least, that's what we meant when we talked to Mom."

I was beyond confused now. "What?"

Cherry then got up off the bed, and walked over to where I was standing. Instinctively, I backed up, but because I was already close to my closed bedroom door, I soon hit it, and had nowhere else to run. Cherry then took both of her hands, and then placed them on my shoulders.

"Arctic, you really need to stop lying to yourself, and to us. It's getting REALLY old now. You've been in denial, and keeping these feelings suppressed is not healthy for your mental state."

"What?"

"Say 'what' again! Say 'what' again! I dare you! No, I double-dare you, Motherf@#ker! Say 'what' one more Celestia-damned time!" Stella laughed from the bed.

I couldn't help but crack a smile at her "Pulp Fiction" joke, but I was still very much confused about what was going on here.

"I'm still SO confused here, Cherry. I still don't see wha.....erhm...you're getting at. Where's all this going?"

"Good save! You almost said it again!" Stella giggled.

I rolled my eyes. However, Cherry then finally shed some light on things.

"It's going towards you, and your true feelings, Arctic. Or to be more specific, your true feelings towards your Sisters and I. You've been in denial about this for a while now, and you need to come clean now. But, for the sake of getting this ball rolling, I'll start. Arctic, on behalf of my Sisters and I, we REALLY need you to f@#k us! We're in heat, we're single, and we REALLY need you to help us! We care about you, so...so deeply. We love you more than anything, and we want what's best for you. Yes, we've all had our eyes on you for some time, and we've done certain things. From cooking and baking for you, to helping you with laundry, homework, and other things around the house, to 'borrowing' your underwear, leaving our dirty panties where you could easily find, and take them to sniff, leaving the bathroom door open just enough to let you see us when we shower, to watching you shower, to even just getting really cozy with you. We want this, Arctic, we really do. Heck, you even told Starry that one night that you'd totally plow her like a fertile field if she wasn't your sister! And that's the thing, Arctic, we're just barely even related! Mom adopted you, all of us are completely free and clear of ANY STD's, and we're still virgins, as are you, which means that there's no risk of anything nasty being spread, or any risks of genetic mutations. And yes, as you rightly deduced, we have been scaring away all other mares and girls. Yes, some of them really were sluts and thots who didn't belong near you, and we really didn't want you to get hurt." Cherry then began to give me her potent puppy-dog eyes. "Please, Arctic? I KNOW that you won't regret it if you do. You're legal now at 17, and you'd get your hot 21 year old Big Sister Starry, your 22 year old Twin Bigger Sisters Dawn and Stella, and your 23 year old Biggest Sister Cherry all to yourself. We'd all be your marefriends, and we'd share you equally. We'd be the perfect little harem for you, Little Brother, and we'd take care of all of your needs. So won't you PLEASE take us like the needy, bratty sisters we've been?" Cherry then jiggled her big G-cup boobs to prove her point.

When she finished, for the second time in my life, I well and truly had no words. The first time was when I was adopted by Scarlet 9 years ago, and now I had no words again when Cherry told me the real truth about what had really been going on. I somehow managed to remain standing, but my jaw remained open, and I was barely blinking either. Cherry tried to get me to snap out of it, but I seemed to be frozen where I was in shock. Cherry was then nudged to the side by Starry, who came up to me, and after wrapping her arms around me, kissed me.

"Come on, Arctic, snap out of it. Do it for me?"

Suddenly, something in my brain came back online, and I came to myself again. I did kiss Starry again, and for a few moments longer, I just held her close to me.

"Come on, Bro", She whispered softly, looking up at me with her most potent puppy-dog eyes. "Do me. I KNOW that you want to. I've been with you the longest, we're the closest in age, and I KNOW that most of your dirty fantasies involve me, and that you've been wanting to take me for a long time. I can feel your dick against my stomach right now, and it's THROBBING! So why don't you just wrap your arms tighter around me, kiss me like you mean it, drag me to the floor, rip my bottoms off, hike my tail up, and f@#k me like you hate me? I.....I REALLY want to be your first!" She whispered, kissing my neck a bit.

This was it, my resistance was fading fast. It wouldn't be too much longer before I actually did drag Starry to the floor and f@#k her like a bull in rut, followed closely by my other sisters, and the Little Angel knew it.

"Come on, Arctic, you HAVE to fight this! You KNOW that this is wrong! Don't listen to your dick, listen to your head and your heart! Don't give into her! Keep fighting!"

"Nah, don't listen to him, Arctic!" The Little Devil interjected. "These little Tarts (ESPECIALLY Starry!), have had this coming for a VERY long time! It's time for you to take control, and bend these sluts to your will! They want you to f@#k them so bad? Then f@#k them into sexual comas! Make them the broodmares for your foals!"

"You're right." I thought. "I do need to take control of this. I want it, they want it, we're just barely related, so what could go wrong If Starry wants me to f@#k her first? If she wants it, then she's gonna get it!"

"That's the spirit! Go get 'er Champ!"

"No! ARCTIC DON'T!!!!" The Little Angel screamed.

"Ah shut up, you harp-toting Sissy!" The Little Devil then whipped out his huge stallion-dick, and used it to cock-slap the Little Angel right off my shoulder, and he fell to the ground with a dull thud. Then the Little Devil turned his attention to the Little Devil version of Starry with devil horns and a devil tail that appeared in front of him, and began to f@#k her from behind.

"Brace yourself, Starry." I warned the real one. "I'm about to make every dirty little fantasy you've ever had about me come true!"

Starry then squealed like a happy schoolfilly, and I dragged her down to the soft rug on the floor by my bed. She was now my mate, and I was going to breed her like a broodmare.

Once we were on the floor, I pinned Starry's wrists to the floor next to her head, and then I straddled her. I was firmly holding her in place, but yet I also didn't want to to hurt her, so I was still being gentle. Plus, Starry was also offering no resistance. I then leaned down, and began to kiss her forcefully.

"Mmmm", She moaned into my mouth as our tongues mixed. Once we finally broke the kiss, she looked at me with her puppy dog eyes. "Please be gentle with me, Bro. I'm still an unpopped mare. I've been saving myself up for you."

I reached down, and gently pushed a bit of her blonde mane out of her eyes. "I know, Sis. And now that this is really happening, I'm glad that my first time is with you. It was either gonna be you or Cherry, and just when it looked like it was gonna be her, you snapped me out of my shocked stupor."

"Hey!" What about us?!" Stella and Dawn asked.

I looked at them. "Maybe if you learned how to bake, and/or cleaned out Maxi's litter box when I asked you to, I might have made you my first. But since you never did clean that litter box, you're just shit outta luck until I get to you!"

Cherry giggled a bit, but Stella and Dawn just pouted. However, they soon began to turn their attention to each other, and were soon kissing, stroking, and fingering each other like lovers, so that would keep them occupied for the time being.

I turned back to Starry, and after reaching down, I ripped (well, not technically, since the knots were as loose as could be) her bikini top off of her, and tossed it to the side. I then began to fondle her large rack.

"Mmmm, you like those big batty-boobies, Babe?" She asked.

"Yeah. They're so soft and squishy!"

"Yeah, I know. I like you touching them too. Your hands are so rough from your job at the power plant, and the skin feels amazing against my fur. Feel free to suck and bite my nipples too!"

"I'll do that, Starry, though I may wait until I'm actually f@#king you to do that."

We were soon kissing again, but I soon felt something tugging on my boxers, which my VERY erect dick had made tight as could be, just as Starry felt something tugging on her bottoms.

"Huh?" I looked back just in time to see Cherry pulling my boxers off, as well as Starry's bottoms.

"What? You guys were taking too long, so I decided to help move things along. Plus, I also wanted to see your Cutie-Marks again."

I looked back at my own hips. For a reason that's still not fully known, Human-Pony hybrids could still earn Cutie-Marks, just like Ponies could. My Cutie-Mark was a large black pawprint with a crisscrossed wrench and shovel in front of it. I earned it when I was 12, though I never fully understood what it meant until I started working at the power plant 4 years later. My special talent was working with heavy machinery helping to produce electricity. By contrast, my sister Cherry's Cutie-Mark was a big cherry pie, Starry's was a cluster of yellow stars, Dawn's was a picture of a school running track, and Stella's was a track hurdle. Aunt Sandy had the Cutie-Mark of a martini glass, and Scarlet's Cutie-Mark was an ax in a log.

"What do you think?" I asked Cherry.

"I like it. It really suits you." Cherry then got down next to me, and began to lick at my dick. "Mmm, I love the musky, salty taste. I guess that Human pre really is a bit sweeter than stallion pre!"

"Hey!" Starry protested. "Get away from his dick! That sucker needs to be inside of me!"

"And it will be, Sis!" Cherry interjected. "I'm just getting him ready for you, and paying him back for the compliment on my baking!" She then stuffed my cock down her throat, and was actually deepthroating me!

"Oughgod!" I groaned. "How the hell did she do that on the first try?!"

Even Starry was impressed. "Well, Bad-Pony does make Human-shaped dildos, and we all have one. Cherry's been practicing her deepthroating to get ready for you."

I was shocked that my sisters had Bad-Pony dildos, but then again, knowing them, that really shouldn't have surprised me at all.

A minute or so later, Cherry finally spit me back out again. My dick was covered in her saliva, and she was gasping for air a bit, and she had tears in her eyes, but Cherry said that she was ok.

"I'm fine. And some of my friends told me about Human dick, but Celestia-almighty! This thing is PERFECT!!! No flare, it's thin, yet really veiny, and while it is smaller than a stallion's dick, I think that it's going to be a LOT of fun! How big are you, Arctic?"

I shrugged. "I dunno. I never measured."

"Here, Sis. Now you can measure it!" Stella then tossed her sister a tape measure that she'd pulled from the drawer of my desk.

Cherry took it, and with help from Starry, measured my dick. Both were surprised. At a full erection, I was exactly 12in.

"Wow! The average stallion dick is only about 16in, so you're really not too far off the mark!"

I then looked down at Starry once Cherry was done. "Are you sure that you're ready for this Starry? 12in is still pretty big!"

She nodded. "Yeah, I'm ready. I won't be bleeding or anything, as my hymen was taken out by my dildo a long time ago, and I've been stretching myself with my dildo too so that I'd be able to take you, so yeah, I'm ready!"

"Ok. Well, I'll still go slowly to start so that you can get used to it."

Starry kissed me. "You're so sweet, you know that, Arctic?"

I blushed, but didn't say anything. Both Starry and Cherry then giggled a bit, and now it was time to get to the real rutting.

Once I was ready, I backed up a little bit, and began to pleasure Starry's snatch. Her dark gray lips were all plump and swollen, and her clitoris was winking at me. A lot of fluids were leaking out of her, and the smell was amazing. If I'd been a full stallion, I would have been able to detect that Starry was most likely in heat, but even though I wasn't, I still could tell, as the signs were obvious. I made a mental note to remember to pull out, as I didn't think that I'd be able to wear a condom.

I leaned down, and I began to lick Starry's wet snatch. The instant I did so, Starry let out a VERY loud moan, forcing Cherry to scramble over to her face, and kiss her deeply to muffle the moan.

"Keep it down, Sis! We don't want Mom to hear!" She whispered urgently. "She said that we could be intimate with Arctic, not anything like this! If she catches us, we're ALL gonna be in trouble!"

Starry moaned a bit softer, and I wasn't fully able to process what Cherry had said, but if I had, then maybe things wouldn't have escalated to the point that they were soon going to.

I kept licking, sucking, and fingering Starry's snatch, and more and more fluids came leaking out. Eventually, once I got to her clit, and began to suck on that, it was enough to push Starry over the edge, and while Cherry held her close to muffle her screams of pleasure, Starry's body spasmed while she was in the throws of a MASSIVE orgasm. I was hit by a tidal wave of hot, sticky mare-cum, and I had to swallow a lot to keep from choking!

Cherry was stunned. "Whoa, damn Girl! How backed up were you?! You look like you just died and went to Heaven!"

Starry cracked a weak smile. "D-damn straight! I've NEVER had an orgasm that strong before!" She then looked at me. "F@#k, Bro, where did you learn to eat pussy like that?!"

I shrugged. "Nowhere! Well, I mean....I have watched porn before.....but yours is the first pussy that I've ever eaten. I'll take it that I did a good job though, right?"

"F@#k yeah! I actually only saw pure white for a few seconds, and my body spasmed uncontrollably with pleasure! I KNEW that I made the right choice when I chose you!"

"And are you still up for sex?" I asked somewhat worriedly.

She gave me a weird look. "Heck yeah! It's gonna take more than one orgasm to quench my heat, Bro. So just take care of it yourself!"

I agreed, and with help from Cherry, while Starry continued to lay on her back, I gently began to rub my dick against her furry mound.

"Wow, I really like your pubes, Sis. Did you shave them into the shape of a heart for me?"

She nodded. "Yeah, I did. And so did Cherry, and the Twins. We all have heart-shaped pubic hair right now."

"Oh. Well, I guess that I'll see the others's pubic-hearts when I get to them, but in the meantime, I have a fertile field to plow!" I then began to push into Starry.

My dick went in easily enough despite its size, and just like Starry had said, her hymen was long-gone, so there was no bleeding. Starry did moan pretty loud, and her pussy kept producing a lot of juices, and I soon gently bottomed out in her.

"Wow. Both of you now have your cherries popped! Congrats! You guys aren't virgins anymore!"

I looked at her. "Thanks, Cherry."

Starry then looked up at me. "You just punched your own Sister's V-Card, while she punched yours. How dirty does that make you feel?"

"Since we're barely related, not too much. Want a kiss?"

She nodded, and I kissed her deeply.

"F@#k me, Bro." Starry whispered.

I nodded, and soon pulled out of her a bit, before pushing back in. I soon began to work myself into a steady rhythm with Starry; I'd push into her, and she'd push back to meet me. I was fondling her large breasts while I f@#ked her, and she had to keep getting kissed by Cherry, as her moans were so loud that Scarlet or Sandy would have heard us for sure if she didn't. Dawn and Stella did slip over to me, and they began to rub their hands over my body, as well as kiss me while I worked up to being able to f@#k Starry at full steam. Starry was in heaven, and I could tell that she had probably turned her back on any stallion who wasn't me for good.

"I can't wait to get my Bro's big, hot Human dick inside of me." Stella whispered to no one in particular. "I want to feel his fat, mushroom-shaped head poking me right in my cervix, before he dumps a hot baby-making load right into my unprotected womb!"

"Degenerate Humiephile!" Dawn laughed.

I rolled my eyes a bit. While not forbidden by any means, some did see Human X Pony relationships to be somewhat taboo. The term "Humaphilia" was coined to describe mares who had fetishes for Humans, sometimes shortened to "Humiephile". I'd heard it thrown around before, alongside it's Human equivalent, "Ponyphilia/Ponyphile", and while some saw it as an insult, most saw it as either a running joke, or a badge of honor.

"Look who's talking. The mare with her fingers in her coochie dreaming about her own brother's big Human dick!" I muttered.

Dawn just giggled. "Yep, guilty as charged!"

"I'm totally guilty too." Cherry admitted. "I've had fantasies about Humans for a long time, at least, certain Humans", She added, giving me bedroom eyes.

I smirked, and blew her a kiss, which she was able to return with an actual kiss once Dawn took her place kissing Starry to keep her moans quiet. However, at this time, I was now ready to go full-steam on Starry, so once the others scooted back just a bit, I grabbed Starry's hips, and began to thrust into her at full-steam. She was soon crying out in pure-bliss, once again with her screams being muffled by her Sisters. Starry kept having multiple orgasms from being f@#ked, and on most of my thrusts, I could feel the tip of my dick kissing the entrance to her womb. It was a strange feeling, but not an unpleasant one. Eventually though, I decided to try another method for keeping Starry quiet. I then stopped thrusting for a moment, grabbed her, flipped her onto her stomach, pushed her face into the rug, and then grabbed her hips, and kept pounding into her doggy-style. I spanked her ass multiple times, causing her to moan like a bitch in heat, and she was soon drooling pretty hard too, but the rug helped muffle everything. My other 3 Sisters were shocked. They'd never seen such a feral display of passion before. It was clear that Starry was now my bitch in every way, and they each soaked the floor under where they were sitting with their own orgasms, imagining that it was me f@#king them instead of Starry.

Starry had just about moaned herself into silence from all of her orgasms, and I was roughly fondling her tits, as well as kissing and nipping her neck, causing Starry to let out a series of bat-like squeaks. It was really cute, but I could feel my own orgasm coming at me like a freight train.

"Shit, I'm gonna cum Starry. I'm gonna pull out, flip you over, and blow on your tits and stomach."

However, Starry had other plans. In a surprising burst of energy, Starry flipped over onto her back by herself, and wrapped her legs, wings, and tail tightly around my back, preventing me from pulling out.

"It's ok, I'm on the pill. Pop inside me, Little Bro! I REALLY wanna have your foals! Do it! Give me all your incestuous foal-gravy!"

My brain was short-circuiting, so I failed to pick up on the fact that Starry was probably lying about being on the pill. I then leaned down, grabbed both of Starry's hands with my own, locked lips with her, pushed as deep into her as I possibly could, before pushing past her cervix, and unloading a MASSIVE creampie right into her womb. We both screamed into each others's mouths as we both climaxed at the same time, and once I was finally done spurting, I managed to pull out of Starry with a very audible *pop!*, and some of my cum began to leak out of her. Starry was lying on her back, breathing really heavily, her tongue was hanging out of her mouth, and she was drooling a bit too, as well as faintly moaning. Her eyes had rolled back into her head, and I was really worried about her.

"Shit. Is she ok?"

Cherry looked at her. "Yeah, she's fine, Arctic. She's just in heaven right now. You f@#ked her absolutely stupid, and she's riding the biggest sex-high of her life right now. Don't worry though, she'll snap out of it here before too long. One of my gal-pals had this exact same thing happen to her when her Human coltfriend f@#ked her. She looked just like Starry does now."

I was slightly relieved. "Well, that's good to know. I'm glad that she's ok, and that she's on the pill."

"Yeah......." Cherry agreed, lying through her teeth. She knew that Starry wasn't on any pill, and so did Dawn and Stella. In fact, none of them were on birth control, and had been off it for weeks. All 3 of them knew that Starry's eggs were most likely being swarmed by my swimmers, and that they were most likely going to be aunties by the end of the year. They were so happy for Starry, but yet, they had their own needs, and I was going to have to take care of them too.

Once I'd helped Starry roll onto her side so that she wouldn't choke on her own saliva, and she was faintly snoring, I looked at Dawn, Stella, and Cherry.

"Ok, so who wants to go next? Don't fight, just figure it out peacefully. And I need to figure out how to pace myself, because I want all 3 of you to feel as good as I made Starry feel."

All 3 of them blushed a bit.

"Aww, that's so sweet of you, Arctic. You actually care if we have pleasure too, unlike certain OTHER coltfriends I could mention!" Cherry growled, still thinking of Crossbow. "Humped me like a bag of bones, and then passed out. I barely felt any pleasure at all!"

"Well, if what happened to Starry is any indication, you won't have that problem with me, Sis!"

Cherry giggled. "Yeah, I think so too!"

I then looked at Stella and Dawn. "And are you guys virgins, or what?"

Dawn nodded, but Stella shook her head. "Yes, we're still virgins, as we've never had sex."

"However, we're not 'pure virgins', as like Starry, our hymens are long-gone thanks to dildos. So no bleeding, just pleasure!"

They both looked at me with lustful looks on their faces, and were hungrily licking their chops, almost in sync.

"If you two want to take him next, go right ahead. I'll watch."

"You mean that, Sis?" Dawn asked her.

Cherry nodded. "Yeah, I'll take up the rear. He can finish off with me, and show me long, slow pleasure. Then we can all snuggle up together in one big, furry pile, maybe even with our hands touching!"

Stella giggled. "Ooh, some kinky shit! I'm game!"

"Me too!" Dawn agreed.

I cocked my head a bit. I still couldn't figure out how cuddling, snuggling, and hand-holding were considered kinkier than actual sex, unless of course it only applied to interspecies relationships, which considering how "taboo" Humaphilia was, was probably why.

"Yeah, I'm down for that. And how are we gonna do this, Sis and Sis?" I asked the Twins.

They looked at each other, smirked, and then looked back at me.

"Prepare for trouble...." Dawn began

"And make it double!" Stella added.

"We're gonna ride you like a rented mule!" They finished together.

I knew then that I was in for a LONG night!

Once the Twins finished crawling over to me, Stella began to kiss me, while Dawn began to rub her hands all over my body.

"Mmm", Dawn purred. "Human skin is so exotic. It feels so smooth under my furry hands, but yet so rugged, so muscular, so......" She then kissed me in place of Stella, "Manly. It's so much better in person than the Human porn that I watched on my laptop. And it's so much better with the added kink of the feeling that we shouldn't be doing this."

"Yeah." Stella agreed. "It feels so wrong, but yet, so right at the same time! So what's really at stake here, aside from getting knocked up?"

Dawn shrugged. "I dunno. Getting caught by Mom, or Aunt Sandy?"

I grimaced a bit. "Yeah, that could be bad."

Stella agreed, but then she looked at Dawn and I. "You guys wanna try a 3-way kiss? I've seen a Human male and 2 mares do it before in porn, but wanna see what it actually feels like?"

Dawn smirked. "Oh yes!"

I agreed. "Sure."

Dawn then sat on one side of me, and Stella sat on the other, forming a crude triangle pattern. Then, once we were ready, we all leaned in, and eventually, our lips all met in the middle. It was a feeling like no other. It felt so strange, yet so arousing to be kissed by 2 mares at the same time, not to mention 2 tongues fighting with my own for dominance. There was also a lot of semi-muffled moaning, and my dick, which had been semi-soft, suddenly sprang to life once again. Both girls just giggled, and while still kissing me, began to give me a double-handjob. Eventually though, they wanted more.

Stella and Dawn then did a game of rock, paper, scissors, and after Stella won with 2 out of 3, she then pushed me onto my back, and began to suck my dick, while Dawn was getting ready to sit on my face.

"I'll be careful, Arctic." She told me as she squatted over my face. "But I think that you'll enjoy this."

"I hope so, Dawn. But if you orgasm, and lose control of yourself, please try not to fall on Starry. Fall forwards onto Stella, back over my head, or left towards the bed."

"Don't worry, I will. Though, I do hope that here before too long I'll be able to join her in 'F@#ked-Stupid Heaven'."

"Me too!" I heard Stella giggle.

"I think that that can be arranged. Though when we get to that, how do you want to be f@#ked?"

"Stella's gonna get your dick all lubed up, then she's gonna f@#k you while you eat me out. Then once she's satisfied, she'll join Starry in Heaven, and then it'll be my turn. Then once I'm with them too, you and Cherry can do whatever."

I looked over at Cherry. "You good with that, Sis?"

She nodded. "Sure. I have something special planned for our first time anyway."

"Ok." I then looked up at Dawn, who was still squatting over my face. "I hope that you're ready for a LOT of orgasms Dawn, because once I start getting REALLY pleasured from Stella, that's gonna translate into more orgasms for you."

"Yep, I was born ready!"

Stella then kept sucking, while Dawn squatted down, and got into a proper kneeling position over my face, and I was soon eagerly eating her out.

We went on like this for several minutes. I would get pleasure from Stella sucking me off, and that would cause my body to shudder, which would cause my tongue to flick against Dawn's clit, resulting in another orgasm for her. Dawn was moaning like a bitch in heat, and had to bite her arm to keep from screaming, or being too loud. Suddenly though, I felt Stella spit me out, though before I could move Dawn's thicc, muscular thighs out of the way to see what she was doing, I felt my tip rubbing against something really wet and gooey. I finally got Dawn's thighs apart just in time to see Stella impale herself onto me reverse-cowgirl. All I could see was her black mane and tail, dark blue fur, and dull-gray wings, not to mention her amazing ass.

"Wow, you've got such a thicc ass, Sis!"

"Thanks, Arctic!" I heard Dawn purr.

"Not you, Dawn, I was talking to Stella! But since you two are identical twins, you both have thicc asses. Muscular too from all the running you guys did in high school, and still do today!"

I heard them giggle. "Thanks, Bro!" They said in unison.

Dawn then kept grinding her wet pussy against my face, while Stella began to ride me. However, Stella soon had to turn around, as she was moaning too loud, and had to kiss her sister Dawn to muffle them. Why was she moaning? Because while I had my hands on Dawn's ass while I was eating her out, I was also thrusting my hips upwards to meet Stella's downward thrusts, which was causing her to moan so loud. Stella had good control of her muscles, but the feeling of being f@#ked by her brother was too much for her, and eventually, she unleashed a very powerful orgasm, right as I gave Dawn one too. Dawn then toppled over sideways next to my bed, which gave me the opportunity to sit up, grab Stella, flip her out of her position, and plant her face on the floor, but keep her ass in the air. I then grabbed her tail, and kept thrusting.

"Oooh yes, harder, Daddy!" She moaned into the floor. "F@#k your little bitch, and knock her up good! F@#k birth control! I never took that shit anyway, and neither did Dawn or Starry! Cherry did, but stopped when she and Crossbow broke up!"

My brain was short circuiting. I heard what Stella said, but was unable to fully process it at the time. However, soon after this, I thrusted as deeply into Stella as I possibly could, pushed past her cervix, and then unloaded another torrent of hot-potent baby-batter directly into her eager womb. Stella then screamed herself into silence, before turning into a quivering, drooling, moaning, f@#ked-stupid mess like Starry had been.

"Whoa, damn, Arctic! She's just been shot up to Heaven like Starry was! Their poor, defenseless little eggs. There's no WAY that they're not all getting gang-raped by your potent swimmers! And it's my turn next, right? You've still got something left in the tank?"

After gently letting Stella down next to Starry, I then turned around to face Dawn, my dick still painfully erect. "Answer your question?" I asked with a smirk.

Dawn turned a bit pale. "I heard that Humans had greater stamina than stallions did, but I never believed it until now. Well, I guess that there's no way to escape you, you Human Stud, you're gonna breed me whether I want it or not, so I don't see any point in resisting. Come here, Big Boy." She then got down on all fours like Starry had been. "Come here and breed me like a bitch....YOUR bitch! Claim another innocent mare's womb for Humanity!"

I cocked my head a bit when Dawn said that. Honestly, I still never fully understood mares who had Humaphilia, but yet, free pussy was free pussy, especially when it belonged to one of my drop-dead gorgeous Bat-Pony sisters, so I definitely wasn't complaining! I then got behind Dawn, grabbed her hips, and began to thrust into her, while pushing some of my white mane out of my eyes. I was sweating a bit, and breathing pretty heavy, but I had more than enough stamina and endurance to take care of Dawn too. I could already tell that she wasn't going to be able to last very long, as I'd already given her a number of orgasms while Stella was riding me, but she still did her best.

I groped her nice D-cup breasts and I also nipped her furry ears a bit while I whispered sweet nothings into them. Dawn was soon a quivering mess, and fell onto her side. However, she still urged me to keep going, so I did. I then gently grabbed her left leg, hoisted it up onto my right shoulder, and kept thrusting. Dawn was enjoying every second of what I was doing to her, and was clawing at the carpet in bliss, even going so far as to chitter in pleasure. Pretty soon, I was ready to blow again, and I pushed as deeply as I could into Dawn, though while I hit her cervix, due to me running out of steam, I was unable to push past it. However, I still unleashed another potent load into her, and Dawn was a drooling, well-f@#ked mess, just like her twin Stella, and her sister Starry. I'd now f@#ked 3 of my sisters, which left only Cherry to go. I helped her place Dawn next to Stella and Starry, and the 3 of them were soon cuddling in their sleep, and then it was Cherry's turn for sex.

Once she was ready though, I sighed. "While I'm still willing to have sex with you Cherry, I'm not sure if I have enough steam. I can feel one final load in my balls, but rutting 3 other mares has really taken it out of me. I don't know if I can perform."

I felt a gentle hand on my shoulder. "Shh, it's ok, Arctic. All you gotta do is lay back, and keep it standing tall and proud. Let me do all the work, as I'm fresh and ready. Plus, I didn't really have a rough and sweaty f@#k session in mind anyway; I just wanted some low and slow, passionate lovemaking. You've already outdone yourself with Starry, Stella, and Dawn, and it doesn't matter to me if you can f@#k me like that tonight, as there's always another night. Just lay back, hold my hands, and let me kiss you, f@#k you, and whisper sweet nothings into your ears."

I nodded, and did as Cherry requested.

Once she was inside me, she gently held my hands, and began to move herself up and down slowly. "Mmm, so good. But then again, it's always been good. One of the happiest days of my life was when Mom and Dad told me that I was gonna have a sister, even though it turned out that I was actually getting twin sisters! Then Starry came along not too long after, and then 12 years later, you come along Arctic. Now, I know that we've told you that we love you (in more ways than one as of tonight!), but what we may have never told you was that the happiest day of our lives was the day that you came into ours. I'll never forget that first day when Mom and Starry brought you home, and we almost smothered you with hugs. You were our little brother, and even though you were a Human-Bat-Pony, that didn't matter at all. We still loved you."

I couldn't quite tell if Cherry was talking more to herself or to me, as she was muttering a lot of what she was saying, but thanks to my Bat-Pony ears, I could still hear her perfectly, and honestly, it was melting my heart. Cherry was pouring out her heart to me, seemingly without even realizing it, and I found that so adorable.

She kept going though. "....You were so much fun to have around, and we got to spend so much time with you. From chopping wood, to playing by the river, swimming in the river, fishing, those times we took you hunting with us, the times you helped me cook and bake, and I'll NEVER forget the day you and Comet brought Maxi home. The look on Mom's face? PRICELESS!!! And I got to see you grow up too. From your first day at grade school, to your first day at middle school, your first day at high school, that time you got 3rd place at the High School Science Fair with your project on electricity, to the day you graduated. And that one night when you comforted me after I broke up with Crossbow? That was the night that I knew that you were perfect husband material. Yeah, I would have to wait another few years until you were legal, but that wait was totally worth it. Now I have you, you have me, and you also have your other 3 sisters too." She then leaned down, held me close to her, and kissed me. "I love you, Arctic. So...so much. Never leave me or your Sisters!"

I held her close too, trying to resist the urge to cry at what she'd just said. "I...I love you too, Sis. I love you, I love Dawn, I love Stella, and I love Starry. You've all meant so much to me over the years, and now tonight I think that we've solidified that love. I'll never leave you, provided of course that you guys never leave me. Though what would Mom think of all this?"

I then felt myself cum inside of Cherry, just as I felt her have another orgasm too. It felt so amazing.

Cherry then kissed me. "Mmm. Don't worry, Arctic, we'll never leave you. You mean too much to us. And don't worry about Mom. Who do you think it was that let us engineer all of this? Mom was the one who allowed us seduce you. She seemingly encouraged our lustful behavior, and even gave us pointers! Heck, she was the one who told us to spike the salt in the black salt-shaker last night with that stuff to make you feel sick so that you'd be all ready for us to make our moves on you tonight! The only rule was to be careful, and I'm pretty sure that we did a good job with that!"

I was pretty surprised that Scarlet had had a hand in this, but then again, maybe I should have expected it. I made a mental note to remind all 4 girls to take more birth control in the morning, little knowing that I would forget it in the night.

Once we were finally done having sex that night, I helped Cherry into my bed, before picking up Dawn, Stella, and Starry, and then helping them into my bed too. I then crawled in there after them, and even though we were all still naked, and it was a VERY tight squeeze fitting into a twin-sized bed, we were all as cozy as could be, and none of us wanted it any other way. Starry was on my right, Dawn on my left, and Stella and Cherry were lying on top of us. I then fell asleep as well with a smile on my face. I was a virgin no longer, my sisters were now my marefriends, and all was right with the world.

However, because it was dark in the room, and I wasn't paying attention, I failed to notice the door to my room be fully pulled shut again after having been unlocked, and left ajar for the past number of hours, and a shadow move away from the door, and head off back down the hallway.

Over the course of the next few days, I was hard at work at the power plant once again, and kept coming home too tired to do too much with my mares other than cuddle, snuggle, and kiss them, and my days off were largely spent recovering my strength.

"So how have things been going at home lately, Arctic?" Comet asked as he stoked up a furnace while I shoveled coal into it. "Have your sisters been causing you anymore problems?"

I shook my head. "No. We've been the best of friends ever since that night about 2 weeks or so ago when everything was finally put right."

Comet just shook his head. "Normally, I would say 'Lucky Bastard', but in this instance, I can't. 4 is 3 too many, and WAY too taboo considering how they're your sisters! Do you know how dangerous that is?"

"Sisters only because I was adopted; we're not blood-related." I corrected. "But yes, I see your point. Which is why I, as well as them, have been keeping absolutely quiet about this. Aside from us, and you too, none of us have told anyone else what really happened that night."

"Well, at any rate, I'm happy for you, Arctic. Your sisters are good mares, and I'm glad that they're happy with you. And at least you guys used protection, right?"

I nodded. "Yeah. We were careful that night. I don't think that anything bad will happen."

That's what I was hoping anyway. However, later that night when I got home, I took off my shoes by the door, said hi to Scarlet, and then went upstairs to take my shower. I wanted to say hi to my Sisters, but I didn't see them anywhere. I didn't think anything of it at the time, and once I left my dirty clothes in a laundry basket, I took my shower, and then came back to my room. When I arrived though, I saw my Sisters in my room. However, all of them were clothed this time, but all 4 of them looked very worried. Not noticing this at first, I hugged all of them.

"Hey Sis's!"

They did hug me back. "Hey Arctic."

"We need to talk though, now."

I gave her a concerned look while I was pulling on a pair of boxer shorts, as well as sweatpants. "What do you mean, Starry?"

She gave me a concerned look. "Shut the door. I don't want Mom to hear this. But we've got a serious problem, Arctic. Well, at least Stella and I do, but yet you, Dawn, and Cherry also probably have the same problem due to being co-conspirators."

"Co-conspirators for what?" I asked as I shut the door. "What's going on?"

Cherry and Dawn then sat on my bed, while Starry and Stella remained standing. I could see that both of them were holding something in their pockets, and they walked over to me, while I leaned against my door.

"Thanks to that night, Arctic, our lives have just been dramatically altered." Starry said quietly.

"Yeah", Stella agreed. "We're not sure what we're gonna do now."

I was about to ask what they meant, but before I could, they pulled those objects out of their pockets, and held them up. They were white, and oblong shaped, and at first I thought that they were thermometers, but then they showed me, and my face went about as white as my mane. Those 2 objects were pregnancy tests, and both of them were positive! I looked at them, and then over at Dawn and Cherry. They just nodded, the same looks of fear on their faces.

Starry then hugged me tightly. "I'm pregnant, and you're the father." She said quietly. "Dawn was right. My eggs, and Stella's eggs, were indeed gang-raped by your sperm."

I hugged her tightly, as well as Stella. "Well, we're all in this together now. I'm not leaving you." I then looked at Dawn and Cherry. "And you guys aren't pregnant?"

Cherry shook her head. "No. As soon as Starry and Stella's tests came back positive, Dawn and I took tests too, but ours came back negative. We took several just to be sure, but they all came back negative."

"Yeah. Either your last 2 loads weren't quite as potent, or our positions weren't the best for inducing a pregnancy. We just got lucky."

I put a hand over my face. "And you guys lied about the birth control, right?"

All 4 of them nodded quietly.

"And does Mom know about this?"

Starry shook her head. "No. We were too scared to tell her. She said that we could be intimate with you, but she never said ANYTHING about f@#king; never mind getting pregnant, and she even told us to be careful! We knew that we could tell you, but now what are we gonna do?"

I didn't know. Both pregnant mares did lift up their shirts, and they let me feel their bellies. Of course, they were still washboard-flat, but that would start to change very soon.

"Our options are pretty limited here, Starry and Stella. You guys don't have coltfriends, and stay away from most colts and stallions. I've been the only guy you've slept with, and there's no way that you're gonna be able to hide your baby-bellies for long."

"So what do we do, Bro?" Stella asked.

I sighed. "Well, if you ask me, our best option would be to just tell Mom. She kinda helped you guys start this mess, so surely she would know what to do. Plus, it's better for her to hear from us now, rather than to just have her find out later when your bellies start to show."

"When?" Starry asked.

"Now. Now would be the best time. Mom's downstairs in the kitchen, and Aunt Sandy's out for a night on the town. She won't be back for a while, which would be the best for a conversation like this. I know that this isn't the best option, but it's the only option we have. We messed up, and now we've gotta face the consequences. I'm not off the hook either, as I'm going to have to help you raise these foals for the next 18+ years."

Both Starry and Stella hugged me again. In all honest truth, I was just as scared as they were. How would Mom react to this? Would she freak out? Yell at us? Try to kick us out of the house? Would she understand? Would she help us? We didn't know, and that was the hardest thing; we didn't know. However, Mom was in the kitchen right then, and the time to tell her was at hand. The next few minutes were absolutely CRITICAL for our future, and they were going to set the stage for whatever was to follow. After talking for a little bit longer, we all got up, opened my bedroom door, and steeled ourselves up for whatever was to come next.

Author's Note

And, that was Chapter 3 Part 1.

I hope that you all enjoyed that, as this chapter contained the very first incest sex-scenes that I ever wrote. I hope that I did a good job with them. So now Arctic has 4 marefriends in his sisters, and he had sex with all of them, but now he, Starry, and Stella have to deal with the consequences. Both of them are pregnant, and he's the father. They have to tell their Mom, but how is that going to go down? How will Scarlet react when 2 of her daughters tell her that they're pregnant by her son? Will she be accepting? Or will she be really upset? Is this the worst thing that could have happened, or was this part of a larger plan? How will Sandy react to her nieces nephew about to make her a great-aunt? And more importantly, who was the person, or persons standing outside of Arctic's room on the night that he had sex with his sisters? Was it Scarlet? Was it Sandy? Or was it both of them? And what could possibly happen next? Well, you know the drill, stay tuned and I'll tell you!

In the meantime though, as always, comments, feedback, questions, as well as spreading the word about this story are always appreciated, and I'll see you all again in Chapter 3 Part 2!

ScarFox out for now!