Marybelle hears a knock as she’s sitting on her couch. “Hang on!” She calls. Looking over to her clock, it is 6:58. She thinks to herself, “Well he was just a little early last time as well.”

She opens her front door to see a smiling blue batpony there in a short pompadour.

Greeting him, she says “Oh! My favorite butthole! Come in! I need to have a chat with you…”

Guyrin’s eyes widen just a little bit as he trots in, holding roses in his mouth.

Marybelle says, “Set the flowers down on the table over there and sit down on the couch across from it. I don’t know what you have planned for tonight, but it needs to wait a few minutes...”

Guyrin trots in and sets the flowers down, then calmly goes over to the couch on the other end of the room. Marybelle sits next to him before saying, “Okay look… I don’t really like to talk about it, but I got hurt pretty bad a few years ago and I really need to take it slow okay?”

Guyrin smiles and nods his head.

Marybelle continues, “Okay I’m glad you understand!”

But as soon as she finishes, Guyrin’s lips are firmly planted on hers. Her eyes widen as she resists the urge to uppercut him and smash his face in with a hammer blow. She can’t help but notice at that point that her knees are also beginning to weaken…

She draws back and she gets up and says, “You kissed me!”

He smiles and nods before going in for another soft sensual kiss.

She’s ready for it this time and maintains herself a bit better as the batpony embraces her in a loving hug while they’re kissing. He then draws back and gasps for air before he starts sensually licking and kissing down her neck. Marybelle is surprised by this, and yet all she can do is freeze as the batpony starts to kiss down her chest and goes lower to her stomach. And then suddenly without warning, she feels his snout against her opening…

Her eyes are as wide as saucers as she slinks back into the sofa and moves her rear end closer to his face while widening her hind legs as she feels his tongue then penetrate the opening of her lips. It begins to lick the lower sections before focusing more on the clitoris at the top and then she feels him as he begins to suck on her nub…

Guyrin eats her out for about 45 minutes and she enjoys herself very thoroughly.

She leans all the way back on the sofa as he gets out from between her legs and crawls up to kiss her. She can still taste herself on his breath when suddenly, she shoves him back, and violently smacks him across his chest hard while saying, “Pervert! You ate me out!”

Guyrin smiles and shrugs his shoulders.

Marybelle stares at him and says, “I just tell you I need to take it slow and you immediately eat me out… Are you insane little batpony? Do you perhaps want me to kick your flanks again?”

Guyrin reaches on his back with his forehooves and pulls off the chalkboard and gets the chalk out of his pocket with his mouth before scrawling down, “U didn’t complain!” on the chalkboard and showing it to Marybelle.

Marybelle squints before saying, “Dammit Guy! The more I think about you, the more I like you… And that only pisses me off even more!”

Guyrin smiles broadly at Marybelle and this only makes the Pegasus seethe with rage as she shoves him off her and yells, “Why did you eat me out?”

Guyrin immediately goes back to his hooves on the floor and shields his face with his left forehoof and shakes when Marybelle suddenly stops…

She takes a deep breath and says, “Guyrin! Do you actually think I’m going to hurt you again?”

Guyrin slowly lowers his left forehoof and solemnly shakes his head yes before looking down.

Marybelle frowns before asking Guyrin, “But…you’re still here? Why?”

Guyrin then puts his right forehoof over his heart and nods with a blank expression on his face.

Marybelle looks down and takes a deep breath again before looking at Guyrin and saying, “Look! I’m really sorry about what I did to you two days ago and uh…”

She trots over to Guyrin and hugs him while whispering softly in his ear, “I’m not going to hurt you anymore Guyrin… You’re safe with me! I promise okay?”

Guyrin smiles dimly and nods his head while in her embrace. She pulls back to all fours and says, “Okay and now I need to ask you… Why did you eat me out?”

Guyrin jots on the chalkboard, “I love U want please”.

Marybelle frowns and says, “Well I came 4 times and so I’d say you definitely achieved your goal… But you’re not getting off the hook that easy mister!”

Guyrin then stares at Marybelle wide eyed as she kisses him passionately and then whispers in his ear, “This isn’t over…”

She pulls back and Guyrin stares at her for a few seconds before scrawling, “What U mean?” on his chalkboard.

Marybelle smiles and says, “Oh you’re not the only one with plans little batpony! But that’s for later! Where are we going?”

Guyrin starts and then scrawls, “Dinner!” on his chalkboard.

Marybelle says, “Oh okay! Lemme guess! You know places open all night, right?”

Guyrin smiles and nods before trotting towards the door and motioning with his right forehoof for Marybelle to do the same.

She trots outside with Guyrin behind her before he shuts the door and then starts trotting towards the West when he stops and looks back at her.

Marybelle is sure she knows what this signal means and she trots up next to Guyrin before they both trot at a brisk pace to the West in the Southern area of Ponyville.

Guyrin stares at Marybelle and smiles at her as she stares back at this confusing little blue creature of the night.

Marybelle says, “I still don’t know what it is about me you like nor am I sure why I’m actually following you and going through with this?”

Guyrin stops trotting and Marybelle does the same. He then looks at her with a serious expression in his eyes and taps his right forehoof to Marybelle’s heart.

Marybelle looks down and breaths before looking up at Guyrin and saying, “Yeah I know I like you! I just…” She then looks down as the batpony stares on with an expression on his face that she can only barely just make out. She finally says, “I’m scared okay! There! I finally admitted it! Guess I’m not such a big tough MMA fighter after all?”

Guyrin smiles, then hugs her tightly. She feels the warmth of his body as the comforting embrace envelopes her. She is comforted like this for a few glorious minutes before Guyrin begins to lick her ear.

Marybelle then shoves Guyrin off her and says, “Oh no you little hornball! Not here! Not now!”

Guyrin smiles and shrugs as he tilts his head to the right.

Marybelle frowns and says, “Okay ground rule number one! If you wanna comfort me, that’s fine! But let it be understood that that has nothing to do with sex okay?”

Guyrin looks up before nodding at Marybelle.

Marybelle continues, “Alright! Awesome! Now before I go marching off to my doom at the mystery place, I just need to say one more thing…” The batpony looks at Marybelle with open eyes as she says, “I never wanted to have sexual relations with you! And while I’m sure that’s just the heat of the moment or whatever, I think we need to take it a bit slower from here on out okay?”

Guyrin smiles and nods.

Marybelle then says, “Okay! Glad we understand each other! Rule number 2! We don’t do anything sexual again until I clearly tell you that I’m ready okay?”

Guyrin smiles and nods his head again.

Marybelle says, “Excellent! Now that that’s out of the way, let’s go!”

Guyrin looks down before turning around. He slowly begins to trot to the West again as Marybelle follows and mutters to herself.

They’re trotting across the empty Market Square in the Southern area of town when Marybelle sees a light in the distance on the other block across the street. She then asks Guyrin, “Is that where we’re going?”

Guyrin looks at her as they trot, smiles, and nods.

Marybelle says, “Well after what we did earlier, it’s probably a little after 8 now. I hope they don’t close soon.”

Guyrin shakes his head no.

Marybelle trots towards the light with Guyrin and mutters to herself, “Oh of course! They’re probably open all night knowing my coltfriend!”

Guyrin smiles at Marybelle before making that peculiar screeching noise at a low volume and looks forward as he continues to trot beside her.

They walk up to the patio of the restaurant. Marybelle knows she’s seen this place before but can’t recall ever seeing them open. Guyrin walks up to a table and pulls out a chair with his teeth and then nods at it and smiles.

Marybelle then says, “And you’re also a perfect gentlepony! Of course!” As she trots up to the chair and sits down.

Guyrin trots around the table, pulls out his own chair with his teeth, and sits down before smiling at Marybelle.

Marybelle looks at Guyrin carefully before saying to him, “You really love and care for me, don’t you? And for some reason, this seems to piss me off…”

Guyrin looks down before back up at Marybelle and silently nods.

Marybelle frowns and says, “Until two days ago, we never even met. And yet, I beat you up and here we are!”

Guyrin smiles before jotting down, “I know U and wanted 2 know more!”

Marybelle then says, “All you know is what you’ve seen of me in the ring little batpony. You don’t really know me!”

Guyrin then scrawls out, “I read UR bio?”

Suddenly, Marybelle has a shocked expression on her face before she says, “R-really? Only 11 copies of my biography were ever sold!”

Guyrin writes out, “U interesting!” and smiles at her.

Marybelle looks down and says, “Well the rest of Equestria didn’t seem to think so?”

At this point, she notices that they are not alone. A light blue Pegasus with a yellow mane and tail is standing at their booth now and she asks him, “Can we help you?”

The Pegasus smiles and says, “Oh I’m Tim! I’ll be your waiter for this evening! And what would the lovely couple like to drink?”

Marybelle then says, “Uh, berry juice please! Guy? What would you like?”

Guy scrawls out, “Black coffee!” on his chalkboard.

Tim smiles, “Thank you! Your menus are in the center of the table!” and then trots off.

At this point, Marybelle suddenly notices that there are indeed small menus at the center of the table. She collects one with her forehooves shortly before Guyrin does the same and looks at it. After a few minutes, she decides on hay cakes as Guyrin can’t stop staring at something on his menu.

The waiter eventually trots back to them on Marybelle’s side while balancing a tray with a clear cup of red juice and a cup with black coffee in it on his snout and then lays it down on the table before standing on his haunches and using his forehooves to fetch everypony’s drink and get it to them. He finally says, “Is the lovely couple ready to order?”

Marybelle looks up and says, “Uh, yes I’ll have the hay cakes please!”

Tim says, “Excellent choice! And would you like your usual Guyrin?”

Guyrin puts his menu down and points with his hoof to the apple and orange plate there.

Tim sees this before saying, “Ah! You wish to try the apple and orange plate tonight instead!” Guyrin happily nods his head and smiles as he continues, “Excellent choice sir!” And then trots off.

Marybelle finally looks at the batpony again and asks him, “Okay Guy, I have to know the truth right here and now… What do you see in me?”

Guyrin scrawls down on his chalkboard for a few minutes and shows it to her. It says, “Wanted interesting companion! U pretty and sweet!”

Marybelle frowns and says, “Well I got my cutie mark earlier and enrolled in martial arts classes because of it. Later when I got good at it, I was accepted in the Royal Fighting Academy and then fought as an MMA fighter for a few years… And now I’m dating a batpony!”

Guyrin smiles at his date as she stares on. She then asks him, “It must get lonely all by yourself at night?”

Guyrin solemnly nods his head.

“So you wanted to find an interesting companion and you chose me? Was that before or after reading my bio?”

Guyrin the scribbles on the chalkboard, “After.”

Marybelle narrows her eyes and asks him, “What was it about my bio that caught your attention?”

Guyrin scrawls down, “Pretty strong brave. Wanted tough pony!”

Marybelle says, “You realize I’m not the only female MMA fighter ever to enter the ring though? So I ask you again, why me?”

Guyrin looks down for a few seconds before writing, “Wanted 2 help U” on his chalkboard.

Marybelle scrunches her nose and pauses before saying, “What do you mean, help me?”

Guyrin stares down and then up before scrawling out, “U been alone 4 awhile”.

Marybelle stares at the batpony while squinting her eyes and says, “So? What business is that of yours?”

Guyrin stares at her shocked before his face begins to visibly loosen and he then scrawls, “We don’t need 2 B alone” on his chalkboard.

Marybelle has a wide-eyed expression as she then says, “Just because we’re both single is not a good reason to get together!”

Guyrin jots down, “I know! But I chose U!”

Marybelle scrunches her nose and frowns before asking Guyrin one more time, “Okay so if you know me being single isn’t a reason to hook up, that would mean you have another reason for wanting to be with me…”

Guyrin scrawls out, “U pretty!”

Marybelle says to Guyrin, “I still don’t think that’s the only reason…”

Guyrin looks down and sighs again. He stares blankly into space before Marybelle finally asks him, “Guy? What are you doing? Weren’t we just having a conversation?”

Guyrin looks at Marybelle carefully before getting off his chair, trotting over to her, and then moving his face closer to hers.

Marybelle asks him, “What are you doing Guy?”

Guyrin tilts his forehead to touch Marybelle’s before she sees an explosion of realization in her mind’s eye. She then immediately understood everything the batpony was doing. She knew that every batpony has powers and that this was his. She knew it hurt him to use it and that he could only do it for maybe a few seconds every few days. She also knew that Guyrin’s father had died 5 years ago and that he lived alone on the West side of town where he worked as a grave digger.

These facts however were not nearly as interesting as what Guyrin then thought about batpony mating procedures. She then knew that when he pleased her, he was extending a contract of courtship to her. She also knew that if and when she pleased him, she would be accepting. And she also instantly knew that she also had the option of sending him away.

All these thoughts flooded Marybelle’s mind in the space of about 6 seconds before Guyrin moved his forehead away and only then could she breath again.

She stares at Guyrin with a furrow in her eyebrows and says, “Butthole! You knew when you did what you did that we’d have to be together after that!”

Guyrin is panting on the table by this point as she stares at him wide eyed and says, “And uh, you just hurt yourself doing that! Be careful!” Marybelle then breathed for a bit more before saying, “And now we have a contract…”

Guyrin then puts his forehooves on the table to bring himself back on his haunches at the chair before slowly picking the chalk up with his mouth and writing out on his chalkboard around his neck, “U can send me away?”

Marybelle then says, “Well I do have that option from what your thoughts just told me? Okay fine! I guess you get a pass this time!” as she then stares at the table and huffs.

They suddenly both become aware of the blue Pegasus currently balancing a tray of food on his snout standing right next to the table. He then gets everypony their food while saying, “You two were having such an interesting conversation that I really didn’t want to interrupt!” He then gets the tray back on his snout with his forehooves and trots off while saying, “Enjoy!”

Guyrin then stares at his fruit plate and begins to hiss as his wings come out of the sides of his body before he stops, stares at Marybelle, and then quietly picks up an apple with his forehooves and begins to calmly munch on it.

Marybelle smiles and says, “I heard you batponies have a ravenous appetite for fruit, but until I saw that, I didn’t know if it was true or not.”

Guyrin stares at the table before grabbing his chalkboard and writing, “I control it well!”

Marybelle says, “Well I don’t think viciously attacking every fruit in sight is normally considered polite behavior for a pony no?”

Guyrin smiles, shakes his head no, and then raises his right forehoof.

Marybelle says, “But you control it?”

Guyrin nods yes. He then looks up and writes on his chalkboard, “Why U call me butthole?”

Marybelle giggles and says, “Well like I told you, I was ready to give up on love. And then you started doing all of these romantic things and that only annoyed the piss out of me! Hence the title “butthole” now belongs to you!”

Guyrin squints at Marybelle as she says, “What? It’s a cute nickname butthole! Wear it with pride!” She looks down before finally getting one of her hay cakes with her forehooves and calmly eating it as Guyrin then grabs an orange with his forehooves and does the same.

They eat like this for a few minutes before Marybelle grabs her glass, takes a big gulp, and sets it down before asking Guyrin, “Even your thoughts weren’t enough to tell me why you love me though?”

Guyrin writes out, “They can’t!” on his chalkboard.

Marybelle says to Guyrin, “Well if your thoughts can’t do it, why do you love me Guy?”

Guyrin sighs again, gets off his chair, trots over to Marybelle, moves his face close to hers while looking directly into her eyes with his yellow slits, nuzzles her softly, and kisses her.

Once again, there’s an explosion of realization in Marybelle’s mind, but she knows this is no batpony power. She can feel the passion, fiery and vibrant burning within her. She moves her forehooves around the small blue night creature as he passionately kisses her lips. She then finally understood that there are some things words cannot express.

Guyrin pulls back in her loving embrace and smiles at Marybelle.

Marybelle takes a couple of breaths and says, “I love you Guyrin… I’m not sure why, but I love you… Although I still think you’re a butthole!”

Guyrin does the weird batpony laugh again before Marybelle continues, “That freaky batpony power couldn’t do it, and yet this kiss did? Uh…” She begins to tear up as Guyrin stares at her wide eyed. She takes another breath and says, “I’m sorry Guy… It’s just been so long…”

Guyrin then leans back over and hugs the Pegasus as she sheds a few more tears and says, “Is this real? You really love me Guyrin?”

Guyrin moves his face to hers and nuzzles her before nodding yes and smiling.

Marybelle rests her head on the shoulder of this sweet little blue fruit sucker as he holds her tightly. For just a few minutes, Marybelle felt at peace and like she didn’t need to be vigilant and protect herself. For just a little while, she felt safe and secure in her new lover’s hooves.

Guyrin lets Marybelle go and goes back to all fours and stares at Marybelle directly in her eyes. She can see that at this point, it doesn’t really matter. The batpony has chosen her and she is what he wants. Also, at that point, her eyes begin to water up and the batpony stares at her wide eyed once more as he pats her head with his right forehoof and makes odd chirping noises.

Marybelle sobs out, “I’ve…been…alone….and now you?” before looking over at the night pony.

Guyrin embraces the Pegasus in a loving hug while nuzzling her neck and she eventually calms down…

Marybelle whispers to the batpony, “Okay Guyrin… I’ll give you a chance now… And yes I’m starting to like you too…”

Guyrin moves his right forehoof from her shoulder to just under her chin and uses it to raise her to face him before kissing her softly and passionately.

Marybelle decides to let him in this time and opens her mouth to invite in his forked batpony tongue. As he enters her mouth, she feels excited once again about being with the batpony and she can’t for the life of her figure out why.

They break their kiss and stare deeply into each other’s eyes. She sees nothing but love and acceptance in the narrow black slits of this night pony’s eyes. She smiles and says, “I can’t believe I’m saying this, but I love you Guyrin… I finally get it now!”

The batpony then squeals with what Marybelle can only assume is delight as he then hugs her tightly and rests his head on her shoulder while embracing her. She can’t see Guyrin, but he’s smiling at this point.

They finally break their embrace and Marybelle says to Guyrin, “I guess we really should finish our food? I mean, we’ve been talking this whole time…”

Guyrin looks up with a start and then down at his plate before happily grabbing an apple and munching down on it.

As Marybelle stares on, she suddenly realized that she made a batpony forget about fruit for a short period of time. She then starts to realize that maybe she does have something to offer.

She thinks like this to herself for a few minutes before she realizes that Guyrin has already eaten most of his plate and she’s barely finished just one of her hay cakes. She then starts to eat her food aggressively to catch up with him.

They both eat like this and finish at about the same time before Marybelle looks at Guyrin and says, “Hey! We finished at around the same time!”

Guyrin smiles and nods at Marybelle.

Marybelle sighs and says, “So did you have a good time Guy?”

Guyrin smiles and nods.

Marybelle then looks down for a few seconds before looking back up at Guyrin and saying, “I guess you should go pay and we can walk back to my place now?”

Guyrin smiles and nods again before getting off his chair and trotting up front to pay. For the next few minutes, Marybelle is left alone with her thoughts. She keeps wondering if this is actually what she needs, but she eventually just decides to throw caution to the wind and go for it… She patiently waits in her chair as Guyrin eventually trots back up to her.

He motions his head towards Marybelle’s house in the distance and smiles at her.

She suddenly thinks he’s so cute just sitting there on all four of his legs with his little fluffy ears and leathery wings smiling at her, but quickly banishes the thought. “No!” she thinks to herself, “I can’t fall for him! Not right now! Not yet!” She then gets out of her chair and back to her hooves and trots up to Guyrin who’s patiently waiting for her with his adorable batpony smile.

Marybelle then says, “Okay Guy! Ready when you are!”

Guyrin starts trotting forward and Marybelle follows him.

She stares at him and asks, “So you love me and that’s all there is to it?”

Guyrin smiles again at her and nods.

She then mutters, “Don’t know why I find that so irritating?”

Guyrin then does his weird batpony laugh.

Marybelle then says, “And that’s also irritating! You annoy the piss out of me and I love you! And that just makes it even more annoying!”

Guyrin then stops and turns to face her.

She notices this and stops as well.

Guyrin then puts his right forehoof over her lips and looks at her with an open and genuine look in his eyes.

She knew then that she really should stop talking.

Guyrin then looks down before turning back towards Marybelle’s place and trotting that way. Marybelle follows a moment later and they once again trot through the empty market square in Ponyville at night.

Marybelle suddenly thinks about how busy this place is during the day and then she sees clearly that it’s dark there and nopony was around. She then understood exactly why Guyrin was so lonely. After losing his father, the only family member he had, he’s been living alone for several years. As she stared at all the empty booths and vacant walkways, she realized that this was Guyrin’s world. A solitary and isolated existence… She then knew more than ever what she had to do…

They silently walk through the vacant town and Marybelle then starts to become less irritated and more sympathetic as she thinks about things. She hates to admit it to herself by the point they’re almost back to her place on the other side of the market, but she really does care for this little batpony.

They finally reach her place with her porchlight on just past a grove on the other side. She looks at Guyrin and says, “Thanks for showing me what love is Guy… Would you like to come inside?”

Guyrin then looks at her wide eyed and points to himself with his right forehoof.

Marybelle smiles and giggles as she says, “Yes you silly! Would you like to come inside?”

Guyrin then looks down for a moment before looking back up at her and finally nodding his head yes and smiling.

Marybelle then says, “Okay! Now let me get my key and we can go inside.” She sees the darting looks from Guyrin’s eyes and realizes that he’s nervous. This tells her she has the little batpony exactly where she wants him.

She finally reaches into the left side of her saddlebags with her mouth, fetches the key, and uses her mouth then to operate it in the door before just kicking it open with her left forehoof like usual. She then walks inside before looking back at Guyrin and saying to the nervous little shadow creature, “Come on in sweetie!”

Guyrin slowly walks inside. He’s almost past the door when suddenly he remembers to shut it with his hoof and does so.

Marybelle notes how he’s acting and giggles before saying, “You okay Guy? You seem kind of out of it?”

Guyrin just looks at her, smiles, and nods.

She then trots over a few feet to get near him and softly whispers, “I’m ready Guyrin…”

Guyrin then looks at her wide eyed as his mouth begins to quiver.

Marybelle smiles and says, “What’s the matter batpony? Not so brave anymore?”

Guyrin then squints at her with his right eye before adjusting himself, walking over to her, and passionately kissing her.

She opens her mouth once again to invite in his tongue and feels it exploring her mouth as she licks it inside. She also feels something burning between her rear thighs. She knows what that is. She then embraces Guyrin in her forehooves and finally pulls back before saying, “We should probably go to my bedroom for this you think?”

Guyrin gives a weird batpony chuckle again before nuzzling her.

Marybelle says, “Well we’re never gonna get there if you keep being affectionate you know?”

Guyrin looks down and sighs before looking back up at Marybelle and nodding while smiling.

Marybelle then says, “Don’t worry batpony. I know you’re nervous and we’ll go slow…”

They then trot back to the bedroom together and for half the night, they make passionate love. It’s different this time for Marybelle. She’s bucked other stallions before, but Guyrin is so sweet, gentle, and caring. He’s actually the most giving lover she’s ever had and then she finally understood him and who he was. Through his love, she finally understood why…

Author's Note

Special thanks to my new editor!
https://www.fimfiction.net/user/355221/Lunar+Fury

In this chapter, Marybelle is finally deciding to let the little batpony in...